Job 28:7–11

Job 28:7

It is a path no bird of prey knoweth, and the vulture's eye hath not seen it;

Job has been describing miners who tunnel into the earth for silver, gold and precious stones. Then he points to a path that no digging, no flight and no strength has ever found. The question the chapter is driving toward is not where treasure is, but where wisdom is.

The picture: a bird above, a miner below

Job names two creatures for what they can do. One sees everything below from the sky. The other relies on sheer strength.

In this section Job speaks of things that are usually hidden from people, but which God brings to light (v.11). There is a path that no bird knows, though it can fly high above earth to observe what is below. No falcon's eye (which is amazingly keen) discerns it (v.7). The proud or fierce lion cannot force his way into it by his superior strength (v.8).

Leslie M. Grant

Man goes the other direction — down. His digging can make him rich, and it still leaves the chapter's question open.

The birds go up into the heights and cross the whole surface of the earth, but they do not venture into the mines where man goes down... There is self in all that. There is what will make a man rich; there is what will bring money and perhaps distinction; but where shall wisdom be found? and where is the place of understanding? Well, it is not on the earth.

William Kelly

The wrong tools: sharp sight and great strength

Older translations call the bird a fowl and the falcon a vulture, which is why several writers use those words. The bird and the lion stand for two things people trust in themselves: sight and strength. Neither reaches this road.

No eye so keen in nature as the vulture's; no animal so bold as the lion. But the boldness and long-sightedness of nature are not equal for the path of faith. Only an eye fixed on Christ as its one Object will give spiritual understanding.

Hamilton Smith

Wisdom comes down, not up

If wisdom is not in the mine, the sea or the sky, it must come from somewhere higher.

True wisdom and true understanding not found in the earth at all! It comes down from heaven. It is found only in Christ... "The sea says, It is not with me... It is hidden from the eyes of all living, and kept close from the birds of the air."

William Kelly

The path Christ walked

Commentators read this hidden path as the Lord's own path through this world.

A path that the sharpest natural sight, pictured here by the vulture's eye, has never seen must be a remarkable path. Such was the Lord's path here... That one path was a lonely one for the Lord while He was on earth. Foxes had holes, and birds had nests, but He had no pillow.

Scripture Quarterly

Where that path ended is as far beyond nature's reach as the path itself.

"I am he that lives and was dead, and behold I am alive for evermore," are His new titles and dignities. By them He has passed into a sphere beyond the vulture's eye, a sphere no bird knows, which the lion's whelps have not trodden, and where the fierce lion has never passed by.

J. N. Darby

Walking a road you cannot see by nature

The natural eye cannot see this way, so the believer needs another kind of sight.

The path of separation is too narrow for the natural eye to discern. The word of God lays down no broad lines to mark the Christian's way through this world. Only the spiritual eye can see the way out of it.

Andrew Miller

So where does this path lead?

Like the path of death, it passes through a world of sorrow — yes, through the valley of the shadow of death. But unlike the path of death, it leads into the presence of the LORD, where there is fulness of joy and pleasures for evermore.

Hamilton Smith

Where the chapter finally lands

Job 28 does not leave the question hanging. The chapter gives its own answer at the end.

It cannot be that we must live in error, in darkness, or uncertainty. "There is a path," blessed be God, though "no bird knows it, and the vulture's eye has not seen it. The lion's whelps have not trodden it, nor the fierce lion passed by it." Where is this safe and blessed path? Hear the divine reply: "Behold, the fear of the Lord, that is wisdom: and to depart from evil is understanding." (Job 28)

C. H. Mackintosh

Summary

- Hidden — The bird's eye and the lion's strength are nature's best. Sight and force at their peak still miss this path.

- Higher — Man digs down and finds silver and gold, but not wisdom. Wisdom is not in the earth at all. It comes down from heaven.

- Him — Commentators read this path as the Lord's own lonely road through this world. It ends in a sphere beyond the vulture's eye.

- Ours — This same path passes through sorrow, yet it leads into the presence of the LORD, where there is fulness of joy.

- How — No broad lines mark it out, so only the spiritual eye sees it. The chapter's answer is the fear of the Lord and turning from evil.

Job 28:8

The proud beasts have not trodden it, nor the fierce lion passed over it.

Job is describing a miner. He sinks a shaft, breaks into the rock and brings up gold and gems from places no animal has reached. Verse 8 measures that feat by what it leaves behind: the boldest beasts on earth have never walked there.

The path under the rock

Verse 8 belongs to a short section about what lies hidden under the ground.

In this section Job speaks of things more hidden from people normally, but which God brings to light (v.11). There is a path that no bird knows, though it can fly high above earth to observe what is below. No falcon's eye (which is amazingly keen) discerns it (v.7). The proud or fierce lion cannot force his way into it by his superior strength (v.8).

