Job 34:26–30

Job 34:26

He striketh them as wicked men in the open sight of others,

Job has claimed that his suffering proves God has wronged him. Elihu answers that charge, and here he turns to how God deals with hardened wrongdoers. Why does God sometimes strike in full public view? And what brings the blow down?

No Act Without A Cause

Elihu's reply starts not with Job's pain but with Job's words:

He shows what Job had got so badly wrong. First, in saying, "I am righteous"; and then for saying it was no use serving God. That shows how self-righteousness leads to unbelief and the deepest spiritual wickedness. God is then shown to be just in all His ways. Man may not see it, but there is a need for every act of God and every permission of God. That is true of His dealings with a nation and of His dealings with a single man.

C Stanley

Struck In The Open

Wrongdoers count on cover. Elihu says the cover fails:

"Therefore He knows their works" — He has no need to investigate them patiently first. He overthrows them, even in the night, when they think they are hidden from view, "and they are crushed." This often happens, but only when God decides it. So He may strike them in their wickedness where others can see, rather than in the dark. The reason is given at once: they turned aside from following Him, and had no regard for any of His ways. This was not true of Job, yet he had spoken in the way the wicked speak.

Leslie M. Grant

Deliberate Contempt

One writer gathers Elihu's picture of these men into a few lines:

He takes account of their deeds. He overturns in a night, and they are crushed, as wicked, struck openly before others. He does this for their deliberate slight of Him and His ways, and to vindicate the poor and oppressed who cried to Him. So truly sovereign is He, and also just and merciful: nation or man makes no difference, since He is above both.

William Kelly

Older translations read "as wicked men" where the ESV has "for their wickedness", and the writers quoted here follow that older wording.

Nothing Hidden, Nobody Favoured

Does a powerful man escape this, while weaker men are struck?

Elihu goes on to speak of the searching judgment of God. It is completely impartial: the rich are subject to it just as much as the poor. And there is no gloom or deep darkness where those who work evil may hide themselves. He went on to say that God's judgments are always right, and that He acts as seems good in His sight. He breaks in pieces and overthrows mighty men, yet on the other hand He hears the cry of the afflicted.

F. B. Hole

Judgment With A Purpose

Judgment like this is not display for its own sake. The same hand can also give quietness:

Elihu reminds his hearers in a few words of God's actual judgments. He strikes down evildoers who depart from Him; He remembers the cause of the poor and needy. So too, if He acquits and gives quietness, who can condemn? "It is God who justifies; who is to condemn?" And if He hides His face, who can look upon Him? This is true whether He deals this way with one person or with mankind in general. He puts down evil men so that they cannot trap the people.

Samuel Ridout

The Turn Elihu Wanted From Job

All of this presses Job toward one choice:

If Job has unfairly charged God in this way, he has a most important lesson to learn. What is fitting for a man in his position? Should he boldly assert his own righteousness and accuse God? Or should he humbly admit that he was wrong to hold such thoughts, and pray, "Teach me what I do not see; if I have done iniquity, I will do it no more"?

Samuel Ridout

Summary

- Cause — The blow is never random. Every act of God, and everything He permits, has a reason, whether or not man can see it.

- Reason — The stroke answers a deliberate slight. These men turned aside from God and had no regard for His ways.

- Openness — Men use darkness to hide from other men; God may answer by striking them in full view instead of in the dark.

- Reach — The same searching judgment falls on rich and poor alike. The God who breaks the mighty also hears the cry of the afflicted.

- Outcome — Public judgment protects. God puts evil men down so they cannot trap the people.

Job 34:27

Because they have turned back from him, and would consider none of his ways;

Commentary for this verse has not been generated yet.

Job 34:28

So that they cause the cry of the poor to come unto him, and he heareth the cry of the afflicted.

Job had charged God with denying him justice. Elihu answers that charge, and here he names what moves God to strike the wicked in open view: the cries of the people they have crushed have reached Him. That raises a hard question for anyone who is suffering. Does God really hear? And if He does, why is the answer so slow?

The cry that brings the blow

The judgment in the verses just before this one is not random. One commentator explains why the blow falls, and whom it is for.

He takes notice of their deeds. He overturns them in a night, and they are crushed as wicked men. He strikes them openly before others, for their deliberate contempt of Him and His ways, and to vindicate the poor and oppressed who cried to Him. He is truly sovereign, and at the same time just and merciful. It makes no difference whether a nation or a single man is in view, for He is above both. He acts so that no corrupt man may reign and trap the people.

William Kelly

So who are the "they" at the start of the verse?

These were those who oppressed the poor.

Leslie M. Grant

A Judge with no favourites

A few verses earlier Elihu had said that God shows no partiality to princes. That cuts straight at Job's own complaint.

"Yet He is not partial to princes, nor does He regard the rich more than the poor" (v.19). Job had been rich, but he should have observed that God did not favour him above others who were poor. In fact, he imagines that God showed partiality by allowing him to suffer rather than others. But this only exposed his lack of discernment. However, all men are "the work of His hands." God is doing a very wise work with every individual.

