And when Shechem, the son of Hamor the Hivite, the prince of the country, saw her, he took her, and lay with her, and humbled her.
Genesis 34 opens with Dinah going out to visit the local women, and this verse is where the trouble breaks. Behind Shechem's act stands a father who had bought land and built a house among these people. Commentators trace much of what follows back to that choice.
Commentators tie this scene to an earlier choice of Jacob's: he bought land at Shechem and built a house.
William KellyOne wrong step away from our true position before the Lord leads to many a sin, scandal, and sorrow. So we find here as the consequence of Jacob's buying the land of the Hivite, and building himself a house. His stay at Succoth and Shechem covers some ten years. He had to be unsettled before he would return to his pilgrim place. The way back was painful for all, and it brought Jacob deep shame, humiliation, and fear.
Another writer asks what fruit that settling produced.
George C WillisJacob seems to have grown weary of the pilgrim path, and yielded to the temptation to settle down and build a home. And what was the fruit of this action? His daughter Dinah goes out to see the daughters of the land. Her father had settled down in the world instead of living as a heavenly pilgrim passing through it. What could be more natural than that his daughter should want to be friends with the world? Who would have guessed that swapping a tent for a house could yield such bitter fruit?
The verse names him three ways: son of Hamor, a Hivite, and prince of the land. So who were the Hivites?
Morrish Bible DictionaryOne of the races found early in Palestine: they were descendants of Ham through Canaan (Genesis 10:17). Jacob, on his return to Palestine, found Shechem occupied by the Hivites (Genesis 34:2). They also held the city of Gibeon, and managed to trick Joshua into making a treaty with them.
One writer asks what business Dinah had with these neighbours at all.
William KellyWith or without the approval of her parents, Dinah went out to see the daughters of the land. What had she to do with them in any way? Everyone but the godless knew that judgment was coming on these people, and that Abraham's offspring would have the land. Their sin was great, though not yet full. Apart from that, how thoughtless and dangerous her behaviour was! She seems to have been as independent of her mother as her brothers certainly were of their father's advice.
The verse stacks three verbs: he "seized her and lay with her and humiliated her." Older translations read "took her ... and humbled her." Commentators differ over how much force was used. One reads it as seduction by a man carried away by desire, without ruling out violence.
William KellyHer wandering curiosity exposed her to the young prince of the land. He was taken with her and carried away by his passion. He seduced her, if he did not force her by violence.
Another writer asks whether her brothers weighed Dinah's own share of the blame.
Leslie M. GrantThe sons, when they came, were not only grieved but very angry at Shechem. Did they not stop to think that the blame was not only Shechem's, but Dinah's also? For though this was sin, it was not rape.
One writer reads the whole chapter as the fruit of one compromise.
F. B. HoleThe whole of Genesis 34 shows the unhappy results that came from Jacob lowering his separation from the world. The evil showed itself not in Jacob himself, but in his family. The tide of evil runs in two broad channels: violence and corruption. The world is just the same today. How often we have to hang our heads in shame and admit that we, as Christian parents, have kept too close to the world — and it has brought sorrow and even disaster into our families.
Another writer weighs Jacob's altar against his way of life.
Numerical Bible NotesHis altar declares God to be his God (El-elohe-Israel). Yet it seems he uses this only to walk in his own ways more openly than before. His house at Succoth and the land he bought at Shechem tell the same story. He is hardly a pilgrim now. He loses his separateness, and Dinah is defiled. God's grace will not comfort those who will not use it in holiness.
One writer measures this household against Abraham's.
J. G. BellettWas this the way of the house of Abraham? Was this the family of the separated patriarch keeping the way of the Lord? Had Abraham been this careless? What contact had he arranged for his children with the sons or the daughters of the land?
- Step — Jacob bought land at Shechem. One wrong step away from his place before the Lord opened the door to sin, scandal, and sorrow.
- Settling — a father who traded the tent for a house should expect his daughter to want the neighbours' friendship.
- Separateness — Jacob lost his separateness, and Dinah was left exposed. The Hivites were a Canaanite people already facing judgment.
- Shame — commentators differ on whether this was force or seduction. One asks whether the brothers weighed Dinah's own part.
- Spread — evil runs in two channels: violence and corruption. Both reached Jacob's family, and parents who stay close to the world still reap sorrow.
And his soul fastened on Dinah the daughter of Jacob, and he loved the maiden, and spoke consolingly to the maiden.
Genesis 34 opens with a wrong done to Jacob's only daughter. Verse 3 then turns to something unexpected: the man who wronged her is bound to her in love, and his words to her are gentle. The rest of the chapter grows out of that strange mix of real affection and real sin.
Commentators trace the whole episode back to one choice. Jacob stopped travelling and settled near the city.
George C. WillisJacob seems to have grown tired of the pilgrim path, and gave in to the temptation to settle down and build a home. And what was the fruit of this? His daughter Dinah goes out to see the daughters of the land. Her father had settled down in the world instead of living as a heavenly pilgrim passing through it. What could be more natural than that his daughter should want to be friends with the world?
One writer pictures Jacob as a cake baked on one side only — half of him belonging to the people around him, half to God.
The Bible TreasuryThe little leaven kneaded into the dough, left to work unseen, unjudged in the fire of God's light and love, would, but for grace, soon leaven the whole lump. "Jacob has mixed himself among the people; he is a cake not turned, half Shechemite, half Israelite, half judged, the other half untouched by fire."
Commentators differ on what happened between Shechem and Dinah. One reads her outing as reckless and leaves the question of force open.
William KellyWith or without her parents' permission, Dinah went out to see the daughters of the land. Josephus claims there was a festival. What business had she with them at all? Everyone but the godless knew that judgment on these people would come one day, and that Abraham's descendants would possess the land. Their sin was great, though not yet full. Apart from that, how foolish and dangerous she was! She seems to have been as independent of her mother as the young men certainly were of any advice from their father. Her restless curiosity exposed her to the young prince of the land. His passion carried him away, and he seduced her if he did not force her.
Another writer says Dinah shared the blame — a question her brothers never stopped to ask.
L. M. GrantThe sons, when they came, were not only grieved but very angry at Shechem. Did they not stop to think that the blame was not only Shechem's, but Dinah's too? For though this was sin, it was not rape.
Verse 3 sets Shechem apart from the man who takes and then discards.
L. M. GrantThe young man was guilty of this act of fornication. Even so, he did not reject her, as many would do. He seems to have truly loved her, and he spoke kindly to her.
That love then cost him something.
L. M. GrantHamor and Shechem fully agreed to the terms Jacob's sons proposed. Shechem in particular did not delay to be circumcised, because he loved Dinah. We are told he was more honourable than everyone in his father's household.
Verse 3's tenderness makes the rest of the chapter darker. The condition Shechem accepted was never meant as an invitation.
William KellyThen Jacob's sons stepped in with deceit, making circumcision the condition for every male. They had not the slightest thought or wish of bringing the Shechemites into the covenant. It was the basest treachery, meant to trap and massacre them. Jacob had nothing to do with the cruel secret. Their pride and revenge ignored God as much as it ignored their father. Shechem was guilty of a great wrong; but Dinah was at fault too.
The damage did not stop with the two young people.
F. B. HoleSo the shameful story of Genesis 34 caused Jacob to "stink to the inhabitants of the land." That was a dreadful position for him, since he was the only man in the land who truly knew God. It also brought judgment on the two who drove the violence. In later days the tribe of Levi acted in a way that won a special blessing. So we are allowed to see how God can turn what was at first a curse into a blessing. The word had been, "I will divide them in Jacob and scatter them in Israel." They were divided — but by Levi being called to special service and scattered through all the tribes.
- Settle — Jacob traded the tent for a house near the city. His daughter then wanted the friendships that choice put within reach.
- Stray — Dinah went out to see the daughters of the land. Commentators call this foolish and dangerous. They differ over whether what followed was seduction or force.
- Sin — the wrong was real, yet at least one writer insists the blame was not Shechem's alone.
- Love — verse 3 shows affection that looks real. Shechem did not discard her, he spoke kindly, and he paid the price asked of him without delay.
- Loss — Jacob's sons answered that sincerity with treachery, and the whole house paid. Jacob stank to the people of the land, and judgment fell on his sons. Yet God later turned that curse on Levi into a blessing.
And Shechem spoke to his father Hamor, saying, Take me this girl as wife.
Shechem has already taken Dinah, and now he wants her as his wife, so he asks his father to arrange it. That one request soon grows into an offer that puts Jacob's whole family at risk.
