Job 31:16–21

Job 31:16

If I have withheld the poor from [their] desire, or caused the eyes of the widow to fail;

Job has reached his final defence. He goes through his life item by item, daring God to find the fault his friends keep insisting must be there. Here he touches money and mercy — what he did with what he had when the poor and the widow came to his door.

A Self-Examination No Friend Could Face

This chapter is not a general claim of innocence.

Job tests himself formally and in fine detail, with a very full list of charges. He does this toward God as well as man — for failing to do good, as well as for self-indulgence and other sins. We can be sure of this. Not one of the friends who as good as put him on trial could have afforded to test himself as Job does here.

William Kelly

Sins of Omission

Verse 16 is not about cruelty. It is about what Job would be guilty of if he had kept what was his and done nothing.

In verses 16-21 he speaks of sins of omission also. Suppose he had not helped the poor, or had ignored the plight of the widow. Suppose he had kept all he had for himself, so that the fatherless went hungry. Suppose he had seen someone die for lack of clothing, or a poor man with nothing to cover him. Suppose the heart of the poor had never blessed Job, never warmed by the fleece of his sheep — then he says, "let my arm fall from my shoulder."

Leslie M. Grant

A Father to the Orphan, a Son to the Widow

Job's care was not charity at a distance. It reached into his own household and out to those who had no one.

Reaching out beyond his household to the needy poor, he let the fatherless and the widow share his food, and he warmed them with his clothing. In brief he was as a father to the orphan, and as a son to the widow. Surely we have here an illustration of religion that is "pure and undefiled" (James 1:27).

Samuel Ridout

Kelly adds another mark of it: Job never used his influence with others to take the smallest advantage.

His compassion always went out to people who were suffering — the widow and the fatherless, the needy and the naked. This was no passing gesture. He cared for them steadily and tirelessly, as a father would, and he watched himself carefully, so that he never took the least advantage of them through his influence with others.

William Kelly

Conscience Before There Was a Written Law

Job lived before God gave the law at Sinai, and before any Scripture existed. That makes his standard here remarkable.

The law had its value, for God does nothing in vain. Yet look how high the moral standard already was — in the soul, and in the daily walk of godly men outside Israel, before the law came from Sinai. And it was not only in matters of right and wrong, which conscience could judge more or less exactly, depending on how much light a man had. We can also see what God's revelation did inside the soul, in its affections and its judgments.

William Kelly

True Kindness That Still Brought No Rest

Everything Job says here is accurate. The trouble is what he is doing with it.

Now, just read chapters 29-31, and you will say, if any man could have justified himself by good works, Job was the man. There is not a man in all your town that can say as much as Job said, and say it truly. As to his kindness to the poor, he was the very opposite of the lying charges brought against him. So he lets memory recount every good act of his life, but it all fails to give rest to his troubled spirit. I, I, I — I did this, I did not do that. But it is all of no use.

C Stanley

Kelly adds what God meant to do about it.

The friends were completely wrong. They had no excuse and no kindness. What Job says was true, but he does not yet know the whole truth about himself — as no one could, until He came who is the Truth, and proved it in grace to the very end at His cross. But Job was taken up with himself and pleased with himself. God would set him free from that, and bless him more than ever. No human being will boast in God's presence. Job had to learn this — to boast only in Him.

William Kelly

Summary

- Test. Job puts himself on trial with a detailed list of charges. It covers not only wrong he did, but good he may have failed to do.

- Omission. Verses 16-21 name a second kind of sin. It is keeping all you have while the poor, the widow and the fatherless go without.

- Reach. His care began in his own household and reached the widow, the orphan, the needy and the naked. It was steady, not occasional.

- Source. This standard was already there before Sinai and before any written Scripture. Conscience, and what God had revealed, shaped the soul.

- Limit. Every word of it was true, and none of it gave him rest. God meant to free him from himself and bless him more than ever.

