And the word of Jehovah came to Jeremiah in Tahpanhes, saying,
Commentary for this verse has not been generated yet.
Take great stones in thy hand, and hide them in the clay in the brick-kiln, which is at the entry of Pharaoh's house in Tahpanhes, in the sight of the Jews,
The people who asked Jeremiah to pray for guidance ignored the answer. Then they dragged him into Egypt with them. At Tahpanhes God speaks to him again — not in a speech, but in an act, with stones, clay and a royal doorway. Why does God ask His prophet to bury stones where no one will see them, and what does the hiding place itself say to the men watching him do it?
God gives this sign to people who already knew the safe path and refused it. One writer traces the whole disaster back to that refusal:
Michael HardtAt one point, those who were told to stay in the city decided to escape the yoke of Nebuchadnezzar by fleeing to Egypt. Gedaliah was the governor the Babylonians had set over the few left in Jerusalem, and he had been murdered. At the last minute, it occurred to them that they had not asked the Lord whether this was His way for them. So they quickly asked Jeremiah to consult Him. When the answer came, and was negative, they refused to listen.
They thought distance from Babylon meant safety. The opposite was true:
William KellyHad they remained quietly in the land subject to the authority of the Chaldean king whom God had placed over them, they would have been preserved. But they, choosing human policy, thought it was safer to go down into Egypt, whereas it proved to be the contrary.
Commentators describe the spot differently. One takes the "brick-kiln" as a paved area and points to a dig there:
Arno Clemens GaebeleinIn 1886 the Egyptologist Professor Petrie dug at Tahpanhes. He found a brick pavement in front of what looks like a palace. This was probably the place where Jeremiah hid the stones. The ruin is called Kasr el Bint Jehudi, which means "the palace of the daughter of Judah." The word brick-kiln means a pavement of bricks.
Another hears in the brick-kiln a reminder of Israel's slavery in Egypt, and sees what God would later set on those stones:
H J VineHow eloquent was this sign! Did not the brick kiln remind them of Israel's former slavery in Egypt? They had reached this spot again in their effort to escape the dominion of the king of Babylon, the servant of the Lord! Had they escaped? Had they found the liberty they expected by disobeying the word of the prophet in this way? To that very spot where these stones were placed, God would send His servant Nebuchadnezzar and set his throne upon them! Egypt and its wealth and its goods would be handed over to him: and so it happened.
God tells Jeremiah to bury the stones "in the sight of the men of Judah." The stones vanish into the clay. The witnesses do not, and neither does the word tied to them:
Michael HardtIs this not a striking message? The stones would have been well fixed in the mortar as a solemn witness of these words. Some time later Jeremiah's prophecy was fulfilled. Nebuchadnezzar came and took Egypt — the same Nebuchadnezzar they had been afraid of in Jerusalem so that they ran away from him.
The proud men carried Jeremiah along with them as baggage. They were carrying their own sentence too:
William Kelly"All the proud men" never guessed what they were doing. They were carrying with them the one man whose voice would soon speak in Egypt to pronounce their doom. And that doom would come by the hand of the very conqueror they hoped to shut out, using the power of the king of the south as a wall he could not cross. Vain hope to escape the hand of the God they despised!
The principle behind the sign reaches far past Tahpanhes:
William KellySo it is always. In righteous government our sin soon becomes our own chastening and the world's sorrow. What our blindness built on as solid rock turns out to be quicksand, tossed by waves and winds in the swift-coming day when God comes to judge.
The stones speak to anyone tempted to run from a hard situation instead of facing it:
Michael HardtGod's discipline does not always come at once. But it is always perfectly designed, proportionate and effective. If we run away from discipline the problem that caused it will catch up with us (and the outcome is likely to be even worse).
The positive side is not restlessness but staying put where God has placed us:
H J VineThis is an important lesson for believers who wander here and there in their restless search for an easy path. They do not abide in Christ where God has set them. We are not left to choose our own way. To do otherwise is to increase the difficulties for ourselves and others. To abide in Him is to assure blessing and increase for ourselves and others also.
- Refusal. They asked for God's answer, disliked it, and went to Egypt anyway. God sends this sign to people already running from a word they knew.
- Place. The stones go into the clay at Pharaoh's doorway. One writer links the spot to an excavated brick pavement by a palace. Another hears in the brick-kiln a reminder of Israel's slavery in Egypt.
- Witness. Hidden in the clay, yet buried "in the sight of the men of Judah," the stones stand as a silent witness to a word that later came true.
- Throne. God would set Nebuchadnezzar's throne on those buried stones. The shelter they ran to became the seat of their judge.
- Lesson. Run from discipline and it follows you; abide where God has set you, and the blessing reaches others as well as yourself.
and say unto them, Thus saith Jehovah of hosts, the God of Israel Behold, I will send and take Nebuchadrezzar the king of Babylon, my servant, and will set his throne upon these stones which I have hidden, and he shall spread his royal pavilion over them.
The people Jeremiah warned have dragged him into Egypt, and at their first stop God gives him one more sign: bury great stones outside Pharaoh's palace. Then he must name the king whose throne will stand on them — and God calls that pagan conqueror His own servant.
Tahpanhes itself carried a message for people who had just run from Babylon to Egypt.
H J VineAt the very spot they then reached, at Tahpanhes, God tells the prophet to hide some great stones in front of them. They were to go in the brick kiln at the entrance of Pharaoh's house. What a powerful sign this was! Didn't the brick kiln remind them of Israel's former slavery in Egypt? They had reached this spot again in their effort to escape the rule of the king of Babylon, the servant of the Lord! Had they escaped? Had they found the liberty they expected by disobeying the word of the prophet? To that very spot where these stones were placed, God would send His servant Nebuchadnezzar and set his throne on them! He would spread his royal canopy over them! Egypt, with its wealth and its goods, would be given into his hands — and so it happened.
The phrase marks a change in who holds God's commission. God had called Israel's kings His servants; now that honour passes to a foreign conqueror.
William KellyThat last phrase is a remarkable word. It was no longer Zedekiah, My servant, but Nebuchadnezzar, My servant. The children of Israel and of Judah were about to lose their special place as His nation too. It was now a question, not of being His servant as a special honour, but merely in providence. Nebuchadnezzar was a Gentile who worshipped idols, yet he could be His servant in this way as much as anyone else.
Another writer traces this change to the start of a whole era of world rule by Gentile kings:
Arno Clemens GaebeleinGod speaks as Creator, and in His sovereignty He appoints Nebuchadnezzar as head over the nations... not for ever, but for a time. God appointed a new form of government, because Jerusalem had failed. The rule of God through the house of David was to pass away. The Lord chooses an imperial head from among the Gentiles. He makes Nebuchadnezzar His servant; with him and his rule begin the times of the Gentiles.
The refugees went to Egypt for safety. The throne on the stones says Nebuchadnezzar would arrive there too.
William KellyThe prophet announced what would fall on the Jews who tried to escape by going down into Egypt. He showed them that there they would only meet more trouble at the hands of Nebuchadnezzar. They could have stayed quietly in the land, under the authority of the Chaldean king whom God had placed over them. Then they would have been safe. But they chose human policy and thought it was safer to go down into Egypt, and it proved to be the opposite.
Another writer turns this into a general rule about God's discipline:
Michael HardtGod's discipline does not always come at once. But it is always perfectly designed, fair in measure and effective. If we run away from discipline, the problem that caused it will catch up with us — and the outcome is likely to be even worse.
A dig may have found the very spot, and history records the invasion that followed.
Arno Clemens GaebeleinIn 1886 the Egyptologist Professor Petrie dug at Tahpanhes. He found a brick pavement in front of what seems to be a palace. It was probably the place where Jeremiah hid the stones... The words "brick kiln" mean a pavement of bricks. Then, after burying the stones, he announced that Nebuchadnezzar would come and set his throne there too. He would conquer Egypt, strike it and burn the idol temples there. Such an invasion took place about 568 BC, when the Egyptian king Amasis was defeated.
One writer reads the whole episode as a rule, not a one-off case:
William KellySo it always is. In righteous government our sin soon becomes our own chastening and the world's sorrow. What our blindness built on as rock turns out to be quicksand. Waves and winds toss it about in the day of reckoning, which comes fast.
- Servant — Judah's kings once wore this title. Now it rests on a pagan conqueror. Nebuchadnezzar serves God in providence, not in piety.
- Throne — Jeremiah buried the stones; the throne set on them opens an age when Gentile rulers govern, not David's house — and only for a time.
- Kiln — The brick kiln recalled Israel's old slavery in Egypt. They ran for freedom to the place where they had once been slaves.
