To whom then will ye liken God? and what likeness will ye compare unto him?
This question comes at the end of a long display of God's greatness as Creator. It does not ask for information. It challenges. If nothing in heaven or earth can stand beside God, can any image of Him ever be true? And can such a God be known at all?
The prophet asks this question, then asks it again a few verses later. One writer shows who the challenge targets and why no one can plead ignorance:
If God is so great and man so small, the prophet challenges those who in their folly attempt to make a likeness of the living God. He opens and closes his challenge with the same searching question, "To whom then will you liken God?" Yet neither riches nor poverty will keep men from this folly. The rich will set up an idol from some enduring wood. But can such people plead ignorance? Have they not known? Have they not heard? Has there been no witness of the Creator from the beginning — from the foundations of the earth?
An image of God fails, and not because the craft is poor. The maker can only draw on what is inside him:
It is impossible for man's thoughts to get beyond himself. So any image of God he makes can only be a reflection of himself. That drags God down to man's own likeness. Job asks a question that no one can answer: "Can you find out the deep things of God? Can you find out the limit of the Almighty?" Whatever the witness of creation may be — true witness as it is — God never really left man to that. As Scripture assures us, He declared Himself at the beginning. It was man who chose to get away from this, banishing himself into the darkness and distortion of his own thoughts.
Idol-making sounds like something done in a workshop long ago. One writer finds the same sin much closer to home:
The root of all idolatry is self-will. It is making a god of our own. It is starting with self and fashioning a god, not necessarily out of silver, and not necessarily with our hands... there is a tool more cunning and skilful than the hands, and that is the intellect of man. Wherever self takes the place of the will of God, you will find the human mind busy making a god to please itself. And it does this in the name of the Lord, in the name of the true God.
God has not left us without words for Himself. But those words work in a different way from a picture:
God first made man in His own likeness. The fall spoiled that likeness, and the true knowledge of God was lost. As a result men have groped after God. They tried to know Him by resemblances or likenesses, and it ruined them. So we are warned against the attempt to liken God to anything in Scriptures such as Isaiah 40:18, 25 and 46:5-7. On the other hand, the names "Father" and "Son," used of God, work by analogy. Their meaning would have been lost on us if we did not know something of fatherhood and sonship in the relationships of this life.
Isaiah's question forbids every likeness men make. It does not forbid the likeness God Himself provided:
Christ is the image of God, in fullness and perfection; He alone showed us the invisible God. Tradition never revealed the true God. Philosophy, on the contrary, made matters worse, as did the resources of human religion... It is utterly impossible that man should see Him who is invisible. Man needed someone to bring God down to him, and to display His word and ways, and Christ is that one image of the invisible God.
God's greatness is not cold. It is the very ground of comfort:
How great He is. He never wearies or faints. But here is our comfort: His heart is as tender toward His own people as His arm is strong in creation. Behold your God, you fearful saints, and take fresh courage. "He will tend his flock like a shepherd; he will gather the lambs in his arms; he will carry them in his bosom." His arm upholds creation, but His bosom is the resting place for His lambs.
- Compare — the prophet asks the question, then asks it again, closing off every likeness from both ends. Nothing in creation can be set beside God.
- Carve — an image fails because the maker cannot get beyond himself. His god ends up a mirror of man, not a revelation of God.
- Conceal — idolatry needs no workshop. Self-will shapes a god with the intellect and calls it by the true God's name.
- Christ — the likeness men make is forbidden. The likeness God gave is His Son, the one image of the invisible God, who alone brings God within reach.
- Comfort — the arm that is strong in creation is the arm that gathers the lambs, so this measureless God is the ground of courage for fearful people.
The workman casteth a graven image, and the goldsmith spreadeth it over with gold, and casteth silver chains [for it].
Isaiah has just described a God too great for any comparison, and then asked who could look like Him. This verse gives the answer men build: a metal figure, plated with gold and hung with silver chains.
The section of Isaiah that opens at chapter 40 has one running argument, and this verse belongs to it.
In the first division of this portion of Isaiah, we find references to idols in every chapter, and this in connection with Israel. It becomes evident that the leading subject is God's controversy with Israel as to their idolatry.