Job 31:17

Or have eaten my morsel alone, so that the fatherless ate not thereof,

Commentary for this verse has not been generated yet.

Job 31:18

(For from my youth he grew up with me as with a father, and I have guided the [widow] from my mother's womb;)

Job's last speech is a sworn defence of his whole life, listed sin by sin before God. Verse 18 breaks in with a memory of an orphan and a widow, and it raises two questions: who is the father here, and can a good record settle anything before God?

Inside a list of things Job never did

The verses around it list kindnesses Job never withheld — and the curse he calls down on himself if he is lying:

In verses 16-21 he speaks of sins of omission also. Suppose he had not helped the poor. Suppose he had ignored the plight of the widow, and had kept all he had for himself, so that the fatherless were left hungry. Then, he says, "let my arm fall from my shoulder, let my arm be torn from the socket" (v.22). In contrast to this, notice his words in parenthesis (v.18), "But from my youth I reared him (the fatherless) as a father, and from my mother's womb I guided the widow."

Leslie M. Grant

Father to the orphan, son to the widow

An orphan has no father. A widow has no husband. Job did not just send help. He stepped into the empty place:

Reaching out to the poor in need, he shared his food with the fatherless and the widow, and he warmed them with his clothing. In short, he was as a father to the orphan, and as a son to the widow. Surely we have here an illustration of religion that is "pure and undefiled" (James 1:27).

Samuel Ridout

Not a mood, but a lifetime

"From my youth" is the key phrase. It turns single acts of kindness into a settled way of living. And that way of living reached far beyond Job's own household:

It was not only a strong sense of kinship inside his own household. His compassion always went out to suffering people — the widow and the fatherless, the needy and the naked. He did not help them now and then. He cared for them as a father does, with care that was constant and never tired. And he kept watch over himself, so that he never used his influence with others to take the least advantage.

William Kelly

A second reading of the same words

The phrase "from my mother's womb" pushes the claim back to birth, and translations and commentators handle it in two ways. The writers above read Job as the one who raised the orphan. On the other reading, God is the father here, caring for Job from before his birth. That makes the end of the book sharper still:

The book of Job records God's lovingkindness in His dealings with this patient man from his earliest days (Job 31:18, amended). "He brought me up as a father, and guided me from my mother's womb." Yet Job is brought to confess, despite all that God had been to him, "I despise myself, and repent in dust and ashes." In the end his sufferings set him free from himself, and even greater blessing marks the close of his story.

The Bible Treasury

The record is true — and still not enough

So Job's conscience was clear. Why did that not settle his case?

He had a completely good conscience, but that is not enough. There is the great principle of self-judgment. There is also the grand principle of full submission to God, and of vindicating Him. He is right and wise in all of it — not only in what He does, but in what He allows.

William Kelly

So the chapter ends in exhaustion, not peace:

If any man could have justified himself by good works, Job was the man... As to his kindness to the poor, he was the very opposite of the lying charges brought against him. So he lets his memory count up every good act of his life, but it all fails to give rest to his troubled spirit. I, I, I, I did this, I did not do that. But it is all of no use.

Charles Stanley

Summary

- Parenthesis — The verse breaks into a list of things Job never did. His answer to the charge is a memory: he raised the orphan and guided the widow.

- Substitute — Job did more than give. He took the missing place: a father to the orphan, a son to the widow. That is religion pure and undefiled.

- Lifelong — "From my youth" marks care that was constant and never tired. It reached past his own household, and he never used his influence to take the least advantage.

- Reversed — On the other reading it is God who fathers Job from the womb. Job still ends by saying he despises himself and repents in dust and ashes.

- Not enough — The record is true, but a clear conscience toward people is not enough. "I, I, I did this" gives no rest. Job must still bow to God.

Job 31:19

If I have seen any perishing for want of clothing, or any needy without covering;

Commentary for this verse has not been generated yet.

