And it came to pass, when she saw that he had left his garment in her hand and had fled forth,
When Potiphar's wife looked down at the clothing still in her hand, the story turned. Joseph had just done the right thing in the only way left to him — he ran. The proof of his innocence then became the evidence that destroyed him.
The moment she sees the garment, she starts building a case.
L. M. GrantShe then saw an opportunity of getting revenge on Joseph because he would not join her in evil. She called out for other men, no doubt servants of the household. She told them Joseph had come in to rape her. She said she cried out, and he left without his garment. So from the moment it happened, she had witness against Joseph that seemed conclusive.
Joseph did not stay to argue, and he did not trust himself to hold the line by willpower. Losing the garment was the price of getting out.
Frank WallaceHe did not stop to say, "I am Joseph, I am a man of God, I can withstand this sort of thing." He knew well the power of nature. He knew well the power of evil. So he fled, leaving his garment in the hand of the evil woman.
One writer turns Joseph's escape into a rule for anyone facing the same pull.
Numerical Bible NotesOur prayer can never be, "Lead us into temptation," and therefore we are never to act as if this were our prayer. In every case where escape is possible without disloyalty, we are to flee rather than face it. "Flee youthful passions." "Abstain (hold off) from the passions of the flesh." Flee, as Joseph fled. There was, perhaps, no bolder man.
This was not one sudden crisis. The pressure came back again and again, and one question held him.
F. B. HoleHere the testing met him day after day. Only his fear of God preserved him, and his recognition of the great wickedness of the seduction placed before him. Whether young or old, we do well to keep this question in our hearts as we pass through this defiling world: "How then can I do this great wickedness and sin against God?" Had he given in, he would have sinned against the woman, against Potiphar and against himself. But the controlling and saving thought was "against God."
What she does next is the same appetite, now aimed at ruining him. Notice also what Joseph never does: he never clears himself by exposing her.
William KellyClearly this young man did more than resist her demands. He was also careful not to wound his master by proving the wife's guilty passion, and her still guiltier revenge on a blameless man. For lust, whether gratified or not, soon turns to hatred.
The pattern reaches past one household, and past one day.
The Bible TreasuryOne event here shows the power of godliness. It also tells what the faithful may expect from this world: slander, false accusation, and prison. This was the first effect of faithfulness… In Potiphar's wife we see the world in a familiar character. Its prince is first the tempter, then the accuser of the saints. Joseph has to wait more than two full years before God appears for him. Faith and patience must have their perfect work.
Joseph never got a public hearing. The charge stood on the record, and he let it.
L. M. GrantNothing was said about why he was put in prison. So far as the record goes, no one ever cleared him of the false charge brought against him. He evidently left this in the hand of God, who knows how to care for His servant's reputation.
One writer reads that undefended suffering as a preview of Someone greater.
William KellyHere then we have the holy youth resisting the tempter, enduring grief, and suffering when he had done no wrong… Joseph could be no true picture of the atonement. But of Christ's suffering unjustly and in grace, he was a blessed foreshadow.
- Flee. Joseph did not negotiate, explain, or test his own strength. Escape was possible, so he took it and left the garment behind.
- Fear. One question carried him through daily pressure: how can I sin against God? The sin would have wronged others too, but God was the restraint.
- Framed. Refused desire turned into hatred, and the proof of his purity became the evidence for the lie. The world tempts first and accuses second.
- Filed away. He never exposed her, and the record never cleared him. He left his good name with God, who cares for His servant's reputation.
- Foreshadow. Joseph suffered though innocent and took it patiently. So he is a foreshadow of Christ, who suffered unjustly and in grace.
that she called to the men of her house, and spoke to them, saying, See, he has brought in a Hebrew man to us, to mock us he came in to me, to lie with me; and I cried with a loud voice;
Joseph has just fled from Potiphar's wife, and she still holds his garment. Within moments she turns it into evidence: she shouts for the household and accuses a foreign slave of assault. What happens when doing the right thing makes everything worse?
