Jeremiah 44:5–10

Jeremiah 44:5 · Darby

But they hearkened not, nor inclined their ear to turn from their wickedness, to burn no incense unto other gods.

God speaks here to the Jews who had fled to Egypt. He starts with their own history: prophets sent again and again, and a people who would not listen or turn from their evil. This verse explains why Judah lies in ruins, and God sets it in front of survivors doing the very same thing.

A warning built out of their own history

Before threatening anything, God reminds the refugees of what they have already watched happen. One writer sets out the flow of the chapter, including the plea God had made through His servants:

In Egypt the word came to Jeremiah about them all (Jer. 44:1-14). They had seen with their own eyes the ruin and desolation that God brought on Judah and Jerusalem because of their wickedness. He had begged them, "Oh, do not do this abomination that I hate." But they did not listen. So the judgment that held off so long came at last with fury and anger.

Modernised from H J VineOriginal wording

Patience that rose above their sin

This verse shows one side of the story. The other side is God sending messenger after messenger, and the reason He gave for it:

All through their history, God's patience rises above their sin. Still, they turned a deaf ear and wanted nothing to do with His correction. The Lord "sent to them by His messengers, rising up early and sending, because He had compassion on His people and on His dwelling place." But they mocked His messengers, despised His words, and abused the prophets. In the end the Lord's anger rose against His people until there was no remedy.

Modernised from The Bible TreasuryOriginal wording

A failure of will, not of light

They were not short of light. They were unwilling. One writer traces what that stubbornness leads to:

God's patience waits. More than that, it uses every means to call back to sincerity and to Himself those who hold the truth, or at least its outward form. The most moving appeals, the strongest warnings, the kindness that stoops to reason with people almost as an equal — men make all of it useless by their stubbornness, despising grace and practising evil. In the end, when God has used up every means of calling them to repentance, the judgment His patience had held back arrives.

Modernised from J. N. DarbyOriginal wording

Refusing a clear word does not leave a person where it found them. It pulls them downward, and the fall is deepest for those who claimed the most:

Unbelief is a steep, fast slide once the heart hardens itself against a direct warning from the Lord. And the greater the show of godliness beforehand, the deeper the fall.

Modernised from William KellyOriginal wording

The hardening that follows refusal

The verse joins two failures: they would not listen, and they would not turn. Refusing a voice you once knew was God's does something to the conscience:

All truth speaks with an authority that honest people recognise. The more precious the truth, the sadder the results when someone refuses to act on it. To play with any truth is dangerous, and a hardened heart is the certain result. How many people carry a conscience paralysed at one point — if we can put it that way — because they refused something in which they once recognised the voice of God.

Modernised from Frederick W GrantOriginal wording

God asked for more than agreement. He asked them to "turn from their evil":

Where is repentance if the very thing He condemns carries on? To repent is to judge the evil as God does and leave it behind. We are to "cease to do evil" and "learn to do good."

Modernised from The Bible TreasuryOriginal wording

Egypt: a shelter that became a snare

The survivors had run to a place that could not save them:

Danger hung over them. Egypt would prove a useless shelter, and in the meantime it was all too sure a lure into idolatry.

Modernised from William KellyOriginal wording

His verdict on them is blunt:

Sadly, they had ears, but they did not hear. The remnant was rotten to the core.

Modernised from William KellyOriginal wording

Summary

- God spoke first. God sent messenger after messenger because He had compassion on His people. The warning was mercy before it was ever a threat.

- The ear decided. They did not listen or incline their ear. The problem was not missing light. It was stubbornness against grace.

- Turning was the test. Repentance is not regret about evil but departing from it — to cease doing evil and learn to do good.

- Refusal hardens. Playing with truth you once recognised deadens the conscience. The fall is steepest for those who claimed the most.

- Then judgment comes. When patience has used every means, the judgment it held back falls. Egypt, chosen as a shelter, proved only a lure into the same sin.

Jeremiah 44:6 · Darby

And my fury and mine anger was poured forth, and was kindled in the cities of Judah and in the streets of Jerusalem; and they are become a waste, a desolation, as at this day.

