Job 34:14–15

Job 34:14

If he only thought of himself, [and] gathered unto him his spirit and his breath,

Elihu has just asked who put God in charge of the world, and now he presses further: what if God drew back the spirit and breath He gives? The question is sharp — Job's own next breath comes from the God he accuses of unfairness.

Elihu's Argument Against Job's Charge

Elihu is defending God's justice. No one appointed God to His office. So no one can call Him to account for it, and the world He keeps alive is His own.

Elihu dismisses the thought that there is any wrong in God, the Judge of all. And who or what was man, to sit in judgment on the Almighty? Was it he, or anyone else, who put God in charge of the earth? And who founded the universe? Creation owes its existence and its continued life to God's unselfish goodness. He would only have to draw His care back into Himself and gather up His life-giving Spirit. Then all flesh would breathe its last, and man, the highest creature here below, would return to dust.

William Kelly

"Set His Heart" — Upon Man Or Upon Himself?

Commentators differ over the opening clause. The wording above reads "set his heart to it." Older English versions read "if he set his heart upon man." Several writers prefer "upon Himself" — God turning His attention inward and thinking only of Himself.

Suppose He turned His heart only to Himself, instead of remembering the need of the creation that depends on Him. He is completely self-sufficient. He needs nothing from outside. In all the past of eternity, God — Father, Son and Spirit — found enough delight in the Divine circle. Suppose, says Elihu, He were to turn back into that Divine Sufficiency. Suppose He set His heart not upon man, as in our version, but upon Himself. What would become of His creation?

Samuel Ridout

Read that way, the verse measures God's greatness.

Others translate verse 14, "If He only thought of Himself, and gathered to Him His spirit and His breath." The result would then be this: all flesh would die together, and man would return to the dust. Such is the greatness as well as the rightness of God.

F. B. Hole

No Self-Running World

Many people assume the world runs on its own laws and momentum. Elihu assumes the opposite. God's direct action holds creation in being every moment.

There is not a doubt God gives an impulse to all the heavenly bodies, and the earth among the rest. He gave them their motion; but then it is God who keeps it up. Men attribute this to second causes. But it is not in the nature of motion to be perpetual. That is all a great mistake; there is no such thing. It is God who keeps everything going. If God withdrew the direct action of His power for a moment, everything would collapse. That is what Elihu teaches here.

William Kelly

"His Spirit And His Breath"

The two words in the verse have drawn different readings. Some see the pairing as evidence that the breath God breathed into the first man is the human spirit.

Elihu also refers to the material and the spiritual when he speaks of God. He says that if God were to "gather to Himself his spirit and his breath," then "all flesh shall perish together, and man shall return again to dust" (Job 34:14-15). This Scripture gives us further light. It links the spirit with the thought of breath. That suggests the breath of life in Genesis 2:7 is the spirit of a man.

Hamilton Smith

Others reject that reading. Some argue from this verse that a man's spirit is only his breath. One writer answers that the verse names both:

Job 34:14 has been treated in the same way. But it is hard to see how he can quote "his spirit and his breath" to prove that the two are one. The opposite would seem self-evident.

Frederick W Grant

Why It Humbles Us

The verse strikes at human pride.

In fact, if God so desired, He could "gather to Himself His Spirit and His breath" by which He gives life to all mankind. What would happen then? "All flesh would perish together, and man would return to dust" (vv.14-15). How withering a rebuke to the pride of man! How plainly this tells us that we always depend on the power of God. He did not only create us; He keeps us alive at every moment.

Leslie M. Grant

Summary

- Accountable — No one gave God charge of the earth. So no one can charge Him with wrong. Man answers to God, not God to man.

- Self-sufficient — He needs nothing from outside Himself. If He turned His heart inward, all flesh would breathe its last.

- Sustaining — He does not turn inward, so everything keeps going. Withdraw His power for a moment and it all collapses.

- Dependent — Your spirit and breath are God's to give and to gather back. That is the rebuke to pride.

- Good — Creation exists, and keeps existing, because of God's unselfish goodness; your next breath is His gift.

