For God speaketh once, and twice, -- [and man] perceiveth it not --
Job had found fault with God and had not understood His ways. Elihu, answering him, says God is not silent at all — He speaks, and speaks again, but the failure lies in the listener.
The trouble started with what Job had lost sight of:
He had completely failed in the reverence due to God. He had entirely forgotten the infinite distance between God and man, and the majesty of God. So instead of finding fault with himself for falling so far short, he found fault with God. He did not understand His ways fully. Now he ought to have trusted them, though he did not understand them.
The numbers here show patience. God says it again, and the reason lies in us:
God does not speak only once to a man. He speaks "twice, in fact three times," because we are poor listeners. God cares deeply that souls should be brought back from the Pit. That means rescue from the negative horror of being without God, and instead the positive blessing of being enlightened with the light of life.
The plagues God sent on Egypt show the same pattern:
It seems to be part of God's ways to warn twice. Then, if no one listens, He strikes the third time without any warning. Later on we do get the word, "God speaks in one way, and in two, though man does not perceive it" (Job 33:14). Elihu's words proved true here.
The problem is not how loudly God speaks. It is how we listen. One writer sets our dullness beside Christ:
He has learned the lesson well, that "power belongs to God." God had spoken it once, but Jesus had heard it twice. He heard it with a full witness of its truth; so wide did He open His ear to divine instruction morning by morning (Isa. 50:4). Man is a duller scholar. (See Job 33:14)
Why does God speak? Not to inform us, but to deal with something hidden:
His object is to correct wrong thoughts and actions. It is to withdraw man from "mischief," or his own purpose, and to hide pride from man (geber, the hero or mighty man). This goes deeper than action, for pride lurks in the heart, and God would hide it from man — hinder its control over him. "Keep back your servant also from presumptuous sins" (Ps. 19:13).
This verse is not telling you to wait for a dream:
The same truth holds with even fuller force now. We do not need a revelation by dreams and visions; we have it in the written word of God. He who spoke in many ways — dreams among the rest — has now given us the full revelation of Himself in His Son. That revelation, the entire word of God, we have in the Scriptures.
If the gentle way fails, a harder way follows. Its purpose is still mercy:
"He keeps back his soul from the pit" — such is the merciful object of God's intervention — "and his life from perishing by the sword." Here is more than a dream of the night or a passing vision. Here are corrective ways, as well as glimpses of God's light — or of His judgment, which the man was despising.
The verse is personal. Has God already spoken to you, and did you let it pass?
You have heard the voice of God. He has spoken and you have not paid attention. Perhaps twice this very day you have heard the voice of God through His Word... You have heard the Word of God but you have not perceived it. You have let it go by you unheeded. Some of us who know the Lord can look back and remember how many times He spoke to us, and we did not listen... But has He given you up, given up His pursuit of your soul? No.
- Speaks. God is never the silent one. Job blamed a God who was already speaking.
- Twice. He repeats Himself out of patience, not doubt. He speaks again because "we are poor listeners."
- Missed. The failure is on our side. Christ heard twice what God said once; "man is a duller scholar."
- Withdraws. The aim of the speaking is rescue: to pull a man back from his own purpose and to hide pride from him before it rules him.
- Then the rod. Ignore the voice, and corrective dealings follow. Even these keep the soul back from the pit.
In a dream, in a vision of the night, when deep sleep falleth upon men, in slumberings upon the bed;
Elihu has just told Job that God speaks once and twice, and man does not notice. This verse names the first of those quiet channels: the night, sleep, a dream.
Elihu names Job's real problem: he argued with God instead of asking Him anything.
Not only was Job judging God, but he was also not subject to Him. There was a lack of submission in his heart. If God was dealing with him, why did he not ask Him, instead of murmuring?
God chooses the setting. Daylight lets a person stay busy; sleep does not.
Since God is invisible, He speaks to man in ways that do not show Him personally, but ways that awaken man's serious attention... Though man may not perceive that it is God speaking to him, yet often God does so "in a dream, in a vision of the night, when deep sleep falls on men." At such a time God has a captive audience, whether man wants to listen or not. God spoke to Pilate's wife this way (Matthew 27:19), though sadly Pilate did not act on her advice. He had already trapped himself by his weak indecision.
Another writer applies this to nights when sleep will not come:
When all is quiet at last, God can speak... So insomnia, or sleeplessness, can sometimes be a hidden blessing. It is always a good habit, when we cannot sleep, to praise and pray.
One writer traces the Hebrew word behind it across Scripture:
The word for deep sleep, tardemah, is never used of natural sleep. It is used of sleep that is either supernatural, sent for a special purpose (Gen. 2:21; Gen. 15:12; Job 4:13; Job 33:15), or spiritual, part of God's dealings in governing man (Prov. 19:15; Isa. 29:10).
Verse 15 runs straight on into verse 16. Elihu says what God is after when He sends a dream.
When the light of nature is withdrawn, when all is silent, He speaks in "a still small voice" and makes known His mind. So instruction is sealed on the heart of man. His purpose is to correct wrong thoughts and actions, to withdraw man from "mischief," or his purpose, and to hide pride from man (geber, the hero or mighty man). This goes deeper than action, for pride lurks in the heart, and God would hide it from man — hinder its control over him.
That gives a test for any dream:
If a dream is a warning against what I may be inclined to do, or if it humbles me, then I should take it to heart.
In the chapter as a whole, the night dream is only the opening move. The sequence runs on to the ransom of verse 24.
Verses 15-22. He shows God using the plough — of a dream, of a striking providence, of bodily pain or sickness — to break up such fallow ground. And such is the work to this day... Verses 23-24. The sower comes after the ploughman. The seed is the Gospel. God provides the ransom and brings deliverance to the sinner.
The plough first works on someone who does not yet know God:
He begins with the first work of God in the man who does not know Him. It is grace working to awaken an unconverted soul... It is exactly what marks divine mercy in appealing to the unconverted man. He is carried away by his own will. But God knows how to bend or break it.
Commentators differ. One holds that the need for dreams has passed:
The same truth is in even fuller force now, for we do not need a revelation by dreams and visions, but have it in the written word of God. He who spoke in many ways (dreams among the rest) has now given us the full revelation of Himself in His Son.
Another says such nudges still come, but rank below Scripture:
I think I have been aware of God whispering little things to me about myself. He advised me to be careful about what I was doing. He made me judge myself in a way I had not done before... The great point is that it is altogether inferior to the word. This is where we have our great advantage.
- Speaks. God is not silent, as Job charged. He speaks once and twice, and man fails to perceive it.
- Sleeps. He picks the hour when no one can escape Him. The "deep sleep" here is not ordinary rest, but sleep sent for a special purpose.
- Opens. The dream opens the ear. It pulls a man back from what he planned, and reaches the pride hidden in the heart, not just the wrong action.
- Ploughs. Dream, providence and sickness are the plough that breaks hard ground. Then the sower comes with the gospel and the ransom of verse 24.
- Speaks again. God has now spoken in His Son, so the written word is the surer voice. Some writers hold dreams are no longer needed. Others say they still come, but always rank below Scripture.
Then he openeth men's ears, and sealeth their instruction,
Elihu has told Job that God is greater than man, yet God is not silent — He speaks again and again, and man does not notice. Verse 16 is the turning point: God Himself opens the ear, and He does it for a reason.
God is not the one who is silent. Man's own will carries him along, and grace has to break in. One writer sees this verse as the first work of God in a person who does not yet know Him:
Here Elihu rightly begins at the beginning. He starts with the first work of God in the man who does not know Him. It is grace working to wake up a soul that is not yet converted... This is exactly what marks out God's mercy when He appeals to the man who is not converted. His own will carries him away. But God knows how to bend it or break it.
The verse says "men," not "believers." The same writer presses that word, and adds that believers are not left out either:
"Then he opens the ears of men" (verse 16). That is what this chapter shows. It does not say "believing" men; it is any man, so that he may believe. Yet we do not always behave as believers. When that happens, we may get a little word that simply shows us where we are — that we are "walking as men," as the apostle said.
The ESV ends verse 16 with a warning; older translations, which these writers quote, read "and seals their instruction." To seal something is to fix it in place so it cannot be lost. When the light of day is gone, God presses the lesson home, and it reaches deeper than behaviour:
Elihu makes it plain that God does speak to man in this way. When the light of nature is gone, when all is silent, He speaks in "a still small voice" and makes His mind known. In this way He seals the instruction on the heart of man. His aim is to correct wrong thoughts and actions, to draw man back from "mischief," or from his own purpose, and to hide pride from man. The word for man here is geber, the hero or mighty man. This goes deeper than what a man does, for pride hides in the heart, and God would hide that pride from him — He keeps it from ruling him.
Commentators differ here. Some say God spoke this way before the Bible was finished, and does not now:
When there was no Bible, no written revelation of God, God spoke to individuals by dreams and visions. He does not do so any longer, for we have His finished Word, which makes His will known to us.
