:

Hear, my beloved brethren Has not God chosen the poor as to the world, rich in faith, and heirs of the kingdom, which he has promised to them that love him?

Read Full Chapter

Commentary for this Verse

James has just described favouritism in the meeting. Now he asks the question that settles it: whom has God Himself chosen? His answer overturns the world's ranking. The people with nothing are the ones He makes rich, and the ones who will inherit the kingdom.

"Poor in the world"

One writer looks closely at the Greek phrase here and finds a poverty measured by one standard only.

The true reading, found in the oldest and best manuscripts and adopted by the most recent scholars, is tō kosmō. It appears to be the dative of reference — that is, poor in respect of, or as to, the world. This is a common enough use.

William Kelly

Where God's choice has fallen

James asks his readers to look at the facts in front of them. The people flattering the rich were flattering the very class that was attacking them.

The rich Jews were mostly the proud opponents of Christ and His people, and they blasphemed His worthy name. God's choice had mainly fallen on the poor. The words of the apostle to the Gentiles in 1 Corinthians 1:26-31 agree with this. These chosen poor ones — true Christians — were rich in faith and heirs of the coming kingdom. They fawned on the proud blasphemers and persecutors because they were rich. They poured contempt on the followers of Christ because they were poor. That only proved the blindness and folly of those who acted that way. They looked at both rich and poor with the world's shallow gaze, not with the penetrating eye of faith.

F. B. Hole

This is not God shutting a door on anyone. Another writer traces the pattern to what people do with the message.

Of course God does not discriminate against the rich. He declares His gospel to all alike. But it is the poor who receive it, while the rich mostly see no need of it. So it is the poor who are blessed by it. And God honours the riches of their faith: they become heirs of the kingdom, for they love Him.

Leslie M. Grant

Why poverty becomes an advantage

"Rich in faith" is not a consolation prize. Grace turns the low place into a real advantage.

When God calls the poor, grace makes their humble position a decided advantage to them. No bondage is more overbearing than the one "society" imposes on those who serve it. Nothing is more at odds with the Lord of all. He passed judgment on the whole of it by standing outside it all. He ignored all its claims and walked His path of holy goodness to everyone in unswerving obedience. The poor believer sees this, rich in faith, and escapes his class's determination to rise in the world by religious means as by every other way.

William Kelly

Heirs of a kingdom

The word "heirs" points forward. Its honour is of a different order from the honours people chase now.

The world thinks it an honour to keep company with those who stand high in the kingdoms of this world and its glory. Far greater is the privilege of keeping company with those whom God has called to His kingdom and glory. Even if down here they were only uneducated fishermen, they are going to sit on thrones judging in the kingdom of Christ. It is a far greater honour to be found with them than with the greatest ruler of this passing world.

Hamilton Smith

"Those who love Him"

Some have read the final clause as though it marked out the poor alone. One writer rejects that. Love for God is not the mark of a special class of Christian. It is the mark of the new nature in every believer.

1 John 5:1 shows that loving God and loving one's brother cannot be separated from being born of God. It is essential to the new nature. How dreadful to imagine a believer who does not love God or obey Him! It is precious to know that God has chosen the poor as to the world, rich in faith and heirs of the kingdom. But the verse adds the words "which He has promised to those who love Him". Who except the legal mind would confine that clause to the poor and refuse it to a Nicodemus or a Joseph of Arimathea?

William Kelly

The inconsistency exposed

Set against God's choice, the behaviour looks absurd. Poor people were flattering money and forgetting what they owned themselves.

These weak Jewish believers were mostly poor. They had so far forgotten their early warmth of faith that they cringed before the wealthy — even in their meetings, if a rich man came in. Yet were they not rich in faith, the poorest of them? Were they not heirs of the kingdom which the One who chose them promised to those who love Him? What inconsistency, to put on the air of valuing a little money and to close the eye of faith to their own hopes of glory.

William Kelly

The same danger is named as a present one, and not only for the obviously worldly.

This truth needs insisting on in a day like the present, when the money of this world has become the snare of the professing church, and when those who claim to have more light, and to be walking a separate path, are in danger of being attracted by the world's respectability, wealth, and position.

The Christian's Friend

Summary

- Chosen — God's choice has mainly fallen on the poor. His gospel excludes no one; the poor simply receive what the rich see no need of.

- Poor — poor by one measure only: as to the world.

- Rich — grace makes the low place an advantage. It frees the believer from society's demand to rise.

- Heirs — the inheritance is a kingdom. Standing with fishermen who will reign there outranks standing with the greatest ruler of this passing age.

- Loving — the promise is to all who love God, and that is everyone born of Him. To flatter wealth after that is to shut the eye of faith on your own hope of glory.