- Reach — Fleeing the rod does not shorten it. At home, under Babylon's yoke, they would have been safe. In Egypt they met more of Nebuchadnezzar.
- Rock — What unbelief treats as solid ground proves to be quicksand. The one safe place is the one God appoints, however hard it looks.
And he shall come and smite the land of Egypt such as are for death to death, and such as are for captivity to captivity; and such as are for the sword to the sword.
In Egypt, Jeremiah buried stones in the ground as a sign. The king of Babylon would set his throne on that spot — and this verse says what his coming would mean for the people who had fled there to be safe.
These people left Judah for one reason: they were afraid of the Babylonians. One writer traces where that fear took them.
J. N. DarbyThey take refuge in Egypt to escape Nebuchadnezzar, but they only fall under the sword that would have spared them in Judea, if they had stayed there and submitted to the king. In Egypt they give themselves up to idolatry, so that the wrath of God might come upon them to the end.
The sword was never their real danger. Disobedience was.
The proud men who took Jeremiah with them to Egypt had no idea who they were carrying.
William KellyThe "proud men" never expected what they were carrying with them. It was the one man whose voice would soon speak in Egypt to announce their doom. And it would come by the hand of the very conqueror they hoped to shut out, using the power of the king of the south as a wall he could not cross. What a vain hope — to escape the hand of the God they despised!
The one who comes and strikes is not acting on his own. God gives him a title that runs through the whole book.
H J VineNebuchadnezzar, whom the Lord calls "My Servant," is spoken of about forty times. He is raised up to carry out His judgment on Israel, and on other nations too. The Lord says, "I have given all these lands into the hand of Nebuchadnezzar, the King of Babylon, My Servant: … and all nations shall serve him." Dominion is given to him by God; it is taken away from Israel.
The verse sorts people into three groups: pestilence, captivity, and the sword. Older translations read "death" where the ESV reads "pestilence." One writer draws out the principle behind that sorting.
William KellySo it is always. Under God's righteous government our sin soon becomes our own chastening and the world's grief. What our blindness built on as rock turns out to be quicksand, tossed by waves and winds in the day of visitation that comes so quickly.
This was not a threat that stayed in the air. One writer points to how it turned out in history.
Arno Clemens GaebeleinThen, after burying the stones, he announced that Nebuchadnezzar would come and set his throne there too, that he would conquer Egypt, strike it, and burn the idol temples there. Such an invasion took place about 568 B.C., when the Egyptian king Amasis was defeated.
The verse has a practical edge. It shows what happens when people run from correction instead of taking it.
Michael HardtGod's discipline is not always immediate, but it is always perfectly designed, proportionate and effective. If we run away from discipline, the problem that caused it will catch up with us (and the outcome is likely to be even worse). Had these people remained in Jerusalem and accepted the Babylonian yoke, they could have lived quietly in their own country. But having fled to Egypt, they were still within Nebuchadnezzar's reach and would die.
- Flight. They crossed a border to escape Nebuchadnezzar. He came to Egypt anyway, so the border bought them nothing.
- Servant. The Lord calls him "My Servant" and gives him dominion. The invading army is God's instrument, not Egypt's bad luck.
- Sorting. Each group gets its portion: pestilence, captivity, the sword. This is God's righteous government, where sin becomes its own chastening.
- Reversal. Egypt looked like rock. It proved to be quicksand, and the king they sheltered under was defeated.
- Return. Run from discipline and the cause of it follows you. Staying and taking it is the safer road.
And I will kindle a fire in the houses of the gods of Egypt, and he shall burn them, and carry them away captive; and he shall array himself with the land of Egypt, as a shepherd putteth on his garment; and he shall go forth from thence in peace.
Commentary for this verse has not been generated yet.
And he shall break the pillars of Beth-shemesh, which is in the land of Egypt; and the houses of the gods of Egypt shall he burn with fire.
The people who begged Jeremiah for God's word then refused it and took him down into Egypt with them. At Tahpanhes he buries stones in the pavement, a sign that Babylon's throne will follow them there. His message ends not with armies or palaces but with smashed stone pillars and burning temples. So what was God's real quarrel with Egypt?
The ESV calls the place Heliopolis; older translations keep the Hebrew name, Beth-shemesh. The name itself says what went on there:
Morrish Bible DictionaryAn idolatrous temple in Egypt, Jeremiah 43:13. Because its name means "house of the sun," people take it to be the same as On, or Heliopolis, a place linked with sun-worship.
One writer names the pillars and dates the invasion that fulfilled this word:
Arno Clemens GaebeleinThen, after burying the stones, he announced that Nebuchadnezzar would come and set his throne there too. He would conquer Egypt, strike it, and burn the idol temples there. Such an invasion took place about 568 BC, when the Egyptian king Amasis was defeated. The pillars mentioned in verse 13 are obelisks, and Beth-Shemesh means "the house of the Sun" (Heliopolis or On).
Why do the temples get the last word in the sentence? Commenting on a similar prophecy against Egypt, one writer traces this back to the night of the passover:
William KellyIt is with the gods of Egypt, as at first so now at last, that God's main controversy lies. This was before Him when the destroyer went through the land and struck the firstborn on the night of the passover. It is before Him here when He adds that there shall be no more a prince of the land of Egypt.
God calls the man who does this breaking His own servant. That title had belonged to Zedekiah, Judah's king:
William KellyThat is a remarkable word. It was no longer Zedekiah, My servant, but Nebuchadnezzar, My servant. The children of Israel and of Judah were about to lose their special place as His nation, too. Being His servant was now a matter of providence, not of special honour. Nebuchadnezzar, a Gentile who worshipped idols, could be His servant in this way as much as anyone else.
The spot chosen for the stones carried a message of its own:
H J VineHow eloquent this sign was! Did the brick kiln not remind them of Israel's former slavery in Egypt? They had reached this spot again in their effort to escape the rule of the king of Babylon, the servant of the Lord! Had they escaped? Had they found the liberty they expected by disobeying the word of the prophet? God would send His servant Nebuchadnezzar to the very spot where these stones lay, and set his throne on them!
They carried the prophet into Egypt with them, and with him they carried their own sentence:
William Kelly"All the proud men" never expected that they were carrying along with them the one whose voice would so soon speak in Egypt to pronounce their doom. And that doom would come by the hand of the very conqueror they hoped to shut out, using the power of the king of the south as a barrier no one could pass. What a vain hope, to escape the hand of the God they despised!
One writer applies this to anyone tempted to escape a hard situation by turning to the world:
The Bible TreasuryIf people think that by going into the world they will escape trouble, they make a great mistake. We get tired of strife and divisions and weakness, but going into the world does not improve matters.
- Sun. The Heliopolis of this verse is Beth-shemesh, "house of the sun." Also called On, it was Egypt's centre of sun-worship, and its pillars were obelisks.
- Gods. Breaking those pillars shows where God's controversy really lay. It was with the gods of Egypt, from the night of the passover to the last.
- Servant. The hand that breaks them is Nebuchadnezzar's, and God calls him "My servant." The title is not an honour here but providence, once Judah had lost its place.
- Sign. The stones hidden in the brick pavement at Tahpanhes marked the exact spot where Babylon's throne would stand. The invasion came about 568 BC.
- Escape. Those who ran to Egypt to escape Nebuchadnezzar carried both the prophet and their sentence with them. No border keeps out the God whose word they despised.
The word that came to Jeremiah concerning all the Jews who dwelt in the land of Egypt, who dwelt at Migdol, and at Tahpanhes, and at Noph, and in the country of Pathros, saying,
At the end of chapter 43 Judah's own leaders took the last survivors down into Egypt, and carried Jeremiah with them. Chapter 44 opens with God's word finding them there, scattered through the towns of Egypt. So why does God still speak to people who had run that far to get away from what He said?
They had a direct warning from the Lord, and they hardened their hearts against it. One writer shows how fast a refusal like that gathers speed, and why God still sends a message.
William KellyThe path of unbelief is a rapid descent when the heart hardens itself against a direct warning of the Lord. The greater the show of godliness before, the deeper the fall... God loves to be the Saviour of those who bear His name; if they desert Him for another, woe to them! It cannot but be to their shame, sorrow and ruin. Even when they have revolted to the very end, they are not left without a message, in case anyone might yet hear and escape.
The four names are not decoration. They show how far the runaways had scattered across a foreign country, and God's word reaches every one of those settlements.
