Jeremiah 31:3–17

Jeremiah 31:3 · Darby

Jehovah hath appeared from afar unto me, [saying,] Yea, I have loved thee with an everlasting love; therefore with loving-kindness have I drawn thee.

This verse sits in Jeremiah's promises about Israel's future. God is speaking to a people about to be scattered, and He tells them why He will gather them again. His reason is not their record but His own love. That raises the questions commentators ask: who is God speaking to, how far back does this love go, and what does it mean to be "drawn"?

The whole nation in view

The promise is not limited to one part of the nation. Reading verse 1 alongside verse 3, one writer stresses how wide the restoration is:

So in Jeremiah 31, God makes this new relationship very clear. "At that time, declares the LORD, I will be the God of all the clans of Israel." There is to be a complete restoration of the scattered and dispersed tribes, not of Judah only but of all Israel: "all the clans of Israel." Nothing could be clearer.

Modernised from William KellyOriginal wording

The same writer notes that when God gathers them, even the weak are carried along: "even the suffering and the sick will be brought safely back by God's command and care… Jehovah will forget none."

Love as the reason behind the glory

The chapter goes on to promise rebuilding. One writer points out what that hope rests on. (The older translation quoted here ends verse 3 "therefore with loving-kindness have I drawn you"; the ESV reads "therefore I have continued my faithfulness to you.")

In chapter 31 the Holy Spirit goes on encouraging the heart with bright hopes of the coming glory. And He shows that the secret behind it all is the unchanging, eternal love of God. God says, "Yes, I have loved you with an everlasting love: therefore with loving-kindness have I drawn you. Again I will build you, and you shall be built, O virgin Israel!"

Modernised from H J VineOriginal wording

Love speaks before rebuke

God speaks this love to a people who had sinned. One writer draws out what comes first:

Whatever the state of His people, the Lord never forgets His love for them, and He is never slow to say so… We might have expected His first word to be a warning and a rebuke for their sins. But no. God's first word should have reminded them of the length and breadth, the depth and height, of that unchanging love… So we are brought face to face with the source of our redemption, and of every blessing we enjoy. We can never be reminded too often that we do not belong to the Lord because we love Him. We belong to Him because He has loved us and made us what we are.

Modernised from Edward DennettOriginal wording

Love that survives correction

An everlasting love is not a love that never corrects. Another writer holds both together, and points out who God was speaking to:

God never has turned away from the cry of His people, and He never will. He loves them with an unchanging love. He must often correct them for their waywardness… yet He will not give them up. It was about these stubborn children of Jacob that He said: "I have loved you with an everlasting love, and with loving-kindness I will draw you."

Modernised from J T MawsonOriginal wording

Grace found in the wilderness

Verse 3 answers the verse before it, where a people who survived the sword found grace in the desert. One writer traces that grace from start to finish:

So it was a story of grace from first to last. Grace saved them from the sword. Grace kept them in the wilderness. And grace brought them at last into the promised rest. They had plenty of hard fighting to do before they could settle in the land. Even so, it was not their own effort that brought them into rest. It was the grace of their God.

Modernised from The Bible TreasuryOriginal wording

The same writer adds that the grace is found in the trial, not away from it: "It is 'in the wilderness' we shall 'find grace'… No, the greater the trial the greater the grace ready for us."

Drawn — and how far back the love reaches

"Therefore" ties the drawing to the love. One writer follows that line backwards past conversion, past birth, past creation itself:

His love, His mercy, were set upon us. When we were converted? No, before then. When we were born? No, before then. When the world was created? No, even before then… Jeremiah writes, "Yes, I have loved you with an everlasting love; therefore with loving-kindness have I drawn you." He has drawn us to Himself, and He looks for an answer to His love.

Modernised from Paul DronsfieldOriginal wording

The same love known now

Commentators apply the verse in two ways: to Israel's future, and to believers today. One writer sets the two side by side:

In their times of sorrow, the psalms will teach Israel the deep sympathy of the Spirit of Christ. The knowledge of unchanging love will hold them up — "I have loved you with an everlasting love" (Jer. 31:3)… How much more do we know that same eternal love, made known to us in the Son!

Modernised from The Christian's FriendOriginal wording

Summary

- Source. The love comes first: we belong to God not because we loved Him, but because He loved us and made us what we are.

- Reach. That love reaches back further than we do — before we turned to Him, before we were born, before the world began.

- Pull. Because the love is everlasting, the drawing follows — loving-kindness is the cord, and it looks for an answer.

- Wilderness. The same love supplies grace along the way, not around it; the harder the road, the greater the grace given on it.

- End. The love carries through to rest — a full restoration for all the clans of Israel, none forgotten, and that same love shown to us in the Son.

Jeremiah 31:4 · Darby

I will build thee again, and thou shalt be built, O virgin of Israel! Thou shalt again be adorned with thy tambours, and shalt go forth in the dances of them that make merry.

God makes this promise to a nation He is about to scatter: He will rebuild the very people He is tearing down. Three questions follow: who is "virgin Israel," what makes such a turnaround certain, and why does the promise end in music and dancing?

The Reason Behind the Rebuilding

The word "again" looks back at the verse before it. God names Himself as the builder, and this is no fresh decision. It flows from a love that never stopped.

The Holy Spirit keeps encouraging the heart in chapter 31 with bright hopes of the coming glory. He makes known that the secret behind it all is the unchanging, eternal love of God. As He says, "I have loved you with an everlasting love; therefore I have continued my faithfulness to you. Again I will build you, and you shall be built, O virgin Israel!" (vv. 3-4).

Modernised from H J VineOriginal wording

That order holds for everyone God saves. His love comes first; our love answers it.

We are thus brought face to face with the source of our redemption, and of all the blessings we enjoy; for we cannot be too often reminded that we do not belong to the Lord because we love Him, but because He has loved us and made us what we are.

Modernised from Edward DennettOriginal wording

Who Is Being Rebuilt

This promise is not for Judah alone. The chapter opens by naming the whole scattered nation.

In Jeremiah 31 God states this new relationship plainly: "At that time, declares the LORD, I will be the God of all the clans of Israel." He will fully restore the scattered and dispersed tribes — not of Judah only, but of Israel: "all the clans of Israel." Nothing could be more definite.

Modernised from William KellyOriginal wording

Some readers treat promises like this as pictures of the church rather than pledges to a nation. Commentators answer that the text names its own subject.

There is a way of reading prophecy that spiritualizes it and explains it away, applying it to the Church and to Christianity. As if to guard against that, we are told, "These are the words that the LORD spoke concerning Israel and Judah." They are not words about something else pictured under the names of Israel and Judah. They are words the Lord spoke (a solemn thought!) about Israel and about Judah.

Modernised from W. TrotterOriginal wording

Virgin Israel

The title is surprising. The same prophet calls this nation a backsliding daughter. Commentators read the name as a picture of what she will become, not of what she has been.

Jeremiah is speaking of "the virgin of Israel," the same people he also calls "you backsliding daughter." He sees that in the day of restoration the virgin remnant of Israel will keep herself morally pure, free from all defilement with the idolatry of Babylon.

Modernised from William J HockingOriginal wording

Timbrels and Dances

The tambourine and the dance were the sounds of a rescued people. Israel had known that joy once before, on the morning God redeemed them out of Egypt.

Every heart was full of gladness, and it came out in music, dancing, and song. They were redeemed, and they knew it on that happy morning. Loaded with the joy of their salvation, they pour it out in words of thanks and praise.

Modernised from Edward DennettOriginal wording

When that sound returns, God Himself will welcome it. Their gladness comes back to Him as an offering.

The virgin of Israel will then go out again with dance, music, and song (Jer. 31:4). Their glad rejoicing will be acceptable to the Holy One. It will be the thankful offering of a people whose righteousness and beauty are the lasting memorials of His own abounding grace.

Modernised from A. PridhamOriginal wording

Summary

- Love first. The word "therefore" points back. The rebuilding grows out of an everlasting love, not out of anything the nation offered. We belong to the Lord because He loved us, not because we loved Him.

- Built again. God rebuilds the very people He had torn down. He promises restoration, not replacement.

- Israel again. The promise reaches the whole scattered nation, not Judah only. The Lord spoke about Israel and Judah, not about someone else under their names.

- Virgin again. God gives the backsliding daughter a name of purity. It describes what grace will make her in the day of restoration.

