Let the day perish in which I was born, and the night that said, There is a man child conceived.
Job has lost his children, his wealth and his health, and his friends have come to sit with him. Then the man famous for his patience opens his mouth and curses the day he was born.
Satan's disasters never made Job complain. Something gentler broke him open.
J. N. DarbyBut nothing had yet reached the depths of Job's heart, and God's purpose was to reach them, whatever Satan's thoughts may have been. Job did not know himself. Up to this time, for all his godliness, he had never been in the presence of God... Satan is defeated, because the grace of God kept Job's heart from complaining. But God still has His own work to do. What the storm Satan raised against Job failed to do, the sympathy of his friends does.
Stop the book here and you have a hero, but no lesson.
William KellyIf the trial had stopped here, the book would have lost its lesson. We would have missed the ways and the end of the Lord.
The curse falls on a date, and on the night that announced a conception. It never falls on God.
William KellyJob mourns and curses his day — not God, nothing of that kind. Yet he speaks in a way he should not, showing his horror of the day that announced his birth. The whole scene of his birth stood before him in gloom. Everything to do with his coming into the world looked horrible to him... He asks why he was ever born, when he was destined for such misery.
Job asks for something that cannot happen. Anguish is speaking, not faith.
Leslie M. GrantEven now Job did not accuse God of wrong, but he did curse the day of his birth. He was not blaming God openly. Yet, little as he saw it, he was blaming God all the same, because it was God who gave him life... How could the day perish on which Job was born (v.3)? How could history run backwards? That day had passed long before, and at the time it was a day of light, because a boy had been born into the world... Later Job would thank God that he had been born, and that thankfulness will last forever... But anguish moved him, not faith.
Almost everyone marks a birthday with gladness. Job could only mourn his.
F. B. HoleTo poor Job his birthday seemed a moment to mourn and curse. In his days of plenty he had feared that some trouble might come. Now it had come on him with a force beyond anything known. His words of agony in Job 3 still move us to sympathy, some four thousand years after he spoke them.
Still, the writers do not excuse the wish. To want your own life cancelled is a serious thing for someone who belongs to God.
Samuel RidoutOnly of one man has it ever been said — by our Lord — "It would have been better for that man if he had not been born" (Matthew 26:24). Judas had turned away from the faith. Satan entered his heart, and he sold his Master for thirty pieces of silver... For a child of God to wish he had never been born shows a total, though only temporary, eclipse of faith.
Set Job's cry beside Christ. Christ felt His suffering deeply, and still owned it as the reason He came.
William KellyBut the great point is his mourning over this terrible lot of his: that he was ever allowed to come into the world to bear such awful suffering. Where do you find that in Christ? "I was sent for this purpose." The Lord accepts it. He felt it, and felt it deeply. He was troubled in spirit. He felt it, and yet He accepted it. This was why He had come. Job was different. He could not understand why a holy God should allow such suffering, though his own sufferings were nothing beside those of Christ.
Job's collapse is not the end of his story, and it is not wasted.
Hamilton SmithJob had begun to take pleasure in his own goodness and to trust his own righteousness. So, to destroy Job's confidence in himself, God allows Satan's malice, within set limits, to sift him with terrible trials. The result was twofold. Job triumphed over all the power of the enemy. He also learned, through the trials, to judge the secret and unsuspected evil of his own heart.
- Purpose. Satan aimed to break Job. God aimed deeper — to reach a heart that, for all its godliness, had never stood in His presence.
- Curse. Job curses a date, not God; even at his lowest he does not turn on the One who gave him life.
- Impossibility. No past day can perish. The wish is anguish speaking, not faith — and Job would one day thank God for that very day.
- Contrast. Christ felt His hour as deeply and still owned it as the reason He came. Job could only ask why.
- End. The collapse is the doorway: through it Job learns his own heart, and then learns the Lord's.
That day -- let it be darkness, let not +God care for it from above, neither let light shine upon it
After seven days of silence, Job opened his mouth and cursed the day he was born. He asks for that day to be blotted out and left dark, unnoticed by God — and his words raise a hard question: what was God doing in letting a godly man sink this far?
Job stayed silent under the loss of everything. His friends arrived, and that is what opened his mouth.
J. N. DarbyIt may have been the pride of his heart, which could not bear to be found in such a state by people who had known his greatness. It may have been their sympathy, which weakened that pride and left him feeling his misery in full. Either way, it was the presence and the words of his friends that brought out all that was in his heart. The depths of Job's heart had not yet been reached, and reaching them was God's purpose. He acts in grace in cases like this, for the good of the soul He loves.
Another translation words the three wishes of the verse like this:
William KellyThat day — let it be darkness; Let not God from above ask after it; And let not light shine upon it.
Job names God once here, and only to ask Him to take no notice of that day.
Leslie M. GrantHow could the day perish in which Job was born? (v.3). How could history reverse itself? That day had passed long before, and at the time it was a day of light that a man-child had been born into the world. Could Job's words change that light to darkness? He mentions God once in this section, wanting God to ignore that day (v.4). Later Job would thank God he had been born, and that thankfulness will last for eternity. But when trouble comes like Job's, we do not tend to think calmly and carefully. Wishful thinking will never achieve anything... he was moved by his anguish, not by faith.
Commentators weigh this outburst differently. Some stress the line Job never crossed:
Arno Clemens GaebeleinNotice this. Job gives way to his feelings in this passionate outburst, yet he did not renounce God. There is not a word of rebellion against Him. All through his reply to his friends' arguments he does not lose sight of God. Again and again he expresses confidence in the unseen One.
