Job 14:7–8

Job 14:7

For there is hope for a tree if it be cut down, it will sprout again, and its tender branch will not cease;

Job is near the end of a long reply to his friends. He points to something anyone can check: a tree that is cut down and grows back. Does a person get the same second chance? Commentators call Job's answer honest but incomplete.

Where the words fall in the book

Job's reply ends with a comparison between man and a tree.

He closes his answer (Job 14) with wider thoughts on man's miserable lot in this world. Man is frail and faulty by nature, with no hope of coming back to life here — unlike a tree, which can sprout again however low it is cut down.

William Kelly

The picture behind the words

Job had watched this happen over years.

He started to reason the matter out. He took the example of a tree that had been cut down, its root long in the earth. He had watched the years pass, and the stump left behind had begun to decay. Yet a change came. Something happened. Perhaps an earth tremor cracked the rocks and opened a fresh channel for water to reach its roots. As a result, the dead tree came to life and sprouted again. The hope of Job was that something like that lay before mankind.

F. B. Hole

The contrast that troubled him

Job saw something true here, but he could not see past it.

In Job 14, he does not go beyond this present world of sight, and in the bitterness of his spirit he has no sense of resurrection. The tree sprouts now, here where we can see it — man does not, and never will, unless by a miracle, as with Lazarus. Death has passed fully on him as someone who lives in this world — a child of Adam. Such life he never recovers. Job was right, only he did not see beyond, nor here know Him who is the resurrection and the life.

J. N. Darby

The mystery lies on the other side of the comparison. One writer points to the part of man that is not the body:

There was no mystery about the tree, but there was about the human race. Like the tree stump, the body of man wasted away in the ground. Yet no sign of continuing life appeared, as it did when the young shoots sprang from the old roots of the tree. Still, Job realised that man is made of more than body, for he spoke of his spirit, and this is what puzzled him.

An Outline of Sound Words

Reading Job's words for what they are

The chapter records a man reasoning in the dark, and some quote it as if it settled doctrine.

That is the language of man apart from revelation. It is the expression of one who is in darkness and uncertainty. Teachers of error often quote Job and the words of his friends to defend false teachings such as soul-sleep and the annihilation of the wicked, as if these were true revelations from God. But their words are only the expressions of the human mind, and often false and misleading. What Job and his friends said is recorded in an inspired account that cannot fail, yet revelation is a different matter altogether.

Arno Clemens Gaebelein

Yet Job does not stop where despair usually stops.

People very often stop there, but the Spirit of God does not stop there in Job. It is plain that he says what Scripture fully backs — "till the heavens are no more." That is a remarkable phrase. We might have expected "till the earth is no more," which would be natural enough. But man lives and dies, and does not rise — not till the earth is no more, but "till the heavens are no more he will not awake or be roused out of his sleep."

William Kelly

A nation cut down and sprouting again

The same figure is later picked up for a whole nation, and there the hope proves real.

Does this mean that Israel can never be restored? No, it does not. For a tree may die, so that in its first state it bears fruit no more. Yet "there is hope for a tree, if it be cut down, that it will sprout again, and that its shoots will not cease. Though its root grow old in the earth, and its stump die in the soil" (Job 14:7-8). Israel will rise again in a different state from the one that brought her to ruin. This will truly be "life from the dead" (Romans 11:15).

Leslie M. Grant

Summary

- Cut down. Job argues from something he had watched. A tree was cut down, its stump decayed for years, then water reached it and it sprouted again.

- Contrast. The tree comes back where all can see it. A man does not, and that silence pressed on Job. He had not yet met the One who is the resurrection and the life.

- Caution. These are the words of a man reasoning without revelation. The record is inspired, but his words are not settled teaching about the dead.

- Crack of light. Job says man will not wake "till the heavens are no more" — not the earth, but the heavens. The phrase is larger than the despair around it.

- Confirmation. The same cut-down tree pictures a nation reduced to nothing and sprouting again. The hope Job could only reach for turns out to be real.

