Who removeth mountains, and they know it not, when he overturneth them in his anger;
Job answers Bildad. He agrees that God is just, then presses the question he cannot answer: how can a man be just with a God this great? Verse 5 begins his picture of that greatness. God removes mountains, and they never know what happened to them.
Job's speech here has been mapped as a series of stages, and this verse begins the section on power. What comes just before it sets the mood: Job concedes God is just, but the concession is bleak.
Samuel RidoutAlthough he speaks quietly, there is an intense bitterness in what Job says here. Job seems to agree with Bildad that God is just. He says, "Of course He is just, for there is no appeal from whatever He does. He has both wisdom and power, and can overwhelm any useless attempt to reason with Him." This is terrible. This is not a humble man daring to ask God for a reason, as Jeremiah does in a similar situation (Jer. 12:1-4). It is the hardness of despair — might is right, and God has might on His side.
The phrase "they know it not" has puzzled readers: who fails to know? One rendering ties the two halves together, so that the mountains themselves are unaware of what has been done to them.
William KellyHe removes mountains, and they know not that He has overturned them in His wrath; He shakes the earth out of its place, and the pillars of it rock themselves; He commands the sun, and it rises not, and He sets a seal about the stars.
Everything Job says here is accurate. But accuracy is not the same as trust. One writer points out what is missing here.
Samuel RidoutIn this part Job enlarges upon the power and greatness of God. The language is noble, the description true, but underneath lies the awful doubt of this great and powerful Being's goodness. God overturns the unconscious mountains in His wrath; He makes the earth to tremble... These are marvelous sweeps of language, taking in the whole heavens. But sadly it is not, "The heavens declare the glory of God." It is a declaration of absolute, unstoppable Power.
How does God overturn a mountain? One writer explains it in plain physical terms, then follows the same control into the sky and the sea.
Leslie M. GrantGod could remove mountains by an earthquake, shaking the earth and causing its most stable influences to tremble. Also, high above the earth, He could command the sun not to rise, that is, as far as we can see... He "alone spreads out the heavens, and treads on the waves of the sea." Whether the earth or sky or sea, He is in perfect control. The New Testament gives a precious confirmation of His control of the sea. Jesus "came to them, walking on the sea" (Matt. 14:25). That is clear proof that Jesus is God.
These words come from a part of the world with no volcanoes. That makes the detail in them striking.
Scripture QuarterlyThere were no volcanoes in the land of Israel or in the neighbouring countries. Yet the Spirit dictated these records: "who looks on the earth and it trembles, who touches the mountains and they smoke" (Ps. 104:32); "He who removes mountains, and they know it not, when He overturns them in His anger" (Job 9:5)... The textbooks of science change twice in every generation. Scripture stands firm. It watches human explanations of the universe get built, and then replaced by ones that seem more likely.
The description is not decoration. Job is testing one possible answer to his own question — that a man might simply stand up to God and argue.
F. B. HoleSupposing man adopts a defiant attitude and contends with God; what then? Disaster, and no justification! Sin has made mankind into rebels, so defying God is their first instinct. But Job saw how ruinous such an attitude would be. God is so infinitely great that no rebel can prosper.
Power silences Job. It still leaves him one question: how can a sinful man be just before God?
William KellyJob did not doubt that God would see him through all his difficulties. But he could not work out on what ground of righteousness God would do it. If man was a poor sinful man, and God still showed him saving mercy, how was man to be just? You cannot put justice and sins together until you have Christ. He died for the sins and rose again for the believer's justification. There the sins are completely blotted out.
- Truth — Job's words are accurate: God removes mountains, and they do not know what happened to them.
- Gap — True words about God's power hide a doubt about God's goodness. This is not "The heavens declare the glory of God." It is raw power alone.
- Reach — That power runs through earth, sky and sea, and the One who walked on that sea is God.
- Dead end — Defiance gets a man nowhere, since no rebel can prosper against a God this great.
- Answer — Justice and sins come together only in Christ. He died for the sins and rose again for the believer's justification.
Who shaketh the earth out of its place, and the pillars thereof tremble;
Job is answering Bildad with a picture of God's power: mountains overturned, the earth shaken out of its place, sun and stars switched off at a word. The description is grand, but a painful question drives it: if God is this strong, how can a man ever be right with Him?
The trembling pillars are earthquake language. One writer takes the pictures one at a time — earth, then sky, then sea.
