The burden of Egypt. Behold, Jehovah rideth upon a swift cloud, and cometh to Egypt; and the idols of Egypt are moved at his presence, and the heart of Egypt melteth in the midst of it.
This chapter is a word of judgment against Egypt, Israel's old oppressor. Egypt was proud of its wisdom, its river and its gods, and the chapter opens with God Himself arriving. What does it mean that the Lord comes riding on a cloud, and why do Egypt's idols shake before He does anything at all?
Isaiah 19 belongs to a long run of prophecies. Each one is headed by a word the ESV translates "oracle" and older translations translate "burden." The term carries weight in both senses.
Scholars do not agree on the force of massa in such places. Its natural meaning would be "a judgement that lies heavy on the people." But some take its meaning to be "an oracle or sentence pronounced against them."
The cloud is not scenery. A comment on the mighty angel of Revelation, who also comes down clothed with a cloud, points back to this verse:
A mighty angel comes down out of heaven, clothed with a cloud, the special sign of Jehovah's majesty (Isa. 19:1): none but He has the title to come thus clothed.
Egypt's safety lay in its water barriers and its wealth. A God who travels by cloud is not stopped by rivers.
The prophet speaks out plainly here, with full moral truth. He declares the certain overthrow of this great realm — the home of the old world's wisdom, of degrading idolatry, and of rich natural resources. What good were the boasted defences of their waters? Jehovah "rides upon a swift cloud," and He dooms Egypt to shame and decay. Their appeal to their false gods was worse than useless.
Why do the idols tremble first? Commenting on a similar passage in Ezekiel, one writer traces the quarrel from the night Israel left Egypt to the end:
It is with the gods of Egypt, as at first so now at last, that God's main controversy lies. This was before Him when the destroyer went through the land and struck the firstborn on the night of the Passover. It is before Him here too, when He adds that there will be no more a prince in the land of Egypt.
Verse 1 describes something that began in history and reaches far beyond it. A principle for reading prophecy explains the movement:
The prophet takes up circumstances near at hand, ones that concerned the faith of God's people at the time. He then goes on to later and final events, where God would display His government and bring it to a close… In Isaiah 19 the prophecy begins with the present things. At verse 16 it starts to pass on to the ultimate events, taking the present judgments as the picture.
Egypt was the crutch God's people kept reaching for, even after He had rescued them from it.
Egypt has been a breaking staff to Israel; a staff of reed, which offered much but never kept its promises, bringing only ruin to all who trusted it. Going down to Egypt for help was the constant snare of the people of God. Yet God had rescued them from that land, and in their own rescue they had seen His judgment on it… The lesson is as plain as it is basic. It is the lesson, "Cease from man, whose breath is in his nostrils, for of what account is he?"
Egypt's story does not stop with melted hearts. The same chapter closes with Egypt named among God's own.
That nation was so proud of its natural wisdom, the old oppressor and frequent snare of Israel. God will humble it to the dust. Out of the dust it will cry to Jehovah, the God of Israel, and He will send them a mighty deliverer. They will know Him and worship Him in a way He accepts — He who struck them, but who will heal them with a great salvation.
- Burden. The heading word means both a sentence pronounced and a weight that settles on a nation — God tells Egypt in advance what will press it down.
- Cloud. Riding on a swift cloud is the sign of Jehovah's majesty, and no one else may come that way. Egypt's rivers and defences cannot stop Him.
- Idols. They tremble because they are the real target — the same quarrel God took up on Passover night He takes up here to the end.
- Staff. Egypt was the reed Israel kept leaning on. It promised much and always failed, and the lesson is to stop trusting man.
- Healing. The chapter that begins with melting hearts ends with Egypt crying to the Lord. He sends a mighty deliverer, and the God who struck them heals them.
And I will incite the Egyptians against the Egyptians; and they shall fight every one against his brother, and every one against his neighbour; city against city, kingdom against kingdom.
Egypt was the old world's showcase of wisdom, wealth and religion. Here the Lord says its ruin will come from inside its own borders. Who is behind a nation's collapse into civil war? And is that judgment God's last word for that people?
The threat is not a foreign army. It is Egyptians turned against Egyptians, and the Lord Himself says, "I will stir up." One writer sets this breakdown at home beside the attacks coming from outside. He asks what Egypt's famous defences were worth:
What use were the boasted defences of their watery barriers, if Jehovah, who "rides upon a swift cloud," dooms Egypt to humiliation and decay? Their appeal to their false gods was worse than useless. Their idols would tremble at His presence, and the heart of Egypt would melt within it. Internal division and civil war (v. 2) would come on top of the crushing attacks from outside. Foolish advice would complete the downfall, along with the wasting away of all national spirit.
The Lord's hand does not stop at the border. It reaches the very things Egypt counted as its glory. The same writer points to Ezekiel's picture of the proud creature lying among his own streams:
The hand of Jehovah would fall not only on the defences of the country, but on its internal supports — and on everything that was their glory and their confidence. For is this not Ezekiel's "great dragon that lies in the midst of his streams," the one who says, "My Nile is my own; I made it for myself" (Ezekiel 29:3)?
Another writer explains what Egypt stands for. It is the picture of a man who has lost faith in God and so puts his faith in himself:
The soul away from God has lost faith in Him. It must then have faith in itself, or there would be despair at once. So man's own competence steps in to fill the gap left by a God he now counts incompetent. He takes freely what God has graciously given him, and uses it to build himself up in pride and self-sufficiency. We see this unmistakably in Egypt, the lesson of which is as clear as it is fundamental.
Neighbour fighting neighbour is not unique to Egypt. It happens again and again in the Bible's history:
Often in biblical history the enemies kill one another. Jonathan proved it (1 Samuel 14:20), Gideon (Judges 7:22), Jehoshaphat (2 Chronicles 20:23), Egypt (Isaiah 19:2).
Another writer sees the same hand governing nations, not only people:
God's government deals with nations as well as with people. In the days of Israel's trouble, God was bringing disturbance among the nations all around them: "nation was broken against nation, and city against city," and peace could not be found. If men will not have God, they must suffer at the hand of God for their self-will and idolatry.
Commentators see the prophecy working on two levels. Part of it landed soon after Isaiah spoke; part of it still waits:
Again we notice a feature that is so common in these prophecies. The predictions soon pass from judgments close at hand to those that will ripen at the end of the age. History tells us that soon after Isaiah's day Egypt did fall from her former high position, and the things listed in verses 1-10 came upon them. The princes of Zoan did become fools, though long before, in the days of Moses, "the wisdom of Egypt" was famous.
Another writer leans more toward the future:
There may have been a partial fulfilment of what God brings before us in this chapter. But the end of the chapter makes it very plain that the future is in view.
The strife of verse 2 is not Egypt's final chapter. The same prophecy that announces anarchy also announces mercy:
Here we have the burden of Egypt — its judgment and its blessing. Not Israel only, but Assyria, Israel's conqueror at that time, will be blessed. Even if ruin fell on that land in the meantime, even if anarchy followed and cruel lords later oppressed it, grace will follow and bless in the end.
- Stirred — The civil war is no accident of politics. The Lord says He will set Egyptians against Egyptians, and the collapse follows His word.