The prophet then turns on the idol-makers themselves.
If then God is so great and man so small the prophet challenges those who in their folly attempt to make a likeness of the living God. He opens and closes his challenge with the same searching question, "To whom then will you liken God?" Yet sadly, neither riches nor poverty will preserve men from this folly. But can such people plead ignorance? Have they not known? Have they not heard?
The verse names the materials: gold overlay and silver chains. The choice of metals is not accidental.
"Their idols are silver and gold, the work of human hands," says the psalmist (Ps. 115:4). "Their land is filled with silver and gold … their land is filled with idols," says the prophet (Isa. 2:7-8). That which man considers most precious, which his heart craves and which adds to his glory, he makes into a god. That is the root of idolatry. God is displaced and man exalted, in the exaltation of his idol. The result is a terrible degradation, as the first chapter of Romans tells us (Rom. 1:25).
Set beside a God this great, the finished product is pitiable. So is the man who paid for it.
God is great beyond all our thoughts, as verse 18 shows. In the presence of His glory, the makers of carved images look foolish and deserve contempt, as verses 19 and 20 say — images that cannot even move. And how feeble and small are men! They look like grasshoppers. Their princes and judges are nothing and emptiness, like stubble before a whirlwind.
Isaiah returns to this contrast later in the book. It comes down to one question: who makes whom?
So idols stand in contrast with Jehovah, yet you cannot compare them with the true God for a moment. Jehovah is the Maker; an idol has to be made. Once made, it carries no one; someone has to carry it. Once set in its place, it cannot move. It cannot answer a cry for help, and it cannot save anyone from trouble.
If no craftsman can represent God, verse 18's question still waits for an answer. Commentators find it in a Person, not a thing.
Christ is the image of God, in fullness and perfection. He alone has shown us the invisible God. Tradition never revealed the true God. Philosophy made matters worse, and so did everything human religion could offer. Christ, and Christ alone, has truly represented God to man, as He alone was perfect man before God.
This has a sharp edge for anyone who thinks the danger died out with metal statues. The mind's own manufactured picture of God falls under the same verdict.
If anyone tries, by any effort of his mind or work of his imagination, to form an image of God or of Christ, that is nothing but idolatry. To reach any knowledge of God or of Christ except by Scripture is nothing but mysticism and confusion. More than that, it puts us straight into the devil's hands, to be led by him into the wildest, darkest and deadliest delusion.
The practical test is which way the weight travels.
The contrast exists around us today. It is still a fitting question — Do you go your way, carrying the things that you idolize, or does your God carry you? The idols of the modern English-speaking world are not images. They are subtler things, such as money, pleasures and desires. Yet as life draws to its end they let you down. The God whom we know, revealed in our Lord Jesus Christ, carries us through to the finish, for His love holds us and will never let us go.
- The question. "To whom then will you liken God?" opens and closes the challenge. Verse 19 gives the answer men build: a cast figure, plated with gold and chained with silver.
- The materials. What a man prizes most becomes his god. Gold and silver in an idol displace God and exalt man.
- The failure. God makes; men make the idol and then carry it. It cannot move, answer, or rescue.
- The alternative. No craftsman and no imagination can picture God. Christ alone has represented Him, and Scripture alone tells us of Him.
- The test today. Idols now are money, pleasure and desire. You carry them, and they fail at the end. The God revealed in Christ carries you.
He that is impoverished, so that he hath no offering, chooseth a tree that doth not rot; he seeketh unto him a skilled workman to prepare a graven image that shall not be moved.
This verse ends a short, sharp sketch of idol-making inside Isaiah's great chapter on the greatness of God. It raises a hard question: why does even poverty not stop a man from making a god?
Idols come up here in chapter after chapter. One writer reads that repetition as the clue to God's real dispute with His people.
In the first division of this portion of Isaiah, we find references to idols in every chapter, and this in connection with Israel (see Isa. 40:18–25; Isa. 44:9–20; Isa. 46:1–7). So it becomes clear that the leading subject is God's controversy with Israel as to their idolatry.
