Job 33:31–33

Job 33:31

Mark well, Job, hearken unto me; be silent, and I will speak.

Job has spent long speeches justifying himself, and his friends have failed to reach him. Now Elihu asks for attention and silence: will Job stop defending himself long enough to hear?

Placed right after the good news

This is not where Elihu began. He calls for attention only after he has brought God in as the One who shows grace.

After this glowing utterance in which Elihu brings in God in His grace, he turns to Job. "Do you have anything to say? Then answer me." But Elihu waits in vain. Job's lips are sealed.

Arno Clemens Gaebelein

An invitation, not a demand

Asking a man to be quiet can be a way of silencing him. Elihu's aim is the opposite.

Elihu addresses himself directly to Job, for it was Job who needed an answer for his predicament. Elihu wanted time to say all that was on his mind, yet he did not demand that he should do all the speaking. Rather, he invites Job to speak out plainly if he has anything to say. Elihu was not putting Job down, as his friends did. He wanted Job to be justified. He did not mean that Job should justify himself, for this was already Job's tragic mistake. No doubt he wanted Job to be justified from God's viewpoint, just as the tax collector was justified rather than the Pharisee, when he prayed, "God, be merciful to me, a sinner!"

Leslie M. Grant

On Job's side, against Job's self-defence

Elihu's anger had one target, and it was not Job himself.

Elihu was for Job; but he was not for his self-righteousness. Against this he was angry. When the blessed Jesus walked this earth, nothing made Him so angry as the self-righteousness of the Pharisees. At this He was filled with indignation. You may have been deeply grieved that you could not be self-righteous, so as to justify yourself. The very attempt has grieved Him more.

C. Stanley

Why Job needed to stop talking

Job's friends had talked at him for chapters without reaching him. Elihu asks for silence because Job still did not know himself.

He brings the light of "truth" to bear upon Job's conscience. At the same time he applies the precious balm of "grace" to his heart… Truth puts everyone in his right place. And just because it does so, it cannot hand out flattering titles to a poor guilty mortal, however much that mortal might enjoy them. Man must be brought to know himself, to see his true condition, to confess what he really is. This was precisely what Job needed. He did not know himself, and his friends could not give him that knowledge. He needed to be led down into the depths; but his friends could not take him there. He needed self-judgment; but his friends were completely unable to produce it.

C. H. Mackintosh

A pause, not pressure

Elihu stops and leaves Job room to answer. Job says nothing — and what does that silence mean?

And now, Job, what have you to say to all this? Elihu wants to bring out Job's true condition — he would not excuse his wrong, but treat him with complete fairness. He pauses for a reply: Job is not to be forced, but does he not agree with what has been said? May we not read his silence as an acknowledgment of the truth of what we have been dwelling on?

Samuel Ridout

The wisdom on offer

Commentators differ over Elihu. Some have judged him harshly; others weigh his speech far higher.

Those who carry far more weight in godliness and discernment see him differently. In him they find a fairer and fuller assessment of Job and his friends. They also find the first real insight, shown throughout the book, into the place and aim of discipline through suffering.

William Kelly

Job's answer

Elihu asked for silence and got it. Job's quiet was a choice, not a defeat.

Job then had nothing to say. No doubt he recognised that Elihu's message was higher than he had considered, and he wisely chose to listen.

Leslie M. Grant

Summary

- Grace first. Elihu calls for attention only after he has spoken of God's grace. He points Job to good news, not a scolding.

- Listen, then speak. Elihu wants the floor but does not seize it; he invites Job to answer if he has anything to say.

- Justified, not self-justified. Elihu wants God to justify Job. That is the opposite of Job justifying himself.

- Silence makes room. Job needed self-judgment. No friend's argument could produce it, so the talking had to stop and let truth reach his conscience.

- He listened. Job had nothing to say. He judged Elihu's message higher than he had thought, and chose to hear it.

Job 33:32

If thou hast anything to say, answer me; speak, for I desire to justify thee.

Elihu has been speaking to Job at length, and now he stops and hands him the floor. His reason is what matters: he wants Job justified — not Job defending himself, but God putting him right.