- Struck within — His hand reaches past Egypt's borders to its inner supports. It falls on the very river Egypt claimed as its own.
- Self-sufficiency — Egypt shows man at his plainest. He takes God's gifts freely, then builds himself up in pride.
- A pattern — Enemies destroy one another again and again in Scripture. Gideon, Jonathan and Jehoshaphat all saw it.
- Grace after ruin — Commentators differ on how much has already happened. But the chapter ends in blessing. Anarchy and cruel rulers come first, then mercy.
And the spirit of Egypt shall fail in the midst of it, and I will destroy the counsel thereof; and they shall seek unto the idols and unto the conjurers, and unto the necromancers, and unto the soothsayers.
Egypt's fall in this chapter starts inside the nation. Nerve fails, counsel breaks down, and the people turn to idols and mediums for the guidance they can no longer find in themselves. Two questions follow. What does it mean for a nation's spirit to be "emptied out"? And why does God let a terrified people run straight into the occult?
Foreign attack and civil war are only part of the judgment. The deeper stroke drains away Egypt's courage and good sense. That loss drives the nation back to its old superstitions, and from there into slavery.
The prophet speaks boldly, and with full moral truth. He sets out the certain overthrow of the great realm of the old world's prudence, of degrading idolatry, and of abundant natural riches… Civil war and internal division (v. 2) would come on top of the crushing assaults from outside. Mad counsels, and the wasting away of all national spirit, would complete the downfall. In their distress they would go back to their old haunts of superstition and sorcery. Then God would shut them up to the hard bondage of cruel lords and a fierce king.
William Kelly (Kelly's own rendering of the verse: "the spirit of Egypt shall be made void in the midst of it.")
Older translations call some of these men "charmers." The word points to the low, soft muttering of the sorcerer, and to the way that softness works on a person.
"Charmer," from chabar, "to join together, to fascinate." It goes with another word, lachash, "to speak in a soft, gentle manner," and is then applied to charming serpents (Ps. 58:5). In the same way a man is deceived and disarmed of his dislike of dealing with evil spirits, until he finds himself under their power. In Isa. 19:3 a different word, ittim, is translated "charmer," with a similar meaning — the gentle sound made in the incantations of the sorcerers.
Isaiah had already described this among his own people. Men listen to the muttering of mediums when they will not turn to the living God.
We find from Scripture that Satan once worked among the people of Israel by using human "tongues" to draw them away from the living God. Instead of turning to the Lord, they were persuaded to "inquire of the mediums and the necromancers who chirp and mutter" (Isa. 8:19). These diviners chirped and muttered in cries no easier to understand than those of birds and beasts… See also the reference to "whisperers" in the margin of Isa. 19:3.
God Himself says, "I will confound their counsel." That strikes Egypt where it was proudest. Egypt was famous for its wisdom, so the prophet turns on it with a challenge.
The prophet next (v. 11) taunts this proud power. He strikes at the very thing that made it stand highest, both in its own opinion and in the esteem of men. For who has not heard of "the wisdom of the Egyptians"?… "Where are they then, your wise men?" is the prophet's piercing challenge, "and let them tell you now; and let them make known what Jehovah of hosts has purposed upon Egypt."
Nineveh went the same way. The same trade with evil spirits is alive in our own day.
Like all these ancient cities, Nineveh was full of witchcrafts, that is, sorceries. The power of darkness showed itself in the rule of evil spirits, which Nineveh courted. Spiritism, as promoted today by men of research and culture… is not a new thing. Egypt, Babylon, Nineveh and other centres of paganism were full of occultism, and the practice of it hastened their doom. The same evil powers will complete the doom of our age.
The same instinct shows up whenever trouble comes and God has been ignored in good times.
On every hand, in the middle of their deep troubles and overwhelming disasters, men are once again stretching out their hands to demons. Having lived without God in the days of their ease and prosperity, and refusing to own God in the day of their calamity, they fall under the power of demons.
The chapter does not end in ruin. The land full of idols is promised something else.
In the past Egypt was well filled with altars to false gods and with pillars raised in honour of its despotic kings. It is going to have an altar to the Lord in its midst and a pillar to the Lord on its border. Not many of either, notice, but one only — for by then they will acknowledge the one true God. Though He strikes them for their sins, He will heal them and send them a deliverer.
- Emptied. The judgment strikes inside first. Courage drains away and God confounds their counsel, and "mad counsels as well as the wasting away of all national spirit" finish the collapse.
- Whispered. The words behind "charmer" mean a soft, gentle muttering. That softness leaves a person "disarmed of his dislike of dealing with evil spirits."
- Confounded. God strikes Egypt's proudest asset, its famous wisdom. The prophet then dares its wise men to say what God has purposed against Egypt.
- Hastened. Courting the powers of darkness never rescues a nation. In Egypt, Babylon and Nineveh the practice "hastened their doom," and the same evil powers work in our own age.
- Healed. The chapter that begins with idols and mediums ends with one altar and one Lord — He strikes Egypt, then heals it.
And the Egyptians will I give over into the hand of a cruel lord, and a fierce king shall rule over them, saith the Lord, Jehovah of hosts.
Isaiah's prophecy against Egypt reaches a turning point here. God hands a nation famous for its wisdom, its wealth and its gods over to a harsh master, and He signs the sentence with His own name. Older translations, which the writers quoted below use, read "cruel lord" where the ESV reads "hard master."
In its trouble Egypt turned back to superstition and sorcery. One commentator reads the harsh ruler as God's answer to that.
The prophet speaks boldly, and with the fullest moral truth. He sets out the sure overthrow of this great kingdom — the kingdom of the old world's shrewd wisdom, of degrading idolatry, and of plentiful natural riches. What use were the boasted defences of their water barriers, if the Lord, who "is riding on a swift cloud," dooms Egypt to humiliation and decay?… In their distress they went back to their old haunts of superstition and sorcery. So God would shut them up to the hard bondage of cruel lords and a fierce king.
This blow landed on Egypt's strong point. One writer explains what that was.
It was the same human wisdom that Israel looked to, and Egypt is the symbol of it in the ancient world. No country in the early history of the world was so famous for natural wisdom as Egypt… Egypt's chief support was good counsel, as if there were no living God. It leaned on the counsel of man sharpened by long experience, for it was one of the oldest powers to rise to greatness.
One writer notes how these prophecies move in two stages.
Again we notice the feature so common in these prophecies. The predictions soon pass from judgments close at hand to those that will ripen at the end of the age. History tells us that soon after Isaiah's day Egypt did fall from her former high position. The things described in verses 1-10 came upon them.
One commentator points past what the record of history shows.
History here seems to be silent, but prophecy is not. It declares that the land of Egypt will not escape the king of the north, the last Assyrian, at the time of the end. He must then himself be broken without hand (Dan. 11:41-45).
The same pattern appears with another empire. One commentator explains what a conqueror really is.
God had raised up the Babylonians to carry out His work of government. The Babylonians little thought why God had raised them to the height of power. He raised them only to be an instrument in His hand, to chastise His people and to restrain the evils of the nations. Yet so it was in the prophet's day. And so it has been again and again in the history of the world, when God has let ruthless tyrants run their course of aggression over the nations around them for a time.