- Joy again. The tambourines and dances of a redeemed people return. God welcomes their gladness as a memorial of His own grace.

Jeremiah 31:5 · Darby

Thou shalt again plant vineyards upon the mountains of Samaria; the planters shall plant, and shall eat the fruit.

Samaria's hills belonged to the ten northern tribes. They were scattered among the nations long before Jeremiah wrote, and they never came back. So who receives this promise of vineyards, and when do the planters sit down and eat?

The love behind the replanting

The chapter opens with God speaking to tribes that had abandoned Him. His reason for bringing them back is His own love, not their repentance.

Jeremiah foretold the promised restoration of the nations of Israel from their scattering among the Gentiles. Out of the Lord's "everlasting love," even toward the ten tribes who had turned away from Him, He says, "I will bring them" back, "for I am a Father to Israel, and Ephraim is My firstborn" (Jer. 31:1-9).

Modernised from William J. HockingOriginal wording

Ephraim is the name that stands for all ten northern tribes.

In the prophecies about the future blessing of the twelve tribes, Ephraim stands for the ten tribes. See Ezekiel 37:16-22, where the twelve tribes become one nation in their own land, with one king over them. That prophecy has never yet been fulfilled, but God will surely accomplish it in His own time.

Modernised from Morrish Bible DictionaryOriginal wording

Wider than the return from Babylon

Some read this as fulfilled when exiles came home under Ezra and Nehemiah. The scale of the promise argues against that.

This is no return of Judah, but of the twelve tribes. How different from the small remnant of Jews, with a few stragglers from other tribes, under Ezra and Nehemiah! Here all the families of Israel are in question.

Modernised from William KellyOriginal wording

The record of that return names which tribes actually came home.

It is plain from this and other scriptures that only two tribes were restored — Judah and Benjamin. There may have been people from other tribes among them… For the same reason, the ten tribes will not be gathered and restored until after the appearing of the Lord for the salvation of the remnant in the land.

Modernised from The Christian's FriendOriginal wording

Israel, not a figure for something else

Some read such promises as pictures of the Church. The prophecy names its own subject.

These words seem meant to guard against the method of interpretation that explains such prophecies away by applying them to the Church and to Christianity. We are told, "And these are the words that the Lord spoke concerning Israel and concerning Judah." They are not words about something else pictured under the names of Israel and Judah. They are words the Lord spoke (solemn thought!) about Israel and about Judah.

Modernised from W. TrotterOriginal wording

That does not leave Christians without a share. It sorts out which hope belongs to whom.

Israel's is an earthly calling… In days to come, grace will restore and save them. They will then stand in grace, no longer holding their blessings on the terms of their own obedience. Even so, the blessings that mark out their calling and position will still be earthly. Ours is a heavenly calling.

Modernised from W. TrotterOriginal wording

Why a vineyard, of all pictures

Vines were not a random crop. Israel had already been pictured as God's vineyard, and that story ended badly.

They would have understood well the picture of a "vineyard" standing for Israel. God had formed it on a very fruitful hill and planted it with the choicest vine. He had done everything possible for its fruitfulness and protection. Yet when He looked for fruit, He found only wild grapes. In the end God broke down its wall, and the vineyard was trampled down — a picture of the state of Israel until now. Ps. 80; Isa. 5:1-10.

Modernised from Morrish Bible DictionaryOriginal wording

The planters keep what they grow

The second half of the verse answers an old warning. Under the law, disobedience meant others ate what you grew.

First, a man would enjoy the fruit of his own labour. This is simply the fulfilment of the promises God made to His people, on the condition that they observed and kept His commandments (see Deut. 28:1-12). The same chapter shows the contrast: if they turned aside from God's statutes and laws, others would eat the fruit of their land and all their labours. (v. 33.)

Modernised from Edward DennettOriginal wording

Vine-clad hills, and singing on them

The vineyards are not the end of the picture. Planting leads to dancing and feasting.

They will say of Him whom their fathers rejected, "He is our God." And He will own them, and take pleasure in them, as His people. With dance and tambourine they will crown the vine-clad mountains of Samaria, in the happy joy of an acceptable gladness. The Lord's loving-kindness will have drawn them into the covenant of endless peace, and they will keep their feasts of gladness in the beautiful garments of salvation (Jer. 31:4-5).

Modernised from A. PridhamOriginal wording

Summary

- Love plants. The replanting starts in God's everlasting love toward tribes that had walked away. It does not start with any change in them.

- Love reaches. Ephraim stands for the ten northern tribes. The promise reaches past Judah to all the families of Israel.

- Love outlasts. Only Judah and Benjamin came back under Ezra and Nehemiah. Commentators here place the gathering of the ten tribes after the Lord's appearing.

- Love repays. Under the law, others ate what Israel grew. Here the planters eat their own fruit, and the trampled vineyard is planted again.

- Love sings. The vines on those hills end in dancing and feasting. That is the earthly blessing of an earthly people; the Church's calling is heavenly.

Jeremiah 31:6 · Darby

For there shall be a day, when the watchmen upon mount Ephraim shall cry, Arise, and let us go up to Zion, unto Jehovah our God.

Watchmen stand in the northern hill country and shout. That land belonged to the ten tribes that broke away from Jerusalem. Their cry sends people south, to worship at Zion. Why is that so surprising, and when does the day come?

The hills of Ephraim

Start with the place. A reference work explains the term:

This does not refer to any particular mountain, but to the range of hill-country in Ephraim.

Modernised from Morrish Bible DictionaryOriginal wording

Not Judah only

How far does this promise reach? One writer weighs the words "all the families of Israel":

There is to be a complete restoration of the scattered and dispersed tribes. Not of Judah only, but of Israel: "all the families of Israel." Nothing can be more distinct.

Modernised from William KellyOriginal wording

The call reverses Jeroboam

A king once built his whole religion on stopping that very journey. One writer describes what Jeroboam did:

Jeroboam had no faith in God and His word. He feared for his throne if the people kept going up to Jerusalem to worship. So he installed golden calves in Bethel and Dan. He appointed priests from all classes, ignoring the special privilege of the Levites. He set up feasts of his own devising against God's law. This turned the people completely away from God's centre and from His order. All this was more than unfaithfulness; it was open apostasy.

Modernised from W. W. FeredayOriginal wording

Later the invitation to come back was offered again. One writer records how the northern tribes answered:

The message reached Ephraim, Manasseh and Zebulun. Most of the people met it with nothing but contempt and mockery. The Lord had already broken down much of their false worship. Yet when the chance came to return to God's true centre of worship, Jerusalem, they refused in folly and pride.

Modernised from Leslie M. GrantOriginal wording

Why Zion

The place they are called to matters too. One writer traces God's choice of Zion back to a moment when everything had collapsed:

Scripture ties Zion to David and his rule. It ties Zion, just as plainly, to the sovereign grace of God, at a time when everything entrusted to man in Israel had failed. The priesthood had broken down. The ark had gone into captivity in the enemy's land. God's judgment on the Philistines brought it back, yet no one sought after it in the days of Saul. He was the Lord's anointed king, yet he had become apostate. Everything might have seemed lost. But it was not. At that lowest point, as the seventy-eighth psalm says, "Then the Lord awoke as from sleep… and He put His adversaries to rout. He rejected the tent of Joseph; He did not choose the tribe of Ephraim, but He chose the tribe of Judah, Mount Zion, which He loves… He chose David His servant."

Modernised from Frederick W. GrantOriginal wording

One nation, one king

The two kingdoms do not stay two. One writer gathers the same promise from other prophets:

Ephraim shall no more provoke Judah, nor shall Judah again provoke Ephraim (Isaiah 11:13). They shall be "one nation in the land, on the mountains of Israel. And one king shall be king over them all, and they shall be no longer two nations, and no longer divided into two kingdoms" (Ezekiel 37:22).

Modernised from Edward DennettOriginal wording

The timing

When does that day come? One writer sets it after the Lord's return, and explains why these tribes are treated differently:

The restoration of the ten tribes will happen after the Lord has taken His kingdom. Because they had no part in the rejection and crucifixion of Christ, they will be spared the fearful and unusual trials their brothers must pass through. They will still be judged for their own sins. Those trials fall on their brothers because they accept the antichrist and join themselves to him.