Shechem's request did not come out of nowhere. The trouble in this chapter began before Shechem ever saw Dinah.
F. B. HoleThe whole of Genesis 34 is filled with the unhappy results of Jacob lowering his separation from the world. The evil effects did not show in Jacob himself, but in his family. The tide of evil runs in two broad channels: violence and corruption... The world is just the same today. How often we, as Christian parents, have to hang our heads in shame. We must admit that a little compromise with the world on our part has led to sorrow and even disaster in our families.
Measured against the family's own past, Dinah's outing was already out of character.
J. G. Bellett"And Dinah, the daughter of Leah, whom she bore to Jacob, went out to see the daughters of the land." Genesis 34:1. Was this the way of the house of Abraham? Was this the family of the separated patriarch keeping the way of the Lord? Had Abraham been this slack? What contact had he arranged for his children with either the sons or the daughters of the land?
Shechem's request to his father soon grew into an offer to merge the two peoples. That is where the danger lay.
G C WillisWhen Shechem saw Dinah he said to his father, "Get me this girl for my wife." So Hamor asked Jacob. Jacob and his sons all knew they should not agree, but they spoke deceitfully. Hamor also promised to give Jacob many things. He suggested the two peoples might be one, living in the land, trading, and marrying together. Just like the world of today; they want Christians to be one with them — no difference. Christians, be careful! The Lord says, "Go out from their midst, and be separate." (2 Corinthians 6:17.) The world says, "We may be one."
Dinah had no business among these people, and Shechem did not treat her as a passing conquest.
William KellyWhat did she have to do with them at all? All but the godless knew that the time for judgment on these people would come, and that Abraham's descendants would possess the land. Their sin was great, though not yet full... Her wandering curiosity exposed her to the young prince of the land. He was taken with her, and his passion carried him away. He seduced her, if he did not force her. Meanwhile Shechem was eager for marriage at any price. His father went to Jacob and pleaded hard for his son's fixed desire to have her as wife. He offered the readiest terms of peace between the two peoples, while Shechem pressed his own case.
Commentators differ on how far force went. Kelly leaves it open. L. M. Grant sees a real fondness in verse 3, following a real sin.
L. M. GrantShe became sexually involved with a young man, son of the prince of that land. The young man was guilty of fornication. Even so, he did not reject her afterwards, as many would do. He seems to have truly loved her, and he spoke kindly to her (v. 3).
The wrong was not all on one side. And the answer Jacob's sons gave was itself a lie.
William KellyJacob's sons then answered with a trick. They made circumcision of every male their condition. They had not the smallest thought or wish of bringing the Shechemites into the covenant. It was the basest treachery, meant to trap and massacre them... Shechem was guilty of a great wrong, but Dinah too was at fault. Their own mothers and their grandmother did not come from circumcised fathers, and no godly or careful reluctance had appeared in their own marriages. The condition was a lying and cowardly excuse, used to carry their resentment through to the end.
The story did not end there. Jacob was still speaking of it on his deathbed.
F. B. HoleThe anger came to a head in the terrible violence of Simeon and Levi. Jacob never forgot it, and neither did God. At the end of his life Jacob spoke of his sons as a prophet. He foretold the future of the tribes and gave certain blessings. He condemned these two sons and cursed their anger, as recorded in Genesis 49:5-7.
- Settling. Jacob let his separation from the world slip; the trouble showed up not in him but in his children.
- Straying. Dinah went out to see the daughters of the land — behaviour unthinkable in Abraham's household.
- Seizing. Shechem took her first and asked afterwards, pressing his father to secure the marriage at any price.
- Merging. The request grew into an offer to be one people, marrying and trading together. The world still makes that offer to God's people.
- Reaping. Jacob's sons answered with deceit. Violence followed, and Jacob was still cursing that anger on his deathbed.
And Jacob heard that he had defiled Dinah his daughter; but his sons were with his cattle in the fields, and Jacob said nothing until they came.
News of Dinah's disgrace reaches Jacob first, while his sons are still out with the livestock. He says nothing, and his silence hands the crisis to them.
The chapter's grief did not begin with Shechem. It began earlier. Jacob stopped travelling, built a house and bought land instead of going on to Bethel. One writer ties the daughter's wandering to her father's choice of home:
George C WillisJacob seems to have grown tired of the pilgrim path, and gave in to the temptation to settle down and build a home. And what was the fruit of this? His daughter Dinah goes out to see the daughters of the land. Her father had settled down in the world instead of living as a heavenly pilgrim passing through it. So what could be more natural than his daughter wanting to be friends with the world? We all know the sad, shameful result. Who would have guessed that trading a tent for a house could bear such bitter fruit? Yet so it is. In our day, friendship with the world still means being an enemy of God. If we settle down in this world and lose the pilgrim spirit, we can hardly blame our children for seeking the friendship of the people we have settled among.
The verse is careful about timing. Jacob knows before Hamor arrives, and he waits for sons who are not yet home.
Leslie M. GrantJacob had heard the news before Hamor came, but had said nothing, waiting till his sons returned from their work in the field before saying anything at all about the shame of Shechem's sin with Dinah.
Not every writer reads that silence kindly. One speaks straight to Jacob, and the silence closes a list of failures:
The Bible TreasuryAt Shechem you buy a field, and Dinah is defiled by Shechem; your sons act by deceit, and Simeon and Levi — instruments of cruelty, fierce anger and cruel wrath — are cursed: and you hold your peace! You are a foolish dove without heart!
Commentators do not lay the whole weight on Shechem. The sons come home grieved and angry, and one writer asks what their anger overlooked.
Leslie M. GrantThe sons, when they came, were not only grieved but very angry at Shechem. Did they not stop to think that the blame was not only Shechem's, but Dinah's also? For though this was sin, it was not rape.
Another writer looks at Dinah too, and at how little her parents counted at home. Commentators differ on whether force was used:
William KellyWith or without her parents' permission, Dinah went out to see the daughters of the land. What business did she have with them at all? Everyone but the godless knew that judgment would come on these people one day, and that the descendants of Abraham would take the land. She seems to have been as independent of her mother as the young men clearly were of their father's advice. Her restless curiosity exposed her to the young prince of the land. He was taken with her and carried away by his passion, and he seduced her if he did not force her. Her poor father was silent until the sons came back from work.
Because Jacob waited, his sons answered Hamor instead of him. Their offer used the language of the covenant to hide a plan for slaughter.
William KellyThen Jacob's sons stepped in with guile, setting the condition that every male be circumcised. They had no thought or wish at all of bringing the Shechemites into the covenant. It was the basest treachery, meant to trap and massacre them. Jacob had nothing to do with the cruel secret. Their pride and revenge ignored God as it did their father.
One writer sees Jacob meeting his own past in his sons:
Arno Clemens GaebeleinAfter Peniel, Jacob built a house at Succoth and bought a piece of land instead of going on to Bethel. If he had gone to Bethel, perhaps this sad event would never have happened. God permitted it for the humbling of His servant Jacob. Again he reaps what he had sown, and the father's deceit is reflected in the deceit of some of his sons.
The story does not stop at ruin. The curse spoken over Simeon and Levi was not the last word:
F. B. HoleIn later days the tribe of Levi acted in a way that gained a special blessing. So we are allowed to see how God can turn what was once a curse into a blessing. The word had been, "I will divide them in Jacob and scatter them in Israel." They were divided — but the division came through Levi's call to special service and Levi's scattering throughout all the tribes.
- Settle — Jacob traded the tent for a house. His daughter's wandering followed his settling.
- Hear — the news reaches Jacob first, and he waits for sons still in the field.
- Silence — writers differ on that silence; one calls the waiting father a foolish dove without heart.
- Seize — the sons fill the gap. Their grief was real, but their plan was treachery, and their father knew nothing of it.
- Salvage — the curse scattered Levi, and God turned that scattering into service.
And Hamor the father of Shechem came out to Jacob, to speak to him.
Genesis 34 finds Jacob camped beside a Canaanite city instead of at Bethel. In verse 6 the city walks into his camp: Hamor, the local ruler and father of the man who has violated Dinah, comes out to talk terms. Commentators read this quiet verse as the price of where Jacob had chosen to live.
Hamor's arrival was no accident. Writers trace it back to the land Jacob bought and the house he built near Shechem, instead of living in a tent.
William KellyOne wrong step away from our true position before the Lord leads to many a sin, scandal, and sorrow. So we find here, as the result of Jacob buying the land of the Hivite and building himself a house. His stay at Succoth and Shechem covers some ten years. He had to be unsettled to bring him back to his place as a pilgrim; but the way was painful for all, and brought deep shame, humiliation and fear to Jacob.
