Surely there is a vein for the silver, and a place for gold which they refine;
Job breaks off his argument with his friends and pictures men sinking shafts deep into the earth for silver and gold. The scene admires human skill, yet it opens a chapter with a question that skill cannot answer: where is wisdom found?
Commentators note how abruptly this chapter arrives, and where Job's eye now rests.
William KellyNow in the next chapter (Job 28) we have a very remarkable addition — one of the most striking in the book of Job. It seems very abrupt. He now turns away from man altogether in his bad ways, and from defending those who really looked to God. He looks at the general state of mankind. Not any particularly evil class or righteous class.
The link with the chapter before is the subject of riches.
Samuel RidoutJob speaks on. He now contrasts the doom of the ungodly rich, described in the chapter before, with the true riches, which can never be lost... The opening part of the chapter describes the toil and care with which men search for the "delved gold"... This chapter would prove that Job could not be the hypocrite his friends would make him out to be.
The two halves of the line do not say the same thing twice. (Kelly quotes an older translation, which reads "vein for the silver," and "brass" where newer ones read "copper.")
William Kelly"Surely there is a vein for the silver and a place for gold where they find it." Men do not find gold in veins as they find silver. Gold comes in quite a different way — often as dust, and sometimes as nuggets. But silver runs in large and rich veins. "Iron is taken out of the earth, and brass is molten out of the stone." That is exactly where men find copper. Where we read "brass" it is very often "copper" — chiefly so in the Bible.
What follows in the chapter reads like a report from inside a working mine, and the speaker clearly knows the trade.
Arno Clemens GaebeleinHe speaks first of the treasures of the earth, the riches which man seeks after, but which do not last, and are so often man's undoing. Job shows that he had a good knowledge of mining operations. He knows of veins of silver and how gold is refined... Then he describes how the miner with his mining lamp makes an end to the darkness when he digs into the mountains and then he sinks a shaft... All this man does, risking life and comfort, to get gold and the treasures of the earth.
What men will spend on this search says something about the heart.
Samuel RidoutIt is wealth, gold, jewels, glory, that man seeks after, and for which he is ready to barter his very life and soul... Of course, this does not mean that these precious things are sinful in themselves. Nor does it deny that we need their proper use. But the restless craving for them shows the poverty of man's heart, seeking what can never satisfy.
Samuel RidoutThere is a mine for silver, the "current money with the merchant." How much labour goes into that shining white metal! In the East people use it widely as money. Sadly, of what it pictures — the redemption-price for the soul of man (Ex. 30:11-16; Ex. 38:25-28) — men know little and care less... Men also refine gold in the fire and make it into beautiful ornaments and the king's crown. They will travel to the ends of the earth for it. Most treat the true gold — the righteousness of God in Christ — as worthless.
The verse begins a list of what man can do. What does all that skill gain him?
William Kelly"He binds the floods from overflowing; and the thing that is hidden he brings forth to light. But where shall wisdom be found?" No, there is no wisdom in all that. There is self in all that. There is what will make a man rich. There is what will bring money and perhaps standing. But where shall wisdom be found?
Time has only widened the gap between what people can find and what they still lack.
F. B. HoleMen may discover much. Since Job's day they have discovered vastly more. But wisdom still escapes them. Suppose Job could have seen what men do and discover in our atomic age. He would say the same, only a hundred times more strongly.
- Turn — Job stops arguing about particular men and looks at mankind as a whole. He sets the lost wealth of the ungodly against riches that cannot be lost.
- Detail — The verse is exact. Silver runs in rich veins; gold comes as dust and nuggets. The "brass" of the next line is often copper.
- Cost — Men will trade life itself for these treasures. The craving, not the metal, exposes a heart chasing what can never satisfy.
- Picture — Silver pictures the redemption-price for the soul. Gold pictures the righteousness of God in Christ. Men value both least.
- Failure — Every shaft sunk still leaves the chapter's question open. Modern discovery has only widened the gap.
