Hebrews 11:35–38

Hebrews 11:35

Women received their dead again by resurrection; and others were tortured, not having accepted deliverance, that they might get a better resurrection;

The same faith leads to two opposite outcomes here: some women get their children back alive, while others suffer torture and refuse release. Why does God record both, and what is the "better life" that made refusing rescue worth it?

Faith that acts and faith that endures

The chapter has just listed faith's victories. At this verse the tone changes. One writer puts the two kinds of faith on the same level, and finds an honour in the suffering one.

Faith wins triumphs when it attacks sin and death with active energy. God marks with equal pleasure its gentle, steady endurance of undeserved sorrow and suffering... God has not always hidden His prophets. Sometimes He has honoured them by putting to their lips the cup that Jesus would later taste.

A. Pridham

Another writer explains why rescue so often does not come.

Usually, though, God does not step in at once, and suffering follows... They endured. They did not accept the rescue that could have reached them if they had taken back their words or compromised. Faith suffered, but it carried them through.

F. B. Hole

The women who received their dead

Two mothers stand behind the first half of the verse. In one of them a writer sees a much older story repeated.

The Shunammite woman repeats, on a smaller scale, the story of Abraham and Sarah. The promised child was given to a woman with no natural hope of one, then taken away in death, and then raised again. We see something similar in the story of Elijah.

Samuel Ridout

Should we expect such raisings today? One writer answers no, and points forward instead.

In these cases, to live was better than to die, because God was dealing with an earthly people. Faith has since learned that to depart and be with Christ is now far better than to stay on earth. So such displays of its power are no longer likely to be seen. Those who mourn will receive their dead back to life when God soon brings with Jesus those who have fallen asleep in Him (1 Thess. 4:14).

A. Pridham

The deliverance they turned down

The release on offer was real, and so was the price of taking it.

These were not saved out of death. Their faith counted on the better resurrection. Not every martyr was rescued from the death that faced them... But they would not accept release at the price of loyalty to Him. He had called them to that better resurrection, and the eyes of their faith were fixed on it.

Samuel Ridout

Believers long after the Old Testament faced the same terms.

They did not accept release, though it was offered to them if they would renounce Christ. Their faith triumphed in death, and they wait for the full victory in resurrection. "Of whom the world was not worthy" (Heb. 11:38) — that is God's estimate of every such faithful martyr.

Raymond K. Campbell

Why the resurrection is "better"

Older translations, which these writers use, read "a better resurrection" where the ESV has "rise again to a better life". The word "better" points back to the first half of the verse: those sons came back to a life they would lose again.

A better resurrection means resurrection to life, not a return to this world. The Shunammite's son and the son of the widow of Zarephath only came back to this world.

C. E. Stuart

Read the two halves together, and you see what these sufferers expected for their own bodies.

Compare and contrast the two statements, and it is hard to doubt the meaning. Some received their dead back from the grave, the well-known and much-loved body alive again. Others looked for their own bodies to be raised too, but in a different way and for a different end: never to die again, but to live for ever beyond death. A better resurrection indeed!

The Bible Treasury

Unnamed here, known above

The verse names none of these sufferers. But heaven keeps their record.

The others who were tortured refused the release that men offered. They wait for a better resurrection still to come, and they are better known in heaven than on earth.

William Kelly

Summary

- Received. Faith once took children back out of death — a real gift, but a temporary one, since those raised would die again.

- Refused. Faith also turned down a genuine offer of release, because the price was loyalty to the One who had called them.

- Better. The better resurrection means life, not a return to this world. These bodies rise never to die again.

- Equal. God takes the same pleasure in quiet endurance as He does in faith's loudest victories.

- Remembered. Their names are missing from the page, but heaven knows them better than earth ever did.

Hebrews 11:36

and others underwent trial of mockings and scourgings, yea, and of bonds and imprisonment.

Hebrews 11 has just listed the victories of faith. Then the chapter turns: from verse 35 the same faith wins no rescue, and verse 36 names what "others" got instead — ridicule, the whip, chains, a prison cell.

