The word that came to Jeremiah from Jehovah, saying,
Chapter 18 opens with the briefest introduction Jeremiah ever gives: a word came to him from the LORD. What follows is not a sermon but an errand. God sends His prophet to a workshop, where a potter at his wheel becomes His picture of what He is doing with a whole nation.
God first tells His servant where to go. He promises to speak once Jeremiah arrives.
In Jeremiah 18:1-2, the LORD tells His servant to "go down to the potter's house," and there He would cause him to hear His words. Jeremiah obeyed and went. He saw the potter working on a vessel at the wheel: "And the vessel he was making of clay was spoiled in the potter's hand." The potter then took the clay again and made it "another vessel, as it seemed good to the potter to do."
God did not leave the sign unexplained. He told Jeremiah what it meant for Israel.
Having seen what the potter did, the LORD spoke to His servant as He had promised. He addressed His words to the house of Israel. God was teaching His servant about His sovereignty: "Can I not do with you as this potter has done? … Behold, like the clay in the potter's hand, so are you in my hand, O house of Israel" (Jer. 18:5-6). Israel was not free to do as it pleased, for it was in God's hand, and He could do with it as He pleased.
The same hand shapes every other kingdom too.
The circle of civilization is to Him just what the workshop is to the potter. As the potter holds the clay and moulds it into vessels of many shapes, so the LORD holds the nations in His hands. He fashions and forms them as He thinks good. Who shall question the work of God? … Where is haughty Assyria, and corrupt Babylonia? How low has He brought Persia and Greece and Rome for their sins! … Broken and rejected kingdoms, like the potter's useless earthenware, lie scattered over the face of the ground.
Israel was that spoiled vessel. God had given the nation every advantage first.
God in His goodness had brought them out of Egypt, and had planted them in the land of promise to be a witness for Himself to the nations of the world. He had hedged them in, keeping them apart from the nations so that they might be free from all their pollutions. He had protected them, and had given them His law, so that they might know how to be pure as a people for Himself. But they proved to be spoiled in the hand of the potter. They had become polluted with idolatry. Their kings, their priests, their princes, their elders, and the people themselves were all caught up in the ruin that was about to bring the judgment of God upon them.
The potter's right does not lock the outcome. One commentator points to a city that proved it.
If God threatens a nation with destruction and that nation turns to the LORD, He will relent of the disaster He pronounced on it. Jonah's prediction of Nineveh's overthrow is a full illustration of this, and that prediction came from God. Nineveh repented, and God did not carry out the judgment on that generation. But if the LORD has promised a nation good and that nation does evil in His sight, He will relent of the good He had promised them. So the potter's action carries a great lesson: the lesson of God's sovereignty, to do as He pleases, yet always in perfect righteousness.
But "relent" does not mean God had second thoughts about a mistake.
This change of mind on God's part … does not imply any regret about His original decision. Instead, it shows His grace and righteousness in suspending the sentence when He sees the least sign of repentance in the guilty one.
The same hand that shapes nations works on one person, and the dividing line is how each person answers His word.
He sees a flaw, an imperfection in the clay. Others, looking on, have not spotted it, as the artist's eye does. He crushes the clay under his hand into a shapeless mass again. And again his fingers mould and fashion it into his design. Again and again defects appear. Again and again the clay is reduced to a shapeless mass, until at last it rises before him in perfect design; his eye surveys it with satisfaction and pride, and he takes it from the wheel to place it among the choice things of the earth.
That same hand still divides between two outcomes, and the dividing line is the response to His word.
Every individual, like every nation, is a spoiled vessel in the hand of the Potter, for sin has spoiled us all, and we have taken our own evil way. There are those who, like Israel, will not listen to the word of God through His servants — the word of mercy proclaimed in the gospel — and God has the power to make these spoiled vessels into vessels of wrath. Again, there are those who, like the Ninevites, listen to the message of God, and turn from their evil ways to God, and God makes them vessels of mercy. No man can escape from the hand of God.
- Word — the message starts as an errand: God sends His servant to a potter's house and promises to speak there.
- Wheel — the workshop is to the potter what the whole span of civilization is to God. He shapes the nations, and broken kingdoms lie about like discarded earthenware.
- Flaw — Israel was the spoiled vessel. God rescued, planted and fenced off that nation and gave it His law, yet idolatry polluted it from kings down to people.
- Turn — the potter's right is not a locked verdict. Nineveh turned, and God relented. That is grace suspending a sentence, not God regretting a mistake.
- Vessel — the same hand works on one life. Every person is spoiled clay. Those who refuse His word become vessels of wrath, those who listen become vessels of mercy, and no one escapes the hand of God.
Arise and go down to the potter's house, and there I will cause thee to hear my words.
Before God gives Jeremiah a word for the nation, He sends him down to a potter's workshop. Why must the prophet watch a craftsman at his wheel first?
The order matters. God promised the word at the potter's house, and Jeremiah had to go there before he heard it.
In Jeremiah 18:1-2, the Lord tells His servant to "go down to the potter's house," and there He would cause him to hear His words. Jeremiah obeyed the word of the Lord. He went to the potter's house and saw him working at his wheel. "And the vessel he was making of clay was spoiled in the potter's hand." The potter then took the clay again and made it "another vessel, as it seemed good to the potter to do."
The place God chose was an ordinary workshop, and the trade itself carried the lesson.
Scripture says of the potter that he treads the clay to make it pliable, Isaiah 41:25; and he forms his vessel on a wheel. Jeremiah 18:3. In the East, potters make much of the ordinary pottery in a very simple way. The workman turns the wheel with his feet, and with his hands he forms the vessel as it pleases him.
God then spoke, and He argued from the smaller case to the greater one.
Then came the message: "O house of Israel, can I not do with you as this potter has done? declares the Lord. Behold, like the clay in the potter's hand, so are you in My hand, O house of Israel." If a creature of dust can do as he pleases with the clay, how much more can the Sovereign God. The Holy Spirit evidently uses this in Romans 9:20-32.
The lesson does not stop at Israel. Whole empires have passed through those hands — and on one point the picture is unlike a potter's.
The circle of civilization is to Him just what the workshop is to the potter. The potter holds the clay and shapes it into vessels of many forms. In the same way, the Lord holds the nations in His hands, fashioning and forming as He thinks good… Where is haughty Assyria, and corrupt Babylonia? How low has He brought Persia and Greece and Rome for their sins!… O Lord, You are unlike the potter in this, for You have said: "If that nation, concerning which I have spoken, turns from its evil, I will relent of the disaster that I intended to do to it."
Israel was the spoiled lump on the wheel. Judgment had not yet fallen, and there was a reason for the delay.
In longsuffering and mercy God was waiting. He was looking for some evidence of repentance, so that He might delay the judgment He had predicted long before, or in mercy turn from His anger and bless them. They could not escape from the hand of God. But God was ready, like the potter, to make them into another vessel, a vessel that would be for His pleasure.
Yet mercy meets a real turning, not a claimed one.
The will of man is only evil. The sole hope is in God Himself. But Israel, like Christendom now, feels neither, even where people confess both in words. Where grace works there is a real turning from evil, and man is quick to claim the credit of it.
The same picture fits one man: Saul of Tarsus, who became the apostle Paul.
That was a wonderful transformation. It is very like the picture given us in Jeremiah 18:2-6, where the potter worked the shapeless clay. First the vessel was in the mind of the potter. Then he worked at the wheel and formed the vessel. Then the mind of the potter was in the vessel. From eternity God had a purpose in mind about Saul. Now He picks him up and converts him. His will is broken, and from that moment he becomes a most blessed servant of Christ.
- Go. God promised the word at the potter's house, not before it. Jeremiah obeyed, and then he heard.
- See. An everyday workshop taught it. The potter softens the clay, turns the wheel with his feet, and shapes the vessel as he pleases.
- Hear. If a man of dust may do as he likes with clay, far more may the Sovereign God — the argument Romans 9 later takes up.
- Turn. Here God is unlike the potter: when a nation turns from its evil, He relents of the disaster He intended.
- Be formed. God remakes the spoiled lump; He does not throw it away. First the vessel is in the Potter's mind, then the Potter's mind is in the vessel.
And I went down to the potter's house; and behold, he wrought a work on the wheels.
God sends Jeremiah on an errand with no explanation: walk to a craftsman's shop and watch. A message for a whole nation would come through an ordinary man at an ordinary wheel.
The order came with a promise: go, and God would speak there.
In Jeremiah 18:1–2, the Lord tells His servant to "go down to the potter's house," and there He would let him hear His words. Jeremiah obeyed the word of the Lord and went to the potter's house. There he saw him working on a vessel at the wheel: "the vessel he was making of clay was spoiled in the potter's hand." The potter then took the clay again and made it "another vessel, as it seemed good to the potter to do."
What Jeremiah watched was ordinary trade work, done with feet and hands.
Of the potter Scripture says he treads the clay to make it pliable (Isaiah 41:25). He forms his vessel on a wheel (Jeremiah 18:3). Much of the ordinary pottery in the East is made in a very simple way. The workman turns the wheel with his feet, and with his hands he forms the vessel as it pleases him.
One question decides the scene: where is the vessel while the wheel still turns? And what happens when the clay will not hold the design?
The workman takes the lump of clay; he presses it to the wheel; the wheel turns before his eye. Where now, let me ask, is the vessel? It is in the mind of the potter, before it is formed: the design is there. His fingers shape the mass before him. Little by little it grows up before his eye. Little by little the thought in his mind passes into the clay. It rises up before him, and the thoughts unspoken until now grow into the vessel his fingers are forming. He sees a flaw, an imperfection in the clay. Others looking on have not spotted it; the artist's eye has. He crushes the clay under his hand into a shapeless mass again. And again his fingers shape and fashion it into his design. Again and again defects appear. Again and again he reduces the clay to a shapeless mass, until at last it rises before him in perfect design.
God explains the picture by reasoning from the workman up to Himself. The New Testament picks up the same reasoning.
If the creature of dust can do as he pleases with the clay, how much more the Sovereign God. The Holy Spirit clearly uses this in Romans 9:20–32.
The same lesson set a limit on the nation's freedom.
God was instructing His servant as to His sovereignty, saying, "Can I not do with you as this potter has done? declares the Lord. Behold, like the clay in the potter's hand, so are you in my hand, O house of Israel" (Jeremiah 18:5–6). The nation of Israel was not free to do exactly as it pleased, for it was in God's hand and He could do with it just as He pleased.
The picture is not only about power. It is about timing too: the clay stays soft only for a while.
Things had gone wrong with Israel. Idolatry had become widespread. The vessel had been marred. But the clay was still soft. There was still time to turn to God.
Writers see this picture acted out in one man's story.
In Acts 9 we read the wonderful account of Saul's conversion. Now this "chosen vessel" comes on the scene. His past history gave no sign of what he was to be. The apostle of man's deepest hatred against Christ would become the apostle of God's fullest grace to the Gentiles. The Great Potter (see Jeremiah 18:1–6) was about to take hold of a very unlikely-looking lump of clay and transform it. Until now that "chosen vessel" had been in the Potter's mind — from then on the Potter's mind would be in the vessel.
- Go down. God's word came only after Jeremiah obeyed and went. The workshop was the classroom where He promised to speak.
- Watch the wheel. The potter treads the clay soft, turns the wheel with his feet, and shapes the vessel with his hands as it pleases him.
- Mind before matter. The vessel exists in the potter's mind before his fingers touch the lump. The design comes first; the clay receives it.
- Clay in His hand. If a creature of dust may do as he pleases with clay, far more may the Sovereign God. Israel was never free to do exactly as it pleased.
- While it is soft. A marred vessel can still be remade. Saul the persecutor proves it: the Potter's mind ended up inside the vessel He chose.
And the vessel that he made was marred, as clay, in the hand of the potter; and he made it again another vessel, as seemed good to the potter to make.
God sent Jeremiah down to a potter's workshop. There a lump of clay collapsed under the potter's hands, and the potter shaped it a second time. God turned that everyday sight into a message for His people, and the message runs two ways at once: toward judgment and toward hope.
God promised to speak, but only after Jeremiah had gone down and watched.
In Jeremiah 18:1-2, the Lord tells His servant to "go down to the potter's house," and there He would cause him to hear His words. Obedient to the word of the Lord, Jeremiah went to the potter's house, and saw him working on a vessel on the wheels.
One writer widens that wheel to the size of the world:
The circle of civilization is to Him just what the workshop is to the potter. A potter holds the clay and shapes it into vessels of many different forms. In the same way the Lord holds the nations in His hands, shaping and forming them as He thinks good. Who shall question the work of God?... Broken and rejected kingdoms, like the potter's useless earthenware, strew the face of the ground.
The spoiled clay pictured the nation standing in front of Jeremiah. (Older translations use "marred" where the ESV has "spoiled.")
God in His goodness had brought them out of Egypt, and had planted them in the land of promise to be a witness for Himself to the nations of the world... Sadly, they were found marred in the hand of the potter. They had become polluted with idolatry. Their kings, their priests, their princes, their elders, and the people themselves were all involved in the ruin.
A potter throws out bad material. God does something no craftsman does: He turns back His own stated plan when a nation turns from evil.
The potter rightly rejects faulty material... "Lord, what desolation You have made in the earth! Yet You are righteous in all Your ways. And You are long-suffering and merciful also. For here You are unlike the potter. You have said: if that nation I have spoken about turns from its evil, then I will relent of the evil I had planned to do to them."
That change of course is not God changing His nature. It is God answering a real change in the one He is shaping. (Older translations say "repent" where the ESV of Numbers 23:19 says "change his mind.")
God "is not a man… that He should repent" (Num. 23:19), but He does repent when man changes, especially when man repents.
The potter did not patch the old shape. He pressed the clay down and began again. One writer sees in that the very pattern of grace.
This was to be no more repairing of the creature — such a thing would have been no fit work for God... But grace can make a new thing — not repairing the work marred on the wheel, but making it another vessel, as it seems good to the potter to make it. In its old state it was ruined, but in its ruins grace will take it up to make it a beautiful and pleasant vessel of the richest treasures.
One writer traces that second vessel to Israel's future:
We know that God will make another vessel, which is what the Lord Jesus was showing Nicodemus, as told in John 3. What is born of the flesh — even Abraham's flesh — is flesh. Only what is born of the Spirit is spirit. Only a born-again Israel will enter the Kingdom.
The clay collapses again and again. That is not failure — it is the potter's eye catching flaws no one else sees.
He sees a flaw, an imperfection in the clay. Others looking on have not spotted it, but the artist's eye has. He crushes the clay under his hand into a shapeless mass again. And again his fingers mould and fashion it into his design. Again and again defects appear. Again and again the clay is reduced to a shapeless mass, until at last it rises in perfect design before him.
One writer then asks where the potter himself has ended up:
Where is the potter now? Where was the vessel before he began? It was in the potter! Where is the potter now? He is in the vessel. All that his mind designed and worked is seen there. The vessel is fit for what he intended.
- Clay — nations and people are in God's hand, not their own. He shapes them as He sees good.
- Spoiled — God brought Israel out of Egypt to be His witness to the nations. Instead the whole nation went bad in His hands, from kings down to people.
- Relenting — here God is unlike a potter. He throws out no nation that turns from its evil, and He changes His announced course when people change.
- Remade — He does not repair the ruined shape. Grace takes the same clay and makes another vessel altogether.
- Filled — the crushing repeats until the design stands. The vessel that once lay in the Potter's mind now carries His mind inside it.
And the word of Jehovah came to me, saying,
Jeremiah had just watched a potter crush a spoiled lump of clay and start again. Now God speaks and gives that silent scene its meaning: it is a message about His right over a whole nation, and about the mercy He shows when a nation turns.
God sent Jeremiah to watch ordinary work before giving him anything to say. One writer sees more than a craftsman in that workshop:
He was to see a real work there; vessels made by the hand and skill of the workman. But there was a lesson in the work, as well as a reality. There was a parable in it; for the prophet had to see God Himself at the wheel, as well as the potter.
God aimed that word at a whole nation, and its first lesson is about who holds whom:
Having seen what the potter did, the Lord spoke to His servant as He had promised. He addressed His words to the house of Israel. God was instructing His servant as to His sovereignty, saying, "Can I not do with you as this potter has done? … Behold, like the clay in the potter's hand, so are you in my hand, O house of Israel" (Jer. 18:5-6). The nation of Israel was not free to do exactly as it pleased, for it was in God's hand and He could do with it just as He pleased.
The picture argues from the smaller to the greater:
If the creature of dust can do as he pleases with the clay, how much more the Sovereign God. The Holy Spirit clearly uses this in Romans 9:20-32.
The spoiled vessel matched what Israel had become:
God in His goodness had brought them out of Egypt. He had planted them in the land of promise to be a witness for Himself to the nations of the world. He had hedged them in, keeping them apart from the nations… Sadly, they were found marred in the hand of the potter. They had become polluted with idolatry; their kings, their priests, their princes, their elders, and the people themselves were all caught up in the ruin. That ruin was about to bring the judgment of God on them.