Others allow that God still does so, while ranking it far below the written Word:
He may speak in a dream or a vision. Scripture records that He has often done so, and He clearly still does. It happens most with simple believers who know little of the Bible, and who may not even have much of it in their own language. Where believers have the Bible to teach them — a better kind of guidance — dreams in which God speaks are rare by comparison. And if God does speak to a man in a dream, what is it for? To change his course, and to humble his pride into the dust.
The next verse says what the opened ear is for. That gives a test for anything that comes in the night:
When God sends people dreams, He "opens the ears of men, and seals their instruction" (v.16). This is not to flatter man's pride, but the very opposite: "to turn man from his deed, and conceal pride from man" (v.17). In other words, if a dream is a warning against what I may be inclined to do, or if it humbles me, then I should take it to heart.
Sleep is not the only silence God uses. Illness empties the calendar, and the same opening of the ear follows:
Then, too, "sickness" comes and strikes many. It stops all activity. The whirl of busy life gives way to the quiet of a bed of pain. This has done good to thousands. Then, "He opens the ears of men, and seals their instruction" (Job 33:16). In the quiet they learn how worthless their own efforts are, and where they can find true peace.
- Deaf, not unaddressed. God speaks once and twice. The failure is in man's hearing. His first work is in the person who does not yet know Him.
- He opens. The ear does not open itself — and the "men" here are any men, so that they may believe, not only those who already do.
- He seals. He fastens the lesson on the heart. He aims past conduct at the pride hidden underneath.
- He quiets. Sleep and a bed of pain stop the whirl of activity. In the quiet, a man sees what his own efforts are worth.
- He humbles. Commentators differ on whether God still uses dreams. They agree on the purpose: what turns you from your course and humbles your pride is worth taking to heart.
That he may withdraw man [from his] work, and hide pride from man.
Elihu has just described how God speaks to people who are not listening. He speaks in a dream, in a vision of the night, while they sleep. Verse 17 gives the reason for all that quiet effort: God is aiming at a man's plans and at his pride.
A dream like this is God's opening move on a person who does not yet know Him, and it aims at the will:
In this chapter Elihu shows Job one common way God deals with people, though God does not always work this way. He is not limited in how He reaches men, and can act on the soul in many ways. Elihu rightly begins at the beginning, with the first work of God in the man who does not know Him. It is grace working to awaken a soul that does not know God… This is just what marks out divine mercy when it appeals to such a man. His own will carries him away. But God knows how to bend or break it.
"His deed" — older translations say "his purpose" — is the course a person has set his heart on. God's love does not leave that course alone:
We all forget too easily the weighty fact that "God tries the righteous." "He does not withdraw His eyes from them." We are in His hands and always under His eye. We are the objects of His deep, tender, unchanging love; but we are also the subjects of His wise moral government. His dealings with us are varied. They are sometimes preventive, sometimes corrective, always instructive. We may be bent on some course of our own, the end of which would be moral ruin. He steps in and withdraws us from our purpose. He dashes our castles in the air to pieces. He scatters our golden dreams. He breaks in on many a favourite plan our hearts clung to — a plan that would have ended in certain destruction.
The second half of the verse goes below behaviour. The Hebrew word behind "a man" here is not the ordinary word for a human being:
His object is to correct wrong thoughts and actions. He withdraws man from "mischief," or his purpose, and hides pride from man (geber, the hero or mighty man). This goes deeper than action, for pride lurks in the heart, and God would hide it from man — hinder its control over him. "Keep back your servant also from presumptuous sins" (Ps. 19:13). So man is kept back from destruction. He bows to the correction of God's truth, and so is spared the smiting of the rod, or of the sword.
Since pride is the target, God does not act only after a man has done wrong. Job 33 and Job 36 are not describing the same thing:
Chastenings are not always for actual faults. Job 33:18-19 says, "he keeps back his soul from the pit, his life from perishing by the sword. Man is also rebuked with pain on his bed and with continual strife in his bones." Verse 17 tells us the purpose: to hide pride from man. Then in chapter 36 the chastening is for positive faults (v. 9).
Commentators differ on whether the night-time method of verses 15-17 continues. One holds that it belonged to an age without Scripture:
When there was no Bible, the revelation of God, God spoke to man individually by dreams and visions. He does not do so any longer, for we have His completed Word in which His will is made known to us.
Another gives a test for a dream, taken straight from verse 17. He quotes an older translation:
When God sends dreams to people, He "opens the ears of men, and seals their instruction" (v.16). This is not to flatter man's pride. It does the very opposite: it is "to turn man from his deed, and conceal pride from man" (v.17). In other words, if a dream is a warning against what I may be inclined to do, or if it humbles me, then I should take it to heart.
The pride this verse targets is the pride that defends its own righteousness before God. Losing it can cost a great deal:
Every effort to justify myself before God is striving against God… God "opens the ears of men, that He may withdraw man from his purpose, and hide pride from man." Then the man must pass through this sore pain and affliction. It may be through some fall that all self-trust is blighted.
- Grace speaks first. Before pain comes, God whispers — a dream, a vision, an opened ear — to reach a will that has carried the man away.
- Grace turns. God's first aim is the plan our hearts cling to. He scatters schemes that would have ended in ruin.
- Grace hides. The second aim is deeper than conduct: pride hidden in the heart, stripped of its control over the strong man.
- Grace prevents. God's dealings are not always payment for faults. Sometimes they stop the ruin before it starts.
- Grace can be tested. A voice that flatters your pride fails the test of verse 17. What humbles you, or warns you off your own deed, is worth taking to heart.
He keepeth back his soul from the pit, and his life from passing away by the sword.
Elihu is describing the ways God works on a man who will not listen — a dream, a warning, a sickbed. This verse gives the reason behind them all, and it raises a question: is hardship God punishing a man, or God rescuing him before he falls further?
Elihu is showing Job how God deals with a man who does not know Him. This verse names what those dealings are for.
In this very chapter Elihu points out to Job a fairly common way of God's dealings, though by no means a fixed rule. God is not at all limited in His methods of reaching men, but can act on the soul in many ways. He begins with the first work of God in a man who does not know Him. It is grace working to awaken a soul that has not yet turned to God... "He keeps back his soul from the pit" — such is the merciful purpose of God's intervention — "and his life from perishing by the sword."
The word "pit" carries more than one weight.
In these remarkable words Elihu was acting the part of the interpreter with Job. He showed the good purpose of God in His dealings with men, however hostile those dealings appear. He aims at delivering them from the "pit" of self-esteem and self-satisfaction in this life, and the "pit" of judgment and condemnation in the life to come.
Read with the verse before it, this is not God settling a score.
Chastenings are not always for actual faults. In Job it is said (chapter 33:18-19), "He keeps back his soul from the pit... He is chastened also with pain upon his bed, and with strong pain in many of his bones"; and we find from verse 17 that this is for the purpose of hiding pride from man. Then in chapter 36 the chastening is for actual faults.
Another writer follows this deeper than action, into the heart.
His aim is to correct wrong thoughts and actions, to withdraw man from "mischief," or his own purpose, and to hide pride from man — the word means the hero, the mighty man. This goes deeper than action, for pride hides in the heart, and God would hide it from man — stop it controlling him. "Keep back your servant also from presumptuous sins" (Psalm 19:13). So man is kept back from destruction. He bows to the correction of God's truth, and is spared the striking of the rod, or of the sword.
Elihu is not narrowing this to the godly. He is describing a man moving in one direction who gets stopped.
"Then he opens the ears of men" (v. 16). That is what is shown in this chapter. It is not "believing" men; it is any man, so that he might believe... "That he may withdraw man from his purpose, and hide pride from man." You see, it is one who had never yet been broken. "He keeps back his soul from the pit, and his life from perishing by the sword." He was on the straight road to it.
Commentators differ on how this works. One reads the verse plainly: God stepping in to save a life from real danger.
There is another way God has of pursuing a soul: He preserves from sudden danger. I well remember when I was a boy of sixteen, a brother of mine shot a partridge. The bird fell into the water. "Fetch it," he said, and I plunged into the sea. The bird was not worth sixpence, but I risked my life, risked my soul, to get it. Only the mercy of God brought me to shore... But He spared me, that He might save me.
Being held back from the pit is not the end of the story. Later in the chapter Elihu gives the ground on which God can do it.
"Then he is gracious to him, and says, Deliver him from going down to the pit: I have found a ransom." This is a vivid way of presenting what God was about to do in due time. It is not given here only as a picture and a promise. The language is plain — perhaps as clear as any words in the Old Testament, looking forward to that infinite work which we now know was finished at the cross of Christ.
- Kept back. God's action here is a hand on the shoulder. He holds a life away from the edge it was already moving toward.
- Kept back from pride. The real danger is not the sword but the self-esteem behind it. God works deeper than behaviour, hiding pride from the man before it destroys him.
- Kept back before the fault. The pain is not always payment for a fault. Verse 17 shows it can come first, to hide pride. Chapter 36 is where the discipline answers actual faults.
- Kept back by many means. A dream, a narrow escape, a sickbed — He is not limited in His methods of reaching a soul. And it is not only believing men; it is any man, so that he might believe.