The pause that gives Job a voice

Elihu wants to be heard, yet he leaves Job room to answer. His reason sets him apart from Job's three friends.

Elihu desired time to say all that was on his mind, yet he did not demand that he should do all the speaking. Rather, he invites Job to speak out plainly if he has anything to say (v.32). Elihu was not putting Job down, as his friends did. He wanted Job justified. He did not mean that Job should justify himself, for this was already Job's tragic mistake. No doubt he wanted Job justified from God's viewpoint, just as the tax collector was justified and the Pharisee was not, when he prayed, "God, be merciful to me, a sinner!" (Luke 18:13-14).

Leslie M. Grant

The righteousness that has to be let go

Job had spent chapters defending his own record. One writer shows what had to go before God would justify him.

Job was as busy as he could be, justifying himself. He goes so far as to say, "My righteousness I hold fast, and will not let it go" (Job 27:6). He never made it out, though. At the end of the story he has to put his hand on his mouth and say, "Behold, I am of small account" (Job 40:4). The Lord seems to say, "I will never let you go, Job, till you have given up those filthy rags, your own righteousness. Then I will justify you. I will give you My righteousness." … Only the presence of God can enable anyone to let go of their own righteousness. Not that they have any to let go, really — they only think they have.

W. T. P. Wolston

A desire, not a reluctance

The word "desire" carries the weight of the verse. Elihu does not help Job reluctantly — he wants this outcome. One writer hears God's own heart in it.

God's very object, His desire, His purpose in sending His beloved Son into this world was to justify ungodly sinners. Let the anxious, awakened sinner know this — in coming to Him, He is most ready, and He desires to justify you. The moment you believe on Him who raised up Jesus from the dead for our justification, that moment you are justified from all things. See Acts 13:38; Romans 4:24 to 5:1.

Charles Stanley

Why God is in the judge's seat at all

If God desires to justify, why is He on the judgment seat at all? One writer puts the question back on us.

The common thought is that God is our Judge, and so He is; but who made Him a Judge? Who put God on the judgment seat? You did! I did! The sin and guilt of man have forced God into the place of judgment. God must judge sin. Otherwise God and man would be alike, neither of them thinking much about it, and there would be no righteousness. Yet He has no desire to take the place of judgment. Even here, to Job, He says, "I desire to justify you" (Job 33:32).

W. T. P. Wolston

The man Job had asked for

Earlier Job had cried out for someone to stand between himself and God. One writer shows Elihu stepping into exactly that place.

He reminds Job of his own desire for such a person. Job had said, "There is no arbiter between us, who might lay his hand on us both" (Job 9:33), and, "that he would argue the case of a man with God, as a son of man does with his neighbour" (Job 16:21). To this desire Elihu now replies: "Behold, I am toward God as you are; I too was pinched off from a piece of clay. Behold, no fear of me need terrify you; my pressure will not be heavy upon you" (Job 33:6-7).

Samuel Ridout

Older translations render Job 33:6, "I am according to your wish, in God's stead" — the writer's point is that Elihu stands in God's place toward Job.

The silence that follows

Job takes the open invitation and says nothing. The next verse offers him the other road to wisdom.

Elihu had asked Job to speak if he had anything to say. He rightly adds, "if not, listen to me; be silent, and I will teach you wisdom" (v.33). Job then had nothing to say. No doubt he recognised that Elihu's message was higher than he had considered. He wisely chose to listen.

Leslie M. Grant

One writer weighs what that silence means.

Elihu is truly answering Job's desire for an arbiter. Job's silence may well be a sign of beginning conviction.

Samuel Ridout

Summary

- Desire. The verse turns on one word. Elihu wants Job justified, and one writer hears in it God's purpose in sending His Son to justify ungodly sinners.

- Not self-made. The justifying Elihu wants is not Job's self-defence — that was Job's mistake. It is God putting him right.

- Release. God gives His righteousness only after the filthy rags go. Only His presence makes a man loosen his grip on his own.