Modernised from Edward DennettOriginal wording

Going up together

The call is plural: "let us go up." One writer draws out what such shared movement produces:

These, and many other Scriptures, show the blessedness and joy of the people of God as they move together in relation to His interests… What precious results such movements yield! There is praise and thanksgiving to God. There is gladness of heart in a growing knowledge of God's holy ways. There is a deeper desire to walk in a way that pleases Him, and a testimony that draws others to Himself.

Modernised from F. A. HughesOriginal wording

Summary

- Place — the hill country of Ephraim is a whole region, not one peak. It was home to the tribes that walked away from Jerusalem.

- Reversal — Jeroboam set up calves at Bethel and Dan to stop people going up to worship. Here Ephraim's own watchmen shout the opposite.

- Grace — God chose Zion after everything entrusted to man had failed. The psalm says He did not choose Ephraim. Yet Ephraim is where this call goes out.

- Reach — the promise covers all the families of Israel, not Judah only.

- Result — the two kingdoms become one nation under one king. The same call still marks God's people whenever they move toward Him together.

Jeremiah 31:7 · Darby

For thus saith Jehovah Sing aloud [with] gladness for Jacob, and shout at the head of the nations; publish ye, praise ye, and say, Jehovah, save thy people, the remnant of Israel.

Jeremiah 31:7 is a command to celebrate before the rescue has happened. God tells His people to sing, shout, proclaim and praise while the exile is still a fact. The song He gives them is also a prayer: it asks God to save "the remnant of Israel."

Not the return from Babylon

One writer marks the gap between this promise and the return that history actually recorded.

Another important difference is already set out at the start of Jeremiah 31. It is not a return of Judah, but of the twelve tribes. How different from the small remnant of Jews, with a few stragglers from other tribes, under Ezra and Nehemiah! Here all the families of Israel are in question… Who can claim that this has been fulfilled either in the Jews or in the gospel, much as the gospel has gone beyond it?

Modernised from William KellyOriginal wording

The same writer notes elsewhere that the relationship itself is new and complete: "There is to be a complete restoration of the scattered and dispersed tribes not of Judah only but of Israel: 'all the families of Israel.' Nothing can be more distinct."

Why they can sing

The gladness commanded here does not rest on anything Israel has done. Another commentator names what makes the singing possible, and says it holds for Christians too.

Verses 1–9. Sovereign grace will bring them back and give them the songs of salvation. It is true of Israel: "I have loved you with an everlasting love, and so with loving-kindness I have drawn you." It is just as true of us. What a day of joy it will be when they go back home once more, never to leave the old homeland again!

Modernised from Arno Clemens GaebeleinOriginal wording

That quotation of Jeremiah 31:3 follows an older translation. The ESV reads, "therefore I have continued my faithfulness to you."

"The chief of the nations"

Some have argued that the verse calls Israel itself the chief of the nations. One writer answers that it says no such thing.

This passage does not say that "Israel" is "the chief of the nations," but it is a call of joy among the chief of the nations. Israel means there the whole twelve tribes.

Modernised from A. J. PollockOriginal wording

Commentators differ here. Other writers do speak of Israel regaining first place among the nations. They set that recovery at the end of this age:

In political terms, the Jews once had the chief place among the nations of the world. They lost it through their disobedience. It passed to the Gentiles in the person of Nebuchadnezzar, and the Gentile holds this rule to this day. He will keep it until the Lord comes to judge the rulers of the earth, and gives the Jews back the place they once held as chief among the nations.

Modernised from The Bible TreasuryOriginal wording

When the ten tribes come back

The prayer takes in the ten tribes as well, carried off long before Christ came. Writing about the return under Ezra, one commentator explains why they come back later than Judah.

It is plain from this and other scriptures that only these two tribes were restored, though there may have been people from other tribes among them. So it was only to Judah and Benjamin that Christ was later presented for acceptance, when He was born into this world. They rejected Him. That is why they, and they only of the twelve tribes, will pass through the terrible trouble… For the same reason, the ten tribes will not be gathered and restored until after the Lord appears to save the remnant in the land. (See Zechariah 14, Ezekiel 20:33–44, Ezekiel 34, and Jeremiah 31:6–14.)

Modernised from Edward DennettOriginal wording

Going up together, singing together

The call to sing follows a call to go up to the LORD. One writer sets this beside other passages where God's people move toward Him together, and lists what such movement gives.

"Let us go up … to the LORD our God. For thus says the LORD: Sing aloud with gladness" (Jeremiah 31:6–7). These Scriptures, and many others, show the blessedness and joy of the people of God as they move together in relation to His interests… Such movements yield precious results: praise and thanksgiving to God; gladness of heart in a growing knowledge of God's holy ways; a deepening desire to walk in a way that pleases Him; and a testimony which draws others to Himself!

Modernised from F. A. HughesOriginal wording

Summary

- Love first. God commands the song because of His everlasting love and sovereign grace. Israel did not earn the return. One writer says that same love holds for believers now.

- Love reaches all twelve. The promise covers "all the families of Israel." No return from Babylon did that. Only a small group from Judah and Benjamin came back under Ezra and Nehemiah.

- Love reaches the lost ten. The prayer takes in the ten tribes, carried off long before Christ came. Commentators place their gathering after the Lord appears, later than Judah's ordeal.

- Love, not status, is the point. Commentators differ over "chief of the nations." Is it a shout raised among the great nations, or a promise that Israel regains first place? Either way, the change is coming.

- Love sings out loud. The verse turns joy outward: proclaim, praise, and pray. God's people go up to Him together, and their gladness becomes a testimony that draws others in.

Jeremiah 31:8 · Darby

Behold, I bring them from the north country, and gather them from the uttermost parts of the earth; [and] among them the blind and the lame, the woman with child and her that travaileth with child together a great assemblage shall they return hither.

Jeremiah 31 sits inside a long promise of restoration. Verse 8 shows how that restoration happens: God Himself brings His scattered people home from the ends of the earth. Who is gathered? When does it happen? And why does the list of travellers start with the weakest people in it?

A return larger than any yet seen

Israel did come back from Babylon once. But commentators say the company described here is far larger than that return.

Another important distinction is set out at the start of Jeremiah 31. This is not a return of Judah only, but of the twelve tribes. How different from the small remnant of Jews, with a few stragglers from other tribes, who came back under Ezra and Nehemiah! Here all the families of Israel are in view. … Who can claim that this has come true either in the Jews or in the gospel, much as the gospel goes beyond it?

Modernised from William KellyOriginal wording

The tribes from the north

Commentators differ on how narrowly to read verse 8. Some take it of all twelve tribes. Others split the chapter, giving verse 8 to the northern tribes and later verses to the southern ones. The writer below quotes verse 1 from an older translation; the ESV reads "clans of Israel".

There is the promise that the Lord will be "the God of all the families of Israel, and they shall be My people" (verse 1). Verses 31 to 34 give the terms of the new covenant that will form the basis of that relationship. Then what is said here of the ten tribes will come true … (verse 8), and what is said of the two tribes as well … (verses 16 and 17).

Modernised from Truth & TestimonyOriginal wording

One writer places this gathering after the return of Christ. The ten tribes had no share in the rejection of Christ, so their path differs from Judah's.

The ten tribes will be restored after the Lord has taken His kingdom. They had no part in the rejection and crucifixion of Christ. So, although they will be judged for their own sins, they will be spared the terrible and peculiar trials their fellow Israelites must pass through. Those trials come from accepting the antichrist and siding with him. It is therefore not until after the return of Christ that He will bring to light and restore this long-lost portion of His people.

Modernised from Edward DennettOriginal wording

Nobody left behind

The heart of the verse is its list of travellers: the blind, the lame, the pregnant woman, the woman in labour.

It is a complete deliverance, so that even the suffering and the sick will be brought safely back by God's command and care. He will bring them safely into the holy land. If anyone were likely to be left behind when God gathers Israel, it would of course be the sick and helpless described here. But no — He brings them all back. The Lord will forget none.

Modernised from William KellyOriginal wording

A promise about Israel, not about someone else

Some readers lift these words out of their setting and apply them to the church. Commenting on a similar promise of a gathering out of the north country earlier in Jeremiah, one writer draws a firm line.

