If thou seek earnestly unto щGod, and make thy supplication to the Almighty,
Bildad, the second of Job's three friends, turns from argument to advice. His words sound right, but they carry a hidden accusation — and it comes from a man who has misread his friend's case.
One writer sets out what drives him:
Samuel RidoutBildad now takes up what is fast becoming an argument. He shows less of the courtesy and dignity that marked the speech of Eliphaz, and more harshness toward Job, apparently caused by Job's bitter charge against God. For all his ignorance of God's principles, Bildad is jealous for the honor of God, and will not let anyone accuse Him. He is right about that. But he fails to convince Job, because of the root error in the thinking of all three friends: God must punish sin, so Job must be a sinner, since he is being punished.
Verse 5 does not stand alone. Just before it, Bildad hinted that Job's children died for their own sin. Verse 6 adds a second condition: "if you are pure and upright."
Leslie M. GrantBildad condemned Job's dead sons, then went on to attack Job himself. He told Job that if he would seek God earnestly in prayer, and if he were pure and upright, then God would certainly rouse Himself for him at once and turn his misery into prosperity (vv.5-6). Of course, in saying this he implied that Job had not been pure and upright, and had not sought God earnestly before.
Bildad promises restoration on his own terms. God did restore Job in the end, but not in the way Bildad imagined.
William KellySo instead of bluster and complaint, let Job simply turn to God the Almighty in earnest prayer. Then, if only he is pure, he will soon find that God crowns his home with prosperity, and that his last days flourish beyond his first. And so it happened — but not at all in the way Bildad imagined. Bildad falls back on the old sayings of earlier generations to support the idea that God repays every man strictly, here and now.
Bildad calls God "the Almighty." One writer traces the name behind that title.
A J PollockIn seven places the word for God [El] is combined with Shaddai, which is usually translated "the Almighty." Some understand the name to mean "Almighty in sustaining resources" (like a mother's breasts for her baby). It occurs 48 times in the Old Testament, and the book of Job accounts for no fewer than 31 of them. In that book one thought stands out above all others: the Lord is Almighty. That suits the book well, since it tells the story of God's controversy with Job, who found no relief or blessing until he came to a right view of himself in God's presence.
Nobody would dispute that a man should seek God. That is what makes this advice dangerous.
William KellyThings that are true, but misunderstood and misapplied, can do more harm than many a thing that is false. Misapplied truth lends the apparent authority of God to an error, and that error carries all the more weight because it comes as truth. If someone says a foolish thing, or a plainly false one, people dismiss it. But no believer can brush aside the truth of God. So if the truth of God is used wrongly — if it is used to crush someone God cares about deeply at that moment, how foreign and offensive that is to His mind!
Telling a man to seek God is not the same as bringing him to God:
C. H. MackintoshThey did not know God's character, or His purpose in dealing with His dear servant. They were completely mistaken. They did not know how to present God to Job, and so they did not know how to bring Job's conscience into God's presence. Instead of leading him to judge himself, they only fed his desire to defend himself… They said some true things; but they did not have the truth.
The book's ending reverses the roles. Bildad told Job to plead with the Almighty. In the end, God accepted Job's prayer for Bildad.
Morrish Bible DictionaryHe did not understand Job's case at all. He could only conclude that God was punishing Job for wickedness, though God had called Job a righteous man. God's anger burned against Bildad. But Bildad and his two companions brought a sacrifice, and when Job prayed for them, God accepted him.
- Seek — the counsel. Bildad tells Job to seek God and plead with the Almighty. The words are good. The aim behind them was not.
- Seek — the condition. The "if" of verses 5–6 quietly accuses. It implies Job had not sought God and had not lived rightly. That is why the advice wounded instead of healing.
- Seek — the God addressed. "The Almighty" is Shaddai, the name that fills this book. Job found no relief until he saw himself as he really was before God.
- Seek — the danger. Misused truth does more harm than open error. It borrows God's authority to crush someone God cares for.