The verse ends with a compound Hebrew title — in the ESV, "the Lord GOD of hosts." A Bible dictionary sets out its parts:
Adon Jehovah Sabaoth, Isa. 19:4, the Lord, the LORD OF HOSTS.
Another writer explains the force of that title.
This title means THE LORD of hosts. It occurs over 300 times in the Old Testament… The combination is spread all through the Old Testament. Isaiah alone has 60 occurrences of this beautiful title. It carries the thought of mighty irresistible power and resource in the hands of the Lord.
The fierce king is not the last word in this chapter.
Ruin may fall on that land meanwhile; anarchy may follow; cruel lords may oppress it after this. Still, grace will follow and bless in the end. But what a complete change when the land of Judah will be a terror to Egypt — a thing never yet fulfilled!
- Cause. In its distress Egypt turned to idols, mediums and sorcery. God answered by shutting it up under a hard master and a fierce king.
- Target. The blow fell where Egypt boasted. A nation that leaned on human counsel "as if there were no living God" lost the very thing it trusted.
- Instrument. God raises conquerors to power as tools in His hand. The fierce king over Egypt is God's instrument, not God's favourite.
- Reach. Egypt's fall began soon after Isaiah spoke. Writers see it repeated at the end of the age, when Egypt will not escape the king of the north — who is then broken himself.
- End. God signs the verse as "the Lord GOD of hosts," a title of irresistible power. Yet the same chapter promises grace: after the cruel lords, God blesses Egypt at last.
And the waters shall fail from the sea, and the river shall be wasted and dried up;
Isaiah 19 announces God's judgment on Egypt, and at verse 5 the blow falls on the Nile — the source of the land's food, trade and wealth. Two questions press: why strike a river, and is this past or still ahead?
Verses 1–4 describe invasion, civil war and a cruel ruler. Verse 5 moves inward, to the supply line underneath all of Egypt's confidence.
But the hand of Jehovah would come not only upon the defences of the country. It would come upon its internal supports too, and so upon all that was their glory and their confidence. Is this not Ezekiel's great dragon, lying in the midst of his streams? He says, "My Nile is my own; I made it for myself" (Ezekiel 29:3). Isaiah predicts the same one here.
Egypt's watery barriers were its pride. Kelly asks what they were worth once God set Himself against the land:
What good were the boasted defences of their watery barriers, if Jehovah, who "rides upon a swift cloud," dooms Egypt to humiliation and decay?
Egypt lived by the Nile, not by rain. That made the river a picture of life that never looks upward.
The river, as we see in Scripture itself, was the very symbol of independence. Egypt drank no rain from heaven. Its supply did not come from above. This is the world in its independence of God. But this independence of God, the Giver of life, is only death, and turns to death. The judgment here, as elsewhere, reveals the actual spiritual condition. What is God's creature and His servant is only a means of multiplied blessing. Once it is cut off from Him, it produces only a more settled and complete separation.
The tragedy is that Egypt could not see past the water to its Giver, because the Nile's headwaters lay too far away to be noticed.
It is the river itself that is their all, and they can even claim as their own what is the gift of God: "My river is mine, and I have made it" (Ezekiel 29:3).
Verses 6–10 trace what one dry riverbed does to a whole nation — a chain reaction the prophecy follows all the way to the unemployed labourer.
Their industries will come to a standstill — fishing, farming and textiles, and whatever else depends on them. Foolishness has replaced the wisdom of Egypt. A perverse spirit marks them, sent in God's government, as when Jehovah hardened Pharaoh's heart. Confusion reigns instead of order. There is no work to be had, and fear grips them all because God's hand is against them (vv. 7–16).
Commentators read this prophecy on two levels. One writer sets out the principle:
There is a principle we must keep in mind when reading prophecy. The prophet takes up circumstances near his own eye, in which the faith of God's people was then concerned. He then goes on to later and final events, in which God would display His government and bring it to a close. The move from one to the other is not always noticed at once… In Isaiah 19 it begins with present things. At verse 16 it begins to pass on to the ultimate events, taking present judgments as the image.
And the earlier layer is a matter of record:
History tells us that Egypt did fall from her former high position soon after Isaiah's day. The things recounted in verses 1–10 came upon them. The princes of Zoan did become fools. Yet long before, in the days of Moses, people thought highly of "the wisdom of Egypt."
The same river that was once turned to blood is struck again — but the chapter closes in mercy, not ruin.
God once stepped in for His people to punish Pharaoh and his people for their treatment of them. He did not forget the river, the source of Egypt's prosperity. We learn this from Exodus 7 and 8, for He turned the rivers and waters of Egypt into blood… In a coming day God will step in again to punish the Egyptians, before the day of blessing comes to them. Then "the waters of the sea will be dried up, and the river will be dry and parched" (Isaiah 19:5). In the end, Egypt and Assyria will be blessed with Israel (Isaiah 19:23-25).
How far that mercy goes is striking:
Egypt will be called "His people." When the Lord smites Egypt, that land will return to Him. He will then lift it out of the dust and give it a place of blessing second only to Israel's.
- The boast — Egypt said of the Nile, "My Nile is my own; I made it." It claimed God's gift as its own achievement.
- The river — Egypt drank no rain from heaven, so its river became the symbol of life lived apart from God. That independence is only death.
- The blow — God's hand reaches past the country's defences to its internal supports. It strikes the nation where its glory and confidence lay.
- The collapse — one dry riverbed stops fishing, farming and textiles. Wisdom turns to foolishness, and there is no work to be had.
- The healing — the drying up is not the last word. God smites Egypt, then calls it "His people," lifts it out of the dust and blesses it alongside Israel.
and the rivers shall stink, and the streams of Egypt shall be diminished and drain away the reeds and sedges shall wither.
Isaiah 19 is a prophecy against Egypt, and verse 6 lands on the one thing Egypt could never do without: its water. Why does God aim His judgment at a river? And what happens to a nation when its lifeline dries up?
Older translations turn part of this verse into "the brooks of defence." But the word behind "defence" is a name, not a military term.
The word is in a dual form. This was caused, it has been thought, by the division of that land into Upper and Lower Egypt. The word Matzor, of which Mitzraim is the dual, occurs many times, and the King James Version translates it in various ways. In Isaiah 19:6 it is "defence"; in Jeremiah 10:17, "fortress." But it is a proper name and refers to Egypt. Later translators render it Egypt in all passages.
Egypt's confidence rested on its river. That is exactly where God's hand falls.
But the hand of Jehovah should be not only upon the defences of the country, but upon its internal supports, and this in all that was their glory and their confidence. For is not this Ezekiel's "great dragon that lies in the midst of his streams, which has said, My Nile is my own, and I made it for myself"? (Ezekiel 29:3).
Why would a drying river ruin a whole country? The answer is in Egypt's geography.
It is a little strip of country on each side of the great river that flows through it. It owes its existence to that river alone. The desert on each side hems it in and blows its sands over the land from every direction. Each year the river overflows, lays its load of earth over those sands, and renews the soil. So there goes on, as in the world at large, a constant conflict between life and death. If for one year the river only partly fails, the land is in distress.