Plainly enough, the passage speaks of the deliverance of the whole earthly people, both the ten tribes and the two tribes, and of nothing else. We may take the principle of the promised restoration of Israel to show how good the Lord is towards us, but nothing more. The truth is that we have never been driven out of our heritage, as Israel was.

Modernised from William KellyOriginal wording

Another writer makes the same point about the wider prophecy. He rests it on the way the text names its subject.

Some would spiritualise these prophecies and explain them away, trying to apply them to the Church and to Christianity. As though to guard against that, we are told, "And these are the words that the Lord spoke concerning Israel and concerning Judah."

Modernised from W. TrotterOriginal wording

The bond that made the gathering certain

Behind the promise stands a bond God made with this people long before.

This tie, once formed, God never broke or disowned. The failure of the people could not dissolve it, and God will never forget it. Hosea 11:1 reminded them of it in the past; Jeremiah 31:8-9 predicted what will give them joy from it in the future. … It was not, and it is not, a question of deserving. The question is one of God's sovereignty. He formed the tie of His own will. He will never break it, and He will never stop owning it.

Modernised from C E StuartOriginal wording

Summary

- Gathered by God. He brings, and He gathers. The exiles do not organise this return; God does.

- Gathered from everywhere. From the far north to the ends of the earth. This company is far larger than the group that returned under Ezra and Nehemiah.

- Gathered without exception. The blind, the lame and the woman in labour head the list. The very people most likely to be left behind are the ones named as coming.

- Gathered as Israel. Commentators warn against reading the promise as a picture of the church. It speaks of God's earthly people, both the ten tribes and the two.

- Gathered because of a tie God never dropped. Israel's failure did not dissolve the bond. That is why a scattered people still has a homecoming ahead.

Jeremiah 31:9 · Darby

They shall come with weeping, and with supplications will I lead them; I will cause them to walk by water-brooks, in a straight way, wherein they shall not stumble; for I will be a father to Israel, and Ephraim is my firstborn.

Jeremiah 31 promises a homecoming still ahead — a whole people led back by God Himself. Verse 9 shows how they come: in tears, on a road God clears, because of a tie He formed and never broke.

Who Is Being Brought Back

Ephraim stands for the ten tribes who turned away from God. They are the people this promise names.

Later in their history, Jeremiah used this same beautiful image when he foretold the restoration of the nation of Israel from their scattering among the other nations. Out of Jehovah's "everlasting love," reaching even the ten tribes who had turned away from Him, He says, "I will bring them" back, "for I am a Father to Israel, and Ephraim is My firstborn."

Modernised from William John HockingOriginal wording

The promise is far wider than the small return from exile led by Ezra and Nehemiah.

It is not a return of Judah, but of the twelve tribes. How different from the small remnant of Jews, with a few stragglers from other tribes, who came back under Ezra and Nehemiah! Here all the families of Israel are in question.

Modernised from William KellyOriginal wording

They Come Weeping

The verse opens with tears. They show how Israel comes home — and how they do not.

Israel will not return with vainglory and pride, as if their own arm had delivered them. Their salvation in that day will not be due to the influence of money or to diplomacy, or to anything of man. "With weeping they shall come, and with pleas for mercy I will lead them back." It will be a real work of God in them and for them. A work of repentance in their souls will accompany their restoration.

Modernised from William KellyOriginal wording

A Path Where They Will Not Stumble

The middle of the verse pictures a road God chooses. The One who leads has walked it first.

The Shepherd leads, though often by paths we do not know, until He brings us into the path of righteousness. He has walked the path of faith before us. The good shepherd, as the Gospel of John says, goes before His sheep and meets the enemy first. They follow in His footsteps, so they must expect a thorny path, though one He has already walked. Their Shepherd is with them, and His presence makes darkness light and crooked things straight. The foolish sheep are only wise when they hand themselves over to His guidance and follow wherever He leads. He will make them walk in a straight way where none will stumble and be hurt, for He rejoices over His people to do them good.

Modernised from VariousOriginal wording

A Father to Israel

God calls Himself Father to this nation while they are still scattered and still guilty.

This tie, once formed, God never broke nor disowned. The failure of the people could not dissolve it, nor will God ever forget it.

Modernised from C E StuartOriginal wording

Ephraim My Firstborn

"Firstborn" here cannot mean first in time. Ephraim was Joseph's younger son.

The word "firstborn" is often used in Scripture, as with ourselves, to signify priority in time — the one who comes first. Scripture also uses the word to signify pre-eminence and dignity. God speaks of Ephraim as "My firstborn," though Manasseh was in fact the son born to Joseph first.

Modernised from Hamilton SmithOriginal wording

The same is true when the word describes the whole nation.

So "firstborn" Israel was not the first nation to exist, for Egypt and many other nations came before it. Nor was "firstborn" Ephraim the oldest of the tribes of Jacob. In each case, "firstborn" marked a position held in relation to others. That privilege did not rest on who existed first, but on God's favour and choice.

Modernised from William John HockingOriginal wording

What This Fatherhood Did Not Yet Give

Israel held this title long before Christ came. Yet it did not mean they knew God as Father.

Israel was God's son, His firstborn; the children of the Lord their God. Jehovah was a Father to Israel, and Ephraim was His firstborn. Yet they never worshipped Him as the Father; for no one can know the Father except those to whom the Son will reveal Him.

Modernised from The Christian's FriendOriginal wording

Summary

- Love first. The gathering flows out of an everlasting love that reaches even the tribes that walked away.

- Tears next. They arrive weeping and pleading, not boasting. God works repentance in them as He brings them home.

- Leading throughout. God chooses the road, walks it ahead of them, and keeps them from stumbling on it.

- Family, not merit. "Father" names a tie God formed and refuses to dissolve, whatever the people have done.

- Rank by grace. "Firstborn" means honoured place, not first birth. Ephraim was the younger son, and the title rests on God's choice.

Jeremiah 31:10 · Darby

Hear the word of Jehovah, ye nations, and declare [it] to the isles afar off, and say, He that scattered Israel will gather him, and keep him, as a shepherd his flock.

God tells the nations to pass a message on to the far coastlands. The God who scattered Israel is the same God who will gather him and guard him — the Scatterer is the Shepherd.

Same Hand That Scattered

The verse does not blame an enemy for the scattering. It points to God. One writer shows why that is good news:

Jeremiah 31 is the chapter of the "new thing" and "the new covenant." The Lord does not excuse the bad men who scattered the sheep of Israel. Yet He shows that He Himself has been behind it all for good. He calls to the nations to see that His people are not outside His care.

Modernised from H J VineOriginal wording

Message Sent to the Coastlands

What are the far-off coastlands? Older translations call them "the isles":

There are no islands near Palestine. Cyprus is the nearest, and that is about seventy miles from the closest point of Syria, far to the north. So the term "the isles" sometimes stands loosely for places or nations far away. We read of "the isles which are beyond the sea," "the isles afar off," and "isles of the Gentiles."

Modernised from Morrish Bible DictionaryOriginal wording

God calls the nations to listen, but the news is not about them:

I know the nations are summoned to hear, but it is not about their own salvation; it is about Israel's blessing.

Modernised from William KellyOriginal wording

Why They Were Scattered

This scattering was no accident of history. One writer traces it back to the moment Israel refused the Shepherd who came to them:

He came to gather His sheep. But as a people they refused to listen to the voice of the Good Shepherd. He was struck down, and God, ruling as judge, "scattered" the flock.

Modernised from Edward DennettOriginal wording

Israel Means Israel

Do these promises still belong to the nation of Israel? One writer says a great deal rests on the answer:

God will yet make good every one of the faithful promises He made to Abraham His friend, and to David the man after His own heart. This will prove true: "He who scattered Israel will gather him, and will keep him as a shepherd keeps his flock." Those who fail to see it lose one of the most important pictures of God's faithfulness. The Prophets and the Psalms are full of promises to Israel. If we turn them all into blessings for the Church instead, what becomes of the gifts and calling of God for His earthly people?

Modernised from Samuel RidoutOriginal wording

Israel's return does not happen all at once. One writer sets a separate time for the ten tribes, the long-lost part of the nation:

The ten tribes will be restored after the Lord has taken His kingdom. They had no part in the rejection and crucifixion of Christ. They will still be judged for their own sins, but they will be spared the fearful trials that the rest of the nation must pass through. So it is only after Christ returns that He will bring to light and restore this long-lost part of His people.