The pressure on Joseph came day after day, not in one moment. When the temptation failed, persecution began:
Hamilton SmithThe temptation came "day after day" (v. 10), and the attacks grew more persistent. Then Joseph "flees" from the temptation, and the devil is foiled. But having failed as the tempter, he now becomes the persecutor (vv. 13-18). The woman who once cast her evil eyes on Joseph now bears witness against him with a lying tongue. As an old writer said, "Those who have broken the bonds of modesty will never be held by the bonds of truth. It is nothing new for the worst of criminals to accuse the best of men falsely of the worst crimes." As a result, Joseph escapes from a bad woman and keeps a good conscience. But keeping a good conscience can cost much.
Joseph's refusal did not end the matter. It made her his enemy. Commentators read her as a type — a picture standing for something bigger than one household:
The Bible TreasuryWe may regard Potiphar's wife as a type of the world, whose attractions she symbolises; and, failing to attract the prosperous servant of God, she becomes his fiercest and most unscrupulous foe. Evil company too often comes with prosperity. But for the God-fearing soul, prosperity tied to evil company cannot last. If he stays faithful, the evil company will destroy the prosperity.
Notice her first move: she calls in witnesses and gives them her story. She never uses Joseph's name. He is "a Hebrew," a foreigner her husband brought in, and she aims the insult at "us" — the whole household.
Leslie M. GrantShe then saw an opportunity of getting revenge on Joseph because he would not join her in evil. She called out to other men, no doubt servants of the household. She told them Joseph had come in to rape her. She said she cried out, and he left without his garment. So, from the moment it happened, she had witnesses against Joseph who seemed to prove her case.
Joseph never answers back. One writer weighs the choice this left Potiphar:
William KellyOn the one hand stood the proved, unquestionable trustworthiness of his slave. On the other stood his wife. A woman capable of such an approach must have shown her evil character in many other ways long before, if not in this one. So her word was already doubtful. Still, she was his wife. Her fraud was bold, shameless, and malicious. Yet we hear of no effort on Joseph's part to clear himself by exposing her wickedness. A simple denial of her charge would not stand against a husband's natural anger. Potiphar had no wish to look closely at the terrible alternative.
Joseph's punishment is itself a clue. A slave guilty of attacking his master's wife could expect death, not prison:
C. KnappThe wicked woman's husband evidently did not really believe his wife's foul lie. It was perhaps only to keep up appearances that he made a show of punishing Joseph. If he really believed her story, it is hard to see why he did not have this Hebrew slave put to death at once. He probably knew her character well.
Joseph loses everything for the one act that was right. One writer gives that a name:
William KellySo here we see the holy young man resisting the tempter, bearing grief, and suffering wrongfully. And this is grace in the day of trial… Joseph could be no real type of the atonement. But of Christ suffering unjustly and in grace he was a blessed foreshadow.
Another writer takes the picture further, using words from the Psalms:
Hamilton SmithIn all this Joseph is only a type of One whose sufferings were far deeper, just as His glory is far greater… He, too, suffered under the false accusations of the wicked. Again He can say, "They laid to My charge things that I knew not" (Ps. 35:11). He, too, was led to prison and to death.
(The author quotes Psalm 35:11 from an older translation; the ESV reads, "they ask me of things that I do not know.")
- Tempted. The pressure came day after day. Joseph refused, and the refusal cost him everything he had.
- Accused. When temptation failed, persecution took its place. Those who have broken the bonds of modesty will not be held by the bonds of truth.
- Framed. She called in witnesses on the spot and held up the garment, so the case looked conclusive from the first minute.
- Silent. Joseph never exposed her. He lost his freedom for doing right — what the writers call suffering wrongfully, and grace in the day of trial.
- Foreshadowing. A greater One also had things laid to His charge that He knew nothing of, and He too went to prison and to death.
and it came to pass when he heard that I lifted up my voice and cried, that he left his garment with me, and fled and went out.
