Job 39:5–8

Job 39:5

Who hath sent out the wild ass free? and who hath loosed the bands of the onager,

God is questioning Job about the creatures He made. Here He points to an animal nobody owns, turned loose in the wilderness with no driver — and He asks who granted it that freedom.

The Point of the Question

The chapter is often read as a test of Job's knowledge. One writer answers that God, not man, decides how each creature lives.

Clearly the question here is not one of zoological knowledge, but of that kind care which goes with perfect knowledge of every creature. God watched over them all with such care — young and old, beast and bird, even the least familiar or the most out of reach. He did so according to the goodness and wisdom that made them. Was it not for Job, then, to listen and learn, instead of darkening counsel with words without knowledge? And certainly His ways with His people are far deeper than His dealings with the animal realm. Yet even there we see His sovereign disposal everywhere. He, not man, has made them what they are, and ordered their habits and their homes. He has given some animals to carry man's loads. Others He has freed from any such service, like the wild donkey. Its house is the desert and its home the steppe, where a city's noise and a driver's shouts are unknown.

William Kelly

A Creature Beyond Human Reach

So where does an animal like this live, and who feeds it?

The wild donkey is a completely different kind of creature, found mainly in the plains or wilderness. Man just does not control the habits of this animal that is "free as the breeze." Though it lives in "the barren land," God somehow sustains it in finding food. It keeps away from the noise of the city and is not like the tame donkey that must obey the direction of a driver.

Leslie M. Grant

Dependence Underneath the Freedom

A suffering man might envy such freedom. One writer turns that envy into hope.

He is entirely different from the wild goats in ways and habits. But one thing he has in common with them: he is completely dependent on his Creator. What control has Job over a creature like this, who knows no bonds and serves no master? As he thinks of their freedom, Job might sigh under his own burdens. God is able to loosen his bonds. Let him not doubt, but wait on God.

Samuel Ridout

A Mirror Held Up to Man

The verse gives the creature two names, and one reference work reads both as a picture of man — not a flattering one.

The wild donkey is very wild and very swift. It is seldom tamed. It is therefore a fitting emblem of man's natural birth (Job 11:12).

Morrish Bible Dictionary

Another writer turns the picture on the reader.

In the Word of God the donkey is not only presented as unclean; it is also the very synonym for self-will. Read the Lord's account of him in His reasoning with His servant in Job 39:5-8. And what is sin? ... sin is lawlessness. In other words, sin is doing our own will and neglecting the will of God. Who can claim to be exempt here? Who among us does not love to have his own way, whatever it costs?

W. W. Fereday

A Portrait of a Nation

One writer sees a real people in this description: the descendants of Ishmael, Abraham's son by Hagar.

Scripture shows us how God governs the world in providence, apart from His covenant. It does this in the very books that reveal the dealings of His electing grace... No more vivid a sketch was ever drawn than the one given of Ishmael's descendants in the words quoted [Job 39:5-8]. Such exactly are the Bedouins.

William Kelly

Summary

- Question — The "who" in the verse has one answer, and it is not Job; God alone set this creature loose and no man ever tamed it.

- Care — The subject is not animal facts. It is God's kind oversight of creatures too far off for man to notice. Job's part was to listen, not argue.

- Freedom — God gave some animals to carry man's loads. This one He freed from all service. Even wildness is an assignment.

- Mirror — Writers see in this untamed animal a picture of man as he is born. It pictures self-will too, and self-will is sin: doing our own will and neglecting God's.

- Release — The freest creature alive still depends on its Maker. The God who loosed its bonds can loose Job's. So let him wait on God.

Job 39:6

Whose house I made the wilderness, and the salt plain his dwellings?

God points Job to a creature that lives where nothing grows, and asks who gave it that ground. Job had been demanding answers; now he must name who houses an animal he does not feed, own, or command.

The house God Himself assigned

The words "home" and "dwelling place" are the language of a landlord, not a bystander. One writer sees the same hand behind every animal in the chapter.

He, not man, has made them what they are, and ordered their habits and their habitations. If He has given some to carry man's loads, He has freed others from any such service. Take the wild donkey, with its house in the desert and its dwelling place on the open plain. There no city noise and no driver's shouts ever reach him. He can range the mountains at will as he searches out every green thing.

William Kelly

A house that produces nothing

"Arid plain" and "salt land" name ground that grows no crop. Yet the animal placed there does not starve.

The wild donkey is a totally different type of creature, found mainly in the plains or wilderness. Man just does not control the habits of this animal, which is "free as the breeze." He lives in "the barren land," yet God somehow sustains him in finding food. He avoids the noise of the city and is not like the tame donkey that must obey the direction of a driver.

Leslie M. Grant

Free creature, burdened man

Job, tied down by suffering, might have envied that freedom. One writer turns the envy into hope.