Modernised from Edward DennettOriginal wording

Two Verbs: Gather and Keep

The promise does not stop at collecting the sheep. It adds guarding them. And the Shepherd who does the keeping is not a stranger to us:

He foretells the day when the Lord Himself will recover His scattered people, and "will gather him, and will keep him as a shepherd keeps his flock." He also tells us of One who will be raised up from the seed of David, the shepherd king. In His days Israel will live in safety. The believer knows this Shepherd now, and receives eternal life from Him before He returns to gather Israel.

Modernised from H J VineOriginal wording

What the Gathering Produces

The gathering is not an end in itself. It opens into song and abundance, and one writer presses the nations to notice:

God speaks to the nations here. If only the great nations of today would listen to this message: "He who scattered Israel will gather him, and will keep him as a shepherd keeps his flock." His promises made to Israel will not fail. The nations should understand, though they do not, that Israel will yet become the head of all the nations of the earth. What singing that will be in that day! What rejoicing after their sorrow!

Modernised from Arno Clemens GaebeleinOriginal wording

Summary

- Scattered — God's own hand did this, acting as judge, after His people refused the voice of the Good Shepherd.

- Kept — He was behind it all for good. The flock was never outside His care.

- Gathered — the Lord Himself will recover His scattered people. He hands the task to no one else.

- Declared — God calls the nations to carry the news to the far coastlands. The message is about Israel's blessing, not their own.

- Trusted — read these promises as anything but promises to Israel, and you lose one of the clearest displays of God's faithfulness. The believer already knows the Shepherd who will gather them.

Jeremiah 31:11 · Darby

For Jehovah hath ransomed Jacob, and redeemed him from the hand of one stronger than he.

Jeremiah has just told the nations to carry a message to the farthest coastlands. This verse gives the reason. The God who scattered Israel is the God who buys them back. Two verbs carry the weight: ransomed and redeemed. Behind them stands a captor named only as stronger than the captive.

A message for the nations, about Israel

The heralds are the nations, but the news is not their own. One commentator points out who the good news is about:

I know the nations are summoned to hear, but it is not about their own salvation — it is about Israel's blessing.

Modernised from William KellyOriginal wording

The promise keeps its plain sense. One writer warns that turning Israel's promises into Church blessings costs us a picture of God's faithfulness:

God will yet make good every one of the faithful promises He made to Abraham His friend, and to David the man after His own heart. You will find that "He who scattered Israel will gather him, and will keep him as a shepherd keeps his flock" (Jer. 31:10). Those who fail to see this fact lose one of the most important illustrations of the faithfulness of God. Suppose we turn all the promises to Israel that fill the Prophets and the Psalms into blessings for the Church instead. What then becomes of the gifts and calling of God for His earthly people?

Modernised from Samuel RidoutOriginal wording

The scatterer is the gatherer

The scattering was never outside God's control, and He meant good by it:

Jeremiah 31 is the chapter of the "new thing" and "the new covenant." The Lord does not excuse the bad men who scattered the sheep of Israel. Still, He shows that He Himself has been behind it all for good. He calls the nations to see that they are not outside His care… They shall "flow together"! Take the fences away! That is what the one flock will do. Let the scatterers stop their scattering! The sheep will flow together to the goodness of the Lord.

Modernised from H. J. VineOriginal wording

Redeemed — and ransomed

Two words are used, and writers see two sides of one rescue in them. The prophets' language of Israel's future deliverance is not detached from the cross:

God's power works in another way, still future, and Scripture calls it redemption… The Psalms and Prophets use the word again and again for the future deliverance of Israel for His kingdom on earth. Another word carries the same sense, and Jeremiah 31:11 is one of the places that uses it. All of it, however, rests on His blood-shedding. The return from Babylon was an outward sample and pledge.

Modernised from William KellyOriginal wording

The one who was stronger

Jacob is not just lost; he is held. So redemption means a bond broken by power:

Redemption is God stepping in, in the end for the body as well, to break the bond of the enemy and deliver the one who was captive. It may be by blood for the soul, but finally by power for the body. This is always how Scripture treats it. So you find, "Let the redeemed of the LORD say so, whom He has redeemed" (Ps. 107:2). Whom does the Spirit mean? All mankind? Not so, but Israel only.

Modernised from William KellyOriginal wording

Israel's law gave the near kinsman two very different duties. The second one matches this verse, and one commentator carries it to our own case:

In the first case, ransom or buying back, the Kinsman dealt with a rightful claimant and met his demands. His brother, or his brother's inheritance, had been sold. It had to be bought back at a price set fairly and justly, according to the law of valuations. But this duty of rescuing or delivering a brother is different. Here the Kinsman deals with a stranger or an enemy. He must do this service by meeting force with force, by the strength of a stronger arm. But this is also our natural condition, our state under the ruins of the fall. And the Son of God, who shared our flesh and blood, does this Kinsman-service for us.

Modernised from J. G. BellettOriginal wording

Why the rescue holds

Because the deliverance is God's own doing, nothing in the delivered can spoil it:

It is a deliverance worked by the Lord, and therefore it is complete. Its enjoyment is not hindered by weakness. It is a deliverance that melts the heart and brings tears and pleading. Yet it removes every cause for tears except grace.

Modernised from J. N. DarbyOriginal wording

The chapter itself supplies the two roots of that certainty — a love that never ends, and a covenant God will make:

This shows at once that it was not merely the restoration from Babylon. He declares that His love is an everlasting love. He redeemed Jacob (v. 11); they would come and sing on the height of Zion. Verse 31 declares that this rests on establishing the new covenant.

Modernised from J. N. DarbyOriginal wording

Summary

- Scattered. The dispersion was not an accident of history — the God behind it is the God who gathers, and He sends that news to the nations.

- Ransomed. The price side of the rescue rests on blood. The return from Babylon was only a sample and a pledge of what is still coming.

- Redeemed. A captor stronger than Jacob held him. So the Kinsman comes with a stronger arm and breaks the bond by power.

- Complete. The Lord Himself does the delivering. So weakness in His people cannot limit their enjoyment of it.

- Everlasting. A love that never ends holds the whole rescue, together with a new covenant God Himself will establish.

Jeremiah 31:12 · Darby

And they shall come and sing aloud upon the height of Zion, and shall flow together to the goodness of Jehovah, for corn, and for new wine, and for oil, and for the young of the flock and of the herd; and their soul shall be as a watered garden, and they shall not languish any more at all.

This verse belongs to a promise of Israel's restoration, and it says what the people will do when they come home — sing, gather, and be satisfied. Two questions follow: who is it for, and when has it ever happened?

A Promise That Outgrew the Return from Babylon

The promise takes in both families of God's people. Commentators say a small return from exile could never exhaust it, and they point to something later in the chapter for the reason.

Both families (chapter 31) would be His people. This shows at once that it was not only the restoration from Babylon. God declares that His love is an everlasting love. He redeemed Jacob (v. 11); they would come and sing in the height of Zion. Verse 31 declares that all this rests on establishing the new covenant.

Modernised from J. N. DarbyOriginal wording

Others press the point that the wording itself blocks any attempt to turn these named peoples into figures of something else.

As though to guard against the spiritualizing mode of interpretation, which would explain away such prophecies in the attempt to apply them to the Church and to Christianity, we are told, "And these are the words that the Lord spoke concerning Israel and concerning Judah." They are not words concerning something else figuratively represented under the names of Israel and Judah, but words spoken by the Lord — solemn thought! — concerning Israel and Judah.

Modernised from W. TrotterOriginal wording

One Flock, Flowing Together

The ESV says the people will be radiant over the goodness of the LORD; older translations read that they will flow together to it. One writer takes that word at face value: sheep long kept apart move as one stream once the barriers come down.

They shall "flow together"! Take the fences away! That is what the one flock will do. Let the scatterers stop their scattering! The sheep will flow together to the goodness of the Lord. The good Shepherd knows His own sheep and they know Him. Let the hindrances disappear, and the freed sheep — the one flock — will happily flow together and flock around the One who gave His life for the sheep.

Modernised from H. J. VineOriginal wording

Grain, Wine and Oil

The verse names grain, wine and oil, then adds the young of the flock and the herd. The three crops are not a random list.