One writer sets out what the passage shows about man:
The will of man is only evil. The sole hope is in God Himself. But Israel, like Christendom now, feels neither, even where both are confessed in words. For where grace works there is a real turning from evil, and man is quick to claim the credit for it. On the other hand, man is prone to depart from the living God. And God would deny Himself if He made light of disobedience, and treated evil in His sight as if it were good.
God had already spared one guilty city:
How wonderful is God's mercy! He has no delight in judgment, but He delights in mercy… Jonah had pronounced the judgment of God on the guilty city, crying, "Yet forty days, and Nineveh shall be overthrown!"… Then we read, "When God saw what they did, how they turned from their evil way, God relented of the disaster that He had said He would do to them, and He did not do it." How very sad it is to see God's people Israel reject God's offers of mercy by refusing to turn from their evil ways! They were just as evil as the Ninevites, but with less excuse, since they had more light.
The picture does not stop with Israel:
In Jeremiah 18 we have seen God's ways with the nations, but in Romans 9 we learn something of God's ways with people… Every person, like every nation, is a marred vessel in the hand of the Potter. For we have all become marred by sin, and by taking our own evil way… Those who reject His mercy come in for judgment, and those who listen to Him He brings into blessing.
One writer points to a later scene where the clay is no longer soft:
This time it is not clay that can still be formed but an earthen vessel that has been hardened in the fire. It can only be broken. The message is clear but solemn. There is a time when discipline can be accepted for profit, and there is a time when it is too late.
- Sign, then word. Jeremiah watched real work at a wheel. Then God's word turned that scene into a message about Himself.
- Hand. The message is about position. A nation is clay, and God holds it. If a man may do as he pleases with clay, far more may the Sovereign God.
- Marred. Israel matched the spoiled vessel. Idolatry had reached kings, priests, princes, elders and people alike.
- Turn. God relents when a nation turns from evil. Nineveh proved it. Israel refused, with more light than Nineveh had.
- Remade. Romans 9 brings the picture down to each person: every one of us is marred clay in the Potter's hand. Those who listen to Him He brings into blessing. Clay left to harden can only be broken.
House of Israel, cannot I do with you as this potter? saith Jehovah. Behold, as the clay in the potter's hand, so are ye in my hand, house of Israel.
God sends Jeremiah to a workshop to watch a craftsman at his wheel. Then He turns that scene into a message for the whole nation. What does it mean to be clay in God's hand? Does that crush a people, or give them their only real hope?
The sign works by comparison. A man shaping a pot has full control over the lump in front of him. God presses that everyday fact into a much larger claim.
If a creature made of dust can do as he pleases with the clay, how much more the Sovereign God. The Holy Spirit clearly uses this in Romans 9:20-32.
The point lands on Israel's freedom to act:
The nation of Israel was not free to do exactly as it pleased, for it was in God's hand and He could do with it just as He pleased.
Jeremiah watched a vessel spoil under the potter's hands. That was the nation's state when God spoke — and not because God had neglected them.
In His goodness God had brought them out of Egypt. He had planted them in the land of promise to be a witness for Himself to the nations of the world. He fenced them in and kept them apart from the nations, so that they might be free from all their pollutions. He protected them. He gave them His law, so that they might know how to be pure as a people for Himself. Sadly, they turned out marred in the potter's hand.
The verse names Israel. One writer sees the same hand at work over every nation in history.
The circle of civilization is to Him just what the workshop is to the potter. The potter holds the clay and shapes it into vessels of many forms. In the same way the Lord holds the nations in His hands, shaping and forming them as He thinks good. Who can question the work of God?… Where is haughty Assyria, and corrupt Babylonia? How low has He brought Persia and Greece and Rome for their sins!
The clay is helpless, but a marred vessel was not thrown out of the workshop.
They could not escape from the hand of God, but God was prepared, like the potter, to make them into another vessel, a vessel that would be for His pleasure.
One writer marks the one point where the comparison breaks down:
In this You are unlike the potter, for You have said: "If that nation I have spoken about turns from its evil, then I will relent of the harm I meant to do to them."
Romans 9 picks up the potter and turns the picture on single lives. Commentators see the two chapters covering different ground.
In Jeremiah 18 we have seen God's ways with the nations. In Romans 9 we learn something of God's ways with people… Every person, like every nation, is a marred vessel in the hand of the Potter. We have all become marred by sin, and by taking our own evil way… Those who reject His mercy come in for judgment, and those who listen to Him He brings into blessing.
There is a careful limit on what the picture proves:
The potter's power over the clay establishes God's absolute right to act as He will, without giving an account of His matters to man. Yet the illustration does not teach that God has made any vessel for dishonour. It asserts and upholds God's rights, and no more.
One writer finds the same process at work in a single life.
God did then what He loves to do now — He stepped in and converted Paul, the foremost opponent of the church. The "chosen vessel" was an apostle of Satanic hate one moment and an apostle of Christ the next. A wonderful transformation that was, very like the figure given us in Jeremiah 18:2-6, where the potter worked the shapeless clay. First the vessel was in the mind of the potter, then he worked on the wheel and formed the vessel, and then the mind of the potter was in the vessel.
- Clay — a potter does as he pleases with a lump of earth. God's right over a nation is far greater.
- Marred — Israel became spoiled clay, and not for lack of care. God had freed them, planted them, fenced them in and given them His law.
- Nations — the whole circle of civilization is God's workshop. Assyria, Babylonia, Persia, Greece and Rome were all shaped and broken in His hands.
- Mercy — here God is unlike a potter. If a nation turns from its evil, He turns from the harm He planned, and He makes the same lump again.
- Vessels — Romans 9 applies the picture to people. It asserts God's right; it does not teach that He made anyone for dishonour. With Paul, the vessel first lay in the Potter's mind, then the Potter's mind filled the vessel.
At the moment that I speak concerning a nation and concerning a kingdom, to pluck up, and to break down, and to destroy,
God speaks here from the potter's house, and the lesson widens from Israel to every nation on earth. Two questions follow, and the rest of the chapter answers them: where does God get such authority, and can He ever take back a sentence He has spoken?
Verse 7 follows what Jeremiah watched at the potter's wheel. That scene shows who is in control of a nation's history.
Having seen what the potter did, the Lord spoke to His servant as He had promised. He addressed His words to the house of Israel. God was instructing His servant about His sovereignty, saying, "Can I not do with you as this potter has done? ... Behold, like the clay in the potter's hand, so are you in My hand, O house of Israel" (Jer. 18:5-6). The nation of Israel was not free to do exactly as it pleased, for it was in God's hand and He could do with it just as He pleased.
These three verbs are not empty language. History is full of the wreckage they describe. Yet at this very point God is unlike any human potter.
The circle of civilization is to Him what the workshop is to the potter. As the potter holds the clay and shapes it into vessels of different forms, so the Lord holds the nations in His hands. He fashions and forms them as He thinks good... Can the Lord not speak about a sinful nation, or an unrighteous kingdom, and say: let it be plucked up, broken, and destroyed? Who can tell Him no?... Where is proud Assyria, and corrupt Babylonia? How low He has brought Persia and Greece and Rome for their sins!... Broken and rejected kingdoms lie scattered over the ground, like the potter's useless pots... Yet You are righteous in all Your ways. And You are long-suffering and merciful also. In one way You are unlike the potter. You have said: "If that nation, concerning which I have spoken, turns from its evil, I will relent of the disaster that I intended to do to it" (v. 8).
An announced judgment is never a bluff. It is also not always final.
Men's threats are sometimes just idle words or empty boasting. God's predicted judgments are not like that. The Creator has never once threatened a judgment He did not intend to carry out. At times the repentance of the people has turned His hand aside. The sparing of Nineveh in the time of Jonah is an example of this. It is part of the declared ways of God to withdraw sentence when men humble themselves before Him. Jer. 18:7-8 shows this plainly. He is also "slow to anger," leaving the door open for repentance until the last. But even the patience of God has limits.
Verse 8 says God will change His course. Yet Scripture elsewhere says He does not change.
The message was clear: there was still time for Judah to repent. If they did, God would "repent." Otherwise, He would have to chasten and discipline them. God "is not a man ... that he should repent" (Num. 23:19, older wording; the ESV reads "change His mind"), but He does repent when man changes, especially when man repents.
Nineveh is the clearest case of this principle at work.
The people came to see that they had sinned deeply against their Maker. They trembled at the mention of His judgment. They humbled themselves before Him. Jer. 18:7-10, as we have already seen, lays down the principles of God's dealing with nations. His eye sees their doings, and He visits them from time to time in His wrath, but is always prepared to show mercy. God's government must not be confused with His grace. The relief the Ninevites received is not the same as the eternal forgiveness of sins. God proclaims that forgiveness to people everywhere in the gospel message (Acts 13:38-39).
The potter image does not stay at the national level. Romans 9 applies it one person at a time.
In Jeremiah 18 we have seen God's ways with the nations. In Romans 9 we learn something of God's ways with people... Every person, like every nation, is a marred vessel in the hand of the Potter. We have all become marred by sin and by taking our own evil way. There are those who, like Israel, will not listen to the word of God through His servants... and God has the power to make these marred vessels into vessels of wrath. And there are those who, like the Ninevites, listen to the message of God and turn from their evil ways. God makes them vessels of mercy.
- Held. Nations sit in God's hand as clay sits in the potter's — Israel was never free to do just as it pleased.
- Warned. The threat is real. Proud Assyria, Babylon, Persia, Greece and Rome lie broken like discarded pots.
- Turn. God is unlike the potter at one point — if the nation turns from its evil, He relents of the disaster He intended.
- Relent. He is not a man that He should change; He changes course when man changes, and above all when man repents.
- Limited. A withdrawn judgment is government, not the gospel. A spared city is not forgiven sin, and His patience has an end.
if that nation, concerning which I have spoken, turn from their evil, then I will repent of the evil that I thought to do unto them.
In the potter's workshop, God gives Jeremiah His rule for dealing with nations: a sentence He has announced can still be withdrawn. The verse raises two hard questions — how can God threaten and then not act, and what does it mean that He "relents"?
One writer draws out God's power over the nations — and the exception verse 8 adds.
The circle of civilization is to Him just what the workshop is to the potter. The potter holds the clay and shapes it into vessels of different kinds. In the same way, the Lord holds the nations in His hands. He forms and shapes them as He thinks good. … Where is haughty Assyria, and corrupt Babylonia? How low He has brought Persia and Greece and Rome for their sins! … Broken and rejected kingdoms lie scattered over the ground like the potter's useless earthenware. "O Lord, what desolation You have made in the earth! Yet You are righteous in all Your ways. And You are patient and merciful also. You are unlike the potter in this. You have said: If that nation, concerning which I have spoken, turns from its evil, I will relent of the disaster that I intended to do to it."
The wording sounds as though God changes. One writer shows where the change really happens.
It does not mean a change of mind on God's part, but a change of action caused by a change of mind on man's part. God sends warnings to man so that man may change his mind and repent. Then God may change His action from judgment to mercy. God has not changed His mind. His mind has always been toward mercy … but man's sin must bring down the righteous judgment of God, even though He is slow to anger.
The suspended sentence does not mean God was wrong at first.
This change of mind on God's part … does not mean any regret about His first decision. Instead it shows His grace and righteousness. He suspends the sentence when He sees the least sign of repentance in the guilty one.
Verse 8 is not a one-time concession to Judah. It is God's declared way of working — and it has a limit.
Men's threats are sometimes just idle words or empty boasting. God's predicted judgments are not like that. The Creator has never once threatened judgments He did not intend to carry out. Yet sometimes the repentance of the people has held back His hand. … It is part of the declared ways of God to withdraw sentence when men humble themselves before Him. Jer. 18:7-8 shows this. He is also "slow to anger," leaving an open door for repentance until the last. But even the patience of God has its limits.
The relief promised here belongs to God's dealings with nations in this world.
God's government must not be confused with His grace. The Ninevites were spared, but that is not the same as the eternal forgiveness of sins. That forgiveness is proclaimed to men everywhere in the gospel message (Acts 13:38-39). The repentance described in Jonah 3:10 does not mean we shall meet the whole population of Nineveh in Heaven. Still, some people — possibly many — may well have found eternal blessing as a result of the great alarm.
The promise of verse 8 has a matching threat in the verses that follow. Judah's answer was defiance.
Suppose God threatens a nation with destruction, and that nation turns to the Lord. He will relent of the evil pronounced on them. … But suppose the Lord has promised a nation good, and that nation does evil in His sight. He will relent of the good He had promised them. … If Israel had then admitted the sin and guilt and turned to the Lord, He would have acted in sovereign grace towards them. Their answer was: "There is no hope; but we will follow our own plans" … They pushed aside the hand that would snatch them out of the fire.
The marred vessel was not thrown away.
Things had gone wrong with Israel. Idolatry had become common. The vessel had been marred. But the clay was still soft. There was still time to turn to God.
Applying the verse to his own troubled generation, one writer put the terms in a single line:
What then is to be done — what should be done? "If that nation," says God, "turns from their evil I will relent of the evil that I had thought to do to them." That is as plain as it is gracious.
- Clay. God holds the nations like clay in a potter's hands. He shapes them, and broken kingdoms lie scattered as proof.
- Turn. One word suspends the sentence: if the nation turns from its evil, God withdraws the disaster He announced.
- Relent. God's mind never changed; His action changed because man did. He was always toward mercy.
- Reprieve. Escaping judgment now is not the same as forgiveness for eternity — government is not grace.
- Now. The vessel was marred, but the clay was still soft. The offer stands only while it lasts, for God's patience has limits.
And at the moment that I speak concerning a nation and concerning a kingdom, to build and to plant,
God has just shown Jeremiah a potter reshaping clay that had gone wrong in his hands. Now He states the rule behind His dealings with every nation on earth. Verse 9 is the positive half of that rule. The moment God promises to build and plant a nation, a condition comes with the promise. What happens when a favoured people treat that gift as untouchable?
Who holds the nations? One writer answers from the potter's workshop.
Civilization as a whole is to Him what the workshop is to the potter. The potter holds the clay and shapes it into vessels of many kinds. In the same way the Lord holds the nations in His hands. He fashions and forms them as He thinks good. Who can question the work of God?
"Build" and "plant" were not abstract words to Jeremiah's hearers. They described what God had already done for them. That is why the warning attached to them stung.
This was a solemn warning to Israel. God had built them up and planted them in the land of Canaan. But they had not obeyed the voice of the Lord; they had done evil in His sight. Israel was indeed a marred vessel in the potter's hand. Because they rejected His mercy, they would become vessels of wrath.
When God takes back a promised good, He is not being unreliable. It follows from who He is.
People drift away from the living God. And God would deny Himself if He made light of disobedience and treated evil in His sight as if it were good.
The chapter says God will turn back from the good He promised. Writers are careful here, because Scripture elsewhere denies that God changes.
The message was clear: there was still time for Judah to repent. If so, God would "repent." Otherwise, He would need to chasten and discipline them. God "is not a man… that he should repent" (Num. 23:19), but He does repent when man changes, especially when man repents.
Where older translations say God will "repent," the ESV says He will "relent." The shift is in God's dealings, not in His mind about what is right.
This change of mind on God's part does not mean He regrets His original decision. Instead it shows His grace and righteousness. He suspends the sentence when He sees the smallest sign of repentance in the guilty person.
Verse 9 tells a blessed nation that it can lose its standing. Judah heard this and hid behind the very religious forms God had given them.
Unbelief still trembles underneath. So it shelters behind what God had set up, assuming it can never fall. It takes forms that have turned away from God and makes them a wall against the God they hide. It credits them with the stability of God Himself.
The principle in these verses governs nations in this life. One writer warns against reading more into it, with Nineveh as his example.
Jeremiah 18:7-10 lays down the principles of God's dealing with nations. His eye sees what they do. From time to time He comes against them in wrath, yet He is always ready to show mercy. Do not confuse God's government with His grace. The relief the Ninevites received is not the same thing as the eternal forgiveness of sins. The gospel message proclaims that forgiveness to people everywhere (Acts 13:38-39). The repentance described in Jonah 3:10 does not mean we will meet the whole population of Nineveh in heaven. Still, it is quite possible that some of them — perhaps many — found eternal blessing through that great alarm.
The New Testament applies the same picture to one person at a time.
In Jeremiah 18 we have seen God's ways with the nations. In Romans 9 we learn something of God's ways with people… Every person, like every nation, is a marred vessel in the hand of the Potter. We have all been marred by sin and by taking our own evil way… Those who reject His mercy come in for judgment. Those who listen to Him He brings into blessing.
- Clay — The nations are clay in God's hands; He shapes and reshapes them as He sees good, and no one can call Him to account.
- Planted — God built and planted Israel in Canaan. The promise of good held only while they obeyed His voice.
