If I beheld the sun when it shone, or the moon walking in brightness,
Job is at the end of his long self-defence, going through his life area by area and naming the sins he did not commit. Here he turns to the sky — and to the question of how looking at the sun or the moon could ever be a sin.
The verse names no idol and no shrine. One commentator points out what is missing here, and what Job was careful never to do:
William KellyJob means looking at the sun or moon in the way of adoration — bowing down to them, which was the earliest form of idolatry. We do not hear here of Baal or Ashtoreth, or of any of the shameful and wicked gods the nations worshipped. What we do hear of is a work of God of the highest kind. Yet Job leaned toward it in no way at all — not even the slightest act of honouring the creature!
In the next verse Job mentions the mouth kissing the hand. The gesture was a known mark of honour:
Morrish Bible DictionaryPermission to kiss the hand of a superior is a mark of honour. The heathen kissed their gods. When the object of worship was far away, like the sun or the moon, they kissed their own hand instead. That is why the most common New Testament word for worship is proskuneo, which comes from kuneo, meaning to kiss.
Job does not stop at the outward gesture. He also denies the pull of the heart behind it, and that inward test runs right through the chapter:
F. B. HoleThis chapter shows that before the law came, a high standard of morality was still found among God-fearing men. That standard covered not only the outward act but also the inward motive behind the act. Look at the examples. In verse 1 he speaks of what he thought, or did not think. In verse 7, of his heart following his eyes. In verse 27, of his heart being secretly enticed. In verse 33, of hiding his guilt and covering his sins, like Adam. This may remind us of the Sermon on the Mount.
This verse follows Job's denial that he trusted his wealth. One writer reads the two together as a single movement of thought:
Samuel RidoutHaving spoken of his generosity, Job goes on to speak of wealth. He rejects the love of gold that is so common among people — that "covetousness, which is idolatry" (Col. 3:5). When his riches had increased, he had not set his heart upon them; gold had not allured him. And when he lifted up his eyes to the shining heavens, he had not given the glory to the sun, a creature of God, nor to the moon, "queen of heaven," walking in splendour. He had not even secretly blown them a kiss of worship, for that would have denied God; he would have been a hypocrite, well deserving punishment.
Why would a secret thought deserve judgment? Because of what it would say about God:
Leslie M. GrantIn contemplating the sun and the moon, had Job been enticed to worship them, as many others are enticed? Both of these are amazing objects, but Job looked higher than them and had not even secretly given them honour. He recognised that anything taking God's place in the heart is an idol. If he had allowed even a secret thought of that kind, it would have been sin deserving of judgment. It would have meant denying the God who is infinitely high above all.
Everything Job says here is true. But he is saying it in a speech that defends himself:
Samuel RidoutTo all of this we can but say, True and excellent, but why should he speak of it? Why not let his fear of God keep him from these things, rather than boast of them?
- Creature. The oldest idolatry was not a carved image but the sun and moon — real works of God, given the honour owed to their Maker.
- Gesture. People kissed their hand to worship what they could not reach. The New Testament word for worship still carries that root.
- Heart. Job denies the secret pull of the heart as well as the visible act. The standard reaches the motive, not just the deed.
- Denial. Anything that takes God's place is an idol. To give it that place, even in thought, is to deny God Himself.
- Boast. All of it is true. Yet Job boasts of it, when his fear of God could simply have kept him from these things.
And my heart have been secretly enticed, so that my mouth kissed my hand
Job has been listing sins he never committed, and here he turns from gold to the sky — to the sun and the moon, the most magnificent things a man can look at. His test is not public bowing. It is whether his heart was ever drawn away in private, and whether a silent kiss of the hand toward a created light would count against him.
In Job's world, a person who honoured the sun would kiss his own hand and send the kiss toward it. One writer points out that even a secret kiss would have made Job a hypocrite:
Samuel RidoutWhen Job lifted up his eyes to the shining heavens, he had not given the glory to the sun, a creature of God, nor to the moon, "queen of heaven," walking in splendour. He had not even secretly sent them a kiss of worship. That would have denied God, and he would have been a hypocrite, well deserving punishment.
Job does not wait for the hand to move before he calls himself guilty. He names the heart first, and he names it as something that can drift quietly. This inward measuring runs right through the chapter:
F. B. HoleThis chapter shows that even before God gave the law, God-fearing men still held a high standard of morality. That standard looked not only at the outward act but also at the inward motive behind the act. Take these instances. He spoke of what he thought, or did not think, in verse 1. He spoke of his heart walking after his eyes, in verse 7. He spoke of his heart being secretly enticed, in verse 27. And he spoke of hiding his iniquity and covering his sins, like Adam, in verse 33.
No shameful idol is in view here. The sun and moon are God's own work, not some carved pagan figure. Job still treats the faintest lean toward them as a crime:
William KellyNow he looks at something quite different — "If I looked at the sun when it shone, or the moon moving in brightness," that is, in the way of any adoration. Bowing down to the sun or moon was the earliest form of idolatry. We do not hear of Baals or Ashtoreths or any of the disreputable and wicked heathen objects of worship. Here was a work of God of the highest kind, and yet no leaning toward it in any way — "and my heart has been secretly enticed, and my mouth has kissed my hand" — even the slightest form of acknowledging the creature! "This also would be an iniquity to be punished by the judge, for I would have denied the God who is above." There we have very sound doctrine.
The idolatry Job refuses tells us something about when he lived. One writer dates the book by it:
William KellyThe Book of Job was written after the flood; there was no idolatry before the flood. The earliest idolatry was the worship of the sun, moon, and stars, and in the course of this book we shall see that this is the only idolatry Job refers to. It was common at that time, and later people fell into much more degraded forms of it.
Job is telling the truth. The problem is that he is the one advertising it, instead of leaving it to God:
Leslie M. GrantWhen Job looked at the sun and the moon, had they enticed him to worship them, as they entice many others? (vv. 26-27). Both of these are amazing objects, but Job looked higher than them and had not even secretly given them honour. He recognised that anything that takes God's place in the heart is an idol. If he had been guilty of even secretly allowing this in his thoughts, then this would be iniquity deserving of judgment (v. 28). It would amount to denying the God who is infinitely high above all… Though Job was no doubt speaking truth, yet there was no reason for him to advertise what his character had been. Why did he not stop to consider that God knew his actions, his words and his motives perfectly? He could wait on God to bring to light the truth about His servant.
- Secretly enticed. The pull starts inside, before any hand moves — Job judges the motive, not only the act.
- Secretly kissed. A kiss thrown toward the sun was the smallest possible gesture of honour, and Job counts even that as guilt.
- Secretly denied. To give the least acknowledgement to a created light is to deny the God who is above it.
- Secretly seen. What no human eye could catch is still a crime before the Judge, because God knows the motive perfectly.
- Secretly weak. Job's record was true, yet he advertised it instead of waiting for God to bring the truth about His servant to light.
This also would be an iniquity for the judge, for I should have denied the щGod who is above.
Commentary for this verse has not been generated yet.