Egypt could water its fields without ever looking up at the sky. That habit did not die with Egypt.
They were, in a way, independent of God. They had the river Nile to irrigate the country. They did not depend at all on the dews and rains of heaven… This is like the world. They have no need of God. Their springs are all down here. Christians can say, "All my springs are in You." God is the source of all their joys. They look to heaven for everything. The ungodly are not like that. Their resource is some "river." It is gold and stocks and houses and lands with some. Give others the ballroom, the theatre, the cards and the novels, and they are satisfied. What do they care for Christ? Egypt had its river, and the world, which spiritually is called Egypt, has its river too.
This prophecy has two horizons.
We notice again a feature that is common in these prophecies. The predictions soon pass from the nearer judgments to those that will mature at the end of the age. History tells us that soon after Isaiah's day Egypt did fall from her former high position. The things recounted in verses 1-10 came upon them.
Judgment is not God's last word for Egypt.
Out of all this discipline, which is yet to fall on the land of Egypt, some spiritual good will come. Egypt has been well filled in the past with altars to their false gods and with pillars put up in honour of their tyrant kings. It is going to have an altar to the Lord in its midst and a pillar to the Lord on its border. Not many of either, you notice, but one only, for by then they will acknowledge the one true God. Though He strikes them for their sins, He will heal them and send them a deliverer. In the end Egypt will know Jehovah and bow to Him.
- The word: The "defence" of older translations is not a fortress. Matzor is a name for Egypt itself.
- The target: God's hand reaches past Egypt's defences to its inner supports — its glory and its confidence.
- The reason: Egypt boasted that the Nile was its own, made by itself. God touched the very thing it trusted.
- The mirror: Egypt's springs were all down here, not in heaven. Everyone has some "river." Christians can say, "All my springs are in You."
- The end: The drying is discipline, not destruction. He strikes and He heals, and Egypt will one day have an altar to the Lord in its midst.
The meadows by the Nile, on the banks of the Nile, and everything sown by the Nile, shall be dried up, be driven away, and be no [more].
Isaiah 19:7 sits inside a long prophecy against Egypt. The prophet watches the Nile shrink and the green land along its banks dry out. Why does God aim judgment at a river, and what happens to a nation when the thing it trusted most dries up?
Older translations call the bare places by the river "paper reeds." That plant supported a real Egyptian industry.
The paper reeds, aroth, were the papyrus, much of which grew in the Nile, and of which paper was made. Some of such paper has been found in the tombs of Egypt, but it is very fragile.
Translators have read the Hebrew differently here. One rendering gives open pasture rather than reeds, and reads the "brooks" as the Nile itself and its channels:
The meadows by the Nile, by the banks of the Nile, and everything sown by the Nile, shall be dried up, be driven away, and be no more.
Either way the sense holds: whatever grew by the water goes.
Egypt's border was guarded by water. The verses before this one show that God does not stop at the border.
But the hand of Jehovah would fall not only on the defences of the country. It would fall on its inner supports too, and on all that was their glory and their confidence. For is this not Ezekiel's "great dragon that lies among his rivers, and has said, My river is my own, and I have made it for myself?" (Ezekiel 29:3).
The boast and the judgment match. The river Egypt claimed to own is the river God empties.
Egypt's whole existence hung on the river.
It is a little strip of country on each side of the great river which flows through it, and to which alone it owes its existence... If the river fails even partly for a single year, the land is in distress. The world is just like that. The stream of God's mercies flows without a break, and it keeps alive what could not otherwise exist. Yet for all this dependence, the world does not see what it really depends on, any more than Egypt sees.
The lesson is not locked in the past. Every life has some supply it quietly leans on instead of God.
This is like the world. They have no need of God. Their springs are all down here. Christians can say, "All my springs are in Thee." God is the source of all their joys... Their resource is some "river." It is gold and stocks and houses and lands with some.
Verse 7 names the crops; the verses around it name the trades that lived off them. The failure spreads through the whole economy.
Their industries will come to a standstill: fishing, farming, cloth-making, and whatever else depends on them... Confusion rules instead of order. There is no work to be had, and fear grips them all because God's hand is against them (vv. 7-16).
Prophecy here works on two levels.
Again we notice a feature so common in these prophecies. The predictions soon move from nearer judgments to those that will come to full term at the end of the age. History tells us that soon after Isaiah's day Egypt did fall from her former high standing, and the things listed in verses 1-10 came upon her.
Another writer marks the exact hinge in the chapter.
In Isaiah 19 it begins with the present things: in verse 16 it begins to pass on to the ultimate events, taking present judgments as the image.
The chapter does not end in dry riverbeds. The same hand that withers the fields later heals the land.
Out of all this discipline, which yet is to fall on the land of Egypt, some spiritual good will come... It is going to have an altar to the Lord in its midst and a pillar to the Lord on its border. Not many of either, you notice, but one only, for by then they will acknowledge the one true God. Though He smites them for their sins, He will heal them and send them a deliverer.
- River — Egypt's life came from a river it did not make, yet it could boast, "My river is my own."
- Reach — God's hand passes the country's defences and touches its inner supports: the crops on the riverbank, Egypt's glory and confidence.
- Ruin — When the sown fields go, fishing, farming and cloth-making go with them. The whole working life of the country stops.
- Repetition — Verses 1-10 fell on Egypt soon after Isaiah spoke. From verse 16 the chapter moves on to judgments still ahead, using the earlier ones as the picture.
- Restoration — God smites Egypt for its sins, then heals it and sends a deliverer, leaving one altar to the Lord in the land.
And the fishers shall mourn, and all they that cast fish-hook into the Nile shall lament, and they that spread net upon the waters shall languish.
Isaiah's "burden of Egypt" reaches down to ordinary men at the water's edge with a hook or a net. When the Nile fails, they lose their living. Why does God's judgment reach so far into ordinary working life?
One writer notes that the blow falls on what Egypt trusted most, and ties the Nile to a boast in Ezekiel:
The hand of Jehovah would fall not only on the defences of the country, but on its internal supports. It would touch everything that was their glory and their confidence. For is this not Ezekiel's "great dragon that lies in the midst of his streams, that says, 'My Nile is my own; I made it for myself'" (Ezek. 29:3)?
The fishermen's grief makes sense once you see how narrow Egypt's margin was:
The name for Egypt in Scripture is Mizraim, which means "double straitness," or "double strip," and that describes exactly what Egypt is. It is a little strip of country on each side of the great river which flows through it. Egypt owes its existence to that river alone... If the river only partly fails for a single year, the land is in distress. And such is the world. The stream of God's mercies flows without a break, and it keeps up an existence that would otherwise be impossible. Yet although it is so dependent, the world does not see, any more than Egypt sees, what it really depends on. Canaan drinks water from the rain of heaven. Egypt is different: the sources of its river are too far off for anyone there to acknowledge them. The river itself is their all. They can even credit themselves with what is the gift of God: "My Nile is my own; I made it for myself" (Ezek. 29:3).