- Repents — God does not regret His decisions. He turns back from a declared course when people turn. He withdraws a promised good when they do evil. He will not treat evil as though it were good.
- Shelter — Judah hid behind the religious forms God had given them. They treated what He set up as if it could never fall.
- Vessels — What is true of a kingdom is true of a person. Every one of us is marred clay. Those who listen to Him He brings into blessing; those who refuse His mercy meet judgment.
if it do evil in my sight, that it hearken not unto my voice, then I will repent of the good wherewith I said I would benefit them.
At the potter's house God gives two rules: verse 9 is about building and planting a nation, verse 10 about that nation then turning to evil. So can a nation lose good that God Himself promised — and does God change?
The lesson begins in a potter's workshop, and the point is who holds whom.
God was instructing His servant about His sovereignty, saying, "Cannot I do with you as this potter? ... Behold, as the clay is in the potter's hand, so are you in My hand, O house of Israel" (Jer. 18:5-6). The nation of Israel was not free to do exactly as it pleased, for it was in God's hand and He could do with it just as He pleased.
These verses are not a one-off threat. Commentators read them as God's stated policy for any nation. One writer also marks off what that policy does not offer.
Jer. 18:7-10, as we have already seen, lays down the principles of God's dealing with nations. His eye sees their doings, and He visits them from time to time in His wrath, but is always ready to show mercy. Do not confuse God's government with His grace. The relief the people of Nineveh received is not the same thing as the eternal forgiveness of sins. The Gospel message proclaims that forgiveness to people everywhere (Acts 13:38-39).
The verse says God will "relent" — older translations say He will "repent" — of good He had said He would do. Elsewhere Scripture says He is not a man that He should repent. Writers answer by asking whose mind changes — and what God's warnings are for.
It does not mean a change of mind on God's part, but a change of action caused by a change of mind on man's part. God sends warnings to man, so that man may change his mind and repent. Then God may change His action from judgment to mercy. God has not changed His mind. God's mind has always been toward mercy... but man's sin must bring down the righteous judgment of God, even though He is slow to anger. There is only one way of escape, and that is repentance on the part of sinful man. With this in view God sends warnings to individuals and to nations. If they hear and repent, then God may act according to the desires of His heart, and show mercy. If man will not repent, judgment must fall.
One writer separates two kinds of word from God: the kind He may withdraw, and the kind He never will.
God is not a man, so He does not repent about His eternal and unchangeable counsels and unconditional promises. Those "are without repentance." But in His grace He may repent of a threatened judgment — that is, not carry it out — as He did with Nineveh.
Verse 8 offers hope to a condemned nation; verse 10 puts a favoured nation on notice.
On the other hand, God promised to bless Israel in the land only if they obeyed. So if they did evil, He would turn from, or repent of, the good He had said He would do — whether to Israel or in fact to any nation. Jer. 18:8-10. He would change the order of His dealings towards them... All this involves the responsibility of man, as well as God's government.
The words of verse 9 — to build and to plant — match what God had already done for Israel. So verse 10 speaks to them, not to some imagined nation.
This was a solemn warning to Israel. God had built them up and planted them in the land of Canaan. But they had not obeyed the voice of the LORD; they had done evil in His sight. Israel was indeed a marred vessel in the potter's hand. They had rejected His mercy, so they would be the vessels of wrath.
The evil in view is disobedience — "not listening to my voice." One writer roots God's answer to it in His own character, and applies it well beyond Israel.
The will of man is only evil. The sole hope is in God Himself. But Israel, like the Christian world today, feels neither, even when both are confessed in words... On the other hand, man is prone to turn away from the living God. And God would deny Himself if He made light of disobedience, and treated evil in His sight as if it were good.
- Potter — Israel is clay in God's hand, not free to act as it pleases. The workshop scene teaches His sovereignty first.
- Principle — Verses 7-10 state how God governs nations. He shows real mercy in this world. That mercy is not the eternal forgiveness offered in the gospel.
- Gift — God had built and planted Israel. The good in verse 10 is a promise already given, not one imagined.
- Forfeit — God tied blessing in the land to obedience, so evil in His sight changes His dealings. Man's responsibility meets God's government, and repentance is the one way back.
- Unchanged — The relenting is a change of action, not of mind. His eternal counsels and unconditional promises stand. Man moves; God answers.
And now, speak to the men of Judah and to the inhabitants of Jerusalem, saying, Thus saith Jehovah Behold, I prepare evil against you, and devise a device against you turn ye then every one from his evil way, and amend your ways and your doings.
The word from the potter's house now becomes a message for Judah and Jerusalem. The God who shapes nations says He is shaping trouble for them. Yet the same sentence opens a door out of it. Why would a God who has already decided still say "return"?
The picture behind the message is a workshop. Nations sit in God's hands as wet clay sits in the potter's hands. But at one point the potter's rights and God's ways part company, and the writer turns to speak to God directly.
The circle of civilization is to Him just what the workshop is to the potter. The potter holds the clay and shapes it into vessels of many different forms. In the same way, the Lord holds the nations in His hands, fashioning and forming them as He thinks good... The potter rightly rejects faulty material. Can the Lord not speak about a sinful nation or an unrighteous kingdom, and say: Let it be plucked up, broken, and destroyed? Who shall tell Him no?... But You are unlike the potter in this. You have said: "If that nation, concerning which I have spoken, turns from its evil, I will relent of the disaster that I intended to do to it."
God announces trouble before He sends it. He has a reason for speaking first.
If God threatens, it is so that man may turn from his sin and be spared. Why else should He warn the sinner? Why not leave him to ripen for judgment without a warning? But these are not the ways of God.
Verse 11 rests on the rule stated just before it: God may turn back from the disaster He has announced. That does not make Him unstable.
From this, Jeremiah draws a lesson. If the people turn away from their evil ways and doings, God may relent of His sentence against them. On the other hand, if in the end they turn away from Him, the announced blessing can be lost. This change of mind on God's part does not imply any regret about His first decision. Instead it shows His grace and righteousness. He holds back the sentence when He sees the least sign of repentance in the guilty one.
Jeremiah does not just predict. He states the terms out loud, and one writer says this sets his prophecies apart from every other.
Jeremiah's prophecies are more conditional than any other, except only Jonah's. In fact they state their conditions even more openly than Jonah's. Jonah did not put forward a condition, "If you repent, God will spare Nineveh." But Jeremiah does state the condition: "If you repent, the Lord will relent of what He means to do."
A call from God can harden as well as soften. Judah refused this call, and one writer describes what such refusal does to a person.
Another dreadful effect of persisting in evil is despair. Man never really trusts God; and a divine call or warning provokes this form of his will. If his will were broken, he would at least cry to God and throw himself on what God is, who cannot deny that He is love. God's goodness leads to repentance; man's will leads to desperation.
Judah's refusal is best measured against a city that did listen. Both outcomes came from the same patience.
When Jonah preached to the Ninevites there was an amazing response... and God spared the city... With Jerusalem it was very different. The temple of God was there. But the men of the city looked on it as a kind of charm that they imagined would protect them from the judgment... God showed His longsuffering in every case, but He also showed that His ways were equal in sparing Nineveh and destroying Jerusalem.
The command is personal: each one turns from his own way. One writer applies it to anyone who has drifted from truth once known.
Know this for certain, dear friends. If we have drifted away from the truth we once knew and practised, we will know no outward and visible blessing from God. His word is, "Return, every one from his evil way, and amend your ways and your deeds."
- Clay: Nations lie in God's hands as clay lies in the potter's; He may pluck up and break what is faulty, and no one can tell Him no.
- Warning: He announces the trouble before He sends it, so that people may turn and be spared. Otherwise He would leave them to ripen for judgment without a warning.
- Relenting: God's change of action is not regret over an earlier decision. It is His grace and righteousness holding back the sentence at the least sign of repentance.
- Condition: Jeremiah does not just predict. He names the terms, and no prophecies are more conditional than his.
- Response: Nineveh turned and God spared it. Jerusalem trusted the temple and fell. The same patience met two answers, and God's ways were equal in both.
But they say, There is no hope; for we will walk after our own devices, and we will each one do [according to] the stubbornness of his evil heart.
At the potter's house God called His people to turn from evil, and this verse is their flat refusal. Their answer is strange: they admit their own heart is evil, then announce they will follow it anyway.
Their words — "There is no hope," as older translations render the phrase — are not humility. One commentator sees despair as the fruit of keeping on in evil. He sets what God's goodness leads to against what man's will leads to:
Another terrible effect of persisting in evil is despair. Man never really trusts God, and a divine call or warning provokes this form of his will. If his will were broken, he would at least cry to God and throw himself on what God is, for God cannot deny that He is love. His goodness leads to repentance; man's will leads to desperation.
The people were right that nothing good could come out of themselves. The same writer points to where the only hope lies. He adds that people can confess both facts in words and feel neither:
The will of man is only evil. The sole hope is in God Himself. But Israel, like Christendom now, feels neither, even where both are confessed in words; for there is a real turning from evil where grace works, and man is quick to claim the credit for it.
The people did not argue with the message. They announced what they meant to do. One writer weighs the nerve of it and turns the question on the reader:
What depravity and wicked boldness these words reveal! They refused to believe the message of the Lord. They pushed aside the hand that would have snatched them out of the fire. They admitted the evil heart. Then they deliberately declared that they would carry on in wicked defiance of the Lord. And is it any better in professing Christendom today?
They were not answering one warning. God had called them for years, and He wanted their good:
In the case of the privileged nation of Israel, we have a special example of the long-suffering of our God. He was so concerned for their good that He called to them again and again — "rising up early," as He so often puts it. He called them to return to Himself and find the settled blessing His gracious heart desires for them. But they would not, for they said, "There is no hope" (v. 12). They did not forget to seek their own pleasure. But they forgot the Lord, and so brought evil on themselves.
The marred clay could be reshaped. That chance does not last forever, and one writer applies this to every unbeliever:
These first two symbolic events (the clay and the vessel) have a solemn message for unbelievers too. There is an acceptable time when God gives the opportunity to repent. But when the heart is hardened (or death steps in) it is too late. The inevitable result is the smashing of the potter's vessel.
Two responses are possible, and both outcomes rest in the same hand:
Every individual, like every nation, is a marred vessel in the hand of the Potter. We have all become marred by sin and by taking our own evil way. Some, like Israel, will not listen to the word of God through His servants — the word of mercy proclaimed in the gospel. God has the power to make these marred vessels into vessels of wrath. Others, like the people of Nineveh, listen to the message of God and turn from their evil ways to Him. God makes them vessels of mercy.
The words outlive Judah. One writer hears believers say the same about the divided state of the church, and answers that reasoning directly:
Israel of old said there is no hope, and that they would walk after their own plans and each one act on what his evil heart imagined (Jer. 18:12). Many believers have said the same about the ruined, divided condition of the Church. … it is clear that there must be some way of meeting of a different kind. However great the ruin and confusion, this way of meeting is still open. Otherwise God would be demanding obedience and compelling disobedience!
- The call. God rose up early and called them again and again to return and be blessed. This refusal answers years of patience, not one warning.
- The refusal. They did not argue with the message. They admitted the evil heart and said they would follow it anyway.
- The despair. Keeping on in evil ends in "no hope." God's goodness leads to repentance; man's own will leads to desperation.
- The correction. They were half right: man's will is only evil. But hope was never in them — the sole hope is in God Himself.
- The window. There is an acceptable time to repent. Refuse it, and the marred vessel breaks. Listen and turn, and God makes you a vessel of mercy.
Therefore thus saith Jehovah Ask ye now among the nations, Who hath heard such things? The virgin of Israel hath done a very horrible thing.
At the potter's house, God offered to relent if Judah would turn. They answered that there was no hope, so verse 13 is His reply: He calls the nations in as witnesses, and He gives His people a name that makes the charge sting.
The word "therefore" points back to what the people had just said. One writer weighs that answer and finds in it both an admission and an act of defiance:
If Israel had admitted the sin and guilt then and turned to the Lord, He would have acted in sovereign grace toward them. Their answer was: "There is no hope; we will follow our own plans, and every one of us will do what his evil heart imagines." What depravity and wicked boldness these words reveal! They refused to believe the message of the Lord. They pushed aside the hand that would have snatched them out of the fire. They admitted their evil heart. Then they deliberately declared that they would go on defying the Lord. And is it any better in the professing Christian world today?
Older translations give the people's reply as "There is no hope"; the ESV has "That is in vain!" One writer treats that despair not as weakness but as a form of self-will:
Another awful effect of persisting in evil is despair. Man never really trusts God; and a divine call or warning provokes this form of his will. If his will were broken, he would at least cry to God and throw himself on what God is, who cannot deny that He is love. God's goodness leads to repentance; man's will leads to desperation.
The comparison does not flatter the nations. It works the other way: Israel treated the true God worse than idol-worshippers treat gods that are nothing.
The way runs downward. Israel left her true God and sinned in a way that even worshippers of false gods would have been ashamed of. "Has a nation changed its gods, even though they are no gods?" the Lord asked through Jeremiah. "But my people have changed their glory for that which does not profit" (Jer. 2:11)... So Israel, away from God, became more pagan than the pagan nations.
Another writer explains what actually made Israel exceptional:
We are not to suppose that they were worse than other people. They are exceptional only in this: God brought them into a closer visible relation to Himself than any other nation, and their history is given to us, written with the unerring pen of inspiration. This great privilege was also the thing that searched out to the very bottom everything that was in their heart. "God is light"; and "whatever makes manifest is light."... Did this prove that Israel was worse than the nations? No. If they had only had false gods, they would not have changed them either!
The title is not a comment on the nation's innocence. It is one of Jeremiah's regular ways of addressing the nation as a whole:
He uses this same figure, "virgin," in connection with the nation in other parts of his prophecies (Jer. 14:17; 18:13; 31:4).
Behind the figure lies the bond that makes the sin so shocking — and, in the end, the ground of hope:
The sad truth is that Israel was married to the Lord, as the prophets remind the people (Isa. 54; Jer. 3). So Scripture brands their unfaithfulness as adultery (as in Hosea 3 and elsewhere), not as prostitution, which is how the New Testament brands Babylon. Yet in time His grace may deal with Israel, not as a guilty widow, but as a woman forsaken and a wife of youth.
One writer traces the chapter's lesson forward, from the potter's house to John the Baptist:
The parable of the potter in Jeremiah 18 was meant to teach Israel one thing. God had brought them into covenant, yet they were still within the range of the Lord's judgments and visitations. So Jeremiah 19 acts that judgment out in a picture. In John the Baptist's time Israel shows the same spirit of self-confidence. In that spirit they said, "We have Abraham as our father."
The same writer turns the warning forward, so that no reader treats it as ancient history:
The professing Christian world, the Babylon of Revelation, has now taken the place Israel held of old. Babylon trusts in her security, despite her moral condition. She says, "I sit as a queen, I am no widow, and mourning I shall never see" (Rev. 18:7). But Revelation 18 repeats what the prophet did in the potter's house and in the valley of the son of Hinnom. It teaches the unfaithful steward that the doom of the shattered vessel awaits him.
- Patience first. The potter's offer came before the charge: God would have relented if they had turned.
- Charge next. He calls the nations as witnesses. His own people wronged the true God worse than idol-worshippers wrong gods that are nothing.
- Privilege exposes. Nearness to God did not make Israel worse than others. It brought the light that searched their hearts to the bottom.
- The name accuses. "Virgin Israel" recalls a marriage bond. That is why the prophets call this sin adultery, and why grace can still restore her.
- Covenant is no shelter. Being God's people never puts anyone beyond His dealings. The shattered vessel warns every confident steward, then and now.
Shall the snow of Lebanon cease from the rock of the field? Shall the cool flowing waters coming from afar be dried up?
God asks this question of a people who have just told Him there is no hope for them. The chapter around it shows a potter at his wheel, and the question sets Judah's behaviour beside the most reliable things in nature — mountain snow and mountain streams.
The chapter opens in a potter's workshop. Commentators take the scene as God's claim over whole nations. Yet the same passage adds something a potter never says to his clay.
The circle of civilization is to Him just what the workshop is to the potter. As the potter holds the clay and moulds it into vessels of different shapes, so the Lord holds the nations in His hands, fashioning and forming them as He thinks good… Lord, You are unlike the potter in one way. You have said: "If that nation, about which I have spoken, turns from their evil, then I will relent of the evil that I planned to do to them."
Judah refused that offer. They answered that they would keep walking after their own plans. One writer sees such despair as the end of a life spent resisting God.
Another dreadful effect of continuing in evil is despair. Man never really trusts God; and a divine call or warning stirs up this form of his will. If his will were broken, he would at least cry to God and throw himself on what God is, who cannot deny that He is love. His goodness leads to repentance; man's will leads to desperation.
That refusal sharpens the question. Nature keeps its place; this people would not keep theirs.