Iron is taken out of the dust, and copper is molten out of the stone.
Job pauses his long speech to describe men digging metal out of the ground. He builds a picture of human skill, then asks the one question skill cannot answer: where is wisdom found?
The ESV says copper; older translations say "brass." One commentator explains the difference, and says the verse names exactly where copper is found:
William Kelly"Iron is taken out of the earth, and brass is molten out of the stone." That is just exactly where copper is found. Where we read "brass" it is very often "copper" — and that is mostly the case in the Bible. He now gives us a remarkable sketch of mining in very early times.
Job writes like a man who has watched the work done, and who knows what it costs:
Arno Clemens GaebeleinHe speaks first of the treasures of the earth — the riches man goes after. They do not last, and they are so often man's undoing. Job shows that he had a good knowledge of mining operations. He knows of veins of silver and how gold is refined. Iron is taken out of the earth and copper molten out of stone. Then he describes the miner with his lamp. He puts an end to the darkness as he digs into the mountains and sinks a shaft. He also mentions the dangers of mining — "they hang (suspended by ropes) far from men, they swing to and fro." All this man does, risking life and comfort, to get gold and the treasures of the earth.
Some writers read these metals as pictures, and they differ in what they draw out. One sees God's own hand in placing them where men can find them:
Leslie M. GrantGod has seen fit to put these metals in places where men can find them without difficulty, and men certainly make much use of them. Yet they know little of the spiritual truths these metals stand for. Gold speaks of the glory of God. Silver speaks of the redemption that is in Christ Jesus. Iron speaks of the strength of the kingdom of God. Copper speaks of the holiness of God.
Another writer sets what men will work for against what they ignore:
Samuel RidoutIron, needed in every kind of work, takes hard labour to draw out of the dust of the earth. Man labours for these earthly necessities, but forgets Him in whom alone is strength. Brass, or copper, with its unyielding strength, was and still is melted out of the stone that holds it. But men place little value on the unchanging judgments of God.
Human skill is real and wide-ranging. It still falls short of what Job is looking for:
J. N. DarbyThis is a very remarkable chapter. It follows man's skill as he does all sorts of things — metalwork, engineering, holding back the floods, and bringing hidden things out of the earth. His skill is unlimited, in a way, over what is under his control — but this is not wisdom... God arranged all these things. So far as creation goes — that is, where man lives — He had wisdom about the things that occupy man. But He put man in relationship with Himself, that is more. Truly recognising this, and the exercise of conscience that follows — that is wisdom for man.
Time has only widened the gap:
F. B. HoleMen may discover much, and since Job's day they have discovered far more, but wisdom still eludes them. If Job could see what men do and discover in our atomic age, he would say the same, only a hundred times more strongly.
One writer names what drives all this daring:
William KellyMan's daring resources, with covetousness behind, conquer all difficulties. The hard flint gives way to his hand. He overturns mountains by the root if they stand in his way, and cuts rivers through the rocks, to reach the precious things his eye sees.
- Dug. Job describes real mining — iron from the ground, copper melted out of stone — like a man who knew the shafts, the lamps and the ropes.
- Driven. The skill is genuine, but a covetous heart lies behind it; men overturn mountains to reach what their eye values.
- Deeper. The metals men handle every day carry meanings they miss. Writers see glory, redemption, strength and holiness in ore that men value only by weight.
- Deficient. Skill over everything under man's hand is still not wisdom. Every advance since Job's day only sharpens the point.
- Dependent. God put man in relationship with Himself. Recognising that, and letting conscience act on it, is wisdom no mine can yield.
[Man] putteth an end to the darkness, and exploreth to the utmost limit, the stones of darkness and of the shadow of death.
Job pauses his argument to describe something men do well. They go down into the dark places of the earth and drag out its treasure. The picture admires their skill. But it sets up the question of the chapter: if men can conquer the darkness underground, why can they not find wisdom?
The verse sits inside a description of early mining. One commentator walks through what the miners were after and how they reached it.