- Kept back at a cost. The reason God can order a man's release from the pit comes a few verses later: a ransom has been found.
He is chastened also with pain upon his bed, and with constant strife in his bones;
Elihu answers Job with a claim the three friends never made. Suffering can be God's way of speaking, not only His way of punishing. The man he speaks to is flat on his back, worn down by constant pain in his bones. Will he listen?
The verse sits inside a sequence. Elihu has already named the problem: man is dull toward God. One summary maps the whole chapter as farming work:
Job 33:14. He states man's natural dullness and lack of feeling toward God. Job 33:15-22. He shows God using the plough — a dream, a striking providence, physical pain or sickness — to break up such hard, unworked ground. And this is still His work today. Job 33:23-24. The sower comes after the ploughman. The seed is the gospel. God provides a ransom and brings deliverance to the sinner.
(The writers quoted here use older English Bibles. Where the ESV says "rebuked with pain," they read "chastened with pain.")
The setting is part of the message. Illness takes away the activity that fills a person's day and crowds God out.
Another way God speaks is by inflicting "strong pain." It often comes in bed. There a man cannot occupy himself with the many things that keep him from listening to God (v. 19). Sickness and suffering have often driven people to the Lord.
The previous verses describe dreams and warnings. Here God's dealing becomes physical. That shift lands on the man Elihu is addressing.
"He is chastened also with pain on his bed." It is not only these dealings with the soul, but also with the body. There he touches the very case of Job.
Job's three friends had already read his suffering as evidence against him. Elihu's account of pain breaks with theirs at the root.
As we have admitted, there is a great measure of truth in what the friends have said. But it has been one-sided truth, distorted and spoiled by a wrong principle: that all suffering is for wickedness. That principle makes every affliction proof that the sufferer is simply a sinner found out.
God disciplines Job here, but not for something he has done. One writer sets this chastening beside a different kind later in the book.
Chastenings are not always for actual faults. In Job it is said (chap. 33:18-19), "He keeps back his soul from the pit, and his life from perishing by the sword. He is chastened also with pain on his bed, and all his bones with strong pain." Verse 17 shows that this is to hide pride from man. Then in chapter 36 the chastening is for positive faults (v. 9).
The same principle applies to believers. God can use sickness to bring hidden faults into the light.
He chastises them by sickness; and it is important to keep truth in the inner man. Men hide their faults; they want to walk as if all were going well; but God judges His people. He tries the heart and the mind. They are held in bonds of affliction. God shows them their faults, or their unbroken self-will. Man "is chastened also with pain on his bed, and all his bones with strong pain," Job 33:19.
The pain is not the end of the story. Elihu points past it to what God is after.
Elihu shows that God's purpose is Job's full deliverance. This is His purpose too when He permits all the buffeting and conflict the believer passes through. Yes, he comes to the last sinking point. Then: "If there is a messenger with him, an interpreter, one among a thousand, to show to man his uprightness, then He is gracious to him. He says, Deliver him from going down to the pit, I have found a ransom."
- Plough — pain on a bed is God breaking up hard, unworked ground in a man who did not notice His quieter voice.
- Bed — the place matters: illness takes away the activity a person uses to avoid listening.
- Body — God moves from dreams to bones, and touches Job's own case.
- Pride — the stated aim is to hide pride from man. So this chastening is not a verdict on past sins. Elihu breaks with the friends' rule that suffering always exposes a sinner.
- Ransom — the ploughing is for a sowing. God brings the sufferer low, then sends a messenger to announce a ransom.
And his life abhorreth bread, and his soul dainty food;
Elihu has been describing how God speaks to a man who will not listen: first in dreams at night, then through the body. Verse 20 shows how far that second voice goes: a sick man can no longer face even bread.
after_note: DELETE
One writer sets this verse beside Job's own earlier words, and finds that Elihu's picture fits the man listening to him:
But God has another way of speaking to men. If they do not listen to His word, He may send them His rod. In enlarging on this, Elihu practically describes the case of Job. Severe chastening pains come on him, and his bones seem to wither in deadly struggle... He is brought so low that he loathes even the food that would keep him alive. "The food I refused to touch has become my food of sorrow." "My soul is weary of my life."
The place matters too. On a bed a man runs out of ways to keep busy and avoid God:
God has another way of speaking: He sends "strong pain." It often comes in a man's bed, where he cannot keep himself busy with the many things that keep him from listening to God (v.19). Sickness and suffering have often driven people to the Lord. A man finds himself unable even to eat (v.20). Then he loses weight and becomes little more than "skin and bones." An early death stares him in the face.
The verse names two foods, not one. Here is how one translator renders verses 19-21:
He is also chastised with pains on his bed, and the strife of his bones is lasting. And his life loathes bread, and his soul the food it desires. His flesh wastes out of sight, and his bones that were not seen stand out.
The man turns from plain bread and from choice food alike. What kept him alive and what he enjoyed lose their worth together.
This is not God grinding a man down for no reason. The same writer reads God's dealing here as mercy at work on a will that has never been bent:
It is exactly what marks out divine mercy in appealing to the unconverted man. He is carried away by his own will. But God knows how to bend or break it. "He keeps back his soul from the pit" (such is the merciful object of God's intervention), "and his life from perishing by the sword."
One writer applies this in two directions at once — to the person who has never turned to God, and to the believer as well:
God may also speak through pain and sickness. Verses 19-22 describe it in vivid detail. He may keep speaking until the sufferer comes face to face with death itself... How often has a blow like this led a careless sinner to turn to God and awakened him for his eternal salvation. How often too has a believer had to look back to a time of severe sickness as an occasion of much spiritual blessing.
The starved body of verse 20 is not the last word. Two verses later the man is at the edge of the grave. There a messenger comes to him:
God uses these outward means of dealing with a man. He works by His word, and as a rule also by a messenger He sends — an interpreter, as we are told, one among a thousand. "Then He is gracious to him, and says, Deliver him from going down to the pit: I have found a ransom." That is a strikingly vivid way of presenting what God was about to do in due time... Here the language is plain — perhaps as clear as any words in the Old Testament. It looks forward to that infinite work which we now know to be finished in the cross of Christ.
- Voice. When the night-time word goes unheard, God speaks through pain — the rod after the word.
- Bed. Illness takes away the distractions a man uses to avoid listening. First appetite goes, then flesh, then life itself.
- Will. The aim is not ruin. God bends or breaks the self-will that is carrying the man toward the pit.
- Reach. The same dealing wakes a careless sinner, and brings a believer much spiritual blessing.
- Ransom. The wasting ends at a messenger and a word — "I have found a ransom" — which commentators read as pointing to the cross.
His flesh is consumed away from view, and his bones that were not seen stick out;
Elihu is describing a second way God speaks to a man: not by dreams at night, but by pain in the body. Here the picture reaches its worst point, and the question is whether such a collapse is God's anger or God's voice.
Elihu is not describing random bad luck. He is listing the methods God uses when His first appeal goes unheard. This verse belongs to the second method: the sickbed, where a man cannot distract himself.
Another way God speaks is by inflicting "strong pain." It often comes in one's bed, where a man cannot occupy himself with the many devices that keep him from listening to God (v.19). Sickness and suffering have often driven people to the Lord. One finds himself unable even to eat (v.20). Then he loses weight and becomes little more than "skin and bones." An early death stares him in the face (vv.21-22).
Every detail Elihu lists, Job had already said about himself in earlier chapters. Elihu is holding up a mirror, not inventing a case.
Sore chastening pains come upon him, and his bones seem to wither in the struggle for life. "The night racks my bones, and the pain that gnaws me takes no rest" (Job 30:17). He is brought so low that he hates even the food which would sustain his life... His flesh is wasted away, and his bones look and stare upon him. "My bones stick to my skin and to my flesh" (Job 19:20).
The first method touched the ear during sleep. This one reaches the flesh and bones. It can fall on a believing man too.
"He is chastened also with pain upon his bed." It is not only these dealings with the soul, but also with the body. There he touches the very case of Job... "His flesh is consumed away" — how true it was of poor Job... He is a fallen man. He may be a believing man. But still he is a man, as we can say, with the flesh in him. And that flesh may be working strongly, as it did in Job as well as the others.
(Where older translations read "his flesh is consumed away," the ESV says his flesh is "wasted away.")
Elihu lays out how God works and leaves Job to draw the line himself.
Elihu does not say in so many words that Job has refused to listen to God's warnings. He does not say he is describing Job's case exactly. He speaks of God's method of dealing with men. Has it no voice for Job? Can he not at least see that God is speaking in the affliction and that He has something to say?
The wasted body is not God's aim. Mercy is at work behind it.
It is exactly what characterizes divine mercy in appealing to the unconverted man. He is carried away by his own will. But God knows how to bend or break it. "He keeps back his soul from the pit" (such is the merciful object of God's intervention), "and his life from perishing by the sword." Here is more than a dream of the night or a passing vision. Here are corrective ways.
What Elihu described still happens. Writers point to it as an experience many have lived through, both before and after conversion.
