Genesis 37:5–10

Genesis 37:5 · Darby

And Joseph dreamed a dream, and told [it] to his brethren, and they hated him yet the more.

Joseph's brothers already resent him. Then God gives him a dream, and he tells it to the very men who cannot speak a kind word to him.

Where the dream came from

Joseph did not invent this dream. One writer traces every dream in his story back to God's own hand.

Next comes the record of Joseph's two dreams. It is remarkable how large a part dreams played in his history. Scripture records no fewer than five of them before the climax, and every one contained a prophecy. Each was therefore produced by the finger of God touching the unconscious mind of the sleeper. Each marked a divine intervention, and indeed a revelation of secret things.

Modernised from F. B. HoleOriginal wording

Should we expect dreams like that today? One writer points to what has changed since Joseph's day.

In the ages before Moses there was no written revelation of God's will. He often used dreams to communicate His mind, or to reveal coming events beforehand… Now we have His written revelation, the completed Bible. Only in very rare and exceptional cases can we recognise a dream as having come from God. "For a dream comes with much business," that is, from purely natural causes, Scripture says.

Modernised from C KnappOriginal wording

A testimony he would not soften

The words "he told it to his brothers" are the hinge of the verse. Joseph could have stayed quiet and stayed safe.

In Joseph's case, we see that his brothers refused his first dream, and yet he in no way softened his testimony… This was simple testimony founded on divine revelation; but it was testimony that brought Joseph down to the pit. He could have held back his testimony, or taken off some of its edge and power, and so spared himself. But no — he told them the truth, and so they hated him.

Modernised from C. H. MackintoshOriginal wording

Why the hatred grew

They already hated him before the dream. The dream added a second thing they refused to hear.

The dreams that speak of Joseph's future supremacy are a fresh motive for the envy and hatred of the brothers. He had been a witness against them of their evil; now he is a witness to them of his future glory. They will have neither one nor the other. The Lord did the same. He witnessed against the evil of the world and bore witness to His coming glories. Like Joseph, He drew hatred on Himself… Before the assembled leaders of Jerusalem He can say, "From now on you will see the Son of Man seated at the right hand of Power." A furious outburst of hatred followed that confession.

Modernised from Hamilton SmithOriginal wording

The question of wisdom

Was it wise to repeat a dream like this to men who envied him? One writer leaves the question open, and still refuses to blame the dream.

Whether it was wise or fitting to repeat his dreams to those who had no love for him may be a question. But the dreams were of God, as the effect on his brothers was of the enemy… The whole record marks Joseph out as a devout youth. He had moral courage. He was faithful toward those going wrong. He had a humble mind, and wondered at the dreams as much as anyone or more… A sign of coming exaltation always provokes adversaries to madness and revenge. Yet, strange as it may seem in their eyes, God turns even their spite and wicked ways to accomplish His purpose.

Modernised from William KellyOriginal wording

What the dream did for Joseph himself

God gave this promise of honour to a boy who was soon thrown into a pit. It was not wasted. It became fuel for the years in between.

We may not doubt that God had a gracious purpose in this. He was exercising Joseph's spirit and strengthening his heart for the distress and the many troubles ahead of him, before those remarkable foreshadowings came true… The dreams were simple and striking, and they touched the whole family. If his brothers could not forget them, the sufferer could forget them still less. In the middle of grief and shame he remembered the visions of strange dignity that awaited him.

Modernised from William KellyOriginal wording

How far the dream reaches

The dream looks like nothing more than a family quarrel. One writer sees it opening onto something far wider.

All this applies in a striking way to the One Joseph pictures, our Lord Jesus. The Jews, His brothers by natural descent, hated Him without a cause and rejected Him when He came among them. Yet the day is coming when they will bow down before Him. But not only this. He is to be the central Object of worship to the heavens as well as the earth. What had been secret is now revealed. We know that God's purpose, according to His good pleasure, is "to unite all things in him, things in heaven and things on earth."

Modernised from F. B. HoleOriginal wording

Summary

- Given — the dream was not Joseph's ambition. It was God's finger touching a sleeping mind, a revelation of secret things.

- Told — he passed it on unchanged; softening it would have spared him, and telling it took him to the pit.

- Hated — first he testified against their evil, then to his coming glory. They would have neither, and God used their spite to serve His own purpose.

- Carried — God gave the promise early to steady Joseph through the long years of trouble before it came true.