- Mediator. The offer comes through a man who does not terrify Job. That was Job's own cry — for someone to stand between him and God.

- Silence. Job is free to answer and has nothing to say. That silence is the first sign of conviction, and the doorway to the wisdom promised next.

Job 33:33

If not, hearken thou unto me; be silent, and I will teach thee wisdom.

Elihu has just described how God works again and again to turn a man back from the pit. Now he turns to Job with two questions: has he anything to say, and if not, will he be still and learn wisdom?

The closing of a whole argument

The verse closes Elihu's address and repeats the invitation he made at the start. One outline traces the chapter from God's ways of saving souls to this last pause:

Job 33:29-30. Elihu tells Job that these are samples of God's way in saving souls. Job 33:31-33. He asks Job at the last, as at the first, whether he had anything to say.

The Bible Treasury

An offer, not a demand

The verse begins with "if not," so the door is still open for Job to speak. Elihu waits for an answer, and reads Job's silence as agreement rather than defeat.

And now, Job, what have you to say to all this? Elihu wants to bring out Job's true condition. He would not justify his wrong, but would treat him with complete fairness. He pauses for a reply. He will not force Job, but does Job not agree with what he has heard? May we not read his silence as an admission that what we have been dwelling on is true?

Samuel Ridout

The aim behind the offer

Just before this verse, Elihu says he wants to see Job justified. That sounds odd, said to a man whose great fault was defending himself. One writer draws out the difference:

He invites Job to speak out plainly, if he has anything to say. Elihu was not putting Job down, as his friends did; he wanted Job to be justified. He did not mean that Job should justify himself, for that was already Job's tragic mistake. No doubt he wanted Job justified from God's viewpoint. God justified the tax collector rather than the Pharisee, when the tax collector prayed, "God, be merciful to me, a sinner!" (Luke 18:13-14).

Leslie M. Grant

Where the wisdom comes from

Elihu is the younger man here, yet he promises to teach wisdom to older men. He can make that claim only because the wisdom is not his own.

Elihu speaks against his own wish. He stands in front of men he would gladly have learned from, if only they could have taught him the mind of God. Yet he is careful to stand for nothing except what comes from God. He has learned, as never before, that spiritual wisdom is of God's Spirit, not of a man's age. It is the very opposite of self-confidence or boasting, though his heart is so full that he has to speak.

William Kelly

The silence he practised first

The call to be silent comes from a man who had stayed silent through the whole debate. That answers the charge that Elihu was a brash young man pushing his way in.

On what other ground could a younger man speak, and correct everyone who had gone before? He kept silent until even Job had no more to say. He spoke only when Job, as much as his friends, could not help feeling that the riddle was still unexplained. That silence is the strongest proof of how little he deserves the charge of being bold, forward, meddling, conceited, arrogant, or boastful. He certainly shows in the clearest light how completely those failed who had condemned Job without answering him, and who did it with hints that condemned themselves.

William Kelly

Job's silence

The chapter ends without a word from Job.

After this glowing speech, in which Elihu brings in God in His grace, he turns to Job. "Have you anything to say? Then answer me." But Elihu waits in vain. Job's lips are sealed.

Arno Clemens Gaebelein

That silence is exactly what the verse asked for:

Elihu had asked Job to speak if he had anything to say. Now he tells him, and rightly, "If not, listen to me; be silent, and I will teach you wisdom" (v. 33). Job then had nothing to say. No doubt he recognised that Elihu's message was higher than he had thought, and he wisely chose to listen.

Leslie M. Grant

Summary

- Invited — the verse ends Elihu's address with the offer he began with: speak, if you have something to say.

- Free — Job is not forced. Elihu pauses for a reply and reads the quiet that follows as agreement, not surrender.

- Justified — Elihu's goal is not to crush Job. He wants Job justified from God's viewpoint, the way the tax collector went home justified and the Pharisee did not.

- Taught — the wisdom on offer is not the speaker's own. It is of God's Spirit, not of a man's age, so the younger man may teach the older.

- Silent — Job says nothing, and that is the right answer. The man who had argued for chapters now takes the place of a listener.