Trouble now came to Jacob from the household he had been busy protecting. One writer sets that beside his silence, and raises a question the family never asked itself.
Leslie M. GrantJacob had been concerned about his own house. Now he must learn through painful experience that when he puts his house first, he will find trouble and sorrow from his house. Jacob had heard the news before Hamor came, but had said nothing. He waited till his sons returned from their work in the field before speaking at all about the shame of Shechem's sin with Dinah. The sons, when they came, were not only grieved but very angry at Shechem. Did they not stop to think that the blame was not only Shechem's, but Dinah's also? For though this was sin, it was not rape.
Hamor does not arrive as an enemy. He comes as a father speaking for a son, and, by his own standards, doing the decent thing.
William KellyShechem earnestly sought marriage at any price, and his father went to Jacob. He pleaded hard for his son's fixed desire to have her as wife, and offered the readiest terms of peace between the two peoples, while Shechem urged his own case.
The terms go far past one marriage. Hamor proposes that the two peoples merge, and one writer hears in that a voice still speaking today.
G. C. WillisHamor also promised to give Jacob many things, and suggested they might be one people and live in the land and trade, and marry together. Just like the world of today; they want Christians to be one with them — no difference. Christians, be careful! The Lord says, "Therefore go out from their midst, and be separate from them, says the Lord" (2 Corinthians 6:17). The world says, "We may be one." The Lord says, "Let everyone who names the name of the Lord depart from iniquity" (2 Timothy 2:19).
Hamor could make such a proposal because the two households were no longer separate. Years later Jacob saw what his time at Shechem had produced.
J. G. BellettHe finds out, at the end, the real character of all this, the fruit of his living at Shechem. In self-will a man had been killed there, and a fence thrown down. But surely Jacob himself had dug down God's fence before. God's call had raised a wall between the clean and the unclean, between the circumcised people and the Gentiles. Jacob himself had broken that wall down in spirit when he settled as a citizen or property owner on the land he had bought at Shechem. And Simeon and Levi may finish the job as soon afterwards as they please.
The story does not end in shame. Writers see God using that shame to move Jacob on to Bethel.
The Bible TreasuryJacob is made to feel the shame and humiliation of the position he had chosen for himself. Then the word of the Lord falls freely on his soul, and the discipline has prepared him to respond to it. "Arise," says the Lord, "go up to Bethel and dwell there. Make an altar there to the God who appeared to you when you fled from your brother Esau." Jacob, leaving Shechem for Bethel, leaves all his defilements behind him. The idols have to be left at Shechem; they cannot be taken to Bethel.
- Settling. Jacob stopped being a pilgrim and became a neighbour. He bought land and built a house short of Bethel, so the city could walk into his camp.
- Silence. Jacob heard about Dinah before Hamor arrived and said nothing. He waited for his sons, and their anger filled the space he left.
- Proposal. Hamor came pleading for his son and offering easy terms of peace. By his own standards, this was the honourable way to settle it.
- Merger. The real offer was that the two peoples become one, with no difference left. The world still makes that offer; Scripture answers it with the call to come out and be separate.
- Return. The shame worked as discipline. It drove Jacob out of Shechem toward Bethel, and the idols could not travel with him.
And the sons of Jacob came from the fields when they heard [it]; and the men were grieved, and they were very angry, because he had wrought what was disgraceful in Israel, in lying with Jacob's daughter, which thing ought not to be done.
Jacob's sons hear the news and hurry in from the field. Shechem has shamed their sister, and the men are furious. Two questions follow. How did a family under God's promise end up here? And was their anger the same thing as righteousness?
One writer traces the whole disaster to an earlier choice. Jacob bought land at Shechem and built himself a house.
William KellyOne wrong step away from our true position before the Lord leads to many a sin, scandal, and sorrow. So we find here, as the consequence of Jacob's buying the land of the Hivite and building himself a house. His stay at Succoth and Shechem covers some ten years. He had to be unsettled to bring him back to his pilgrim place. But the way back was painful for everyone, and it brought deep shame, humiliation and fear on Jacob.
Dinah had gone out among the local women. Another writer holds that against the household Abraham kept.
J. G. BellettWas this the way of the house of Abraham? Was this the family of the separated patriarch keeping the way of the Lord? Had Abraham been this slack? What contact had he arranged for his children with either the sons or the daughters of the land?
Compromise rarely stops with the person who makes it.
F. B. HoleThe whole of Genesis 34 deals with the unhappy results that sprang from the lowering of Jacob's separation from the world. The evil did not show itself in Jacob but in his family. The tide of evil runs in two broad channels: violence and corruption... The world is just the same today. How often we, as Christian parents, must hang our heads in shame and admit that a little closeness to the world on our part has brought sorrow and even disaster into our families.
The verse does not merely report an offence; it labels it, and the label attaches to the whole household. (Older translations read "folly wrought in Israel"; the ESV renders it "an outrageous thing in Israel.")
The Bible Treasury"So here was folly wrought in Israel… which ought not to have been done" — a matter of grief and wrath — a horrible thing in Israel. "Israel is defiled and Jacob holds his peace."
Jacob waited for his sons before he said anything. Their grief was real, but one writer asks whether they weighed their sister's part in it too.
L. M. GrantJacob had heard the news before Hamor came, but said nothing. He waited until his sons returned from their work in the field before he spoke at all about the shame of Shechem's sin with Dinah. The sons, when they came, were not only grieved, but very angry at Shechem. Did they not stop to think that the blame was not only Shechem's, but Dinah's also? For though this was sin, it was not rape.
Grief that looked like family loyalty turned into a plan. The brothers used circumcision, the sign of God's covenant, as bait.
William KellyThen Jacob's sons stepped in with deceit. They set the condition that every male among the Shechemites be circumcised. They had no thought or wish of inviting these men into the covenant. It was the basest treachery, meant to trap and massacre them. Jacob had nothing to do with the cruel secret. Their pride and revenge ignored God, just as it ignored their father.
The story does not end with the raid. Judgment fell on the brothers who led the violence — and God did not leave it there.
F. B. HoleThe shameful story of Genesis 34 made Jacob "stink among the inhabitants of the land." That was a dreadful position for him, since he was the only man in the land who had the true knowledge of God. It also brought judgment on the two men who led the violence. Yet in later days the tribe of Levi acted in such a way as to gain a special blessing. So we are allowed to see how God can turn what was first a curse into a blessing. The word had been, "I will divide them in Jacob and scatter them in Israel" (49:7). They were divided — but the division came when God called Levi to special service and scattered him through all the tribes.
- Step — It starts before verse 7. One move away from the pilgrim place, a house at Shechem, and ten settled years.
- Soil — Closeness to the world bore fruit in the family: corruption and violence. The parents' compromise showed itself in the children.
- Sentence — The verse calls the deed folly in Israel, a thing that must not be done. The shame touched the whole household, not one man.
- Sword — The brothers' grief was real. It hardened into pride and revenge that ignored God and their father alike.
- Scattering — The judgment stood, and God scattered Levi. Yet He turned that scattering into service — a curse becoming a blessing.
And Hamor spoke to them, saying, My son Shechem's soul cleaves to your daughter I pray you, give her to him as wife.
Jacob's family has settled near the city of Shechem, and the ruler's son, also named Shechem, has already violated Jacob's only daughter, Dinah. Now the young man's father, Hamor, comes to talk terms. His first words are not an apology. He asks for the girl in marriage — and that is only the opening move in a much larger proposal.
In the Bible the "soul" is where a person's affections sit. One writer gathers the verses that show this, and Hamor's plea heads his list:
Frederick W GrantSo it is the seat of the affections: Genesis 34:8 — the soul of my son longs for your daughter. 1 Samuel 18:1 — the soul of Jonathan was knit to the soul of David. Psalm 42:1 — so my soul pants for You, O God. Psalm 84:2 — my soul longs for the courts of the Lord.
Hamor does not come as an equal making a business offer. He comes as a father begging, and he brings peace terms with him:
William KellyMeanwhile Shechem was eager to marry her at any price. His father went to Jacob and pleaded hard for his son's fixed desire to have her as wife. He offered the easiest terms of peace between the two peoples, while Shechem pressed his own case.