See how fully God set blessing before Israel. "The corn, the wine, and the oil" are joined together again and again in Deuteronomy and other scriptures. They take in the produce of the field, the vineyard and the orchard. God makes all of it yield its increase in blessing. Of Him it is said, "The earth is the LORD's and the fullness thereof."

Modernised from The Christian's FriendOriginal wording

God once promised these same things on terms Israel failed to keep. What changes now is the footing they rest on.

Sin had interfered with the giving of blessing to the earth. Redemption reconnects the broken links, and the chain is complete. This shows most plainly when the Lord Jesus reigns in glory over the earth. Jezreel — the place once of sin and judgment, now of mercy — calls to the corn and the wine and the oil, as the evidence of God's favour, and in line with His promise at the beginning. Israel forfeited it then, because God made it conditional on obedience. It is secure now through restoring grace.

Modernised from The Bible TreasuryOriginal wording

The Watered Garden

In that part of the world a garden lived or died by its water supply. The image has an opposite as well.

Water was always necessary. In Eden a river watered the garden, and so people described a fruitful place as well watered, "like the garden of the LORD" (Genesis 13:10). The picture also stands for great blessing. When Israel is restored, "their life shall be like a watered garden" (Jeremiah 31:12). Under God's judgments, though, they were like a garden without water (Isaiah 1:30).

Modernised from Morrish Bible DictionaryOriginal wording

Israel's trouble was never the water supply. It was their own drift away from God.

The people of Israel were planted beside the waters. That is to say, they were in direct relationship with the LORD. Yet they kept turning aside from Him, to their own hurt as well as to His dishonour. But a day is coming when the people will turn back to the One they have so badly neglected. They will see God in Christ… Let us avoid Israel's failure. Let us hold fast to the Head, from whom the whole body … grows with a growth that is from God (Colossians 2:19).

Modernised from W. W. FeredayOriginal wording

Sorrow Ended — and Still Awaited

The verse ends with a promise: they will languish no more. Centuries have passed with no sign of it. One writer answers that difficulty in the words of the people who will one day sing this song.

Ages have passed since Jeremiah wrote these words. Generations have come and gone, yet these promises are unfulfilled. How, then, can they feel sure it will be fulfilled to them, in their day? … In the land as the restored remnant, though outside Jerusalem, they have seen the soil grow fertile again. It lay uncultivated for so long, keeping its sabbath. Now it yields its fruit in plenty. God has remembered the land.

Modernised from The Bible TreasuryOriginal wording

Summary

- Gathered. The scattered flock comes home. This promise is far too large for the return from Babylon. It rests on everlasting love and the new covenant.

- Flowing. Take the barriers away, and the one flock flows together around the One who gave His life for the sheep.

- Goodness. Field, vineyard and orchard — grain, wine and oil — are the evidence of God's favour. Israel forfeited them under conditions; restoring grace makes them secure.

- Watered. A garden lives by its water. A life like a watered garden is a people back in direct relationship with the LORD — the opposite of the dry garden of judgment.

- Unending. Sorrow ends for good. Faith holds the promise through centuries of delay, reading the land's new fruitfulness as God remembering.

Jeremiah 31:13 · Darby

Then shall the virgin rejoice in the dance, and the young men and old together; for I will turn their mourning into gladness, and will comfort them, and make them rejoice after their sorrow.

Jeremiah wrote to a nation about to lose its land, its city and its temple. Into that darkness God sets a picture of dancing, of young and old glad together, and of grief that He Himself turns to joy. Two questions follow: who is this joy for, and why has it not come yet?

Whose Joy This Is

One writer points to how carefully the prophecy names who it is about.

It is as if God guards against the way of reading prophecy that treats it as a symbol — explaining such promises away by applying them to the Church and to Christianity. So we are told, "And these are the words that the Lord spoke concerning Israel and concerning Judah." They are not words about something else pictured under the names of Israel and Judah. They are words spoken by the Lord (a solemn thought!) about Israel and about Judah.

Modernised from W. TrotterOriginal wording

History records only one small return from exile. One writer says this promise is far bigger than that.

This is not a return of Judah only, but of all twelve tribes. How different from the small remnant of Jews, with a few stragglers from other tribes, under Ezra and Nehemiah! Here all the families of Israel are in view.

Modernised from William KellyOriginal wording

The Reason Behind the Reversal

The verse gives no human cause for the change. Three times the verse names God as the one who acts — He turns, He comforts, He gives gladness. One writer traces that back to what God says of Himself earlier in the same chapter.

In chapter 31 the Holy Spirit goes on encouraging the heart with bright hopes of the coming glory. He makes known that the secret behind it all is the unchanging, eternal love of God. He says, "Yes, I have loved you with an everlasting love; therefore I have drawn you with loving-kindness. Again I will build you, and you shall be built, O virgin of Israel. You shall be adorned with tambourines again, and shall go out in the dances of those who celebrate" (vv. 3-4).

Modernised from H. J. VineOriginal wording

Young and Old Together

The verse puts young and old in the same celebration. One writer sees a picture of unity here; the translation he used reads "young men and old together."

Jeremiah 31:13 shows a scene of mourning that the Lord turns into joy, where young and old are united together.

Modernised from F. A. HughesOriginal wording

Another writer stands back and looks at the whole scene, and at what has happened to sorrow in it.

Sorrow is shut out for ever. Young and old, unmarried and married, join to show their cheerfulness and delight. Sorrow and mourning are mentioned only as things now past — mentioned to mark the contrast between past and present.

Modernised from W. TrotterOriginal wording

A Promise Still Outstanding

The promise has waited a long time. One writer does not hide the difficulty.

Ages have passed since these words were written. Generations have come and gone, yet these promises are unfulfilled. How, then, can God's people feel sure it will be fulfilled to them, in their day?

Modernised from The Bible TreasuryOriginal wording

One writer answers by turning to the nations who are watching, and to what they still fail to grasp.

His promises made to Israel will not fail. The nations should understand, as they do not, that Israel will yet become the head of all the nations of the earth. What singing that will be in that day of which the prophet speaks. What rejoicing after their sorrow! What fullness will be theirs!

Modernised from Arno Clemens GaebeleinOriginal wording

Comfort for Those Who Mourn Now

The verse looks ahead to a day when no one mourns. One writer asks what that leaves for people who mourn today.

The coming kingdom will have no place for mourners: all will rejoice then; but those who mourn now, feeling the ruin of outward conditions, will be blessed in the sweetness of being comforted by God.

Modernised from Leslie M. GrantOriginal wording

Summary

- Turned, not faded. The mourning does not wear off with time; God says He will turn it, comfort them, and give gladness — every verb is His.

- Turned by love. The reason lies earlier in the chapter: an everlasting love that draws, builds, and restores the dance.

- Turned for Israel. God speaks these words about Israel and Judah, and about all twelve tribes — far more than the small group that came back under Ezra and Nehemiah.

- Turned for everyone. Young women, young men and the old share one gladness; the joy joins the generations.

- Turned, but not yet. Generations have passed and the promise still waits. Faith rests on God's word, not on the calendar — and those who mourn now are comforted by Him.

Jeremiah 31:14 · Darby

And I will satiate the soul of the priests with fatness, and my people shall be satisfied with my goodness, saith Jehovah.

Jeremiah is a book full of judgment, yet here God promises the opposite: priests filled with the best He has, and a whole nation satisfied with His goodness. Three questions follow — who these priests are, when this happens, and why God's goodness satisfies when nothing else does.

The Close of a Complete Deliverance

The promise closes a chapter about God gathering His scattered people and bringing them home for good.

Judah, the people Jeremiah's prophecies were addressed to, would not be the only ones restored. All the families of Israel would enjoy this blessing. Jehovah would be their God, and they would be His people... The Lord Himself works this deliverance, so it is complete. Weakness cannot spoil their enjoyment of it. It is a deliverance that melts the heart and brings tears and pleading, but it removes every cause for tears except grace. They will sorrow no more. Their soul will be like a watered garden. They will be satisfied with goodness from Jehovah... This will come through a new covenant — not the one made when they came out of Egypt. The law will be written in their heart. They will all know Jehovah, and none of their sins will be remembered any more.

Modernised from J. N. DarbyOriginal wording

Words About Israel, Meant About Israel

Some read such promises as pictures of the Church. One writer answers that head on.