God speaks to the Jews who had fled to Egypt, and He points first to the ruin behind them: Judah's towns and Jerusalem's streets lie empty because His anger fell there. So did God strike without warning, why does He retell the disaster, and why were the survivors already repeating the sin that caused it?

Judgment That Waited Long

This verse looks back on something that had already happened. The people hearing it had watched it happen, and the closing words "as at this day" mean the ruin was still in front of them. One writer sets the fury of this verse against the long pleading that came first:

With their own eyes they had seen the destruction and desolation God brought on Judah and Jerusalem for their wickedness. He had begged them, "Oh, do not do this abominable thing that I hate." But they did not listen. So the judgment that waited long came at last with fury and anger.

Modernised from H J VineOriginal wording

The Patience That Came First

Before the fire fell, God took pains to warn. What stands out in that record is the hardness of the people, not the severity of God:

Notice the hardness of the people's heart. They were stubborn in evil, and refused to bow the neck to God's testimony, despite all the pains God took, if we may put it that way, to warn them… The Lord had always set a full and lasting blessing before the people, if they repented; but they would not.

Modernised from J. N. DarbyOriginal wording

Where The Fire Fell

The people had burned incense to another god in those same streets. When Jeremiah confronted them, they defended that worship and blamed their hardship on having stopped it:

So they gloried in their shame. They took no notice of what the Lord had done, or of the working of His hands, and it led to their own destruction. They read their troubles as the result of slighting the queen of heaven. Their will was set hard on a so-called religion that made sheer depravity and passion holy.

Modernised from William KellyOriginal wording

The same writer identifies the figure they were worshipping in those streets:

This was the female form of Baal or Bel. She was called Beltis, Ashtaroth, Astarte, Alitta, Mylitta, Aphrodite, and other names, and her worship involved the grossest immorality.

Modernised from William KellyOriginal wording

reason: "rehearses" is not plain English

Retelling a disaster can be cruelty, or it can be rescue. Here the aim was to reach the survivors before they repeated the sin in Egypt:

Did God take pleasure in recounting their sins, and His judgments as well as His warnings? No — it was His pity, and His desire that those in Egypt might listen at last… Danger was closing in on them. Egypt would be a useless shelter, but meanwhile it was a sure trap that drew them into idolatry.

Modernised from William KellyOriginal wording

The direction of their flight mattered. This group stands in sharp contrast to the exiles taken to Babylon:

These go down into Egypt, against the word of the Lord, and sword, famine and disease will consume them. Those at Babylon have a promise of peace, prosperity and plenty for a time… God redeemed the people out of Egypt at the beginning. But Babylon became the place of their captivity after they turned away from the Lord. So to return to Egypt was fatal, while from Babylon there was deliverance.

Modernised from H J VineOriginal wording

Trouble Misread

Everything turns on who is behind the desolation. The people traced their losses to an offended idol; Jeremiah traced them to God:

Why did they not put their troubles down to the chastening hand of God, which was the truth? That is exactly what the prophet presses home, with the simplicity and force of truth.

Modernised from William KellyOriginal wording

Summary

- Warned — God took pains to warn, and set full blessing before the people if they would repent. The fire in this verse falls only after that pleading has run out.

- Burned — The fury fell where the incense had risen: Judah's towns and Jerusalem's streets. The worship of the goddess they served there involved gross immorality.

- Recalled — In Egypt God names the ruin again. He does it not to shame the survivors but out of pity, so that this group might listen at last.

- Misread — They blamed their hardship on neglecting the queen of heaven, not on the chastening hand of God. So they gloried in the very thing that had destroyed them.

- Chosen — Direction decided the outcome. From Babylon there was deliverance; going back to Egypt against God's word was fatal.

Jeremiah 44:7 · Darby

And now thus saith Jehovah the God of hosts, the God of Israel Wherefore commit ye great evil against your souls, to cut off from you man and woman, infant and suckling, out of the midst of Judah, to leave you no remnant;

God is speaking to the survivors of Judah's collapse, who fled to Egypt against His word. There they took up the idolatry that ruined their homeland, and now He asks why they are destroying their own families.