Just before the snow and the streams, God tells them to ask among the nations whether anyone has heard such a thing. An earlier chapter gives the answer: no nation was ever so false to its own idols.
See how slow the Lord is to abandon His people! He pleaded with those in front of Him then, and on down to their children's children. Go where they pleased — north-west or south-east, to Greeks or to Arabians. They would hear of no one so false to their false gods as Israel was to the true God.
Water here is more than scenery. Jeremiah had already called God the fountain of living waters. One writer says we make the same exchange Israel made.
Israel of old forsook "the fountain of living waters, and hewed out cisterns for themselves, broken cisterns that can hold no water." Like them, we look for satisfaction in earthly things. We only find that all earthly springs run dry. If only we could trust the Lord not only to save our souls, but to satisfy our hearts! Then He would lead us into the green pastures that never wither, and beside the still waters that never run dry.
Lebanon's streams never fail. What Israel chose instead held nothing.
Behind the question lies one charge: they forgot the Lord. One writer notes that their memory failed in one direction only.
He was so concerned for their good that He called to them again and again — "rising up early," as He so often puts it. He called them to return to Himself and find the stability and blessing His gracious heart desires for them. But they would not, for they said, "There is no hope." What they did not forget was to seek their own gratification. They forgot the Lord, and so brought evil on themselves.
Why say all this to a people already in covenant with God?
The parable of the potter, in Jeremiah 18 and 19, was meant to let Israel know that, though brought into covenant, they were still within the range and reach of God's judgments, and that such judgments would overtake them because of their sins.
- Clay. God holds nations as a potter holds clay — but unlike a potter, He says that if a nation turns from its evil, He will relent.
- Refusal. Offered that turning, Judah said, "There is no hope." Continuing in evil ends in despair. God's goodness leads to repentance; man's own will leads to desperation.
- Unheard of. Search the nations and you find no one as false to false gods as this people were to the true God.
- Water. They left the fountain of living waters for broken cisterns that hold nothing. The Lord's streams never run dry.
- Cost. They forgot Him but never forgot their own gratification. Being in covenant did not put them beyond the reach of judgment.
For my people hath forgotten me they burn incense to vanity; and they have caused them to stumble in their ways, the ancient paths, to walk in by-paths of a way not cast up;
Here God explains the ruin He has just announced: Judah's disaster goes back to a people who dropped Him out of mind and worshipped things that are nothing. How does a nation forget the God it still names, and where do its side-roads lead?
The charge is not that Israel stopped being religious. Their God slipped out of view, while their appetite for themselves stayed awake. One writer sets God's patience beside what they did keep in mind:
He was so concerned for their good that He called to them again and again, "rising up early," as He so often puts it. He called them to return to Himself and find the settled blessing which His gracious heart desires for them. But they would not, for they said, "There is no hope" (v. 12). They did not, however, forget to seek self-gratification. But they forgot the Lord, only to bring evil upon themselves (vv. 11-17).
They gave their offerings to gods that are no gods. God had already put that swap to them as a question of plain profit:
"Has a nation changed its gods, even though they are no gods? But my people have changed their glory for that which does not profit... For my people have committed two evils: they have forsaken me, the fountain of living waters, and hewed out cisterns for themselves, broken cisterns that can hold no water" (Jer. 2:11-13). This is His plea. Did the nations — the pagan peoples — ever do what My people have done? My people have changed their glory for that which does not profit. You will find all through Scripture that what profits is the great point. If there has been departure from God, has it profited you?
"The ancient roads" do not mean old customs in general. Earlier in the book, Jeremiah had already said what filled those paths:
What then are the ancient paths? Holiness to the Lord (Jer. 2:3). "I remember the devotion of your youth, your love as a bride, how you followed Me in the wilderness, in a land not sown. Israel was holy to the Lord, the firstfruits of His harvest." Do we not hear an echo of this for believers today? Revelation 2:4 says, "I have this against you, that you have abandoned the love you had at first."
(Older translations read "Israel was holiness unto the Lord," the phrase quoted just above.)
The verse ends with feet on side-roads instead of the highway. One writer, looking at Israel's march through the desert, shows what such a track is and how to undo it:
The first step onward gave character to their whole path. We see in it the effort of flesh to find a path for itself in the wilderness, apart from the one marked out by God. Flesh cannot walk in His paths. It seeks a bypath — an easier way, which seems right, and seems to lead, as flesh sees it, to the same end. It proves to be a snare. It must be retraced to the very spot where it turned aside. There you re-enter God's true path, which alone is sure to reach the goal.
Nobody leaves the highway in one jump. One writer traces the stages, quoting another:
Must we not confess it? In recent years there has been a gradual tendency to decline from God's principles, to forsake the old paths and seek a wider path. That path carries little reproach. It is more popular, and more pleasing to the vanity of the flesh. One has truly said, "The principles of God may be deserted by easy stages. They may first be relaxed, then forgotten, then despised. They may pass from a firm hand into an easy one, from there to an indifferent one, and find themselves at last flung away by a rebellious one."
This verse sits inside the chapter of the potter. God claims the right to break a spoiled vessel — then He says something no potter would say:
The Lord holds the nations in His hands, shaping and forming them as He thinks good... Broken and rejected kingdoms, like the potter's useless earthenware, lie scattered over the face of the ground. "O Lord, what desolation You have made in the earth! Yet You are righteous in all Your ways. And You are long-suffering and merciful also. For You are unlike the potter in this. You have said, 'If that nation, concerning which I have spoken, turns from its evil, I will relent of the disaster that I intended to do to it'" (v. 8).
- Forgot — the root sin is not a lack of religion but a forgotten Lord. Self-gratification was never forgotten.
- Exchanged — they traded their glory for what does not profit. Ask of any drift from God: has it paid?
- Left — the ancient paths mean holiness to the Lord and the love of the early days, not mere old custom.
- Wandered — the bypath looks easier and seems to reach the same end. It is a snare, and the way back runs through the exact spot where you turned aside.
- Return — God breaks spoiled vessels. Yet unlike a potter, He relents toward the nation that turns from its evil.
to make their land an astonishment, a perpetual hissing every one that passeth by shall be astonished, and shake his head.
At the potter's house God tells Jeremiah why a rich land would end as an empty ruin. The cause is not Babylon's army but something inside the people: they forgot God, and their feet wandered off the road He built for them.
The verse before names the cause: God's people forgot Him and turned to false gods. One writer weighs Israel's unfaithfulness against the nations around them.
How slow the Lord is to give up His people! He pleaded with those in front of Him then, and with their children's children. They could go where they pleased — north-west or south-east, to Greeks or to Arabians. Nowhere would they hear of a people so false to their false gods as Israel was to the true God. No wonder the heavens are amazed and afraid and utterly desolate at the sight! God's people were guilty of two such evils: they forsook Him, the fountain of living waters, and cut out cisterns for themselves — broken cisterns that hold no water!
That same verse says the people left the ancient paths. One writer asks what those paths are, and answers from Jeremiah's opening chapters.
What then are the ancient paths? Holiness to the Lord (Jer. 2:3). "I remember you, the kindness of your youth, your love as a bride, when you went after me in the wilderness, in a land not sown. Israel was holiness to the Lord, the first-fruits of His increase." Do we not have an echo of this for believers today? Revelation 2:4 says, "I have this against you, that you have abandoned your first love."
There is another way on offer, and it looks easier. A writer explains what it promises and where it ends.
We see in it the effort of the flesh to find a path for itself in the wilderness, apart from the one marked out by God. The flesh cannot walk in His paths; it looks for a side path — an easier way, which seems right, and seems, to the flesh's eye, to lead to the same end. It proves to be only a snare. You must retrace it to the very spot where you turned aside, and re-enter God's true path there. That path alone is sure to reach the goal.
A writer traces the same threat against Jerusalem's princes and people.
So Jerusalem — its princes and its people — would become "a desolation, an astonishment, a hissing, and a curse." And He carried out His word with startling exactness.
The verse says the hissing lasts forever. A writer commenting on the same threat in the law of Moses shows what passers-by do. They do more than stare. They ask a question, and the question has an answer.
Such evil is to come upon them and upon the land that "the stranger who comes from a far land shall say, when they see the plagues of that land… even all nations shall say, Why has the LORD done so to this land? What does the heat of this great anger mean?" Strangers from far lands, tourists and pilgrims, have visited Palestine in fulfilment of this prediction. Seeing the sad condition of that land, they have often asked these questions and known their answer. "Then men shall say, Because they have forsaken the covenant of the LORD God of their fathers. He made that covenant with them when He brought them out of the land of Egypt."
The potter's sign in this chapter answers a comfortable assumption — that God will never judge a people He has chosen. One writer follows that lesson into the New Testament.
The parable of the potter in Jeremiah 18 taught Israel this: though God had brought them into covenant, they were still within reach of the Lord's judgments and visitations. So Jeremiah 19 acts that judgment out as a picture. In John the Baptist's time Israel shows the same self-confidence. In that spirit they said, "We have Abraham as our father." Under the Lord's ministry it is still the same — they still boast in the fatherhood of Abraham and of God. (John 8.) But these boasts were empty, as both John and the Lord tell them. They teach Israel again the lesson of Jeremiah 18 — being in covenant did not put them beyond the reach of judgment.
- Forgetting. The ruin starts inside. God's own people left the fountain of living water and cut broken cisterns instead.
- Wandering. Leaving the ancient paths means leaving holiness and first love. The flesh prefers an easier side road of its own making.
- Snare. That side road never reaches the goal. The way back is the exact spot where the foot first turned aside.
- Ruin. The threatened horror and hissing were not poetry. God's word came true with startling exactness.
- Witness. The wrecked land makes strangers stop and ask why. The answer never changes: they forsook the covenant of the LORD.
As with an east wind will I scatter them before the enemy; I will shew them the back, and not the face, in the day of their calamity.
At the potter's house God had just shown that a nation's future was not fixed — it could still be re-shaped. Verse 17 shows what is left when a people refuse that offer. They are scattered like dust in a hot wind. In their worst hour they look for God's face and see only His back.
God speaks here, but He answers something the people said first. Just before this they told Him there was no hope, and said they would follow their own plans anyway. One commentator sees that answer as the real tragedy of the chapter. It is not weakness. It is the human will refusing to be broken.
Another dreadful effect of keeping on in evil is despair. Man never really trusts God; and a divine call or warning brings out this form of his will. If his will were broken, he would at least cry to God and throw himself on what God is, who cannot deny that He is love. God's goodness leads to repentance; man's will leads to desperation.
Scripture uses the east wind again and again for one thing. A comment on Job names what it stands for, and what happens to those who try to escape it.
The east wind is often spoken of in Scripture as signifying God's judgment (Ex. 14:21). That judgment is slow to arise, but when it comes, it "does not spare". Men may try to flee desperately from its power, as they do from hurricanes, but to no avail.
The wind also had a name. Writing on Tyre, where the same picture appears, one commentator says who that east wind was.
Tyre is a ship that founders at sea. Nebuchadnezzar is the east wind that upset her.
Verse 15 gives the cause. The people forgot God Himself. One writer shows how often that charge comes back in Jeremiah, chapter after chapter.
Turning inward like this is a wretched habit. It always follows turning away from the Lord Himself. It caused the great damage then, just as it is doing now. No doubt people think their feelings and moods are good and pious and wise. But it is still self-occupation. It is contrary to the true knowledge of the blessed God… Here in our chapters the same words come back again and again, and they are touching: "You have forgotten ME"; "YOU HAVE FORSAKEN ME"; "THEY HAVE FORSAKEN ME".
Showing someone your back is the opposite of turning your face toward them. A comment on the same threat in Moses' song explains why it is so severe.
They had spurned Him without reason; now He spurns them with good reason. They receive something of their own treatment. His face had before been shining with pleasure on Israel. Now He hides His face from them, to see what their end will be. If God's face does not shine with approval on His creatures, they cannot continue without serious consequences.
The chapter opens at the potter's house. There the lesson is that God can take back a judgment He has announced. One writer explains what that change of mind does not mean.
This change of mind on God's part does not mean He regrets His first decision. It shows His grace and righteousness. He holds back the sentence when He sees the least sign of repentance in the guilty one.
God carried out the threat. Writing on Zechariah, one writer draws out what the scattering itself was meant to do.
They did not want God. So He put them among people who did not know God. There they would learn by experience how bitter it is to be away from the kindness and care of their faithful Creator… This was true during the seventy years of captivity. It happened again when Israel rejected the Lord Jesus, who came in grace.
- Forgotten. The chain starts in verse 15, not verse 17: forgetting God is the root, and everything else is its fruit.
- Warned. At the potter's wheel, God can still take back a sentence. He does it at the least sign of repentance.
- Refused. "There is no hope" is the human will hardening into despair. God's goodness leads to repentance; man's will leads to desperation.
- Scattered. The east wind is judgment — slow to rise, sparing no one — and here it blows through a human enemy.
- Turned away. The worst loss is not the land but the face. Where God's approval no longer shines, nothing can stand. Yet the exile itself had a lesson: how bitter life away from Him is.
And they said, Come, and let us devise devices against Jeremiah; for law shall not perish from the priest, nor counsel from the wise, nor word from the prophet. Come and let us smite him with the tongue, and let us not give heed to any of his words.
Commentary for this verse has not been generated yet.
Jehovah, give heed to me, and listen to the voice of those that contend with me.
Jeremiah has just brought God's message from the potter's house, and his hearers answer with a plot to strike him with words. He does not fight back; he hands the quarrel to God, in a prayer Christians find hard to read.
The prophet does not defend himself. Slandered, he has one thing left: prayer.
Jeremiah had stood before God to speak for his people and to try to turn the Lord's wrath away from them (18:20). Faced with slander and criticism, the prophet can only say in his prayer, "Hear me, O LORD, and listen to the voice of my adversaries" (18:19).
He asks God to listen not only to him, but to the voices ranged against him. One writer sets out what they did, and what Jeremiah did instead.
They rose in rebellion against the messenger of the Lord. They hated him. They would strike him with the tongue, malign him, bring false accusations against him. But the man of God does not take up their contentions. Like Hezekiah when the enemy reviled him, Jeremiah turned to the Lord. He tells the Lord all about it.
The opponents were not outsiders. They were the religious leaders. Their boast was that priest, wise man and prophet would never fail them.
It was a day like ours. The religious party boasted that the law would not perish from the priest, nor counsel from the wise, nor the word from the prophet. They said, "Come and let us strike him with the tongue, and let us not give heed to any of his words" (Jer. 18:18-19). They refused God's testimony and set up the plea of tradition and succession.
Slander of God's servants did not stop with Jeremiah.
And what shall we say of the negative criticism aimed at the servants of God? It risks interfering with their ministry and discrediting their message. Even Paul had this sad experience, especially at Corinth and in Galatia. And was not the Lord Himself accused by false witnesses, and by Pharisees who said He was casting out demons by the prince of demons! What a painful experience for servants of God under such attacks. And what serious consequences will face those who "strike with the tongue" when they stand before the Lord to answer for their words.
His message did not soften them. It hardened them.
But this draws out hatred of the prophet, and a determination to defend things as they are. So the tested witness of the Lord can only plead against Israel — even though he had sought before God to speak good for them and to turn away His wrath.
Jeremiah goes on to pray for judgment on his enemies. Was that prayer wrong?
The prophet prays against them, for they repaid his good with evil. This prayer was not unrighteous in a servant of the Lord whose promises and hopes were earthly. Yet it would not be suitable for those who know the surpassing grace of God now... Those who know the true grace of God today have received favour they had no merit or claim to. They are saved, justified and blessed eternally in Christ Jesus. Our blessed God and Father has treated them in this way. For them to pray against others would be inconsistent indeed.
The same holds for other prayers that call down judgment on enemies.
Take some of the petitions recorded in the Psalms — imprecatory petitions, as they are called... it will be at once seen that the spirit of such prayers is completely foreign to what is taught to the Christian. The same is true of many of the prayers found in Jeremiah (Jer. 10:24-25; Jer. 18:19-23, etc.). This is enough to show that a prayer given by the Spirit of God in one period is not necessarily suited to God's people in every age.
One writer sees these words spoken again, by a suffering people still to come.
Here once more we must look upon these words prophetically. During the great tribulation, expressions like these will come from the lips of the remnant of Israel. They suffer from their enemies, and they righteously call for heaven's vengeance. That vengeance will fall upon these enemies when the Lord is manifested in glory.
- Plot — The message from the potter's house drew hatred, not repentance. The leaders answered God's word with a plan: strike the prophet with the tongue and ignore him.
- Prayer — Jeremiah does not take up their contentions. He turns to God and asks Him to listen to what his opponents are saying, as Hezekiah did when his enemy reviled him.
- Reversal — He had stood before God to speak good for this people and turn away His wrath. Now they hunt him, and he can only plead against them.
- Restraint — What he prays next was righteous for a servant under earthly promises. Writers agree it does not suit those who have received grace they never earned.