Read on its own, the proposal looks decent. Shechem wants to marry Dinah, not discard her. His father treats it as a matter a good offer can settle:
L. M. GrantHamor came at this time to tell them that Shechem had real affection for Dinah and wanted to marry her. At the same time he invited them to remain in the land and have their families intermarry. No doubt to the mind of Hamor this was the honourable way to meet the question. Shechem adds to this that he is willing to pay any dowry that they might ask of him for Dinah.
Hamor's plea does not stay personal for long. It opens into a plan to merge two peoples, and commentators see the same pressure on Christians today:
G C WillisHamor also promised to give Jacob many things. He suggested they might be one people, live in the land, trade there, and marry together. Just like the world of today; they want Christians to be one with them — no difference. O Christians, be careful! The Lord says, "Go out from their midst, and be separate from them" (2 Corinthians 6:17). The world says, "We may be one." The Lord says, "Let everyone who names the name of the Lord depart from iniquity" (2 Timothy 2:19).
The chapter's trouble did not begin with Hamor's speech. It began earlier, when Jacob stopped travelling and bought land:
George C WillisJacob seems to have grown tired of the pilgrim path, and gave in to the temptation to settle down and build a home. And what was the fruit of this action? His daughter Dinah goes out to see the daughters of the land. Her father had settled down in the world instead of passing through it as a heavenly pilgrim. What could be more natural than his daughter wanting to be friends with the world?
Hamor's plea met an answer that sounded religious but was a trap:
William KellyThen Jacob's sons stepped in with a deceitful condition: every male must be circumcised. They had not the smallest wish to bring the men of Shechem into the covenant. It was the basest treachery, meant to trap and massacre them. Jacob had nothing to do with the cruel secret. Their pride and revenge ignored God as it did their father. Shechem was guilty of a great wrong; but Dinah too was at fault.
The defilement, the marriage offer, the slaughter — one writer traces it all back to a single earlier choice:
F. B. HoleThe whole of Genesis 34 is filled with the unhappy results that came from Jacob lowering his separation from the world... The tide of evil runs in two broad channels: violence and corruption... The world is just the same today. How often we have to hang our heads in shame and admit that a little settling on the edge of the world, as Christian parents, has led to sorrow and even disaster in our families.
- Settle — Jacob swapped the pilgrim's tent for a home near a Canaanite city. He lowered his separation from the world before any of the damage came.
- Stray — a father who settles in the world should expect his daughter to want the friendship of the neighbours he chose.
- Sweeten — Hamor's plea mixes real affection with easy terms: any dowry, trade, land, marriage between the families. It looked to him like the honourable solution.
- Merge — behind the plea for one girl lies the real proposal: one people, no difference. The world still makes Christians that offer.
- Reap — Jacob's sons answered with treachery dressed as religion, and the city paid for it in blood.
And make marriages with us give your daughters to us, and take our daughters to you.
Jacob's daughter Dinah has been wronged, and the father of the man who did it now comes with an offer. It reaches far past one wedding: trading daughters would blend the two families into one people.
Hamor does not come as an enemy. He comes as a neighbour who thinks he is doing the decent thing by Dinah's family.
Leslie M. GrantHamor came at this time to tell them that Shechem had real affection for Dinah and wanted to marry her. At the same time he invited them to remain in the land and have their families intermarry. No doubt to the mind of Hamor this was the honorable way to meet the question. Shechem adds to this that he is willing to pay any dowry that they might ask of him for Dinah.
The offer is not only about Dinah. Give daughters and take daughters, and in a generation the two families are one. Commentators hear in it the same offer the world still makes.
G. C. WillisHamor also promised to give Jacob many things. He suggested that they might be one people, living in the land, trading, and marrying together. Just like the world of today; they want Christians to be one with them — no difference. O Christians, be careful! The Lord says, "Go out from their midst, and be separate from them" (2 Cor. 6:17). The world says, "We may be one."
Nobody offers a merger to a man who is only passing through. Jacob had bought land at Shechem and settled on it, and that is what made Hamor's offer possible. The wall was already down, and Jacob had taken it down himself.
J. G. BellettIn self-will a man had been killed there, and a fence thrown down. But surely Jacob himself had dug down God's fence before. God's call had raised a wall between the clean and the unclean, between the circumcised and the Gentile. Jacob himself, in spirit, had broken that wall down when he settled at Shechem as a citizen and landowner on the estate he had bought.
The cost of Jacob's settling did not fall on him first. It fell on his children.
F. B. HoleThe whole of Genesis 34 is taken up with the unhappy results that sprang from Jacob lowering his separation from the world... The world is just the same today. How often we have to hang our heads in shame and admit that a little living on the world's border, on our part as Christian parents, has led to sorrow and even disaster in our families.
Jacob's sons answer Hamor with a condition of their own. Saying no to the world's terms is right; saying no by treachery is a second evil.
William KellyThen Jacob's sons stepped in with guile, making circumcision for every male their condition. They had not the smallest thought or wish of inviting the Shechemites into the covenant. It was the basest treachery, meant to trap and massacre them. Jacob had nothing to do with the cruel secret. Their pride and revenge ignored God as they ignored their father. Shechem was guilty of a great wrong; but Dinah too was in fault. Neither their mothers nor their grandmother came from circumcised fathers, and no reverent or careful reluctance showed itself in their own marriages. The condition was a lying and cowardly pretext to carry out their resentment to the full.
The remedy is not a small repair at Shechem. God calls Jacob away from it, up to Bethel.
C. H. Mackintosh"God said to Jacob, 'Arise, go up to Bethel and dwell there.'" When there is failure or decline, the Lord calls the soul back to Himself... The soul must be recalled to the very highest point; it must be brought back to the divine standard. The Lord does not say, "remember where you are"; no, but "remember the lofty position from which you have fallen."
- Fence. God's call drew a line between Jacob's family and Canaan. Jacob pulled it down himself when he bought land at Shechem and settled there.
- Offer. With the line gone, Hamor could propose marriage between the families, and any dowry they asked. By local custom it looked honourable.
- Merger. The real ask was not one wedding but "one people". The world still makes the same offer: let there be no difference left.
- Harvest. The cost fell on the children. Dinah was wronged, and her brothers turned circumcision into a lying pretext for massacre.
- Return. The answer is not damage control at Shechem. God calls Jacob up to Bethel — back to the highest point, not the nearest one.
And dwell with us, and the land shall be before you dwell and trade in it, and get yourselves possessions in it.
Hamor answers the wrong done to Dinah with a business offer. Settle here, trade here, buy land here, and let our families marry. It sounds generous, but Jacob was only ever meant to be passing through.
Nothing in Hamor's approach is hostile. He comes pleading, and his son offers to pay anything asked.
William KellyShechem earnestly sought marriage at any price. His father went to Jacob, pleading hard for his son's fixed desire to have Dinah as wife. He offered the readiest terms of peace between the peoples, and Shechem urged for himself.
Hamor is not inviting a stranger. Jacob had already bought ground there and built himself a house.
William KellyOne wrong step away from our true position before the Lord leads to many a sin, scandal, and sorrow. So we find here, as the consequence of Jacob's buying the land of the Hivite and building himself a house. His stay at Succoth and Shechem covers some ten years. He has to be unsettled to get him back to his pilgrim place. But the way was painful for all, and a deep shame, humiliation and fear for Jacob.
One writer traces Dinah's wandering back to her father's choice of a house over a tent.
G. C. WillisJacob seems to have grown tired of the pilgrim path, and gave in to the temptation to settle down and build a home. And what was the fruit of this action? His daughter Dinah goes out to see the daughters of the land. Her father had settled down in the world instead of being a heavenly pilgrim passing through it. What could be more natural than that his daughter should want to be friends with the world? We all know the sad, shameful result. Who would have guessed that swapping a tent for a house could produce such bitter fruit?
Behind the trade and the property, Hamor asks for one people. One writer hears the same voice in the world today.
G. C. WillisHamor also promised to give Jacob many things. He suggested they might be one people, live in the land and trade, and marry together. Just like the world of today — they want Christians to be one with them, no difference. Christians, be careful! The Lord says, "Go out from their midst, and be separate from them" (2 Cor. 6:17). The world says, "We may be one." The Lord says, "Let everyone who names the name of the Lord depart from iniquity" (2 Tim. 2:19).
When Hamor takes the plan home, he sells it to his neighbours on profit.
L. M. GrantAll no doubt recognised that circumcision had a religious meaning. They would not be in the least suspicious of any hidden design against them. Besides, the wealth of Jacob's family would be a welcome addition to the area, and everyone would benefit from them (vv. 20-23). These were persuasive arguments, and the men of the city fully agreed, so that all of them were circumcised.