William KellyGold is not found in veins like silver. It is found in quite a different way — very often in the form of dust, and sometimes of nuggets. But silver lies in large and rich veins... "He sets an end to darkness." He now gives us a remarkable sketch of mining in very early times. "He sets an end to darkness, and searches out all perfection" — searching for these precious metals, gold, silver or the like — "the stones of darkness, and the shadow of death." That is, he goes down to the depths of the earth after them.
These writers quote an older English translation, which has "searches out all perfection" where the ESV has "searches out to the farthest limit." One of them explains the phrase. He also names what the search costs the man who makes it.
Samuel RidoutIn his search after these treasures, man digs into the dark hollows of the earth with his lamp. He makes an end to the darkness as he goes into the farthest extremities (rather than "perfection") of the mines. He is searching for those ore-laden "stones of darkness" — stones hidden in the darkness. The depths of the earth are like the shadow of death, and often bury the tough miner in them, but nothing holds him back. Men will give their lives for gold.
Something has to be strong enough to send a man into a pit that could become his grave. One commentator names what lies behind the daring.
William KellyHe knows how to make his way despite the darkness, overcoming it with artificial light, no matter what the danger — a danger learnt every now and then at the cost of a life... Man's daring resources, with covetousness behind, conquer all difficulties. The hard flint gives way to his hand, and he overturns mountains by the root if they stand in his way.
Job's point is not that mining is wrong. It is that all this digging never turns up the one thing worth having. Later discovery has not changed that.
F. B. HoleThey dig down. They divert the underground stream. They make paths where the strongest beasts and the sharpest-eyed birds have never been. But in all this searching they never find wisdom... Men may discover much. Since Job's day they have discovered an immense deal more. But wisdom eludes them.
The same commentator asks what all this effort actually produces.
William Kelly"He holds back the floods from overflowing, and brings what is hidden out into the light. But where shall wisdom be found?" No, there is no wisdom in all that. There is self in all that. There is what will make a man rich. There is what will bring money and perhaps standing. But where shall wisdom be found?
If wisdom is not in the deepest shaft, it must have another source.
William KellyWhat a very solemn thing that is! True wisdom and true understanding not found in the earth at all! It comes down from heaven. It is found only in Christ — and Christ had not yet come. This came out even more clearly in Christ's rejection and death.
The chapter ends with God's own answer to the question.
Leslie M. Grant"To man He said, Behold, the fear of the Lord, that is wisdom, and to depart from evil is understanding" (v.28). The only reason that wisdom eludes people is this: "there is no fear of God before their eyes." So they have no heart to depart from evil. The fear of the Lord is not terror, but a wholesome reverence that gives Him the place of supreme honour.
- Lamp — "An end to darkness" is a miner carrying light into the deepest shaft. He hunts "stones of darkness" hidden in the gloom.
- Cost — The depths are like the shadow of death, and they often bury the miner. Nothing holds him back. Men will give their lives for gold.
- Motive — Behind the daring is covetousness. There is self in all of it — what makes a man rich, what brings money and standing.
- Limit — Every barrier gives way except one. Men discover an immense deal, and wisdom still eludes them.
- Answer — Wisdom is not in the earth at all. It comes down from heaven, and God names it: the fear of the Lord, and turning from evil.
He openeth a shaft far from the inhabitants [of the earth] forgotten of the foot, they hang suspended; away below men they hover.
Job 28:4 sits inside a picture of mining. Miners cut shafts in lonely places and go down into the dark, all for metal and gems buried underground. The skill is real. The question Job is heading toward is one that skill cannot answer.
Job writes here like a man who knows the mining trade.
Arno Clemens GaebeleinJob shows that he had a good knowledge of mining operations. He knows of veins of silver and how men refine gold. Men take iron out of the earth and melt copper out of stone. Then he describes the miner with his lamp. The miner makes an end to the darkness as he digs into the mountains, and then he sinks a shaft. They are so far down that the foot passing above knows nothing of where they are. He mentions the dangers of mining too: "they hang (suspended by ropes) far from men, they swing to and fro." Man does all this, risking life and comfort, to get gold and the treasures of the earth.