Leslie M. GrantGod could remove mountains by an earthquake. It shakes the earth and makes even its steadiest parts tremble. Also, high above the earth, He could command the sun not to rise — that is, as far as we can see. Of course He does this by placing clouds in the sky, and the clouds hide the stars too... Whether the earth or sky or sea, He is in perfect control.
Job piles up this power for a reason. It belongs to a question he raised at the start of the chapter.
F. B. HoleHe began by admitting that God's disciplinary ways are right. But he raised the all-important question: how could a man be right with God? In our day the short sentence, "Get right with God," has been used to awaken interest in the gospel message. It might well provoke the reply, "Yes, but how is it to be achieved?"
One answer is to fight back and argue the case out with God. Job weighed that and saw where it ends.
F. B. HoleSin has made mankind into rebels, so defying God is their first instinct. But Job saw how ruinous such an attitude would be. God is so infinitely great that no rebel can prosper... The earth and the heavens with their constellations proclaim the Creator's greatness and glory.
Commentators differ on Job's tone here. One holds that every word of the description is true, and that something vital is still left out of it.
Samuel RidoutIn this part Job enlarges upon the power and greatness of God. The language is noble and the description is true. But underneath lies the awful doubt about this great and powerful Being's goodness. God overturns the unconscious mountains in His wrath; He makes the earth to tremble... These are marvellous sweeps of language, taking in the whole heavens. But sadly it is not, "The heavens declare the glory of God." It is a declaration of absolute, unstoppable Power.
The same writer hears a cornered man in the opening lines. Job grants that God is just because there is no appeal against Him.
Samuel RidoutThis is terrible. It is not someone humbly asking God for a reason, as Jeremiah does in similar circumstances (Jeremiah 12:1-4). It is the hardness of despair — might is right, and God has the might on His side.
His trouble was never doubt about the source of his suffering. That certainty was precisely the problem.
William KellyThat is exactly where Job was. He was quite sure that it was of God, and that is the very thing that made the difficulty. Because his conscience was pure toward God, and he knew the goodness of God — and yet how was this? He could not understand it... He was not a proud man; but as all men are, until they learn in the way I have described, he had a very good opinion of himself. That must all come down.
One writer names what Job was missing — and what no one on earth knew then.
William KellyJob did not doubt that God would see him through all his difficulties. But he could not imagine on what ground of righteousness that could be done. If man was a poor sinful man, and yet God showed him saving mercy, how was man to be just? You cannot put justice and sins together until you have Christ. He died for the sins and rose again for the believer's justification. There the sins are completely blotted out. How could Job know anything about that? Nobody knew it; no man on earth.
- Power — the shaking earth and trembling pillars are earthquake language. What looks most solid moves when God acts, on land, in the sky and at sea.
- Question — Job piles up that power to press one point: how can a man be right with God? "Get right with God" is quickly said, but how is it to be done?
- Defiance — arguing your case against a God who overturns mountains can only ruin you. No rebel prospers.
- Doubt — the poetry is true but incomplete. It declares unstoppable power, not goodness; one writer hears despair in it, not worship.
- Answer — what Job lacked was Christ, who died for the sins and rose again for the believer's justification. Only there do justice and sins meet, and the good opinion of self comes down.
Who commandeth the sun, and it riseth not, and he sealeth up the stars;
Bildad has argued that God is just, and Job agrees — then turns that agreement into a problem. He piles up pictures of a God so strong that the sun will not rise at His word, yet one question drives it all: how can a man be right with God?
Every line about mountains, sun and stars sits under one question raised a few verses earlier. One writer puts it in today's words:
F. B. HoleJob's striking words in Job 9 begin by acknowledging that God's ways of discipline are right. But they raise the all-important question: how could a man be right with God? In our day the short sentence, "Get right with God," has stirred interest in the gospel message. It might well bring the reply, "Yes, but how is it to be done?" That is exactly the question Job asked in verse 2. The rest of the chapter shows how earnest and sincere he was in asking it.
The verse moves from the sun to the stars. One writer reads both halves as God shutting the sky off from our sight:
Leslie M. GrantAlso, high above the earth, He could command the sun not to rise — that is, as far as we can see. Of course He does this by placing clouds in the sky, which hide the stars too. He alone spreads out the heavens and treads on the waves of the sea. Whether earth or sky or sea, He is in perfect control.