Arno Clemens GaebeleinThe message is about all the Jews who were now living in Egypt. As well as being in Tahpanhes, they were also in Noph (Memphis) and in Pathros, which was in upper Egypt. Ancient papyri in Aramaic came to light not long ago. They show that a Jewish colony lived in that part of Egypt. In his message Jeremiah reminds them how God had dealt with Jerusalem and Judah for their idol worship, though He had sent prophets to warn them. And now they were doing the same thing in Egypt.
The message that follows goes back over what God had already done to Jerusalem. Why repeat a record of failure? One writer puts the question and answers it.
William KellyDid God take pleasure in recounting their sins, and His judgments as well as His warnings? No, it was His pity and His desire that those in Egypt might at last listen... Imminent danger hung over them; Egypt would be a useless shelter, but in the meantime it was far too certain a decoy into idolatry.
Two groups of Jews were now outside the land. One was captive in Babylon; the other had chosen Egypt for itself. Their two stories end very differently.
H J VineThe story of this remnant stands out as a complete contrast to that of the remnant in Babylon. This group goes down into Egypt against the word of the Lord, and sword, famine and disease will consume them. Those in Babylon have the promise of peace and prosperity and plenty for the time being. This group carries Jeremiah into Egypt even though he announces their doom. The others have Ezekiel and Daniel with them at Babylon, where Daniel prevails in prayer with God for their deliverance and restoration. God at the beginning redeemed the people out of Egypt, but Babylon became the place of their captivity when they had turned away from the Lord. To go back to Egypt, then, was fatal, but from Babylon there was deliverance.
Egypt was the country God had brought them out of in the first place. Running back to it for safety was not a new mistake, and one writer refuses to treat it as a fault belonging only to them.
Numerical Bible NotesGoing down to Egypt for help was the constant snare of the people of God. Yet God had delivered them out of that land, and they had seen His judgment on it in their own deliverance. Yet again and again they could turn back to it. Sadly, it is an inconsistency that not one of us who knows himself can be a stranger to! Happy are those who are taught by some means at last to say, as the apostle says for Christians: "For we are the circumcision, who worship by the Spirit of God and glory in Christ Jesus and put no confidence in the flesh."
- Disobedience put them there. They hardened their hearts against a direct warning from the Lord and went to Egypt anyway. The greater the earlier show of godliness, the deeper the fall.
- Distance did not silence God. From Migdol to Pathros in upper Egypt, He names every place they had scattered to.
- Pity explains the message. God goes back over Jerusalem's ruin not for the pleasure of it, but so that those in Egypt might at last listen.
- Direction decided their future. Babylon, the place of their captivity, held deliverance; Egypt, which they chose, was a useless shelter and a decoy into idolatry.
- Danger remains ours. Turning back to what God once delivered us from is a snare no one who knows himself can claim to be a stranger to.
Thus saith Jehovah of hosts, the God of Israel Ye have seen all the evil that I have brought upon Jerusalem, and upon all the cities of Judah; and behold they are, this day, a waste, and no man dwelleth therein,
Commentary for this verse has not been generated yet.
because of their wickedness which they have committed to provoke me to anger, in that they went to burn incense to serve other gods which they knew not, they, [nor] ye, nor your fathers.
Commentary for this verse has not been generated yet.
And I sent unto you all my servants the prophets, rising early and sending, saying, Oh, do not this abominable thing which I hate!
This verse looks back over a long history. God recalls how He kept sending prophet after prophet to Judah. Each one carried the same plea, long before the ruin fell. He speaks it to survivors now living in Egypt. Why repeat old warnings to people who ignored them? And why does He hate what they are doing?
One writer sets two things side by side: what these people were in themselves, and what God was toward them.
The Bible TreasuryIf all this shows what man is in self-will and rebellion, it also shows what God is in patient grace and goodness (Jeremiah 44:4; 2 Peter 3:9). Grace follows them even into Egypt, and still pleads with them; but nothing humbles them or brings them to repentance. But there is a limit to patience, and judgment follows from which there is no escape.
The same writer adds a warning: "If people think that by going into the world they will escape trouble, they make a great mistake."
Here God goes back over what He once did — the prophets He sent, the plea He made. One writer asks why He would open such painful ground again.
William KellyDid God take pleasure in recounting their sins, and His judgments as well as His warnings? No — it was His pity and His desire that those in Egypt might at last listen.
The same writer says why Egypt could not save them: "Egypt would be a useless shelter, but meanwhile it was all too sure a lure into idolatry."
One writer draws out the picture behind God's sending. The people matched His energy, but used it the other way.
William KellyAs the Lord rose early to send them messages and warnings, they rose early to indulge in their wickedness.
The thing God hates here is idolatry. One writer shows how far God's view of it sits from man's casual one.
William KellyIn every age, nothing shows the gap between God's word and men's thoughts more clearly than this. People treat idols and strange gods lightly, and God hates that, above all in His own people. There may be no deliberate plan to abandon His worship. It may only be what they count a small thing — going along with idolatry now and then, while still professing His name. But God absolutely rejects any such unholy compromise, quite apart from the danger, for those who allow it, of complete revolt from Him. It strikes at His majesty, at holiness and truth, and is intolerable in His eyes.
One writer traces the whole sequence: what the people had already seen, what God asked of them, and what their refusal brought.
H J VineThey had seen with their own eyes the destruction and desolation God had brought on Judah and Jerusalem for their wickedness. He had pleaded earnestly with them, saying, "Oh, do not do this abomination that I hate!" But they did not listen. So the judgment that had waited long came at last with fury and anger.
One writer applies this to readers today. God's habit has not changed: He warns before He judges.
W. T. P. WolstonWhy does the Spirit warn you so often? Why does He so often bring your own case, as it were, before you? Why? Is it not because God always warns before He judges? Is it not that He often gives the unsaved soul the opportunity of escape, though sadly, they pay no attention to it? Yes, He is a God of mercy now, though one day He will be a God of judgment to those who scorn and reject His offered mercy.
- Sent — God did not judge Judah in silence. He sent prophet after prophet, long before the ruin came.
- Early — He rose early to send His warnings. His people rose just as early to spoil their own doings.
- Hated — what He asked them to drop was no small habit. Idolatry strikes at His majesty, and He will not tolerate it.
- Followed — grace pursued them even into Egypt and pleaded again. Going over their sins was pity, not pleasure in accusing.
- Limited — patience has an end. The judgment that waited long fell at last. The same God still warns before He judges.
But they hearkened not, nor inclined their ear to turn from their wickedness, to burn no incense unto other gods.
Commentary for this verse has not been generated yet.
And my fury and mine anger was poured forth, and was kindled in the cities of Judah and in the streets of Jerusalem; and they are become a waste, a desolation, as at this day.
Commentary for this verse has not been generated yet.
And now thus saith Jehovah the God of hosts, the God of Israel Wherefore commit ye great evil against your souls, to cut off from you man and woman, infant and suckling, out of the midst of Judah, to leave you no remnant;
God is speaking to the survivors of Judah's collapse, who fled to Egypt against His word. There they took up the idolatry that ruined their homeland, and now He asks why they are destroying their own families.
They were not dragged to Egypt. They walked there, after God had told them what would happen.
William KellyThe path of unbelief is a rapid descent when the heart hardens itself against a direct warning of the Lord. The greater the claim to godliness before, the deeper the fall... it was a fatal step when the prophet gave them the word of the Lord. That word assured them of safety in the land under Nebuchadnezzar, and of destruction in Egypt. Yet their impulse — indeed their determination — was to go there for shelter as a sensible precaution. God loves to be the Saviour of those who bear His name; if they desert Him for another, woe to them!
They picked Egypt as a hiding place. It failed them in two ways.
William KellyDanger was closing in on them. Egypt would be a useless shelter, but meanwhile it was all too sure a trap into idolatry.
God opens by asking why. He is not listing their crimes for the record.
William KellyDid God take pleasure in going over their sins, His judgments and His warnings? No — it was His pity, and His desire that those in Egypt might listen at last.
The wrong strikes at God, yet the ruin falls on them. They had watched this story play out once in Jerusalem, and were now repeating it.
Arno Clemens GaebeleinJeremiah reminds them in his message how God had dealt with Jerusalem and Judah because of their idolatries. He had even sent prophets to warn them. And now they were doing the same thing in Egypt. "You too are bringing utter ruin on yourselves and all your own."
The verse counts the cost household by household: man, woman, child, infant. Kelly points to the part the wives played in the idolatry.
William KellyNotice here that the prophet stresses the wickedness of wives, and the part it played in bringing on the disasters of Israel, both before and now. Women are more ready to hear and feel, for good or ill, than men... It is a great grace from the Lord when they receive the truth and are saved. It is an awful sign that judgment is near when they renounce the truth and are bold and shameless in their determination to serve a false god.