Joseph has just run from Potiphar's wife, leaving his coat in her hand. Here she calls the servants and turns his escape into a charge of assault, with the coat as her proof.
The garment was in her hand, and Joseph had run outside. Her story keeps both facts and reverses who was chasing whom.
L. M. GrantShe then saw an opportunity of getting revenge on Joseph because he would not join her in evil. She called out for other men, no doubt servants of the household, and told them Joseph had come in with the object of raping her. She said she cried out, and he left without his garment. So from the very moment of the incident, she had a witness against Joseph that seemed conclusive.
The same woman who wanted him now wants him ruined. One writer sees the devil behind both moves.
Hamilton SmithThe temptation came "day by day" (v. 10), and the attacks grew more persistent until Joseph "flees" from the temptation and the devil is foiled. But having failed as the tempter, he now becomes the persecutor (vv. 13-18). The woman who had earlier cast her evil eyes on Joseph now testifies against him with a lying tongue. As an old writer said, "Those who have broken the bonds of modesty will never be held by the bonds of truth. It is nothing new for the best of men to be falsely accused of the worst crimes by those who are themselves the worst of criminals."
Joseph left his coat behind because he would not stay and argue. That can look like weakness. One writer calls it boldness.
F. W. GrantIn all cases where escape is possible without disloyalty, we are to flee rather than face it. "So flee youthful passions." "Abstain (hold off) from the passions of the flesh." Flee, as Joseph fled; and there was, perhaps, no bolder man.
Joseph kept a clear conscience and lost everything else.
Hamilton SmithIn the end Joseph escapes from a bad woman and keeps a good conscience. But keeping a good conscience may cost much. Joseph has to exchange the comfort of Potiphar's house for the hardships of Pharaoh's prison.
Joseph could have defended himself. His master knew his record. He stayed silent.
William KellyWe can easily imagine how hard this was for Joseph's master, because of his wife's treachery. On one side stood the proven, unquestionable trustworthiness of his slave. On the other stood a wife capable of such an approach. A woman like that must long have shown her bad character in many ways, even if not in this one, so her word was doubtful. Still, she was his wife. However bold, shameless, and malicious her fraud, we never hear of Joseph trying to clear himself by exposing her wickedness.
One writer sees an early sketch of Christ here. The picture has a limit: it shows unjust suffering, not the atoning death.
William KellyHere then we have the holy youth resisting the tempter, and enduring grief, suffering wrongfully… "But if when you do good and suffer for it, you endure, this is a gracious thing in the sight of God. For to this you have been called, because Christ also suffered for you, leaving you an example, so that you might follow in His steps. He committed no sin, neither was deceit found in His mouth. When He was reviled, He did not revile in return; when He suffered, He did not threaten, but continued entrusting Himself to Him who judges justly." Joseph could be no real type of the atonement; but of Christ's suffering unjustly and in grace he was a blessed foreshadowing.
The accusation works, and Joseph goes to prison. But another hand was at work.
C. H. MackintoshIn Genesis 39 Satan uses Potiphar's wife, and in Genesis 40 he uses Pharaoh's chief butler. He used the first to put Joseph into the dungeon. He used the second to keep him there, through his ungrateful forgetfulness. But it was all in vain. God was behind the scenes. His finger was guiding every part of the vast machine of circumstances. When the due time came, He brought forth the man of His purpose and set his feet in a wide, open place.
- Refusal. Joseph would not sin, so he ran. Running, not arguing, was the bold move.
- Revenge. His refusal turned the tempter into the persecutor. The woman who wanted him now lied about him.
- Evidence. The garment made the lie look airtight. From that very moment she had a witness that seemed conclusive.
- Silence. Joseph never exposed her to clear himself. He foreshadowed One who, when reviled, did not revile in return.
- Reversal. The cost was real: comfort traded for a dungeon. But God was behind the scenes, and at the due time He brought out the man of His purpose.