Jacob's sons did not accept the offer and did not refuse it. They used circumcision as bait.
William KellyThen Jacob's sons stepped in with the deceitful condition of circumcision for every male. They had not the smallest thought or wish of inviting the Shechemites into the covenant. It was the basest treachery, meant to trap and massacre them. Jacob had nothing to do with the cruel secret. Their pride and revenge ignored God as they ignored their father.
The invitation to live and trade among them ended with those same neighbours loathing Jacob.
F. B. HoleSo the shameful story of Genesis 34 caused Jacob to "stink to the inhabitants of the land." That was a dreadful position for him, since he was the only man in the land who truly knew God. It also brought judgment on the two who drove the violence. It is interesting that in later days the tribe of Levi acted in such a way as to gain a special blessing. So we are allowed to see how God can turn what was at first a curse into a blessing. The word had been, "I will divide them in Jacob and scatter them in Israel" (49:7). They were divided — but by Levi being called to special service and scattered through all the tribes. The first verse of Genesis 35 shows us how God stepped in when things had reached this sorry state. He called Jacob back to the place where God first made Himself known to him. There he was to live, and there his altar was to be.
- Settle — Jacob bought land and built a house where he should have stayed a pilgrim. One wrong step opened the door to the rest.
- Invite — the world's offer arrives dressed as kindness: live here, trade here, own here, and marry among us.
- Merge — the real request is that there be no difference. Scripture's call is to come out and be separate.
- Profit — the townsmen had their own reason to say yes: Jacob's wealth.
- Reap — deceit answered deceit, and the land came to loathe Jacob. Yet God later turned even the curse on Levi into blessing.
And Shechem said to her father and to her brethren, Let me find favour in your eyes; and what ye shall say to me I will give.
Genesis 34 opens with Jacob's daughter Dinah going out to visit the women of the land. By verse 11 the prince who wronged her stands before her father and brothers, asking for their goodwill and offering to pay any price they name.
Shechem is not brushing the matter aside. He wants Dinah as his wife at any price. He pleads with the brothers because their father has stayed silent.
William KellyWith or without her parents' permission, Dinah went out to see the daughters of the land… Her wandering curiosity exposed her to the young prince of the land. He was taken with her and carried away by his passion. He seduced her, if he did not take her by force. Her poor father stayed silent until his sons came back from work. Meanwhile Shechem pushed hard for marriage at any price. His father went to Jacob and pleaded for his son's fixed desire to have her as his wife. He offered the readiest terms of peace between the two peoples, while Shechem pressed his own case.
The promise is not vague generosity. Shechem is naming a known custom, spelled out in the next verse as the bride-price.
Morrish Bible DictionaryThe sum paid by a man to the relatives of the woman who becomes his wife. Genesis 34:12; Exodus 22:16-17; 1 Samuel 18:25… The dowry which Jacob gave for his wives was seven years' service for each. Genesis 29:18, 27.
Jacob had once paid such a price himself. Now a man offers a price for his daughter.
Shechem and Hamor hoped generous terms would repair the damage. Instead the anger grew.
F. B. HoleHis daughter Dinah wanted to enjoy the company and pleasures of the other young women of the land. As a result she became entangled and defiled. This stirred up great anger among Jacob's sons. What Shechem and Hamor did to repair the damage did not calm it. The anger came to a head in the terrible violence of Simeon and Levi, which Jacob never forgot, nor did God. At the end of his life Jacob spoke as a prophet about his sons. He foretold the future of the tribes and gave certain blessings. He condemned these two sons and cursed their anger, as recorded in Genesis 49:5-7.
Verse 11 is one line in a much larger offer. One writer hears in that offer a voice Christians still hear today.
G. C. WillisHamor promised to give Jacob many things. He suggested that they might be one people, live in the land, trade, and marry together. Just like the world today, they want Christians to be one with them — no difference. Christians, be careful! The Lord says, "Go out from their midst, and be separate from them" (2 Corinthians 6:17). The world says, "We may be one." The Lord says, "Let everyone who names the name of the Lord depart from iniquity" (2 Timothy 2:19).
The brothers answered his open-handed plea with words that sounded religious. They were a trap.
William KellyThen Jacob's sons stepped in with a deceitful condition: every male must be circumcised. They had not the slightest thought or wish of bringing the Shechemites into the covenant. It was the basest treachery, meant to trap and slaughter them. Jacob had nothing to do with the cruel secret. Their pride and revenge ignored God just as it ignored their father. Shechem was guilty of a great wrong; but Dinah was at fault too… The condition was a lying, cowardly pretext. It let them carry their resentment to the limit.
Why was such a proposal even on the table? Because Jacob's family had already dropped the separation that should have kept the two households apart.
J. G. BellettIn self-will a man had been killed there, and a fence had been thrown down. But it was Jacob himself who had dug down God's fence first. God's call had raised a dividing wall between the clean and the unclean. Jacob broke that wall down in spirit when he settled as a citizen and landowner on his purchased estate at Shechem. And Simeon and Levi may finish the job as soon afterwards as they please.
- Compromise — Jacob broke God's fence first, settling and buying land at Shechem. His sons only finished what he had started.
- Corruption — Dinah's visit to the daughters of the land left her entangled and defiled. That is the wrong verse 11 tries to settle.
- Compensation — Shechem offers the bride-price, the sum a man paid the woman's relatives. Jacob had paid it himself, with fourteen years of work.
- Confederacy — the payment hid a bigger proposal. Two peoples become one, sharing land and marriages. That is the world's standing invitation. Scripture answers it: "go out from their midst, and be separate
- Cost — the brothers answered with treachery dressed as covenant, and Jacob cursed their anger on his deathbed. The whole chain started when Jacob settled down instead of staying separate.
Impose on me very much as dowry and gift, and I will give according as ye shall say to me; but give me the maiden as wife.
Shechem has sinned with Jacob's daughter Dinah, and now he offers her family any price they care to name. Two questions follow: can money settle a wrong, and how did Jacob's family end up here at all?
Writers trace the whole chapter back to one choice by Jacob, and to what it cost his daughter:
George C WillisJacob seems to have grown tired of the pilgrim path, and gave in to the temptation to settle down and build a home. And what was the fruit of this? His daughter Dinah goes out to see the daughters of the land. Her father had settled down in the world instead of being a heavenly pilgrim passing through it. What could be more natural than that his daughter should want to be friends with the world?
The bride-price Shechem names had a fixed meaning in that world:
Morrish Bible DictionaryThe sum paid by a man to the relatives of the woman who becomes his wife. Genesis 34:12; Exodus 22:16-17; 1 Samuel 18:25... The dowry which Jacob gave for his wives was seven years' service for each. Genesis 29:18, 27.
Shechem puts no ceiling on the sum, and his father comes to Jacob's family to arrange it:
L. M. GrantHamor came at this time to tell them that Shechem had real affection for Dinah and wanted to marry her. At the same time he invited them to remain in the land and have their families intermarry. No doubt to the mind of Hamor this was the honorable way to meet the question. Shechem adds that he is willing to pay any dowry they might ask of him for Dinah.
The trouble started before any offer was made:
F. B. HoleHis daughter Dinah wanted to enjoy the companionship and pleasures of the other young women of the land. As a result she got entangled and defiled. This aroused great anger among Jacob's sons. What Shechem and Hamor did to repair the damage did not calm it.
The money came attached to a wider proposal:
G C WillisHamor also promised to give Jacob many things. He suggested that the two peoples might become one, and live in the land, and trade, and marry together. Just like the world of today; they want Christians to be one with them — no difference. Christians, be careful! The Lord says, "Go out from their midst, and be separate from them" (2 Corinthians 6:17).
Grant does not lay all the blame on Shechem:
L. M. GrantThe sons, when they came, were not only grieved but very angry at Shechem. Did they not stop to think that the blame was not only Shechem's, but Dinah's also? For though this was sin, it was not rape.
Shechem's open offer met a closed reply. The brothers named a religious condition they had no intention of honouring:
William KellyThen Jacob's sons stepped in with deceit. They set one condition: every male must be circumcised. They had not the smallest thought or wish of inviting the Shechemites into the covenant. It was the basest treachery, meant to trap and massacre them. Jacob had nothing to do with the cruel secret. Their pride and revenge ignored God as much as it ignored their father. The condition was a lying and cowardly pretext, used to push their resentment as far as it would go. Hamor and Shechem fell into the trap. They had enough influence to persuade all their townsmen to join them in the painful rite, and in the danger they never saw coming.