Leslie M. Grant

Nothing hidden, no one beyond reach

Hearing the cry of the afflicted is one half of a pair. The same God who hears also sees, and the wicked cannot get out of range of either.

Elihu goes on to speak of the searching judgment of God. There is no darkness or deep shadow where those who do evil may hide themselves. He went on to say that God's judgments are always right. He acts as seems good in His sight, breaking in pieces and overthrowing mighty men, yet on the other hand hearing the cry of the afflicted.

F. B. Hole

Their cause remembered

One writer links God's memory of the poor to the safety of everyone God has acquitted.

Lastly, Elihu with few words reminds his hearers of God's actual judgments. He strikes evildoers who depart from Him; He remembers the cause of the poor and needy. So too, if He acquits and gives quietness, who can condemn? "It is God who justifies. Who is to condemn?" (Rom. 8:33-34). If He hides His face, who can look upon Him?

Samuel Ridout

The unpaid and the ignored

This has a sharp edge for anyone able to make others cry out. The same principle shows up in a warning about unpaid wages.

Do you want to know what God thinks of such behaviour? Then listen to these words of holy indignation: "Behold, the wages of the labourers who mowed your fields, which you kept back by fraud, are crying out against you, and the cries of the harvesters have reached the ears of the Lord of hosts." (James 5:4) "The Lord of hosts" hears the cry of the wronged and disappointed labourer. God will not let anyone heartlessly toss aside the claims of the poor.

C. H. Mackintosh

Job's own cry

Elihu is not only talking about oppressors and their victims. He is answering the man in front of him, who felt God was ignoring him.

Did God hear the cry of the poor? Yes indeed! Did God hear the complaints of Job? Job did not think so. But God does hear, and He will answer in His own time and way… At the moment God had not given quietness to Job, though He certainly did so later.

Leslie M. Grant

Summary

- Cause — oppressors themselves send the cry of the poor up to God. Their own cruelty puts the case of the poor before Him.

- Heard — God hears the cry of the afflicted, and He remembers the cause of the poor and needy.

- Impartial — God shows no partiality to princes. He does not put the rich above the poor. All are the work of His hands.

- Exposed — no darkness hides those who do evil. God overturns them and strikes them in front of everyone.

- Timing — God does hear, but He answers in His own time and way. Job found that out later, when God gave him quietness.

Job 34:29

When he giveth quietness, who then will disturb? and when he hideth [his] face, who shall behold him? and this towards a nation, or towards a man alike;

Elihu is answering Job's complaint that God has denied him justice. This verse is the high point of his reply: what God settles, no one can unsettle, and what God withdraws, no one can take back by force.

Quietness that no power can break

Older translations read the first line as "When He gives quietness, who then can make trouble?", and the writers here follow that wording. One of them notes that the God who gives quietness stands above more than human power.

Then he shows another side, when God gives quietness. God, after all, is always above the devil, despite his restless wickedness. Not only above man, but above Satan and all his power.

William Kelly

Acquittal, and the face turned away

Commentators read the two halves in different ways. One treats God's quietness as an acquittal, and ties it to Romans 8.

If He acquits, gives quietness, who can condemn? "It is God who justifies. Who is to condemn?" (Rom. 8:33-34). If He hides His face, who can look upon Him? He may deal this way with a single individual, or with mankind in general. He puts down evil men so that the people are not ensnared by them.

Samuel Ridout

Another divides the verse by the people involved rather than by the courtroom.

He may give quietness to the afflicted, and who then can disturb it? He may hide His face from the wicked, and who then can behold Him? And this is true whether a nation is in question or only an individual.

F. B. Hole

Nations rest on the same terms as men

The verse says the rule holds for a nation as much as for one person. One writer shows this in the reign of Josiah, a king of Israel, and asks where a country should look for safety.

In the goodness of God no external complications arose while Josiah was engaged in his good work. The movements of nations are under divine control. Elihu said truly: "When He gives quietness, who can make trouble?" and he added that this applies to nations as well as to individual men. ... In Jehoshaphat's reign "the realm was quiet, for his God gave him rest all around" (2 Chron. 20:30). ... Is it not better to trust God than to seek safety in treaties and alliances?

W. W. Fereday

The purpose behind the silence

Verse 30 adds a purpose to all this. One writer explains what God's way of working does to the hypocrite.

God uses each of these cases to put the hypocrite in his place (v.30). A hypocrite would like to hold the place of authority. But his thoughts are moved by his feelings, not by faith. So God's sovereign wisdom defeats him, because God works in a way that does not pamper men's feelings. People are then not trapped by the hypocrite, if they simply believe God.

Leslie M. Grant

When the quietness has not yet come

Job had not yet been given quietness. One writer asks whether God was hearing him at all.