The mourning is not limited to the men with nets. One summary of the chapter traces how far the collapse spreads:
Their industries will come to a standstill — fishing, farming and cloth-making, and whatever else depends on them... Confusion reigns instead of order. There is no work to be had, and fear grips them all because God's hand is against them.
Commentators read this chapter on two levels:
Again we notice a feature so common in these prophecies. The predictions soon pass from nearer judgments to those that will mature at the end of the age. History tells us that soon after Isaiah's day Egypt did fall from her former high position. The things recounted in verses 1-10 came upon them.
Another writer marks where the chapter turns:
In Isaiah 19 the prophet begins with present things. At verse 16 he begins to pass on to the final events, using the present judgments as the picture.
One writer sees the same independence from God in the world today:
They were, in a way, independent of God. They had their river Nile to irrigate the country, and did not depend at all on the dews and rains of heaven. This is like the world. They have no need of God. Their springs are all down here. Christians can say, "All my springs are in you." God is the source of all their joys... "The wicked are not so." Their resource is some "river." With some it is gold and stocks and houses and lands. Give others the ballroom, the theatre, the cards and the novels, and they are satisfied. What do they care for Christ? Egypt had its river, and the world, which spiritually is called Egypt, has its river too.
The chapter does not leave Egypt in mourning:
Egypt has passed through many judgments... The final judgment on Egypt comes in that day when the Lord appears in visible glory... But mercy is also in store for Egypt. Egypt will be called "His people." When the Lord smites Egypt that land will return to Him. It will then be lifted out of the dust and receive a place of blessing second only to the one Israel will enjoy.
- The river — Egypt's whole life hung on one stream, and it took the credit for what God gave. One partial failure of the river left the land in distress.
- The hand — God did not stop at Egypt's borders or its gods. He touched the inner supports, the very things Egypt trusted and boasted in.
- The mourning — hook, net and loom fail together. When the river goes, fishing, farming and weaving go with it, and there is no work to be had.
- The horizon — verses 1-10 fell on Egypt soon after Isaiah spoke. From verse 16 the chapter moves on from present judgments to what ripens at the end of the age.
- The lesson — every age has its river. Believers can say their springs are in God; the world keeps its springs down here, and God can dry them up.
And they that work in fine flax, and they that weave white stuffs shall be ashamed.
Isaiah 19 is an oracle against Egypt, a nation whose wealth grew out of the Nile. Verse 9 names two ordinary trades: the flax workers and the weavers. Why does God's judgment on a proud empire land on the workshop floor?
The chapter's earlier verses strike Egypt's defences. From verse 5 the blow moves inward, to what the country lived on.
But the hand of Jehovah would fall not only on the defences of the country. It would fall on its internal supports too, on everything that was their glory and their confidence. Is this not Ezekiel's "great dragon that lies among his rivers, and says, My river is my own, and I made it for myself"? (Ezekiel 29:3). Surely it is the same one about whom Isaiah predicts here… "And those who work in fine flax, and those who weave cotton (or, white stuffs), will be ashamed."
Flax becomes linen only through spinning and weaving. Verse 9 names workers at both ends of that craft.
Egypt practised this art early on, and though the looms were of the simplest kind, some Egyptian work was very fine. The Israelites knew weaving too, and with it they made fine work for the tabernacle and the priests' robes.
The second trade is harder to pin down. Older English versions carried a note about it in the margin.
The margin of Isaiah 19:9 reads "white works." It means any woven work full of holes.
Kelly's own rendering leaves the material open: "cotton (or, white stuffs)."
Flax grew by the water. So did the crops of verse 7, and the fish of verse 8 lived in it.
Their industries will grind to a halt — fishing, farming, cloth-making, and whatever else depends on them… There is no work to be had, and fear grips them all, because God's hand is against them.
The Nile did feed Egypt. The problem was what she made of it.
Egypt worshiped her river. The river came to her so steadily that she seemed independent of heaven; yet heaven was the source of her supply. She did not see the blue hills that poured down the blessing they had received. And they worshiped only the river. This is our own state by nature, away from God. God was far off to us. We did not see the blessed hand that all things came from, and we took the blessings in willing ignorance of the hand on which both they and we really depend.
Trades built on that river were built on something God could withdraw.
Egypt's fall is a matter of record, not only of prediction.
History tells us that soon after Isaiah's day Egypt did fall from her former high position, and the things described in verses 1-10 came upon them. The princes of Zoan did become fools, though long before, in the days of Moses, people thought highly of "the wisdom of Egypt."
But the chapter does not stop there. One principle in reading prophecy explains how a single chapter can look at two horizons.
The prophet takes up the circumstances in front of him, the ones the faith of God's people was then concerned with. He then goes on to later and final events, in which God will display His government and bring it to a close… In Isaiah 19 he begins with present things. At verse 16 he begins to pass on to the final events, taking the present judgments as the picture.
The chapter that shames Egypt's weavers ends by naming Egypt among the blessed. That outcome is not shared by every judged nation in Isaiah.
We should also note that there is a vast difference between the destiny of Egypt and that of Babylon. Isaiah 19 sets before us the blessings that are in store for Egypt. It ends like this: "And the Lord will strike Egypt, striking and healing, and they will return to the Lord… Blessed be Egypt My people, and Assyria the work of My hands, and Israel My inheritance."
- River — Egypt's wealth flowed from one source she treated as her own, and flax was part of that harvest.
- Reach — The hand that touched her borders touched her looms too. God's judgment went after her glory and her confidence, not just her army.
- Ripple — Fishing, farming and cloth-making failed together. All of them hung on the water, and when the source dries, no trade survives.
- Range — Verses 1-10 fell on Egypt soon after Isaiah spoke. The same chapter then moves on to final events, using the present judgments as its picture.
- Result — He strikes and He heals. The nation whose workers despair in verse 9 is the one He calls "My people" at the chapter's close.
And her pillars shall be broken in pieces, and all workers for hire shall be sad of soul.
Isaiah 19:10 closes a run of verses on what happens to Egypt when the Nile fails and every trade with it. What becomes of a nation when the one thing it trusted stops working?
Everything in this verse hangs on two words, and translators have read them in different ways:
The meaning here turns mainly on two words. Henderson gives a better translation: "and her foundations (that is, nobles, pillars of the state) shall be broken, and all workers of hire (that is, labourers) are grieved in mind."
Read that way, the verse names the top and the bottom of society in one breath. The labourers are not just poorer; they are grieved in mind. William Kelly points to where the blow lands. It falls not on Egypt's borders, but on what held her up inside:
But the hand of the LORD would fall not only on the country's defences, but on its internal supports — on everything that was their glory and their confidence.
The verse is the last item in a chain. Fishing goes, farming goes, cloth-making goes, and then the whole economy stalls:
Their industries will be paralyzed — fishing, agriculture and textiles, and whatever else depends on them… Confusion reigns instead of order. There is no work to be had, and fear grips everyone because God's hand is against them.