How They Came to Be in Egypt

They were not dragged to Egypt. They walked there, after God had told them what would happen.

The path of unbelief is a rapid descent when the heart hardens itself against a direct warning of the Lord. The greater the claim to godliness before, the deeper the fall... it was a fatal step when the prophet gave them the word of the Lord. That word assured them of safety in the land under Nebuchadnezzar, and of destruction in Egypt. Yet their impulse — indeed their determination — was to go there for shelter as a sensible precaution. God loves to be the Saviour of those who bear His name; if they desert Him for another, woe to them!

Modernised from William KellyOriginal wording

They picked Egypt as a hiding place. It failed them in two ways.

Danger was closing in on them. Egypt would be a useless shelter, but meanwhile it was all too sure a trap into idolatry.

Modernised from William KellyOriginal wording

A Question Asked in Pity

God opens by asking why. He is not listing their crimes for the record.

Did God take pleasure in going over their sins, His judgments and His warnings? No — it was His pity, and His desire that those in Egypt might listen at last.

Modernised from William KellyOriginal wording

Evil Against Themselves

The wrong strikes at God, yet the ruin falls on them. They had watched this story play out once in Jerusalem, and were now repeating it.

Jeremiah reminds them in his message how God had dealt with Jerusalem and Judah because of their idolatries. He had even sent prophets to warn them. And now they were doing the same thing in Egypt. "You too are bringing utter ruin on yourselves and all your own."

Modernised from Arno Clemens GaebeleinOriginal wording

No One Left — Not Even the Infants

The verse counts the cost household by household: man, woman, child, infant. Kelly points to the part the wives played in the idolatry.

Notice here that the prophet stresses the wickedness of wives, and the part it played in bringing on the disasters of Israel, both before and now. Women are more ready to hear and feel, for good or ill, than men... It is a great grace from the Lord when they receive the truth and are saved. It is an awful sign that judgment is near when they renounce the truth and are bold and shameless in their determination to serve a false god.

Modernised from William KellyOriginal wording

Eyewitnesses Who Learned Nothing

The ruin of Judah was not distant history to these people. They had watched it happen, and God set the lesson before them again.

They had seen with their own eyes how God destroyed Judah and Jerusalem and left them empty, because of their wickedness. He had pleaded with them: "Oh, do not do this abomination that I hate." They did not listen, so the judgment He held back for so long came at last with fury and anger. They must let that lesson teach them. They are not to provoke the Lord to wrath any more by their abominable idolatry, for if they did not listen they would be wiped out.

Modernised from H J VineOriginal wording

The Answer They Gave

Later in the chapter they answer this appeal. They read their own disasters backwards, blaming the idol they had stopped serving.

So they gloried in their shame. They took no notice of the works of the Lord or of the work of His hands, and it destroyed them. They blamed their troubles on neglecting the queen of heaven, because their will was set on a so-called religion that made depravity and passion sacred.

Modernised from William KellyOriginal wording

Summary

- Chosen — nobody forced Egypt on them. They picked it as shelter against a warning already given, and unbelief falls fast once a heart hardens against God's direct word.

- Trapped — the shelter protected nothing. It pulled them straight back into the idolatry that had already ruined Jerusalem.

- Self-harm — the sin is against God, but the ruin falls on them and on all they have.

- Whole households — man, woman, child and infant all count in the loss. The prophet names the wives' part in the idolatry as a sign that judgment was near.

- Pity — God's why is not a charge sheet but an appeal. He asks because He still wants them to listen, though they answered by boasting in their shame.

Jeremiah 44:8 · Darby

provoking me to anger with the works of your hands, burning incense unto other gods in the land of Egypt, whither ye are come to sojourn, that ye should be cut off, and that ye should be a curse and a reproach among all the nations of the earth?

After Jerusalem fell, Judah's survivors fled to Egypt against God's word and took up the worship of Egypt's gods. Now God asks them why, and His question points to where the harm lands: on themselves.

