I know that thou canst do everything, and that thou canst be hindered in no thought of thine.
For many chapters Job has argued, protested, and demanded a hearing. Then God answers out of the whirlwind, and Job's reply confesses the two things he had questioned: God's power and God's plans.
Job does not keep this to himself. He says it out loud, and the complaining is over.
The friends are silent; Job does not believe in his heart only but makes confession with his mouth. He murmurs no more, he resents no more, he questions no more. He now admits openly, as something he knows in his soul, that the Lord is able for all things, and that no purpose is withheld from Him. Evil in men or Satan, ruin everywhere in this fallen world, had touched Him in no way at all.
Job's earlier speeches came out of a gap in his knowledge of God. Another man in the Bible had to learn the same thing.
He now realises that ignorance of God had driven his earlier words. God "can do everything." This reminds us of Peter's words to the Lord Jesus, "Lord, you know everything" (John 21:17). Peter needed the same lesson Job needed. He too had shown too much confidence in the flesh when he insisted that he would not deny the Lord Jesus, even if all the others did.
Job had spoken against God. Now he takes all of it back, and he sees more in God's purposes than raw strength.
He acknowledges God's omnipotence, and that He cannot be thwarted in His purposes, which exhibit His power, wisdom and goodness as fully as do His works. There is a complete surrender and reversal of all that he had previously said against God.
One writer takes the same truth beyond Job's own life. God's purpose settles what is coming for the whole world.
His counsel will stand, and He will do all His pleasure… God will show His supremacy. He will secure, for His own glory and pleasure, all that He has purposed for the blessing of this poor world.
Commentators differ here, because translators render the Hebrew in two ways. Some read the line as God's purpose being unstoppable. Others follow an older translation, "no thought can be withheld from You," and read it as God knowing every thought a man has.
In God's presence, as it were under God's eye, Job learned by experience that He was Almighty. He learned that God searches every thought of the heart.
Job's "I know" is not new information. What changed is the way he holds it.
"Who is this that hides counsel without knowledge?" Why, it was himself; he owns it. Then comes his great confession: "I had heard of You by the hearing of the ear." I knew it as a report outside myself. But now I have made it my own. I have applied it to my own soul, my own circumstances, my own state — "but now my eye sees You. Therefore I despise myself, and repent in dust and ashes." That was the great moral victory God had won.
Once someone admits that God can do all things, putting God on trial has nowhere left to stand.
If man could fathom the government of God, he would no longer be man, but God… If God is to be God, then His ways, the workings of His government, the mysteries of His providence, His purposes, His counsels and His judgments must lie far beyond the reach of the greatest human or angelic mind. No angel, no man and no devil can comprehend God… When the soul takes this place, all unbelieving questions come to an end. Until then there is little use in discussion.
And the same confession, held by anyone, becomes a resting place rather than a defeat:
Whatever may happen in this world, we can confidently rest in the knowledge that God can "do everything, and that no thought can be withheld from You."
- Cause — Job's wrong words came from not knowing God. Here he admits that the real problem was his ignorance, not God's injustice.
- Knowledge — He had heard of God by report; now his eye sees Him, and second-hand knowledge becomes his own.
- Power — God can do all things, so nothing stops His purposes. They show His wisdom and goodness, not just His strength.
- Reach — The purpose that ruled Job's life rules the world too. God will secure everything He has planned for it.
- Result — Take this place, and the arguing with God ends.
Who is he that obscureth counsel without knowledge? therefore have I uttered what I did not understand; things too wonderful for me, which I knew not.
Job has just heard God speak, and he answers by turning God's own question against himself. This verse is the hinge. A man who argued his case for chapters now admits he had been talking about matters he never understood.
The words "who is this that hides counsel without knowledge?" are not Job's invention. He is quoting the opening question God had put to him, and by quoting it he agrees with it. Some readers have aimed that question at Elihu, one of the men who had spoken to Job.
Here we have his full answer, his complete bowing down before Jehovah. He acknowledges first Jehovah's supreme power. He is all-powerful and can do all things. Then he quotes Jehovah's own words (38:2; 40:2). "You have asked me, Who is this that hides counsel without knowledge?" It is strange that some interpreters misuse these words, as if the Lord were rebuking Elihu again. No — as we have shown before, He rebukes Job for the wild and reckless charges he had made against the Lord. And now Job acknowledges that Jehovah's rebuke is right.
To darken counsel is to throw a shadow over God's ways by talking about them. Job's speeches had not cleared the mystery of his suffering; they had made it darker.