Egypt lived on one stream. That is why trouble in the river reached right down to a hired man's wages:
It is a little strip of land on each side of the great river that flows through it, and it owes its existence to that river alone… If the river fails even partly for one year, the land is in distress. The same is true of the world. The stream of God's mercies flows without a break and keeps alive what could not otherwise exist. Yet for all this dependence, the world does not see what it really depends on, any more than Egypt does… The river itself is their all, and they can even claim as their own what is God's gift: "My Nile is my own; I made it for myself." (Ezekiel 29:3)
Isaiah's words landed on a real nation in real time:
History tells us that soon after Isaiah's day Egypt did fall from her former high position, and the things recounted in verses 1-10 came upon them. The princes of Zoan did become fools, though long before, in the days of Moses, people thought highly of "the wisdom of Egypt."
J. N. Darby gives the rule for reading prophecy like this, and marks where the chapter turns:
The prophet takes up events near at hand, ones that concerned the faith of God's people at the time. He then goes on to later and final events, in which the government of God will be displayed and brought to a close… In Isaiah 19 it begins with present things. At verse 16 it starts to pass on to the final events, using the present judgments as the picture.
This is not only about an ancient economy. Egypt could water its fields without waiting on the sky, and that independence is the point:
They had their river Nile with which to irrigate the country, and were not at all dependent on the dews and rains of heaven… This is like the world. They have no need of God. Their springs are all down here. Christians can say, "All my springs are in You." … Their resource is some "river." It is gold and stocks and houses and lands with some.
Egypt's ruin is not God's last word about her. The same chapter promises her mercy:
Egypt will come, like other nations, to the front once more at the close of the times of the Gentiles. But mercy is also in store for Egypt. Egypt will be called "His people." When the Lord strikes Egypt, that land will return to Him. It will then be lifted out of the dust and receive a place of blessing only second to that which Israel will enjoy.
- The river — Egypt lived on the Nile alone. One poor year in the water left the land in distress.
- The collapse — when the water went, so did fishing, farming and cloth; there was no work to be had.
- The reach — the verse names both ends of society, the pillars of the state broken and the wage-earners grieved in mind.
- The mirror — every age has its river; the world's springs are all down here, while the believer's springs are all in God.
- The healing — the blow is real, but not final. The Lord who strikes Egypt will call her His people and lift her out of the dust.
They are but fools, the princes of Zoan, the wise counsellors of Pharaoh [their] counsel is become senseless. How say ye unto Pharaoh, I am the son of the wise, the son of ancient kings?
Egypt was as famous for its wise men as for its river. Here the prophet turns on the advisers around Pharaoh's throne, and asks how a nation's best minds could fail just when it needed them most.
Isaiah does not attack Egypt at its weakest point but at its strongest. One commentator notes how famous Egyptian learning was, while Europe still had nothing to match it:
Next (v. 11) the prophet mocks this proud power in the very thing it was proudest of, and best known for among people. For who has not heard of "the wisdom of the Egyptians"? Who does not know of their science and civilisation? At that time the most famous lands of the west, which early on wanted to rule the world, were still wild and untaught.
The counsellors answer Pharaoh with their family tree: sons of wise men, sons of ancient kings. Kelly calls the prophet's reply a "piercing challenge" — let these wise men say what the Lord of hosts has purposed against Egypt. A famous ancestor cannot tell you what God plans to do.
Zoan was no minor town, and it was not a stranger to God's power:
A city in Lower Egypt, built seven years after Hebron. It was the capital of the Hyksos, the shepherd kings of Egypt. It was here that Moses and Aaron met with Pharaoh, and here the plagues took place. It was in the "field of Zoan" that God did marvellous things. God denounced the place, and said its princes had become fools. The site is the ancient city of Tanis, built over the ruins of Zoan.
That history sharpens the insult. God worked His wonders in this very city, and its princes still ended up as fools.
The collapse of Egypt's thinking is not an accident. Isaiah goes on to name its cause — God's own doing, worked out through the men who set policy:
"The princes of Zoan have become foolish, the princes of Noph [Moph, or Memphis] are deceived; and the cornerstones of its tribes have caused Egypt to err. Jehovah has mingled a spirit of perverseness in its midst; and they have caused Egypt to err in all its work, as a drunkard staggers in his vomit." God Himself confuses them in their policy, as an act of judgment.
The damage spreads through the whole country. One writer traces the chain in this chapter: industry stops, confusion replaces order, no work can be found, and fear spreads, "because God's hand is against them" (An Outline of Sound Words).
Commentators read this as a prophecy with both a near and a distant horizon. History supplied the first instalment:
History tells us that soon after Isaiah's day Egypt did fall from her former high position. The things described in verses 1-10 came upon them. The princes of Zoan did become fools. Yet long before, in the days of Moses, people prized "the wisdom of Egypt".
A second writer sets out the rule for reading such passages, and marks where the chapter turns:
The prophet takes up circumstances near at hand, which the faith of God's people was concerned with at the time. He then goes on to later and final events, in which God would display His government and bring it to a close… In Isaiah 19 it begins with present things. At verse 16 it begins to pass on to the ultimate events, taking present judgments as the picture.
The verse is not left in ancient Egypt. Kelly presses it on readers who consider themselves too advanced for prophecy:
How many today are caught in their own craftiness, like the wise counsellors of Egypt! They are too wise to listen to the sure and solemn words of God's prophecy. They are not wise enough to guard themselves from foolish superstition, or from unbelief, which is more foolish still.
Another writer saw the pattern repeat in a nation at war. Its plans began without reason, ran on without care, and ended without settlement. He wrote that "God lets the incapacity of the rulers marry the corruption of society, and man blames his misfortunes on everyone but himself" (William J. Lowe).
- Pride — Isaiah hits Egypt at its strongest point: the wisdom and science it was famous for, while the rest of the world was still wild.
- Pedigree — Pharaoh's advisers point to their ancestors. But no line of wise men or ancient kings can tell them what the Lord of hosts has purposed.
- Perversity — The folly is God's judgment. He mingles a spirit of perverseness among them, and the leaders themselves lead Egypt astray.
- Paralysis — The confusion spreads. Industry, order and work all fail, and fear takes hold, because God's hand is against them.
- Pattern — The chapter starts with things near at hand, then moves at verse 16 to final events. The same folly still catches those too wise to listen to prophecy.
Where are they then, thy wise [men]? Let them now tell thee, and let them make known what Jehovah of hosts hath purposed upon Egypt.
Isaiah's message against Egypt turns from the land to the men who ran it. The prophet does not attack their army or their river. He dares Egypt's famous advisers to do an adviser's one job: tell the king what is coming.
Egypt's standing rested on wisdom. That is where both the judgment and the taunt land:
Egypt's downfall would be completed by foolish counsels, as well as by the wasting away of all national spirit. … The prophet next (v. 11) taunts this proud power in the one thing above all for which it stood high, in its own opinion and in the reputation of men. For who has not heard of "the wisdom of the Egyptians"? Who does not know of their science and civilisation? At that time the most famous lands of the west, which early aimed at ruling the world, were still wild and untaught. … Then comes the prophet's piercing challenge: "Where then are your wise men? Let them tell you that they might know what the LORD of hosts has purposed against Egypt."
Why Egypt, of all nations? The same writer answers:
What going down into Egypt was for Israel, taking counsel from natural wisdom instead of from God is for us. It was this same natural wisdom that Israel sought, and Egypt is the symbol of it in the ancient world. No country in the early history of men was so distinguished for natural wisdom as Egypt. … Egypt relied mainly on good counsel, as if there were no living God. It relied on the counsel of man sharpened by long experience, for it was one of the oldest powers to rise to greatness.