Others press the seriousness of the wish itself:
Samuel RidoutOf only one man has it ever been said, by our Lord, that it would have been better for him if he had not been born: Judas, who sold his Master for thirty pieces of silver, betrayed Him with a kiss, and then went and hanged himself. For a child of God to wish he had never been born shows a complete, if only temporary, eclipse of faith.
Christ suffered far more, and He never mourned that He had come into the world.
William KellyThe great point is what he mourns: that he was ever allowed to come into the world to bear such awful suffering. Where do you find that in Christ? "For I was sent for this purpose." The Lord accepts it; He felt it, felt it deeply; He was troubled in spirit. He felt it, but He also accepted it. For this cause He had come. Not so Job. His sufferings were nothing compared to those of Christ. Even so, he could not understand why a holy God should allow such suffering. It was inexplicable to Job.
This is where despair begins. For a person who knows God, it is also where something else begins.
The Bible TreasuryWhen you wake up to the full sense of your misery, the first thought — and the most bitter one — is to curse your day. It is a terrible feeling, and where God is not known it is the thought that leads to suicide. But where God is known, as with Job, it is the start of healthy action. Not because of the discontent and wretchedness it uncovers, but because you now know and feel what death is: being cut off from everything... Discipline may have the effect of making us feel that death is better than life, but it is working out God's purpose.
- Depths. The disasters did not break Job; his friends did. God used them to bring out the depths of his heart, and that was His purpose.
- Darkness. Job asks for his day to be given over to darkness, and for God above never to look for it again. He names God once in the lament, and only to ask Him to look away.
- Anguish. The wish was impossible and he knew it; he was speaking out of pain, not out of faith.
- Distinction. He cursed his day, not God — yet wishing you had never been born is still a real, if temporary, eclipse of faith.
- Design. Christ felt His hour deeply and accepted it; Job could not. Where God is known, even this depth of darkness is the start of His work, not the end of the man.
Let darkness and the shadow of death claim it; let clouds dwell upon it; let darkeners of the day terrify it.
Job opens his mouth and curses the day he was born. Verse 5 is the heart of that curse: he calls on gloom, deep darkness and cloud to take that day back and frighten it out of existence.
Job's curse runs through the day and then the night. One writer renders the Hebrew line by line:
William KellyThat day! let it be darkness; let not God from above ask after it; and let not light shine upon it. Let darkness and death's shadow reclaim it; let clouds settle over it; let the darkenings of the day terrify it. That night! let thick darkness seize it.
(Kelly gives his own translation of the Hebrew here, not the ESV. Where the ESV reads "deep darkness," he has "death's shadow.")
Job does not curse his enemies or his losses. He curses a date, and the return of that date every year.
Samuel RidoutIn this first part Job curses the day of his birth, wishes that it could be blotted out of the calendar, because it allowed his birth. He desires that that day and night never come into remembrance — so that the very recurrence of the day that was a reminder of his existence might cease.
Job asks for something that cannot happen. One writer traces where such words come from:
Leslie M. GrantJob's grief was so deep that he did not even consider that what he was saying was an impossibility. How could the day perish in which Job was born? How could history reverse itself? That day had passed long before and at the time was a day of light that a man-child had been born into the world. Could Job's words change that light to darkness? He mentions God once in this section, desiring that God would ignore that day. Later Job would thank God he had been born, and that thankfulness will endure for eternity… But he was moved by his anguish, not by faith.
Job's wish sounds like words the Lord once spoke about one man only. One writer weighs the difference:
Samuel RidoutOf only one man has it ever been said — by our Lord "It would have been better for that man if he had not been born" (Matthew 26:24). Judas was an apostate. He was the "son of destruction," and Satan entered into his heart… For a child of God to wish he had never been born shows a complete, though only temporary, eclipse of faith.
A crushing blow first leaves a man with nothing to say. One writer explains why the complaint came later, and what God meant to do with it:
The Bible TreasuryA terrible blow can shut a man off from everything around him so completely that he does not even try to complain or to speak… But the moment he wakes up to where he stands in relation to everything here, self must occupy him — unless he is done with himself. God sends this discipline to set aside self, and to bring the heart into its true relation with God, apart from self. So the discipline exposes the secret workings and feelings of self. Otherwise they would never be detected or known — and if not known, never renounced.
Job is famous for patience. One writer sets that patience beside Christ:
J. N. Darby"You have heard of the patience of Job?" Yet he opened his mouth to curse his day. He complained that the Preserver of man had set him up as a target, so that he was a burden to himself. In Christ nothing was brought out but what was perfect.
- Darkness asked for. Job calls gloom, cloud and deep darkness to take back the day of his birth. He wants the date blotted out of the calendar, so its yearly return can never remind him he exists.
- Darkness that changes nothing. The day cannot perish. History cannot reverse itself. These are words shaped by anguish, not by faith.
- Darkness in a believer. The Lord said of Judas, not of a believer, that he would have been better off never born. In a child of God such a wish marks a real but temporary eclipse of faith.
- Darkness with a purpose. Suffering brings self to the surface. God uses it to expose feelings that would otherwise never be detected — and so never renounced.
- Darkness answered. Job would one day thank God he had been born. Where Job cursed his day, in Christ nothing came out but what was perfect.
That night -- let gloom seize upon it; let it not rejoice among the days of the year; let it not come into the number of the months.
After seven days of silence with three friends, Job's grief breaks out, and he wants the night of his conception struck off the calendar. Is this the cursing of God that Satan expected?