And she laid his garment by her until his lord came home.
Joseph has just torn himself away from his master's wife, and the cloak she grabbed is still in her hands. She keeps it and waits for Potiphar — turning proof of Joseph's escape into proof of a crime he never committed.
Commentators note that she told her story twice — first to the household servants, then to Potiphar. Each time the cloak lay there as proof no one could argue with.
L. M. GrantShe then saw an opportunity of getting revenge on Joseph because he would not join her in evil. She called out for other men, no doubt servants of the household. She told them Joseph had come in to rape her. She said she cried out, and he left without his garment. So from the very moment of the incident, she had a witness against Joseph that seemed conclusive. When Potiphar came home, she told him the same false story. Joseph's garment lay there as apparent proof of her evil accusation.
The same woman who wanted Joseph now wants him ruined. Commentators trace that turn to what lust always does, whether it gets what it wants or not.
William KellyBecause he kept his eyes on the God no one can see, Joseph pushed back the temptation and came through it unstained. He quietly suffered under the false charge of the shameless woman who tried to seduce him. Clearly this young man did more than resist her pressure. He was also careful not to wound his master by proving the wife's guilty passion and her still guiltier revenge on an innocent man. For lust, whether satisfied or not, soon turns into hatred.
The tempter failed, so he changed tactics. Keeping a clear conscience now cost Joseph dearly.
Hamilton SmithThe temptation came "day by day" (v. 10). The attacks grew more persistent until Joseph "flees" from the temptation and so defeats the devil. But having failed as the tempter, he now becomes the persecutor (vv. 13-18). The woman who had once cast her evil eyes on Joseph now testifies against him with a lying tongue. As an older writer said, "The bonds of truth will never hold those who have broken the bonds of modesty. It is nothing new for the worst of criminals to bring false charges of the worst crimes against the best of men." The result is that Joseph escapes from a bad woman and keeps a good conscience. But keeping a good conscience may cost a great deal. Joseph has to swap the comfort of Potiphar's house for the hardship of Pharaoh's prison.
Joseph had every fact on his side. He never used one of them.
William KellyWe can easily imagine the difficulty the wife's treachery created for Joseph's master. On one side stood the proven, unquestionable trustworthiness of his slave. On the other stood his wife. A woman capable of such a proposition must long have shown her bad character in many ways, even if not in this one. That alone would make her word doubtful. Still, she was his wife. Whatever her bold, shameless, malicious fraud, we hear of no effort by Joseph to clear himself by exposing her wickedness.
Commentators read Joseph's ordeal as a picture of someone greater. He too moved from service to false charges to prison.
Hamilton SmithIn all this Joseph is only a picture of One whose sufferings were far deeper, just as His glory is far greater. During His life on earth He too was among us as One who serves, for He could say, "Man acquired Me as bondman from My youth" (Zechariah 13:5). He too suffered under the false accusations of the wicked. Again He can say, "They laid to My charge things that I knew not" (Psalm 35:11). He too was led to prison and to death.
Two people were used against Joseph in these chapters. Commentators point to a third hand behind the scenes.
C. H. MackintoshIn Genesis 39 Satan uses Potiphar's wife, and in Genesis 40 he uses Pharaoh's chief cupbearer. He used the first to put Joseph into the dungeon. He used the second to keep him there, through ungrateful neglect. But it was all in vain. God was behind the scenes. His finger was guiding all the springs of the vast machine of circumstances. When the right time came, He brought out the man of His purpose and set his feet in a large room.
- Refusal. Joseph would not sin, so the woman wanted revenge. The garment he left behind became her proof.
- Reversal. A refused desire does not cool down. Commentators note that lust, satisfied or not, soon turns into hatred.
- Role change. The enemy failed as tempter, so he became persecutor. Joseph kept a clear conscience and lost his freedom.
- Restraint. With the facts on his side, Joseph never defended himself by exposing her — a shadow of the One of whom it was said, "They laid to My charge things that I knew not."