Job 34:15

All flesh would expire together, and man would return to the dust.

Job had charged God with wronging him. Elihu answers with a question nobody had asked: who appointed God over the world, and what would happen if He turned His attention away from it? Verse 15 gives the answer — every living thing collapses back into dust.

God Cannot Do Wrong

Elihu does not argue that God happens to be just. He argues that God could not be anything else:

"Far be it from God to do evil." "God is light, and in Him is no darkness at all" (1 John 1:5). The Almighty can do everything, but "He cannot lie." "He cannot deny Himself." This ensures perfect and impartial justice in His dealings with men... How could God act wickedly or twist what is right? He would not be God if this were possible.

Samuel Ridout

How Verse 14 Reads

Commentators read the line before this one in two ways. Older English versions have God setting His heart "upon man." Others take it to mean that God turns His heart back on Himself alone.

Note verse 14 in its true rendering, "Should He set His heart upon Himself," what then would become of man? All flesh would then expire and man would turn to dust again. But He does not set His heart upon Himself.

Arno Clemens Gaebelein

Read that way, the two verses form one enormous conditional, and the size of the consequence is itself part of the argument:

Verse 14 has been translated, "If He only thought of Himself, and gathered to Him His spirit and His breath;" then the result would be that all flesh would expire together and man return to the dust. Such is the greatness as well as the rightness of God.

F. B. Hole

God Owes the World Nothing

God is under no obligation to anyone. He could withdraw into His own sufficiency:

Let Job look at God's providential care over His creation. It is His own, and not something committed to Him by another. He is self-sufficient. He needs nothing from outside Himself... Suppose, says Elihu, He were to turn back into that Divine Sufficiency. Suppose He set His heart on Himself, and not upon man as older versions read it. What would become of His creation? "All flesh would perish together, and man would return to dust" (ver. 15). "You take away their breath, they die" (Ps. 104:29)... So Peter tells believers who are suffering to "entrust their souls to a faithful Creator while doing good" (1 Peter 4:19). How good it is to remember this. The One who "upholds the universe by the word of His power" is also our Saviour, Lord and Friend.

Samuel Ridout

A Rebuke to Human Pride

Job had been speaking as though God were accountable to him. Elihu turns the question around, and points at something as ordinary as breathing:

He is asking in effect, "Is God answerable to anybody?" Did Job appoint God as the authority over the whole world? If so, of course then God would be answerable to Job! Indeed the opposite is true: Job, and every individual, is answerable to God. In fact, if God so desired, He could "gather to Himself His Spirit and His breath" by which He gives life to all mankind. What would happen then? "All flesh would perish together, and man would return to dust" (vv.14-15). How withering a rebuke to the pride of man! How clearly this tells us that we always depend on the power of God. He not only created us; He keeps us alive moment by moment.

Leslie M. Grant

Spirit, Breath and Dust

The verse names two things going in opposite directions — what God gathers back, and what returns to the ground. One writer, following the older reading "upon man," takes this as a picture of how a person is made:

"The preacher" speaks of death as touching both parts of man — the material and the spiritual. He says, "Then the dust returns to the earth as it was, and the spirit returns to God who gave it" (Eccles. 12:7). Elihu also speaks of the material and the spiritual. He says, "If He set His heart upon man, if He gathers to Himself His spirit and His breath, all flesh would perish together, and man would return to dust" (Job 34:14-15). This Scripture gives us further light. It links the spirit with the thought of breath. That suggests the breath of life in Genesis 2:7 is the spirit of a man.

Hamilton Smith

Summary

- Owes — God is answerable to no one; nobody put Him in charge of the earth, so nobody can call His dealings unjust.

- Gives — Your spirit and breath are His, lent moment by moment. His power made you, and His power keeps you alive.

- Withholds — If He turned His heart back on Himself alone, every living thing would die at once and man would return to dust.

- Sustains — He does not withdraw. The One who upholds everything is also Saviour, Lord and Friend.

- Trust — He is a faithful Creator. Sufferers can hand Him their souls while doing good, rather than accuse Him as Job did.