Another writer reads the same details the same way: the shaft is opened where nobody lives, and rope is the only way in.
Leslie M. GrantHe sinks a shaft into the earth in places away from civilisation (v.4), let themselves down by ropes, and swing to and fro with the object of finding the metal they desire.
Commentators differ over what the verse describes. Working from an older English translation, one writer reads it as underground water, not as men hanging on ropes. He explains why water matters so much in a mine.
William Kelly"The flood breaks out from the inhabitant" — water there is very dangerous. So the great point is to get rid of it safely. They drain it or turn it aside so that they may work their mine. "Even the waters forgotten of the foot." That is, waters that people do not walk beside — not rivers and streams, but water deep in the earth. "They are dried up; they are gone away from men." That is the drainage, done to carry the work on.
One writer names the motive behind all the skill.
William KellyHe knows how to pursue his way despite the darkness, which he overcomes with artificial light. He goes on no matter what the danger — a danger learnt every now and then at the cost of life. We see the shaft formed far away from human dwelling. We see the means used to carry men where none could walk, suspended by ropes, it would seem, and swinging to and fro… Man's daring resources, with covetousness behind, conquer all difficulties.
Another writer sets this against what the surface of the earth already gives.
Samuel RidoutMen will give their lives for gold. They are not content with the fertile earth that yields food for man's need… What man seeks after is wealth, gold, jewels, glory. For these he is ready to trade his very life and soul… The typical and spiritual teaching here is very clear: "But if we have food and clothing, with these we will be content." Of course this does not mean that these precious things are sinful in themselves, or that their proper use is unnecessary. But the restless craving for them shows the poor heart of man, seeking what can never satisfy.
(The words quoted inside are 1 Timothy 6:8, given here in the ESV.)
All this reach ends at a wall.
F. B. HoleThey dig down, they divert the underground stream, they make paths untrodden by the strongest of beasts or the most keen-sighted of birds. But in all this searching they never find wisdom… Men may discover much. Since Job's day they have discovered a great deal more. But wisdom eludes them.
One writer turns the miner's persistence into a question.
Samuel RidoutAgain we ask: why will men not work like this for the "hidden wisdom"? Why will they not sift it out as it lies so close by, or, if need be, remove in faith the very mountains of difficulty… "The one who seeks finds" is still true. But the seeking and the finding are different from what the toil for gold would suggest. The wisdom is hidden, the way to it is not known, because God is not known, and men will not listen to Him.
Where, then, does the chapter land? The answer does not come from the mine.
William KellyMan knows nothing of wisdom; but it is not here… It is not in this world. It is not in man as he is. Eagerness after present objects only shuts it out… The answer comes at last from God Himself: "The fear of the Lord, that is wisdom, and to turn away from evil is understanding."
- Dig — The verse pictures a shaft cut far from any settlement. Men hang on ropes in the dark, far below any foot that passes above.
- Danger — Men pay for this with their lives. The skill is real, and so is the covetousness behind it.
- Depth — Man reaches where no bird flies and no lion treads, and still comes up empty of wisdom.
- Disagreement — Commentators differ on the wording. Some read men hanging by ropes. Others read underground water, drained off so the mine can be worked.
- Direction — Turn that same tireless search toward God, and it finds what the mine never held. The fear of the Lord is wisdom, and turning from evil is understanding.
As for the earth, out of it cometh bread, and underneath it is turned up as by fire;
Job pauses his argument with his friends to describe something everyone can see: people dig. Verse 5 sets ground that gives us food beside the same ground ripped open far below — and the chapter will ask what all that digging never finds.
