And Israel beheld Joseph's sons, and said, Who are these?
Jacob is near death in Egypt when Joseph brings him two sons born there to an Egyptian mother. The old man's eyes are too dim to make the boys out, so he asks who they are — and the answer will decide whether two children of Egypt can belong to Abraham's family.
The question is not a test. Jacob cannot make the boys out. One writer sets that failing eyesight beside the way Jacob had lived his earlier years.
F. B. HoleWhen Rachel died, Jacob was still at full strength. Now his natural strength was gone and his eyes were dim, so that he could not even make out the sons of Joseph. In his strong days he had too often walked by the sight of his own eyes. Now at the end he begins to walk and act by faith, not by sight. At the same time he sees how very kind God has been to him.
The text changes the old man's name at this point. Up to here he has been looking back over his own history. From the question on, he becomes God's spokesman.
Hamilton SmithJacob has spoken up to now, but from this point in the story he speaks as Israel. Jacob, the man of nature, has looked back over the past and seen all his hopes end in death. Now, as Israel (the prince with God), he will declare the mind of God. As Jacob he has seen death ending the plans of man. As Israel he looks beyond death and unfolds the purpose of God (verses 8-11)... If heavenly things are opening to him, earthly things are fading from him.
By birth these boys had no place in Abraham's family line. One commentator explains why Jacob had to act before he could bless.
J. G. BellettHe then adopts the sons of Joseph. This was needed to give them the rights of children, because, in strict legal terms, they were strangers to Abraham. Their mother was an Egyptian. So they were the kind of children the law of that day would have sent away. But Jacob adopts them. He takes them into the family.
Jacob had already settled what he would do with these boys before he ever set eyes on them. The same writer draws out why that order matters.
J. G. BellettHe adopted them before he saw them. He gave them the place of the firstborn in the family while he had still not looked on them, for his eyes were dim with age. All the desire of his heart had gone out to them while they had never yet stood before him. So when the blessing does come, it comes with all its value. The warmth of Jacob's heart and tongue came with it. It is sealed, and sealed again, before Ephraim and Manasseh enjoy it. They are to know that their adoption had been their father's delightful plan and promise — the subject of his thoughts and love — before it was ever made known to them.
Jacob himself had received a blessing that was not his by natural right. Now, with failing eyes, he sees the same free favour reaching his grandsons.
The Christian's FriendAs Jacob received the blessing, so now he gives it to both the sons of Joseph. Jacob had no claim on God for a blessing. He was a fugitive from his elder brother Esau, to whom by natural right the blessing belonged. But God allows no rights. He acts according to the counsels of His own will... He could look at his grandchildren, and see the blessing of God coming on them from the grace of God, as freely as it had come on him.
Joseph does not leave his sons at a distance. He brings them to his father to be blessed. One writer sees a larger picture in that.
Truth & TestimonyJoseph is a wonderful picture of Christ, who brings His children into the Father's presence. It is the Father's delight to bless us.
- Dim. Jacob's eyes fail him. He cannot make out his own grandsons. Writers mark this as the moment he stops walking by sight and starts walking by faith.
- Israel. The name changes with the question. From here on, the man of nature gives way to the prince with God, who looks past death and speaks God's purpose.
- Strangers. Born in Egypt to an Egyptian mother, the two boys had no legal standing in Abraham's family. That is why adoption, not birth, had to come first.
- Chosen. Jacob adopted the boys before he ever saw them. Their place in the family was settled in his heart while they were still out of his sight.
- Passed on. The fugitive who had no claim of his own now hands the same free blessing to a second generation. Joseph brings the children near to receive it.
And Joseph said to his father, They are my sons, whom God has given me here. And he said, Bring them, I pray thee, to me, that I may bless them.
Jacob is old, sick and nearly blind, and when he sees two young men standing beside Joseph he has to ask who they are. Joseph answers, and Jacob asks for the boys. What follows is the act Scripture later marks as Jacob's great act of faith.
Joseph does not say that these are the sons he fathered in Egypt. He traces them back to God, and the names he had given them say the same thing.
G C WillisPharaoh gave Joseph a wife, and God gave Joseph two sons. The oldest was named "Manasseh" ("Forgetting"), because God made Joseph forget his work and sorrow. The younger was named "Ephraim" ("Fruitful"), because God caused him to be fruitful in the land of his trouble.
The word "here" matters. God gave these sons in the land of Joseph's trouble, not after the trouble was over.
By birth the boys belonged to Egypt, not to Abraham. Jacob does not argue the difficulty away. He acts.
J. G. BellettHe then adopts the sons of Joseph. This was needed to give them the rights of children. In a real legal sense they were strangers to Abraham. Their mother was an Egyptian. They were a seed, therefore, whom the law would in its day have put away. But Jacob adopts them. He takes them into the family.
Where does a dying man find anything to give? Not from himself.
Hamilton SmithBut if blessing rests on the promise made sure to Jacob's descendants, then Jacob can claim a blessing for Joseph's sons. Jacob can say, "they shall be mine." He claims them as his descendants and therefore as the heirs to the inheritance.