Job aims his words at a single date on the calendar.
Samuel RidoutIn this first part Job curses the day of his birth. He wishes it could be wiped off the calendar, because it allowed his birth. He wants that day and night never to come into remembrance. Then the day would stop returning to remind him that he exists.
Coming from a man known for blessing God, the sound of it is a shock.
Arno Clemens GaebeleinThe silence is broken by Job. Sadly, his lips do not utter praises now — he cursed the day of his birth. It was a painful trial for Job to look into the faces of these devout friends. They stood there in full health and strength. He was more devout than they were, yet God had stricken him and struck him down.
Nothing Job asks here is possible, and he is too deep in pain to notice.
Leslie M. GrantJob did not even now charge God foolishly, but he did curse the day of his birth. This did not blame God directly. Yet it blamed Him indirectly, however little Job realised it, for it was God who gave him life… Job's grief was so deep that he did not even consider that what he was saying was impossible. How could history reverse itself?… Later Job would thank God that he had been born. That thankfulness will last for eternity. But he was moved by his anguish, not by faith.
Where Job aims his curse matters, and so does the strain that pulled it out of him.
William KellyJob then did not curse God. No, he did not fall into what the devil thought he would do, but he cursed his own day, cursed his own lot. I do not say that this was right; I do not say so, far from it. But that was how it came out, that Job then opened his mouth. It came after seven days of silence. For seven days his dearest friends sat stunned at the size of his sufferings! Well, we must not be surprised that he broke out.
Loss alone did not produce this speech. Company did.
The Christian's FriendTrials come. Job remains as exemplary in adversity as he had been in prosperity… But at last God permits his friends to visit him and offer comfort. Then Job, so noted for his patience, curses the day of his birth. What afflictions we can endure in secret! But as soon as our friends become witnesses of them, our pride is stirred. Man's compassion excites impatience.
One complaint lies under the imagery: why was I ever brought into a life like this? Christ came into the same world and did not ask it.
William KellyThe great point is his mourning over this terrible lot. He grieves that he was ever allowed to come into the world to bear such awful suffering. Where do you find that in Christ? "For this cause was I sent." The Lord accepts it; He felt it, deeply felt it; was troubled in spirit. He felt it, but He also accepted it. For this cause He had come. But not so Job. His sufferings could not compare with those of Christ. Still, he could not understand why a holy God should allow such suffering. It was inexplicable to Job.
Job wants death as a way out. The New Testament points elsewhere.
Arno Clemens GaebeleinWeighed in the light of the New Testament, all these expressions are found wanting. Death is not a friend whose visit is to be desired, but an enemy. In the light of the gospel, the hope of God's people in affliction and sorrow is not relief by death. It is the coming of the Lord… Job's language is that of a man in despair. He seems to have quite forgotten the bright and blessed days of the past, and he fears a hopeless future.
- Silence breaks. Seven days of unbroken grief end, and the most patient man opens his mouth and curses the day of his birth instead of praising God.
- Sympathy stings. Job bore his losses in private. The arrival of friends stirred his pride and turned endurance into impatience.
- Day erased. Job wants his birth-night struck out of the year, so its return stops reminding him he exists. History cannot grant that.
- God spared. He curses his day, not God. Kelly will not call the words right, yet the devil still did not get what he expected.
- Christ contrasted. Job cannot see why he was ever sent into such suffering. Christ felt His suffering deeply and accepted it, because He had come for that very purpose.
Behold, let that night be barren; let no joyful sound come therein;
Job has sat in silence for seven days, and now the silence breaks. His first words reach back to the night that began his life. He wants it emptied — no birth in it, no shout of gladness in it at all.
Job's curse moves from the day of his birth to the night behind it.
William KellyJob then mourns and curses his day — not God, nothing of that kind. Yet he still speaks out his horror of the day his birth was announced, and that is unfitting. His whole birth-scene was before him, wrapped in gloom. Everything connected with his coming into the world was horrible in his eyes.
Kelly quotes the line in an older translation: "Lo, let that night be solitary, let no joyful voice come therein." The joyful cry Job wants silenced is the one that greets a birth.
F. B. HoleAlmost everywhere, a birthday is an occasion of remembrance and rejoicing. To poor Job it seemed a moment to be deplored and cursed. In his days of prosperity he had feared that some trouble might come. Now it had come upon him with unequalled force. His agonized words in Job 3 surely move our sympathy. We read them some four thousand years after he spoke them.
Job never curses God. But the curse he does pronounce still lands somewhere.
Leslie M. GrantJob did not even now charge God foolishly, but he did curse the day of his birth. This was not directly blaming God, but however little he realised it, he was indirectly blaming God, for it was God who gave him life.
The night Job curses is long past. Nothing can make it barren now.
Leslie M. GrantJob's grief was so deep that he did not even consider that what he was saying was an impossibility. How could the day perish in which Job was born? How could history reverse itself? That day had passed long before. … Later Job would thank God he had been born, and that thankfulness will endure for eternity. But he was moved by his anguish, not by faith.
Job bore the loss of his children and his health without this language. It broke out only once three friends were sitting in front of him.
J. N. DarbyOne of two things upset the mind of Job, or perhaps the two together. It may have been the sympathy of his friends — for alone, and from God in His presence, we can bear what we cannot bear once we have the chance to complain in front of man. Or it may have been pride, which is not roused while we are alone but is wounded when others witness our misery. And so he curses the day of his birth. The depths of his heart are displayed. It was this that he needed.