Two Faces of One Faith

One writer sets the two halves of the list side by side:

(Verses 33, 34). First, he points to incidents that show the power of faith. It subdues kingdoms and overcomes armies. It is strong in weakness and brave in fight. It triumphs over the power of nature, as represented by the lion, and quenches the violence of the elements such as fire. It even wins victory over death.

(Verses 35, 36). Second, the Apostle sets before us the endurance of faith. Under torture it refused to accept deliverance. In trial it endured mockings and scourgings, bonds and imprisonments.

Hamilton Smith

Mockery Before the Whip

The verse names mocking before flogging. Samuel Ridout weighs the two:

They had trial of something that may be harder to bear than physical suffering — the scorn of those who do not know our Lord. How keenly sensitive natures feel the slights put upon them! The neglect, the coldness, the sarcastic and condescending smile of pity — these are scourgings that bite deeper than the lash laid across the shoulders. But faith endures, and triumphs over it all.

Samuel Ridout

The Tongue Is a Weapon

If mocking is listed alongside flogging, then words are counted as violence — which turns the verse into a warning for anyone tempted to hand out that treatment:

Let us take care that we do not become persecutors. Some think there is no persecution except fire and sword; but there is persecution of the tongue. Reviling is called persecution: "men shall revile you and persecute you"; this is tongue persecution. "His words were softer than oil, yet were they drawn swords" (Ps. 55:21). You may kill a man in his name as well as in his person; a good name is as precious ointment... So the earliest saints endured the persecution of the tongue. They "suffered mocking" (Heb. 11:36).

Hamilton Smith

Names Withheld, Not Lost

Every earlier hero in the chapter has a name. From verse 35 the names stop. One writer says where they are kept:

This leads on to the last condition we are to look at — faith in times of persecution... Now names are unrecorded, but the acts of faith were never to be forgotten. So, though we cannot identify all those referred to, we are well assured that their names are remembered in heaven.

C E Stuart

Another writer points to where the rest of that history is found:

The Old Testament does not give us the details of such history, at least in many of these cases. Yet no doubt such cases were not few. The records of later church history tell of many godly people who suffered these very things, and tortures even more cruel, for Christ's sake.

Leslie M. Grant

God Does Not Step In

The hardest feature of the verse is not the suffering but the silence of heaven while it happens. One writer refuses to soften it:

In every age and in every country it has been so. We find the people of faith the objects of the hatred of man. But God owns this people... Here God gives His history of them. He does not interfere. He leaves them "destitute, afflicted, tormented." He does not meddle with the world, and the world goes on. It will not always be so, but that is the present fact... The world has departed from Him, and He will not own it.

J. N. Darby

Rescued or Not, the Same Faith

The chapter puts rescue and chains side by side without explaining the difference. One writer traces the same pattern in two men and in two churches:

As we read in Hebrews 11:33-38, some are delivered and escape the edge of the sword; others are tortured, undergo trials, are slaughtered, or wander about. The mystery of God allows John the Baptist to perish in prison while Peter is rescued. The word to Smyrna is: "Be faithful unto death, and I will give you the crown of life." The word to Philadelphia is: "I will keep you from the hour of trial that is coming" (Rev. 2:10; 3:10).

Georges André

Summary

- Same faith. The chapter does not switch topics at verse 35. Power that subdues kingdoms and endurance that absorbs chains are one faith with two faces.

- Scorn first. Mocking heads the list because it can cut deeper than the lash. Neglect, coldness and the pitying smile wound where the whip cannot reach.

- Tongues persecute. Reviling counts as persecution. So the verse warns the mocker as much as it honours the sufferer.

- Names kept. From here the names stop, but the acts are never forgotten. Earth did not record them; heaven does.

- No rescue promised. God does not always step in; one man dies in prison while another walks free. Faith shows itself in endurance, not in escape.