How they got there

The people did not arrive at Egyptian idolatry in one leap. One commentator traces the slide to a warning they refused. He also names what God wants to be for His people:

Unbelief goes downhill fast when the heart hardens itself against a direct warning from the Lord. And the greater the show of godliness before, the deeper the fall. Going down into Egypt for safety was a fatal step. The prophet had given them the word of the Lord, assuring them of safety in the land under Nebuchadnezzar and of destruction in Egypt, where they were determined to go for shelter. God loves to be the Saviour of those who bear His name; if they desert Him for another, woe to them! It cannot but be to their shame, sorrow and ruin. Even when they have rebelled as far as they can go, God still sends them a message, in case any might yet hear and escape.

Modernised from William KellyOriginal wording

The wrong direction

Other Jews were living as captives in Babylon at the same time. The two groups ended very differently:

This short history is especially interesting, because the story of this remnant stands out as a complete contrast to the story of the remnant in Babylon. These people go down into Egypt against the word of the Lord, and sword, famine and disease will destroy them. Those at Babylon are promised peace, prosperity and plenty for the time being... At the beginning God redeemed the people out of Egypt. Babylon became the place of their captivity after they turned away from the Lord. To return to Egypt therefore was fatal, but from Babylon there was deliverance.

Modernised from H. J. VineOriginal wording

The works of your hands

The phrase God uses here is not a general word for sin. It belongs to one thing:

"The works of their hands" is a phrase peculiar to heathen idolatry (Isa. 2:8; Jer. 1:16; 25:6-7, 14; Deut. 4:28; Ps. 115:4-7; 135:15).

Modernised from Walter ScottOriginal wording

Handmade gods are only the visible end of it. One writer traces the root further back. The same thing happens where no carved image is in sight:

The root of all idolatry is self-will, it is making a god of our own. It starts with self and shapes a god of our own — and it need not be made of silver, or made with our hands... There is a tool more cunning and skilful than the hands: the mind of man. Wherever self takes the place of the will of God, you will find the human mind at work, shaping a god to please itself. And it does this in the name of the Lord, in the name of the true God.

Modernised from Samuel RidoutOriginal wording

Why God asks

God lists their sins and asks them to explain themselves. He has a reason for both, and a warning about the country they had chosen:

Did God take pleasure in listing their sins, and His judgments as well as His warnings? No. It was His pity, and His desire that those in Egypt might listen at last... Danger hung right over them. Egypt would be a useless shelter, and meanwhile it was all too sure a lure into idolatry.

Modernised from William KellyOriginal wording

The outcome

They went on with the idols, and God announced the outcome:

These wretched people start serving other gods again in the land of Egypt where they had fled. These words describe their state: "They have not humbled themselves even to this day, nor have they feared, nor walked in my law and my statutes that I set before you and before your fathers" (Jer. 44:10). So God declares that of all those who had gone down to Egypt, only a very small number would escape (v. 28). None of the rest would escape or survive or return to the land of Judah (Jer. 44:14).

Modernised from H. L. RossierOriginal wording

Summary

- Descent. Harden your heart against one clear warning and the slide is fast. The louder the earlier show of godliness, the deeper the fall.

- Decoy. Egypt looked like shelter. It gave them no safety, and it lured them into idolatry.

- Self-will. The root of idolatry is not silver or stone. It is a will that shapes a god to suit itself, and the mind is a more cunning tool than the hands — it works even in God's name.

- Self-harm. They provoke God, but the loss is theirs. Their own act cuts them off and makes them a curse among the nations.

- Pity. God lists their sins and asks them why, not for pleasure, but so that they might still hear Him. He loves to be the Saviour of those who bear His name.

Jeremiah 44:9 · Darby

Have ye forgotten the wickedness of your fathers, and the wickedness of the kings of Judah, and the wickedness of their wives, and your own wickedness, and the wickedness of your wives, which they have committed in the land of Judah and in the streets of Jerusalem?

Jeremiah is speaking to Jewish refugees. They had fled to Egypt after Jerusalem fell, and there they took up idol worship. God asks whether the sins that ruined Judah have already slipped out of their memory. Behind the question lies a deeper issue: judgment teaches nothing to a heart that will not bow.