What control has Job over a creature like this, who knows no bonds, serves no master? As he thinks of their freedom, Job might sigh beneath his burdens. God is able to loosen his bonds. Let him not doubt, but wait on God.

Samuel Ridout

The picture of a will that answers to no one

Elsewhere in Scripture this animal stands for something in us. One writer gathers those passages, quoting them from an older translation.

In the Word of God the donkey is not only represented as unclean; it is also the very synonym for self-will. Read the Lord's account of him when He reasons with His servant in Job 39:5-8. And what is sin? … In other words, sin is doing our own will and neglecting the will of God. Who can claim to be exempt here? Who among us does not love to have his own way at whatever cost? … Job 11:12 is very pointed when it says: "Vain man would be wise, though man be born a wild donkey's colt." Genesis 16:12, correctly rendered, says of Ishmael, "He will be a wild donkey of a man."

W. W. Fereday

Another writer applies the picture to Job himself.

But in some respects Job was like the wild donkey — independent, rebellious, wanting his own way. So he had another object lesson to consider.

Leslie M. Grant

A description that has outlived Job

One writer reads these words as a sketch of a real people whose life still matches them.

No more graphic a sketch was ever drawn than is given of Ishmael's descendants in the words quoted here (Job 39:5-8). Such exactly are the Bedouins.

William Kelly

What the question was for

The chapter's parade of animals had a purpose beyond the animals.

Clearly the question here is not about knowledge of animals. It is about the kind care that goes with perfect knowledge of every creature. God watched over young and old, beast and bird, even the least familiar and the most out of reach, according to the goodness and wisdom that made them. Was it not for Job, then, to listen and learn, instead of darkening counsel by words without knowledge? And certainly His ways with His people are far deeper than His dealings with the animal world.

William Kelly

Summary

- Given. The desert is not where the donkey escaped to; it is the house God handed him. The verse is God naming what He assigned.

- Sustained. The ground yields nothing, yet God feeds the creature. He keeps what no man owns or controls.

- Free. No driver, no master, no bonds — and still living on what God gives. Real freedom runs on His supply.

- Mirrored. The unbridled donkey is Scripture's picture of self-will, and Job had to see himself in it.

- Applied. If God tracks a creature no one values, He is not neglecting a suffering man. Job's part was to stop arguing and learn.

Job 39:7

He laugheth at the tumult of the city, and heareth not the shouts of the driver;

God is questioning Job out of the storm. Here He points to the wild donkey — an animal nobody owns, nobody feeds, nobody drives. Who arranged a life like that? Who gave one animal a stall and a master, and another the open waste and no voice to obey?

Who Loosed the Bands

One writer sets out what these animal questions were for: God's care for each creature, and His free hand in deciding how each one lives.

This is plainly not a question about animal science. It is a question about the kind care that goes with perfect knowledge of every creature. Suppose God did watch so carefully over young or old, beast or bird, even the least familiar or most out of reach. Suppose His care matched the goodness and wisdom which made them. Was it not then for Job to listen and learn, instead of darkening counsel by words without knowledge? … He, not man, has made them what they are, and ordered their habits and their homes. Some He has given to be the burden-bearers of man. Others He has freed from any such service — like the wild donkey, with its house in the desert.

William Kelly

No City, No Driver

The verse names two sounds — city noise and a driver's shout — and this donkey answers to neither. One writer shows how he lives instead.

The wild donkey is a completely different creature. He is found mainly in the plains or wilderness. Man does not control the habits of this animal that is "free as the breeze." He lives in "the barren land," yet God somehow sustains him in finding food. He avoids the tumult of the city and is not like the tame donkey that must obey the direction of a driver.

Leslie M. Grant

A Mirror Held Up to Job

The same writer turns the portrait back on the man listening to it.

Would men have even thought of creating an animal like this? But in some respects Job was like the wild donkey — independent, rebellious, wanting his own way. So he had another object lesson to consider.

Leslie M. Grant

Another writer hears longing here rather than rebuke. Job was the one in chains, while this creature roamed free.

What control has Job over a creature like this, who knows no bonds, serves no master? As he thinks of their freedom, Job might sigh beneath his burdens. God is able to loosen his bonds. Let him not doubt, but wait on God.

Samuel Ridout

The Picture of Self-Will

Other parts of Scripture use this animal as a symbol. One writer takes it straight to the meaning of sin.

In the Word of God the donkey is not only represented as unclean; it is also the very synonym for self-will. Read the Lord's account of him as He reasons with His servant in Job 39:5-8. And what is sin? … "Sin is lawlessness." In other words, sin is doing our own will and neglecting the will of God. Who can claim to be exempt here? Who among us does not love to have his own way at whatever cost?

W. W. Fereday

Desert Dwellers

One writer applies the picture to a real people: the descendants of Ishmael, a son of Abraham.