The challenge is not "give good advice" but "tell what is coming." That is a test Scripture reserves for God alone:
Who knows the future but God! With us there is a yesterday, a today, and a tomorrow. But with God the most distant future is as vivid and well known as the present. … Israel had fallen foolishly in love with idols. In His dispute with them about this, the LORD challenges the gods of the nations to declare "things to come." That would prove them to be gods indeed. "I am God, and there is none like me, declaring the end from the beginning and from ancient times things not yet done, saying, My counsel shall stand, and I will accomplish all my purpose" (Isaiah 46:9-10).
The verse points to something God has already purposed. That purpose runs under all of history:
We should always remember that God has His own purpose before Him. Behind everything He does there is that purpose — behind His acts towards His ancient people Israel, His dealings with the nations of the earth, and His discipline of the saints who form the church. Everything bends to it. … "The LORD of hosts has sworn: As I have purposed, so shall it stand. … This is the purpose that is purposed concerning the whole earth, and this is the hand that is stretched out over all the nations. For the LORD of hosts has purposed, and who will annul it?" (Isaiah 14:24-27). This purpose was not formed because events turned out as they did in world history. Instead, the events that have happened serve to bring about God's purpose, and His purpose is an eternal purpose.
Isaiah 19 moves in two stages. Verse 12 belongs to the first:
When reading prophecy we must keep one principle in mind. The prophet takes up circumstances near at hand, which then concerned the faith of God's people. From there he moves on to later and final events, where God displays His government and brings it to a close. … In Isaiah 19 it begins with present things; at verse 16 it begins to pass on to the ultimate events, taking present judgments as the picture.
This failure is not only ancient. The same writer turns the taunt on his own day:
How many now are wrapped up in the same worldly security. How many in our day, like the wise counsellors of Egypt, are caught in their own craftiness! They are too wise to heed the sure and solemn words of divine prophecy. They are not wise enough to guard themselves from foolish superstition, or from still more foolish unbelief. Is it not a rule among the thinkers of Christendom that no one can know a prophecy until the event fulfils it and fixes its meaning? We dare to say that no idea could be less reasonable in itself, or more directly contrary to the word of God.
- Boast — Egypt's glory was its counsel. The prophet aims at that strength, not at any weakness.
- Symbol — Egypt stands for the counsel of man, sharpened by long experience, acting as if there were no living God.
- Test — Real counsel must tell what is coming. Only God declares the end from the beginning.
- Purpose — God's counsel stands. Events do not shape His plan; they serve it, and no one can annul it.
- Application — Anyone too clever to heed prophecy repeats Egypt's failure, caught in his own craftiness.
The princes of Zoan are become foolish, the princes of Noph are deceived; and the corner-stones of its tribes have caused Egypt to err.
Egypt's judgment falls hardest on the men at the top — the officials of Zoan and Memphis, the country's finest advisers. The verse raises a hard question — how does a nation famed for wisdom end up misled by its own wisest men?
Zoan was no minor town. God had already dealt with Egypt there once, in the days of Moses.
A city in Lower Egypt, built seven years after Hebron. It was the capital of the Hyksos, or shepherd kings, of Egypt. It was here that Moses and Aaron met with Pharaoh, and here the plagues fell; for it was in the "field of Zoan" that God did marvellous things. The place was denounced by God, and He said its princes had become fools.
The sting of the verse lies in what Egypt was famous for.
In the early history of mankind, no country was as famous for natural wisdom as Egypt... Egypt's main support was good advice, as if there were no living God. It leaned on the advice of man sharpened by long experience, for it was one of the oldest powers to rise to greatness. They knew the statecraft of the ancient world, so they had a huge reputation for knowing how to handle national troubles, peace, plenty, and so on.
The second city named in the verse is Noph. One writer identifies both cities and says where their confusion came from.
Zoan was the ancient royal city of Egypt, named Tanis by writers outside Scripture. Noph is Moph, or Memphis... God has judged these princes by throwing their own policy into confusion.
The staggering here is not bad luck, and its effects reach the whole country.
Foolishness has replaced the wisdom of Egypt. A perverse spirit marks them, sent in God's government, as when the LORD hardened Pharaoh's heart. Confusion reigns instead of order. There is no work to be had, and fear grips everyone because God's hand is against them.
The verse blames the cornerstones of Egypt's tribes for her staggering. One writer watched a war of his own time run the same course.
From beginning to end of the recent war one finds a series of half-formed plans carried out for no clear reason. It was begun without reason, carried on without prudence, and ended without settlement. The war has proved that man at his best is altogether vanity, and that his heart is set on mischief. God lets the failure of the rulers join hands with the corruption of society, and man blames his misfortunes on everyone but himself.
Did any of this come true? One writer points to what happened soon after Isaiah's day.
History tells us that soon after Isaiah's day Egypt did fall from her former high position. The things described in verses 1-10 came upon them. The princes of Zoan did become fools, though long before, in the days of Moses, people prized "the wisdom of Egypt".
Kelly adds that this was not the end of the matter.
Enough happened then to steady the faithful. But it was no more than a first instalment of the exact and full payment which God will yet make. He will make it in honour of His own words and of the Lord Jesus, when His manifested glory dawns and His world-kingdom comes.
The collapse of Egypt's thinkers has a use beyond ancient history.
The world's wisdom and learning ("the princes of Zoan have become fools," Isa. 19:13) are indeed baffled by the simple faith that takes God at His word, and finds its triumph in the proved helplessness of nature.
- Counsel boasted. Egypt leaned on shrewd advice, acting "as if there were no living God" — and that is what the verse targets.
- Counsel confounded. The princes of Zoan and Memphis did not just make a mistake. God Himself threw their policy into confusion, as judgment.
- Counsel corrupted. God sends the confusion Himself, as when He hardened Pharaoh's heart. The fool here is made, not born.
- Counsel contagious. The nation's cornerstones spread their own delusion. Failed rulers and a corrupt society collapse together, and everyone blames someone else.
- Counsel outlasted. Egypt's fall after Isaiah's day was only a first instalment. A fuller settlement is still to come, and plain faith in God's word outlives all of it.
Jehovah hath mingled a spirit of perverseness in the midst thereof; and they have caused Egypt to err in every work thereof, as a drunkard staggereth in his vomit.
Isaiah 19 announces God's judgment on Egypt, a nation famous for its wisdom. This verse says the collapse of that wisdom was no accident. The confusion came from the Lord.
William Kelly reads verses 13 to 15 together. He names Egypt's leading men by their cities, then says what God had done to their policy.
The princes of Zoan (the ancient royal city of Egypt, called Tanis by non-biblical writers) have become foolish, the princes of Noph — Moph, or Memphis — are deceived; and the cornerstones of its tribes have caused Egypt to go astray. Jehovah has mingled a spirit of perverseness in its midst; and they have caused Egypt to err in all its work, as a drunkard staggers in his vomit... God has confounded them in their policy as an act of judgment.