The Setting: Egypt

These Jews had settled in several Egyptian towns, and the move had not changed their habits.

The message is concerning all the Jews who were now dwelling in Egypt. Besides being in Tahpanhes, they were also in Noph (Memphis) and in Pathros, which was in upper Egypt... In his message Jeremiah reminds them how God dealt with Jerusalem and Judah because of their idol worship, though He had sent prophets to warn them. And now they were doing the same thing in Egypt.

Modernised from Arno Clemens GaebeleinOriginal wording

The choice of Egypt was itself part of the tragedy. Babylon held another group of exiles, and their story ran the opposite way.

This short piece of history is especially interesting. The story of this remnant stands in complete contrast to the story of the remnant in Babylon. These people go down into Egypt against the word of the Lord, where sword, famine and disease will destroy them. Those in Babylon have a promise of peace, prosperity and plenty, for a time... At the beginning God redeemed the people out of Egypt, but Babylon became the place of their captivity after they turned away from the Lord. So going back to Egypt was fatal, but from Babylon there was deliverance.

Modernised from H. J. VineOriginal wording

Why God Lists the Sins

Such a list could look like a God who enjoys keeping accounts. The reason behind it is the opposite.

Did God take pleasure in recounting their sins, and His judgments as well as His warnings? No, it was His pity and desire that those in Egypt might at last listen... Danger hung right over them. Egypt would be a useless shelter, but meanwhile it was all too sure a trap into idol worship.

Modernised from William KellyOriginal wording

Five Named Groups

The question does not stop at the fathers and the kings. It reaches the kings' wives, the hearers themselves, and their own wives. Wives are named twice, and one writer explains why influence like theirs cuts both ways.

Notice here that the prophet lays stress on the wickedness of wives. It had its part in bringing on the disasters of Israel, both before and now. Women are more ready to hear and feel, for good or ill, than men... It is a great grace from the Lord when they receive the truth and are saved. It is an awful sign of speedy judgment when they renounce the truth and are bold and shameless in their resolve to serve a false god.

Modernised from William KellyOriginal wording

Memory as Responsibility

Knowing what God did to the last generation raises the standard for this one. The same writer makes the point with a family picture.

Suppose a child has grown up knowing his father's dishonour, and hearing of his disgrace and punishment. If the child had any right feeling, would that sin not be especially hateful in his eyes? The public example of his father's evil ways would always be before him. But suppose the son treated it lightly and used it as encouragement to walk in the same path. Is it not just that a still more severe punishment should fall on that son?

Modernised from William KellyOriginal wording

The Unhumbled Heart

Forgetting here is not a failure of memory. The next verse gives the real diagnosis.

These wretched people begin again to serve other gods in the land of Egypt to which they had fled. These words describe their state: "They have not humbled themselves even to this day, nor have they feared, nor walked in My law and My statutes that I set before you and before your fathers" (Jer. 44:10).

Modernised from H. L. RossierOriginal wording

A few verses later they answered Jeremiah. Their reply measured the past by their own comfort, not by God's word.

So they gloried in their shame. They took no notice of the works of the Lord or the work of His hands, and it led to their own destruction. They read their troubles as the result of neglecting the queen of heaven, because they clung with all their will to a so-called religion that treated corruption and lust as sacred.

Modernised from William KellyOriginal wording

Summary

- Remembered — God lists the sins of fathers, kings, wives and hearers out of pity, not to settle scores. He wants them to listen at last.

- Repeated — In Egypt the refugees did what had already emptied Judah. A new country changed nothing, because the idol worship travelled with them.

- Wrong refuge — Babylon held a remnant with a promise of return. Egypt was the land God once redeemed them out of, and going back there was fatal.

- Accountable — Knowing a father's disgrace and then walking the same road makes the sin worse, not lighter. God is just to punish it more severely.

- Unhumbled — Forgetting is not weak memory but an unbroken will. They never humbled themselves, never feared, and blamed their losses on the idol they had dropped.