Leslie M. Grant

Why the picture is here at all

Commentators differ over whether verses 7-11 still describe mining or already reach past it. Ridout points to Job's repeated wording in verse 21.

Delitzsch connects this portion (verses 7-11) closely with what goes before, as describing the search after earth's precious stores. Part of it does go into further details. But the similarity of verse 21 to verses 7 and 8 suggests that even this early in the chapter Job is hinting at his main theme — the true riches. Verse 12 confirms this thought.

Samuel Ridout

Everything found except the one thing needed

Man goes where no lion can follow, and still comes up empty.

Job 28 holds remarkable words about man's search after wisdom. In Job's day people mined for iron or copper, for gold or silver or gems, and it may have been a new pursuit then. They dig down, they divert the underground stream, they make paths untrodden by the strongest of beasts or the most keen-sighted of birds. But in all this searching they never find wisdom.

F. B. Hole

Kelly weighs what all that effort actually gains.

"But where shall wisdom be found?" No, there is no wisdom in all that. There is self in all that. There is what will make a man rich; there is what will bring money and perhaps distinction; but where shall wisdom be found? and where is the place of understanding?

William Kelly

Two things nature is famous for, both useless here

Verse 7 names a bird, verse 8 a lion. Each is nature at its peak. (Where the ESV has "falcon," older translations read "vulture.")

In the path of God's will mere human wisdom and understanding will not help. It is a path no bird knows and no lion has trodden (Job 28:7-8). No eye in nature is as keen as the vulture's; no animal is as bold as the lion. But the boldness and long sight of nature are not equal to the path of faith. Only singleness of eye, with Christ as its one Object, will give spiritual understanding.

Hamilton Smith

Ridout reads the lion's desert as land that gives the soul nothing:

The wide deserts, where the proud lion roams with no fear of man, hold no treasure that the heart craves. The hermits, the "desert dwellers," have failed to get peace for their souls by their fasting and punishing of the body.

Samuel Ridout

Where the path finally turns up

If the search downward fails, the chapter looks up. The One who knows the way is not only the Maker of the world but the One who shows Himself in His Son.

We turn now from nature to its Author, from creation to God. He knows the way, and He alone can reveal it to man. And it is not merely God as Creator, but as Revealer in the person of His Son — "I am the way, and the truth, and the life." … He has seen wisdom; no, He is that Wisdom.

Samuel Ridout

A path meant to be walked

The path is not locked shut. The chapter's closing answer brings it within reach.

It cannot be that we are forced to live in error, in darkness, or in uncertainty. "There is a path," blessed be God, though "no bird of prey knows it … the proud beasts have not trodden it." Where is this safe and blessed path? Hear the divine reply: "Behold, the fear of the Lord, that is wisdom, and to turn away from evil is understanding." (Job 28)

C. H. Mackintosh

Summary

- Hidden — The verse names a path no sharp-eyed bird has seen and no strong beast has walked.

- Hinted — The same wording returns later in the chapter. Job is pointing past buried ore to the true riches.

- Hollow — Men dig where no animal can follow and bring up gold; wisdom is the one thing the digging never turns up.

- Helpless — Keen sight and bold strength, the best nature offers, are not equal to the path of faith.

- Held out — God alone knows the way, and shows it in His Son; He holds the path out to anyone who fears the Lord and turns from evil.

Job 28:9

[Man] putteth forth his hand upon the flinty rock, he overturneth the mountains by the root.

Job pictures human achievement: men digging deep into the earth for treasure. Verse 9 shows that effort at its peak, and it sets up the question the whole chapter asks — where is wisdom found?

What the verse pictures

One commentator pictures the miner at work in the rocks:

Job returns to the search for treasure. He describes a fruitless quest, in which man takes hold of the rocks (possibly pebbles) and overturns the mountains. We see him washing and sifting the pebbles and sand, or blasting into the solid mountains. He cuts his way deep down, following the vein like a river in its course. He looks with greedy eyes at the rich shining treasures locked up in it.

Samuel Ridout

Skill is not wisdom

The chapter does not belittle human skill. It measures it, and finds that skill and wisdom are not the same thing:

This is a very remarkable chapter. It follows man's skill doing all sorts of things — metallurgy, engineering, damming the floods, and bringing hidden things out of the earth. Skill that is unlimited in a certain sense, in what is subject to him — but this is not wisdom.

J. N. Darby

What drives the hand on the rock

A man who can overturn a mountain learns to tell treasure from rubbish. But what is he after?

They gain a keen understanding of what things are worth — though by no means are they always right... but as a rule they learn what is valuable. "But where shall wisdom be found?" No, there is no wisdom in all that. There is self in all that. There is what will make a man rich; there is what will bring money and perhaps distinction. But where shall wisdom be found?