Some explain such prophecies away by applying them to the Church and to Christianity. As if to guard against that, we are told, "And these are the words that the Lord spoke concerning Israel and concerning Judah." They are not words about something else pictured under the names of Israel and Judah. They are words the Lord spoke — a solemn thought — about Israel and about Judah.

Modernised from W. TrotterOriginal wording

Christ's return in power sets the timing.

His second coming will end wars. He comes whose Person is the answer to every question and the solution to every problem. He comes to deliver His people and to reign supreme... Jeremiah 31 describes the joy of Israel at that moment, when they will come and sing aloud on the height of Zion.

Modernised from James McBroomOriginal wording

The Portion That Belonged to God

Older translations read "fatness" here rather than "abundance." Why that word?

It would mean enjoying the very best that God's own circle provides. It is striking that the fat is included, because in the sacrifices the fat belonged to God. Still, we do read in Psalm 36, "They shall be abundantly satisfied with the fatness of Your house, and You shall make them drink of the river of Your pleasures."

Modernised from George DavisonOriginal wording

The priestly name will belong to the whole nation. Others will supply them.

God will renew the land, rebuild the ruined cities, and make the strangers who once despised them their servants. But the crown of it all will be their spiritual blessing. They will be the "Priests of Jehovah" and "Ministers of God" in the coming age. Under the law the offerings of the ordinary people supported the priests. So it will be for them, and in abundant measure, for they are going to "eat the riches of the Gentiles."

Modernised from F. B. HoleOriginal wording

Filled to the Full, Not Sampled

How much do God's people themselves expect from this promise?

They speak with confidence, not just about the righteous, but about themselves. "We shall be satisfied." The blessing will come in their day. With the word of God before them, what else could they expect? It is grace indeed, but God had beforehand announced it. What they look for now is not a taste of goodness, a slight sense of what God could give. They look to be filled to the full.

Modernised from The Bible TreasuryOriginal wording

Filled Is Not the Same as Satisfied

Being full and being satisfied are not the same thing.

A man may hunger after the world and not be filled; the world is fading, not filling. A man may be filled and not satisfied. A sinner may take his fill of sin, but it is far from satisfaction, "The backslider in heart shall be filled with his own ways" (Prov. 14:14). This is the kind of filling the lost in hell have; they will be full of the fury of the Lord. But whoever hungers after righteousness will be filled and satisfied. "My people shall be satisfied with My goodness" (Jer. 31:14).

Modernised from Hamilton SmithOriginal wording

Summary

- Source. God works the deliverance Himself, under a new covenant where He remembers their sins no more. So it is complete, and no weakness of theirs can hold it back.

- Gift. In the sacrifices the fat belonged to God. Here He gives away His own best.

- Reach. Priests first, then "my people." In that day the whole nation carries the priestly name, and the nations supply it.

- Measure. Not a taste of goodness, but being filled to the full — and God announced it beforehand, so they expect it.

- Result. The world can fill a person and leave him empty. Only God's goodness fills and satisfies.

Jeremiah 31:15 · Darby

Thus saith Jehovah A voice hath been heard in Ramah, the wail of very bitter weeping, -- Rachel weeping for her children, refusing to be comforted for her children, because they are not.

Jeremiah 31 promises that God will bring His people home, and then it stops for a mother's cry in Ramah. Why is Rachel weeping here, and why does Matthew quote her when Herod's soldiers reach Bethlehem?

The Town in the Verse

Ramah is a real town with a hard history. Rachel's descendants were going into exile when this cry went up.

The Rama or Ramah spoken of in these verses was a city of the tribe of Benjamin, some 5–10 miles north of Jerusalem (Joshua 18:21 and 25). The Assyrian, the rod of His anger, had already removed the ten tribes — the kingdom of Israel — out of the Lord's sight (2 Kings 17; Isaiah 10:5). The tribes of Ephraim and Manasseh, the descendants of Joseph, the first son of Rachel, were among them. Now Nebuchadnezzar was removing the tribe of Benjamin, Rachel's second son, along with the tribe of Judah, "at the commandment of the Lord" (2 Kings 24).

Modernised from Truth & TestimonyOriginal wording

Why Rachel

Two things tie Rachel to Bethlehem: her grave and her son.

Why Rachel's voice? While Bethlehem belonged to the tribe of Judah, Benjamin was next to them; and you remember Benjamin was Rachel's son. Bethlehem is first mentioned in connection with Rachel's death (Gen. 35:16-20), and her tomb was "in the border of Benjamin, at Zelzah" (1 Sam. 10:2). This bit of land, belonging to the tribe of Benjamin, dipped down into the land of Judah. A little building still marks the site of her tomb, about a mile north of Bethlehem, on the main road from Jerusalem and Bethel.

Modernised from W. T. P. WolstonOriginal wording

Herod's soldiers reached into Benjamin's ground too, and the voice raised over it belongs to a woman centuries dead.

Herod was so determined to sweep the area clear that he had children killed not only in Bethlehem, but in the districts around it — the parts of Benjamin just mentioned. Rachel had been dead for centuries and centuries, but the Spirit of God puts it in this remarkable way, as if her spirit had risen from the dead. Rachel's voice is lifted up in weeping over this terrible slaughter of so many of her own children, as well as the murdered infants of the tribe of Judah. Her cries of sorrow are heard even in Ramah, the chief town of Benjamin.

Modernised from W. T. P. WolstonOriginal wording

Sorrow That Turns

The sorrow in this verse is not the end of the road. One writer finds the turn in the two names of Rachel's son.

The story begins in chapter 30, and Jacob's name becomes prominent at once. Like his, the nation's way to the glory is through trial and trouble. The reference to Rachel's anguish (Jer. 31:15) points the same way. But "Benoni" — the son of her sorrow — becomes "Benjamin" — the son of the right hand.

Modernised from H J VineOriginal wording

Matthew Quotes Half

Matthew applies this verse to the killing at Bethlehem. He stops at the tears and leaves out the promise that comes next.

It is beautiful to see that the Holy Spirit (Matt. 2:17-18) applies to that event the passage about sorrow but not that about joy. Here is what follows: "Thus says the Lord: Keep your voice from weeping, and your eyes from tears, for there is a reward for your work, declares the Lord, and they shall come back from the land of the enemy" (verse 16).

Modernised from William KellyOriginal wording

The place made the grief sharper. This was the town where the King was born.

There was bitter sorrow then, even in the birthplace of royalty. Deep anguish was in the place where there ought to have been the greatest joy. The birth of the Messiah ought to have been the signal for universal joy in the land of Israel. And there would have been if there had been faith in God and His promise, but there was not.

Modernised from William KellyOriginal wording

The Comfort Left on the Page

Comfort was within their reach in the same chapter. They only had to read on.

But what comfort there would have been for them if they had turned to the Scripture which spoke of their sorrow. There we read, "The Lord appeared to Me from far away, saying: Yes, I have loved you with an everlasting love; therefore I have continued My faithfulness to you… and there is hope for your future, declares the Lord, that your children shall come back to their own country" (Jer. 31).

Modernised from J. T. MawsonOriginal wording

Still to Be Finished

Bethlehem was a real fulfilment, but not the last one. The verse's promise of a journey home is still ahead.

Read that verse with its context, and you will see that its final and complete fulfilment comes in the last days. Then God will end Rachel's weeping by bringing her children back from the land of the enemy. Still, what took place at Bethlehem was the same kind of thing on a smaller scale.

Modernised from F. B. HoleOriginal wording

Summary

- Ramah. A town of Benjamin, north of Jerusalem — the chief town of the tribe Nebuchadnezzar was carrying away.

- Rachel. Mother of Joseph and Benjamin. She died near Bethlehem, and the tribes of both her sons went into exile.

- Refused. She would not be comforted. Yet the next verses tell her to dry her eyes: there is a reward, a return, and a future.

- Repeated. Herod's killing at Bethlehem was the same sorrow on a smaller scale. Matthew quotes the grief and stops before the joy.

- Restored. Benoni became Benjamin. Sorrow first, then the children come home — a return still ahead.

Jeremiah 31:16 · Darby

Thus saith Jehovah Refrain thy voice from weeping, and thine eyes from tears; for there is a reward for thy work, saith Jehovah; and they shall come again from the land of the enemy.

In the verse just before this one, Rachel weeps for her children and will not be comforted. God answers her here, and commentators trace that answer from the exile in Babylon to the mothers of Bethlehem, and on to the day the children come home.