A close rendering of the passage shows the man's situation and his remedy: he has nothing to bring, so he settles for wood, and hires skill he does not have himself.
Then He challenges the folly of those that set up graven images as entitled to resemble or to represent Him. "To whom then will you liken God? and what likeness will you compare to Him? The workman casts a graven image, and the goldsmith spreads it over with gold, and casts silver chains. He that is impoverished so that he has no offering chooses a tree that does not rot; he seeks him a skilled workman to prepare a graven image that shall not be moved."
Verse 19 shows a man with gold and silver to spend. Verse 20 shows a man with almost nothing. The same folly runs through both.
God is so great and man so small. So the prophet challenges those who in their folly try to make a likeness of the living God. He opens and closes his challenge with the same searching question, "To whom then will you liken God?" Yet sadly, neither riches nor poverty will preserve men from this folly. The rich will set up an idol from some enduring wood. But can such people plead ignorance? Have they not known? Have they not heard? Has there been no witness of the Creator from the beginning — from the foundations of the earth? … What folly, then, to liken God to an image made by human hands!
He cannot afford a sacrifice, yet he funds wood and a craftsman. One writer names the drive underneath that arithmetic.
Human nature shows itself in the blindness and folly of its religious side. It will make a god rather than not have one, and is not competent to estimate the value of a god so made… Not liking to retain God in his knowledge, man makes Him what he wishes Him to be — the reflection of his own passions and desires. These are what already control him, and in his idol he merely yields himself to their control. A further power comes in when many people take up that first choice, and time hides where it came from. Then the idol gains authority over the conscience as well as power over the heart.
He picks wood that will not rot and pays for an image that will not move. One writer shows what such a fixed god is worth.
Idols stand in contrast to Jehovah, but cannot for one moment be compared with the true God. Jehovah is the Maker; an idol has to be made. Once made, it does not carry others — it has to be carried. Set in its place, it cannot move, cannot respond to the cry of need, and cannot save from trouble.
The answer to the idol-maker is the greatness of God Himself. One writer traces that to where it lands for a believer today.
God is great beyond all our thoughts, as verse 18 shows. In the presence of His glory, how foolish and contemptible are the makers of graven images, as verses 19 and 20 say — images that have not even the power of motion… He who created all things has no equal and cannot be likened to any other. We do well to ponder this magnificent passage. This God of unspeakable power and majesty has been made known to us in Christ as our Father.
This is not only an old problem in a far country. One writer points to its effects much nearer home.
See the folly of idolatry, shown up so strongly in these chapters! See the dishonour to God! See the debasing effect on the idolaters themselves! Notice, too, the terrible effects of idolatry and superstition in the Christian world; just compare them with the results of faith. The differences are wide and plain to those who are able to see. The true believer needs neither idol nor image. For him the Son of the Father's love, our Lord Jesus Christ alone, is the image of the invisible God.
- Controversy. Idols appear in every chapter of this section. God's dispute with His people over idolatry is the running theme.
- Craving. Human nature "will make a god rather than not have one," and cannot judge the worth of a god it made itself.
- Cost. Neither riches nor poverty cures the folly. The man too poor for an offering still buys wood and hires a craftsman.
- Contrast. He wants a god that will not rot or move. But an idol must be made and must be carried. It cannot answer a cry or save.
- Christ. God has no equal, and He is known as Father in Christ. The believer who has Him needs no image.
-- Do ye not know? Have ye not heard? Hath it not been told you from the beginning? Have ye not understood the foundation of the earth?
Four questions come one after another, and not one of them asks for information. God is speaking to people who swapped Him for images they made, and His charge is not that they lacked proof but that they ignored it.
This question belongs to a longer argument. If anything could excuse people who make images of God, it would be ignorance.
If God is so great and man so small, the prophet challenges those who in their folly try to make a likeness of the living God. He opens and closes his challenge with the same searching question, "To whom then will you liken God?" But sadly, neither riches nor poverty will keep men from this folly. The rich will set up an idol made from some lasting wood. But can such people plead ignorance? Have they not known? Have they not heard? Has there been no witness of the Creator from the beginning — from the foundations of the earth?