William Kelly

Energy pointed the wrong way

Men will move mountains when they want something enough. The same is not true of their search for wisdom:

Again we ask, why will men not labour like this for the "hidden wisdom"? Why will they not seek to sift it out as it lies so close by, or, if need be, in faith remove the very mountains of difficulty? The course of this world sweeps along like a river. If it would swallow up the true riches, why do men not stop it, or turn it away from them, so that they may take hold of this thing whose value is above all wealth?

Samuel Ridout

The same verdict on every later age

Centuries of digging and discovery since Job have not changed the outcome:

They dig down. They divert the underground stream. They make paths untrodden by the strongest beasts or the sharpest-eyed birds. But in all this searching they never find wisdom... Men may discover much. Since Job's day they have discovered an immense amount more. But wisdom eludes them. If Job could see man's activities and discoveries in our atomic age, he would say the same, only with emphasis a hundredfold greater.

F. B. Hole

Where wisdom is found

If wisdom is not in the ore or the overturned mountain, it must come from somewhere else:

What a very solemn thing that is! True wisdom and true understanding are not found in the earth at all. It comes down from heaven. It is found only in Christ.

William Kelly

The chapter ends with an answer that changes how a person sees everything:

The depths of the earth will not reveal it, and its value far exceeds that of gold and rubies. God alone can declare its true nature and value: "And He said to man, 'Behold, the fear of the Lord, that is wisdom, and to turn away from evil is understanding.'" ... So until God has His rightful place in a man's mind and heart, he cannot view anything wisely. His thoughts are off centre. His beginning is all wrong.

W. W. Fereday

Summary

- Skill — Human power at full stretch: a hand on flint, mountains uprooted, veins traced deep underground. The chapter does not deny the achievement.

- Limit — That skill is "unlimited in a certain sense, in what is subject to him" — and still it is not wisdom. Capability and wisdom are different currencies.

- Motive — Behind the moved mountain is self: what will make a man rich, what will bring money and distinction. The trained eye learns what is valuable and misses the one thing worth most.

- Misdirection — Men will remove mountains for gold but not for wisdom, though wisdom "lies so close by." The problem is not lack of energy but aim.

- Source — Wisdom is not in the earth at all; it comes down from heaven and is found in Christ. It starts where the mining stops: the fear of the Lord, and turning from evil.

Job 28:10

He cutteth out channels in the rocks, and his eye seeth every precious thing.

Job has been describing the mines of his day: deep shafts, ropes swinging in the dark, ore torn out of the rock. Verse 10 is the peak of that skill, and it leads straight to a question no miner can answer.

Man's power over the rock

Nothing in the rock is hard enough to stop the search. One commentator also names what drives it.

Man's daring resources, with greed behind them, conquer every difficulty. The hard flint gives way to his hand. He overturns mountains by the root if they stand in his way, and he cuts rivers through the rocks, to reach the precious things his eye picks out.

William Kelly

Following the vein, turning the water

The verse describes a method, not just brute strength.

He cuts his way deep down, following the vein the way a river follows its course, and looking with greedy eyes at the rich shining treasures locked up inside. If water flows in, he finds a way to divert it, so that he can go after the hidden wealth he has uncovered.

Samuel Ridout

The trained eye that still misjudges

The verse credits the miner with an eye that "sees every precious thing" — a real skill. But even here the expert gets it wrong.

They develop a very sensitive sense of what a thing is worth — though they are by no means always right. Sometimes miners in our country have thrown away as rubbish something just as valuable as the thing they were after. But as a rule they do learn what is valuable.

William Kelly

Whose hand does the cutting

Commentators differ over who does the cutting. Most take it to be man. One reads verses 9 to 11 as God at work, and makes the timing of every discovery His.

God's hand does what creatures cannot. He overturns mountains at the roots, to expose what lies hidden beneath (v.9). Through the hard rocks He cuts out channels, using water to wear the rock away. And in those rocks "He sees every precious thing" — which man would not discover until God saw fit to uncover it (v.10).

Leslie M. Grant

The one thing the shaft never reaches

Right after this display of skill, Job asks where wisdom is. No amount of digging turns it up, and the centuries since have not changed that.

They dig down, they divert the underground stream, they make paths where the strongest beast and the sharpest-eyed bird have never walked. But in all this searching they never find wisdom. This is the question he raised in verse 12, and he was right to say that these human activities could not find it. Men may discover much, and since Job's day they have discovered a great deal more, but wisdom still escapes them.

F. B. Hole

One commentator names what the digging does produce, and what it never touches.

No, there is no wisdom in any of that. There is self in all of it. There is what will make a man rich; there is what will bring money and maybe status; but "Where shall wisdom be found? And where is the place of understanding?"

William Kelly

The energy turned the right way

Put the effort men spend on ore beside the effort they spend on God, and the verse turns into a rebuke.