- Seek — the outcome. Job's later days did flourish, but not on Bildad's terms. In the end, God accepted Job's prayer for his friends.
If thou be pure and upright, surely now he will awake for thee, and make the habitation of thy righteousness prosperous;
Bildad answers Job with a condition: purity and uprightness, and then God will act. It sounds like a promise. But everything hangs on the word "if" — and on whether suffering proves the sufferer has done wrong.
Bildad does not say outright that Job is guilty. He builds his hope on two conditions, and the conditions themselves carry the charge.
Leslie M. GrantBildad condemned Job's dead sons, then went on to attack Job himself. He told Job this: if he would seek God with earnest prayer, and if he were pure and upright, then God would surely wake up for him at once and turn his misery into prosperity (vv. 5-6). Of course, in saying this he implied that Job had not been pure and upright and had not earnestly sought God before.
Bildad's condition also carries an offer. "Restore your rightful habitation" means Job's home made prosperous again.
William KellyInstead of bluster and complaint, let Job only turn to God the Almighty with earnest prayer. Then he will soon find — provided he himself is pure — that prosperity from Him will crown his home. His latter end will flourish beyond the beginning.
Bildad sends Job looking inside himself for the fault behind his losses. He has misread the trial.
The Bible TreasuryBildad here sharply rebukes Job, telling him that the words of his mouth are like a strong wind, and that if he were pure and upright God would wake up for him. So he throws Job back on himself even more. He implies that Job's trials are judicial payments for sin. In fact they were the discipline of God, leading him to the full end of himself. Job knew that he had done nothing to deserve it. But he had to learn that he could claim nothing. His friends knew this no more than he did; they stood on righteousness alone.
Bildad states his outcome as certain. Set against what God was doing with Job, that certainty collapses. (The quote below follows an older wording: "If you were pure and upright.")
William Kelly"If you were pure and upright" — ah, there they were at it again! So it was not only the children who had sinned! "If you were pure and upright" — why, Job was much more so than they were! "If you were pure and upright, surely now He would wake up for you." Certainly not. The Lord was going to bring the trial to its full completion. He allowed all these discussions to bring out everything that was in their hearts. Then He came in with His own word and cast down completely these principles that governed the three friends — and Job could not properly answer them.
In the end Job's home and fortunes did come back. But not for the reason Bildad gave.
Samuel RidoutNext, he proves the justice of those ways. He tells Job there is restoring mercy for him, if he will only turn to God in prayer. "If you are pure and upright" — there is a strong hint of suspicion here — God will restore everything, and bless Job's latter end. This did come true, but in a very different way from what Bildad expected. Job is not blessed for his purity, and not for confessing the evil they suspected in him.
The friends' words about God were true. That is what made them dangerous.
William KellyThings that are true, but misunderstood and misapplied, may do more harm than many a thing that is false. Misapplied truth gives the apparent authority of God to an error, and that error carries all the more weight because it comes as the truth.
Underneath Bildad's "if" sits one assumption: a man can be righteous before God on his own.
The Christian's FriendThis is just where Job's friends were. They saw that God loves righteousness and hates evil, and that Job was suffering. What conclusion did they draw from it all? That if Job had been a righteous person, God would have accepted him. They were on wrong ground altogether. It is quite true, and blessedly true, that God loves righteousness. But the fallacy lies in the idea that a man can be righteous with God. That thought must always produce either self-righteousness, or despair and misery.
- The "if" accuses. Bildad's condition hides a charge. To promise God's help if Job is pure is to say that Job's ruin proves he is not.
- The measure is false. The friends stood on righteousness alone. They read Job's trial as payment owed for sin, not as God's discipline.
- True words, wrong target. Truth aimed at the wrong man does more damage than open error. It lends God's authority to a mistake.
- The condition cannot be met. God does love righteousness. The flaw is the idea that a man can be righteous with God. That road ends in self-righteousness or in despair.
- The outcome outran the formula. Job's latter end did flourish. But not because he was pure, and not because he confessed sins his friends only suspected.