Jacob's eyes are failing. Yet the record now calls him Israel, and the change of name marks a change in what he sees.
Hamilton SmithAs Jacob he has seen death ending the plans of man. As Israel he looks beyond death and unfolds the purpose of God. But the eyes of Israel were dim with age, so that he could not see. If heavenly things are opening to him, earthly things are fading from him. And so he no longer thinks of the sorrows along the way, but of the goodness of God that had never forsaken him. He acknowledges that God had been better to him than all his natural thoughts.
Read the whole chapter and one pattern runs through it. Jacob's own part is only to agree.
J. G. BellettIn Genesis 48, which follows, we get the one act in his life that the Spirit marks out as the act of faith. See Hebrews 11:21. But the whole chapter is beautiful. All is grace on God's part, and all is faith in the heart of Jacob. It is the proper business and duty of faith to accept the decisions of grace, and that is just what grace is doing here. Grace adopts the sons of Joseph, who had no claim by birth, and takes them into the family of Abraham. Grace gives them the place and portion of the firstborn, the double portion, as though they were Reuben and Simeon. Grace sets the younger of them above the elder.
Joseph's part is only to bring the boys. Parents can bring their children to God the same way, and one writer separates two reasons for doing it.
F. B. HoleSuppose we bring them with a desire for their prominence and glory. Suppose we want them distinguished either in this world or the world to come, so that our natural pride and pleasure in them grows. Then we have no ground for expecting the Lord to act. If we bring them so that their desperate need may be met and their blessing accomplished, He will hear us. The varying circumstances on our side will be no hindrance.
- Given. Joseph calls his sons a gift from God. Their names record what God did in the land of his trouble: He made Joseph forget, and made him fruitful.
- Brought. Jacob asks for the boys to come close before he blesses them. Blessing does not reach them at a distance.
- Adopted. The boys had no legal standing in Abraham's family. Jacob adopts them and gives them the place of the firstborn.
- Blessed. Jacob has nothing of his own to hand over. He can bless because God's promise runs to his descendants, and the boys now count among them.
- Accepted. All is grace on God's side and faith on Jacob's. Faith's one job is to accept what grace has decided.
But the eyes of Israel were heavy from age he could not see. And he brought them nearer to him; and he kissed them, and embraced them.
I have strong material. Here is the commentary:
An old man sits on his bed, too blind to make out the faces of the two boys in front of him. Scripture treats this as the high point of Jacob's faith: his eyes fail, yet the blessing he gives is exactly right.
The dimness is not only physical. The world Jacob had clung to is slipping out of his hands, and the loss turns out to be a gain.
Hamilton SmithJacob — the man of nature — is weakened by age and sickness. The world he had clung to so tightly is fast fading from his view. His eyes are dim with age (verse 10). But his natural strength weakens and his natural sight grows dim. Everything on earth is fast slipping from his grasp. So he rises above the loss of all earthly joys and finds in God his only trust and unfailing resource.
What goes out at one window comes in at another. Writers note the exchange directly: as one kind of sight closes, another opens.
Hamilton SmithIf heavenly things are opening to him, earthly things are fading from him. And so it is he no longer thinks of the sorrows by the way, but of the goodness of God that had never forsaken him.
Jacob had spent most of his life relying on his own cleverness. The failure of his eyes marks the end of that method — and the start of a better one.
F. B. HoleWhen Rachel died Jacob was still in full strength; now his natural strength was gone, his eyes were dim, so that he could not even recognise the sons of Joseph. In his days of vigour he had too often walked by the sight of his own eyes; now at the close he begins to walk and act by faith and not by sight, and at the same time he realises the exceeding kindness of God toward him.
The same point is put as a reversal: the shrewdness that once served him has drained away, and what replaces it is sharper.
The Christian's FriendDim as to his natural eye, but clear-sighted by faith, he guided his hands knowingly. Jacob had used his own natural shrewdness in many ways in his past life. But now, as his natural powers fade, faith is very keen in discerning the ways of God.
Here the gifted son is the one who cannot see.
William KellyJoseph does not know God's purpose for his sons. He lets his natural desires govern him. He places the elder son in front of his dying father's right hand, and the younger in front of his left. So Joseph would have had it; but not so Jacob. His eyes were dim with age, but in this he was clearer-sighted than Joseph after all. No one ever saw more clearly than Joseph. Yet Jacob, dying, sees the future with a steadier and fuller gaze.
Gift alone does not produce such insight.
The Christian's FriendIt needs an exercised soul, as well as a spiritual gift, to see clearly the way of grace. Joseph stands far above his father Jacob in both gift and moral worth. But Jacob had been well sifted, and had learned by experience his need of grace.
Jacob is now in his father's position: old, blind, and blessing sons. But the two bedsides end differently.
C. H. MackintoshIsaac's eyes were dim, so he could be deceived, and they set about doing so, instead of looking to God, who would have completely frustrated Isaac's purpose to bless the one whom God would not bless — a purpose rooted in nature, and in very unlovely nature, for "Isaac loved Esau," not because he was the firstborn, but "because he ate of his game."
Jacob had once used his father's blindness against him. Now he is the blind one.