Commentators set Job's cry beside the Lord Jesus, who faced far worse.
William KellyThe great point is the mourning over this terrible lot of his, that he was ever allowed to come into the world to bear such awful suffering. Where do you find that in Christ? "For this cause was I sent." The Lord accepts it; He felt, deeply felt; was troubled in spirit. He felt it, but He also accepted it. For this cause He had come. But not so Job. He could not understand why a holy God should allow such suffering, though his own sufferings were nothing compared with those of Christ.
Job speaks at the lowest point of the account, with no view of how it ends.
William KellyIndeed there had never been a child of Adam or a believer so visited as Job; and as yet he did not know the end, that the Lord is full of pity, and of tender mercy. He was in the depth of his trial, and the silence of his friends made it worse. Worse still was coming: their suspicion, spoken more and more openly, like drawn swords.
The reverse of Job's barren night is a believer who can sing in the dark.
Samuel RidoutWhat a contrast is the joy of the believer as he dwells on his spiritual birthday. … So in the many persecutions and afflictions which happened to Paul for the gospel's sake, we hear not the faintest approach to these laments of Job. He and Silas were beaten, thrown into prison, their feet fast in the stocks. Their thoughts were not of cursing the day of their birth; they brought songs in the night.
- The night. Job asks that the night of his conception be left empty and silent — no life started, no glad shout heard.
- The limit. He curses his day, not God; yet the wish reaches back toward the One who gave him life.
- The futility. Anguish, not faith, is speaking: the day cannot perish, and history will not run backwards.
- The exposure. Under the eyes of his friends the depths of his heart come out — and this is exactly what he needed.
- The end. Job does not yet know what the story will show: that the Lord is full of pity and tender mercy, and that songs can be sung in a night like this.
Let them curse it that curse the day, who are ready to rouse Leviathan;
Job has sat in silence for seven days. When he speaks, he curses the day of his birth, and here he calls in help: people who make a trade of cursing days and know how to wake a monster. The line raises two questions. What is Leviathan doing here, and how far has Job's mind drifted from God?
Older English Bibles read "their mourning" here instead of a creature's name. One reference work says the creature is the right reading, and ties the word to a figure Scripture uses elsewhere for Satan:
Morrish Bible DictionaryIn Isaiah 27:1 it also stands for Satan: "Leviathan the fleeing serpent, Leviathan the twisting serpent," whom God will punish… In Job 3:8 it should be translated "leviathan" instead of "their mourning." This confirms the general meaning of some monster.
Cursing days was a trade. One writer reads the line against a myth, and finds in it a measure of where Job's mind had gone:
Samuel RidoutOne translation of verse 8 reads, "Let those who curse the day curse it, who are skilled in stirring up leviathan." It points to the pagan myth that a dragon swallowed the sun and moon and so stopped the day. If this is correct, it shows how far Job had drifted in his thoughts, to turn to pagan superstitions.
Even at his lowest, Job kept inside a line:
F. B. HoleHe opened his mouth and cursed his day. He did not curse God, note it well. He called down a curse upon the day he was born, grieving that he had not died when his mother gave him birth.
The curse aimed at something no curse can touch. A day already lived cannot be unmade, and behind that day stands the God who gave Job life:
Leslie M. GrantJob did not even now charge God foolishly, but he did curse the day of his birth. This was not blaming God directly. But however little he realised it, he was blaming God indirectly, because it was God who gave him life… How could the day of Job's birth perish? How could history reverse itself? That day had passed long before… But anguish moved him, not faith.
The despair itself has a use. Job feels only his misery; God is working toward something else:
The Bible TreasuryThe first thought after waking to a full sense of one's misery, and the most bitter one, is to curse one's day. That is a terrible impression, and where God is not known it leads to suicide. But when God is known, as in Job's case, it is the beginning of healthy action. Not because of the discontent and misery it uncovers, but because he knows and feels the sense of death, of being utterly wiped out from everything… He does not know that God seeks to make him a witness of dependence on Himself against Satan.
Job wanted Leviathan stirred up to serve his curse. God does bring the creature before him, but for another purpose:
Charles StanleyGod now shows Job, under the figure of leviathan, that Satan's power is too great for him. What a terrible being he is, this king over all the proud… But what could be God's object in describing the power of the enemy? Surely it was to lead Job into complete dependence on Himself. "I know," says Job, "that You can do all things."
Job mourns that he was ever allowed into the world. Christ never speaks that way:
William KellyThe great point is his mourning over this terrible lot of his — that he was ever allowed to come into the world to bear such awful suffering. Where do you find that in Christ? "I was sent for this purpose." The Lord accepts it. He felt it, and felt it deeply; He was troubled in spirit. He felt it, but He also accepted it.
- Translation. The right reading is not "their mourning" but Leviathan — a monster Scripture uses elsewhere as a picture of Satan.
- Drift. Job turns to hired cursers of days and a pagan story of a dragon swallowing the sun. It shows how far his thoughts had drifted.
- Limit. He cursed his day, not God. Yet the wish blamed God indirectly, because God gave the life he wanted undone.
- Discipline. The bitterness comes to the surface for a reason: God is making Job a witness of dependence on Himself against Satan.
- Answer. God does bring Leviathan before Job at last — not to serve his curse, but to show him a power too great for him, and to drive him into dependence on God.
Let the stars of its twilight be dark; let it wait for light, and have none, neither let it see the eyelids of the dawn
This verse ends Job's curse on the day and night of his birth: he wants its dawn stars black, and its morning light gone. How does a good man come to ask that one sunrise vanish from history?