- Fulfilled — the bowing widens from his brothers to earth and heaven alike, with Christ at the centre.

Genesis 37:6 · Darby

And he said to them, Hear, I pray you, this dream, which I have dreamt

Joseph is already the least loved member of his family when he asks his brothers to listen to his dream. That raises two questions: where did the dream come from, and was it wise to tell it?

The Dream Came from God

Joseph is not repeating a random night's imagination. Dreams shape his whole story, and writers trace each one back to God.

Next comes the record of Joseph's two dreams. It is striking how large a part dreams played in his history. Before the story reaches its climax, Scripture records no fewer than five, and every one of them contained a prophecy. So the finger of God produced each dream, touching the sleeper's unconscious mind. Each one marked a Divine intervention — indeed, a revelation of secret things.

Modernised from F. B. HoleOriginal wording

The Question of Wisdom

Was Joseph wise to tell such a dream to brothers who had no love for him? Writers leave that open. But they do not leave open where the dream came from.

Joseph spoke the truth about their evil ways, and his father loved him. That made him hateful to the sons of the servant mothers. The special robe Jacob gave him did not soften their harshness, and neither did his two dreams. "Wrath is cruel, anger is overwhelming, but who can stand before jealousy?" Was it wise or fitting to tell his dreams to those who had no love for him? That may be a question. But the dreams were of God, just as their effect on his brothers was of the enemy.

Modernised from William KellyOriginal wording

Speaking Anyway

Joseph did not soften his message after the first dream. He told the second one too.

Now, in Joseph's case, we see that he in no way relaxed his testimony because his brothers refused his first dream. "Now Joseph had a dream, and when he told it to his brothers they hated him even more" … "Then he dreamed another dream and told it to his brothers." This was simple testimony founded on divine revelation. But this testimony brought Joseph down to the pit. If he had held back his testimony, or blunted its edge and power, he might have spared himself. But no — he told them the truth, and so they hated him.

Modernised from C. H. MackintoshOriginal wording

Two Things They Refused to Hear

Joseph had already spoken against his brothers' evil. Now he tells them of his coming glory. Writers find the same pattern in the Lord's words before the leaders of Jerusalem.

The dreams speak of Joseph's future supremacy, and that gives the brothers a fresh motive for envy and hatred. He had been a witness against them of their evil; now he is a witness to them of his future glory. They will have neither one nor the other. The Lord did the same. He witnessed against the evil of the world and bore witness to His coming glories. Like Joseph, He drew the world's hatred upon Himself. Before the assembled leaders of Jerusalem the Lord speaks of His coming glories: "From now on you will see the Son of Man seated at the right hand of Power." A furious outburst of hatred follows that confession. Priests and elders unite to spit in the face of the Son of God.

Modernised from Hamilton SmithOriginal wording

What the Dream Meant

The next verse gives the dream itself: sheaves of grain in a field. It pictures something still far off.

In Joseph's first dream he tells his brothers that he and they were binding sheaves of grain in the field: his sheaf arose and stood erect, and those of his brothers all bowed down to his sheaf (v. 7). Joseph probably did not understand that God meant the dream as a prophecy: his brothers would one day bow to his authority. Genesis 42:6 tells us they did. Of course, the most vital lesson here is that all Israel will yet bow to the Lord Jesus, whom they have despised and hated.

Modernised from L. M. GrantOriginal wording

Given Early, Needed Later

Years of trouble lie between the telling of the dream and its fulfilment. God had a purpose in that gap.

We may not doubt that God had a gracious purpose here. He was exercising Joseph's spirit and strengthening his heart for the distress and many troubles that would be his portion before those remarkable foreshadowings came true… The brothers could not easily forget dreams so simple and striking, dreams that touched nearly the whole family. Still less could the sufferer forget them. In the middle of much grief and shame, he remembered the visions of strange dignity that awaited him within his lifetime and theirs.

Modernised from William KellyOriginal wording

Summary

- Given — the dream was not Joseph's invention. Each of the five dreams in his story carried a prophecy and marked God stepping in.

- Spoken — Joseph told it as testimony resting on divine revelation. Blunting its edge would have spared him the pit.

- Hated — he spoke against their evil, then spoke of his coming glory. They would accept neither.

- Fulfilled — the sheaves came true when his brothers bowed to him, and point on to Israel bowing to the One they rejected.

- Carried — the dream that stirred their hatred also strengthened Joseph for the grief and shame before the glory.