Job 14:8

Though its root grow old in the earth, and its stock die in the ground,

A cut-down tree can sprout again, even after long years in the ground. Job asks whether a dying man has the same prospect — and how far his own answer reached.

The Picture Job Chose

This is no fresh cut. The tree is long past the point where anyone would expect anything from it — and then a change comes.

He took the picture of a tree that had been cut down, its root long in the earth. He had watched the years pass, until the stump left behind began to decay. Yet a change came. Something happened — an earth tremor may have cracked the rocks and opened a fresh channel for water to reach its roots. Then the dead tree came to life and sprouted again. Job's hope was that something like that lay ahead for mankind.

F. B. Hole

Man Has No Such Spring

The picture exposes a gap. A plant can lose everything above ground and still rise. For this life, a man cannot.

"Though its root grow old in the earth, and its stump die in the soil, yet at the scent of water it will bud and put out branches like a young plant. But a man dies and is laid low." There is no hope for him in this earthly life; he dies and is done with. A plant, on the other hand, may be brought down to the worst and nothing appear, and yet it may shoot up again, especially if there is water to help it.

William Kelly

How Far Job Could See

Job's sight here stops at the world in front of him.

In Job 14, he does not go beyond this present world of sight, and in the bitterness of his spirit he has no sense of resurrection. The tree sprouts now, in plain view, in this present world. Man does not, and in fact never will, unless by a miracle, as with Lazarus. Death has wholly passed upon him as a dweller in this world — a child of Adam. Such life he never recovers. Job was right, only he did not see beyond, nor here know Him who is the resurrection and the life.

J. N. Darby

Reading a Sufferer's Words Rightly

Job speaks here in the dark, and that changes how his words should be used.

He speaks of man who "lies down and rises not." That is the language of man apart from revelation. It is the expression of one who is in darkness and uncertainty. Teachers of error often quote Job and the sayings of these friends to defend false teachings — such as soul-sleep, or the annihilation of the wicked — as if these were true revelations from God. But their words are only the expressions of the human mind, and often false and misleading.

Arno Clemens Gaebelein

Contrast or Comparison?

Commentators differ on how much Job himself grasped. Some read the tree as a contrast that defeats him. Others read it as a likeness he failed to press home.

Yet the fact is this. Though man's body decays completely in the grave, the new sprouting of a tree is a comparison, not a contrast, to the eventual "sprouting" of a new body from the old. Man's resurrection is longer delayed, but it is just as certain. Job knew this, as he says in chapter 19:26. But in chapter 14 he is too concerned about the immediate future to give proper weight to the distant future.

Leslie M. Grant

The Old Root and the Nation

One writer takes the old root and the dead stump beyond one man's grave, to a whole nation.

Job can say, "There is hope for a tree, if it be cut down, that it will sprout again … though its root grow old in the earth … yet at the scent of water it will bud and put out branches" (Job 14:7-9). Israel has indeed failed. The tree has been battered by wind and storm among the nations, but the root remains, so Israel will bud and bring forth branches again.

Hamilton Smith

What We Are Not Left to Reason Out

Job had to reason his way to hope from a tree stump. Readers now start from somewhere else.

People in Old Testament times believed that the soul of man survived death and that resurrection lay ahead. Job's words here show it, and the Lord made it plain when He argued with the Sadducees of His day. What God had not yet made known was that for the saint resurrection will mean entering a new and incorruptible order of things. Our Lord showed this when He rose from the dead. So we have no need to discuss the matter and reason it out, as Job does here. God has plainly revealed the whole truth of it.

F. B. Hole

Summary

- The root. An aged root and a decayed stump still hold life; water reaches them, and the dead tree sprouts.

- The gap. What the root has, man does not have in this world — he dies and is laid low, with no new spring to follow.

- The dark. Job speaks apart from revelation. Scripture records his words exactly, but they are not God's doctrine.

- The dispute. Some read the tree as a contrast that leaves Job hopeless. Others read it as a comparison: a resurrection just as certain, only longer delayed.

- The answer. The root remains for Israel. For the saint, Christ's resurrection has made the whole truth plain — nothing left to reason out from a stump.