"From the beginning" and "from the foundations of the earth" point to a testimony that started when the world did. One writer ties this witness to what the created world still says about its Maker.
Creation is the earliest witness of God to man. As soon as man fell, he needed more than that — and in the mercy of God he found it. If men turned their back on that witness, or corrupted it with their own folly, it still remained. They could not silence it. "For his invisible attributes, namely, his eternal power and divine nature, have been clearly perceived, ever since the creation of the world, in the things that have been made. So they are without excuse" (Rom. 1:20).
What should they have understood? The verses around this one answer: God is so great that people and rulers alike shrink to nothing before Him.
God is great beyond all our thoughts, as verse 18 shows. In the presence of His glory, how foolish and contemptible are the makers of graven images, as verses 19 and 20 say — images that cannot even move. And how feeble and unimportant are men! They appear as nothing more than grasshoppers, and their princes and judges as nothing and vanity, and as stubble in the face of a whirlwind. We do well to think over this magnificent passage. This God of indescribable power and majesty has made Himself known to us in Christ as our Father.
The verse asks what they had understood since the earth was founded. One writer contrasts what Isaiah wrote about the earth with what the world around him believed.
The ancients believed that the earth rested on the shoulders of a mythical giant named Atlas. Egyptian philosophy was putting forward the "flat earth" theory. Isaiah, meanwhile, stated that God sits on the circle of the earth and marks out a circle on the face of the deep, proclaiming the rounded shape of the earth.
The point of all this is not the size of God on its own. Isaiah answers people who had decided their case had slipped past God's notice.
So Israel had the witness of creation to the power and glory of God, and yet they are rebuked for their unbelief in turning to idols. They acted as if their way, with all its difficulties, was hidden from God, and as if He was indifferent to the rights of His people. What folly! The God with whom His people have to do is everlasting, and ever present as Jehovah — the I AM. He is also the Creator of the ends of the earth. There is no place hidden from Him.
But greatness alone is not the comfort. The comfort lies in whose greatness it is.
How great He is. He never wearies or faints. But here lies our comfort: His heart is as tender toward His own people as His arm is strong in creation. Behold your God, you fearful saints, and take fresh courage. "He will tend his flock like a shepherd; he will gather the lambs in his arms; he will carry them in his bosom" (v. 11). His arm upholds creation, but His bosom is the resting place for His lambs.
- Told — the four questions are a charge, not a quiz. The truth went out from the beginning.
- Still told — creation has spoken since the world began. No one can silence it, and no one has an excuse for ignoring it.
- Retold wrongly — men who had this witness still set up images of their own making. The prophet calls that folly, not ignorance.
- Beheld — they should have seen a God so great that nations are vanity and rulers are stubble. He has made Himself known to us in Christ as our Father.
- Upheld — the same greatness that dwarfs the nations carries the weak. His arm upholds creation; His bosom holds His lambs.
[It is] he that sitteth upon the circle of the earth, and the inhabitants thereof are as grasshoppers; that stretcheth out the heavens as a gauze curtain, and spreadeth them out as a tent to dwell in;
Isaiah 40 answers a people who had begun to distrust God. This verse lifts their eyes to the One seated above the whole earth — and asks what image made by human hands could ever stand in for Him.
The chapter sets God against the idols His people had turned to. One summary of its flow:
Then comes the contrast between Jehovah and idols. Princes shall be brought to nothing. He is the Creator of the heavens. Why does Israel distrust Him?
The word "circle" describes the shape of the earth God sits above. One writer shows how unusual that claim was at the time:
The ancients believed that an imaginary giant named Atlas carried the earth on his shoulders. Job knew, a thousand years before Socrates, that the earth is balanced in space and held in orbit by gravity. "He hangs the earth on nothing" (Job 26:7) was his inspired statement. Egyptian philosophy was putting forward the "flat earth" theory. Meanwhile Isaiah stated that God sits above the circle of the earth and marks out a circle on the face of the deep. He was declaring that the earth is a sphere.