Hebrews 11:37

They were stoned, were sawn asunder, were tempted, died by the death of the sword; they went about in sheepskins, in goatskins, destitute, afflicted, evil treated,

The roll of faith in Hebrews 11 ends without names. Three deaths and one long homelessness fill their place. The verse forces a hard question: why did God let faith end this way?

The unnamed sufferers

Every earlier hero in the chapter is named. Here the record gives no names. Yet several of these deaths match people we can still identify.

Their names are not given, but God knows them all. He also knows the countless thousands of martyrs constantly added to this list… Some were stoned, as Zechariah (2 Chron. 24), and Jeremiah, according to tradition. Some were sawn in two, as Isaiah was under Manasseh. Some were killed with the sword, as Urijah was (Jer. 26:23), and James the brother of John (Acts 12). They could have worn silks and velvets. They could have lived in the palaces of princes — if they had denied God and believed the world's lie.

Arno Clemens Gaebelein

Stoned by the guardians of the law

Stoning was not street violence. Israel's own law commanded it as a penalty. That is what makes its use against faithful people worse, not better.

The law required stoning for Jews guilty of idolatry, blasphemy, or other open rebellion against the LORD. That is what made the deaths of Naboth and of Zechariah so terrible. The wickedness lay wholly with those in high authority, who twisted the law to hurt saints. We can hardly imagine a worse or bolder wrong. Godly people died the death of the ungodly at the hands of ungodly rulers. It was done by clever lies or in uncontrolled rage.

William Kelly

Tempted

Older translations add a fourth item here, between the sawing and the sword: "were tempted." The ESV does not carry it. What the temptation was is not spelled out, but the pattern is familiar from later persecutions.

"Were tempted." The kind of temptation is not stated. No doubt it was some offer of escape from suffering, if only they would give up Christ. This was tried again and again with martyrs for the name of Jesus during the pagan persecutions of the early Christians. It was tried too in the equally pagan public burnings in Spain. There, release was offered even after the victim stood in the flames, if only he would deny the truth that had set his soul free. We can well imagine how sharp such temptations were. Loved ones — wives, little children — all begged the father to stay with them, instead of sealing with his blood the faith he had confessed.

Samuel Ridout

The ones who were not killed

The verse turns from those who died to those left alive in animal skins.

Next comes the more drawn-out suffering in life of those who, for one reason or another, were not killed. "They went about in skins of sheep and goats, destitute, afflicted, mistreated." For some this was an even harder test of faith than a sudden death, whether by law or by violence.

William Kelly

Why the world hated them

There was a reason the world turned on them.

Whether before Christ or after Him, the solid fact remains: God has always had a line of sufferers who believed. It was their faith that made them objects of dislike and persecution. It was not so much that they condemned the world, its pursuits, pleasures, sins, or godlessness. It was the quietest and most telling witness of all — separation from the world to God and His word.

William Kelly

No rescue

No rescue comes in this verse. Where was God while this happened?

In every age and in every country it has been so. We find the people of faith to be the objects of man's hatred. But God owns this people… Here God gives His own account of them. He does not step in. He leaves them "destitute, afflicted, mistreated." He does not interfere with the world. The world carries on. It will not always be so, but that is the present fact.

J. N. Darby

Your place in this army

Ridout turns the list into a question for the reader.

What an army! No gold braid or uniform on them, no great glory and honour. There you see them in the caves and holes of the earth, dressed in sheepskins and goatskins. Is your place with them? Is that reproach worth more in your eyes than "the treasures of Egypt"? Faith will always link us with that company "of whom the world was not worthy." They are the ones Christ is not ashamed to call brothers.

Samuel Ridout

Summary

- Unnamed, not unknown. Their names drop out of the record, but not out of God's memory. He knows every one, and the list is still growing.

- Killed by law. Stoning was Israel's legal penalty for blasphemy. The horror is that rulers used God's own law to kill God's own people.

- Tempted, not just tortured. Deny Christ, and you could live and go home to your children. That offer ran right through the suffering, and it cut deep.

- Living on is harder. Those left wandering in animal skins faced a longer test. For some, that slow suffering was harder than a quick death.