Jeremiah 44:10 · Darby

They are not humbled unto this day, neither have they feared, nor walked in my law, nor in my statutes which I set before you and before your fathers.

God's word reaches the Jews who fled to Egypt after Jerusalem fell. Verse 10 says the ruin they had watched taught them nothing.

Why they were in Egypt at all

They came to Egypt to save their lives. One writer traces what the move actually cost them.

They take refuge in Egypt to escape Nebuchadnezzar. But there they fall under the sword. It would have spared them in Judea, if they had stayed there in submission to the king. In Egypt they give themselves up to idolatry, so that the wrath of God might come upon them to the end.

Modernised from J. N. DarbyOriginal wording

Egypt promised safety and delivered idolatry.

God's motive in listing their sins

Verse 10 ends a long recital of sins — their fathers' and their own. Why go through the whole list?

Did God take pleasure in recounting their sins, and His judgments as well as His warnings? No, it was His pity and His desire that those in Egypt might at last listen… Imminent peril hung over them. Egypt would be a useless shelter. But meanwhile it was too sure a lure into idolatry.

Modernised from William KellyOriginal wording

Not humbled to this day

God does not say they were unhappy. He says they had not humbled themselves. Older translations read "they are not humbled," which points to the humbling God does when a person will not do it himself. One writer sorts out the difference.

The invariable way of God is this: "Whoever humbles himself will be exalted." Faith alone gives self-humiliation. There are two forms of it. The happiest of all is to be humble. The next best thing is to be humbled… Humility is the effect of grace. Humbling belongs instead to God's righteous government, where we are not humble… Judgment must come instead of humbling. But in every case anything is better than to have our soul lifted up.

Modernised from William KellyOriginal wording

That is the exact position of the people in Egypt. Grace had not made them humble. Disaster had not humbled them. Only judgment was left.

Why seeing the ruin changed nothing

They had watched a whole nation collapse, and the sight left them unchanged. One writer, describing a judgment where darkness falls, gives the reason.

Nor does the darkness produce repentance: "They gnawed their tongues in anguish and cursed the God of heaven for their pain and sores, and did not repent of their deeds." Such is the hardening character of sin. Such also is the powerlessness of judgment by itself to break the heart and subdue the soul to God.

Modernised from Frederick W GrantOriginal wording

Another writer finds the same thing in Israel's history. A person can study God's past dealings just to learn how to keep sinning with the least damage to himself, "without in the least being softened into true penitence" (Samuel Ridout).

Neither feared, nor walked in My law

The verse lists three failures: not humbled, not fearing, not walking in His law. A few verses later, those failures come out of their mouths.

The people, however, had become so hardened in their evil ways that they tell the prophet without hesitation, "We will not listen to you"! They inform him that they will continue their idolatry and burn incense to the queen of heaven. Their reason: when we did these things in Judah and Jerusalem we had plenty of bread, we were well, and saw no disaster. Jeremiah points out that this was the very thing which brought God's judgment on Judah and Jerusalem.

Modernised from H J VineOriginal wording

They even read their losses backwards. They blamed their troubles on having stopped the idol worship — "so they gloried in their shame, ignoring the works of the Lord and the work of His hands, to their own destruction" (William Kelly).

The warning carried forward

One writer carries the charge into the present day.

What defiance and wickedness, the fruit of their unbelieving hearts! Still greater is the defiance and wickedness of today, when people deliberately reject the cross and the gospel of Christ.

Modernised from Arno Clemens GaebeleinOriginal wording

Summary

- Seen — They watched Jerusalem fall for this very sin. The sight taught them nothing. Judgment by itself has no power "to break the heart and subdue the soul to God."

- Pitied — God's long list of their sins was mercy, not spite: His desire was "that those in Egypt might at last listen."

- Unhumbled — The best thing is to be humble. The next best is to be humbled. Where neither happens, "judgment must come instead of humbling."

- Defiant — An unhumbled heart does not stay silent. It tells God's messenger, "We will not listen to you." It even blames its losses on leaving the idol.

- Today — Egypt was a useless shelter and a sure lure into idolatry. The defiance is greater still where people knowingly refuse the cross and the gospel.