The verse sits inside a challenge that opens and closes with the same question. Creation has borne witness from the beginning, so no one can plead ignorance:
If God is so great and man so small, the prophet challenges those who in their folly try to make a likeness of the living God. He opens and closes his challenge with the same searching question: "To whom then will you liken God?" Sad to say, neither riches nor poverty will keep men from this folly. The rich will set up an idol made of some lasting wood. But can such people plead ignorance? Have they not known? Have they not heard? Has there been no witness to the Creator from the beginning — from the foundations of the earth? Is there no witness to the One before whom the inhabitants of the earth are mere grasshoppers? What folly, then, to liken God to an image made by human hands!
The comparison takes in the strongest men too — and then lifts our eyes higher:
And how feeble and insignificant men are. They appear as no more than grasshoppers. Their princes and judges are nothing and vanity, like stubble before a whirlwind. We may also lift up our eyes and look at the mighty creation beyond our little earth. He has numbered and named it all, and He upholds it too, so that not one fails. He who created them has no equal and cannot be likened to any other. We do well to think about this magnificent passage. This God of indescribable power and majesty has made Himself known to us in Christ as our Father.
He handles the sky the way a person puts up a tent. One writer runs through that greatness and lands somewhere personal:
He "stretches out the heavens like a curtain, and spreads them like a tent to dwell in" (Isa. 40:22). Even the stormy wind carries out His word (Ps. 148:8). The nations are counted as a drop from a bucket, and as the fine dust on the scales (Isa. 40:15). He rolled the mountains together and set valleys, seas and rivers in their places. He calls all the stars by name, so that not one is missing (Ps. 147:4). This is the God who loves me!
Because size means nothing to Him, no detail of a life is beneath His notice:
Great and small are only terms used among men. They cannot apply to Him "who humbles Himself to behold the things that are in heaven," as well as "the things that are on earth." All are alike to Him "who sits above the circle of the earth." Jehovah can count the stars, and while He does so He can notice a falling sparrow. He can make the whirlwind His chariot and a broken heart His dwelling place. Nothing is great or small with God.
- Look up. The verse answers a people who had begun to distrust God. He sits above the earth, and He is not absent from it.
- No excuse. Creation has borne witness from the beginning, so no one can claim ignorance of the Creator.
- Idols shrink. No carved image can stand for the One who spreads the sky like a tent. It is folly to liken God to the work of human hands.
- Rulers shrink too. People look like grasshoppers to Him. Princes and judges are stubble before a whirlwind.
- Then come close. The God who stretches out the heavens notices a falling sparrow and lives in a broken heart. He has made Himself known to us in Christ as Father.
that bringeth the princes to nothing, that maketh the judges of the earth as vanity.
Isaiah 40 brings comfort to a people who had every reason to feel small. Here the prophet turns to the men who look largest on earth, the rulers, and says God reduces them to nothing. Why would a message of comfort spend its strength on cutting down human greatness?
The verse is not a stray remark about politics. It sits inside a challenge the prophet presses twice, aimed at people who thought they could make an image of God.
If God is so great and man so small, the prophet challenges those who in their folly try to make a likeness of the living God. He opens and closes his challenge with the same searching question, "To whom then will you liken God?" ... What folly then to liken God to an image made by human hands!
Next to God, ordinary people shrink to insect size, and the verse does the same to the ones who rule them. Older translations read "judges" for rulers and "vanity" for emptiness — the wording these writers use. One writer carries that measuring beyond our earth, and ends with what this God is to us in Christ.
How feeble and insignificant are men! They appear only as grasshoppers. Their princes and judges are only as nothing and vanity, like stubble in the face of a whirlwind. We may also lift up our eyes and look at the mighty creation outside our little earth. He numbers and names it all, and He upholds it too, so that not one fails. He who created them has no equal and cannot be likened to any other. We do well to ponder this magnificent passage, for Christ has made this God of unspeakable power and majesty known to us as our Father.
The verse uses the present tense: God brings princes to nothing. Writers read this as a description of how history runs now.
The knowledge of God's power everywhere at work on our behalf is meant to produce confidence in our hearts towards Himself. But the whole moral world is under His control as well. He rules or overrules the hearts of all men, and the whole realm of human thought and action. He rules or overrules public opinion in all its forms, at all times, with all the characters great and small who appear in it. So He orders the rise and fall of nations, the course of their histories and the extent of their territories.