William KellyJacob clear, where Isaac had been dim; Jacob clearer than Joseph, who until now had seen into divine things more deeply than any other man of God. What deep self-judgment must have passed through Israel's spirit as he reviewed the blessing he had once stolen by his own trickery!
The kiss and the embrace in this verse go to boys Jacob has never seen.
J. G. BellettHe adopted them before he saw them. He gave them the place of the firstborn in the family while he had not yet looked on them, for his eyes were dim with age. All the desire of his heart had been toward them while they were still unknown to him. So when the blessing does come, it comes with all its value. They may know that their adoption had been the delightful theme of the father's counsel and promise, the subject of his thoughts and affections before he made it known to them.
- Fading. Jacob's dim eyes mark the world slipping out of his grip. At that very moment he finds in God his only resource.
- Faith. The shrewdness Jacob once relied on has faded. In its place, faith reads God's ways with a keen eye.
- Clearer. Blind Jacob reads God's purpose better than his gifted son Joseph. Gift is not enough on its own; Jacob had also learned by experience his need of grace.
- Reversed. Isaac's dim eyes made him easy to trick, and the son he meant to bless was the one God would not bless. Jacob's dim eyes do not stop him blessing the right one.
- Loved first. Jacob adopted these boys and gave them the firstborn's place before he ever saw them. The embrace only showed what his heart had already settled.
And Israel said to Joseph, I had not thought to see thy face; and behold, God has let me see also thy seed.
For years Jacob believed his favourite son was dead. Now, at the end of his life, he holds that son's children. His words admit that his fears about God had been wrong. They also raise the question every grieving person asks: what is God doing when life runs against me?
Jacob had read his own life wrongly for years. One writer traces the low point:
A. J. PollockWhen at last he had to part with Benjamin, he poured out his grief: "All this has come against me." Were they against him? He could not see far enough. Little did he think that the shadow of dreaded loss resting on his spirit was in reality the clouds breaking. Instead of losing Benjamin he was about to regain Joseph. In regaining Joseph, every pinch of want would be a thing of the past. He would live in the land where Joseph supplied the food, and receive from his plenty, even though all the rest of the earth was suffering famine. Ask Jacob, "Does God care?" Hear him say to Joseph for answer, "I never expected to see your face; and behold, God has let me see your offspring also."
The losses themselves were the road to the blessing:
An Outline of Sound WordsThe very things that he thought were against him were working for richest blessing, both for him and for his children. Not only was Joseph alive, but very soon he would see Joseph, and also his sons. God used the loss of Joseph to preserve Jacob and his house, and also to preserve the lives of many more.
What nature could see and what God knew were two different things:
C. H. MackintoshIn Genesis 48:11 we have a very beautiful example of the way our God always rises above all our thoughts, and proves Himself better than all our fears… To nature's view Joseph was dead; whereas in God's view he was alive, and seated in the highest place of authority, next to the throne.
Jacob does not just get back what he mourned. He also gets a generation he never counted on:
F. B. HoleIn his days of vigour he had too often walked by the sight of his own eyes. Now at the close he begins to walk and act by faith and not by sight. At the same time he realizes the exceeding kindness of God toward him. He had spent weary years thinking he would never see the face of his beloved son again. Now he has seen not only him but his offspring as well.
The chapter changes the old man's name at this exact point:
Hamilton SmithJacob has spoken up to now, but from this point in the story he speaks as Israel, the prince with God… As Jacob he has seen death ending the plans of man. As Israel he looks beyond death and unfolds the purpose of God. But the eyes of Israel were dim with age, so that he could not see. If heavenly things are opening to him, earthly things are fading from him. And so he no longer thinks of the sorrows along the way, but of the goodness of God that had never forsaken him. He owns that God had been better to him than all his natural thoughts.
The two boys were half Egyptian. Jacob brings them inside the family line:
J. G. BellettHe then adopts the sons of Joseph. This was needed to give them the rights of children, because in a great legal sense they were strangers to Abraham. Their mother was an Egyptian. They were offspring whom the law would, in its day, have put away. But Jacob adopts them. He takes them into the family.
Seeing God's goodness does not leave Jacob talking about himself. It ends in worship:
Hamilton SmithWith the goodness of God filling his soul, Joseph and his two sons pass from his thoughts for the moment. In the presence of God "he bowed himself with his face to the earth." He has reached the highest moment in his spiritual life — he is a worshipper. We know from the Holy Spirit's comment in Hebrews 11 that this was the crowning act of faith in the life of Jacob… The scheming, the pushing of others out of their place, the selfishness, and the independence that so often marred his path had passed away. At last Jacob shows faith, dependence, and worship.
- Fear — Jacob said that everything had come against him. The very losses he mourned were God's means of preserving his whole house.
- Sight — nature saw a dead son. God saw a living one next to the throne, and He proves Himself better than all our fears.
- Gift — the word "also" is the surplus. Jacob expected no face at all, and God showed him a face and a generation.
- Reach — the grandsons God showed him had an Egyptian mother, and Jacob takes them into the family as his own.
- Worship — the old schemer ends face down on the ground. Hebrews 11 calls this the crowning act of faith in his life.