Quoting Jehovah's own words, he asks himself, Who is he who darkens counsel? — who dares to throw a shadow upon the Almighty! There are mysteries in His ways, as there are in all creation and providence. But no one gains anything by rebelling against these mysteries of God's counsel. He did not even know the simplest truths of nature in their hidden meaning. Yet he had spoken of things beyond the reach of a limited mind, and so he had spoken folly. How different he had been from the devout psalmist: "Such knowledge is too wonderful for me; it is high, I cannot attain it" (Ps. 139:6). He had intruded into the things of God, and had dared to speak evil of divine omnipotence and goodness!
Job's confession is about reach, not honesty. He had handled subjects far above him, and behind that lay how little he knew of God.
He now realises that his earlier words came out of ignorance of God, who "can do everything." This reminds us of Peter's words to the Lord Jesus, "Lord, you know everything" (John 21:17). Peter had to learn the same lesson as Job. He too had trusted himself too much, insisting that he would never deny the Lord Jesus, even if everyone else did. Job fully admits to the Lord that he had spoken without knowing what he was saying — things too wonderful for him. He had tried to handle matters far beyond his understanding, and he found himself humiliated.
Job had spent chapter after chapter answering his friends. Notice who is missing from his confession.
He complains no more, he resents no more, he questions no more. He openly owns, as something real in his soul, that Jehovah is able to do all things, and that no purpose is withheld from Him. Evil in men or Satan, and ruin everywhere in this fallen world, had touched Him in no way. His own difficulties and arguments were only the unsubmissive heart of a man who darkened counsel without knowledge, as Jehovah Himself had said at the start. Now it was Job who declared his own ignorance. He did not understand — things too wonderful for him that he did not know. Not a word now about his friends, or their lack of intelligence, honesty and charity, however true that was. He judges himself before God. He takes the words God had used against him — the crushing proof of his presumption — and makes them his own. They become the humble words of a man who felt his need to learn from God, and who wanted that learning worked in him.
Job's outward life was excellent. The problem was what that excellence had done to his opinion of himself.
Job had opened his mouth "in vain," or "in vanity." His words were many, but they carried no knowledge. The excellence of Job's outward life had betrayed him into an inward spirit of vanity. That vanity was the root of his failure to truly know himself. Job himself confesses this in Job 42:3.
- Knowledge missing. Job's speeches were many but empty. Many words are not the same as understanding, and God's question exposes the gap.
- Knowledge borrowed. He repeats God's own words instead of building a defence. That is the mark of a rebuke he now accepts as true.
- Knowledge overreached. He reached for matters beyond any creature's grasp. The reaching cast a shadow over God's ways instead of clearing them.
- Knowledge turned inward. The friends vanish from his answer. The man who judged everyone else now judges himself before God.
- Knowledge at the root. A fine outward life had bred inward vanity. His real ignorance was not about God's world but about himself.
Hear, I beseech thee, and I will speak I will demand of thee, and inform me.
Here Job takes God's own words onto his own lips, and they sound like a demand for a hearing. Yet he has just admitted he spoke about things he did not understand.
The line is not Job's invention. He repeats back to God the challenge God had already thrown at him — and he does it twice in this short speech.
Here we have his full answer, his complete prostration before Jehovah. He acknowledges first Jehovah's supreme power. He is omnipotent and can do all things. Then he quotes Jehovah's own words (38:2; 40:2). You asked me, "Who is this that hides counsel without knowledge?" … And now Job acknowledges that Jehovah's rebuke is right. It is all true, he says, I uttered things I did not understand, things too wonderful for me, beyond my grasp. Hear me now, Jehovah, I will speak. Once more he quotes Jehovah's word. You have said (40:2), "I ask of you, answer Me." Here then is MY answer, he replies.
Repeating a question can be defiance or surrender. Here the repeating is Job bowing.
Job is still applying Jehovah's words to himself. He asks, "Who is this?" and says, "Hear, and I will speak." It is as though he would bow low to these questions by repeating them, and so give his answer to his divine Questioner. And what an answer it is! It is the only answer human pride can give to God: "I have heard of You by the hearing of the ear." Job had received right instruction in a general way, but he had only learned about God. "But now my eye sees You."
Earlier Job had asked for this meeting, and was sure how it would go. He gets it, with the roles reversed.
Look back at the beginning of Job 23. There Job had spoken with self-confidence about his wish to meet God. He felt sure he could set out his case before Him, fill his mouth with arguments, and know the words in which God would answer him. Now the moment came for that wish to come true. Jehovah tells him to brace himself like a man and to be ready to answer the voice of God. The questioning would now come from God.