Genesis 37:7 · Darby

Behold, we were binding sheaves in the fields, and lo, my sheaf rose up, and remained standing; and behold, your sheaves came round about and bowed down to my sheaf.

Joseph is a young man working the fields with brothers who already resent him. Then God gives him a dream of the harvest field, where his sheaf stands and the others bow. Two questions follow. Where did the dream come from, and how far does its meaning reach?

Where the dream came from

Joseph did not invent this picture, and he did not boast about it. One writer asks whether he was wise to repeat it to brothers who hated him. Then he looks at where the dream came from, where their hatred came from, and what God does with both.

Was it wise or fitting to repeat his dreams to those who had no love for him? That may be a question. But the dreams were from God, while the effect on his brothers came from the enemy... Everything recorded marks Joseph as a godly youth. He had moral courage. He was faithful toward those who went wrong. He had a humble mind that wondered at the dreams as much as anyone, or more... Such a sign always provokes opponents to madness and revenge. Yet God turns even their spite and wicked ways to accomplish His purpose.

Modernised from William KellyOriginal wording

Commentators differ here. Another writer defends the telling outright.

To tell what his dreams, or his visions in the Spirit, had shown him was from God.

Modernised from J. G. BellettOriginal wording

A picture drawn from their own work

God drew the picture from work these men did every day: binding grain in a field.

In Genesis 37, what could be simpler or better suited to these men? Joseph's sheaf rises up and keeps standing, while the other sheaves come round and bow down to his sheaf... The dream was so plain, vivid and startling that it needed no interpreter.

Modernised from William KellyOriginal wording

From Egypt to Christ

The dream reached further than Joseph's own life, and further than he understood.

Joseph likely did not understand that God meant the dream as a prophecy: his brothers would one day bow to his authority. Genesis 42:6 tells us they did. The most vital lesson here is bigger still. All Israel will yet bow to the Lord Jesus, whom they have despised and hated.

Modernised from L. M. GrantOriginal wording

The harvest field and a coming kingdom

One writer looks past Joseph to what the harvest field pictures. Then he presses the point on the reader.

The scene of this dream is the harvest field. It is Christ's kingdom on earth... All the earth shall own His rule... He does not yet openly take up His great power and reign. But He will, when He reaps the harvest of this earth. Now is the day of His kingdom and patience.... He waits in patient grace to see if you will submit to His authority of your own choice. If you refuse Him now, while He is patient, sheer force will make you own His righteous rule in the day of His power.

Modernised from C KnappOriginal wording

The cost of speaking

His brothers threw the first dream back at him. Joseph could have gone quiet. He did not.

In Joseph's case, he did not soften his testimony when his brothers refused his first dream... This was simple testimony founded on God's revelation. But it was testimony that brought Joseph down to the pit. If he had held back his testimony, or blunted its edge and power, he might have spared himself. But no — he told them the truth, and so they hated him.

Modernised from C. H. MackintoshOriginal wording

The road through the pit

Slavery in Egypt looked like the death of everything the sheaves had promised. It was the opposite.

These dreams of their young brother enraged his jealous brothers, and they got rid of him. They sold him to passing merchants, who took the boy to Egypt and sold him as a slave. This did not look like the fulfilment of Joseph's dreams of future greatness. It was indeed a very sorrowful road to the answer of his dreams, but it was THE road.

Modernised from A J PollockOriginal wording

Summary

- Source — The dream came from God; the hatred it stirred came from the enemy. Joseph wondered at it as much as anyone.

- Sheaf — God spoke in the language of their daily work, so plain and startling that no one needed an interpreter.

- Sequel — Those same brothers bowed to Joseph in Egypt. Commentators see beyond that a day when Israel bows to the Lord they despised.

- Silence refused — Joseph did not blunt his testimony when they rejected the first dream. That faithfulness put him in the pit.

- Sorrowful road — Slavery looked like the end of the dream; it was the way to it. Submit to Christ's rule now in the day of His patience, or own it later under His power.

Genesis 37:8 · Darby

And his brethren said to him, Wilt thou indeed be a king over us? wilt thou indeed rule over us? And they hated him yet the more for his dreams and for his words.

Joseph told his brothers his first dream, and they answered with two sharp questions and a deeper hatred. Where did that dream come from, why did telling the truth make the hatred worse, and what does the scene point forward to?

Dreams from God

One writer separates two questions: where the dreams came from, and whether Joseph was wise to repeat them.