Another writer draws the same conviction from the history of the empires. Their success was never a matter of who was strongest.
It is not man that governs in any case, but God. God is sovereign, and therefore acts according to His own will. It is not a question of the party that has the most strength or the most wisdom. It was not because of their superior power that Babylon, or Persia, or Greece, or Rome won the empire of the world. Most of them had small beginnings.
A chapter of comfort spends its middle section pulling down human greatness. The greatness on display belongs to the Shepherd of that same people.
His glory and power serve His goodness to His people. So they will rejoice that their Shepherd is none less than the LORD, who counts all creation a very little thing, and the nations less than nothing. What a death-blow to any likeness of Him! — to an image carved by man!
The two halves of the chapter belong together: the arm with no rival is the arm that carries the weak.
How great He is. He never wearies or faints. But here lies our comfort: His heart is as tender toward His own people as His arm is strong in creation. Behold your God, you fearful saints, and take fresh courage. "He will tend his flock like a shepherd; he will gather the lambs in his arms; he will carry them in his bosom" (v. 11). His arm upholds creation, but His chest is the resting place for His lambs.
Words like these do not land the same way on everyone. One writer ties the effect to where the hearer stands with God.
The majesty of God must always fill the fallen creature with terror. But that terror connects itself with the different states and positions of men in relation to the moral rule of God. Those who were deaf to God's claims could hear such words from Him only with pure terror. The godly, those in whom there was a work of God, felt godly fear combined with a sense of divine mercy.
- Nothing — God does not just limit rulers and judges. He reduces them to nothing and emptiness, like stubble before a whirlwind.
- Nobody — If the greatest people measure out at zero, no carved image can stand in for God. That is the argument the verse serves.
- Now — This is not only a future reckoning. God orders the rise and fall of nations. The empires of history won their place by His sovereignty, not their strength.
- Ours — The power that empties thrones belongs to the Shepherd of His people. His arm holds up creation and gathers the lambs.
- Response — The same majesty leaves one hearer in bare terror. In another it stirs godly fear mixed with a sense of mercy.
Scarcely are they planted, scarcely are they sown, scarcely hath their stock taken root in the earth, but he also bloweth upon them and they wither, and the whirlwind taketh them away as stubble.
Isaiah 40 comforts a people who felt forgotten. It works by shrinking the things they feared. Verse 24 takes the rulers of the earth, who look firmly settled, and treats them as seedlings with no roots yet, blown away by a breath.
The prophet asks one question twice over in this section: what can you compare God to? One commentator traces the argument, from the smallness of man to the folly of making a god:
If God is so great and man so small, the prophet challenges those who in their folly try to make a likeness of the living God. He opens and closes his challenge with the same searching question, "To whom then will you liken God?" Yet neither riches nor poverty will keep men from this folly. The rich will set up an idol made from some lasting wood. But can such people plead ignorance? Have they not known? Have they not heard? Has there been no witness to the Creator from the beginning — from the foundations of the earth? Is there no witness to the One before whom the people of the earth are mere grasshoppers? Before Him the great ones of the earth are as nothing and vanity. His power makes the greater ones wither, and carries them away like stubble. What folly then to liken God to an image made by human hands!
One writer runs down the same scale — idol-makers, ordinary people, then their princes and judges — and ends with what this God is to us now:
God is great beyond all our thoughts, as verse 18 shows. In the presence of His glory, how foolish and contemptible are the makers of graven images, as verses 19 and 20 say — images that cannot even move. And further, how feeble and small are men! They appear only as grasshoppers. Their princes and judges are as nothing and vanity, and as stubble in the face of a whirlwind. We do well to ponder this magnificent passage, for this God of unspeakable power and majesty has been made known to us in Christ as our Father.
The storm in this verse is not a stray weather image. The same picture comes back through the Old Testament, in God's hand:
This is often referred to in the Old Testament as one of the means God uses in His judgements on the earth. It is twice connected with the south. Job 37:9; Isa. 21:1; Isa. 40:24; Isa. 41:16; Jer. 23:19; Jer. 30:23.