God may speak through pain and sickness, described so vividly in verses 19-22, until the sufferer comes face to face with death itself... How often has a careless sinner, when struck this way, been led to turn to God and awakened for his eternal salvation. How often too has a saint had to look back to a time of severe sickness as an occasion of much spiritual blessing.
- Voice, not verdict. The wasted flesh is God speaking a second time, after the dream in the night went unheard.
- Bed, not battlefield. Pain pins a man where he cannot run to his usual distractions, so the message finally lands.
- Mirror, not charge. Elihu quotes Job's own symptoms back to him and asks only whether he can hear God in them.
- Body, not just soul. The stroke reaches the flesh, and it can fall on a believing man in whom the flesh is still working strongly.
- Mercy, not destruction. God's declared aim is to keep the soul back from the pit. That is why a sinner's sickbed has so often become the place of his salvation.
And his soul draweth near to the pit, and his life to the destroyers.
Elihu describes a man wasted by illness until nothing stands between him and the grave — and the question the whole passage turns on is whether anyone can reach him there. One commentator shows that almost every line of this description can be matched from Job's own earlier speeches.
If they do not listen to His word, He may send them His rod. As he expands on this, Elihu is in effect describing the case of Job. Painful chastening comes upon him, and his bones seem to wither in deadly struggle. "The night racks my bones, and the pain that gnaws me takes no rest" (Job 30:17). He is brought so low that he loathes even the food that would keep him alive... His flesh is wasted away, and his bones look and stare at him. "My bones stick to my skin and to my flesh" (Job 19:20). He is at the last of life, drawing near to the grave, or the more dreadful "pit of destruction." "I know that You will bring me to death, and to the house appointed for all living" (Job 30:23).
Elihu never says outright that this is Job. He leaves the man to recognise himself.
Elihu does not say in so many words that Job has refused to listen to God's warnings, nor does he say he is describing his case exactly. He speaks of God's method of dealing with men. Has it no voice for Job? Can he not at least see that God is speaking in the affliction, and that He has something to say?
The verses before this one list the ways God gets a hearing: a dream, a vision, then the sickbed.
And again, God may speak through pain and sickness. Verses 19-22 describe it vividly. God speaks until the sufferer comes face to face with death itself. How often has a careless sinner, when struck down like this, been led to turn to God and awakened for his eternal salvation. How often too has a believer had to look back to a time of severe sickness as an occasion of much spiritual blessing.
The wasting away is not God finishing a man off. Elihu had already named the purpose behind it, two verses earlier.
The man is carried away by his own will. But God knows how to bend or break it. "He keeps back his soul from the pit" — this is the merciful purpose of God's intervention — "and his life from perishing by the sword." Here is more than a dream of the night or a passing vision. Here are corrective ways, as well as glimpses of God's light, or of His judgment, which the man was despising.
The picture ends at a wall. What follows is a question.
One finds himself unable even to eat (v.20). Then he loses weight and becomes little more than "skin and bones," with an early death staring him in the face (vv.21-22). "His soul draws near the pit." Is there any help?
The next verse answers with a person: a messenger, an interpreter. Both words carry weight.
The word for "messenger" is "angel," and this suggests a supernatural revealer of the mind of God... Here we have a suggestion of the Mediator. The next word makes this stronger: "an Interpreter," or "Mediator" — one sent as an ambassador to make known the mind of God. No ordinary messenger will do; it must be "one of a thousand."
Job already had three men at his bedside. None of them could do this work.
There may be many who can sympathise and sometimes condemn the afflicted one, as Job's three friends did. To give the mind of God is another and a greater thing.
The messenger does not bring advice. He brings God's own word spoken over a dying man.
"Then He is gracious to him, and says, Deliver him from going down into the pit; I have found a ransom." This is a vivid way of presenting what God was about to do in due time... Here we have plain enough language — perhaps as clear as any words in the Old Testament, anticipating that infinite work which we now know to be finished in the cross of Christ.
The messenger's task is "to declare to man what is right for him." One writer explains what is right for a sinner in this position.
What the sinner needs to be shown is what uprightness means for him: bowing before God, and owning his true state without holding back or hiding anything. This would be genuine uprightness, and it would at once draw out the response from the heart of God.
- Voice — when dreams and warnings go unheeded, God speaks through sickness on the bed. The wasting body is a message, not only a misfortune.
- Edge — the illness carries the man to the brink of the pit. There the description stops and asks: is there any help?
- Purpose — God's aim is to keep the soul back from the pit. The rod corrects, and its object is mercy.
- Messenger — help comes through an interpreter, one among a thousand, who gives the mind of God, not sympathy or blame.
- Ransom — the answer at the brink is God's own word: "I have found a ransom." Commentators read it as pointing ahead to the work finished at the cross.
If there be a messenger with him, an interpreter, one among a thousand, to shew unto man his duty;
Elihu has described how God speaks to a man in dreams, and then through pain on a sickbed. Here he adds one more thing the sufferer needs: someone to tell him what God is doing. Two questions follow. Who is this rare messenger, and whose "uprightness" does he show?
One writer maps the chapter as farm work. Verse 23 marks the turn from ploughing to sowing.
Job 33:15-22. He shows God using the plough — a dream, a striking providence, bodily pain or sickness — to break up such unploughed ground. And such is the work to this day. Job 33:23-24. The sower comes after the ploughman. The seed is the Gospel. God provides the ransom, and deliverance comes to the sinner.
Each of the three words carries its own weight in the Hebrew.
The word for "messenger" is "angel," and this suggests a supernatural revealer of the mind of God. We find this often in the Old Testament, where the "angel" made known the will of God (see Judges 2:1; Judges 13:3). The "angel of Jehovah" is indeed His representative — so fully that Scripture calls Him Jehovah Himself ("The angel of His presence," Isaiah 63:9). Here we have a hint of the Mediator, and the next word makes it stronger: "an Interpreter," or "Mediator" (see Genesis 42:23; 2 Chronicles 32:21) — one whom God sends as an ambassador to make His mind known. An ordinary messenger will not do; it must be "one of a thousand."
"One among a thousand" is a measure of scarcity, and a crisis is where the shortage shows.
Times of emergency are the opportunity for the one Elihu called a "messenger," an "interpreter." He can show what God has to say in these things. Such people are not common, as we know, but they are of great value, and Elihu called them "one among a thousand," which shows how rare they are. Many can pity the afflicted one, and sometimes condemn him, as Job's three friends did. To give the mind of God is another and a greater thing.
Many read the messenger as pointing beyond Elihu altogether.
Yes, there is help, but only in God, who knows how to send a messenger at the right time, a messenger who is also a mediator, "one among a thousand" (v.23). Such an individual is typical of the Lord Jesus, the "one mediator between God and men" (1 Tim. 2:5).
Commentators differ on how far to press this. One holds that Elihu is the answer to Job's longing for a go-between, and not Christ arriving early.
He had asked for someone with feelings like his own, when he was crushed in spirit under the hand of God. He longed for a man who would step in between God and himself. And God now gives him what he wanted (not yet the man Christ Jesus), a man of God indeed, but with weaknesses like his own.
The last clause is the disputed one. One writer takes it as what is upright for the man — the sense in the ESV phrase "what is right for him."
We fully grant that the Hebrew word can sometimes be translated "duty," but that hardly fits man's sinful state and condition before God. No doubt his state calls for self-judgment; but you could not press this on him as a duty... The sinner needs someone to show him what, for him, is uprightness: bowing before God, and owning his true state, holding nothing back and hiding nothing.
Another reads the pronoun as pointing to God, not the sufferer.
This interpreter is to show man his uprightness. But whose uprightness, or righteousness, does this mean?... Most commentators explain that the interpreter tells the sufferer how to do right before God, and critics even suggest changing the word "uprightness" to "fault." There is a deeper meaning here. The word "his" should carry a capital "H" — not man's righteousness, but God's.
Whichever reading you take, the outcome is the same. The soul comes to an upright position, and God's love meets it there.
The moment the conscience bows under the sin and confesses it, it comes into an upright position. Where evil has been, uprightness of soul shows itself in the awareness of that evil, and in the power to confess it... Get sin judged in the conscience, and then comes the revelation of the unfailing love of God to meet the need.
- Plough, then sow. Dreams, providence and sickness break up the ground. The messenger of verse 23 comes after, bringing God's meaning to the broken man.
- Messenger. The word is "angel" — one who reveals the mind of God. "Interpreter" carries the sense of mediator, an ambassador who makes that mind known.
- One of a thousand. Sympathy and condemnation are common; giving the mind of God is rare, and that rarity is the point of the phrase.
- Mediator. Many see a picture of the one Mediator between God and men. Others hold that Elihu is simply the man Job longed for.
- Uprightness. Read it as the sinner's honest owning of his true state, or as God's righteousness shown to him. Either way, the bowed conscience is where God's love meets the need.
Then he will be gracious unto him, and say, Deliver him from going down to the pit I have found a ransom.