- Future — The same cries will rise again from a suffering remnant. God Himself answers their call for vengeance when Christ appears in glory.
Shall evil be recompensed for good? For they have digged a pit for my soul. Remember how I stood before thee to speak good for them, to turn away thy wrath from them.
Earlier in this chapter God shows Jeremiah a potter shaping clay, and his hearers answer that message by plotting against the man who brought it. His question here is the cry of a wounded man who prayed for these people and then watched them turn on him.
He had asked God to hold back judgment from these people, and their reply was to dig a pit for him. One writer marks the reversal this forced on the prophet.
But this draws out hatred of the prophet, and a determination to defend things as they are. Meanwhile the tested witness of the Lord can only plead against Israel, however much he had sought before Him to speak good for them and to turn away His wrath.
"I stood before you" describes a place, not a mood. He held that place between God's anger and a guilty people until God Himself closed it.
Let us remember that the Lord is "slow to anger". Jeremiah lived in the middle of outrageous provocations, and he was himself the target of much of them — the reproaches of the Lord falling on him. Yet poor Jeremiah could appeal to God how he had stood in the gap to turn away the indignation from them. This went on until the Lord said to him, "Pray not for this people," and the indignation took its course. For intercession is always the place for the one who has the mind of God. There he makes a way for God's love, until that place for intercession closes.
They planned to strike him with the tongue. One writer follows that weapon into the life of the church, and shows where those who use it must finally answer.
Spreading rumors does great harm among the people of God. Such rumors may be true in themselves, yet they run others down and belittle them. Is it done to enhance one's own image? And what shall we say of the negative criticism aimed at the servants of God? Such criticism risks interfering with their ministry and discrediting their message. Even Paul had this sad experience, especially at Corinth and in Galatia. And did not false witnesses accuse the Lord Himself? Pharisees even claimed He was casting out demons by the prince of demons! What a painful experience this is for servants of God who face such attacks. And what serious consequences will face those who "smite with the tongue" when they stand before the Lord to answer for their words.
The prophet never answers his accusers. He takes the whole matter to God, and one writer looks past Jeremiah's own day to who will speak such words again.
The man of God does not take up their quarrel. Like Hezekiah when the enemy insulted him, Jeremiah turned to the Lord. He tells the Lord all about it. Then he prays for judgment to fall on them. Here once more we must look at these words prophetically. During the great tribulation, expressions like the ones the prophet uses here will come from the lips of the remnant of Israel. They suffer from their enemies and righteously call for heaven's vengeance. That vengeance will fall on these enemies when the Lord is revealed in glory.
Verse 20 opens a prayer that ends, in verses 21-23, with requests for God to punish these enemies. Other prayers in the Bible do the same.
Take some of the petitions recorded in the Psalms — imprecatory petitions, as they are called. Turn for example to Psalm 69:22-28. You will see at once that the spirit of such prayers is completely unlike the spirit taught to the Christian. The same is true of many of the prayers found in Jeremiah (Jer. 10:24-25; Jer. 18:19-23, etc.). This shows one thing plainly. A prayer given by the Spirit of God in one period does not necessarily suit the people of God in every age.
Jeremiah's question was later put to a far greater test, by One who had done nothing but good for the people who took His life.
Already they had surrounded Him with words of hatred and fought against Him without a cause. They had repaid Him evil for good and hatred for love. At every step He had shown perfect grace; on every hand He had done only good. He had healed the sick, clothed the naked, fed the hungry, forgiven sins, delivered from the devil and raised the dead. He had warned these men, pleaded with them, and wept over them, but all in vain.
- Plea. Jeremiah had stood before God to speak good for the very people who now hunt him.
- Place. Intercession is a place a servant holds to make room for God's love. God, not the servant, decides when it closes.
- Pit. They dug the pit with their tongues. Slander against a servant of God discredits his message, and the speakers will answer for it.
- Prayer. Attacked, he does not take up the quarrel. He tells the Lord all about it. The judgment he then asks for belongs to an earlier age, not to Christian prayer.
- Person. The question "Should good be repaid with evil?" finds its full answer in Christ. He did nothing but good, and men hated Him without a cause.
Therefore give up their children to the famine, and deliver them over to the power of the sword; and let their wives be bereaved of children and be widows; and let their men be swept off by death, their young men be smitten by the sword in battle.
Commentary for this verse has not been generated yet.
Let a cry be heard from their houses, when thou shalt bring a troop suddenly upon them; for they have digged a pit to take me, and have hidden snares for my feet.
Jeremiah's hearers have just plotted against him. Instead of arguing with them he lays their plot before God, which raises two hard questions: what had they done to him, and how should we read a prophet who asks God to bring disaster on his own neighbours?
The plot was a response to the sign of the potter. There God claimed the right to shape or break the nation as He pleased.
In Jeremiah 18 we have the potter's house brought before us as a prophetic sign. The house of Israel was, of course, the clay for the potter to mould... So the Lord shows the desperate case of this people, with whom He had taken such trouble. The effect of sending His precious words to them was their anger and hatred of His servant. Jeremiah was the great object of their animosity.
The "pit" and the "snares" were not only physical traps. The plotters had already announced their method: they would strike him with the tongue and refuse to listen to anything he said.
The people were angry at Jeremiah's preaching about the vessel the potter remade. So they plotted against the prophet. They decided to "strike him with the tongue", and to spread false rumours about him. Backbiting and slander would in effect stop his preaching and keep anyone from listening to any of his words.
The same weapon is still in use, and the same people tend to be its targets.
Spreading rumours does great harm among the people of God — rumours perhaps true in themselves, but which run others down and belittle them... And what shall we say of the negative criticism aimed at the servants of God? It risks getting in the way of their ministry and discrediting their message.
What makes the pit so bitter is who dug it. Jeremiah had been standing between these people and the judgment they were courting.
But this draws out hatred of the prophet, and a determination to defend things as they are. Meanwhile the tested witness of the Lord can only plead against Israel — however much he had come before Him to speak good for them and to turn away His wrath.
Notice what Jeremiah does not do. He does not argue back with the men who attack him.
They rose in rebellion against the messenger of Jehovah. They hated him. They would strike him with the tongue, slander him, bring false accusations against him. But the man of God does not take up their quarrel. Like Hezekiah when the enemy insulted him, Jeremiah turned to the Lord. He tells the Lord all about it. Then he prays for judgment to fall on them. Here once more we must look at these words prophetically. During the great tribulation, the remnant of Israel will speak words like these. They suffer from their enemies, and they rightly call for heaven's vengeance.
Commentators agree the prayer was just in its own setting. They also agree it is not a model for believers today, and the reason is what God has done for us.
The prophet prays against them, for they repaid his good with evil. That prayer was not unrighteous in a servant of the Lord whose promises and hopes were earthly. Yet it would not suit those who know the surpassing grace of God now... Those who know the true grace of God today have received favour they never merited and could never claim. God has saved them, justified them and blessed them for ever in Christ Jesus. For such people to pray against others, when our blessed God and Father has treated them this way, would be inconsistent indeed.
Jeremiah's suffering points forward to the Lord Jesus. Yet the likeness stops at one exact place.
All their sinful doings are before him, and he knows them fully. Yet the prophet suffers like his Lord, of whom he is a type. He is brought "like a lamb" to the slaughter. They had devised wicked schemes against him, to cut him off from the land of the living... All this is like what Isaiah 53 says of our blessed Lord. But the prophet's prayer in the next verse is quite unlike His prayer, for Jeremiah asks for vengeance on his persecutors... while the Lord Jesus asked His Father to forgive His enemies.
- The pit's cause — the potter's sign angered them, and the anger fell on the messenger. Jeremiah became the target of their hatred.
- The pit's tools — slander and rumour, meant to silence his preaching. The same weapon still harms God's servants today.
- The pit's injustice — he had pleaded for the very people who trapped him; they repaid his good with evil.
- The pit's answer — he did not take up the quarrel. He told the Lord everything, and his words will one day be the cry of a suffering remnant.
- The pit's limit — the prayer was right for a prophet with earthly promises. It is not for those who have received grace they never earned. Jesus, plotted against in the same way, asked His Father to forgive.
And thou, Jehovah, knowest all their counsel against me to slay me. Forgive not their iniquity, neither blot out their sin from thy sight, but let them be overthrown before thee deal with them in the time of thine anger.
The men Jeremiah served are plotting to kill him, and he hands the whole matter over to God. Then he prays one of the hardest prayers in the Bible: that God would never forgive them.
The prophet had once prayed for these very people.
This draws out hatred of the prophet, and a determination to defend things as they are, while the tested witness of the Lord can only plead against Israel — however much he had earlier sought Him, to speak good for them and to turn His wrath away.
Notice what he does not do.
They rose up in rebellion against the messenger of the Lord. They hated him. They would strike him with the tongue, speak evil of him, bring false accusations against him. But the man of God does not take up their quarrel. Like Hezekiah when the enemy insulted him, Jeremiah turned to the Lord. He tells the Lord all about it. Then he prays for judgment to fall upon them.
The potter in this chapter is God's picture of how He handles nations. He had already said what would stop the judgment.
"Lord, what desolation You have made in the earth! Yet You are righteous in all Your ways. And You are patient and merciful too. For You are unlike the potter in one way. You have said: if that nation, concerning which I have spoken, turns from its evil, then I will relent of the disaster I intended to do to it" (v. 8).
The offer stood open. Instead they plotted to kill the man who brought it.
Jeremiah asks God never to blot out their sin. That raises a question bigger than his enemies: can any sin be dealt with apart from what God provides?
The sinner is therefore entirely in the hands of the One against whom he has sinned. If God appoints something that can make atonement, well and good. If He does not, the iniquity of the offender can never be purged… Isaiah speaks of people whose iniquity would not be purged until they died (22:14). And Jeremiah asked God not to forgive the sins of his persecutors (18:23). What a solemn thought this is! … Thank God, the sinner's case is not beyond remedy if he listens to God. The cases just mentioned are of people who reject the divine testimony. But God must prescribe the remedy, and the offender must accept it.
Writers agree that this prayer was not sinful in Jeremiah's mouth. They also agree that copying it today would be out of place.
They also devised schemes against Jeremiah and sought his life. The prophet prays against them, for they repaid his good with evil. This prayer was not unrighteous in a servant of the Lord connected with earthly promises and hopes. But it would not suit those who know the surpassing grace of God now, for they are connected with the heavenly purpose and hope, which rises far above what was then made known. They opposed Jeremiah unrighteously, and he asked the Lord to reward them righteously… Those who know the true grace of God today have received favour they did not merit and could not claim. They are saved, justified and blessed eternally in Christ Jesus. God our Father has treated them like this. For such people to pray against others would be inconsistent indeed.
The principle reaches further than one verse. It shapes how we read the Old Testament prayers that call down curses on enemies.
Take some of the requests recorded in the Psalms — imprecatory requests, as they are called… you can see at once that the spirit of such prayers is completely foreign to what the Christian is taught. The same is true of many of the prayers found in Jeremiah (Jer. 10:24-25; Jer. 18:19-23, and others). This is enough to show one thing. A prayer given by the Spirit of God in one period does not always suit the people of God in every age.
These words also look ahead.
Here once more we must look at these words prophetically. During the great tribulation, expressions like the prophet's here will come from the lips of the remnant of Israel. They suffer from their enemies and righteously call for heaven's vengeance. That vengeance will fall on those enemies when the Lord is revealed in glory.
- Plot. Jeremiah had prayed for these men, and they planned to kill him. He stopped arguing and told God everything.
- Potter. God said He would relent if the nation turned from its evil. Instead they plotted to kill the prophet who brought the offer.
- Pardon. God prescribes the remedy for sin, and the offender must accept it. Only those who reject His testimony are past remedy.
- Period. A prayer given by the Spirit in one age is not a prayer for every age. This one fitted a servant tied to earthly promises. It does not fit people who live under grace they never earned.
- Prophecy. The same cry will rise again from a suffering remnant in the tribulation. The Lord will answer it when He appears in glory.
Thus saith Jehovah Go and buy a potter's earthen flagon, and [take] of the elders of the people, and of the elders of the priests;
God tells Jeremiah to buy a clay flask and to walk out of the city with a group of elders and priests beside him. The errand looks small. But why does the prophet who watched soft clay on a wheel in the last chapter now carry a finished, fired pot?
The verse opens one connected action: buy the flask, take witnesses, go, and speak.
He was to get a potter's earthen bottle, accompanied by elders and priests, and go to the valley of the son of Hinnom. There he should proclaim the words the LORD would breathe into him.
The destination is not neutral ground. The valley carries one meaning, and that meaning reaches past Jeremiah's own day.
In Jeremiah 19 we have the sign of the potter's earthen vessel further developed. Now the valley of the son of Hinnom comes into view, and it always signals judgment. Tophet points to the great judgment which the Lord will carry out when He Himself comes. It is not merely a place of execution by man.
Chapter 18 and chapter 19 are two stages, not the same lesson twice. In the first, the clay could still be worked.
Things had gone wrong with Israel. Idolatry had become prevalent. The vessel had been marred. But the clay was still soft. There was still time to turn to God.
That is what changes in chapter 19. Now Jeremiah must buy a finished vessel instead of watching one take shape.
This time it is not clay that can still be formed but an earthen vessel that has been hardened in the fire. It can only be broken. The message is clear and solemn. There is a time when discipline can be accepted and bring profit. There is also a time when it is too late. The warning not to harden the heart applies.
Jeremiah goes to a valley with a history. One writer names what had happened there.
This time his task is to buy an earthen vessel. He must take some of the elders of the people with him and go to the valley of the son of Hinnom. This dreadful place was famous for idolatry: people sent their children through the fire and sacrificed them to Molech (see 2 Kings 23:10).
The old names for the place would give way to a worse one. News of the judgment would travel far beyond the valley.
Here is the solemn sign that the city, its surroundings and its people will be punished in public for their sin and idolatry. Others will hear of it, and their ears will tingle. So it becomes a powerful witness to how terrible sin is. Even the vile names Tophet and Hinnom were not strong enough for the place of their punishment. It should be called "The valley of slaughter."
The witnesses are the leaders — the very people who might think their standing protected them.
The parable of the potter, in Jeremiah 18 and 19, was meant to teach Israel one thing. They had been brought into covenant, yet they were still within the range and reach of God's judgments. Those judgments would overtake them because of their sins. In Jeremiah's day they would say, "The temple of the LORD, the temple of the LORD, are these."
Acted signs run right through Jeremiah's ministry, and each one came true.
Striking signs like the girdle were fulfilled exactly. The potter's vessel of Jeremiah 18 and the earthen vessel of Jeremiah 19 were fulfilled in the same way. We know how all this came to pass. It happened in a way that leaves no room to question either what God foretold or how He carried it out.
The two vessels speak past Jeremiah's day to anyone reading now. One writer draws two lines from them at once.
These first two symbolic incidents (the clay and the vessel) have a solemn application to unbelievers as well. There is an acceptable time when God gives an opportunity to repent. But once the heart is hardened, or death comes, it is too late. The inevitable result is the smashing of the potter's vessel. Yet the same principle applies to discipline — and this appears to be the primary thought here.
- Clay — chapter 18 showed a marred vessel still soft on the wheel; while the clay yields, there is still time to turn to God.
- Kiln — chapter 19 begins with a bought, fired flask. Fired clay cannot be reshaped, only broken. Discipline has a season, and that season can close.
- Witnesses — elders of the people and of the priests come along to watch. The men who trusted in "the temple of the LORD" had to learn that a covenant puts no one beyond judgment.
- Valley — Jeremiah takes the sign to the valley where they had burned children to Molech. The site of Israel's worst sin becomes the site of its sentence: "The valley of slaughter."
- Fulfilment — Jeremiah's acted signs came true to the letter. God's warning and His way of keeping it leave no room for doubt.
and go forth unto the valley of the son of Hinnom, which is by the entry of the pottery-gate, and proclaim there the words that I shall tell thee,
Chapter 18 sent Jeremiah to watch a potter at work; here he is sent out of the city with a finished clay jar in his hand. One writer sets the two scenes side by side to show how the second finishes what the first began.
The parable of the potter in Jeremiah 18 was meant to let Israel know one thing. They had been brought into covenant with God, yet they were still within reach of the Lord's judgments and visitations. So in Jeremiah 19 that judgment is carried out in picture form.
The valley outside Jerusalem already had a history. Jeremiah had to speak God's message on that very ground.
This time his task is to buy an earthen jar. He must take some of the elders of the people with him and go to the valley of the son of Hinnom. This dreadful place was known for idolatry: there people sent their children through the fire and sacrificed them to Molech (see 2 Kings 23:10). Jeremiah had to announce judgment there. Then he had to break the jar: "So will I break this people and this city, as one breaks a potter's vessel, so that it can never be mended."
Wherever Scripture names this valley, the meaning is the same. One writer says its new name points past any judgment carried out by men.