The verse ends with a strange image: the eyelids of the morning. One writer says the form of the words matters as much as what they say:
Samuel RidoutAs we go through this book, we must not miss the exquisite beauty of the expressions, both of Job and of all who speak. For if the Spirit of God has seen fit to inspire a writing, He would have us note its form as well as its contents. So in verse 9 the margin of our version reads, "Neither let it see the eyelids of the morning." Another rendering has, "Let it not refresh itself with the eyelids of the dawn" — poetry indeed of exquisite beauty.
The curse has one aim, and it runs through this whole first part of the chapter:
Samuel RidoutIn this first part Job curses the day of his birth, wishes that it could be blotted out of the calendar, because it allowed his birth. He desires that that day and night never come into remembrance — so that the very recurrence of the day that was a reminder of his existence might cease.
Job does not accuse God directly. Yet the life he wishes away came from God:
Leslie M. GrantThis was not directly blaming God. But however little he realised it, he was blaming God indirectly, because it was God who gave him life… He was moved by his anguish, not by faith.
The turning point was not the pain itself but the suspicion behind it:
Samuel RidoutHe felt himself as if in the hands of arbitrary power, suffering for what he had not done. He sees no way of escape, and so he wishes for death… As long as his sufferings were outward, or physical, Job was calm. But when he let doubts of God's goodness in, he collapsed.
For all the bitterness, one line is never crossed. Job curses his day; he does not curse God:
Arno Clemens GaebeleinBut notice this. Though Job gives way to his feelings in this passionate outburst, he did not renounce God. There is not a word of rebellion against Him. All through his answers to the arguments of his friends he does not lose sight of God. Again and again he expresses confidence in the unseen One, as in that matchless saying, "Though He slay me, I will hope in Him" (13:15).
The outburst also exposes something in Job himself:
C. H. MackintoshWe can say with confidence: no one who had learned even a little to say "Your will be done" could ever curse his day, or use the language of Job 3… Job was a true saint of God. But he needed to learn himself, as we all do. He needed to see the roots of his own moral being laid bare, so that he might truly abhor himself and repent in dust and ashes.
Job wanted his hour wiped out. Here is the Sufferer who accepted His:
Samuel RidoutLet us contrast all these godly men with the matchless Sufferer. "Now is my soul troubled. And what shall I say? 'Father, save me from this hour'? But for this purpose I have come to this hour. Father, glorify your name." Ah, He never failed. The intensity of His sufferings only gave the occasion for the display of His sinless perfection.
The same kind of night can produce a different sound:
Samuel RidoutPaul and Silas were beaten and thrown into prison, with their feet fast in the stocks. Their thoughts were not of cursing the day of their birth. They brought songs in the night.
- Darkness requested. Job asks for the dawn stars to stay black. He wants the whole date wiped from the calendar, so nothing reminds him he exists.
- Darkness explained. He stayed calm while the suffering was outward. He collapsed when he began to doubt God's goodness and felt himself in the hands of arbitrary power.
- Darkness limited. Even here he never renounces God — the man who curses his day is the same man who says, "Though He slay me, I will hope in Him."
- Darkness exposed. The outburst reveals a will not yet broken; Job had to learn himself before he could say, "Your will be done."
- Darkness answered. Christ received the hour Job wished away, and those who follow Him can sing in the stocks.
Because it shut not up the doors of the womb that bore me, and hid not trouble from mine eyes.
Job's lament reaches back past his pain to his birth, and blames that day for letting him out into the light. Two questions follow: was this cursing God, and what was God doing in letting a godly man come to such words?
Job does not simply wish for death now; he traces his misery to the moment the womb opened. One writer unfolds the question inside it. If this was always going to be his lot, why was he born at all, and why the care that kept him alive?
William KellyAnd so he asks, in the anguish of his soul, why, if such was to be his lot living, did he not die from the womb? Why should he have been so tenderly cared for, only to meet such agony in the end?
Job curses the day, not God. Yet a wish that the womb had stayed shut aims at more than a date on the calendar. It reaches for something God settled long ago.
Leslie M. GrantJob did not even now charge God foolishly, but he did curse the day of his birth. This did not blame God directly. But however little he realised it, it blamed God indirectly, for it was God who gave him life... Later Job would thank God he had been born, and that thankfulness will endure for eternity... The doors of Job's mother's womb had been opened long ago (v.10), and Job knew this could never be reversed. But he was moved by his anguish, not by faith.
The verse names two things: doors that were not shut, and trouble that was not hidden. Wishing them otherwise, Job turns against his own helpless infancy and the love that met it.
Samuel RidoutIt is sad when a man cannot look back on those early days of helplessness with tender thoughts. Loving care watched over him when he was too young to know it. Of all creatures, man is the most helpless and dependent in infancy. It is to "hide pride" from him, and to call forth love on his behalf. To curse his infancy like this was to trample on what is best in our fallen humanity. It shows a soul far from communion with God. Job had forgotten all the past; the sorrow of the present had eclipsed everything else.
Jeremiah later cursed the day of his birth in almost the same terms, so the question is not peculiar to Job. Commentators locate the root of it well behind the ash-heap.
H. L. RossierThe original cause of such despair lies deeper. If the creature had not turned away from his Creator in the beginning, he would not now curse his existence. When men like Job and Jeremiah could curse the day of their birth, it only proves how far man has drifted away from God. As long as all goes well, the rebellion and sullenness of the human heart stay hidden. Trials bring them to light. Temptations are therefore good and necessary — not so that God may find out what is in man's heart... but so that man may learn to know himself.