Job's picture sweeps from the mountains up to the whole heavens. Yet one writer notices what is missing from it:
Samuel RidoutHere Job dwells on the power and greatness of God. The language is noble and the description true. But underneath lies a dreadful doubt about the goodness of this great and powerful Being. God overturns the mountains in His wrath, and they know nothing of it; He makes the earth tremble. Moving from earth to heaven, He makes the sun and stars stop shining… These are marvelous sweeps of language, taking in the whole heavens. But sadly they are not, "The heavens declare the glory of God." They declare absolute, unstoppable Power.
Job speaks calmly here. The same writer weighs the spirit behind the calm and sets Job beside the prophet Jeremiah, who also questioned God's ways:
Samuel RidoutAlthough he speaks quietly, there is an intense bitterness in what Job says here. On the surface he agrees with Bildad that God is just. Job says, "Of course He is just, for there is no appeal from whatever He does. He has both wisdom and power, and can crush any useless effort to reason with Him." This is terrible. This is not a man humbly daring to ask God for a reason, as Jeremiah does in similar circumstances (Jeremiah 12:1-4). It is the hardness of despair — might is right, and God has might on His side.
Job believed God would bring him through. What he could not see was how God could count a sinful man righteous:
William KellyHe knew man was weak and faulty. Still, Job did not doubt that God would bring him through all his troubles. What he could not work out was the ground of righteousness for it. If man was a poor sinful man, and God still showed him saving mercy, how was man to be just? You cannot put justice and sins together until you have Christ, who died for the sins and rose again for the believer's justification. There God blots the sins out completely. How could Job know anything about that?
- The question. The whole chapter grows out of one earnest question: how can a man be right with God?
- The power. God's control reaches past earth to the sky. He can hold back the sunrise and hide the stars. Earth, sky and sea are all in His hands.
- The gap. Job's words are noble and true. But they declare raw, unstoppable Power, not the glory of God, because doubt about God's goodness lies underneath.
- The danger. Job admits God is just only because no one can appeal against Him. That is not Jeremiah's humble questioning. It is the hardness of despair — might is right.
- The answer. Justice and sins only come together in Christ. He died for sins and rose again for the believer's justification — the ground of righteousness Job could not yet see.
Who alone spreadeth out the heavens, and treadeth upon the high waves of the sea;
Job speaks these words while answering Bildad. He opens his reply with the question that drives the whole book: how can a man be right with God? What follows is not calm praise. It is a man measuring himself against a power he cannot argue with.
Job's description of God's greatness is not there for its own sake. It is his answer to a problem he cannot solve. One commentator points out that nobody alive yet had the answer.
William KellyJob describes in a very grand way what God is in His ways — His uncontrollable power and authority. He knew man was weak and faulty. Even so, Job did not doubt that God would see him through all his difficulties. But he could not imagine on what ground of righteousness. If man was a poor sinful man, and God still showed him saving mercy, how was man to be just? You cannot put justice and sins together until you have Christ. He died for the sins and rose again for the believer's justification. There the sins are completely blotted out. How could Job know anything about that? Nobody knew it; no man on earth.
The verse names two things God does alone. He stretches out the sky, and He walks on the sea. One writer sets that beside the earthquake and the darkened sun in the lines just before. (His wording, "treads on the waves of the sea," follows an older translation.)
Leslie M. GrantGod could remove mountains by an earthquake, shaking the earth and causing its most stable features to tremble. Also, high above the earth, He could command the sun not to rise — that is, as far as our vision is concerned. Of course He does this by placing clouds in the sky, so that the stars too are sealed off from view. He "alone spreads out the heavens, and treads on the waves of the sea." Whether the earth or sky or sea, He is in perfect control.
Job's words travel. Another writer follows them from the ground up to the sky, then back down to the water.
Samuel RidoutGod overturns the unconscious mountains in His wrath; He makes the earth tremble. Passing from earth to heaven, He causes the sun and stars to stop shining. Returning to earth, He walks upon the raging waves of the sea.
Here is the sting. Every word Job says about God is true. Yet the same writer hears something missing underneath.
Samuel RidoutThe language is noble and the description true. But underneath it lies the awful doubt about this great and powerful Being's goodness… These are marvellous sweeps of language, taking in the whole heavens. Sadly, though, this is not "The heavens declare the glory of God." It is a declaration of absolute, unstoppable Power.
It shows in the way Job talks about God's justice.
Samuel RidoutAlthough he speaks quietly, there is an intense bitterness in what Job says here. Apparently agreeing with Bildad that God is just, Job says, "Of course He is just, for there is no appeal from whatever He does. He has both wisdom and power, and can overwhelm any pointless attempt to reason with Him." This is terrible. This is not someone humbly asking God for a reason, as Jeremiah does in a similar situation (Jer. 12:1-4). It is the hardness of despair — might is right, and God has might on His side.