The chapter moves in steps. It tells Jerusalem her suffering is over. It calls the people themselves grass. It sets God against the idols. Then it asks why Israel distrusts Him:
Isaiah 40:1-8 is introduction. Jerusalem has been chastened enough, and the Lord speaks to her heart. But that comes with this solemn truth — "All flesh is grass." God's own people, according to the flesh, come under this description too: "the people are grass." Grass withers. That does not stop their full blessing. But they must know that "the word of our God will stand forever." That word secures the promises and their fulfilment... Then comes the contrast between Jehovah and idols. He brings princes to nothing. He is the Creator of the heavens. Why does Israel distrust Him? The strongest shall faint — "they who wait for the LORD shall renew their strength."
A verse about withering rulers could sound bleak. It is part of a comfort. The chapter that reduces flesh to nothing points to a God who never tires:
Note that Isaiah 40, in comforting Israel, shows the nothingness of flesh (in Israel as elsewhere) and of the nations of idols compared with God. But the power and tirelessness of God secures Israel in grace. He that waits on Him, Jehovah, renews his strength.
- Comparison. The verse answers one question — what can you compare God to? — by showing that the great ones of the earth wither before His power like stubble.
- Rootlessness. Princes and judges have no time to take root. Before God they are grasshoppers, as nothing and vanity.
- Whirlwind. The storm that carries them off is one of the means God uses in His judgements on the earth, not an accident of weather.
- Distrust. Idols and princes come to nothing. So the question turns back on us: why distrust Him?
- Renewal. The strongest faint. Those who wait for the Lord renew their strength, because His power never tires.
To whom then will ye liken me, or shall I be equal? saith the Holy One.
Isaiah 40 brings comfort to people who feared God had lost sight of them. In the middle of it God asks for someone to compare Him with. No one can be named, and the title He signs the question with, "the Holy One," shows why.
This is not a stray line. It repeats the challenge asked seven verses earlier. The whole section on idol-making sits between two matching questions.
God is so great and man so small. So the prophet challenges those who in their folly try to make a likeness of the living God. He opens and closes his challenge with the same searching question: "To whom then will you liken God?" Sadly, neither riches nor poverty will keep men from this folly. The rich will set up an idol from some lasting wood. But can such people plead ignorance? Have they not known? Have they not heard? Has there been no witness of the Creator from the beginning?
God signs the question with a name. That name is not decoration — it says what makes Him beyond comparison.
The name "Holy One of Israel" means that the God of Israel stands completely apart from all evil, for His eyes are too pure to look at evil. The seraphim say the same thing when they cry out in front of His throne: "Holy, holy, holy, is the Lord of hosts."
Behind this warning lies a problem in us. One writer separates two ways truth can reach us: by resemblance and by analogy.
Others have noted that truth about things we do not know may reach us either by resemblance or by analogy. Man was first made in the likeness of God, but the fall badly spoiled that likeness, and men lost the true knowledge of God. So they have groped after God and tried to gain some knowledge of Him by resemblances or likenesses, and that to their ruin. This is why Scripture warns us against trying to liken God to anything, in passages such as Isaiah 40:18, 25; 46:5-7. On the other hand, the names "Father" and "Son," as used of the Godhead, work by analogy. Their meaning would have been lost on us if we had not known something of fatherhood and sonship in the relationships of this life.
God does not leave the question hanging. He points instead to what He has made, and to what that means for us now.
We may also lift up our eyes and look at the mighty creation outside our little earth. He numbers and names it all, and He upholds it too, so that not one fails. He who created them has no equal and cannot be likened to any other. We do well to think long about this magnificent passage, for Christ has made this God of unspeakable power and majesty known to us as our Father.
Creating belongs to God alone. One writer builds on that to answer who the Son is.
The Son, then, is eternally divine. An inspired prophet teaches us that one attribute of Godhead is Creator... He, then, who created all things is Jehovah. So in this first aspect of the Son we have the clearest possible proof that He is "from everlasting."
All this greatness has a purpose. It answers Israel's fear that God had stopped caring.