Joseph was a witness against their evil ways, and his father loved him. That made him hateful to the sons of the servant mothers. The special robe Jacob gave Joseph did not soften their harshness, and neither did his two dreams. Whether it was wise or fitting to repeat his dreams to those who had no love for him may be a question. But the dreams were of God, just as the effect on his brothers was of the enemy.

Modernised from William KellyOriginal wording

What the sheaf meant

The brothers needed no help reading the dream. One writer thinks Joseph understood less of it than they did.

Joseph tells his brothers his first dream. He and they were binding sheaves of grain in the field: his sheaf rose and stood upright, and the sheaves of his brothers all bowed down to it (v. 7). Joseph probably did not understand that God meant the dream as a prophecy: his brothers would one day bow to his authority. Genesis 42:6 tells us they did. Of course, the most vital lesson here is that all Israel will yet bow to the Lord Jesus, whom they have despised and hated. At the time Joseph's brothers thought it ridiculous that he would ever have dominion over them (v. 8).

Modernised from L. M. GrantOriginal wording

Envy underneath

Their hatred had a history. It began with the father's preference and grew when God marked Joseph out.

And so his sufferings begin. The Lord marks him as the heir of glory. He speaks of the goodness he had found, and of God's high purpose for him. And his brothers hate him. They envy him; and who can stand before envy? They had already begrudged him his father's favour, and now they hate him for God's. They hate him for his words and for his dreams.

Modernised from J. G. BellettOriginal wording

Hated for his words

The verse gives two causes: his dreams and his words. One writer traces the words back to the lives behind them.

Finally, Joseph's brothers hated him for his words. … So too Christ is still the object of a hatred that men cannot hide, however hard they try. … But never forget what lies behind the "harsh things that ungodly sinners have spoken against him": the "ungodly deeds that they have committed in such an ungodly way." The evil lives of Joseph's brothers lay behind the hatred in their hearts and the evil words of their lips (Jude 15).

Modernised from Hamilton SmithOriginal wording

Standing by the testimony

The brothers refused the first dream. Joseph then told them a second one.

Now, in Joseph's case, we see that he in no way relaxed his testimony because his brothers refused his first dream. … This was simple testimony founded on divine revelation; but it was testimony that brought Joseph down to the pit. Had he held back his testimony, or blunted its edge and power, he might have spared himself. But no — he told them the truth, and so they hated him.

Modernised from C. H. MackintoshOriginal wording

The scene repeated in Christ

One writer finds the same refusal repeated on a national scale.

He was the object of his father's love, and the subject of very high destinies. His brothers' hearts were not in fellowship with these things, so they hated him. They had no share in the father's love. They would not yield to the thought of Joseph's exaltation. In all this they represent the Jews in Christ's day. "He came to his own, and his own people did not receive him." … They would neither own Him as the Son of God nor as king of Israel.

Modernised from C. H. MackintoshOriginal wording

Dreams fulfilled

Nothing they did to Joseph stopped the dreams.

Joseph was lord. His rule was absolute in that great land. His dreams came true. The other sheaves bowed to his sheaf; sun, moon, and eleven stars bowed to him. His brothers had said, "Let us … throw him into one of the pits … and we will see what will become of his dreams." Well, now they had seen!

Modernised from F. B. HoleOriginal wording

Summary

- Given — The dreams came from God. Commentators differ on whether Joseph was wise to repeat them to brothers who had no love for him.

- Refused — The brothers caught the meaning at once. They would not accept the thought of Joseph raised above them.

- Envied — They already resented their father's favour. Now they resented God's, and their own evil lives lay behind the hatred.

- Unsoftened — Joseph blunted nothing. Had he held back the testimony he could have spared himself, but the truth he told took him to the pit.

- Fulfilled — They asked whether he would really reign. In Egypt they bowed, and Israel will yet bow to the One Joseph pictures.

Genesis 37:9 · Darby

And he dreamed yet another dream, and told it to his brethren, and said, Behold, I have dreamt another dream, and behold, the sun and the moon and eleven stars bowed down to me.

Commentary for this verse has not been generated yet.

Genesis 37:10 · Darby

And he told [it] to his father and to his brethren. And his father rebuked him, and said to him, What is this dream which thou hast dreamt? Shall we indeed come, I and thy mother and thy brethren, to bow down ourselves to thee to the earth?