The ruin of Judah was not distant history to these people. They had watched it happen, and God set the lesson before them again.
H J VineThey had seen with their own eyes how God destroyed Judah and Jerusalem and left them empty, because of their wickedness. He had pleaded with them: "Oh, do not do this abomination that I hate." They did not listen, so the judgment He held back for so long came at last with fury and anger. They must let that lesson teach them. They are not to provoke the Lord to wrath any more by their abominable idolatry, for if they did not listen they would be wiped out.
Later in the chapter they answer this appeal. They read their own disasters backwards, blaming the idol they had stopped serving.
William KellySo they gloried in their shame. They took no notice of the works of the Lord or of the work of His hands, and it destroyed them. They blamed their troubles on neglecting the queen of heaven, because their will was set on a so-called religion that made depravity and passion sacred.
- Chosen — nobody forced Egypt on them. They picked it as shelter against a warning already given, and unbelief falls fast once a heart hardens against God's direct word.
- Trapped — the shelter protected nothing. It pulled them straight back into the idolatry that had already ruined Jerusalem.
- Self-harm — the sin is against God, but the ruin falls on them and on all they have.
- Whole households — man, woman, child and infant all count in the loss. The prophet names the wives' part in the idolatry as a sign that judgment was near.
- Pity — God's why is not a charge sheet but an appeal. He asks because He still wants them to listen, though they answered by boasting in their shame.
provoking me to anger with the works of your hands, burning incense unto other gods in the land of Egypt, whither ye are come to sojourn, that ye should be cut off, and that ye should be a curse and a reproach among all the nations of the earth?
Commentary for this verse has not been generated yet.
Have ye forgotten the wickedness of your fathers, and the wickedness of the kings of Judah, and the wickedness of their wives, and your own wickedness, and the wickedness of your wives, which they have committed in the land of Judah and in the streets of Jerusalem?
Commentary for this verse has not been generated yet.
They are not humbled unto this day, neither have they feared, nor walked in my law, nor in my statutes which I set before you and before your fathers.
God's word reaches the Jews who fled to Egypt after Jerusalem fell. Verse 10 says the ruin they had watched taught them nothing.
They came to Egypt to save their lives. One writer traces what the move actually cost them.
J. N. DarbyThey take refuge in Egypt to escape Nebuchadnezzar. But there they fall under the sword. It would have spared them in Judea, if they had stayed there in submission to the king. In Egypt they give themselves up to idolatry, so that the wrath of God might come upon them to the end.
Egypt promised safety and delivered idolatry.
Verse 10 ends a long recital of sins — their fathers' and their own. Why go through the whole list?
William KellyDid God take pleasure in recounting their sins, and His judgments as well as His warnings? No, it was His pity and His desire that those in Egypt might at last listen… Imminent peril hung over them. Egypt would be a useless shelter. But meanwhile it was too sure a lure into idolatry.
God does not say they were unhappy. He says they had not humbled themselves. Older translations read "they are not humbled," which points to the humbling God does when a person will not do it himself. One writer sorts out the difference.
William KellyThe invariable way of God is this: "Whoever humbles himself will be exalted." Faith alone gives self-humiliation. There are two forms of it. The happiest of all is to be humble. The next best thing is to be humbled… Humility is the effect of grace. Humbling belongs instead to God's righteous government, where we are not humble… Judgment must come instead of humbling. But in every case anything is better than to have our soul lifted up.
That is the exact position of the people in Egypt. Grace had not made them humble. Disaster had not humbled them. Only judgment was left.
They had watched a whole nation collapse, and the sight left them unchanged. One writer, describing a judgment where darkness falls, gives the reason.
Frederick W GrantNor does the darkness produce repentance: "They gnawed their tongues in anguish and cursed the God of heaven for their pain and sores, and did not repent of their deeds." Such is the hardening character of sin. Such also is the powerlessness of judgment by itself to break the heart and subdue the soul to God.
Another writer finds the same thing in Israel's history. A person can study God's past dealings just to learn how to keep sinning with the least damage to himself, "without in the least being softened into true penitence" (Samuel Ridout).
The verse lists three failures: not humbled, not fearing, not walking in His law. A few verses later, those failures come out of their mouths.
H J VineThe people, however, had become so hardened in their evil ways that they tell the prophet without hesitation, "We will not listen to you"! They inform him that they will continue their idolatry and burn incense to the queen of heaven. Their reason: when we did these things in Judah and Jerusalem we had plenty of bread, we were well, and saw no disaster. Jeremiah points out that this was the very thing which brought God's judgment on Judah and Jerusalem.
They even read their losses backwards. They blamed their troubles on having stopped the idol worship — "so they gloried in their shame, ignoring the works of the Lord and the work of His hands, to their own destruction" (William Kelly).
One writer carries the charge into the present day.
Arno Clemens GaebeleinWhat defiance and wickedness, the fruit of their unbelieving hearts! Still greater is the defiance and wickedness of today, when people deliberately reject the cross and the gospel of Christ.
- Seen — They watched Jerusalem fall for this very sin. The sight taught them nothing. Judgment by itself has no power "to break the heart and subdue the soul to God."
- Pitied — God's long list of their sins was mercy, not spite: His desire was "that those in Egypt might at last listen."
- Unhumbled — The best thing is to be humble. The next best is to be humbled. Where neither happens, "judgment must come instead of humbling."
- Defiant — An unhumbled heart does not stay silent. It tells God's messenger, "We will not listen to you." It even blames its losses on leaving the idol.
- Today — Egypt was a useless shelter and a sure lure into idolatry. The defiance is greater still where people knowingly refuse the cross and the gospel.
Therefore thus saith Jehovah of hosts, the God of Israel Behold, I will set my face against you for evil, and to cut off all Judah.
God had pleaded with the Jews now living in Egypt, and nothing moved them. This verse is His answer. Two things stand out. God Himself takes a stand against them. The judgment reaches "all Judah" — the very people who had run to Egypt to save their lives.
Judgment is not where God started. This verse marks the point where the pleading ends.
The Bible TreasuryIf all this shows what man is in self-will and rebellion, it shows also what God is in patient grace and goodness. Grace follows them even into Egypt, and still pleads with them; but nothing humbles them or brings them to repentance. But there is a limit to patience, and judgment follows from which there is no escape. If people think that by going into the world they will escape trouble, they make a great mistake.
God had said the same words earlier over Jerusalem. One writer weighs what they must mean coming from Him:
William KellyNot only would the Lord give the inhabitants of Jerusalem up like the vine for fuel, He would "set His face against them." Think what that means to those who know His name and know that He must hate evil! The Lord announces His settled hostility. As if that were not definite enough, He adds that they will go out from the fire, and the fire will devour them. So indeed it was with Jerusalem, the guilty city of the Great King. If they left one fire behind here, it was only to meet the fire there. There was no escape, for no real repentance followed, and God was not mocked.
They went to Egypt for safety, not for the sake of rebellion. That is what made the step so serious.
William KellyThe path of unbelief is a rapid descent when the heart hardens itself against a direct warning of the Lord. The louder the claim to godliness before, the deeper the fall... But it was a fatal step. The prophet gave them the word of the Lord. He assured them of safety in the land under Nebuchadnezzar, and of destruction in Egypt. Yet their impulse — yes, their determination — was to go to Egypt for shelter as a prudent move. God loves to be the Saviour of those who bear His name; if they desert Him for another, woe to them!
The place chosen as a refuge became the place of death. That pattern is not unique to them:
C. H. MackintoshThe word of God does not suit man's thoughts; it judges them. It stands in direct opposition to his will, it interferes with his plans, and so he rejects it... Jonah would go to Tarshish, when he ought to have gone to Nineveh. The result was that he found himself "in the belly of Sheol," with the weeds wrapped about his head. ... The remnant in the days of Jeremiah would go into Egypt, when they ought to have remained at Jerusalem. The result was that they died by the sword, by famine, and by pestilence in the land of Egypt where they wanted to go and live.
Others of the nation were captives in Babylon at the same time. Their story ran the opposite way.
H J VineThe story of this remnant stands out as a complete contrast to that of the remnant in Babylon. These go down into Egypt, against the word of the Lord, and sword and famine and pestilence will consume them. Those in Babylon have the promise of peace and prosperity and plenty for the time being. These carry Jeremiah with them into Egypt although he announces their doom. The others have Ezekiel and Daniel with them in Babylon... God at the beginning redeemed the people out of Egypt. But Babylon became the place of their captivity when they had turned away from the Lord. To return to Egypt was therefore fatal, but from Babylon there was deliverance.