Job 31:20

If his loins have not blessed me, and if he were not warmed with the fleece of my lambs;

Job is answering his friends' accusations by walking through his own life. Here he points to a poor man who left his door warm instead of shivering. The wool came off Job's own flock, so the claim is concrete. Yet the way he tells it raises a second question: who was the good in Job, and who deserves the credit?

Sins Of Omission

The verse belongs to a run where Job defends himself not for what he did, but for what he never failed to do.

In verses 16-21 he speaks of sins of omission also. Suppose he had not helped the poor, or had ignored the plight of the widow. Suppose he had kept all he had for himself, so that the fatherless went hungry. Suppose he had seen anyone die for lack of clothing, or any poor man without covering. Suppose the heart of the poor had not blessed Job, because it was not warmed by the fleece of his sheep. Then, he says, "let my shoulder blade fall from my shoulder, and let my arm be broken from its socket" (v.22).

Leslie M. Grant

The Loins That Blessed Him

The thanks Job speaks of comes from a part of the body, not from a speech. Where the ESV says "his body," older translations read "his loins."

The loins are the body's chief seat of strength, when they are properly belted for work.

Andrew Miller

So the blessing is the poor man's own strength giving thanks. Warmth had returned to a body that once lay exposed.

Constant, Not Casual

Job's care ran through his household and reached far past it. It also kept watch over itself.

His care was not only a strong sense of family inside his own household. His compassion always went out to suffering people — the widow and the fatherless, the needy and the naked. He did not help now and then, but with the constant, tireless care of a father. And he watched himself, so that he never took the smallest advantage by using his influence with others.

William Kelly

Another writer traces the same care outward, from the servants in Job's house to the poor at his door.

He starts with his household. Its good order grew out of the purity of its master. He claims he was fair in every dealing with his servants, since he saw that they shared his nature and stood before a God "who shows no partiality." Then he moves outward to the needy poor. The fatherless and the widow had shared his food, and he had warmed them with his clothing. In short, he was a father to the orphan and a son to the widow. Here we surely have an example of religion that is "pure and undefiled" (James 1:27).

Samuel Ridout

The Question It Puts To Us

The verse is not only a defence of one man. It is a measure anyone can hold up to their own life.

To close, and to be practical: what is my life, and what is your life? Am I a fruitful vine? Are you? Am I, are you, touching the world's need, for God's glory and to show His character?... Clearly Job was not an empty vine.

A. J. Pollock

Borrowed Garments

Everything Job says here is true. The trouble is the telling. A man wrapping himself in his own record has taken something that was never his to wear.

We cannot question the truth or the sincerity of all that he says. But we may well ask: is his conclusion a happy one even for himself?... Divine truth, as well as divine love, will not let him wrap himself in these clothes of self-righteousness. Most of them are borrowed garments that belong to God, and Job gives Him not the least bit of glory for them. The rest are only filthy rags, fit for the dust and ashes where Job will soon put himself.

Samuel Ridout

What The Good Man Still Needed

The wool was real, and so was the warmth. The kindness came from God working in Job. Yet something was still missing, and God set out to deal with it.

Now Job needed this, and God saw that he needed it. He was gracious and godly, but he did not know himself. He had never seen God in a way that brought him to a real knowledge of himself in His presence. So God deals with him in a way that brings his sinfulness right out into the open. Then He sets him, with that sinfulness now clear to his conscience, in His own presence... Job had acted well, for grace had acted in him; but he did not know himself before God.

J. N. Darby

Summary

- Seen. Job counts failure to act as guilt. Passing a man with no covering would have been sin, not just a missed chance to do good.

- Given. The covering came off his own flock. Real mercy costs the giver something he owned.

- Warmed. The loins are the body's seat of strength. The poor man's restored strength is the thanks Job receives.

- Blessed. Steady care — from the servants in his house out to the widow and the orphan — is an example of religion that is pure and undefiled.

- Boasted. The deeds were true, but grace had worked them. Worn as self-praise, they become borrowed garments. The man who wears them still does not know himself before God.