No sharper picture of Ishmael's descendants was ever drawn than the words quoted here: "He scorns the tumult of the city; he hears not the shouts of the driver" (Job 39:5-8). The Bedouins are exactly like this.

William Kelly

The Better Freedom

The wild donkey hears no driver. One writer sets the opposite picture beside him: a horse that does.

The wild donkey likes his own wild ways. He likes to run about at will and refuses to be bridled or tamed, or to submit himself to another's will. Is this not a striking picture of the heart that has never been changed by God? But a horse in Pharaoh's chariots has been broken in. It has learned to give up its own wishes. It yields to the pull of the rein in its master's hand, and so spends its energy in its master's service.

The Christian's Friend

Summary

- Freedom given. The donkey did not win his liberty; God loosed the bands and assigned him the desert instead of the stall.

- Freedom fed. No driver means no feeder either. Yet God feeds him in the barren land, and His care reaches the creature that serves no man.

- Freedom mirrored. God held up a mirror. Job too was independent and wanting his own way. Commentators differ here: some read the scene as rebuke, others as comfort that God can loosen Job's bonds too.

- Freedom exposed. Hearing no driver is the picture of self-will. Doing our own will in place of God's will is what sin is.

- Freedom fulfilled. Real freedom is not running loose in the desert. It is the broken horse in the chariot, giving its strength to the rein and to its Master's service.

Job 39:8

The range of the mountains is his pasture, and he searcheth after every green thing.

God's answer to Job runs through creature after creature. Here He stops at the wild donkey — an animal no one owns, feeding where no farmer plants. Who arranged that life, and what does it say to Job?

The Creator Assigned the Habitat

One writer puts the wild donkey next to the working animals. The same hand arranged both.

He, not man, has made them what they are, and ordered their habits and their homes. He has given some animals the work of carrying man's burdens. Others He has kept free from any such service. Take the wild donkey. Its house is the desert and its dwelling-place the open country. There a city's noise and a driver's shouts are unknown. It can range the mountains at will as it searches out every green thing.

William Kelly

Fed Where Nothing Grows

The pasture in this verse is not rich farmland.

The wild donkey lives in "the barren land," yet God somehow sustains him in finding food. ... His pasture is the lower ranges of the mountains, not the rocks. There he may find green vegetation.

Leslie M. Grant

Care for Creatures Men Ignore

God's care reaches creatures men would write off. The argument then runs from them to Job.

The series opens with God's provision for beasts and birds of prey, as seen in the lion and the raven. Next, the wild animals of the mountain and desert come under His all-wise care... They might seem worthless, even harmful, yet He cares for them with unerring wisdom. Shall He fail to watch over His child who knows and trusts Him?

Samuel Ridout

A Portrait Job Could Recognise

Commentators also read the animal as a mirror held up to Job.

Would men have even thought of creating an animal like this? But in some respects Job was like the wild donkey — independent, rebellious, wanting his own way. So he had another object lesson to consider.

Leslie M. Grant

The lesson is not for Job alone.

In the Word of God the donkey is not only unclean; it is also the very picture of self-will. Read the Lord's account of him as He reasons with His servant in Job 39:5-8. And what is sin? Scripture defines it in 1 John 3:4: "sin is lawlessness." In other words, sin is doing our own will and neglecting the will of God. Who can claim to be exempt here? Who among us does not love to have his own way whatever the cost?

W. W. Fereday

Comfort for a Man in Bonds

Suffering held Job down while this animal roamed free.

Moving from the mountain to the plain, the Lord points out the one creature that lives in those waste places: the wild donkey. He is quite different from the wild goats in ways and habits. But he shares one thing with them: he depends completely on his Creator. What control has Job over a creature like this, who knows no bonds and serves no master? As he thinks of their freedom, Job might sigh under his burdens. God is able to loosen his bonds. Let him not doubt, but wait on God.

Samuel Ridout

A Description That Still Fits

One writer applies the same description to a people still living this way.

No more vivid sketch was ever drawn than the one given of Ishmael's descendants in the words quoted... Such exactly are the Bedouins. No sober Christian supposes an ongoing miracle in Ishmael's case. Yet what God said of that race is as sure as what He said of Israel.

William Kelly

Summary

- Freed by God. God gave this donkey his freedom. He made the desert his home and kept him clear of human service.

- Fed by God. His pasture is barren ground below the rocks. God feeds him there as he searches out every green thing.

- Known by God. His care reaches even the creatures men count worthless. It will not fail His child who trusts Him.

- Mirrored in Job. Independent, rebellious, wanting his own way: the animal pictures self-will. God asks Job to see himself in it.

- Released by God. The One who loosed this creature's bands can loose Job's; the lesson ends not in envy of the free but in waiting on God.