Elihu has been listening while Job and his three friends argue. Now he answers them. In two lines he sets out the whole shape of rescue: a man on the road to the pit, a messenger who makes God's mind plain, and a ransom God Himself has found.
The verse leans on the messenger named just before it. One writer asks what that messenger is for, and what the two words describing him mean:
If a man is to profit from God's chastening, he must understand its purpose, and for that he needs someone who can explain it. The word for "messenger" is "angel," and this points to a heavenly messenger who reveals the mind of God. Often in the Old Testament the "angel" made known the will of God (see Judges 2:1; 13:3). The "angel of Jehovah" is His representative — so fully that Scripture calls Him Jehovah Himself ("The angel of His presence," Isa. 63:9). So here we have a hint of the Mediator, and the next word strengthens it: "an Interpreter," or "Mediator" (see Gen. 42:23; 2 Chron. 32:21) — one whom God sends as an ambassador to make His mind known. And an ordinary messenger will not do; it must be "one of a thousand."
"Ransom" — one writer explains the Hebrew word behind it and how God dealt with sin before the cross:
The word translated "ransom" here means a "covering," close to the word translated "atonement" in the Old Testament. Before Christ came, God covered the sin of the repentant sinner from His own holy eye. He was waiting for the time when the sacrifice of Christ, enough for everything, would make full propitiation. So Romans speaks of God passing over "former sins" in "his divine forbearance" (Rom. 3:25). Those past sins were the sins of believers who lived before Christ — Job's among them.
Notice who says "I have found." Job's friends could offer him no ransom. Elihu's confidence rested elsewhere:
The means of such grace is wonderful: "Deliver him from going down into the pit; I have found a ransom" (v.24). Elihu could not have understood the full weight of his own words. We know the ransom is the Lord Jesus Himself, in His perfect sacrifice for sinners at the cross. Job's friends could not think of suggesting a ransom for Job. But Elihu's heart overflowed with the conviction that there must be such a ransom, since he knew the character of His Creator. The Spirit of God put such words into his mouth. It was not any man who had found the ransom, but God.
One writer presses that respectable people travel the same road as the openly wicked:
Look at that drunkard! He is "going down into the pit." … Look at the man who only claims to believe — respectable and respected, honest and honourable, the most religious and most self-righteous church or chapel member, whether a robed priest or an ordinary member of the congregation! He too is "going down into the pit." The word of God says that everyone is travelling that road, whatever their outward, moral, or religious state, unless they have personally taken for themselves the ransom that God found and God gave.
One writer weighs how plain these words are next to the rest of the Old Testament:
"He is merciful to him, and says, 'Deliver him from going down into the pit; I have found a ransom'" — a strikingly vivid way of setting out what God was about to do in due time, and not merely a promise given here in picture form. The language here is plain enough. These are perhaps as clear as any words in the Old Testament, looking ahead to that infinite work which we now know was finished at the cross of Christ.
Another writer links the word "found" to Hebrews 9:12, where older translations read "obtained":
In Elihu's words we find a beautiful expression of the good news of God — "I have found a ransom"; or, in the language of the New Testament, "having obtained (Greek: found) eternal redemption" (Heb. 9:12).
Deliverance from the pit is only the start of what the following verses describe:
Now we see the blessed results of this work of the Interpreter in the ransomed man. He can now pray with confidence and rejoice in God's favour, seeing His face with joy. He has found a righteousness — not of his own goodness but of Another — "the righteousness which is of God by faith."
- The road — everyone is travelling to the pit. The moral and religious go the same way as the openly sinful, unless God's ransom delivers them.
- The messenger — "messenger" is the word for angel, and "interpreter" means mediator. No ordinary helper will do. It must be "one of a thousand," a picture of the true Mediator.
- The ransom — the Hebrew word means a covering, close to the word for atonement. God covered the repentant sinner's sin until Christ's sacrifice made full propitiation at the cross.
- The finder — no man found this price. God did, and Elihu spoke better than he knew, since the ransom is Christ Himself.
- The result — the ransomed man prays with confidence and sees God's face with joy. He stands in a righteousness that is not his own but Another's.
His flesh shall be fresher than in childhood; he shall return to the days of his youth.
Elihu has just told Job that God has found a ransom for the dying man, and this verse says what comes next. Writers read it as a picture of what God does with a soul He spares, though they differ over how much Elihu himself could see. (They quote an older translation of this verse and the ones near it: "His flesh shall be fresher than a child's: he shall return to the days of his youth.")
after-note: reason follows
One writer reads Elihu's whole speech as a farming picture. God ploughs hard ground before any seed goes in.
Job 33:15-22. He shows God using the plough — a dream, a striking providence, bodily pain or sickness — to break up that hard ground. And such is the work to this day… Job 33:23-24. The sower comes after the ploughman. The seed is the Gospel. God provides the ransom; He brings deliverance to the sinner. Job 33:25-26. The condition of the believer… Job 33:29-30. Elihu tells Job these are samples of God's way in saving souls.
God dealt with something hidden inside Job before He restored him.
He was a godly man; there was no one like him. Yet God saw a defect in him… Here God does not deal first with outward sin, but with the inward working of a man's ignorance of himself, and then with its breaking out, through God's dealings, into actual sin. So when Job was brought into God's presence, the thing was found out and came into his conscience. When God reveals His presence, the effect is first submission, then confession. "I have uttered what I did not understand… I despise myself, and repent in dust and ashes." And God restores him to full blessing… Job was not upright in the full, true sense until he despised himself and said so — that is, until he confessed. Then his flesh became fresher than a child's again.
The word "child" sends one writer to the story of Naaman. He was an army commander, healed of leprosy when he washed in the Jordan as the prophet told him.
So a freshness better than that of youth is given — as Naaman gives us an example. "His flesh was restored like the flesh of a little child, and he was clean" (2 Kings 5:14). It is a new birth, by the incorruptible seed of the word of God.
Job kept looking back and wishing for his old days. One writer says this new freshness is not a return to that old life.
What freshness of soul this gives! "His flesh shall be fresher than a child's; he shall return to the days of his youth." It is no longer, "Oh that I was as in months past." The old "I" is done with. It is no longer I, but Christ in me; no more wretched striving to justify the old me. Ah, no! but my soul filled with freshness in contemplating God's ransom, and God's perfection in justifying me by that ransom.
One writer warns against loading the verse with truth that belongs to a later day, while still finding real repentance in the passage.
We have here nothing at all about the two natures. The Old Testament saint never understood that. Man cannot profit by that truth, or understand it, until he sees Christ by faith — sees the Son and believes in Him. Now we are made to understand it simply and fully… "He looks upon men, and if any say, I have sinned, and perverted what was right, and it profited me not" — there you see is just what the repentant soul says. It is not called "repentance" here… but here we have the thing, repentance, although the word is not used. It is very comforting to think that this was what God was doing in those days, and was known to be doing — because the gospel was not preached then.
Job had asked for someone to stand between him and God. One writer sees Elihu taking that role, and looking past his own day for the full answer.
Elihu seems to call himself the interpreter Job asked for. He says that a go-between, an interpreter, would bring the solution Job was looking for… Elihu says that the only complete answer to this will come when the full results of the interpreter's coming have reached us.
- Plough — Dreams, sudden events and pain are God's plough, breaking up hard ground. This verse comes at the harvest end of that work, not the wounding end.
- Ransom — The new freshness rests on the word just spoken over the dying man: God has found a ransom.
- Confession — Restoration comes after submission and confession, not self-defence. Job got his youth back only after he despised himself and said so.
- Child — Flesh like a child's is the language of new birth. Naaman's cleansed skin shows it: a freshness better than the youth that was lost.
- Not yet — The verse is real for the believer now. Its full result still waits on all that the promised interpreter came to do.
He shall pray unto +God, and he will receive him with favour; and he shall see his face with shoutings, and he will render unto man his righteousness.
Elihu has been describing how God brings a man back to Himself. Here he shows what that recovery looks like: prayer, God's welcome, and joy. Two questions follow. Whose righteousness does God restore? And how does a man reach this place at all?
The verse describes a man God has ransomed. One writer sees here the result of that work: a voice restored in prayer, and a righteousness that came from someone else.
Now we see the blessed results of this work of the Interpreter in the ransomed man. He can now pray with confidence, rejoice in God's favour, and see His face with joy. He has found a righteousness — not from his own goodness but from Another — "the righteousness from God that depends on faith." No doubt this includes God recognising faithfulness in a child of God, as in Job's case. But the principle carries us much further.
The last clause raises a question. Older translations read it as "He will render to man His righteousness." One writer hears there a righteousness God gives, and points to what had to happen first before God could give it.
Elihu speaks of God showing man what was righteous. That came to light in the path our Lord walked. But he adds, "He will render to man His righteousness." That could only be as a result of the work upon the cross (Job 33:23-26).
Commentators differ here. Another writer applies the same word to Job himself, and to the change of attitude Job still had to make.