In Jeremiah 19 we have the sign of the potter's earthen vessel further developed. Now the valley of the son of Hinnom comes into view, and that valley always means judgment. "Therefore, behold, days are coming, declares the LORD, when this place shall no more be called Topheth, or the Valley of the Son of Hinnom, but the Valley of Slaughter." Topheth points to the great judgment which the Lord will execute when He Himself comes. It is not just the place where men carry out a sentence.
Commentators differ on the timing. One writer ties them to the siege that soon came: "It was fulfilled during the siege of Jerusalem (Lam. 4:10)," writes Arno C. Gaebelein.
The preaching was public, at a city gate, and the clay jar preached along with the prophet.
The earthen bottle of chapter 19 is figurative of Jerusalem and the people. The earlier sign showed God's right to handle any nation or kingdom as He saw fit, and His power to do it. This sign is more solemn. God will punish the city, the land around it and the people in the open for their sin and idolatry. All who hear of it will feel their ears tingle. So the sign becomes a loud witness to how terrible sin is. The foul names Topheth and Hinnom were not strong enough to describe the place of their punishment. It should be called "the Valley of Slaughter" (v. 6).
The place Jeremiah stood in gave its name to the strongest word the New Testament uses for final judgment.
Gehenna is the Greek equivalent for two Hebrew words, signifying "valley of Hinnom." It was the place near Jerusalem where the Jews made their children pass through fire to heathen gods, and which was afterwards defiled (2 Kings 23:10). A continual fire made it a fit emblem of the place of eternal punishment (Matt. 5:22, 29, 30; Matt. 10:28; Mark 9:43-47; Luke 12:5; James 3:6). The above-named place of defilement and fire is also called in the Old Testament Topheth (2 Kings 23:10; Isa. 30:33; Jer. 19:13).
One writer turns the same warning on those who feel safe today.
Christendom or Babylon has now taken this place of Israel of old. Babylon trusts in her security, despite her moral condition. She says, "I sit as a queen... and mourning I shall never see" (Rev. 18:7). But Revelation 18 is another action like that of the prophet in the potter's house, or in the valley of the son of Hinnom, teaching the unfaithful steward that the doom of the shattered vessel awaits him.
- Place — God sent the word to the valley of Hinnom, where people had burned their children to Molech. Jeremiah preached on the ground that held the sin.
- Sign — The clay jar stood for Jerusalem and its people. Chapter 18 warned of judgment; chapter 19 broke the jar past mending.
- Public — The word went out at a city gate, and all who heard it would feel their ears tingle. The jar stood there as a witness to how terrible sin is.
- Sentence — The valley would carry a new name: the Valley of Slaughter. Writers differ here. Some point to the siege that soon came, others to a judgment the Lord Himself will execute.
- Reach — That valley's name became Gehenna, the emblem of eternal punishment. Its warning still stands over anyone who says they will never see sorrow.
and say, Hear the word of Jehovah, O kings of Judah, and inhabitants of Jerusalem. Thus saith Jehovah of hosts, the God of Israel Behold, I will bring evil upon this place, the which whosoever heareth, his ears shall tingle;
God sends Jeremiah out of the city with a clay jar in his hand, and tells him whom to address: the kings of Judah and everyone living in Jerusalem. The warning is so severe that simply hearing of it will make a person's ears ring. The place where he delivers it is part of the message.
God did not let Jeremiah announce this anywhere. He had to buy a jar, gather witnesses, and walk to one particular valley.
In the next chapter (ch. 19), Jeremiah has to perform another symbolic action. This time he must buy an earthen vessel, take some of the elders of the people with him, and go to the valley of the son of Hinnom. This dreadful place was known for a terrible idolatry: people sent their children through the fire and sacrificed them to the god Molech (see 2 Kings 23:10). Jeremiah had to announce judgment there.
Jeremiah pronounces the sentence on the very ground where the crime was committed. The valley's names already told the story. In Topheth, in the valley of Hinnom, people passed their children through the fire to false gods, until King Josiah defiled the place to stop it (Morrish Bible Dictionary).
The disaster God announces is not meant to stay private.
The earthen bottle of chapter 19 is figurative of Jerusalem and the people. The earlier sign showed God's right to deal with any nation or kingdom as He saw fit, and His power to do it. This one is the solemn sign that God will punish the city, its surroundings and its people in public for their sin and idolatry, and in a way that makes the ears of all who hear of it tingle. So it becomes a powerful witness to how terrible sin is. The vile names Topheth and Hinnom were not strong enough to describe the place of their punishment. It was to be called "the Valley of Slaughter" (v. 6).
This valley stands for more than one local disaster.
Jeremiah 19 takes the sign of the potter's earthen vessel further. Now the valley of the son of Hinnom is brought forward, which is always significant of judgment. "therefore, behold, days are coming, declares the LORD, when this place shall no more be called Topheth, or the Valley of the Son of Hinnom, but the Valley of Slaughter." Topheth points to the great judgment the Lord will carry out when He Himself comes. It is not only the place where men carry out a sentence.
The name itself travelled into the New Testament. "Gehenna" is the Greek form of "valley of Hinnom." It became the word the Lord used for the place of eternal punishment (Morrish Bible Dictionary).
The object in Jeremiah's hand is not the soft clay of the earlier sign.
This time it is not clay that can still be formed but an earthen vessel already hardened in the fire. It can only be broken. The message is clear but solemn. There is a time when correction can still be taken to heart and do good, and there is a time when it is too late. The warning not to harden the heart (Hebrews 4:7) applies.
The people warned here were God's covenant nation, and that is what they leaned on.
The parable of the potter in Jeremiah 18 and 19 was meant to teach Israel one thing. God had brought them into covenant, yet they were still within reach of His judgments, and those judgments would come upon them because of their sins. In John the Baptist's day Israel shows the same self-confidence. In Jeremiah's day they would say, "This is the temple of the LORD, the temple of the LORD." In John's day they said, "We have Abraham as our father." But John, like Jeremiah, taught them again that judgment could reach them even though they were in covenant.
- Where. God announces the sentence in the valley of Hinnom, the ground where children were burned to false gods. The sin and the punishment share one address.
- Who. Kings and citizens alike must hear, and elders come along as witnesses. Rank excused no one.
- Hearing. They would not listen, so others would hear about them. The news would make ears tingle — a public witness to how terrible sin is.
- Too late. Soft clay can be reshaped; a jar fired hard can only be smashed. There is a time when correction still profits, and a time when it no longer can.
- No shelter. Covenant, temple and ancestry never put anyone beyond the reach of God's judgment.
because they have forsaken me, and have estranged this place [from me], and have burned incense in it unto other gods, whom neither they nor their fathers have known, nor the kings of Judah; and have filled this place with the blood of innocents;
God names the reasons for the disaster He has just announced, and He speaks through Jeremiah, standing in the valley where the crimes happened. The charge runs in steps. The people left God. They filled the gap with gods nobody had ever heard of. Then they shed innocent blood.
"This place" is not a neutral word. God sent Jeremiah to one valley south of Jerusalem. Its history explains why He read the sentence there.
This is often called "the valley of the son of Hinnom," but who Hinnom and his son were is unknown. The valley running from east to west, south of Jerusalem, still carries that name. In part of this valley, thought to be the east end, people passed their children through the fire to false gods. To stop this, King Josiah defiled Topheth in this valley. In God's judgments the valley will become the "valley of slaughter."
Those fires are one reason God speaks here of "the blood of innocents." The name also keeps its meaning through the rest of the book, and what it points to is bigger than anything an army could do.
In Jeremiah 19 the sign of the potter's clay jar develops further. Now the chapter brings forward the valley of the son of Hinnom, which always stands for judgment… Tophet points to the great judgment the Lord will carry out when He Himself comes. It is not just the place where men carry out judgment.
The list of charges opens with leaving God. Elsewhere in the book He calls that one half of a double wrong, and names the other half beside it.
With sorrow and pleading He cries out, "Be appalled, O heavens, at this; be shocked, be utterly desolate, declares the Lord, for My people have committed two evils: they have forsaken Me, the fountain of living waters, and hewed out cisterns for themselves, broken cisterns that can hold no water." Yet how graciously and kindly He asks them, "Have I been a wilderness to Israel, or a land of thick darkness?"
The gods that took God's place were new to everyone — the people, their ancestors, and the kings alike. The worst part was where the people put the images.
This is the state idolatry dragged people into. And that is not the worst of it. Worse still, and Israel and Judah showed it: they put the images of the gods in the temple of the Lord — gods whose worship approved these vile practices. It was lowering the true God to the level of their idols.
That is what "profaned this place" means in practice: people handed the ground God had claimed over to idols. An older translation reads "estranged this place from me" — they made God's own place foreign to Him.
The verse names bloodshed beside idolatry. Judah's history brought the two together in one verdict, dated from the reign of King Manasseh.
The Lord removed Judah out of His sight for the sins of Manasseh: "For he filled Jerusalem with innocent blood, and the Lord would not pardon." From the time of Manasseh this decree could not be taken back… There were two causes for this final judgment: idolatry, and innocent blood.
God later forgave Manasseh himself. That makes what happened to the nation more sobering, not less.
God was very merciful. Even so, the evil of Manasseh brought God's government down on the nation… When King David sinned, the Lord pardoned his sin, but God's government on his house still ran its course. It was the same with Manasseh. God heard and answered his prayer when he humbled himself. Even so, God's righteous government fell on the guilty nation he had led astray.
This charge sits inside an object lesson. In chapter 18 the clay was still on the wheel. Here the material has changed, and so has what the potter can do with it.
This time it is not soft clay that can still be shaped. It is a clay jar, hardened in the fire. It can only be broken. The message is clear and solemn. There is a time when a person can take correction and profit from it, and a time when it is too late. The warning not to harden the heart applies.
- Forsaken. The charge starts with leaving God. Elsewhere He calls it trading a living fountain for cracked tanks that hold nothing.
- Filled. Nothing stays empty. Into the gap came gods that neither the people, their ancestors, nor their kings had ever known.
- Defiled. They carried idols into the place God had claimed, and so lowered the true God to the level of idols.
- Bloodied. Idolatry and innocent blood were the two causes of Judah's final removal. God forgave the king himself, yet His government still fell on the nation.
- Broken. Clay on the wheel can be reshaped. A jar already fired can only be smashed. There is a moment when correction still profits, and a moment after it.
and they have built the high places of Baal, to burn their sons in the fire as burnt-offerings unto Baal, which I commanded not, nor spake it, neither came it up into my mind
This verse names the crime that brought Jerusalem's judgment: parents built shrines to Baal and burned their own children there as offerings. God does more than condemn it — He never asked for this, never spoke of it, and it never entered His mind.
Baal was no minor local god. His shrines already stood in the land when Israel arrived. A Bible dictionary explains his name and the worship attached to it.
The name means 'master, possessor,' and whether singular or plural it always has the article. He was the chief male god of the Phoenicians and the Canaanites, and Ashtoreth was the chief female goddess. When the Israelites came into the land, they no doubt found temples, groves, altars and high places set apart to Baal. There people offered incense, burned offerings, and sacrificed children to him. A great company of prophets and priests served him, as its later revivals make clear.
Some deny that the children were really burned. One writer answers that, and sets what these idols demanded beside what God accepted.
Parents were so blinded by Satan that they gave their children as sacrifices to Molech, the god of the Ammonites. From Jeremiah 19:5 it appears that Baal was worshipped in the same way. Some have reasoned about "passing through the fire," here and elsewhere, so as to deny that they burned their children. But this seems a well-meaning attempt to soften the reality of the wickedness. It was the fullest, though not the only, profanation of the name of Israel's God. Jehovah accepted a sheep or an ox, or even a much smaller sacrifice; Satan under these names demanded their sons.
The sharpest words in the verse are about God's own mind. One writer turns that same charge on worship that people invent for themselves.
How many practices and customs in Christendom have been "devised" of men's own hearts which have no foundation in Scripture! Many seem to think that in spiritual things everyone may do "what is right in his own eyes," instead of "Thus says the LORD." God condemned Israel for doing what, He says, "I did not command them, nor did it come into My heart" (Jer. 7:31; also 19:5; 32:35). It is the thoughts of God's heart, not mine, that I am to heed and put into practice.
The judgment matches the crime. God renames the valley where they burned their children.
In Jeremiah 19 we have the sign of the potter's earthen vessel developed further. Now the valley of the son of Hinnom comes into view, and it always means judgment. "Therefore, behold, the days are coming, declares the LORD, when this place shall no more be called Topheth, or the Valley of the Son of Hinnom, but the Valley of Slaughter." Topheth points to the great judgment which the Lord will carry out when He Himself comes. It is not merely the place of execution by man. Plainly, the judgment of Jerusalem is the subject.
The valley outside Jerusalem did not stay in the past. Its name became the word Jesus used for hell.
Does not our Lord here, in speaking of Gehenna, or hell-fire, refer to the valley of Hinnom, where the people burned their children alive? It is also called the valley of Topheth, from the fire-stove where they burned the children. This valley was the scene of those wicked sacrifices. After Josiah's time, most believe, the valley of Hinnom (Gehenna in Greek) went on being a place of foul filth and pollution. There people burned refuse and dead bodies, and worms fed on the pieces the fire did not consume.
Does this warning belong only to the past? One writer says the same road runs through Christendom.
Idolatry and moral degradation always go together. The fearful road of falling away in Christendom is no exception. Rejection of God's revelation leads into idolatry — not necessarily idols of wood and stone — and into moral decline.
- Master. "Baal" means master or possessor. He was the chief god of Canaan, served with priests, incense, high places, and the sacrifice of children.
- Demanded. God asked for a sheep or an ox; under these idol names Satan demanded their sons — the fullest profanation of God's name.
- Devised. What men build for God out of their own hearts, God disowns: never commanded, never spoken, never in His mind.
- Renamed. God renames the ground where they burned their children. It becomes the Valley of Slaughter, and it points past Jerusalem's fall to His own final judgment.
- Repeated. The valley's name became Jesus' word for hell. The pattern that filled it still repeats: revelation rejected, idolatry adopted, morals in decline.
therefore behold, days come, saith Jehovah, that this place shall no more be called Topheth, nor Valley of the son of Hinnom, but the valley of slaughter.
God gives the valley south of Jerusalem a new name, and that name is His sentence on it. The ground where the people offered their children will be the ground where their own bodies fall.
Who Hinnom was, nobody knows. What happened in his valley is on record.
This is often called "the valley of the son of Hinnom," but who Hinnom and his son were is unknown. The valley running from east to west, on the south of Jerusalem, now bears that name. In some part of it, thought to be the east end, children were passed through the fire to false gods. To stop this, Josiah defiled Topheth in this valley. Isaiah gives the key to why the New Testament links this valley, under the name Gehenna, with eternal punishment. In God's judgments the valley shall become the "valley of slaughter."
The new name is not just harsher. The old ones, foul as they were, could not carry the weight of what God was about to do there.
The earthen bottle of chapter 19 is a picture of Jerusalem and the people. In the earlier sign the point was God's right to handle any nation or kingdom as He saw fit, and also His ability to do so. Here the sign is solemn: God will punish the city, its surroundings and its people in public for their sin and idolatry. Those who hear of it will feel their ears tingle. So it becomes a powerful witness to how dreadful sin is. The vile names of Tophet and Hinnom could not say enough to describe the place of their punishment. It should be called "The valley of slaughter."
This was no empty threat. The sentence reached the bodies of the people who had worshipped there.
In Tophet, the valley of Hinnom, they had done their detestable things and burned their sons with fire. Now it should become the valley of slaughter, so that their dead bodies would be eaten by the birds and wild beasts. He would cause them to eat the flesh of their loved ones. It was fulfilled during the siege of Jerusalem (Lamentations 4:10). Then he broke the bottle as a sign that the people and the city would be broken in the same way.
Commentators differ on how far this verse reaches. Gaebelein reads it as fulfilled in the siege. William Kelly sees the valley pointing further ahead, to a judgment no army could carry out.
In Jeremiah 19 we have the sign of the potter's earthen vessel developed further. Now the valley of the son of Hinnom comes into view, and it always stands for judgment… Tophet points to the great judgment the Lord will carry out when He Himself comes. It is not merely a place of execution by man. Plainly, the judgment of Jerusalem is the subject.
The name outlived Jeremiah's generation, and it changed as it travelled.
A writer says: "Less than thirty years before the Chaldeans destroyed Jerusalem, the good king Josiah swept the idol out of the valley — the hideous ox-headed human figure of Moloch — with everything that belonged to it. He defiled the place so completely that no one could ever use it again for that frightful worship. But the horrors of the past had marked people's minds so deeply that from then on the spot bore the name Tophet — the abomination, the place to be spat upon. Later the very words Ge-hinnom, the Valley of Hinnom, changed slightly into gehenna and became the common name for hell."