Job had gone further than wanting a hearing. He had said he would come near to God as a prince — and God took up the boast.
He winds up what he thought would be his final speech with a challenge to the Almighty Himself. "Behold, my desire is that the Almighty would answer me," he cries. "I would declare to Him the number of my steps. AS A PRINCE I WOULD GO NEAR TO HIM." … The Almighty took up his challenge. He had heard all his proud words and now He answers him and demands that Job open his mouth again. "Gird up your loins like a man; for I will question you, and you answer Me" (chap. 38:3).
Job's earlier questions had been protests. The same words can come from two very different hearts, and that difference decides everything.
You can ask any question in two ways. You can ask in humility, with a sincere desire to learn. Or you can ask in presumptuous rebellion against the answer, whatever it may be. In the first case the questioner truly takes the place of a learner, and that is the right thing for him to do. In the second case he assumes there is no satisfactory answer, or that the answer is certainly being kept from him.
Job now takes the place of the learner. He has stopped instructing God and started listening.
God's questions left Job with nothing to say for himself.
God laid Job low on every point. He overwhelmed him in every way with a sense of his own ignorance and presumption. Job had talked about the far more wonderful ways of a God who deals with a man's heart, a man's soul, a man's circumstances now. The Lord does not put that last part into words. It was God showing His majesty, power, wisdom and goodness in outward things. If that were true of God, how much more in spiritual things?
Nothing his friends said had reached him this way.
These moments in the presence of God had produced a result which all the talk of the three friends, and even of Elihu, had not achieved. This man stood out among men, and even God Himself had given him a testimonial. Yet he had discovered his own utter sinfulness in the deepest springs of his being. A discovery we all in our turn have to make!
- Challenge — God told Job to brace himself and answer Him. Job now says those same words back to God.
- Echo — Repeating the question is his way of bowing to it. He hands the argument over instead of continuing it.
- Learner — The same question can come from humility or from rebellion. Job has moved from rebellion to humility.
- Sight — What he had known by report he now knows by encounter: heard by the ear, then seen with the eye.
- Result — Questions he could not answer did what all the talk of his friends could not. They laid him low and showed him to himself.
I had heard of thee by the hearing of the ear, but now mine eye seeth thee
Job has spent long chapters defending himself and demanding an answer from God. Now God is near, and Job's knowledge of Him turns first-hand — at the cost of everything he thought of himself.
Job sets two ways of knowing God side by side. The second is not seeing with the eyes:
Previously he had known of Him by "the hearing of the ear"; that is, by tradition. But now, said he, "my eye sees you"; that is, he grasped God in a new and living way. He did not "see" in a literal sense, as 1 Timothy 6:16 assures us, yet the eye is only the organ of sight and it is the mind that sees. Again and again we say, "I see," when something that made no appeal to our eyes has sunk into our minds.
Until now Job had only ever measured himself against men:
He perceived God in his soul, by his enlightened reason and above all by conscience. God had drawn near, personally near, and Job was conscious of that indescribable holiness, as well as power, that belong to Him. Previously he had been in the presence of man, and could more than hold his own with the best of them. In God's presence no creature can boast... All the "filthy rags" of an imagined personal righteousness dropped from him.
In the next verse Job's loathing lands on something deeper than his words:
Though Job had heard something about the Lord, it was not enough to meet Job's actual need. Now he came face to face with the greatness and glory of the Lord. The result was, "I abhor myself." He did not abhor only what he had done. He abhorred himself. That self was the root of whatever he may have done, and God was dealing with the root: the pride of Job's very character.
Job had once described his days of honour with these same two senses. The reversal is exact:
There was a time when things were very different for Job. He was prosperous, flourishing, and very pleased with what he had done. Then he stated, "when the ear heard me, then it blessed me; and when the eye saw me it gave witness to me." Now he says, "I had heard of you by the hearing of the ear, but now my eye sees you. Therefore I abhor myself and repent in dust and ashes." When the eye was filled with Job there was one story to tell. When Jehovah filled the vision, and Job appeared only in the light of His presence, the story was quite another.
Job did not discover himself by looking inward. The order is fixed:
The light that shows us what we are is the light of God. So our knowledge of Him always runs ahead of our knowledge of ourselves: "My eye sees you: therefore I abhor myself." Peter learned what a sinful man he was in the presence of the Saviour. This is what holds us up as we come to know ourselves.