Centuries later, men watched someone do this very thing.
Leslie M. GrantThere is a precious New Testament confirmation of His control of the sea, when "He came to them, walking on the sea" (Matt. 14:25), a clear proof that Jesus is God.
And He did it as a Man.
James McBroomWe see Him as a Man, yet the great "I Am," in a scene that shows in picture all the power of evil under His feet. He walks upon the sea as His by double right: in Godhead He created it, and in Manhood it forms part of His vast domain.
- Alone. Sky, sun, stars, earth and sea are all the work of one hand. Nothing in Job's world stands outside God's control.
- Alone, and out of reach. Job's problem is not that God is too weak. It is that no one can argue with Him. His real question is how a man can be right with God.
- True words, cold heart. Every line Job speaks about God is true. Yet it declares raw power, not glory. Despair can say right things.
- The missing answer. No one can put justice and sins together until Christ. He died for sins and rose again for the believer's justification.
- The feet on the water. The One who treads the waves later walked on the sea as a Man — the same power, now seen close enough to touch.
Who maketh the Bear, Orion, and the Pleiades, and the chambers of the south;
Job is answering Bildad by piling up the works of God, and he ends with the stars. Why does a man in agony turn to astronomy, and does naming the constellations bring him closer to the God he cannot find?
The first name in the verse is hard to translate. Older English Bibles read "Arcturus"; newer ones read "the Bear."
Morrish Bible DictionaryThe word ash or aish has always been a difficult one to translate, and the versions differ a great deal. But most now agree that this is not the star known as Arcturus, but the constellation known as the Great Bear. "His sons" are thought to be the stars in the tail of the bear. In the northern hemisphere this constellation shows all year round. It seems to circle the north star without ever stopping, and none but the mighty God can guide it.
The second group Job names is a cluster, and the Hebrew word says so.
Morrish Bible DictionaryKimah. The Hebrew means "a heap or collection." The verse names it with Arcturus and Orion, so it doubtless refers to the group of stars that still bears the name Pleiades. In Amos 5:8 the same Hebrew word becomes "seven stars." There are many stars in the group, but seven are visible to the naked eye.
Job's list runs to every quarter of the heavens. It ends with a region he has never seen.
Samuel RidoutIn this part Job enlarges on the power and greatness of God. The language is noble, the description true, but underneath it lies the terrible doubt about this great and powerful Being's goodness. He is the Creator of those distant glorious constellations. Arcturus is in the north. Orion is "sloping downward toward the west." Pleiades is in the east. And there are the unknown "chambers of the south," toward the horizon and beyond sight. This language sweeps across the whole heavens. But sadly it is not "The heavens declare the glory of God." It is a declaration of absolute, unstoppable power.
The first three names belong to the northern sky. The fourth does not.
William KellyThese are all in the northern sphere. But the people of those days had explored far enough to cross the equator, and they knew there was a southern world. They did not know much about it; they knew very little.
Job is not guessing at any of this.
Leslie M. GrantAll the constellations of the stars are His workmanship. Notice that people already knew these astronomical facts at this early date. Job could speak with real knowledge about the greatness of God just as well as Bildad, if not much better.
Job's knowledge of the Creator left him one question he could not answer: how can a sinful man be just before God?
William KellyJob did not doubt that God would see him through all his difficulties. But he could not see on what ground of righteousness. If man was a poor sinful man, and God still showed him saving mercy, how was man to be just? You cannot put justice and sins together until you have Christ. He died for the sins and rose again for the believer's justification. There God blots the sins out completely. How could Job know anything about that? Nobody knew it; no man on earth.
When God Himself speaks, He takes up Job's own words and turns them into questions.
Samuel RidoutPointing next to the heavenly host, the Lord almost takes up the words of Job (Job 9:9)... Some think the Pleiades stand for a cluster of brilliant jewels: "Can you fasten the shining brooch on the bosom of the night?" Others say the Pleiades is the constellation of Spring, as Orion is the constellation of Winter. To loose the bands of Orion would break up the Winter. To bind the sweet influences of the Pleiades would delay the Spring. Can you hold back the coming of Spring, or bring Winter to an end?
Commentators differ on what these names picture.
Job spoke before God had revealed Himself fully in His Son.