Jesus took that borrowed name and used it for a far worse ruin.
People knew the Valley of Hinnom, the rubbish dump outside Jerusalem, as Gehenna. Fires always burned there, and maggots did their work without stopping. On the Lord's lips this word became a terribly fitting picture of the dwelling place of the lost. Hell will indeed be the great rubbish heap of eternity. There God will keep everything that is evil beyond correction apart from the good, and it will lie for ever under His judgment. This dreadful fact comes to us from the lips of Him who loved sinful men and wept over them.
- The place. A ravine south of Jerusalem where children went through the fire to false gods. Josiah cleaned it out, but its memory stayed.
- The sin. The idolatry there was so vile that even the names Tophet and Hinnom fell short of the punishment God had prepared.
- The name. God renames the valley "slaughter" — the place of their worship becomes the place of their burial.
- The proof. The siege of Jerusalem fulfilled the threat. Kelly sees in Tophet a further judgment the Lord Himself will carry out when He comes.
- The echo. Ge-hinnom became gehenna. On the lips of Jesus that valley became the picture of hell — a warning from the One who loved sinful men and wept over them.
And I will make void the counsel of Judah and Jerusalem in this place; and I will cause them to fall by the sword before their enemies, and by the hand of them that seek their life, and their carcases will I give as food to the fowl of the heavens and to the beasts of the earth.
Jeremiah takes a clay bottle out to the valley of Hinnom and speaks God's sentence over Jerusalem there. In that valley the people had burned their children, and now three blows answer it: their plans fail, their army falls, and their dead lie unburied.
This sign follows an earlier one, and it makes a different point.
The earthen bottle of chapter 19 is a figure of Jerusalem and the people. In the previous sign the point was God's right to handle any nation or kingdom as He saw fit, and also His ability to do so. Here it is the solemn sign that God will punish the city, its surroundings and its people in public for their sin and idolatry. Those who hear of it will feel their ears tingle. So it becomes a striking witness to how awful sin is. The vile names Tophet and Hinnom could not say enough about the place of their punishment. It was to be called "the valley of slaughter."
The first blow falls on their thinking, not on their walls. God Himself empties their plans, and He does it in that very place. Psalm 33 says the same about the plans of nations.
The contrast between the counsel of the Lord and the counsel of the nations is found in Psalm 33:10-11. The Lord brings all the plans of the nations to nothing, but His counsel is eternal. Nothing can frustrate it. It remains, showing the wisdom and the power of God. As it was then, so it is today: if the Lord so desires, He will bring to nothing all the plans of men, however wise.
The place of their sin becomes the place of their punishment. They gave their children to the fire there; now God gives their bodies to the birds and beasts there.
He was to get a potter's earthen bottle and go, with elders and priests, to the valley of the son of Hinnom. There he was to proclaim the words the Lord would give him. In Tophet, the valley of Hinnom, they had done their abominations and burned their sons with fire. Now it was to become the valley of slaughter, so that their bodies would be eaten by the birds and wild beasts. He would cause them to eat the flesh of their loved ones. It was fulfilled during the siege of Jerusalem (Lam. 4:10). Then he broke the bottle as a sign that the people and the city would be broken like that.
The last clause is not just a picture of chaos. God announces it as a penalty in its own right.
One of the judgments announced on the people of Jerusalem was this: they would not be buried. Their bodies would be food for the birds and the wild beasts.
The wording is not new with Jeremiah either. Writers trace his language back to the terms of the covenant God made with the nation through Moses, listing his parallels — among them the birds feeding on the dead.
Jeremiah's quotations from the Book of the Covenant are too many to mention. Notice a few from Deuteronomy as examples. Compare Jer. 2:6 with Deut. 32:10; Jer. 5:15 with Deut. 28:49; Jer. 7:33 with Deut. 28:26; Jer. 11:3 with Deut. 27:26; Jer. 11:4 with Deut. 4:20, and so on.
The valley's meaning does not stop with that siege.
In Jeremiah 19 we have the sign of the potter's earthen vessel developed further. Now the valley of the son of Hinnom is brought forward, and it always stands for judgment. Tophet points to the great judgment which the Lord will carry out when He Himself comes. It is not merely the place of execution by men. Plainly, the judgment of Jerusalem is the subject.
That valley later gave Jesus the word He used for hell.
When our Lord speaks of Gehenna, or hell-fire, does He not point back to the valley of Hinnom? That is where the people burned their children alive. It is also called the valley of Tophet, from the fire-stove in which the children were burned. Most believe that after King Josiah's time the valley stayed a place of filth and pollution. There people burned refuse and dead bodies.
- Emptied. The bottle pictures the city. The first thing God empties is not their blood but their plans, before a sword falls.
- Answered. Each blow answers a sin. The valley where they burned their children becomes the valley where they die.
- Exposed. God names no burial as a judgment on the city, with the bodies left to the birds and beasts.
- Fulfilled. The siege of Jerusalem carried out what the broken bottle pictured. Lamentations 4:10 records the horror.
- Extended. Tophet does not end with that siege. It stands for judgment the Lord carries out Himself, and it gave Jesus His word for hell.
And I will make this city an astonishment and a hissing; every one that passeth by shall be astonished and hiss because of all the plagues thereof.
Jeremiah stands outside Jerusalem in the valley of Hinnom. He holds a clay bottle, and the city's elders and priests are watching. There God tells him what Jerusalem itself is about to become. The verse raises two questions: why would God turn His own city into a spectacle, and is such a sentence ever final?
The location is part of the message. The place he stood in already carried a meaning.
In Jeremiah 19 the sign of the potter's earthen vessel goes a step further. Now the valley of the son of Hinnom comes into view, and that valley always stands for judgment. "So look, the days are coming, says the Lord, when this place will no longer be called Tophet, or the valley of the son of Hinnom, but The valley of slaughter." Tophet shows the great judgment the Lord will carry out when He Himself comes. It is not only the place where men carry out a sentence. Clearly, the subject is the judgment of Jerusalem.
The ruin is not random. God gives His reasons before He gives the sentence.
"Because they have forsaken Me, and have made this place strange to Me, and have burned incense in it to other gods that neither they, nor their fathers, nor the kings of Judah have known. They have filled this place with the blood of innocent people. They have also built the high places of Baal, to burn their sons in the fire as burnt offerings to Baal. I never commanded that, I never spoke of it, and it never came into My mind."
The earlier sign made one point about God. This one makes another about the city.
The earthen bottle of chapter 19 stands for Jerusalem and the people. The earlier sign meant that God has the right to handle any nation or kingdom as He sees fit, and the power to do so. Here is the solemn sign that God will punish the city, its surroundings and its people in public for their sin and idolatry, in such a way that when others hear of it, their ears will tingle. So it becomes a powerful witness to how terrible sin is. The vile names Tophet and Hinnom were not strong enough to describe the place of their punishment; it was to be called "The valley of slaughter" (v. 6).
Chapter 18 showed soft clay on the potter's wheel. Chapter 19 puts something else in Jeremiah's hands.
This time it is not clay that can still be formed but an earthen vessel that has been hardened in the fire. It can only be broken. The message is clear but solemn: there is a time when we can accept discipline and profit from it, and there is a time when it is too late. The warning not to harden the heart (Heb. 4:7) applies.
Jeremiah acted out several signs. What happened next tested them all.
Striking signs like the belt (Jer. 13) came true exactly. The Lord had taken up Israel for His honour; but they sought their own honour with "great pride" (v. 9), so they would be destroyed as a nation. The same is true of the potter's vessel of Jeremiah 18, the earthen vessel of Jeremiah 19, and the bonds and yokes of chapters 27 and 28. We know how all this came about, and in a way that leaves no room to doubt either God's prediction or His carrying it out.
The lesson does not stop with Jerusalem. One writer traces it to the end of the Bible.
But all this has a lesson for us today. Christendom, or Babylon, has now taken the place Israel once held. Babylon trusts in her safety, despite her moral state. She says, "I sit as a queen, I am no widow, and I shall never see sorrow." (Rev. 18:7.) Revelation 18 is another act like the prophet's act in the potter's house, or in the valley of the son of Hinnom. It teaches the unfaithful steward that the doom of the shattered vessel is waiting for him.
- Place: God announced judgment in Hinnom, where they had burned their own children. The sin and its sentence share one address.
- Cause: God gives His reasons first — they left Him, served other gods, and filled the place with innocent blood.
- Sign: A hardened vessel can only be broken; there is a time when correction still works, and a time when it is too late.
- Reach: God makes the ruin public. Passers-by hiss, and their shock tells everyone how terrible sin is.
- Result: Every sign came true. The same warning still reaches anyone who carries God's name but trusts in his own safety.
And I will cause them to eat the flesh of their sons and the flesh of their daughters, and they shall eat everyone the flesh of his friend, in the siege and in the straitness wherewith their enemies, and they that seek their lives, shall straiten them.
This verse holds some of the most terrible words in the Bible. God warns that a siege will drive parents in Jerusalem to eat their own children — so why does He say it, and did it happen?
God does not threaten this out of nowhere. The threat comes at the end of a list of charges, and He gives it in the valley of Hinnom, just outside the city — the very place where the people had burned their own children to idols.
In Jeremiah 19 the Lord tells the prophet to take a potter's earthen bottle before the elders of the people and of the priests. In the valley of Hinnom he is to proclaim His new message... "Because the people have forsaken me and have profaned this place by making offerings in it to other gods whom neither they nor their fathers nor the kings of Judah have known. They have filled this place with the blood of innocents. They have built the high places of Baal to burn their sons in the fire as burnt offerings to Baal, which I did not command or decree, nor did it come into my mind."
This threat was not new. Deuteronomy 28 had already spelled out what a siege would do to a people who turned away from God, including the loss of natural love inside the family.
They would besiege the cities, no matter how well fortified, causing the starving occupants to go so far as to eat their own children (v.53). See 2 Kings 6:28-29 and Jeremiah 19:8-9... in verse 54 we read that even the most refined of people would become hostile toward their wives and their children. Such would be the desperation caused by hunger that there would be no consideration left for even the closest loved ones (v.55).
Israel went through the same thing in another siege. The suffering did not turn their hearts back to God.
Israel's heart was hardened, so that in the famine accompanying the siege, instead of turning to the Lord, some of the inhabitants in their terrible extremity turned to the horrible deed of eating even their own offspring! See Leviticus 26:26-29; Deuteronomy 28:52-53; which was finally fulfilled under the Romans.
God puts the act in His own hand: "I will make them eat." He used an army to do it. Nebuchadnezzar, king of Babylon, surrounded Jerusalem, and commentators point to that siege as the fulfilment of this verse.
Nebuchadnezzar builds ramparts all around Jerusalem and undertakes a siege which lasts about eight months. Famine intensifies in the city, according to the word of Jeremiah (Jer. 19:9). During all this time, despite the countless dangers threatening him, Jeremiah stands firm for the Lord.
Lamentations mourns the fall of Jerusalem. It reports what the siege produced inside the walls.
Every trace of compassion and even of natural feeling had gone. We are next told: "The hands of compassionate women have boiled their own children; they became their food during the destruction of the daughter of my people" (v. 10). Nothing could account for such barbarity but what the prophet adds right after (v. 11): "The Lord gave full vent to his wrath; he poured out his hot anger, and he kindled a fire in Zion that consumed its foundations." What can be more thorough than to devour foundations?
Jeremiah spoke these words holding a potter's clay bottle. What the Lord told him to do with it shows what the words meant.
The earthen bottle of chapter 19 represents Jerusalem and the people. It is the solemn sign that God will publicly punish the city, its surroundings and its people for their sin and idolatry. News of it will make the ears of everyone who hears tingle. It becomes an eloquent witness to how awful sin is. Even the vile names Tophet and Hinnom could not describe the place of their punishment strongly enough; it would be called "the Valley of Slaughter." To the prophet the Lord said, "Then you shall break the flask in the sight of the men who go with you, and shall say to them, 'Thus says the LORD of hosts: So will I break this people and this city.'"
- Warned — None of this came out of nowhere. Leviticus 26 and Deuteronomy 28 had described this siege, this famine and this act centuries in advance.
- Deserved — The charges came first: God abandoned, other gods served, innocent blood spilled, children burned to Baal.
- Refused — Israel had already lived through the same horror, and still would not turn back. Suffering by itself does not produce repentance.
- Fulfilled — Nebuchadnezzar's siege lasted about eight months and made the words literal. Lamentations records mothers boiling their own children, and commentators point to a later fulfilment under the Romans.
- Signified — The Lord told Jeremiah to smash the clay bottle in front of the men with him: He would break this people and this city in the same way. News like that makes the ears of all who hear it tingle.
And thou shalt break the flagon in the sight of the men that go with thee,
God tells Jeremiah to smash a clay jar in front of the men who came with him — a message acted out, not just spoken. Why does God move from moulding soft clay in the previous chapter to shattering fired pottery here, and can anything mend such a break?
Jeremiah is holding a picture of his own city. The break is public on purpose: others will hear of it and shudder.
The earthen bottle of chapter 19 is figurative of Jerusalem and the people. The previous sign showed God's right to handle any nation or kingdom as He saw fit, and His ability to do so. This one is the solemn sign that God will punish the city, its surroundings and its people in public for their sin and idolatry. When others hear of it, their ears will tingle. It becomes an eloquent witness of how awful sin is. The vile names of Tophet and Hinnom were not strong enough to describe the place of their punishment; it should be called "The valley of slaughter" (v. 6).
The previous sign used clay that could still be shaped. This jar has already been through the fire.
This time it is not clay that can still be formed but an earthen vessel that has been hardened in the fire. It can only be broken. The message is a clear but solemn one: there is a time when discipline can be accepted for profit and there is a time when it is too late. The warning not to harden the heart (Heb. 4:7) applies.
Jeremiah broke the jar in a valley with a name and a history. One writer reads the judgment tied to that place as pointing further ahead than any judgment men carry out.
In Jeremiah 19 we have the sign of the potter's earthen vessel further developed. Now the valley of the son of Hinnom is brought forward, which always signifies judgment. Tophet points to the great judgment the Lord will carry out when He Himself comes. It is not just the place of execution by man. The judgment of Jerusalem is clearly the topic.
Jeremiah did not break the jar alone or in private. He took witnesses to the valley, and what he acted out there later came true in detail.
He was to take a potter's earthen bottle, go with elders and priests to the valley of the son of Hinnom, and there proclaim the words the Lord gave him. In Tophet, the valley of Hinnom, they had done their abominable things and burned their sons with fire. Now it should become the valley of slaughter, so that birds and wild beasts would eat their bodies. He would make them eat the flesh of their loved ones. This came true during the siege of Jerusalem (Lam. 4:10). Then he broke the bottle as a sign that the people and the city would be broken in the same way.
The broken jar carries a warning for more than one city. One writer turns it on a church that boasts of being God's own city, safe while others fear:
It is a favourite thought with her that while other churches tremble for their safety, she is above such fears — she is God's city, and has His walls around her. This is impressive. But when weighed by the teaching of the Word, it only declares more plainly what she is. It shows her all the more ripe for the judgment of God. This is because the boast is defiance. It is not faith in God, but a denial of His rights and authority.
The breaking is not the end of the story. Judgment on the vessel leaves room for what God will make next.
In prophecy God announces two things in this way. He will judge Israel (the earthen vessel). He will also form a people whom He will "build" and "plant" again (the Jewish remnant: see Isa. 10:20–22; Jer. 23:3; 31:7; Rom. 9:27).
- Vessel. The jar pictures Jerusalem and its people, and Jeremiah breaks it in front of elders and priests. The verdict is public.
- Hardened. Chapter 18 had soft clay that could be reshaped; this vessel has been through the fire, so it can only be broken.
- Place. He acts in Tophet, where they had burned their sons. The scene of the sin becomes the valley of slaughter.
- Fulfilled. The siege of Jerusalem carried out to the letter what the smashing announced.
- Rebuilt. Judgment on the vessel is not God's final word: He goes on to form a people He will build and plant again.
and shalt say unto them, Thus saith Jehovah of hosts Even so will I break this people and this city, as one breaketh a potter's vessel, that cannot be made whole again. And they shall bury in Topheth, till there be no place to bury.
God sends Jeremiah out of the city with a clay jar and tells him to smash it. The place chosen is the valley where children had been burned in sacrifice. One chapter earlier, the potter reshaped spoiled clay into a new vessel. So why can this jar never be mended?
Commentators read the jar as a picture of one city and one people. They set it against the sign that came before it.
The earthen bottle of chapter 19 is a picture of Jerusalem and the people. In the previous sign the meaning was God's right to handle any nation or kingdom as He saw fit, and also His ability to do so. Here it is the solemn sign that God will punish the city, its surroundings and its people in public for their sin and idolatry. All who hear of it will feel their ears tingle. So it becomes a powerful witness to how awful sin is. Even the vile names of Topheth and Hinnom were not enough to describe the place of their punishment. It was to be called "the Valley of Slaughter."