God said all this aloud to people who had already stopped listening. One commentator sums up their condition in a line:
William KellyThey had ears, but they did not hear. The remnant was rotten to the core.
Yet judgment on a whole class was not the last word for every person in it:
The Bible TreasuryWhen the remnant fails, that does not relieve anyone from individual faithfulness. But there were faithful ones, some of them named... If a cup of cold water given to a disciple in faith and love cannot lose its reward, how could these faithful ones be forgotten, who in a dark and evil day helped the servant of the Lord and so rescued and preserved His word and testimony?
- Grace first. God pleaded with them and followed them even into Egypt. Judgment came only when nothing humbled them.
- Face. "I will set My face against you" is settled hostility from God Himself. Where it falls, escape from one fire only leads into another.
- Flight. God promised them safety where they were. They chose Egypt instead. Deserting the God whose name they bore turned their refuge into ruin.
- Pattern. Jonah ran to Tarshish, this remnant to Egypt. Self-will rejects the word that crosses its plans, and lands in the disaster it was fleeing.
- Contrast. Their fellow-Jews in Babylon had prophets, promises and a way home. Going back to Egypt was the one road with no return.
And I will take the remnant of Judah, that have set their faces to enter into the land of Egypt to sojourn there, and they shall all be consumed in the land of Egypt shall they fall; they shall be consumed by the sword [and] by the famine, from the least even unto the greatest; they shall die by the sword and by the famine, and they shall be an execration, an astonishment, and a curse, and a reproach.
Commentary for this verse has not been generated yet.
And I will punish them that dwell in the land of Egypt as I have punished Jerusalem, by the sword, by the famine, and by the pestilence;
Commentary for this verse has not been generated yet.
and none of the remnant of Judah, that have come into the land of Egypt to sojourn there, shall escape or remain, so as to return into the land of Judah, whither they have a desire to return to dwell there; for none shall return but such as shall escape.
Commentary for this verse has not been generated yet.
Then all the men who knew that their wives burned incense to other gods, and all the women who stood by, a great assemblage, even all the people that dwelt in the land of Egypt, in Pathros, answered Jeremiah, saying,
The scene is Egypt. A group of Judeans had fled there for safety after Jerusalem fell. Jeremiah has just warned them that their worship of other gods will destroy them. In verse 15 the crowd answers him back — husbands, wives, and a whole settlement of exiles, speaking with one voice.
Their presence in Egypt was already an act of defiance. The prophet had told them where safety lay, and they went south anyway.
William KellyUnbelief goes downhill fast once the heart hardens itself against a direct warning of the Lord. And the greater the profession of piety before, the deeper the fall. Going down into Egypt for safety was not natural in those who had always been reluctant to bow to Babylon... But it was a fatal step. The prophet gave them the word of the Lord. He assured them of safety in the land under Nebuchadnezzar, and of destruction in Egypt. Egypt was exactly where their impulse — their determination — drove them to go for shelter. God loves to be the Saviour of those who bear His name. If they desert Him for another, woe to them! Even when they have revolted as far as they can go, God still sends them a message, in case any might yet hear and escape.
The verse places this crowd in Pathros. Writers differ over how far that name reaches.
William KellyFrom Isaiah 11:11, Pathros, as distinct from Egypt, would seem to be the upper part of the land... The chief difficulty is that Jeremiah links Pathros (44:1) with cities in Lower Egypt, and speaks of it more generally later on (v. 15). But nothing in that grouping is decisive enough to set aside our referring Pathros to the land farther south.
The verse is careful to say the husbands knew. That one word spreads the blame.
Arno Clemens GaebeleinThe women seem to have had most to do with this, but they did so with the knowledge and the consent of their husbands.
One writer sees a pattern here that runs wider than this one crowd.
William KellyThe prophet lays stress on the wickedness of wives, and the place it had in bringing on the disasters of Israel before and now. Women are more ready to hear and feel, for good or ill, than men... It is a great grace from the Lord when they receive the truth and are saved. It is an awful sign of judgment close at hand when they renounce the truth and turn bold and shameless in their resolve to serve a false god.
A whole community refuses God's word with one voice. One writer traces where that kind of corruption starts.
J. G. BellettIt is painful but profitable to trace the progress of religious corruption. It arises not from outside, but from within. No outward temptation, it seems, could have brought the people of Judah to rebel with so bold a face. Corrupt prophets and a corrupt priesthood did that. They still kept the ordinances God had given, but held them as forms that human wisdom had put in place of His power. That blindness is what made the people answer Jeremiah as they did.
Their refusal had a cause, and one writer names it.
Hamilton SmithThe self-will that was determined to take a certain course deceived them. Nothing will so warp the understanding and hinder the grasp of truth as self-will. It will not see what it does not want to see. And, as always, behind the self-will there was pride that would not admit they were wrong.
They had run to Egypt to get away from trouble. Their answer to Jeremiah shows what the move cost them.
The Bible TreasuryIf people think that by going into the world they will escape trouble, they make a great mistake. We get tired of strife and divisions and weakness, but going into the world does not mend matters. We see here the sad effect of going into the world: it left them without heart or conscience. It would be hard to find a bolder, more shameless and wicked defiance of God and His word.
- Descent. Refusing a direct warning starts a fast slide. The higher the earlier profession of piety, the deeper the fall.
- Escape. They fled to Egypt to avoid trouble, and the flight itself left them without heart or conscience.
- Complicity. The wives made the offerings, but the husbands knew and agreed. The sin belonged to whole households.
- Blindness. Self-will warps the understanding. It will not see what it does not want to see, and pride will not admit it was wrong.
- Inside job. The corruption did not come from Egypt around them. It came from within. That is how a great crowd could refuse God's word together with such a bold face.
[As for] the word that thou hast spoken unto us in the name of Jehovah, we will not hearken unto thee,
The men and women of Judah had fled to Egypt after Jerusalem fell. Now they stand before Jeremiah in a crowd and refuse the message he brings in the name of the Lord. How does a people that has just watched God's judgment fall on its own city come to say such a thing out loud?
This is not quiet drifting. They announce the decision to the prophet's face. One writer shows how hard they had grown before they could say it:
H J VineThe people, however, had become so hardened in their evil ways that they tell the prophet without hesitation, "We will not listen to you"! They boldly inform him that they will keep up their idolatry and burn incense to the queen of heaven. When we did these things in Judah and Jerusalem, they say, we had plenty of bread and were well, and saw no evil.
They do not argue that Jeremiah misheard God. They prefer their own plan. One writer names what is working underneath the refusal:
Hamilton SmithThe self-will that was determined to take a certain course deceived them. Nothing twists the understanding and blocks the grasp of truth like self-will. It will not see what it does not want to see. And, as always, behind the self-will there was pride that would not admit they were wrong.
This was no harmless local custom. The title they use belonged to a goddess worshipped by the nations around them:
Arno Clemens GaebeleinThey had provoked Him by making cakes to the queen of heaven. They had fallen in with the worship of a female idol. That worship was common among the idolatrous nations around them: the Phoenicians, the Assyrians, the Egyptians and the Babylonians. They called the Babylonian Venus, Ishtar, the queen of heaven... The Phoenicians worshipped this "queen of heaven" under the name of Ashtoreth or Astarte. All kinds of immoral ceremonies went with this wicked worship, and the Jews had taken it up. The women made cakes to present to this goddess.
Their defence rests on memory: life was comfortable while the incense burned. They then read the reverse into their recent losses.
William KellySo they gloried in their shame. They took no notice of the works of the Lord or the work of His hands, and it destroyed them. They read their troubles as the result of neglecting the queen of heaven. They had handed their will over completely to a so-called religion that made mere depravity and passion sacred.
Jeremiah points them to the cause they left out:
William KellyWhy did they not put their troubles down to the chastening hand of God, which was the truth? This is exactly what the prophet presses home with the simplicity and force of truth.
They had asked Jeremiah for a word from God, then refused it. Egypt looked like the safe choice:
J. N. DarbyThey consult Jeremiah, but refuse to obey the word of the Lord from his mouth. They take refuge in Egypt to escape Nebuchadnezzar. But there they fall under the sword that would have spared them in Judea, if they had stayed there in submission to the king. In Egypt they give themselves up to idolatry, so that the wrath of God might come on them to the end.
One writer carries the same refusal into the present:
Arno Clemens GaebeleinWhat defiance and wickedness, the fruit of their unbelieving hearts! The defiance and wickedness of today is even greater, when people deliberately reject the cross and the gospel of Christ.
- The word. God speaks through Jeremiah. The crowd tells him to his face that they will not listen.
- The will. Behind the refusal is self-will backed by pride, which will not see what it does not want to see.