That self-knowledge is not the end. God has a further aim in what He allows.
C. H. MackintoshOne great object in God's dealings with souls is to produce real brokenness and humility. He strips us of all false righteousness, empties us of all self-confidence, and teaches us to lean wholly on Christ. Everyone must pass through what we may call the process of stripping and emptying.
Job wanted his birth erased. Paul suffered too, yet never spoke this way, because he had another birth to look back on.
Samuel RidoutWhat a contrast this is to the joy of the believer as he dwells on his spiritual birthday. How Paul loved to look back to the time when the light above the brightness of the sun shone into his darkened heart... So in the many persecutions and afflictions that came on him for the gospel's sake, we hear not even a hint of these laments of Job. He and Silas were beaten and thrown into prison, their feet fastened in the stocks. Even then their thoughts were not of cursing the day of their birth. They brought songs in the night.
- Cause. Job's words do not curse God, yet they blame Him indirectly, since it was God who gave him life. Anguish moves him here, not faith.
- Care. The doors he wished had stayed shut opened onto years of loving care. Cursing his infancy tramples on what is best in fallen humanity.
- Concealment. He wanted trouble hidden from his eyes. God uses trial to bring hidden things to light instead — not to inform Himself, but so man learns to know himself.
- Cost. God strips away false righteousness and empties out self-confidence. He teaches the soul to lean wholly on Christ.
- Consequence. Job would later thank God for his birth, and that thankfulness will last for eternity. The cursed birthday gives way to a birthday worth blessing.
Wherefore did I not die from the womb, -- come forth from the belly and expire?
Job has lost everything, and after seven days of silence he curses the day he was born. This verse is the sharpest edge of that lament, and it raises a hard question: why did God let a patient man break like this?
Job had held steady while the losses fell. It was human company, not calamity, that finally opened his mouth.
J. N. DarbyJob remained as exemplary in his adversity as he had been in his prosperity. The root of sin was not yet reached. He then became more remarkable for his patience than even for his goodness. Scripture bears this testimony to it: "You have heard of the steadfastness of Job." God at last permits his friends to come and offer him comfort. How many hardships we can endure alone; but as soon as our friends see them, our pride stirs. The compassion of man often provokes our impatience; and Job, so distinguished for patience, at last curses the day of his birth!
Job weighs the care given to a newborn against the agony that same life has now brought him.
William KellyHe was in the depth of his trial, and the silence of his friends made it worse. Soon they would make it worse still, attacking him with suspicion they voiced more and more openly. And so he asks, in the anguish of his soul, why, if this was to be his lot in life, he did not die at birth. Why should he have been so tenderly cared for, only to meet such agony in the end?
Job aims his curse at the day, not at God.
Leslie M. GrantJob did not even now charge God foolishly, but he did curse the day of his birth. This was not directly blaming God, but however little he realised it, he was indirectly blaming God, for it was God who gave him life... Later Job would thank God he had been born, and that thankfulness will last for eternity. But when trouble comes like the trouble Job had to bear, we do not tend to think soberly and calmly. Yet wishful thinking never achieves anything. The doors of his mother's womb had been opened long ago, and Job knew this could never be reversed. But he was moved by his anguish, not by faith.
To wish the womb had been a grave is to reject the very kindness that kept him alive as a helpless infant.
Samuel RidoutIt is sad indeed when someone cannot look back on those early days of helplessness with tender thoughts. Loving care watched over him while he lay there unaware. Of all creatures, man is the most helpless and dependent in infancy. It is to hide pride from him, and to call out love on his behalf. To curse his infancy in this way was to trample on what is best in our fallen humanity. It shows a soul far from communion with God.
Job pictures the grave as one long sleep, the same for everyone.
Samuel RidoutJob puts everyone into an unconscious sleep, "as infants who never see the light." Is there no distinction between the condition of the wicked and of the righteous after death?... The constant contrast between the righteous and the wicked, and their moral unlikeness, points quite clearly to very different futures. Scripture says: "The wicked is overthrown through his evildoing, but the righteous finds refuge in his death." By blurring the future in this way, Job shows how far his soul had drifted from the truth of God.
The same words can come from a learner or from a rebel, and everything depends on which.
H. L. RossierEvery question can be asked in two ways. One person asks in humility, with a sincere desire to learn. Another asks in presumptuous rebellion against the answer, whatever it may be. In the first case the questioner honestly takes the place of a learner, which is the right thing for him to do. In the second case he assumes there is no satisfactory answer, or that the answer is withheld.
Why did God let a godly man reach this point?
William KellyJob must know himself, in a way he never could have imagined otherwise. To know yourself is a very different thing from being converted to God, and it is necessary if we are to be fully blessed... A man might be pious and yet never have really stood in God's presence for himself. I mean a thorough judgment of self, measured by God Himself.
- Pressure. Job bore his losses in silence. It was his friends' presence that finally drew out the curse on his birth.
- Aim. He cursed the day, not God — yet the day came from God's hand, so the complaint reached further than he knew.
- Anguish. Pain moved him, not faith. He asked for something that could never be undone — yet later he would thank God he had been born.
- Drift. Wishing the womb had been his grave despised the care that kept him alive. It also painted death as blank sleep for everyone alike.
- Purpose. God let the question stand so Job would know himself in God's presence — you can ask the same "why" as a learner or as a rebel.
Why did the knees meet me? and wherefore the breasts, that I should suck?