He would never surrender his integrity. He would never let go his righteousness. But, as Elihu puts it, his "righteousness," or his "uprightness" (see Job 33:23, 26) would now mean something different. It would mean bowing under God's hand. It would mean trusting the searching work of His discipline, and learning the lesson God would teach. In short, it would mean looking away from himself to God, and living on that new principle before Him — centred in God and no longer in self.
Prayer here is the overflow of new life. One commentator links the verse to what God said about Saul of Tarsus.
The freshness of that new life will overflow in thankful prayer to God. Take Saul of Tarsus. God's grace woke him and saved him, and he had the distinction of having God say of him, "Behold, he is praying" (Acts 9:11). That is the result of being born again: "then man prays to God, and He accepts him" (v.26). More than that, "he sees His face with a shout of joy" — a wonderful honour given to every believer, because God has rendered to him His righteousness (v.26). We throw away our own righteousness as filthy rags, and the believer's confidence is now in God's righteousness.
Verse 26 is the end of a sequence, not the start of one. Something comes first: a conscience that agrees with God about the sin.
He takes notice of every departure from Him. But the door is always open for "repentance." When a man judges his sin, and sees it in the light in which God sees it, nothing stands in the way of immediate restoration. The moment the conscience bows under the sin and confesses it, it comes into an upright position... So the church of God, or an individual soul, must come into this state of uprightness before God, so that He can restore it; Job 33:23-26. Judge sin in the conscience, and then God reveals His unfailing love to meet the need.
The same order holds today. One writer shows how simple the way back is.
The way to be cleared is so simple. Why should anyone walk with a burdened conscience? Make an upright and honest confession, and we are not only forgiven but cleansed. Elihu says the same of the soul that has come to judge itself: "then man prays to God, and He accepts him; he sees His face with a shout of joy."
- Sin judged. God notices every departure from Him, but the door stays open. When the conscience bows and owns the sin, restoration comes at once.
- Righteousness given. The righteousness here is not the man's own goodness but Another's. Only the work of the cross could secure it.
- Prayer returns. The ransomed man prays with confidence; new life shows itself first in prayer, as it did with Saul of Tarsus.
- Joy restored. He sees God's face with joy. That honour belongs to every believer, because God's righteousness, not ours, is now our confidence.
- Two readings. Commentators differ on "his righteousness." Some take it as God's righteousness given to man. Others take it as the uprightness of a man who stops defending himself and bows under God's hand.
He will sing before men, and say, I have sinned, and perverted what was right, and it hath not been requited to me;
Elihu describes a broken man's first honest words. Everything turns on whether he owns the truth about himself, and commentators call that the turn toward deliverance.
Admitting "I sinned" looks like weakness. One writer treats it as the opposite:
"I have sinned" — this is uprightness. A sinner's uprightness consists in owning his condition. God says he is a sinner, and his uprightness is to own it. This is the way God is going to save souls at this time. The truth must be out, and owned, as to what you are. God will not, as it were, electroplate you over and make you look like silver when you are nothing but dross. The very first step in the conversion of a soul is owning his sins before God. Not to your fellow man, not to a priest, but to God. Sin confessed is sin forgiven.
The man admits three things: sin, a twisting of what was right, and a loss. One writer ties the "perverting" to Job's own wrong view of God. He also takes the last clause to mean that the sin was never paid back to the man:
"I had sinned and perverted what was right." Job will soon admit his sin. He had perverted, that is, misunderstood, the righteous character of God. In the same way the sinner can look back to the time when he was "a blasphemer and injurious." But God has not repaid that iniquity to the one who was once guilty. "It was not recompensed to me" — for so should the last clause of verse 27 read.
Commentators differ over the opening line. One keeps the older reading, "He looks upon men," and hears in it a man who knows God is watching him:
The wording of verse 27 may be a little uncertain. But the original King James Version seems the most likely to be correct... A real work in the heart of men must begin with God. The person is moved when he realises that God is watching him. He confesses his own sin and perversion, and admits that he has gained nothing by it. So there is joy in the presence of the angels of God over one sinner who repents.
Older translations word the verse as a condition: "if any say, I have sinned." One writer points out what that condition does not ask for:
Mark those words, "If any say, I have sinned." Is this the language of your heart now? Can you cast yourself at the feet of Christ a confessed sinner? You may take that place without any fear of being a hypocrite. In owning what you are, as a sinner, before God, there is no fear of deceiving yourself, much less of deceiving God... It is not, If any have served me, or If any have not sinned. It is, If any have sinned.
Why can God answer such words? Earlier in the chapter He says He has found a ransom. One writer looks at what that word means:
The word translated "ransom" here simply means a "covering," related to the word translated "atonement" in the Old Testament. Before Christ came, God covered the sin of the repentant sinner before His holy eye. He waited for the time when Christ's all-sufficient sacrifice would make full propitiation. This is why Scripture speaks of the passing over of sins done beforehand, through the forbearance of God (Romans 3:25). Those past sins were the sins of believers who lived before Christ — Job's among them.
That ransom was not the sinner's discovery, which is why past failure cannot cancel it:
It is not you who found the ransom; God found it. Satan may tell Him of all your sins. He may point above all to your deep ingratitude and failure since you were a child of God. God's reply is, "I have found a ransom."
The verse is not only for a first conversion. It sets a pattern for how a believer handles his own failures:
Take sides fully with your true Master against the sin which is both His enemy and yours. This means you must not excuse yourself in the least degree for giving way to sin, nor blame it on anything or anyone else, but blame yourself fully for it. Let it be stressed that this is a vitally important matter, for far too many defeat themselves by not honestly taking the full blame for their failures.
- Owned — a sinner's uprightness is to agree with God about himself. God will not plate over dross to make it look like silver.
- Worded — the confession names the sin, the twisting of what was right, and the loss. Writers differ over the last clause: "it profited me not" or "it was not repaid to me."
- Unqualified — the condition is not "if any have served me" but "if any say, I have sinned," so no one can be too guilty to use it.
- Ransomed — God can answer such words because He Himself found the covering. It pointed on to the sacrifice of Christ.
- Sung — the forgiven man does not stay silent. He has a new song, and many will hear it and turn to the Lord.
He hath delivered my soul from going into the pit, and my life shall see the light.
Elihu has been describing how God turns a man back from destruction. Here the rescued man speaks for himself. He names three things: his soul redeemed, the pit escaped, and a life that now looks on light. What is that pit, and on what ground does God lift a man out of it?
The word translated "pit" comes from the world of hunting:
shachath, "a pit, a pitfall to entrap animals," place of doom and corruption. Job 33:18, 24, 28, 30
One writer finds two pits here: one a man falls into now, one waiting beyond death:
In these remarkable words Elihu was certainly acting as the interpreter with Job. He showed the good purpose of God in His dealings, which seem so much against men. God aims to deliver them from the "pit" of self-esteem and self-satisfaction in this life, and from the "pit" of judgment and condemnation in the life to come.
The rescue follows a confession. One writer explains why God counts that confession as the sinner's uprightness:
"I have sinned:" this is uprightness. A sinner's uprightness consists in owning his condition. God says he is a sinner, and his uprightness is to own it. This is the way God is going to save souls at this time. The truth must be out, and owned, as to what you are. God will not, so to speak, electroplate you over and make you look like silver, when you are nothing but dross.
God answers that confession at once. His answer rests on something He has already found:
A real work in the heart of men must begin with God. The individual is moved when he realises that God is watching him. He confesses his own sin and perversion, and admits that he has gained nothing by it. So there is joy in the presence of the angels of God over one sinner who repents. There is an immediate answer from God, "He will deliver his soul from going into the Pit, and his life shall see the light" (v.28). This is certainly because of the ransom that God has found. In fact it is the ransom that God has provided — the sacrifice of His own beloved Son.
Another writer links the ransom Elihu speaks of with a phrase from Hebrews:
In Elihu's words we find a beautiful expression of the gospel of God: "Then He is gracious to him, and says, Deliver him from going down to the pit: I have found a ransom." The New Testament says the same thing in its own language — "having obtained (Greek, found) eternal redemption" (Heb. 9:12).
What is the light the verse promises? One writer ties it to what a person can know today:
Then comes the precious word: "He will deliver his soul from going down into the pit; and his life shall see the light." That means the knowledge of a present and full salvation. If you are looking only to Christ, and resting only on Christ, this is what His death has secured for you: you should know the forgiveness of your sins.
Older versions read "his soul" here, but in this wording the man speaks for himself — "my soul," "my life." One writer says he now sings his own story to others:
Now he can speak to God in prayer and look on His face with joy. In the same way, the ransomed soul can speak to other people. "He looks upon men" should rather read, "He sings to men." It is part of the new song he has learned, and many will hear it and be turned to the Lord… But this sin has not been repaid to the once guilty man.
One writer carries that song into heaven:
Not one person in heaven will sing, "I have never sinned, so I got here by myself." The song up there tells of our hopeless ruin — and of the grace of God.
- Pit — the word means a trap dug to catch animals, and a place of doom. Writers apply it to self-satisfaction now and to judgment later.
- Confession — "I have sinned" is the sinner's only uprightness. God will not plate over dross to make it look like silver.