Job's long discipline had a goal, and here it is reached:
This is the effect of having seen God, and of finding himself in His presence. God's work was finished — the work of His perfect goodness. That goodness would not leave Job until it had made him know himself, and had brought him into God's own presence. The discipline reached its object, and Job now has more blessings around him than before.
God teaches in two schools, and Bible study is only one of them:
We do not underrate the importance of Bible study... There are things that can only be learned in God's Bible-study School... But to graduate in the knowledge of God that comes by experience, we must enter His school of discipline — a school whose course lasts a lifetime.
- Hearing — Job's old knowledge came by tradition. It was real, but it was not enough.
- Seeing — this is no vision for the eyes. God draws near, and the mind and conscience take Him in.
- Self — the sight exposes more than bad words. Job abhors the root: the pride of his own character.
- Order — God is seen first. Self-knowledge follows the light, so no one finds himself out by looking inward.
- End — this was God's aim all along. Once Job knows himself in God's presence, the discipline is done and blessing follows.
Wherefore I abhor [myself], and repent in dust and ashes.
God has just spoken to Job out of the whirlwind, and these are Job's closing words. Here the book answers the question it has been driving at: what brings a good man to the end of himself? (Older translations read "I abhor myself"; the ESV renders it "I despise myself.")
Job's self-loathing follows from what verse 5 says: he has seen God. Studying the huge creatures God had just described could never have produced it:
"I had heard of you by the hearing of the ear, but now my eye sees you." It was nothing external now; no mere distant rumour. "Now my eye sees you. Therefore I abhor myself." Do you think that searching into the structure or habits of behemoth and leviathan would have led to anything of the sort? Certainly not. He was dealing with God Himself, who used them for that very purpose, and so turned Job from everything else to Himself.
Job could hold his own against his human critics. Before God he collapses — and what he abhors is not just his speeches:
Before this, Job had been in the presence of men, and he could more than hold his own with the best of them. In God's presence no creature can boast, and Job was at last in that glorious, holy Presence. All the "filthy rags" of an imagined personal righteousness dropped from him, and he stood in all the naked horror of pride and rebellion against God. "Therefore I abhor" — what? The whole past, every unjust suspicion, every hot accusation, every despairing, restless lament? Yes, more, the author and source of these — "I abhor myself." Who can doubt that Job's repentance goes beyond judging his words? He judged himself. The very absence of the pronoun stresses the thought: "I abhor." I stand out before everyone, described by one word — "abhor."
Job stops defending himself and agrees with God about himself. That agreement is what "repent" means here:
Now it is not a question of condemnation but of sin. When the sinner has judged himself, the fear of condemnation has passed away... So Job takes God's side against himself. He laid himself before God, and abhorred himself; and then he repents in dust and ashes; for it is only in the presence of God that we learn repentance. True repentance, at its fullest, is this: our sin is so fully brought out that we take God's side of the question. We judge ourselves, and we justify Him. Then it is that He justifies us, and makes us accepted in the Beloved.
Agreeing that human nature is corrupt costs nothing. Job speaks in the singular:
It is one thing to say "We are all vile." It is quite another to feel, deep down in the heart, that "I am vile." We can only learn that, and keep living in it, in the immediate presence of God. The two things must always go together: "My eye sees You" — "Therefore I abhor myself." As the light of what God is shines in on what I am, I abhor myself... It is of little use to claim very low thoughts of self while we are quick to resent any injury done to us — any imagined insult, slight, or put-down.
Job ends up in the dust. Writers read that low place as the aim of the whole story:
The puzzle of the book of Job is solved. God allowed the afflictions to come on His servant Job. It was not only to show His power. It was for Job's good, to draw him into the place of nearness and blessing. And that place is the dust, "in dust and in ashes."
Job was devout in his prosperous days too. What was missing was this sentence, and God drew it out of him for a reason:
These are the words for which we may say the Lord had long been listening. He had not heard them in the days of the patriarch's prosperity, though his piety was unquestioned... God's purpose was to draw out just this confession. And why? To humiliate him? No, but to give him the true glory — to let him, out of the dust, see the glory of the Lord, and never again to have a cloud upon his soul.
- Sight — Report about God left Job intact; a personal view of God undid him. Verse 5 causes verse 6.
- Self — He does not renounce his arguments only. He renounces the person behind them.
- Side — Repentance here is Job changing sides: judging himself, justifying God. Once a person judges himself, the fear of condemnation goes and acceptance follows.
- Singular — "We are all vile" is a doctrine; "I am vile" is repentance. The test is whether small insults still sting.
- Soil — Dust and ashes look like the ruin of Job's life. They are the place of nearness God aimed at all along, and where true glory is given.