The cost of that day did not end with the city, and judgment was not God's last word on it:
F. B. HoleThe shameful story of Genesis 34 made Jacob "stink to the inhabitants of the land." That was a dreadful position for him, since he was the only man in the land who had the true knowledge of God. It also brought judgment on the two men who promoted the violence. Yet in later days the tribe of Levi acted in a way that won them a special blessing. So we are allowed to see how God can turn what was once a curse into a blessing. The word had been, "I will divide them in Jacob and scatter them in Israel" (Genesis 49:7). They were divided — but by Levi being called to special service and scattered through all the tribes.
- Settled. Jacob grew tired of the pilgrim path and built a home in the world.
- Exposed. A father who settles in the world should not be surprised when his daughter looks for friends there.
- Offered. The dowry was the normal payment to a bride's family. Shechem lifted every limit on it to get Dinah.
- Unrepaired. No payment repairs a defilement. Nothing Shechem and Hamor offered calmed the brothers' anger.
- Compounded. The brothers' deceitful reply ignored God and their father, and judgment followed. Yet God later turned that curse on Levi into a blessing.
And the sons of Jacob answered Shechem and Hamor his father deceitfully, and spoke -- because he had defiled Dinah their sister --
Genesis 34 opens with Jacob's family living too close to the city of Shechem. By verse 13, talks about Dinah's marriage have turned into a trap. The verse calls the answer to Shechem and his father Hamor deceitful, and it gives the reason: he had defiled their sister. A real wrong had been done, and the response to it was a lie.
The trouble did not begin with the answer of Jacob's sons. It began earlier, in how close the family had settled to the world around them.
F. B. HoleThe whole of Genesis 34 deals with the unhappy results of Jacob lowering his separation from the world. Its evil effects showed up not in Jacob himself but in his family. The tide of evil runs in two broad channels: violence and corruption. The world is just the same today. As Christian parents, we often have to hang our heads in shame and admit it. A little flirting with the world on our part has led to sorrow and even disaster in our families.
The condition they set — circumcision for every male — sounded like a religious requirement. It was nothing of the sort.
William KellyThen Jacob's sons stepped in with cunning and set the condition of circumcision for every male. They had no thought or wish of bringing the men of Shechem into the covenant. It was the basest treachery, designed to trap and massacre them. Jacob had nothing to do with the cruel secret. Their pride and revenge ignored God as it ignored their father. Shechem was guilty of a great wrong, but Dinah too was at fault. The condition was a lying and cowardly pretext to carry their resentment to the utmost.
Circumcision was no small thing. It marked this family off from the nations around them. In verse 13 they lay that sign on the table as a bargaining chip. One writer weighs what they traded away, and what they traded it for.
The Bible TreasuryIn crafty malice and greed for gain, Israel's sons hand over to these men God's own title to the land. And the man who thought that title so worthless that he based his claim on another man's rights would think little of trading circumcision away for treasure in this world. Circumcision is the reproach of Christ, separation from the ungodly world, the seal of faith, the sign of God's inheritance.
The brothers wrapped their revenge in religious language. One writer weighs the damage that does.
The Bible TreasuryThey are joined together and deceitful, as religious bigotry always is… In these terrible crusades the innocent suffer with the guilty — the innocent ox along with the guilty Shechem. And Shechem was not half as bad as they were. The worst part of this crime is that they do it in the name of God, religious order and separation. So they drag religion into the contempt of unthinking minds. They manage to wrong the world and the church at the same time.
One writer traces the whole event back to a journey Jacob never finished.
Arno Clemens GaebeleinAfter his experience at Peniel, Jacob built a house at Succoth and bought a plot of land instead of going on to Bethel. If he had gone to Bethel, perhaps this sad event would never have happened. God allowed it to humble His servant Jacob. Again he reaps what he had sown, and the deceit of the father is reflected in the deceit of some of his sons.
The deceit of verse 13 led to a massacre, and the two brothers behind it faced judgment for it. Yet the story does not close there.
F. B. HoleSo the shameful story of Genesis 34 made Jacob "stink to the inhabitants of the land." That was a dreadful position, since he was the only man in the land with the true knowledge of God. It also brought judgment on the two who promoted the violence. Yet in later days the tribe of Levi acted in such a way as to gain a special blessing. So we see how God can turn what was first a curse into a blessing. The word had been, "I will divide them in Jacob and scatter them in Israel." They were divided — but God did it by calling Levi to special service and scattering that tribe through all the others.
- Settle — Jacob lowered his separation from the world and settled beside a Canaanite city. The damage showed up in his children, not in him.
- Sin — Shechem's wrong against Dinah was real, and one writer says Dinah was at fault too. A real grievance did not excuse the answer her brothers gave.
- Scheme — The offer in verse 13 never invited anyone into the covenant. It was a lying pretext that used God's sign as bait. Jacob had no part in the secret.
- Stain — Evil done in the name of God, order and separation wrongs the world and the people of God at once. It drags religion into contempt.
- Salvage — Jacob reaped his own deceit in his sons, and judgment followed. Yet God later turned Levi's scattering from a curse into special service.
and said to them, We cannot do this, to give our sister to one that is uncircumcised; for that [were] a reproach to us.
Hamor has just asked for Dinah and proposed that the two families intermarry. Jacob's sons refuse in the language of a people set apart — but their words hide a plan, and the sign of God's covenant is about to become a bargaining chip.
Their answer was deceitful from the start. Commentators read the whole speech as a trap laid under religious words:
L. M. GrantBut the sons of Jacob were far from honourable in the way they answered. No doubt Jacob did not suspect their motives at all. But it was with cruel deceit that they told Shechem and Hamor their terms. They would agree to Hamor's suggestion only if all the males of the land accepted circumcision. They even promised that, if the men did this, they would live together as one people and be willing to intermarry with the local people there.
The brothers' own family history exposes the excuse:
William KellyNot the smallest thought or wish had they for inviting the Shechemites into the covenant. It was the lowest treachery, meant to trap and massacre them. Their pride and revenge ignored God as it did their father. Shechem was guilty of a great wrong; but Dinah too was in fault. Their own mothers and their grandmother were daughters of uncircumcised men. And no godly or sensitive reluctance showed in their own marriages. They set the condition as a lying, cowardly excuse, so they could carry their resentment as far as it could go.
The brothers call the match a disgrace to them. Yet circumcision carried a meaning of its own, and that is what they sold:
The Bible TreasuryIn crafty malice and greed for gain, Israel's sons hand over to these men God's title to the land. And the one who valued that title so little that he based his claim on another's rights would hardly hesitate to trade circumcision away for treasure in the world. Circumcision was the reproach of Christ, separation from the world of the ungodly, the seal of faith, the sign of God's inheritance.
The brothers speak as though a wall still stood between their family and the people of the land. It did not. Their father had taken it down himself by settling at Shechem:
J. G. BellettIn self-will a man was killed there, and a fence thrown down. But Jacob himself had dug down God's fence first. The call of God had raised a wall between the clean and the unclean, between the circumcised and the Gentile. Jacob himself, in spirit, had broken that wall down when he settled as a citizen or landowner on his purchased estate at Shechem. And Simeon and Levi may complete this, as soon afterwards as they please.
The same writer turns the verse's own word back on the speakers:
J. G. BellettWhat we see here is an uncircumcised Jacob, not circumcised Shechemites.
The brothers made their demand in God's name, so the crime that followed carried a second offence:
The Bible TreasuryThey plot together and deceive, as religious bigotry always does. Every genuinely religious person will join Jacob in disowning them. The innocent suffer with the guilty in these cursed crusades — the innocent ox along with the guilty Shechem — though Shechem was not half as bad as they were. The worst of this crime is that they do it in the name of God, religious order and separation. So they make thoughtless people hate religion. In this way they manage to wrong the world and the church at the same time.
Both sides aim at the same outcome: no difference between the two peoples. The same pull is still at work today:
G C WillisHamor also promised to give Jacob many things. He suggested that they might be one people, live in the land and trade, and marry together. Just like the world of today; they want Christians to be one with them — no difference. Christians, be careful! The Lord says, "Go out from their midst, and be separate from them" (2 Cor. 6:17). The world says, "We may be one." The Lord says, "Let everyone who names the name of the Lord depart from iniquity" (2 Tim. 2:19).
- Cause — Jacob pulled the fence of separation down himself when he settled at Shechem. His sons' fine words defended a boundary the family had already left.
- Pretext — "We cannot do this thing" was a lying, cowardly excuse. The brothers had no wish to bring anyone into the covenant. They wanted a trap.