- The idol. The "queen of heaven" was a real cult — Ishtar, Ashtoreth, Astarte — with immoral rites the people had taken up.
- The excuse. They credited the incense for their good years and blamed its loss for the bad ones. They never traced their troubles to God's hand.
- The end. The Egypt they picked for safety became the place of the sword. Refusing the word of the Lord never removes the judgment it announces.
but we will certainly do every word that is gone forth out of our mouth, to burn incense to the queen of the heavens, and to pour out drink-offerings to her, as we have done, we and our fathers, our kings and our princes, in the cities of Judah and in the streets of Jerusalem; and we had plenty of bread, and were well, and saw no evil.
The survivors of Judah have fled to Egypt against the word of the Lord, and there they answer Jeremiah to his face. Their reply raises two questions: who was this "queen of heaven," and why did they think she paid better than the Lord?
Their words are not a debate but a refusal. One writer weighs what such an answer shows about man, and about God.
The Bible TreasuryIf all this shows what man is in self-will and rebellion, it shows also what God is in patient grace and goodness. Grace follows them even into Egypt, and still pleads with them; but nothing humbles them or brings them to repentance. But there is a limit to patience, and judgment follows from which there is no escape... It would be hard to find a bolder, more impudent and wicked defiance of God and His word. They, moreover, impudently claim that it is better and more profitable to serve idols than to serve the Lord!
The title belonged to a female idol. The nations around Judah all knew her.
Arno Clemens GaebeleinThey had taken up the worship of a female idol. It was common among the idol-worshipping nations around them: the Phoenicians, the Assyrians, the Egyptians and the Babylonians. They called the Babylonian Venus, Ishtar, the queen of heaven. The Assyrians called her Beltis, the female form of Baal. In the sculpture they placed a star over her head and called her "the mistress of the heavens." The Phoenicians worshipped this "queen of heaven" under the name of Ashtoreth or Astarte. The Jews had taken up this wicked worship, and all kinds of immoral ceremonies went with it.
Their case rests on memory: the years of incense were the years of plenty. They read their comfort as proof that the idol worked.
William KellySo they gloried in their shame. They took no notice of the works of the Lord or of the working of His hands, and it led to their own destruction. They explained their troubles as the result of slighting the queen of heaven. Their will was fully set on a so-called religion that treated sheer corruption and lust as sacred.
One writer presses the question they never asked.
William KellyWhy did they not attribute their troubles, as was the truth, to the chastening hand of God? This is exactly what the prophet charges home with the simplicity and force of truth.
Incense and drink offerings were not invented for the idol. They already had a meaning, and the people gave it away.
C E StuartIncense spoke of the merits of Christ. Drink-offerings spoke of the joy found in the life and death of the Lord Jesus. Yet by the incense they burned to idols and the wine they poured out, the people declared by their action that they had learned the merits belonging to false gods. They declared they had found joy in a rite that was, little as they knew it, really the worship of demons. What an insult it was to God, and to Him whom the sacrifice represented, for Israel to give drink-offerings to idols!
They bind themselves to whatever they have vowed. One writer names what lies under that.
Samuel RidoutThe root of all idolatry is self-will, it is making a god of our own. It is starting with self and fashioning a god, not necessarily out of silver, nor necessarily with our hands... wherever self takes the place of the will of God, you will find the human mind at work, fashioning a god to please itself. And it does this in the name of the Lord, in the name of the true God.
One writer sets this group beside the captives in Babylon. The place they chose decided the outcome.
H J VineThese people go down into Egypt against the word of the Lord, and sword, famine and disease will destroy them. Those at Babylon have peace, prosperity and plenty promised to them for the time being... God at the beginning redeemed the people out of Egypt, but Babylon became the place of their captivity when they had turned away from the Lord. To return to Egypt therefore was fatal, but from Babylon there was deliverance... Egypt stands for the place that was ours by nature, under Satan's power.
- Vow. They make their own vow the rule — "everything that we have vowed." That self-will is the root of all idolatry: fashioning a god to please yourself.
- Idol. The "queen of heaven" was a female idol known to Babylon, Assyria, Phoenicia and Egypt. Immoral rites went with her worship.
- Evidence. They argued from full stomachs and quiet years. They credited the idol for what God's hand had given, and blamed their losses on neglecting her.
- Insult. Incense and drink offerings were God's own signs of the worth and joy found in Christ. Given to an idol, they became the worship of demons.
- End. Grace followed them into Egypt and still pleaded, but nothing humbled them. From Babylon there was deliverance; from Egypt there was none.
But since we left off burning incense to the queen of the heavens, and pouring out drink-offerings to her, we have wanted everything, and have been consumed by the sword and by the famine.
The people of Judah had fled to Egypt after Jerusalem fell, and their answer to Jeremiah is simple: serving the queen of heaven brought good times, and stopping brought disaster. Who was this goddess, and do good times and bad times show God's verdict on how we live?
The name in the verse belonged to a goddess of the nations around Judah. The cakes the women baked were part of her worship.
Arno Clemens GaebeleinThey had provoked Him by making cakes to the queen of heaven. They had fallen in with the worship of a female idol. That worship was so common among the idolatrous nations around them, like the Phoenicians, the Assyrians, the Egyptians and the Babylonians. They called the Babylonian Venus, Ishtar, the queen of heaven. The Assyrians called her Beltis, the female form of Baal. In the sculpture they placed a star over her head and called her "the mistress of the heavens." The Phoenicians worshipped this "queen of heaven" under the name of Ashtoreth or Astarte. The Jews had adopted this wicked worship, and all kinds of immoral ceremonies went with it. The women made cakes to present to this goddess.
The people had lived through famine and sword. They drew the opposite conclusion from Jeremiah's.
William KellySo they gloried in their shame, taking no notice of the works of Jehovah nor of the working of His hands, to their own destruction. They read their calamities as the result of slighting the queen of heaven. Their will was wholly committed to a so-called religion that made mere depravity and passion sacred.
Their losses were real. What they refused was the true explanation. The prophet presses that point in the verses that follow.
William KellyWhy did they not attribute their troubles, as was the truth, to the chastening hand of God? This is precisely what the prophet charges home with the simplicity and force of truth.
Their whole argument treats comfort as proof of God's approval. Commentators say it does not work that way in either direction.
F. B. HoleWorldly prosperity and celebration is not always a sign of God's approval, even when it is the fruit of His care and dealings behind the scenes. And affliction is not a sign of His disapproval, as we see far more strikingly in the case of Job.
The speakers date their troubles from the day they stopped their offerings to her. King Josiah's reforms had indeed made them stop, but one writer calls that change a surface one.
The Christian's FriendIt was with his whole heart and soul that Josiah set himself to bring worshippers of carved images back to the living and true God. He was a bright and shining light, and for a season the people were willing to walk in his light... Yet, by the Lord's own declaration, they were idolaters still at heart. They walked in the light of Josiah, not in the light of the Lord.
They had run from trouble into the world, hoping to leave it behind.
The Bible TreasuryIf people think that by going into the world they will escape trouble, they make a great mistake. We get tired of strife and divisions and weakness, but going into the world does not mend matters. Here we see the sad effect of going into the world; it left them without heart or conscience. It would be hard to find a bolder, more shameless and wicked defiance of God and His word.
One writer brings the charge into the present.
Arno Clemens GaebeleinThey claimed that all the disaster that had come on them was the result of abandoning their evil practices. What defiance and wickedness, the fruit of their unbelieving hearts! The defiance and wickedness of today is even greater, when people deliberately reject the cross and the gospel of Christ.
- The idol. The nations around Judah worshipped this goddess under many names. God's people took up her cakes, drink offerings and immoral ceremonies.
- The misreading. They blamed their famine and sword on neglecting her. The true cause was the chastening hand of God, and Jeremiah said so to their faces.
- The false measure. Good times do not prove God's approval. Hard times do not prove His disapproval. Job shows it.
- The shallow reform. Josiah turned Judah from its idols, but the people walked in his light, not the Lord's. At heart they were idolaters still, and the idol returned.
- The dead end. Running into the world to escape trouble mends nothing. It left them with no heart and no conscience. The same defiance meets the gospel today.
And when we burned incense to the queen of the heavens and poured out drink-offerings to her, did we make for her cakes to portray her, and pour out drink-offerings to her, without our husbands?
The women of Judah, now living in Egypt, answer the prophet by pointing at their husbands: the men knew about the cakes and the drink offerings. Their answer raises two questions — who this "queen of heaven" was, and how far the guilt really spread.
This goddess was not a local invention. The nations around Judah worshipped her under many names.