Job 31:21

If I have lifted up my hand against an orphan, because I saw my help in the gate

Near the end of his long defence, Job swears an oath about the town gate — the public court, where a strong man could ruin a weak one and stay within the law. He says he never used his power there against a fatherless child, and he stakes his own arm on it.

The Gate and the Advantage Job Held

Job's claim is not that he never met an orphan. It is that he never pressed his advantage when the judges leaned his way. One writer draws out both halves of the picture: the influence Job had, and the case he refused to push. (His quotation reads "let my arm drop from my shoulder blade." The ESV renders the same line, "let my shoulder blade fall from my shoulder.")

While dwelling on his kindness, Job shows how he had not taken advantage of any legal technicality that would have cleared him in any harsh dealing with the needy. When he saw his "help in the gate" — the judges inclined to decide in his favour, not because they were bribed, but because they were giving him his just dues — he had not pressed his case against the orphans. If he had lifted his hand against them, he says, "let my arm drop from my shoulder blade."

Samuel Ridout

The Accusation Behind the Oath

Job is not speaking into the air. His friend Eliphaz had already made this exact charge. One writer shows how wide of the truth it was.

Eliphaz is only imagining what he thinks Job must have done to explain his troubles. "… You have sent widows away empty, and the arms of the fatherless have been broken. Therefore snares are all around you." You see, all the reasoning is quite mistaken.

William Kelly

So Job answers with the same image. Eliphaz spoke of broken arms. Job offers his own.

Sins of Doing and Sins of Not Doing

This oath sits inside a list of sins of omission. Neglect counts too: not feeding the hungry, not clothing the poor, not defending the fatherless in court.

In verses 16-21 he speaks of sins of omission also. Suppose he had not helped the poor, or had ignored the plight of the widow, but had kept all he had for himself, so that the fatherless went hungry. Suppose he had seen anyone die for lack of clothing. Suppose Job had not championed the cause of the fatherless in the gate, the place of judgment. Then, he says, let his own arm fall from his shoulder, torn from the socket.

Leslie M. Grant

A Conscience Trained Before Any Written Law

Job lived long before God gave the law at Mount Sinai. Yet his moral standard is high. One writer traces that back to how God dealt with people before any Scripture existed.

This closing burst of indignant self-defence on Job's part is deeply interesting and instructive… We can see how high the moral standard was for the soul and for the walk of godly men outside Israel, before the law came from Sinai… God had spoken words. He had also worked in solemn ways with people, one by one and all together, in grace and in judgment. All this was long before He inspired men to write His mind by divine power. And faith received His word, and thought over His dealings, to rich profit, before Scripture existed.

William Kelly

A Clear Conscience, and Still No Rest

Everything Job claims here is true. That is what makes the chapter so searching: a man can be right about his record and still need to judge himself.

He had a perfectly good conscience, but that is not enough. There is the great principle of self-judgment. There is also the grand principle of entire submission to God, and of vindicating Him — that He is right and wise in all, not only in what He does, but in what He allows.

William Kelly

Why the Defence Fails to Comfort Him

The chapter ends without peace. One writer points to the reason: Job counts his own good deeds one by one.

Now, just read chapters 29-31. You will say that if any man could have justified himself by good works, Job was the man… So he lets memory recount every good act of his life. But it all fails to give rest to his troubled spirit. I, I, I, I did this, I did not do that. But it is all of no use.

C Stanley

Summary

- Gate. The scene is the public court, where Job had the judges' ear and could have ruined an orphan within the law.

- Hand. Innocence here is not only what Job did. It is the advantage he refused to press.

- Omission. Job's list counts neglect as guilt: not feeding, not clothing, not defending the fatherless.

- Arm. Job stakes his own arm on the claim: if he lied, let it fall from his shoulder.

- Rest. A clean record still leaves Job restless. A good conscience is not enough; he must submit to God and own that God is right.