- Barter — Circumcision was the seal of faith and the sign of separation from the ungodly. Here the brothers trade it away for revenge and gain.
- Cover — The worst part was doing it in the name of God and separation. That wrongs the world and God's people at once.
- Call — The world keeps saying, "let us be one, no difference." God keeps calling His people to come out and be separate.
But only in this will we consent to you, if ye will be as we, that every male of you be circumcised;
Shechem wants to marry Dinah, and his father Hamor has asked Jacob's family to join with his people as one. The sons answer with a single condition — circumcision — and the chapter shows what happens when people use a holy sign for an unholy purpose.
The terms sound like an invitation into the covenant. They were nothing of the kind.
William KellyThen Jacob's sons stepped in with guile, setting the condition that every male be circumcised. They had not the smallest thought or wish of bringing the Shechemites into the covenant. It was the basest treachery, meant to trap and massacre them. Jacob had nothing to do with the cruel secret. Their pride and revenge ignored God just as it ignored their father. … The condition was a lying and cowardly pretext to carry their resentment to the limit.
The sons' offer came with a promise and a threat.
Leslie M. GrantNo doubt Jacob did not suspect their motives at all. But their words to Shechem and Hamor were cruel deceit. They said they could only agree to Hamor's suggestion if all the males of the land were circumcised. They even promised that if the men were circumcised, they would live together as one people, willing to marry the local people. If the men would not agree to be circumcised, the brothers said they would take Dinah with them and leave the country.
They offered God's own mark on His people as an entry fee. That mark meant the opposite of the merger on the table.
Morrish Bible DictionaryCircumcision was the rite appointed by God as a token of the covenant that He made with Abraham and his descendants. It was also the seal of the righteousness of his faith… It signified the separation of a people from the world to God… Against God's design, circumcision became a mere formal act when the covenant itself was ignored.
So they offered the sign of separation as the price of mixing. They kept the form and emptied out the meaning.
Hamor wanted the merger too, and he made it sound attractive. One writer sees the same pressure on Christians today.
G C WillisJacob and his sons all knew they should not agree, but they spoke deceitfully. Hamor also promised to give Jacob many things, and suggested they might be one people and live in the land and trade and marry together. Just like the world of today; they want Christians to be one with them — no difference. Christians, be careful! The Lord says, "Go out from their midst, and be separate" (2 Corinthians 6:17). The world says, "We may be one." The Lord says, "Let everyone who names the name of the Lord depart from iniquity" (2 Timothy 2:19).
The trouble started before any of this. Jacob had settled at Shechem.
F. B. HoleThe whole of Genesis 34 is filled with the unhappy results that sprang from the lowering of Jacob's separation from the world. Its effects for evil were not seen in Jacob himself, but in his family. The tide of evil runs in two broad channels: violence and corruption… The world is just the same today. How often we have to hang our heads in shame and confess that a little compromise with the world on our part, as Christian parents, has led to sorrow and even disaster in our families.
When the trouble came, Jacob looked at his sons rather than at himself.
C. H. MackintoshInstead of looking at Simeon and Levi, or at the consequences of their rash action, he should have judged himself for being in such a position at all. If he had not settled at Shechem, no one would have dishonoured Dinah, and his sons would never have shown their violence. We constantly see Christians getting into deep sorrow and trouble through their own unfaithfulness. Then, instead of judging themselves, they look at their circumstances and blame them.
The bargain did not buy Jacob peace.
Numerical Bible NotesThen comes the slaughter of the Shechemites. It was a judgment so cruel, and with so much deceit in it, that the Spirit of God later pronounced it accursed through Jacob himself. And now Jacob is shaken out of his ease and security, and plunged into distress and fear once more. God's grace will not comfort those who refuse to use it in a holy way.
The revenge outran the wrong it punished: "their dealings with the city were far worse than was Shechem's sin" (Leslie M. Grant).
- Compromise. The chapter's disasters trace back to one step: Jacob settled at Shechem and lowered his separation from the world. The damage showed up in his children, not in himself.
- Cover. His sons named the covenant sign as their one condition. They had no wish to bring anyone into the covenant. It was a pretext to trap and kill.
- Contradiction. Circumcision stood for a people separated to God. Offering it as the entry fee for intermarriage emptied the sign of the very thing it signified.
- Consequence. Revenge dressed in religion ended worse than the sin it punished. Jacob himself later called it accursed.
- Correction. Jacob blamed his circumstances rather than himself. The lesson is self-judgment: grace does not comfort those who refuse to use it in a holy way.
then will we give our daughters to you, and take your daughters to us, and we will dwell with you, and be one people.
Commentary for this verse has not been generated yet.
But if ye do not hearken to us, to be circumcised, then will we take our daughter and go away.
Commentary for this verse has not been generated yet.
And their words were good in the eyes of Hamor and Shechem, Hamor's son.
Jacob's sons named their terms, and Hamor and his son Shechem liked what they heard. The price of peace was a religious rite, and they were willing to pay it. What they could not see was the trap. The condition was never an invitation into the covenant, and accepting it would cost the men of their city their lives.
The men who framed this proposal already had murder in mind. One writer is blunt about the gap between their words and their real intent:
William KellyThen Jacob's sons stepped in with a trick. They made circumcision for every male the condition. They had not the smallest thought or wish of inviting the Shechemites into the covenant. It was the basest treachery, meant to trap and massacre them. Jacob had nothing to do with the cruel secret. Their pride and revenge ignored God just as it ignored their father. The condition was a lying and cowardly pretext to carry their resentment through to the end. Hamor and Shechem fell into the trap. They had enough influence to persuade all their townsmen to join them in submitting to the painful rite, and to its unexpected danger.
Two things made the offer attractive, and neither raised a warning flag:
L. M. GrantJacob's sons proposed the terms of the pact, and Hamor and Shechem were entirely agreeable. Shechem himself did not delay to be circumcised, because he loved Dinah. We are told that he was more honourable than everyone in his father's household... Everyone no doubt recognised that circumcision had a religious meaning. They would not have been in the least suspicious of any hidden plan against them. On top of that, the wealth of Jacob's family would be a welcome addition to the area, and all would benefit from them. These were persuasive arguments, and the men of the city were fully agreeable, so that all of them were circumcised.
Circumcision was the sign of the covenant. Here Jacob's sons hand it to a whole city as the price of a marriage and a trade deal. One writer says the real damage was not to the Shechemites but to Jacob himself:
J. G. BellettSurely what we see here is an uncircumcised Jacob, not circumcised Shechemites. It is all miserable... This is like the religious energy of Christendom. It has put the name of Christ in the company of a world that lies under His judgment, a world He bears with only in His patience. It is as if Israel had agreed with Pharaoh and undertaken to give the Lord an altar in Egypt. But such altars are no altars — just as another gospel is not another. Such religion is empty, whether practised in these earliest days at Shechem, or now, among the nations of a judged, condemned world. God's call is to separate from it.
Strip away the rite and the dowry, and Hamor was pleased with a merger. One writer warns that the world still makes the same offer:
G. C. WillisHamor also promised to give Jacob many things. He suggested they might be one people, live in the land and trade, and marry together. Just like the world of today — they want Christians to be one with them, with no difference. Christians, be careful! The Lord says, "Go out from their midst, and be separate from them" (2 Corinthians 6:17). The world says, "We may be one." The Lord says, "Let everyone who names the name of the Lord depart from iniquity" (2 Timothy 2:19).
The whole negotiation only happened because Jacob had settled where he did. Instead of blaming his sons, he should have judged his own choice of home:
C. H. MackintoshWe see in Genesis 34 the bitter fruit of his stay at Shechem. A stain fell on his family. Simeon and Levi try to wipe it out by the sheer energy and violence of nature, and that only led to deeper sorrow... If he had not settled at Shechem, Dinah would not have been dishonoured, and the violence of his sons would not have appeared. We constantly see Christians getting into deep sorrow and trouble through their own unfaithfulness. Then, instead of judging themselves, they start looking at circumstances and blaming them.
- Settled. Jacob's stay at Shechem is the root. If he had not settled there, no one would have dishonoured Dinah, and his sons' violence would never have appeared.
- Pleased. A merger pleased Hamor: shared daughters, shared land, shared trade. The world still offers the same deal — no difference.
- Pretext. The rite his city accepted was a lying pretext. Jacob's sons had no wish to bring anyone into the covenant.
- Hollow. A holy sign on an unchanged heart shows us an uncircumcised Jacob, not circumcised Shechemites. Such religion is empty.