Creation itself witnesses to the power and glory of God. In the face of that witness, Israel is rebuked for turning to idols in unbelief, as if their way, with all its difficulties, was hidden from God and He did not care about the rights of His people. What folly! The God with whom His people have to do is everlasting, and ever present as Jehovah — the I AM; He is also the Creator of the ends of the earth. There is no place hidden from Him.
- Question — the verse repeats the challenge of verse 18 and closes the case against image-making.
- Holy — the name on the question means He stands apart from all evil, the holiness the seraphim cry out at His throne.
- Marred — the fall spoiled God's likeness in man. So every likeness we build misleads. "Father" and "Son" teach by analogy, not resemblance.
- Creation — God points overhead instead. He numbers, names and upholds it all, and He has no equal.
- Comfort — that same Creator sees the way His people feared was hidden from Him.
Lift up your eyes on high, and see! Who hath created these things, bringing out their host by number? He calleth them all by name; through the greatness of his might and strength of power, not one faileth.
God does not answer doubt with an argument. He tells His people to look up at the night sky and ask who made it — and the answer turns out to be their own Shepherd.
Just before this, the passage mocks the people who make idols. One writer sets what human hands make against what fills the sky:
God is great beyond all our thoughts. In the presence of His glory, how foolish and contemptible are the makers of carved images that cannot even move. How feeble and small are men too. They appear only as grasshoppers, and their princes and judges as nothing and worthless, and as stubble in the face of a whirlwind. We may also lift up our eyes and behold the mighty creation outside our little earth; all numbered and named by Him, and upheld by Him too, so that not one fails. He who created them has no equal and cannot be likened to any other. We do well to ponder this magnificent passage, for this God of indescribable power and majesty has been made known to us in Christ as our Father.
Notice that God never sets out to prove He exists. He points at what He made and lets it speak:
There is no elaborate argument in proof of the existence of God. The Holy Spirit could not take up anything of that kind. God reveals Himself. He makes Himself known by His works… Who but "God" could "create" anything? "Lift up your eyes on high and see: who created these?"
The God who made the stars also keeps them going. One writer says plainly who this Creator and Sustainer is:
He is next described as "upholding the universe by the word of His power." He is the God of providence as well as the Creator. This is no mysterious pagan deity that we believe in along with all mankind. If only the God of providence were more widely recognised as our Saviour and Redeemer too. He it is who upholds all things, who brings forth the heavenly hosts, calling them all by their names, for He is strong in might; not one fails. But you say, "It is God, surely." Yes, but God the Son, blessed be His name.
God brings the stars out by number and calls them by name. One writer shows what such counting means, starting from the day God counted Israel:
This was an expression of His rights as Lord of Israel. He had title to take their number, for they were all His own. If He had no right to them, and no prospects in them, He would not have counted them. The same divine title appears in another part of His dominions: "He determines the number of the stars; he gives to all of them their names." This is the expression of His sovereignty among the heavenly hosts.
The words "not one is missing" speak of order as well as power:
Those heavenly bodies display His power by their immensity. They also display His wisdom and skill in the harmony with which they follow their appointed courses. He who created them holds them fast in their orbits of unthinkable greatness. "Not one fails." There is no discord, no clash — all makes melody as they declare His glory.
The One who marshals the stars is the same One who cares for weak people:
His glory and power serve His goodness to His people. So they will rejoice that their Shepherd is none less than Jehovah, who counts all creation a very little thing, and the nations less than nothing. What a death-blow to any likeness of Him! — to an image carved by man! He marshals the host of heaven and calls each by name. He also gave poor Jacob his princely name. He never faints; He gives power to the faint. Those who wait for Him shall renew their strength, as Israel will in that day.
- Look — God does not argue that He exists. He points to the night sky and reveals Himself by His works.
- Create — only God can create. Writers point to this verse and say the Creator is God the Son.
- Number — to count something is to claim it. God counted Israel because they were His own, and He counts the stars by the same right.
- Name — He calls each one by name. No member of that vast host is anonymous to Him.
- Uphold — "not one is missing" means perfect order above, and strength below for people who feel faint.