Job breaks his silence in chapter 3 with a wish that his life had ended before it began. Now he goes further and protests against the arms that held him and the milk that fed him as a baby.
Job sets the tender care he once received against the agony he is in now.
William KellyAnd so he asks, in the anguish of his soul, why, if this was to be his lot in life, did he not die from the womb? Why should he have been so tenderly cared for, only to meet such agony in the end? Why did he not share the quiet of the grave with the great ones of the earth? They spent their lives building monuments that decay, or cramming their houses with silver and gold they must leave behind.
Both images cover a baby's first days: arms that hold, and milk that feeds. Job wants none of it.
Samuel RidoutIn the second part of his lament (verses 10-12) Job wishes he had died at birth, or that no one had cared for him or fed him. It is sad when someone cannot look back on those early days of helplessness with tender thoughts. Loving care watched over those hours he cannot even remember. Of all creatures, man is the most helpless and dependent in infancy. It is to hide pride from him, and to call out love on his behalf. To curse his infancy in this way was to trample on what is best in our fallen humanity. It shows a soul far from communion with God.
Job asks for something already settled and impossible to undo. And the wish falls back on the One who gave him that life.
Leslie M. GrantJob did not even now charge God foolishly, but he did curse the day of his birth. This was not directly blaming God. But however little he realised it, he was indirectly blaming God, for it was God who gave him life... The doors of Job's mother's womb had been opened long ago (v.10), and Job knew this could never be reversed. But his anguish moved him, not faith.
The same writer draws the practical line between wishing and faith:
Leslie M. GrantBut wishing is not facing facts as they are. Faith faces facts and gives God credit for doing what He knows is best. But Job's faith had become very weak.
Dark as the words are, Job stops short of one thing.
Arno Clemens GaebeleinBut notice this. Job gives way to his feelings in this passionate outburst, yet he did not renounce God, and there is not a word of rebellion against Him. All through his answers to the arguments of his friends he does not lose sight of God. Again and again he expresses confidence in the unseen One, as in that matchless saying, "Though he slay me, I will hope in him" (13:15).
The most patient man on earth talks this way, and that is the point. His collapse brings out what his heart had been resting on.
J. N. DarbyJob had never really been brought into the presence of God... He was resting in what he was to others, and not in the favour of God Himself... So God goes on dealing with Job, until He brings him to nothing in the very thing Job was most famous for. Job, the most patient man, curses the day of his birth. Why is this? Because we must be broken down. We must be brought to a sense of what we are, as well as of what we have done. Then God can deal with us out of His own heart.
There is one Sufferer whose sorrow never turned into words like these.
James McBroomHe was dependent, sorrowful, made to suffer and despised, but He never murmured and was never embittered. No despairing words fell from Him like those we may hear from a Moses or an Elijah, a Job or a Jeremiah (Num. 11:11-14; 1 Kings 19:4; Job 3:3-14; Jer. 20:14-18).
- Care. The knees and the breasts stand for the helpless dependence of infancy. Job wishes that care away, though it exists to hide pride from us and to call out love.
- Cause. Anguish moved him, not faith. Wishing never faces facts; faith faces them and gives God credit for doing what He knows is best.
- Complaint. Cursing his birth did not blame God directly, yet God gave the life he now wishes away. The doors of the womb opened long ago, and nothing can reverse that.
- Confidence. Even here there is no renouncing of God and no rebellion; the same mouth will later say, "Though he slay me, I will hope in him."
- Purpose. God brought the most patient man to nothing so that Job would learn what he was, not only what he had done. Then God could deal with him out of His own heart.
For now should I have lain down and been quiet; I should have slept then had I been at rest,
Job breaks seven days of silence by wishing he had died at birth, and this verse is his reason. Two questions follow: how did the most patient man reach this point, and was he right about death?
Job had borne much suffering without this outburst. What opened his mouth was the silence of his friends.
William KellyWe hear the outburst of passionate grief at last from Job. He could not stand the presence of his friends. He had borne many sorrows and bitter suffering. But these friends came and looked at his misery without a word. It was too much for Job. Did they suspect him? He could not endure doubts about God's view of him, especially from them. Were they not friends? If they loved him, why that silence — that ominous silence for seven days and seven nights?
Job's longing for the grave was not just pain talking. God was using it to show Job what he really was.
J. N. DarbyJob had never really been brought into the presence of God. There had been a certain work in his soul, which produced fruits... He was resting in what he was to others, and not in the favour of God Himself... So God goes on dealing with Job, till in the very thing in which Job was most famous he is brought to nothing. Job, the most patient man, curses the day of his birth. Why is this? Because we must be broken down. We must come to a sense of what we are, as well as of what we have done. Then God can deal with us out of His own heart.
What Job describes over the next verses is one rest shared by everyone, with all earthly rank cancelled.
Samuel RidoutDeath is described here as a rest that all share equally. The old and the young, even the unborn baby, are at rest. So are the great and the small. Kings whose palaces have crumbled into ruins, and princes who left all their wealth behind, lie here at last in deep and equal rest. The wicked cannot trouble them. No master can demand work from his slave. Prisoners and their captors are no different in the presence of death, that great leveler of mankind.
Commentators differ over how much blame Job's words deserve. One reading holds that Job blurred the difference between the wicked and the righteous after death.
Samuel RidoutEverywhere the righteous and the wicked stand in contrast, morally unlike each other. This points clearly to very different futures: "The wicked is overthrown through his evildoing, but the righteous finds refuge in his death" (Prov. 14:32). In blurring the future in this way, Job shows how far his soul had drifted from the truth of God. In plain language he is longing for annihilation.