Note that Kelly is using his own rendering; the ESV reads "a spirit of confusion" where he has "a spirit of perverseness."
Another writer runs through the disasters of this chapter. He links this spirit to what God had already done to Pharaoh.
Their industries will grind to a halt — fishing, farming, textiles, and whatever else depends on them. Foolishness has replaced the wisdom of Egypt. A perverse spirit marks them, sent in God's government, as when Jehovah hardened Pharaoh's heart. Confusion reigns instead of order. There is no work to be had, and fear grips everyone because God's hand is against them.
Does God send such a spirit on anyone at random? One writer answers by pointing to the order of events.
This hardening comes before destruction; but it comes after man has ripened his iniquity. God bears with great patience the vessels of wrath fitted for destruction. Meanwhile, by His Spirit, He shapes His own chosen vessels of mercy before He glorifies them. "He hardens whomever He wills" is surely true; but He wills to show His wrath in this way, by hardening, only in the case of those whom He has endured with much patience.
The same writer describes what this hardening looks like in people. It does not make them stupid.
Under it, men of refinement and intelligence may take up all kinds of religious nonsense; it may blind rulers and statesmen to the plainest rules of government. Did not Pharaoh keep to a course which, from witness after witness, was certain to ruin his kingdom? Did not the nations of Canaan tremble at the report of Israel's conquests, and of what God had done for Israel — and yet, despite all that, resist Israel like madmen?
William Lowe watched a war in his own day and described it like this.
From beginning to end of the recent war one finds a series of half-thought-out plans carried out in a way nobody can explain. It was begun without reason, carried on without prudence, and ended without settlement. The war has proved, if proof were needed, that man at his best is nothing but vanity, and that his heart is set on mischief. God lets the incompetence of the rulers join with the corruption of society, and man blames his misfortunes on everyone but himself.
Kelly says part of this came true in Isaiah's own day, but not all of it.
We should be willing to allow a measure of fulfilment in the prophet's own time. Only do not let that measure shut out the complete fulfilment that still has to come... God did enough then to steady the faithful. But it was no more than a down payment on the exact and full payment He will yet make.
But staggering is not where the chapter leaves Egypt. F. B. Hole traces where this discipline ends.
Out of all this discipline, which is still to fall on the land of Egypt, some spiritual good will come. In the past Egypt has been full of altars to false gods and pillars raised in honour of its despotic kings. It is going to have an altar to the Lord in its midst and a pillar to the Lord on its border. Not many of either, notice — only one, because by then they will acknowledge the one true God. Though He strikes them for their sins, He will heal them and send them a deliverer.
- Source. Egypt's confusion was not bad luck or bad advisers alone. The Lord mingled it there, and He confounded its leaders in their own policy as a judgment.
- Precedent. This spirit belongs to God's government, working as it did when Jehovah hardened Pharaoh's heart.
- Limit. God never sends such hardening until a man or a nation has ripened its own evil. He bears with them a long time first.
- Symptom. The mark is not ignorance but staggering judgment. Cultured people take up nonsense, and rulers miss the plainest rules of government.
- End. Egypt's staggering is not final: God strikes, then heals, and the land of idols will hold one altar to the one true God.
Neither shall there be any work for Egypt, which the head or tail, palm-branch or rush, may do.
Isaiah 19 is a message of judgment on Egypt. Egypt was the great power of the ancient world, and Israel kept running to it for help. Verse 15 ends the picture with total paralysis: no one in Egypt, high or low, has any work left to do. Why? And is that the end of the story?
The same four words appear earlier in Isaiah, where the prophet defines them. Commenting on that passage, one writer takes the pairs as a way of naming every layer of a society at once:
"And the Lord will cut off from Israel head and tail, palm-branch and rush, in one day. The elder and honoured man is the head, and the prophet who teaches lies is the tail." The ruin is universal in one day on all classes in Israel, from the highest to the lowest, "palm-branch and rush": all plunged into common destruction, leaders and led.
Egypt's collapse is the same: it reaches every layer at once, from ruler to subject.
Egypt's pride was not its army but its learning. That is where the taunt of verses 11–12 lands:
The prophet then mocks this proud power at the very point where it stood highest — in its own opinion of itself, and in what people thought of it. For who has not heard of "the wisdom of the Egyptians"? And who does not know of their science and civilisation? The most famous lands of the west, which early set their sights on ruling the world, were still wild and untaught. "Where then are your wise men?" is the prophet's piercing challenge; "let them tell you now, and let them make known what the LORD of hosts has purposed against Egypt."
after_note: none
The paralysis of verse 15 is not bad luck or bad management. Verse 14 names its source, and the comment on the passage is blunt about what that means:
"The LORD has mingled a perverse spirit in the middle of it, and they have made Egypt go wrong in everything it does, as a drunk man staggers in his vomit. And there will be nothing for Egypt that head or tail, palm branch or reed, may do." God Himself has confused their policy; it is His judgment on them.
Another writer lists what the chapter takes away from Egypt:
Their industries will be paralysed — fishing, farming, textiles, and whatever else depends on them. Foolishness has replaced the wisdom of Egypt. A perverse spirit marks them, sent in God's government, as when the Lord hardened Pharaoh's heart. Confusion reigns instead of order. There is no work to be had, and fear has hold of them all because God's hand is against them.
Verse 15 stands at a hinge in the chapter:
In Isaiah 19 it begins with the present things: in verse 16 it begins to pass on to the ultimate events, taking present judgments as the image. Nebuchadnezzar's invasions foreshadow the final judgments, and are in part their beginning. All of it belongs to the government of God.
Still, that early fulfilment is not the whole of it:
We should be willing to allow some fulfilment in the prophet's own day. Only do not let that shut out the complete fulfilment still to come… Enough happened then to steady the faithful. But it was no more than a down payment on the exact and full settlement God will yet make.
If Egypt itself can do nothing, then anyone depending on Egypt has nothing. That was Israel's repeated mistake:
Egypt gave no help to Israel and only wounded them grievously, like a staff which breaks under the weight of the one leaning on it and pierces his hand. Whenever God's people turn to Egypt (the picture of the world) for help, and form ungodly alliances, they do so to their own hurt and shame.
The chapter does not stop at emptiness. Egypt loses its wisdom and its work, but God gives it something better:
Out of all this discipline, which is still to fall on the land of Egypt, some spiritual good will come… Egypt is going to have an altar to the Lord in its middle and a pillar to the Lord on its border. Not many of either, you notice, but one only, for by then they will acknowledge the one true God. Though He smites them for their sins, He will heal them and send them a deliverer.
- Reach. Head or tail, palm branch or reed: the paralysis covers every class at once, honoured elder and lying prophet alike.
- Cause. The failure is a judgment, not bad management: God mingled a perverse spirit in Egypt and confused its policy.
- Target. The blow lands on Egypt's proudest asset: its famous wisdom. Its counsellors cannot say what the Lord has purposed.
- Timing. Verse 15 closes the near judgment. From verse 16 the prophecy moves to the end of the age, and the early fulfilment is only a down payment on the full one.
- Result. A nation with no work left is a nation no one should lean on. Yet the God who strikes Egypt also heals it and sends it a deliverer.