Again we ask: why will men not work this hard for the "hidden wisdom"? Why will they not sift it out, when it lies so close at hand — or, if they must, remove by faith the very mountains of difficulty? If the sweeping rush of "the course of this world" would swallow the true riches like a river, why do men not stop it, or turn it aside, so that they may have for themselves what is worth more than all wealth? "The one who seeks finds" is still true, though this seeking and this finding are nothing like the hard work of digging for gold. The wisdom stays hidden and the way to it stays unknown, because men do not know God and will not listen to Him.

Samuel Ridout

Summary

- Skill — Human power at its peak: flint gives way, mountains come up by the roots, water turns aside, and a trained eye picks out the treasure.

- Motive — Behind that skill lies greed. The energy is real, but so is the self in it.

- Limit — The same eye that spots every precious stone has thrown away as rubbish what was worth as much as the prize.

- Question — Right after this triumph the chapter asks, "Where shall wisdom be found?" Centuries of discovery since have brought no answer.

- Redirection — Aim that same energy at God: remove the mountains of difficulty, turn back the rush of the world's course, and seek what is worth more than all wealth.

Job 28:11

He bindeth the streams that they drip not, and what is hidden he bringeth forth to light.

The mining picture in Job 28 ends here. Water floods the shaft, so the miner shuts it off and lifts out what the earth had buried. Then comes the question that gives this line its weight: a man who can do all this still has to ask where wisdom is.

The Miner's Last Obstacle

Before this verse, the miner has sunk his shaft and followed the vein. When underground water threatens the work, he moves it out of his way.

Coming back to the search for treasure, Job describes this fruitless hunt, in which man lays hold of the rocks and overturns the mountains… He cuts his way deep down, following the vein like a river in its course, and looking with greedy eyes at the rich shining treasures locked up inside. If water flows in, he finds a way to divert it, so that he can go after the hidden wealth he has now uncovered.

Samuel Ridout

Who Dams the Streams?

Commentators differ on who is acting in verses 9–11. Most take it as the miner. One reads the subject as God, whose dams block the digger instead of helping him.

But God's hand does what creatures cannot. It even overturns mountains at the roots, to uncover what lies hidden beneath (v.9). In the rocks "He sees every precious thing," which man would not discover until God saw fit to expose it (v.10). On streams where man may expect to find treasure, He places dams that thwart men's intentions. But in the end, even what is hidden God brings forth (v.11).

Leslie M. Grant

Real Skill, Wrong Prize

Whoever drains the water, the success is real. That is what makes the next question so sharp.

"He dams up the streams so that they do not trickle, and the thing that is hidden he brings out to light. But where shall wisdom be found?" No, there is no wisdom in all that. There is self in all that. There is what will make a man rich; there is what will bring money and perhaps distinction; but where shall wisdom be found? and where is the place of understanding? Well, it is not on the earth.

William Kelly

The Effort Nobody Spends

The verse describes enormous trouble taken for metal. Ridout turns that energy into a question about the better treasure.

Again we ask: why will men not work this hard for the "hidden wisdom"? Why will they not sift it out where it lies so close by, or, if need be, remove by faith the very mountains of difficulty? If "the course of this world" would sweep over the true riches like a river, why do men not stop it, or turn it away from them, so that they can have what is worth more than all wealth? "The one who seeks finds" is still true. But the seeking and the finding are not what the toil for gold would suggest.

Samuel Ridout

Capacity Is Not the Problem

The mind that drains a flooded mine is a remarkable thing. Its failure to find God is therefore not a failure of ability.

"He can cut out channels among the rocks, and his eyes see every precious thing. He can dam up the streams, and bring what is hidden out to light" (Job 28). But he has lost the knowledge of God through sin, and lost all desire for that knowledge. "No one understands; no one seeks for God." The guilt is not in the capacity, but in the will. "People loved the darkness rather than the light because their works were evil."

The Bible Treasury

Where It Is Found

If wisdom is not under the ground, it has to come from somewhere else.

True wisdom and true understanding are not found in the earth at all! It comes down from heaven. It is found only in Christ… There was a report of that One who is Himself wisdom, and who is the Giver of wisdom to the meek. It was by death that it came to us.

William Kelly

Summary

- Dig: the miner shuts off the underground water and lifts buried wealth into daylight. It is the peak of human skill in the chapter.

- Differ: commentators split on who acts. Most see the miner. One sees God, uncovering what no creature could reach.

- Fall short: the digging succeeds and still misses the prize — "there is no wisdom in all that. There is self in all that."

- Will, not skill: the same mind that masters rock and flood has lost the desire for God; "the guilt is not in the capacity, but in the will."

- Descend: wisdom is never dug up; it comes down from heaven, and is found in Christ.