Be it far from me that I should justify you; till I die I will not remove my blamelessness from me.
Job's friends have been charging him with serious wrong, and he answers with something close to an oath: he will keep his integrity until he dies. Is this the courage of an honest man, or the self-defence of a man who has not yet seen himself as God sees him?
Job turns the charge back on the men who made it, and he says it with the force of an oath.
William KellyHe still holds to it that all their imagination was false. He said now more solemnly than ever — it was like taking an oath — as God lives, this is true. "God forbid that I should justify you." Now he turns on them; he says, "You are the culprits, not I." "Till I die I will not remove my integrity from me. My righteousness I hold fast, and will not let it go; my heart shall not reproach me so long as I live." They were, on the contrary, charging him with what was very bad in most of their speeches.
The ESV reads, "Far be it from me to say that you are right." Older translations read "justify you," and the commentators work from that older word. One writer sets Job's use of it beside God's own use.
The Bible TreasuryThe word translated "justify" occurs in that precise form of the verb only in Exodus 23:7: "I will not acquit the wicked"; that is, God will not make or declare a wicked man a just man. Again, "God forbid that I should justify you" (Job 27:5); that is, acknowledge you to be just in what you have spoken.
Older translations read "I will not justify the wicked" in Exodus 23:7 — the same word again. So Job is not claiming sinlessness here. He is refusing to sign off on his friends' reading of his life.
Job will not confess to a wrong he did not do. One writer sets his stand beside Paul, who also kept a good conscience.
W. H. WestcottWhatever the three friends allege, he will not admit a false charge (v. 5). Despite their harsh judgment, he is determined to pursue the integrity of all his former life to the day of his death. In this setting he says, "My righteousness I hold fast, and will not let it go." That is, nothing could turn him to turn from what he knew to be right. He therefore adds, "My heart shall not reproach me so long as I live." He was for keeping a good conscience all his days, like Paul later.
God Himself calls Job blameless and says he holds fast his integrity — the very thing Job clings to here. He also defends His servant against every accuser.
An Outline of Sound WordsHe points out their failures faithfully. He records the details that men would have hidden. But He will not allow others to speak against them. If a Balaam would curse them, he must bless instead. If Satan would harm Job, God would speak of him as "my servant Job — none like him on the earth, a blameless and upright man, who fears God and turns away from evil; and he still holds fast his integrity."
Commentators differ on Job's tone. One writer grants Job's honesty but still hears self-righteousness in these words.
Samuel RidoutHe will not allow himself to bear false witness; till he dies he will hold fast his integrity. His heart does not condemn him. Looking back over his past life, there is not a day whose record gives ground for reproach... But there is a sound of self-righteousness that does not fit with knowing yourself in the presence of God. Job is not there yet. It is the cry of an honest soul that does not yet fully see the light. Is there any unrighteousness? — it is in his enemy, not in himself. We see, then, that Job was speaking as between man and man.
One writer looks ahead to what Job's righteousness had to become.
W. H. WestcottHe would by no means surrender his integrity, he would by no means let go his righteousness. But, as Elihu puts it, his "righteousness," or his "uprightness," would now be to bow under God's hand, to trust the searching of His discipline, and to learn the lesson God would teach. In short, it would be to look away from himself to God, and to live on that new principle before Him, centred in the Lord and no longer in self.
- Integrity given. God named Job's integrity before Job ever defended it, and would not let others speak against His servant.
- Integrity defended. To "justify" his friends would mean calling them right. Job refuses that. He is not claiming to be sinless.
- Integrity as conscience. He will not confess a crime he did not commit; he means to keep a clear conscience to his dying day.
- Integrity misplaced. The same words carry a note of self-righteousness: he is arguing man to man, not yet standing in the light of God.
- Integrity relocated. He never has to let his integrity go. He must hold it in a new way — bowing under God's hand, centred in God and not in himself.
My righteousness I hold fast, and will not let it go my heart reproacheth [me] not one of my days.
Job's friends have accused him of hidden sin, and in chapter 27 he answers with something close to an oath: he will not confess to sins he never did. Is this the steady voice of a clear conscience, or the first sound of a self-righteousness God will later strip away?
Job's reply is a refusal to agree with his accusers.
William KellyHe still stands by it that all their imagining was false. He said now more solemnly than ever — it was a kind of swearing to it — as God lives, this is true. "God forbid that I should justify you." Now he turns on them; he says, "You are the culprits, not I."
Some read the verse as though Job were claiming to earn God's acceptance. One writer says that reading does not fit the book.
W. H. WestcottThat reading is unlikely on the face of it. The righteousness of God in the gospel sense was not revealed until the gospel came. Satan was allowed to test Job, but not to discover whether he had soul-salvation and a righteous footing before God. The test was whether Job feared God because of his prosperity and material advantages, which Satan claimed were quite enough to produce piety in a man.
Read in its own chapter, the grip Job describes is on conduct, not on standing.
W. H. WestcottIn this setting he says, "I hold fast my righteousness and will not let it go." Nothing could make him turn from what he knew to be right. So he adds, "my heart does not reproach me for any of my days." He was for keeping a good conscience all his days, like Paul later.
The second half of the verse is true as far as it goes. One commentator hears in it both integrity and a warning.
Samuel RidoutHe will not let himself bear false witness; until he dies he will hold fast his integrity. His heart does not condemn him. Looking back over his past life, there is not a day whose record gives ground for reproach… We must take this as the sober statement of a man who had "lived in all good conscience." But there is a sound of self-righteousness that does not match knowing yourself in the presence of God. Job is not there yet. It is the cry of an honest soul that does not fully see the light.
Job's uprightness was real. The danger was in what he made of it.
J. N. DarbyJob had these spiritual affections, but they did not stop him. He turned this consciousness of integrity into a robe of self-righteousness. It hid God from him, and even hid him from himself. He declares himself to be more righteous than God.
His record was clean. But it could not do the work he asked of it.
F. B. HoleThis "righteousness," as Job 29 will show us, had to do with his outward conduct, for as yet the searching light of God had not entered his soul. He had been charged with being a deceiver and a hypocrite. He knew he was not, and he was not going to plead guilty to it for a moment. We too know that he was not, but outward correctness does not in itself count for righteousness in the presence of God.
A good conscience is not worthless. It simply belongs in a different place.
William KellyNow we do need practical righteousness and a good conscience as well as faith to resist the enemy, as we see in Ephesians 6. But we want something far brighter than this armour as a robe before God; we want divine righteousness here; and this Job had to learn. He had confused the two things, as many a believer does today, to his own loss and to God's dishonour.
Job never had to become careless. His grip needed a new object.
W. H. WestcottHe would by no means surrender his integrity, he would by no means let go his righteousness. But, as Elihu puts it, his "righteousness," or his "uprightness," would now be to bow under God's hand. It would be to trust the searchings of His discipline, and to learn the lesson God would teach. In short, it would be to look away from himself to God, and to live on that new principle before Him, centred in the Lord and no longer in self.
- Hold fast — rightly. Job's grip is on his conduct and on his refusal to confess sins he never did. He is not claiming his own merit makes him right with God.
- Hold fast — honestly. Job's clear conscience is real, not a pose. Commentators call it the sober word of an honest man.
- Hold fast — too tightly. The same integrity became a robe of self-righteousness that hid God from him and hid him from himself.
- Hold the right thing before God. You need a good conscience for daily life. But it was never the robe to wear in God's presence.
- Hold fast to Him. Job's uprightness was not cancelled. It was redirected — bowing under God's hand, trusting His discipline, centred on God and not on self.