Another reading takes the same words as death seen from the outside. Job had no fuller revelation to draw on.
J. N. DarbyBut here I see no reason to blame these words on the unbelief that worked in Job's heart alongside much right feeling. This was simply how death appears. A man died, and no one saw him again until the end of all things... he uses words that fit with ignorance of another world and of the state between death and resurrection. But they certainly do not say the dead have stopped existing. They imply the opposite.
Some take this verse as proof that the dead simply stop existing. Job's own word for death points the other way.
Frederick W GrantSo Job's words do not contradict what we have seen elsewhere to be the revealed truth about those who have died. To a man as weary as he was, the unseen world was indeed a place of "rest". But "rest" is not extinction. And even if it were also a "land of darkness", darkness and non-existence are completely contradictory ideas.
Job's own later words, and the language of faith after him, answer the nothingness he longed for here.
Samuel RidoutJob's own words refute his unbelief here: "For I know that my Redeemer lives" (Job 19:25). David also said, "when I awake, I shall be satisfied with your likeness" (Ps. 17:15)... The New Testament letters speak of being "away from the body and at home with the Lord," and of "My desire is to depart and be with Christ, for that is far better." Do such words echo Job's unbelieving laments?
- Trigger — Disaster did not break Job's silence. His friends' wordless staring did.
- Purpose — God broke Job down so that a man resting in what he was to others would learn what he was before God.
- Picture — Job paints death as one level rest. Kings, slaves and unborn infants all share it.
- Dispute — Commentators differ. Some see a soul drifting toward a longing for annihilation. Others see a man describing death with the little light he had.
- Answer — Whatever Job meant, rest is not extinction. His own words, "I know that my Redeemer lives," outlive the wish he voices here.
With kings and counsellors of the earth, who build desolate places for themselves,
Job has lost his children, his wealth and his health, and he breaks his silence by wishing he had never been born. Picturing the grave, he names the company he would have kept there: kings, their counsellors, and princes with houses full of silver.
Job's opening speech moves in stages, and this line belongs to the middle one. One writer sets out the shape of the whole lament:
Samuel RidoutFirst: Job curses the day of his birth (vv. 1-9). Second: He wishes he had died in infancy (vv. 10-12). Third: Death is described as a rest (vv. 13-19). Fourth: He longs for death (vv. 20-23). Fifth: He is oppressed by terror (vv. 24-26).
The ESV says these kings "rebuilt ruins for themselves." One writer, using an older translation that reads "build desolate places," takes those places to be the tombs kings built:
William KellyHe asks why he had ever been born, one destined to such misery. Why was he not left instead, as he says so sharply, "with kings and counsellors of the earth, who build desolate places"? Is this what the greatness of this world comes to — kings building ruins for themselves? "Or with princes who had gold, who filled their houses with silver?" But gold and silver cannot buy escape from sorrow or death. Was this life? Was this the work in which the kings of Egypt sought fame, the building of their own tombs?
Job's list runs downward from kings to slaves, and the point is that the grave makes no distinction between them:
Samuel RidoutDeath is here described as a rest (vv. 13-19) in which all have an equal share. The old and the young, even the unborn baby, the great and the small, are alike at rest. Kings whose palaces have crumbled into ruins, and princes whose vast wealth has all been left behind, are here at last in deep and equal repose. The wicked cannot trouble them. A master cannot demand service from his slave. Prisoners and their captors find no difference in the presence of death, that great leveller of mankind.
But rest is not all Job asks for here. One writer weighs what his picture of death leaves out:
Samuel RidoutJob goes further and puts all in an unconscious sleep, "as infants who never see the light." Is there no difference between the condition of the wicked and of the righteous after death?… By blurring the future in this way, Job shows how far his soul had drifted from the truth of God. In plain language he is longing for annihilation.
The strongest answer to Job's mood comes from Job himself, later in the book:
Samuel RidoutJob's own words disprove his unbelief here: "I know that my Redeemer lives" (Job 19:25). David also said, "when I awake, I shall be satisfied with your likeness" (Ps. 17:15).
Job's cure for his pain is to have died at birth. One writer sets that wish beside faith:
Leslie M. GrantIf only he had died, he says, he would be at rest. In death at least, he claims, the wicked stop troubling, the weary are at rest, the prisoners are released and the slave is free from his master. But wishing is not facing facts as they are. Faith faces facts and gives God credit for doing what He knows is best. But Job's faith had become very weak.
Job's collapse was not a failure in God's plan. One writer explains what God was after in it:
J. N. DarbyJob had never really been brought into the presence of God… He was resting in what he was to others, and not in the favour of God Himself… So God keeps dealing with Job, until He brings him to nothing in the very thing for which Job was most famous. Job, the most patient man, curses the day of his birth. Why is this? Because we must be broken down. We must come to a sense of what we are, as well as of what we have done. Then God can deal with us out of His own heart.
- Ruins. Kings and counsellors built their own tombs. The greatness of this world ends in the ruins they built for themselves.
- Gold. Princes filled their houses with silver, and none of it could buy them out of sorrow or death.
- Level. In the grave the great and small, master and slave, captor and prisoner lie in the same rest. Death is the great leveller.
- Drift. Job's picture of rest slides toward wanting to stop existing, and his own later words answer him: "I know that my Redeemer lives."
- Purpose. The most patient man curses the day he was born. God was not after better fruit, but a heart broken down and brought into His presence.