Joseph tells his second dream to the whole family, and this time his father answers him. The rebuke raises three questions: was Joseph boasting, what did the sun and moon stand for, and did Jacob believe him?

The symbols Jacob read at once

Jacob did not need the dream explained. The heavenly bodies carried a plain meaning in a household like his.

Both his dreams foretold his coming greatness and glory. The meaning was so plain that his brothers, and his father too, saw it at once. The drift of the two was the same. But only the second suggested that his father and mother, as well as his brothers, would bow down to him in a day to come. There was a further difference. Sheaves belong to an earthly harvest, while sun, moon and stars are heavenly objects. The sun is a symbol of supreme authority, and the moon of authority derived from it and joined with it. Jacob saw at once how well this fitted the place of father and mother in his large family.

Modernised from F. B. HoleOriginal wording

Why the rebuke came

Commentators differ on what Jacob was reacting to. One reading is that he heard pride in it.

The second dream seems to have raised questions in his brothers' minds. He told them, and told his father too, that he had dreamed of the sun and moon and eleven stars bowing down to him. His father rebuked him. He evidently felt that pride in Joseph had produced the dream. The implication was plain to him: he himself, Rachel and his eleven children would all bow down to Joseph.

Modernised from L. M. GrantOriginal wording

Another finds no fault in Joseph, and puts the trouble on the brothers.

The second dream implied a remarkable honour, and it moved Jacob. He could not help storing up its meaning, dim as it still was to him. Joseph was simple and open, with no presumption in him at all. That only made his brothers' spite burn hotter, and it soon found an occasion to break out in outrageous malice. How like the way of the Jews with Him who was long afterwards to be the blessed One that Joseph pictured!

Modernised from William KellyOriginal wording

A rebuke that did not close the matter

Jacob's rebuke was not his last word. The next verse says he held on to what he had heard.

His father rebuked him. He assumed that what the dream pointed to could never happen. Yet Scripture records that he "kept the saying in mind." That shows he could not dismiss it, and that he saw more in it than he had thought at first. He had faith in God, even if it was weak; whereas the brothers had none.

Modernised from F. B. HoleOriginal wording

The brothers' response: envy

Jacob questioned the dream; his brothers resented it. That reaction has a direct echo in the trial of Jesus.

And see what happens next. When Joseph tells his second dream, we read that his brothers envied him. It was the same with the great One whom he pictured. It is written of Pilate, "he knew that it was out of envy that they had delivered him up" (Matthew 27:18). And who can stand before envy, as the proverb asks? The rulers and the Pharisees were jealous of His standing. "Look, the world has gone after him," they said, in alarm.

Modernised from C KnappOriginal wording

Why two dreams and not one

The move from sheaves in a field to sun, moon and stars is not repetition. It widens the scope.

One dream might have been enough to foretell the glories of Joseph. It would be far too small to picture the glories of Christ. For His supremacy will have a twofold character… The dream of the sheaves bowing to Joseph's sheaf may well speak of that excellent supremacy over all the earth which Christ is destined to wield. Yet this first dream does not set out His supremacy in full. He is destined to be supreme not only on earth, but to hold universal sway over heaven and earth… And this second dream speaks of that heavenly supremacy. It presents heavenly bodies — the sun, the moon, and the stars — bowing down to Joseph.

Modernised from Hamilton SmithOriginal wording

A dream larger than the household

Jacob measured the dream by the household he knew. The picture reaches further than that.

Jacob's view of the prophetic dream seems limited to his own family. He heard that the sun and moon and eleven stars paid homage to Joseph. He then asked whether he, Joseph's mother and Joseph's brothers would really bow to the ground before him. The sun and the moon were, to Jacob, father and mother. But this dream goes far beyond Jacob's family, or the nation of Israel.

Modernised from The Bible TreasuryOriginal wording

Summary

- Read — Jacob needed no interpreter. Sun stands for supreme authority, moon for authority derived from it, and he applied both to himself and Rachel.

- Rebuked — He objected to the dream. Some read his reaction as a charge of pride; others find no presumption in Joseph at all.

- Retained — The rebuke was not the whole of Jacob. He kept the saying in mind, and that marks faith, weak but real, in a man whose sons had none.

- Resented — The brothers answered the second dream with envy, the same motive Pilate saw in those who handed Jesus over.

- Reach — Jacob measured the dream by his own household. The sheaves picture supremacy over the earth, and the stars supremacy over heaven too.