- Ransom — God's answer is immediate. Its ground lies outside the man: a ransom God found, which Hebrews 9:12 calls "eternal redemption."
- Light — the rescue is more than escape from the pit. It is a salvation known now, with sins forgiven.
- Song — the rescued man then sings to others about his ruin and God's grace. No one in heaven sings of arriving sinless.
Lo, all these [things] worketh God twice, thrice, with man,
Elihu has just described how God speaks to a man — in dreams, in pain on a sick bed, through a messenger who announces a ransom. Now he gathers it all into one sentence: God does this again and again, and the verse asks why He should need to, and what He is aiming at.
Verse 29 closes Elihu's argument. One outline of the chapter follows the whole movement — ploughing, then sowing, then rescue — and treats these verses as his summing up:
Job 33:15-22. He shows God using the plough — of a dream, of a striking providence, of bodily pain or sickness — to break up that hard, unbroken ground. And that is still the work today. Job 33:23-24. The sower comes after the ploughman. The seed is the Gospel. God provides the ransom, and deliverance comes to the sinner… Job 33:29-30. Elihu tells Job these are samples of God's way in saving souls.
God repeats Himself, and the reason lies in us:
Nor does God speak only once to a man, but "twice, in fact three times," for we are poor listeners, and God is concerned deeply that souls should be brought back from the Pit — delivered from the negative horror of being without God, and instead given the positive blessing of being "enlightened with the light of life."
One translation keeps the plain numbers and renders "pit" as corruption:
Look! God does all this twice, three times, with man, to bring back his soul from corruption, that he may be enlightened with the light of life.
The picture behind the word is a trap dug in the ground:
shachath, "a pit, a pitfall to entrap animals," place of doom and corruption. Job 33:18, 24, 28, 30.
God's love and His government of us work together. His hand can feel like the collapse of everything we wanted:
We are the objects of His deep, tender, and unchanging love; but we are also the subjects of His wise moral government. His dealings with us are varied. They are sometimes preventive; sometimes corrective; always instructive. We may be set on some course of our own that would end in moral ruin. He steps in and turns us back from it. He smashes our castles in the air, scatters our golden dreams, and breaks into many a favourite plan we had set our hearts on — a plan that would have destroyed us. "Behold, God does all these things, twice, three times, with a man, to bring back his soul from the pit, to be enlightened with the light of the living."
(Mackintosh quotes an older translation, which reads "oftentimes" where the ESV has "twice, three times.")
Elihu paints a picture of God's ways rather than teaching a doctrine about them:
This is not a doctrine of how grace wakes sinners from the sleep of death. It is a lifelike sketch of His detailed ways. He uses sickness and sorrow, and dreams or visions. Above all, He uses people who come with the light of God to deal with a man's conscience. All this comes out vividly, and so does the effect it produces — "to bring back his soul from the pit, to be enlightened with the light of the living." It speaks to the point so powerfully that we know how often preachers still make it a favourite theme when they bring the gospel to those who are not converted.
The way God meets human need has never changed:
Elihu said this before God gave the law through Moses, yet even then he assures Job that God worked these things often with man. Therefore the gospel of God's grace has always been the way God meets man's need. The simplicity of this is beautiful, and Job could have no objection to it.
- He speaks. God addresses man — by dream, by providence, by pain, by a messenger who brings the light of God.
- We miss it. He speaks twice, three times, because we are poor listeners.
- He aims. His dealings stop us, correct us, and always teach us — often by breaking the plans we had set our hearts on.
- He rescues. The goal comes twice over: back from the pit — a trap of doom and corruption — and into the light of life.
- He always has. Elihu spoke before the law, yet preachers still use his sketch of God's way with a soul today.
To bring back his soul from the pit, that he may be enlightened with the light of the living.
Elihu has just listed God's methods with Job: a dream in the night, pain on a sick bed, a messenger who explains. This verse gives the point of them all. God aims at two things — to bring a soul back from the pit, and to set it in the light.
One writer notes how lifelike this account is, and how long preachers have leaned on it.
This is not a doctrine of how grace wakes sinners from the sleep of death. It is a sketch drawn from life of His detailed ways. He uses sickness and sorrow, and dreams or visions. Above all, He uses those who come with the light of God to deal with the conscience of man. All this stands out vividly, and so does the effect it produces: "To bring back his soul from the pit, to be enlightened with the light of the living." It speaks to the point so forcibly that preachers of the gospel still make it a favourite theme today. Elihu's words are not the fullest material or the deepest ground to preach from. Still, it is striking how much living power clings to this earliest record of God's way with a waking sinner, written hundreds — indeed two thousand — years before the gospel of God's grace went out.
The word behind "pit" is not a vague picture of trouble.
shachath, 'a pit, a pitfall to entrap animals,' place of doom and corruption. Job 33:18, 24, 28, 30; Ps. 9:15; Ps. 30:9; Ps. 35:7; Ezek. 28:8; etc.
The verse names what a soul is taken out of, and what it is brought into. The verse before it says God speaks twice, three times. This outcome is why He keeps speaking.
God does not speak only once to a man, but "twice, in fact three times," because we listen so poorly. God cares deeply that souls be brought back from the Pit. There is the negative side: He delivers them from the horror of being without God. There is the positive side: He gives them the blessing of being enlightened with the light of life.
In Job the phrase means life in this world — to see daylight at all. The New Testament takes the same words and fills them with a Person. (Some translations read "the light of the living" here.)
The comparison of the light of life in the Old Testament and the New has something remarkable in it. In the Old it means coming into the outward light of this world, as if born into it… But for the New, "In Him was life, and the life was the light of men," and then, "Whoever follows Me will not walk in darkness, but will have the light of life." This is not the light of nature — life in this world. In the Old sense, "seeing the light" means being born: having light in this world, having life in it. Now the Light of life is having Christ, and seeing by the power of that life which is in Him. He is at the same time the Light itself.
One writer applies the verse straight to the reader: take the place of a sinner before God.
You may take that place without any fear of being a hypocrite. In owning what you are, as a sinner, before God, there is no fear of deceiving yourself, much less of deceiving God. If this is your confessed state, God will deliver your soul from going into the pit. You will be enlightened with the light of the living. Do not rest until you know this for certain: "God has justified you freely through the redemption that is in Christ Jesus."
These ways are not a new policy. They are God's settled way, and one writer hears in Elihu's words an early witness to the gospel itself.
These are God's frequent ways: dreams, painful discipline, and messengers. By them He wakes a man to a right sense of himself before God. By them He rescues him from corruption, so that he may be enlightened with the light of life… The everlasting gospel had its witness in Elihu, as surely as Noah preached righteousness to the ungodly before the flood.
- Cause — Dreams, sickness, a messenger who explains — none of it is aimless. This verse names the goal God had in all of it.
- Pit — The word pictures a trap set for animals, a place of doom and corruption: the thing a soul must be brought back from.
- Twice, three times — God repeats His appeal. We listen poorly, and He cares that souls come out of the horror of being without Him.
- Light — In Job the phrase means life in this world. In the New Testament the light of life is Christ Himself, seen by the life that is in Him.
- Confession — Own what you are before God. That is not hypocrisy, and it opens the way to justification given freely in Christ Jesus.
Mark well, Job, hearken unto me; be silent, and I will speak.
Job has spent long speeches justifying himself, and his friends have failed to reach him. Now Elihu asks for attention and silence: will Job stop defending himself long enough to hear?
This is not where Elihu began. He calls for attention only after he has brought God in as the One who shows grace.
After this glowing utterance in which Elihu brings in God in His grace, he turns to Job. "Do you have anything to say? Then answer me." But Elihu waits in vain. Job's lips are sealed.
Asking a man to be quiet can be a way of silencing him. Elihu's aim is the opposite.
Elihu addresses himself directly to Job, for it was Job who needed an answer for his predicament. Elihu wanted time to say all that was on his mind, yet he did not demand that he should do all the speaking. Rather, he invites Job to speak out plainly if he has anything to say. Elihu was not putting Job down, as his friends did. He wanted Job to be justified. He did not mean that Job should justify himself, for this was already Job's tragic mistake. No doubt he wanted Job to be justified from God's viewpoint, just as the tax collector was justified rather than the Pharisee, when he prayed, "God, be merciful to me, a sinner!"
Elihu's anger had one target, and it was not Job himself.
Elihu was for Job; but he was not for his self-righteousness. Against this he was angry. When the blessed Jesus walked this earth, nothing made Him so angry as the self-righteousness of the Pharisees. At this He was filled with indignation. You may have been deeply grieved that you could not be self-righteous, so as to justify yourself. The very attempt has grieved Him more.
Job's friends had talked at him for chapters without reaching him. Elihu asks for silence because Job still did not know himself.
He brings the light of "truth" to bear upon Job's conscience. At the same time he applies the precious balm of "grace" to his heart… Truth puts everyone in his right place. And just because it does so, it cannot hand out flattering titles to a poor guilty mortal, however much that mortal might enjoy them. Man must be brought to know himself, to see his true condition, to confess what he really is. This was precisely what Job needed. He did not know himself, and his friends could not give him that knowledge. He needed to be led down into the depths; but his friends could not take him there. He needed self-judgment; but his friends were completely unable to produce it.