- God waits. He did not step in then, and He does not interfere with the world now. That is the present fact, and it will not always be so.

Hebrews 11:38

(of whom the world was not worthy,) wandering in deserts and mountains, and [in] dens and caverns of the earth.

This verse ends a long list of people whose faith cost them everything the world can offer — home, safety, even a name in the records. Then comes one short line of God's own verdict, which raises a question: why did the world treat faith like this?

Driven out and unbroken

The wandering here is not travel but expulsion. Nothing the world offered or threatened could move these people:

So they were often outcasts, roaming in deserts and mountains, and in dens and the caves or crevices of the earth. The same scenes repeated in pagan and papal persecutions after this letter was written. That needs no proof here. In the world's eyes they were unyielding and impossible to work with. Nothing won them: not wealth, ease, or honour. Nothing broke them: not slander, hatred, prison, or death. They refuse present glory. They remember who was crucified and by whom; they await His day and see it approaching.

William Kelly

The caves were real places. Palestine had many of them. Some were large enough to hide a man and his followers while their hunter walked in (Morrish Bible Dictionary).

What provoked the hatred

The offence was rarely a loud attack on the world's morals. It was something quieter and harder to answer.

Still, one solid fact remains, before Christ or after: God has always had a line of sufferers who believed. And it was their faith which made them objects of dislike and persecution. It was not so much their attack on the world — on its pursuits, pleasures, wrongs, or godlessness. It was the quietest and most telling of all testimonies: separation from the world to God and His word... "Of whom the world was not worthy," though they were counted unworthy of a place in it, or even of life. But, as has been said, in condemning them it condemned itself; and God forgets neither.

William Kelly

The same pattern returns wherever people confess Christ. The world did not think Christians fit to live. It judged their Lord the same way when it crucified Him. The Holy Spirit answers by putting the true value on them, as He did on these earlier sufferers (A J Pollock).

The verdict written last

The world speaks first, and the world speaks by driving people into holes in the ground. God speaks afterwards.

God came out and wrote their epitaph, and it reads: "Of whom the world was not worthy."

James Boyd

The sentence cuts two ways at once, and both edges matter:

One little parenthesis in the long chapter which records their testimony places at once a glorious tribute upon them and a fearful condemnation on those of the other side; it says, "Of whom the world was not worthy."

J Wilson Smith

People the record does not name

We cannot match much of what this verse describes to any story in the earlier Scriptures. Commentators differ on who is meant. Some point to believers who suffered after the last Old Testament prophet, in a time when pagan worship was forced on the Jews (F. B. Hole). Others widen the frame further:

The Old Testament does not give us the details of such history, at least in many of these cases. Yet such cases were doubtless not few. And the records of later Church history hold a multitude of godly people who suffered these very things, and tortures even more cruel, for Christ's sake. How full and how precious that word, "of whom the world was not worthy."

Leslie M. Grant

The question left with the reader

The chapter piles these details up on purpose. It speaks to people who were already suffering and tempted to quit.

How the apostle lets it all accumulate before the eyes of those he was addressing! It is as though he were saying: is your affliction worse than that of those who have gone before you? They were heirs of the same precious faith as yourselves... You see what the portion of faith is — nothing here, everything in the living God, everything in the future. You cannot get your portion here; you must wait for it too.

Samuel Ridout

That waiting has a settlement day. They suffered at the world's hands, yet the world was not worthy of them. They were far above it, and this line hints at the reward waiting for them (F. B. Hole).

Summary

- Unworthy how — The world judged them unworthy of a home, a place, even of life. God turns the verdict around and calls the world unworthy of them.

- Cause — Their quiet separation to God and His word drew the hatred, not their protests. In condemning them, the world condemned itself.

- Verdict — The world spoke first and buried them in caves; God spoke last and wrote their epitaph.

- Reach — Most of these names are missing from the earlier record. But the pattern repeats in later history wherever the godly suffer for Christ.

- Result — Faith's portion is nothing here and everything in the living God. Those the world drove out turn out to be far above it.