Arno Clemens GaebeleinThey had joined in the worship of a female idol. This worship was widespread among the idol-worshipping nations around them — the Phoenicians, the Assyrians, the Egyptians and the Babylonians. They called the Babylonian Venus, Ishtar, the queen of heaven. The Assyrians called her Beltis, the female form of Baal. In their sculptures they set a star over her head and called her "the mistress of the heavens." The Phoenicians worshipped this "queen of heaven" under the name of Ashtoreth or Astarte. The Jews had taken up this wicked worship, and all kinds of immoral ceremonies went with it. The women made cakes to present to this goddess. Jewish tradition tells us that they stamped the image of the idol on each cake.
Writers do not all point to the same object in the sky:
Morrish Bible DictionaryJeremiah also says that in Judah and Jerusalem people made cakes to the queen of heaven — a title most take to mean the moon, worshipped as Astarte.
The women's question is not a denial. It is an appeal to a household that acted as one.
Arno Clemens GaebeleinThe women seem to have been the main ones involved in this, but they did it with the knowledge and the consent of their husbands.
One writer weighs why the prophet puts the wives at the front of this charge.
William KellyNotice here that the prophet stresses the wickedness of the wives, and the part it played in bringing on the disasters of Israel, both before and now. Women are quicker to hear and to feel, for good or ill, than men. We see the brighter side in the Acts of the Apostles, and also in the Gospels and Letters of the New Testament. The darker side appears here, as in other places. It is a great grace from the Lord when they receive the truth and are saved. It is an awful sign that judgment is near when they turn from the truth and are bold and shameless in their determination to serve a false god.
They are not embarrassed. They describe the worship openly, as something to be proud of.
William KellySo they gloried in their shame. They paid no attention to the works of Jehovah or to the work of His hands, and so they destroyed themselves. They read their disasters as the result of neglecting the queen of heaven, because their will was fully set on a so-called religion that made mere depravity and passion sacred.
There was a true reason for their troubles, and they missed it.
William KellyWhy did they not put their troubles down to the chastening hand of God, which was the truth? This is exactly what the prophet presses home, with the simplicity and force of truth.
Such bold defiance of a prophet did not come from pressure outside the nation.
J. G. BellettIt is painful but useful to trace how religious corruption grows. It does not come from outside, but from inside. It seems that no outward temptation could have made the people of Judah rebel so boldly. Corrupt prophets and a corrupt priesthood did. They held on to certain ordinances of God, but not in the power of God — only in the form which human wisdom had put in their place. That blinding power made the people reply, "we will not listen to you."
The refusal was not the end of the conversation. God answered it.
H J VineThey boldly inform him they will continue their idolatry and burn incense to the queen of heaven, for say they, when we did these things in Judah and Jerusalem we had plenty of bread and were well, and saw no evil (vv. 15-19). Jeremiah points out to them it was the very thing which brought God's judgment upon Judah and Jerusalem (vv. 20-23).
- Inside the nation. The collapse came from within, not from outside pressure. Corrupt prophets and priests kept God's ordinances in form, without His power.
- Inside the home. The wives led, but the husbands knew and agreed. The guilt covered the whole household.
- Inside the will. No one talked them into it. Their will was set on a religion that made depravity and passion sacred.
- Inside-out history. They blamed their losses on neglecting the goddess. The real cause was the chastening hand of God.
- The verdict. Jeremiah named this very worship as the cause. It had already brought God's judgment on Judah and Jerusalem.
And Jeremiah said unto all the people, to the men, and to the women, and to all the people that had given him that answer, saying,
Commentary for this verse has not been generated yet.
Is it not the incense that ye burned in the cities of Judah and in the streets of Jerusalem, ye and your fathers, your kings and your princes and the people of the land, that Jehovah remembered, and that came into his mind?
Commentary for this verse has not been generated yet.
And Jehovah could no longer bear, because of the evil of your doings, [and] because of the abominations that ye had committed; and your land is become a waste, and an astonishment, and a curse, without inhabitant, as at this day.
Commentary for this verse has not been generated yet.
Because ye have burned incense, and because ye have sinned against Jehovah, and have not hearkened unto the voice of Jehovah, nor walked in his law, nor in his statutes, nor in his testimonies; therefore this evil hath come upon you, as at this day.
Commentary for this verse has not been generated yet.
And Jeremiah said unto all the people, and to all the women, Hear ye the word of Jehovah, all Judah that are in the land of Egypt.
Commentary for this verse has not been generated yet.
Thus saith Jehovah of hosts, the God of Israel, saying, Ye and your wives have both spoken with your mouths, and fulfilled with your hands, saying, We will certainly perform our vows which we have vowed, to burn incense to the queen of the heavens, and to pour out drink-offerings unto her. Ye will certainly establish your vows, and entirely perform your vows.
These words are not Jeremiah's. They are the people's own oath, quoted back to them by God. The Jews who had fled to Egypt had already told the prophet they would not listen. Their vow raises a hard question: what happens when someone hides a sin behind a religious promise and calls it faithfulness?
These people had gone down to Egypt for safety. The prophet had warned them not to.
William KellyThe prophet announced what would fall upon the Jews who tried to escape by going down into Egypt. In Egypt, he said, they would only meet still more trouble from Nebuchadnezzar. God had set the Chaldean king over them. If they had stayed in the land under his authority, they would have been safe. But choosing human policy, they thought it safer to go down into Egypt, and it proved to be the opposite.
The verse names the men and the women, their mouths and their hands.
Arno Clemens GaebeleinWhat hardness of heart, to say to the man of God, "We will not listen to you." They intended to perform their vows to worship "the queen of heaven." All they said was that things went well with them when they worshipped the queen of heaven back home. The women seem to have been the most involved in this, but they did it with the knowledge and consent of their husbands.
These refugees did not invent the title. They took it from the nations around them.
Arno Clemens GaebeleinThey had fallen in with the worship of a female idol. This worship was common among the idolatrous nations around them: the Phoenicians, the Assyrians, the Egyptians and the Babylonians. They called the Babylonian Venus, Ishtar, the queen of heaven. The Assyrians called her Beltis, the female form of Baal. In the sculpture they placed a star over her head and called her "the mistress of the heavens." The Phoenicians worshipped this "queen of heaven" under the name of Ashtoreth or Astarte. The Jews had adopted this wicked worship, with all its immoral ceremonies.
The vow names two acts: making offerings — older translations read "burning incense" — and pouring out drink offerings. Neither was a pagan invention. Both belonged to God's own worship.
C E StuartIncense spoke of the merits of Christ. Drink offerings, as we have seen, spoke of the joy found in the life and death of the Lord Jesus. Yet by the incense they burned to idols and the wine they poured out, the people claimed by their action to have learned the merits belonging to false gods. They claimed to have found joy in a rite which, little as they knew it, was really the worship of demons. What an insult it was to God, and to the One whom the sacrifice represented, for Israel to give drink offerings to idols!
They treat the promise as binding, as if breaking a vow would be the real sin. One writer answers that head on.
G. V. WigramMany men have vowed to commit a sin, and have used the vow as their excuse for doing it. Yet suppose someone had said to them, "Do you dare tell God that He wanted you to commit this murder?" — or whatever the sin may be. They would answer, "Certainly I cannot. Even nature tells me it is sin." If a man has vowed to be an apostle, or to convert many people, or never to marry, let him confess his sin, and leave himself in God's hands. He has assumed that the power lies in himself, and it is not there.
Why refuse warnings this plain? Jeremiah names the reason.
Hamilton SmithHe says, "You dissembled in your hearts." A better translation is, "You deceived yourselves in your own souls." Their self-will was set on a certain course, and it deceived them. Nothing will warp the understanding and block the grasp of truth like self-will. It will not see what it does not want to see.
The verse ends by telling them to go ahead and keep their vows. God does not argue; events will answer them.
Arno Clemens GaebeleinThe answer is plain enough, and they heard what their fate would be for their deliberate unbelief and disobedience. These are solemn words, and the Lord said, "They shall know whose word will stand, Mine or theirs." God's word will always stand, and so will those who stand by the word of God and put their trust in it.
- Flight. Human policy looked safer than obedience. Egypt gave them the opposite — more trouble, not less.
- Vow. They used a promise as the excuse for the sin. The way out is to confess the sin, not to keep the vow.
- Insult. Incense and poured-out wine spoke of Christ. Offered to an idol, they insulted God Himself.
- Self-will. Under the vow lay a will already set. Self-will "will not see what it does not want to see."
- Verdict. Two words now stood against each other, theirs and God's. Events would show which one holds.