James McBroomSuch passages come before the full revelation of God in the Son that we have today. They show the thoughts and feelings of the creature towards his Creator. It could not be otherwise while Jehovah remained behind the veil. He asserted His majesty in many ways: in His rightful claims in the testing of man, and in view of the coming down of the Son. In the Son He has now shone out in the full glory of His Being and Nature as God.
- Bear — the hard Hebrew word ash is now read as the Great Bear. It circles the north star, and none but the mighty God can guide it.
- Heap — kimah, the Pleiades, means "a heap." The group holds many stars, but the naked eye picks out seven.
- Sweep — north, west, east and the unseen south: Job takes in the whole sky. Yet he confesses unstoppable power, not declared glory.
- Silence — all this knowledge of the Creator still left Job unable to see how a man could be just with God. That answer waits for Christ, who died for sins and rose again.
- Answer — God Himself later takes up Job's own constellations and asks whether Job can bind the Pleiades or loose Orion, turning Job's list into a question.
Who doeth great things past finding out, and wonders without number.
Job is answering Bildad. He piles up the works of God — mountains overturned, the sun and stars darkened, the constellations made — and verse 10 sums them all up. The words are true and beautiful. But a desperate question drives them: if God is this great, how can a man ever be right with Him?
The verse gathers up the list Job has just made. No one can search His works to the bottom. No one can count them. One writer notes how much Job already knew of the sky. He also notes that the God who made it moves through the world unseen:
Leslie M. Grant"He made the Bear, Orion, and the Pleiades and the chambers of the south" (v.9). All the constellations of the stars are His workmanship. Notice that people knew these astronomical facts at this early date. Job could speak of the greatness of God with as much knowledge as Bildad, if not far more. As he says, God "does great things beyond searching out, and marvelous things beyond number." In fact, God moves in such a way that Job could not see Him at work. Yet God can do what no one can stop.
Everything Job says here is accurate. What is missing is any warmth toward the One he is describing. So his sweep across the heavens does not land where you would expect:
Samuel RidoutIn this part Job enlarges upon the power and greatness of God. The language is noble and the description true. But underneath lies an awful doubt about the goodness of this great and powerful Being. God overturns the unconscious mountains in His wrath; He makes the earth to tremble. Passing from earth to heaven, He causes the sun and stars to stop shining… These are marvellous sweeps of language, taking in the whole heavens. But sadly, it is not, "The heavens declare the glory of God." It is a declaration of absolute, unstoppable Power.
Job's problem is not that he sees too little of God in the sky. It is that what he sees there cannot tell him whether God is kind. Wonders beyond counting prove that Someone is behind them; they do not tell you what that Someone is like:
The Bible TreasuryUnbelief rests on nature as its way of rising from the visible to a knowledge of the Invisible. But nature fails to tell who and what God is. Nature was never intended to tell us. But men reasoned away even what creation should have shown — His eternal power and divinity. The heavens declare His glory, and the sky shows His handiwork. But even that glorious display of wisdom and power could only tell us that there must be a God. It could not tell us that God in His nature is light and love.
Job opened this speech by asking how a man can be right before such a God. His list of unsearchable works only sharpens the question. It waited a long time for an answer:
W. W. FeredayTo justify a man is to reckon him righteous… To justify someone who has done no wrong is simple. Every court in the world can do it. But to justify a sinner is another matter altogether; this presents a problem that only God can solve. Long ago both Job and his friend Bildad raised the question, "How can man be just with God?" (Job 9; 25). Both had in mind that man is fallen and guilty. Their question found no clear answer in Old Testament times. For this answer, as for many another riddle, men had to wait until God sent His beloved Son. "But now," says the Apostle, "the righteousness of God has been manifested" (Rom. 3:21).
Job's question is not a dead end. Pleading your own record with God is:
J. N. DarbyA man never knows God until he gets to that point — "How shall a man be just with God?" Men are willing to argue with Him. But what good is that? says God. God does love righteousness; but what does that do for me? How many sins today, yesterday, and so on, have I committed? It is no good pleading with God on that ground.
- Unsearchable — Job's list of God's works ends in a confession. No one can trace out the great things or count the wonders.
- Unseen — the God who does them passes by unnoticed, and no one can stop what He does.
- Unwarmed — every word is true, yet doubt of God's goodness runs underneath. It is a hymn to power, not the heavens declaring His glory.
- Unable — creation shows that God is, and shows His eternal power. It was never meant to tell you that He is light and love.
- Unanswered — until Christ — in Job's day the question this greatness raises had no full answer. Now God has made His righteousness known.