Elihu stops and leaves Job room to answer. Job says nothing — and what does that silence mean?
And now, Job, what have you to say to all this? Elihu wants to bring out Job's true condition — he would not excuse his wrong, but treat him with complete fairness. He pauses for a reply: Job is not to be forced, but does he not agree with what has been said? May we not read his silence as an acknowledgment of the truth of what we have been dwelling on?
Commentators differ over Elihu. Some have judged him harshly; others weigh his speech far higher.
Those who carry far more weight in godliness and discernment see him differently. In him they find a fairer and fuller assessment of Job and his friends. They also find the first real insight, shown throughout the book, into the place and aim of discipline through suffering.
Elihu asked for silence and got it. Job's quiet was a choice, not a defeat.
Job then had nothing to say. No doubt he recognised that Elihu's message was higher than he had considered, and he wisely chose to listen.
- Grace first. Elihu calls for attention only after he has spoken of God's grace. He points Job to good news, not a scolding.
- Listen, then speak. Elihu wants the floor but does not seize it; he invites Job to answer if he has anything to say.
- Justified, not self-justified. Elihu wants God to justify Job. That is the opposite of Job justifying himself.
- Silence makes room. Job needed self-judgment. No friend's argument could produce it, so the talking had to stop and let truth reach his conscience.
- He listened. Job had nothing to say. He judged Elihu's message higher than he had thought, and chose to hear it.
If thou hast anything to say, answer me; speak, for I desire to justify thee.
Elihu has been speaking to Job at length, and now he stops and hands him the floor. His reason is what matters: he wants Job justified — not Job defending himself, but God putting him right.
Elihu wants to be heard, yet he leaves Job room to answer. His reason sets him apart from Job's three friends.
Elihu desired time to say all that was on his mind, yet he did not demand that he should do all the speaking. Rather, he invites Job to speak out plainly if he has anything to say (v.32). Elihu was not putting Job down, as his friends did. He wanted Job justified. He did not mean that Job should justify himself, for this was already Job's tragic mistake. No doubt he wanted Job justified from God's viewpoint, just as the tax collector was justified and the Pharisee was not, when he prayed, "God, be merciful to me, a sinner!" (Luke 18:13-14).
Job had spent chapters defending his own record. One writer shows what had to go before God would justify him.
Job was as busy as he could be, justifying himself. He goes so far as to say, "My righteousness I hold fast, and will not let it go" (Job 27:6). He never made it out, though. At the end of the story he has to put his hand on his mouth and say, "Behold, I am of small account" (Job 40:4). The Lord seems to say, "I will never let you go, Job, till you have given up those filthy rags, your own righteousness. Then I will justify you. I will give you My righteousness." … Only the presence of God can enable anyone to let go of their own righteousness. Not that they have any to let go, really — they only think they have.
The word "desire" carries the weight of the verse. Elihu does not help Job reluctantly — he wants this outcome. One writer hears God's own heart in it.
God's very object, His desire, His purpose in sending His beloved Son into this world was to justify ungodly sinners. Let the anxious, awakened sinner know this — in coming to Him, He is most ready, and He desires to justify you. The moment you believe on Him who raised up Jesus from the dead for our justification, that moment you are justified from all things. See Acts 13:38; Romans 4:24 to 5:1.
If God desires to justify, why is He on the judgment seat at all? One writer puts the question back on us.
The common thought is that God is our Judge, and so He is; but who made Him a Judge? Who put God on the judgment seat? You did! I did! The sin and guilt of man have forced God into the place of judgment. God must judge sin. Otherwise God and man would be alike, neither of them thinking much about it, and there would be no righteousness. Yet He has no desire to take the place of judgment. Even here, to Job, He says, "I desire to justify you" (Job 33:32).
Earlier Job had cried out for someone to stand between himself and God. One writer shows Elihu stepping into exactly that place.
He reminds Job of his own desire for such a person. Job had said, "There is no arbiter between us, who might lay his hand on us both" (Job 9:33), and, "that he would argue the case of a man with God, as a son of man does with his neighbour" (Job 16:21). To this desire Elihu now replies: "Behold, I am toward God as you are; I too was pinched off from a piece of clay. Behold, no fear of me need terrify you; my pressure will not be heavy upon you" (Job 33:6-7).
Older translations render Job 33:6, "I am according to your wish, in God's stead" — the writer's point is that Elihu stands in God's place toward Job.
Job takes the open invitation and says nothing. The next verse offers him the other road to wisdom.
Elihu had asked Job to speak if he had anything to say. He rightly adds, "if not, listen to me; be silent, and I will teach you wisdom" (v.33). Job then had nothing to say. No doubt he recognised that Elihu's message was higher than he had considered. He wisely chose to listen.
One writer weighs what that silence means.
Elihu is truly answering Job's desire for an arbiter. Job's silence may well be a sign of beginning conviction.
- Desire. The verse turns on one word. Elihu wants Job justified, and one writer hears in it God's purpose in sending His Son to justify ungodly sinners.
- Not self-made. The justifying Elihu wants is not Job's self-defence — that was Job's mistake. It is God putting him right.
- Release. God gives His righteousness only after the filthy rags go. Only His presence makes a man loosen his grip on his own.
- Mediator. The offer comes through a man who does not terrify Job. That was Job's own cry — for someone to stand between him and God.
- Silence. Job is free to answer and has nothing to say. That silence is the first sign of conviction, and the doorway to the wisdom promised next.
If not, hearken thou unto me; be silent, and I will teach thee wisdom.
Elihu has just described how God works again and again to turn a man back from the pit. Now he turns to Job with two questions: has he anything to say, and if not, will he be still and learn wisdom?
The verse closes Elihu's address and repeats the invitation he made at the start. One outline traces the chapter from God's ways of saving souls to this last pause:
Job 33:29-30. Elihu tells Job that these are samples of God's way in saving souls. Job 33:31-33. He asks Job at the last, as at the first, whether he had anything to say.
The verse begins with "if not," so the door is still open for Job to speak. Elihu waits for an answer, and reads Job's silence as agreement rather than defeat.
And now, Job, what have you to say to all this? Elihu wants to bring out Job's true condition. He would not justify his wrong, but would treat him with complete fairness. He pauses for a reply. He will not force Job, but does Job not agree with what he has heard? May we not read his silence as an admission that what we have been dwelling on is true?
Just before this verse, Elihu says he wants to see Job justified. That sounds odd, said to a man whose great fault was defending himself. One writer draws out the difference:
He invites Job to speak out plainly, if he has anything to say. Elihu was not putting Job down, as his friends did; he wanted Job to be justified. He did not mean that Job should justify himself, for that was already Job's tragic mistake. No doubt he wanted Job justified from God's viewpoint. God justified the tax collector rather than the Pharisee, when the tax collector prayed, "God, be merciful to me, a sinner!" (Luke 18:13-14).
Elihu is the younger man here, yet he promises to teach wisdom to older men. He can make that claim only because the wisdom is not his own.
Elihu speaks against his own wish. He stands in front of men he would gladly have learned from, if only they could have taught him the mind of God. Yet he is careful to stand for nothing except what comes from God. He has learned, as never before, that spiritual wisdom is of God's Spirit, not of a man's age. It is the very opposite of self-confidence or boasting, though his heart is so full that he has to speak.
The call to be silent comes from a man who had stayed silent through the whole debate. That answers the charge that Elihu was a brash young man pushing his way in.
On what other ground could a younger man speak, and correct everyone who had gone before? He kept silent until even Job had no more to say. He spoke only when Job, as much as his friends, could not help feeling that the riddle was still unexplained. That silence is the strongest proof of how little he deserves the charge of being bold, forward, meddling, conceited, arrogant, or boastful. He certainly shows in the clearest light how completely those failed who had condemned Job without answering him, and who did it with hints that condemned themselves.
The chapter ends without a word from Job.
After this glowing speech, in which Elihu brings in God in His grace, he turns to Job. "Have you anything to say? Then answer me." But Elihu waits in vain. Job's lips are sealed.
That silence is exactly what the verse asked for:
Elihu had asked Job to speak if he had anything to say. Now he tells him, and rightly, "If not, listen to me; be silent, and I will teach you wisdom" (v. 33). Job then had nothing to say. No doubt he recognised that Elihu's message was higher than he had thought, and he wisely chose to listen.
- Invited — the verse ends Elihu's address with the offer he began with: speak, if you have something to say.
- Free — Job is not forced. Elihu pauses for a reply and reads the quiet that follows as agreement, not surrender.
- Justified — Elihu's goal is not to crush Job. He wants Job justified from God's viewpoint, the way the tax collector went home justified and the Pharisee did not.
- Taught — the wisdom on offer is not the speaker's own. It is of God's Spirit, not of a man's age, so the younger man may teach the older.
- Silent — Job says nothing, and that is the right answer. The man who had argued for chapters now takes the place of a listener.