Therefore hear ye the word of Jehovah, all Judah that dwell in the land of Egypt Behold, I have sworn by my great name, saith Jehovah, that my name shall no more be named in the mouth of any man of Judah in all the land of Egypt, saying, [As] the Lord Jehovah liveth.
The people had just told Jeremiah to his face that they would go on burning incense to the queen of heaven. They even claimed they had been better off when they did. This verse is God's reply — not another plea, but an oath, and the one thing He swears by is His own great name.
God speaks last here. The people had heard the charge and chosen their course anyway.
H J VineThe people, however, had become so hardened in their evil ways that they tell the prophet without hesitation, "We will not listen to you"! They tell him openly that they will continue their idolatry and burn incense to the queen of heaven. Their reason is this: when we did these things in Judah and Jerusalem we had plenty of bread, we were well, and we saw no disaster (vv. 15-19). Jeremiah points out that this was the very thing which brought God's judgment on Judah and Jerusalem (vv. 20-23). The prophet also told them that, since they were determined to continue their detestable practices, the Lord had said, "Behold, I have sworn by my great name, says the LORD, that my name shall no more be invoked by the mouth of any man of Judah in all the land of Egypt, saying, 'As the Lord GOD lives.'"
Why would God swear at all? One writer answers from what God alone is able to do, and from how quickly we doubt Him.
Numerical Bible NotesGod could swear an oath, for He was able to carry it out, and He knew every consequence of what He pledged Himself to. It is beautiful to see Him do it when He wants to assure the soul of His creature, who is so ready to doubt the perfect faithfulness even of his God. "Therefore God, desiring to show more convincingly to the heirs of the promise the unchangeable character of His purpose, guaranteed it with an oath, so that by two unchangeable things, in which it is impossible for God to lie, we who have fled for refuge might have strong encouragement to hold fast to the hope set before us" (Heb. 6:13-18). His word is as certain as His oath, though it does not seem so to man.
What God removes here is a phrase these people still used. They had not stopped saying "the Lord lives"; they had simply set other gods beside Him. One writer, commenting on the same sin in another prophecy, shows why that mixture is worse than plain idolatry:
William KellyWhat made this idolatry so offensive was the joining of the idols of the nations with Jehovah. To be what we might call a plain, out-and-out idolater was far less evil than to show that you know the true God and then put false gods on a level with Him. This outrage against God is specially described here: people who worship and swear to the Lord, and who also swear by the idol Milcom.
The oath does not come early. One writer traces what God was doing in all the time before it.
The Bible TreasuryIf all this shows what man is in self-will and rebellion, it shows also what God is in patient grace and goodness (Jer. 44:4; 2 Peter 3:9). Grace follows them even into Egypt, and still pleads with them; but nothing humbles them or brings them to repentance (Jer. 44:5-10). But there is a limit to patience, and judgment follows from which there is no escape (Jer. 44:11-14). If people think that by going into the world they will escape trouble, they make a great mistake.
Another group of Jews was in captivity in Babylon at this same time. Their story ran the opposite way.
H J VineThese go down into Egypt against the word of the Lord, and sword, famine and plague will destroy them. Those at Babylon are promised peace and prosperity and plenty, for a time. These take Jeremiah with them into Egypt, even though he announces their doom. The others have Ezekiel and Daniel with them at Babylon, where Daniel prevails in prayer with God for their deliverance and restoration. At the beginning God redeemed the people out of Egypt. Babylon became the place of their captivity after they had turned away from the Lord. So going back to Egypt was fatal, but from Babylon there was deliverance.
- Refusal. The oath follows their flat "we will not listen" — God speaks last, after they have made their choice final.
- Oath. God can swear by His own name. He is able to carry it out, and He knows every consequence of what He promises.
- Mixture. They kept His name on their lips and put other gods beside Him. That insult runs deeper than open idolatry, so God removes His name from their mouths.
- Limit. Grace had followed them all the way into Egypt and pleaded there; patience is long, but it has an end.
- Destination. Babylon held a people who would come back; Egypt held a people who would not. Where you run to when you will not obey decides what you find there.
Behold, I will watch over them for evil, and not for good; and all the men of Judah that are in the land of Egypt shall be consumed by the sword and by the famine, until there be an end of them.
Commentary for this verse has not been generated yet.
And they that escape the sword shall return out of the land of Egypt into the land of Judah, a very small company; and all the remnant of Judah, that have come into the land of Egypt to sojourn there, shall know whose word shall stand, mine or theirs.
Judah's survivors ran to Egypt to be safe. God's answer is that only a handful of them will ever see Judah again — and those few will settle the question of whose word stands, His or theirs.
They had a real alternative. Fear, not faith, decided what they did:
J. N. DarbyEven at this last hour, this remnant could have submitted to the yoke of Nebuchadnezzar. Then peace would have reigned in the land, and these few who remained would have held it. But some revolt, and the others fear the consequences of their folly. There is no idea of trusting in the Lord. They consult Jeremiah, but refuse to obey the word of the Lord from his mouth. They take refuge in Egypt to escape Nebuchadnezzar. There they fall under the sword. That same sword would have spared them in Judea, if they had stayed there under the king.
The direction of their flight matters. Two groups of exiles existed at the same moment, and their histories ran opposite ways:
H. J. VineThese go down into Egypt, against the word of the Lord, and sword, famine and plague will destroy them. Those at Babylon have peace and prosperity and plenty promised to them for the time being. These carry Jeremiah with them into Egypt, though he announces their doom. The others have Ezekiel and Daniel with them at Babylon, and there Daniel prevails in prayer with God for their deliverance and restoration. At the beginning God redeemed the people out of Egypt. Babylon became the place of their captivity later, when they had turned away from the Lord. To return to Egypt was therefore fatal, but from Babylon there was deliverance.
Verse 14 leaves those in Egypt no escape; this verse sends a few home. One writer answers that tension by asking who exactly the threat speaks to:
The Bible TreasuryBut here there is a remnant. Here as elsewhere, when the remnant fails, that does not excuse any individual from being faithful. Those whom the leaders carried away do not belong to the class who dwelt in the land of Egypt. Six or seven times the chapter speaks to that class as dwellers in Egypt, and for them there is no escape (Jer. 44:14).
Mercy sits inside the sentence. God can tell the godly apart from the crowd:
H. J. VineWhile He is angry — rightly angry — He remembers mercy. How comforting to hear Him say even at such a time: "Yet those who escape the sword shall return from the land of Egypt to the land of Judah, few in number" (v. 28). The blessed Lord knows the godly, and knows, too, how to deliver them. No doubt the proud and wilful had carried some of them into Egypt, like the prophet and Baruch. They were few and feeble. They did not go there gladly; circumstances forced them. It is always cheering to remind our hearts of that word, "The Lord knows those who are His" (2 Tim. 2:19). In His own time He opens the way for them to walk where He would have them.
Their unbelief gets a plain answer. It ends by naming the real question:
Arno Clemens GaebeleinThe answer is plain enough, and they heard what their fate would be for their deliberate unbelief and disobedience. These are solemn words. The Lord said, "They shall know whose word will stand, Mine or theirs." God's word will always stand. So will those who stand by the word of God and put their trust in it.
That contest is not limited to Egypt. Belief does not decide whether a word holds:
C. H. MackintoshEven if the thousand million people on this globe denied the truth of God's word, that word would still stand unmoved. Scripture does not depend for its truth upon man's belief. It is true whether he believes it or not.
Running from trouble into the world is the mistake this chapter exposes:
The Bible TreasuryIf people think that by going into the world they will escape trouble, they make a great mistake. We get tired of strife and divisions and weakness, but going into the world does not mend matters. We see here the sad effect of going into the world; it left them without heart or conscience.
- Word refused. They asked the prophet for God's word and then would not obey it; submission would have left them safe at home.
- Word avoided. Egypt looked like shelter from Nebuchadnezzar. It became the place where the sword found them.
- Word remembered. Even in anger God keeps a few — the feeble ones carried along by the wilful, whom He knows and can bring out.
- Word aimed. The doom falls on those who made Egypt their home. Failure all around never cancels your own duty to be faithful.
- Word standing. The survivors exist so that everyone learns whose word holds — and it is never man's, believed or not.
And this shall be the sign unto you, saith Jehovah, that I will punish you in this place, that ye may know that my words shall certainly stand against you for evil
Commentary for this verse has not been generated yet.
thus saith Jehovah Behold, I will give Pharaoh-Hophra king of Egypt into the hand of his enemies, and into the hand of them that seek his life; as I gave Zedekiah king of Judah into the hand of Nebuchadrezzar king of Babylon, his enemy, and that sought his life.
Commentary for this verse has not been generated yet.