The verse contrasts the surface of the ground with what lies far below it. One commentator reads "underneath it" as pointing deep down into the earth. He takes the passage as a picture of mining, and notes that even sharp-eyed birds never go where the miner goes:
William Kelly"As for the earth, out of it comes bread, but underneath it" — that is deep down in it — "is turned up as by fire. The stones of it are the place of sapphires" — precious stones as well as these metals — "and it has dust of gold." The birds do not enter into these depths. They go up into the heights, and they cross the whole surface of the earth. But they do not venture into the mines where man goes down. Not even the vulture.
Commentators differ on what the fire pictures. A second reading ties it to how the treasure below ground came to be:
Leslie M. GrantThe earth itself produces bread, that is, grain, though deeper down the earth is turned up as by fire (v.5). "Its stones are the source of sapphires" (v.6). Stones by intense heat produce precious stones, and gold dust is found where heat has been. Job suggests that man knows these things and takes advantage of them.
The two halves of the verse are also a moral contrast. God gives food on the surface; man rips open what is underneath. One writer takes the fire as the violence of the search itself:
Samuel RidoutMen will give their lives for gold. They are not content with the fertile earth yielding food for man's need; they tear it and search its depths as a fire burning and destroying. Such seems to be the clear meaning of verse 5. It is wealth, gold, jewels, glory, that man seeks after, and for which he is ready to barter his very life and soul. Look at the history of the mining camps of modern times, and it confirms all that Job says. What greed, lust and violence rule in these places… What a contrast to the peaceful work of gathering the rich harvests God has provided on the very surface of the earth. The lesson pictured here is very clear: "Having food and clothing, with these we will be content." Of course this does not mean that these precious things are sinful in themselves, or that their proper use is unnecessary. But the restless craving for them is a sign of the poor heart of man, looking for what can never satisfy.
Note the balance there: the metals and jewels are not condemned. It is the craving that is being weighed.
Verse 5 is not a stray observation. It belongs to the chapter's opening block, and the whole chapter moves from what man can dig up to what only God can reveal:
Samuel RidoutThe chapter may be divided into seven portions. (1) The treasures of earth (vv. 1-6). (2) The hidden treasure (vv. 7-11). (3) Not revealed by nature (vv. 12-14). (4) Its priceless value tested (vv. 15-19). (5) Its report (vv. 20-22). (6) The Revealer (vv. 23-27). (7) The Revelation (v. 28).
One writer links the bread that comes out of the earth to the day Jesus fed a crowd. Jesus did not call down bread from heaven. He began with what the ground had already grown:
The Bible TreasuryThe Lord then called on the disciples to gather their resources. He said to them, "How many loaves do you have?" He was about to show before their eyes His own saying, "To the one who has, more will be given." They answer, Seven. And these loaves the Lord took as the beginning of the food-supply for the people. He did not as of old call down bread out of heaven, but He made use of what came out of the earth (Job 28:5). To this fruit of human toil, already multiplied from the bare grain, He gave a further increase.
All this skill and daring proves the point Job is driving at. Man reaches places no animal reaches — and still comes up empty on the one thing that matters:
F. B. HoleThey dig down, they divert the underground stream, they make paths untrodden by the strongest of beasts or the most keen-sighted of birds. But in all this searching they never find wisdom. He raised this question in verse 12, and he was right that these human activities could not find it. Men may discover much, and since Job's day they have discovered a great deal more, but wisdom eludes them.
- Above. The surface of the earth gives bread — food God provides without a shaft or a rope.
- Below. Deeper down, the ground is turned up as by fire. Commentators differ on what that fire pictures: the heat that formed the gems, or the tearing violence of the search.
- Beyond. Man cuts paths that the strongest beasts and the sharpest-eyed birds never take — not even the vulture.
- Bread, not gold. The restless craving, not the metal itself, is what exposes a heart looking for what cannot satisfy — "having food and clothing, with these we will be content."
- But not wisdom. Every new shaft answers the chapter's question the same way. With all man uncovers, wisdom is never among the finds.
The stones of it are the place of sapphires, and it hath dust of gold.