Chapter 18 and chapter 19 differ in the material itself. Clay on the wheel is still workable. A jar that has been through the kiln is not.
This time it is not clay that can still be shaped, but an earthen vessel that has been hardened in the fire. It can only be broken. The message is clear but solemn. There is a time when a person can take discipline and profit from it. There is also a time when it is too late. The warning not to harden the heart applies.
God does not break without stating His case. The charges read out in that valley name what had been done there:
"Because the people have forsaken me and have profaned this place by making offerings in it to other gods... and because they have filled this place with the blood of innocents, and have built the high places of Baal to burn their sons in the fire as burnt offerings to Baal, which I did not command or decree, nor did it come into my mind."
The same writer points on to a further word from that chapter. It names one more reason:
"Behold, I am bringing upon this city and upon all its towns all the disaster that I have pronounced against it, because they have stiffened their neck, refusing to hear my words."
The verse names Topheth as the burial ground. That place already had a history.
This is often called "the valley of the son of Hinnom." The valley south of Jerusalem, running from east to west, now bears that name. In some part of it, thought to be the east end, children were passed through the fire to false gods. To stop this, Josiah defiled Topheth in this valley. In God's judgements the valley shall become the "valley of slaughter."
One writer sees more in Topheth than a judgment carried out by men:
Topheth points to the great judgment which the Lord will carry out when He Himself comes. It is not only the place where man carries out a sentence.
A shattered jar cannot be put back together. Yet the breaking is not God's last word.
This is prophecy. God announces that He will judge Israel (the earthen vessel). But He will also form a people that He will "build" and "plant" again.
One writer turns the sign on a church that boasts she can never fall:
It is a favourite thought with her that while other churches tremble for their safety, she is above such fears — she is God's city, and has His walls around her. This is impressive. But weigh it by the teaching of the Word, and it only declares more clearly what she is. It shows her more fully ripe for the judgment of God. Because this boast is defiance. It is not faith in God, but a denial of His rights and authority.
- Clay — chapter 18 showed soft clay on the wheel, ready to be remade. Chapter 19 shows a fired jar, which can only be smashed.
- Cause — God Himself gives the reasons — idolatry, innocent blood, and a stiffened neck that refused to hear.
- Place — God staged the sign in the valley where children were burned. That valley becomes the graveyard, so the sin and the sentence share one address.
- Reach — the jar warns every people and every system that boasts it cannot fall. That boast is defiance, not faith.
- Remnant — God breaks the vessel, yet says He will build and plant a people again. The breaking ends the old thing, not His purpose.
Thus will I do unto this place, saith Jehovah, and to the inhabitants thereof, and make this city as Topheth.
Jeremiah has just smashed a clay jar in the valley of Hinnom. Now God ties that sign to Jerusalem itself. Two questions press on the verse: what was Tophet, and why would God make His own city like it?
Tophet was a real place just outside Jerusalem. Its history was ugly, and one writer traces both what happened there and what the name later came to mean.
This is often called "the valley of the son of Hinnom," but who Hinnom and his son were is unknown. The valley runs from east to west, on the south of Jerusalem, and still carries that name. In one part of it, thought to be the east end, children were passed through the fire to false gods. To stop this, Josiah defiled Topheth in this valley. Isaiah gives the key to why the New Testament links it — under the name Gehenna — with eternal punishment… In God's judgments the valley will become the "valley of slaughter."
So the threat runs: the city that hosted this horror will become like it. The place of their worst sin becomes the place of their judgment.
In chapter 18 the clay was still soft on the wheel, and the potter could reshape it. Chapter 19 uses a different object, and that difference carries the whole message.
This time it is not clay that can still be formed but an earthen vessel that has been hardened in the fire. It can only be broken. The message is clear and solemn. There is a time when someone can accept discipline and profit from it, and there is a time when it is too late. The warning not to harden the heart applies.
That is the force of "thus will I do to this place." God is not holding a threat in reserve. Their own hardness has already settled the outcome.
Making the city "like Topheth" is not random severity. God's dealings match what people have chosen. One writer states that rule, and ends it with grace.
If the children of Israel abandon Jehovah to serve idols, Jehovah gives them up to serve idolaters. It is the same with us. If we sin, our sin measures and defines our chastisement. And so grace works repentance when we turn and cry to the Lord in our distress.
Judah handed that valley over to false gods. Now the valley's character is stamped on the city itself.
Human hands carried out part of this. One writer sees the language of Tophet pointing much further.
In Jeremiah 19 we see the sign of the potter's earthen vessel taken further. Now the valley of the son of Hinnom comes forward, and that valley always stands for judgment… Tophet points to the great judgment the Lord will carry out when He Himself comes. It is not just the place where men carry out judgment. Clearly, the topic is the judgment of Jerusalem.
The old names for the valley no longer fit. In God's judgment it takes a new one: the valley of slaughter.
Jerusalem's confidence rested on its temple and its covenant. The broken jar struck straight at that confidence. The same confidence turns up again later in a new form.
The parable of the potter, in Jeremiah 18 and 19, was meant to teach Israel this. They were brought into covenant, yet God's judgments could still reach them. And those judgments would overtake them because of their sins. In John the Baptist's time, Israel shows the same self-confidence. In Jeremiah's day they would say, "the temple of the LORD, the temple of the LORD." In John's day they said, "We have Abraham as our father"… All this has a lesson for us.
The lesson carries over to us. A standing given by God has never been a shelter from His judgment.
- Tophet — a valley south of Jerusalem. Children were passed through the fire to false gods there. Josiah defiled the place. The New Testament later links it with eternal punishment under the name Gehenna.
- Mirror — sin measures its own chastisement. The city gave that valley its character, so God makes the city like the valley.
- Hardened — the potter could reshape the soft clay of chapter 18. The fired jar of chapter 19 can only break. A hardened heart leaves discipline nothing to work with.
- Beyond men — men carried out judgment on Jerusalem. Yet Tophet points on to the great judgment the Lord Himself will carry out when He comes.
- No shelter — the covenant never put Israel beyond God's judgments. The same false confidence later said, "We have Abraham as our father." The lesson is there for us.
And the houses of Jerusalem and the houses of the kings of Judah shall be as the place of Topheth, defiled, all the houses upon whose roofs they have burned incense unto all the host of the heavens, and have poured out drink-offerings unto other gods.
Jeremiah has just smashed a clay jar as a picture of what God will do to Jerusalem. Now the sentence reaches every roof in the city: what people did on their housetops decides what God will make of their homes.
Topheth was a real valley, with a grim history and a grimmer future. A reference work on Bible words traces both:
The valley is often called "the valley of the son of Hinnom," but who Hinnom and his son were is unknown... In some part of this, supposed to be the east end, children were passed through the fire to false gods. To prevent this Josiah defiled Topheth in this valley... In God's judgements the valley shall become the "valley of slaughter."
The valley's name later passed into Greek, and into the New Testament:
Gehenna is the Greek form of two Hebrew words meaning "valley of Hinnom."... A fire that never went out made it a fitting picture of the place of eternal punishment.
The smashed jar stood for the city and its people, palaces included. Their punishment would be as public as the sign:
The clay jar of chapter 19 stands for Jerusalem and the people... Here it is the solemn sign that God will punish the city, its surroundings and its people in the open for their sin and idolatry. Those who hear of it will feel their ears tingle. So it becomes a powerful witness to how dreadful sin is. Even the vile names Topheth and Hinnom were not strong enough to describe the place of their punishment.
One writer reads the threat as reaching past any human army:
In Jeremiah 19 the sign of the potter's clay vessel is taken further. Now the valley of the son of Hinnom comes in, and it always stands for judgment... Topheth shows the great judgment the Lord will carry out when He Himself comes. It is not just a place where men carry out a sentence. Clearly the subject is the judgment of Jerusalem.
The offerings on the roofs went up to the sky. One writer, describing the same practice, gives the cult its modern name:
They worshipped the hosts of the heavens from housetops. They worshipped the stars, and studied their movements as if they could give them help and a revelation. Astrology, so widely practiced among civilized nations today, is an old cult (2 Kings 21:3, 5; Jer. 8:2; 19:13).
Judah had not swapped God for the stars. They kept both:
What made this idolatry so offensive was the joining of the idols of the nations with Jehovah. To be what we might call a plain, outright idolater was not nearly so evil as to show that you know the true God and yet put false gods on a level with Him. It is this outrage against God that the passage describes.
The wine and the incense carried a meaning before the idolaters took them up:
Incense spoke of the merits of Christ, and drink offerings of the joy found in the life and death of the Lord Jesus. Yet by the incense they burned to idols, and the wine they poured out, the people claimed by their action that false gods had merits of their own. They claimed to have found joy in a rite that was really the worship of demons (1 Cor. 10:20), little though they knew it.
Another writer applies this to us:
Every blessing that God has ever given to man, man has corrupted. This is true of the drink offering also. We must make sure that all our worship — and all our thoughts, words and actions — are directed to giving joy to God. Anything else that aims at pleasing ourselves is like offering drink offerings to false gods.
- Roof. The sin starts on the housetops — incense to the stars, studied as if they could give help and revelation. One writer calls this old cult by its living name: astrology.
- Mixture. They joined the idols of the nations to the Lord Himself. Knowing the true God and still putting false gods beside Him is the worse evil.
- Corruption. The poured-out wine was God's own gift, a picture of joy in Christ; redirected to idols it became the worship of demons.
- House. So the houses where it happened — palaces included — take on the defilement of Topheth. That is the valley where they passed their children through the fire, and which King Josiah defiled to stop it.
- City. The broken jar says the whole city goes the same way, publicly, so that others' ears tingle. One writer sees the threat reaching past any human army to the judgment God carries out when He Himself comes.
And Jeremiah came from Topheth, whither Jehovah had sent him to prophesy; and he stood in the court of Jehovah's house, and said to all the people,
Jeremiah has just smashed a clay bottle in the valley outside Jerusalem. Now he walks back through the city gate, stands in the temple courtyard, and says it all again in public. The question this verse raises is why the sign needed a second delivery — and what it cost the man who delivered it.
The valley he came back from already had a history.
This valley is often called "the valley of the son of Hinnom." It runs from east to west, on the south of Jerusalem, and still bears that name. In some part of it, supposed to be the east end, children were passed through the fire to false gods. To prevent this, Josiah defiled Topheth in this valley. In God's judgments the valley shall become the "valley of slaughter."
The chapter uses that valley for a reason:
In Jeremiah 19 we have the sign of the potter's earthen vessel developed further. Now the valley of the son of Hinnom is brought forward, which is always a sign of judgment. Tophet points to the great judgment which the Lord will carry out when He Himself comes. It is not merely the place where men carry out executions. Clearly, the judgment of Jerusalem is the subject.
The words he spoke there named the reason for what was coming:
That was not all. On his return from Tophet the prophet stood in the court of the Lord's house and said to all the people: "Thus says the LORD of hosts, the God of Israel, Behold, I am bringing upon this city and upon all its towns all the disaster that I have pronounced against it, because they have stiffened their neck, refusing to hear my words."
He kept delivering such warnings for years. Where did that come from?
Boldness was not natural to Jeremiah. Quite the opposite. It was the power of God and of His Spirit alone, at work in the prophet, that moved him to deliver the warnings the Lord gave him for his people and their rulers. He did this over the course of so many years.
The message he carried back turned on the material of the sign.
This time it is not clay that can still be shaped, but an earthen vessel hardened in the fire. It can only be broken. The message is clear but solemn. There is a time when discipline can be accepted for profit, and there is a time when it is too late. The warning not to harden the heart applies.
Another writer compares this sign with the earlier one:
The earthen bottle of chapter 19 pictures Jerusalem and the people. In the earlier sign the point was God's right to handle any nation or kingdom as He saw fit, and also His ability to do so. Here it is the solemn sign that God will punish the city, its surroundings and its people in public for their sin and idolatry. He will do it in a way that makes the ears of those who hear of it tingle.
This verse opens a section about what the priests did to him next — and what it cost him inside.
Then we have a historical passage (Jer. 19:14 — Jer. 20:18), dealing with the persecution of the prophet by the priests. This attack by Pashur leads Jeremiah to open up his deepest inward feeling. There was no steeling of his heart against the persecution. His mouth was like steel, no doubt, but his heart was very soft indeed. He went through deep agony because of what he had to say against his adversary. So the very man who seemed as if nothing could bend him was in truth held in the greatest grief before God. At last he pours it out to the Lord.
One writer draws the lesson forward to our own day:
But all this has a lesson for us today. Christendom, or Babylon, has now taken the place that Israel of old once held. Babylon trusts in her security, despite her moral condition. She says, "I sit as a queen, I am no widow, and mourning I shall never see." But Revelation 18 is another action like the prophet's in the potter's house, or in the valley of the son of Hinnom. It teaches the unfaithful steward that the doom of the shattered vessel awaits him.
- Hardened. A potter can still reshape soft clay. A fired vessel can only break. Hardness changes the outcome.
- Hardened necks. God names the reason for the coming disaster: they stiffened their neck and refused to hear His words.
- Hardened place. Tophet, where children passed through the fire, becomes the valley of slaughter. The place of the sin becomes the place of the sentence.
- Unhardened messenger. Jeremiah's mouth was steel, his heart soft; boldness was not his nature but the Spirit's power in him.
- Still speaking. The shattered vessel still warns every unfaithful steward who says, "I sit as a queen."
Thus saith Jehovah of hosts, the God of Israel Behold, I will bring upon this city and upon all her cities all the evil that I have spoken against it; for they have hardened their necks, not to hear my words.
Jeremiah has just smashed a clay jar in front of the elders and priests in the valley of Hinnom. Now he repeats the message in the city's most public place: all the disaster God has spoken is coming, because they would not listen.
The prophet did not speak these words just anywhere.
When the prophet returned from the valley of Hinnom he took his place in the court of the LORD's house and declared the fate of the city.
He spoke it in the courtyard of the temple, where the people came to worship.
The verse is the spoken half of an acted sign. A writer explains what the clay bottle stood for and why it had to be smashed in public.
The earthen bottle of chapter 19 is a figure of Jerusalem and the people. In the previous sign the point was God's right to handle any nation or kingdom as He saw fit, and also His ability to do so. Here it is the solemn sign that God will publicly punish the city, its surroundings and its people for their sin and idolatry. He will do it in such a way that when others hear of it, their ears will tingle.
Nothing new is threatened here. God gathers up everything He has already said and announces that it is now coming. Earlier signs in this book had already come true.
Striking signs such as the belt were fulfilled exactly… The same is true of the potter's vessel of Jeremiah 18 and the earthen vessel of Jeremiah 19… We know how all this came to pass. It happened in a way that leaves no room to question either the divine prediction or the divine fulfilment.
God names one reason for all of this: they stiffened their neck and would not hear. One writer explains that picture:
He tells them to circumcise the foreskin of their heart. That is, they must cut off the selfish, fleshly desires of their heart and "be stiff-necked no longer." Being stiff-necked refers to the stubbornness of wanting our own way.
So the charge is not weakness. It is a will set on having its own way.
Why does God treat a refusal to listen so seriously? Because of who is speaking. One writer draws the line:
This was cold rebellion, not just failure. They would not pay any attention to God's Word. They refused God Himself, not only His Word. In fact, to refuse His Word is to refuse Him. What could they expect as a result? God gave them over to their own stubborn heart. They would have to learn by hard experience the utter folly of walking in their own ways.
The crowd hearing this stood in God's own house. They were His covenant people, in the city He had chosen. The sign struck at exactly that confidence.
The parable of the potter in Jeremiah 18 was meant to teach Israel one thing. Though they had been brought into covenant, they were still within reach of the Lord's judgments and visitations. So in Jeremiah 19 the judgment is acted out. In John the Baptist's time Israel shows the same spirit of self-confidence. They said in that spirit, "We have Abraham as our father"… But these boasts were empty, as both John and the Lord tell them.
One writer applies the scene beyond Jerusalem, to any religious system that assumes it is safe.
But all this has a lesson for us today. Christendom, or Babylon, has now taken this place of Israel of old. Babylon trusts in her security, despite her moral condition. She says, "I sit as a queen, I am no widow, and mourning I shall never see." But Revelation 18 is another acted sign, like the prophet in the potter's house or in the valley of the son of Hinnom. It teaches the unfaithful steward that the doom of the shattered vessel awaits him.
- Hearing. God names one charge: they would not hear His words. Everything else grows out of that refusal.
- Hardening. A stiff neck is stubbornness that insists on its own way — a chosen posture, not a weakness.
- Refusing. To turn down His Word is to turn down Him. God then gives you over to your own stubborn heart.
- Breaking. The earlier sign showed God's right to judge. The smashed jar announced that He would — and it came to pass, just as He said.
- Presuming. Covenant, temple and family name shelter no one. The shattered vessel warns every confident but unfaithful steward.