Did God hear the cry of the poor? Yes indeed! Did God hear the complaints of Job? Job did not think so, but God does hear, and He will answer in His own time and way. Elihu had good reason to ask, "When He gives quietness, who then can make trouble?" (v.29). At the moment God had not given quietness to Job, though He certainly did so later. On the other hand, when God hides His face, who then can understand Him, whether a nation or an individual? God does either of these things when He pleases, and submission to Him is the only proper response from man.

Leslie M. Grant

What it looks like in a life

One writer applies the verse to Gideon, an early leader in Israel, who worshipped God while his nation was falling apart.

How beautiful and quiet all this is in the middle of utter ruin and confusion. "When He gives quiet, who then can trouble?" Gideon has found the God of peace, and we see him, the accepted worshipper. He is hidden in the secret of God's presence from the pride of man and the strife of tongues.

Samuel Ridout

Summary

- Source. Quietness is given, not achieved — and the God who gives it stands above man, above Satan, and above all his power.

- Security. No one can take back what God gives. If He acquits, no one can condemn. If He hides His face, no one can force Him to appear.

- Reach. The same rule governs a nation and a single person. Trusting God is a safer defence than treaties and alliances.

- Purpose. He works this way so that the hypocrite does not reign and the people are not trapped by him.

- Response. When quietness has not yet come, as with Job, God still hears. He answers in His own time, and submission is the only proper answer from man.

Job 34:30

That the ungodly man reign not, that the people be not ensnared.

Elihu has been arguing that the God who governs the world cannot Himself be unjust. Here he names God's purpose in overturning powerful men: rulers fall so that a godless man will not hold power and trap the people under him. (Older translations read "hypocrite" where the ESV has "godless man.")

The Close of Elihu's Defense

Job had charged God with injustice. Elihu answers by pointing to how God acts — He strikes evildoers and remembers the poor:

Lastly, Elihu with few words reminds his hearers of God's actual judgments. He strikes evildoers who depart from Him. He remembers the cause of the poor and needy. So too, if He acquits and gives quietness, who can condemn? "It is God who justifies. Who is to condemn?" (Rom. 8:33-34). He puts down evil men so that the people are not ensnared by them.

Samuel Ridout

God Overturns the Mighty

The removal of a corrupt ruler is not an accident of politics. God acts, and He needs no investigation first, because He already sees everything about the man:

The mighty are removed — and not by a human hand. For all things are naked and open to the eyes of Him with whom we have to do: the ways of a man and all his steps. He does not need to look at a man a second time before that man goes before God in judgment. Without further scrutiny, He is entitled to break the mighty and to set up others in their place. He takes notice of their deeds and overturns them in a night. They are crushed as wicked and struck openly in front of others. This is for their deliberate slighting of Him and His ways, and in vindication of the poor and oppressed who cried to Him. So truly sovereign is He, and at the same time just and merciful. Nation or man makes no difference, since He is above both — so that a corrupt man may not reign and the people are not ensnared.

William Kelly

Nation or Individual Alike

The same hand works on both scales. What God does with an empire He also does with one sufferer. The rich are no more exempt from His scrutiny than the poor:

Elihu goes on to speak of the searching judgment of God, which is completely impartial. The rich are answerable to it just as much as the poor. Also there is "no darkness, nor shadow of death," where those who do evil can hide themselves. He may hide His face from the wicked — and who then can behold Him? And this is true whether a nation is in question or only an individual.

F. B. Hole

The Snare and the Safeguard

Why is a godless ruler a snare? He wants the position, and feelings rather than faith drive him. God's way of governing defeats that ambition — and the people have a safeguard too:

God uses each of these cases to put the hypocrite in his place (v.30). A hypocrite would like to have the place of authority, but his feelings move his thoughts, not faith. So God's sovereign wisdom defeats him, because God does things in a way that does not pamper men's feelings. People then are not snared by the hypocrite if they simply believe God.

Leslie M. Grant

That God removes bad rulers does not license contempt for the office itself:

A king may have his faults, but his office is one that demands reverence from men. We are not only to fear God but to honour the king.

William Kelly

The Lesson Pressed on Job

All of this is aimed at one man. If God governs so carefully, Job's accusation collapses. What is left is not self-defence but a plea to be taught:

If Job has unfairly charged God in this way, he has a most important lesson to learn. What is fitting for someone in his position? Bold claims of self-righteousness and accusations against God? Or the humble admission that he was wrong to harbour such thoughts, with the prayer, "Teach me what I do not see; if I have done iniquity, I will do it no more" (v.32).

Samuel Ridout

Summary

- Cause. God, not chance, removes the mighty. He overturns in a night and needs no second look at a man, because He sees everything.

- Purpose. That removal has a stated aim: a corrupt man must not reign, and the people must not be ensnared.

- Reach. The same hand governs a whole nation or one person. The rich answer to Him as much as the poor.

- Safeguard. A false ruler does not trap people who simply believe God — and respect for the ruler's office still stands.

- Response. For Job, and for anyone reading, the fitting answer is not self-defence but "Teach me what I do not see."