Whose Weeping This Is

Commentators read Rachel's cry as the grief of a nation carried off to Babylon. They also hear in it a promise: the day when God makes a new covenant with Israel and Judah.

In Jeremiah 31:15-17 there is a very touching reference to Rachel and a connection with the affliction of "her children" in the day of the captivity to Babylon. But it looks on to the blessed time of gracious repayment, when the LORD will make a new covenant with the house of Israel and with the house of Judah.

Modernised from William KellyOriginal wording

The refusal to be comforted lasts as long as the exile does.

She appears before us as a true Rachel. As we know, she now refuses to be comforted, and will refuse until her "children shall come again to her own border" (Jeremiah 31:15-17). Such is the heart of the children of Israel.

Modernised from J. G. BellettOriginal wording

Matthew's Half of the Prophecy

Matthew quotes this passage after Herod's killing at Bethlehem. He quotes the sorrow of verse 15 and stops.

In this chapter we find the well-known scripture that is applied to Herod's destruction of the children at Bethlehem. It is beautiful to see that the Holy Spirit (Matthew 2:17-18) applies to that event the passage about sorrow but not the one about joy.

Modernised from William KellyOriginal wording

The grieving mothers had the answer to their own grief lying a few lines further down the page.

But what comfort there would have been for them if they had turned to the Scripture which spoke of their sorrow. There we read, "The LORD appeared to Me from far away, saying, I have loved you with an everlasting love; therefore I have continued My faithfulness to you… Keep your voice from weeping, and your eyes from tears, for there is a reward for your work, declares the LORD, and they shall come back from the land of the enemy."

Modernised from J T MawsonOriginal wording

Sorrow at Night, Joy in the Morning

Because Matthew used only half the prophecy, the other half is still waiting.

So the Holy Spirit applied the first part of the prophecy, but there He stops. When the entire prophecy is fulfilled, there will be sorrow again in the land, great sorrow, but there will also be joy. "Weeping may tarry for the night, but joy comes with the morning." "And there is hope for your future, declares the LORD, and your children shall come back to their own country" (verse 17).

Modernised from William KellyOriginal wording

The Reward for the Work

One writer reads the "work" of this verse as the nation's travail, and looks ahead to the moment it is paid.

Even this anguish points on to the future travail of the nation, just before their labour is rewarded (v. 16). The reward is the presence of Christ with them, their Messiah in resurrection life, the Man Child who has been brought forth before their travail (see Isaiah 66:7). All of this about Rachel and her children shows the comforting truth: joy comes in the morning, though weeping may last through the night.

Modernised from H J VineOriginal wording

Return From the Land of the Enemy

Rachel's children "are not" — they are gone. So the promise that they will come back needs a power reaching past death.

Faith trusts the LORD, but Rachel has to learn that only resurrection holds life and power. For nature there must be a voice "heard in Ramah, lamentation and bitter weeping" — "weeping for her children, and no comfort, because they are not." Yet the LORD says: Keep your voice from weeping, and your eyes from tears. In the power of Him who is in resurrection "they shall come back from the land of the enemy", and there is hope for the time to come.

Modernised from The Bible TreasuryOriginal wording

God gives His people something to hold while they wait.

Hope is the handkerchief that God puts into His people's hands, to wipe the tears from their eyes — tears drawn out by their present troubles and the long wait for mercies they expect (Jeremiah 31:16-17).

Modernised from Hamilton SmithOriginal wording

Summary

- Weeping. Rachel's cry is a nation's grief in exile. That sorrow refuses comfort until the children come home.

- Quoted. Matthew applies only the sorrow of verse 15 to the children killed at Bethlehem. The joy of verse 16 is still ahead.

- Reward. The command to stop crying rests on a promise. The labour has a reward, and one writer names that reward as Christ Himself, present with His people.

- Return. Children who "are not" come back only by resurrection power — the enemy's land does not get the last word.

- Hope. God does not ask for dry eyes without giving the handkerchief; hope is what He puts in the hand of the one still waiting.

Jeremiah 31:17 · Darby

And there is hope for thy latter end, saith Jehovah, and thy children shall come again to their own border.

God speaks here to a grieving mother who refuses all comfort, and He answers her with a future: the loss is not the last chapter. Two questions follow. What "hope" is left when the children are already gone? And where is "their own country" for a people scattered far from home?

A promise that follows the weeping

The verse before it records grief. This verse turns that grief toward morning. One writer notes that Matthew, quoting the lament over the boys killed at Bethlehem, stops there and leaves the rest unsaid.

The Gospel writer did not quote this verse. He only referred to what was fulfilled. … So the Holy Spirit applied the first part of the prophecy, but there He stops. When the whole prophecy comes true, there will be sorrow in the land again, great sorrow, but there will also be joy. "Weeping may endure for a night, but joy comes in the morning."

Modernised from William KellyOriginal wording

The limits of Matthew's quotation

Because the tears of Bethlehem matched Jeremiah's words, some treat that as the whole meaning. The same writer weighs that against the way Matthew introduces the quotation.

It is pointless to quote Matthew 2 as if it proved that verse 15 was completely fulfilled there. The wording Matthew uses points out no more than a likeness in spirit between the prophecy he quotes and the event. It does not say the event was what the prophecy aimed at.

Modernised from William KellyOriginal wording

A homecoming, not a resurrection

One commentator reads the promise as ruling out the idea that the dead children themselves rise. It speaks of captives coming back — and of the change of heart that follows.

But the promise, "they shall come back from the land of the enemy" and "your children shall come back to their own country," clearly shows that captivity is also meant. Rachel's children (Joseph and Benjamin, that is, Ephraim) will return from it after the final tribulation and weeping. Physical resurrection is not in view here. That is why the next verse speaks of Ephraim moaning and repenting. Then comes God's gracious answer: "Is Ephraim My dear son? — I will surely have mercy on him."

Modernised from Arno Clemens GaebeleinOriginal wording

Commentators differ over which part of the nation is in view. Another writer reads verse 8 of the ten tribes, and verses 16 and 17 of the two tribes.

Then God will fulfil what is said here of the ten tribes: "Behold, I will bring them from the north country, and gather them from the farthest parts of the earth…" (verse 8). He will also fulfil what is said of the two tribes: "Keep your voice from weeping, and your eyes from tears… they shall come back from the land of the enemy… and your children shall come back to their own country" (verses 16 and 17).

Modernised from Truth & TestimonyOriginal wording

Deepest darkness before the dawn

The hope points forward, and the road to it runs through more pain. One writer sets Rachel's anguish beside a time of trouble still ahead for the nation, and names the reward promised in verse 16.

Even this anguish points on to the nation's future birth pangs, just before their labour receives its reward (v. 16): the presence of Christ with them, their Messiah in resurrection life, the Man Child brought forth before their birth pangs (see Isaiah 66:7). All of this with Rachel and her children shows the comforting truth that joy comes in the morning, though weeping may last for a night.

Modernised from H. J. VineOriginal wording

Hope as God's answer to tears

God's answer to tears does not deny the loss. He puts something in the mourner's hand instead. One writer pictures what hope does for people worn down by trouble and by mercies that are slow in coming.

Hope is the handkerchief that God puts into His people's hands. With it they wipe away the tears that their present troubles, and the long wait for expected mercies, draw from their eyes.

Modernised from Hamilton SmithOriginal wording

One writer draws this same word into the grief of the Lord Jesus over the cities that would not repent. True grief, he notes, is found where nothing around offers help.

"Then He began to denounce the cities where most of His mighty works had been done, because they did not repent." Here was true grief, and fully felt as grief. There is no true grief except where there is no help around; and Jesus had none around Him. "Rachel weeping for her children, refusing to be comforted because they are no more" — the word to her was, "There is hope for your future."

Modernised from J. N. DarbyOriginal wording

Summary

- Weeping — The grief is real, and God names it before He answers it. The verse does not talk the mourner out of her tears.

- Word — Matthew quotes only the sorrow of this passage. The promise attached to it still stands, waiting to be kept.

- Return — The hope is a homecoming. Children come back from enemy land to their own country; the dead are not raised here.

- Repentance — The road home runs through Ephraim's mourning, and God answers it with mercy.

- Reward — Night comes before morning. Christ's presence with His people rewards their labour at last, and hope is the handkerchief God gives them for the wait.