- Rule. Behind the lie and the prison, God was working the machinery of events toward the moment He would bring His man out.
And she spoke to him according to these words, saying, The Hebrew bondman that thou hast brought to us came in to me to mock me;
Potiphar's wife repeats to her husband the story she had already told the servants, and Joseph's cloak lies beside her as proof. She never names him — he is "the Hebrew servant, whom you have brought among us" — so her story blames Potiphar too.
Her accusation was not just her word against his. She had staged it in advance. First she told the household staff, then her husband. And she had the cloak to show.
L. M. GrantShe saw a chance to get revenge on Joseph because he would not join her in evil. She called out to other men, no doubt servants of the household, and told them Joseph had come in meaning to rape her. She said she cried out, and that he left without his garment. So from the very moment of the incident she had testimony against Joseph, and it seemed conclusive. When Potiphar came home she told him the same false story. Joseph's garment lay there as apparent proof of her evil accusation.
The woman who had pursued Joseph day after day now attacks him with her tongue. Decency had not held her back, and truth would not either.
Hamilton SmithThe temptation came "day by day" (v. 10), and the attacks grew more persistent. Then Joseph "flees" from the temptation, and the devil is foiled. But having failed as the tempter, he now becomes the persecutor (vv. 13-18). The woman who had earlier cast her evil eyes on Joseph now bears witness against him with a lying tongue. As an old writer said, "Those who have broken the bonds of modesty will never be held by the bonds of truth. It is nothing new for the best of men to be falsely accused of the worst crimes by those who are themselves the worst of criminals."
Joseph had no way to answer the charge.
L. M. GrantOf course Joseph was helpless to do anything. His word, the word of a slave, would mean nothing to Potiphar compared with the word of his wife.
Yet the punishment Potiphar chose is itself a clue. A slave guilty of this crime would not have lived.
C KnappThe wicked woman's husband evidently did not really believe his wife's foul lie. It was perhaps only to save appearances that he made a show of punishing Joseph. If he really believed her story, it is hard to see why he did not have this Hebrew slave put to death at once. He probably knew her character well.
Joseph goes to prison for the one thing he did right. Peter wrote about that very situation.
F. B. HoleBy his steadfast refusal he enraged the woman. She invented a cunning story against him. Her husband believed it, and it landed Joseph in prison. But in Joseph's history we are going to see a striking example of what the Apostle Peter wrote in his First Epistle. Peter said, "But if when you do good and suffer for it you endure, this is a gracious thing in the sight of God" (1 Peter 2:20). He was brought low for a moment, but only so that he might be lifted up at the right time.
Joseph suffers though he did no wrong, and that points forward to Christ. One writer also marks the limits of the picture.
William KellyHere we have the holy young man resisting the tempter, and bearing grief, suffering wrongfully. This is grace in the day of trial. Christ also suffered for you, leaving you an example that you should follow His steps… Joseph could be no real type of the atonement. But of Christ's suffering unjustly and in grace he was a blessed foreshadowing.
The record never clears Joseph's name. He comes out of prison with the charge still standing.
L. M. GrantNothing was said about the reason he was put in prison. So far as the record goes, he was never cleared of the charge that was falsely brought against him. He evidently left this in the hand of God, who knows how to care for His servant's reputation.
- Refusal. Joseph's "no" is what triggers the accusation — the lie exists only because he stood firm.
- Revenge. Rejected as tempter, the enemy turns persecutor. Whoever breaks the bonds of decency will not keep the bonds of truth.
- Rigged proof. The garment and the servants she had already called made the story look conclusive. A slave's word could not answer it.
- Reversal. God counts it a gracious thing when you suffer for doing good. Joseph is brought low for a moment, then lifted up at the right time.
- Reputation. No one ever clears his name — he leaves it with God, who knows how to care for His servant's reputation.
and it came to pass as I lifted up my voice and cried, that he left his garment with me, and fled forth.
Commentary for this verse has not been generated yet.