Job breaks off his long argument with his friends. He turns to the wealth buried in the earth: stones that hold sapphires, and dust of gold. The picture is exact, and it is going somewhere. By verse 12 he asks where to find wisdom, and whether any mine can yield it.
Verse 6 says the earth holds dust of gold. That wording is precise: gold turns up in a different form from silver.
William KellyMen do not find gold in veins like silver. They find it in quite a different way — very often in the form of dust, and sometimes of nuggets. But silver they find in large and rich veins.
Verse 6 adds precious stones to the metals. The same writer moves from that straight to the question the search cannot answer.
William Kelly"Its stones are the place of sapphires" — precious stones as well as these metals — "and it has dust of gold." … "But where shall wisdom be found?" No, there is no wisdom in all that. There is self in all that. Here is what will make a man rich. Here is what will bring money and perhaps distinction. But where shall wisdom be found?
Readers have puzzled over how this chapter connects to the one before it. One commentator answers that what looks like an extreme case is the common story of the human race.
William KellyThis might look like an extreme case. But in truth it is the all too common experience of the human race. Men chase an empty show. They are eager for every other object under the sun — yes, deep inside the earth and in the depths of the sea. And they overlook the wisdom that consists in the fear of the Lord and can never be separated from it, and the understanding that turns away from evil.
Others see the connection as a straight contrast between two kinds of wealth, and read verses 1-6 as the first of seven movements in the chapter.
Samuel RidoutJob next contrasts the doom of the ungodly rich, as described in the previous chapter, with the true riches, which can never be lost. … The opening part of the chapter describes the toil and care with which men search for the "delved gold," which so often brings but the "strife and curse which fall over it." He then passes on to the true riches — wisdom; where shall it be found?
The search has a price. One commentator counts what men pay for it.
Samuel RidoutMen will give their lives for gold. The fertile earth yields food for man's need, but that does not content them. They tear it open and search its depths like a fire burning and destroying. … Man seeks after wealth, gold, jewels and glory, and he is ready to barter his very life and soul for them. … The lesson pictured here is very clear: "If we have food and clothing, with these we will be content." Of course this does not mean that these precious things are sinful in themselves, or that their proper use is unnecessary. But the restless craving for them points to the poor heart of man, seeking what can never satisfy. If only he had used the same earnestness in seeking the true riches, how different the result would be.
One writer sums up the whole mining passage, and adds what the years since have shown.
F. B. HoleThey dig down. They divert the underground stream. They cut paths that the strongest beasts and the sharpest-eyed birds have never walked. But in all this searching they never find wisdom. This is the question he raised in verse 12, and he was quite right that no one finds it in these human activities. Men may discover much. Since Job's day they have discovered far more. But wisdom still eludes them. If Job could see man's activities and discoveries in our atomic age, he would say the same, only a hundred times more strongly.
Miners learn to judge what is worth having. One commentator adds that they still get it wrong.
William KellyThey gain a keen sense of what is worth something — though by no means are they always right. Sometimes the miners in our country have thrown away as rubbish what was just as valuable as all that their mind was set upon. But as a general rule they learn what is valuable.
Read as a picture, the gold of verse 6 points past itself.
Samuel RidoutMen will travel to the ends of the earth for gold — gold refined in the fire and made into beautiful ornaments and the king's crown. But most people treat the true gold, the righteousness of God in Christ, as worthless.
- Dig. Verse 6 names the earth's hidden wealth: stones that hold sapphires, and dust of gold. Gold comes as dust and nuggets, not in veins like silver.
- Find. Man's skill works. He digs down, turns the underground water aside, and cuts paths where no bird or beast has gone.
- Pay. The price shows the heart. Men barter life and soul for what can never satisfy, while the surface of the earth yields bread.
- Fail. Every discovery leaves the question of verse 12 unanswered. There is self in all of it, but no wisdom.
- Miss. The one gold worth having is the righteousness of God in Christ, and most people pass it by as worthless.