- Reaped. Believers in trouble of their own making tend to blame circumstances. The call is to judge ourselves instead, and to separate from the world.
And the youth did not delay to do this, because he had delight in Jacob's daughter. And he was honourable above all in the house of his father.
Shechem had wronged Jacob's daughter Dinah. Yet he is the one who moves fastest to put things right, and this verse calls him the most honoured man in his father's house — while her brothers hide murder behind a religious demand.
Jacob had changed the way he lived. He stopped travelling as a stranger and settled near the city, and one writer traces the whole disaster to that choice.
George C WillisJacob seems to have grown tired of the pilgrim path, and gave in to the temptation to settle down and build a home. And what was the fruit of this action? His daughter Dinah goes out to see the daughters of the land. Her father had settled down in the world, instead of being a heavenly pilgrim passing through it. What could be more natural than that his daughter should want to be a friend of the world? We all know the sad, shameful result. Who would have guessed that exchanging a tent for a house could produce such bitter fruit?
The verse gives the reason for Shechem's haste: he loved Dinah. So he agreed on the spot to a painful condition — circumcision, the bodily sign of God's covenant — and his city saw no danger in it.
L. M. GrantHamor and Shechem fully agreed to the terms Jacob's sons proposed. Shechem in particular did not delay to be circumcised, because he loved Dinah. We are told he was more honourable than all the household of his father... No doubt everyone recognised that circumcision had a religious meaning. So they were not in the least suspicious of any hidden plan against them.
The verse rates Shechem above everyone in his own house. One writer rates him above the brothers who killed him, Simeon and Levi. He reads Jacob's later words over those two as the Spirit's verdict on religious violence.
The Bible TreasuryThe condemnation of Simeon and Levi is the Holy Spirit's witness against religious intolerance and persecution... They are allied and deceitful, as religious bigotry always is. But every truly religious man will echo Jacob's rejection: "Let my soul come not into their council; O my glory, be not joined to their company. For in their anger they killed men, and in their willfulness they hamstrung oxen." The innocent suffer with the guilty in these cursed crusades — the innocent ox with the guilty Shechem — though Shechem was not half as bad as they were.
Shechem hurried to meet a demand that was designed to disable him. The brothers had no interest in bringing the city near to God, and one writer says their father knew nothing of the plan.
William KellyThen Jacob's sons stepped in. They set a deceitful condition: every male must be circumcised. They had no thought or wish at all of inviting the Shechemites into the covenant. It was the basest treachery, meant to trap and massacre them. Jacob had nothing to do with the cruel secret. Their pride and revenge ignored God, just as it ignored their father... The condition was a lying and cowardly excuse to carry out their resentment to the limit.
The men of the city took the covenant sign, and it changed nothing. One writer turns the picture around and puts the real failure on Jacob's side.
J. G. BellettSurely what we see here is an uncircumcised Jacob, not circumcised Shechemites. It is all miserable. Is this a son of Abraham? Is this a saint of God? Is this one of God's strangers in a world that has turned away from Him?... Such religion is empty. That was so in those earliest days at Shechem, and it is so now among the nations of a judged and condemned world. God's call is to separate from it.
Shechem's eagerness cost him his life, and the violence cost Jacob's sons a curse. Yet the sentence on Levi did not stay a sentence.
F. B. HoleIt brought a judgment on the two who promoted the violence. In later days the tribe of Levi acted in a way that gained a special blessing. So we get to see how God can turn what began as a curse into a blessing. The word had been, "I will divide them in Jacob and scatter them in Israel." They were divided. But the division came through Levi's call to special service, scattered through all the tribes.
- Drift — Jacob traded the tent for a house. His daughter then went looking for friends among the people of the land.
- Delay — Shechem "did not delay." His speed came from real love, and it walked him straight into a trap.
- Honour — The verse ranks him above his father's house. One writer ranks him above his killers: he was not half as bad as Simeon and Levi.
- Disguise — Jacob's sons turned the sign of God's covenant into a lying excuse for revenge. Scripture condemns that kind of religious bigotry.
- Reversal — The city carried the covenant sign while Jacob lived like a man without it. Yet God turned Levi's curse into scattered service and blessing.
And Hamor and Shechem his son came to the gate of their city, and spoke to the men of their city, saying,
Commentary for this verse has not been generated yet.
These men are peaceable with us; therefore let them dwell in the land, and trade in it. And the land -- behold, it is of wide extent before them. We will take their daughters as wives, and give them our daughters.
Commentary for this verse has not been generated yet.
But only in this will the men consent to us to dwell with us, to be one people -- if every male among us be circumcised, just as they are circumcised.
Hamor and Shechem stand at their city gate and sell the deal to their neighbours. The whole treaty hangs on one requirement: circumcision for every male. Only then can the two peoples live as one. It sounds like a religious concession. It is the bait in a trap.
The demand came from Jacob's sons, not from Jacob. One writer weighs what lay behind it.
William KellyThen Jacob's sons stepped in with guile and set the condition that every male be circumcised. They had not the smallest thought or wish of inviting the Shechemites into the covenant. It was the basest treachery, meant to trap and massacre them. Jacob had nothing to do with the cruel secret. Their pride and revenge ignored God as much as it ignored their father… The condition was a lying and cowardly pretext to carry their resentment to the very end.
Hamor's offer is that the two groups become one people. One writer hears in it the offer the world still makes to Christians.
G. C. WillisHamor also promised to give Jacob many things. He suggested they might be one people, live in the land and trade, and marry together. Just like the world of today; they want Christians to be one with them — no difference. Christians, be careful! The Lord says, "Go out from their midst, and be separate from them." The world says, "We may be one."
Why would a whole town agree to this? One writer gives two reasons.
L. M. GrantAll no doubt recognised that circumcision had a religious meaning. They would not be in the least suspicious of any hidden design against them. What is more, the wealth of Jacob's family would be a welcome addition to the area, and everyone would benefit from them. These were persuasive arguments, and the men of the city agreed fully, so that all of them were circumcised.
Here circumcision is handed out as a membership fee. Its real meaning runs far deeper.
F. B. HoleThe true circumcision is that done without hands in Christians "by putting off the body of the flesh, by the circumcision of Christ." As the next verse shows, this points to His death. He, the Messiah, was cut off, as predicted. He was severed from His life here in flesh and blood, so that He might take up life again in resurrection. As those identified with Him, we put the sentence of death on the old fleshly life we once lived, and so put off the body of the flesh. So the meaning of the rite was the putting of the death sentence on the flesh and all its works.
So the irony is sharp. The men of Shechem take the sign in their bodies, while Jacob's family settles in among them.
J. G. BellettSurely it is rather an uncircumcised Jacob we see here, and not circumcised Shechemites. It is all miserable. Is this a son of Abraham? Is this a saint of God? Is this one of God's strangers in a world that has revolted from Him?… Such religion is empty, whether practised in these earliest days at Shechem, or now in these days of Christendom, among the nations of a judged, condemned world. God's call is to separate from it.
Long before the bargain at the gate, Jacob had settled at Shechem. One writer traces the whole disaster back to that choice.
C. H. MackintoshHe was on low moral ground at Shechem… If he had not settled at Shechem, Dinah would not have been dishonoured, and the violence of his sons would not have been displayed. We constantly see Christians getting into deep sorrow and trouble through their own unfaithfulness. Then, instead of judging themselves, they look at their circumstances and blame them.
- Settle. Jacob settled at Shechem instead of living as God's stranger. Every grief that follows grows from that one choice.
- Mingle. Then came Hamor's offer: one people, no difference. The world still makes it.
- Bargain. The one condition sounded religious. It was a pretext for slaughter, sweetened by the promise of Jacob's wealth.
- Mask. Circumcision marks the death sentence on the flesh. Traded as a membership fee, it left the men of Shechem cut and Jacob the uncircumcised one.
- Reap. Religion tied to the world is empty religion. The harvest here was shame and bloodshed.
Their cattle, and their possessions, and every beast of theirs, shall they not be ours? only let us consent to them, and they will dwell with us.
Hamor and Shechem are selling a deal to their townsmen. Their closing argument is money: accept this one condition, and the livestock and goods of Jacob's household become ours. The offer sounds like friendship, but it is a calculation. Jacob was only exposed to it because he had settled at Shechem.
Jacob had settled at Shechem. One writer traces the whole disaster back to that choice, not to the men of the city.
C. H. MackintoshHis mind was more occupied with his danger among the Shechemites than with his security in the hand of God. He ought to have known that no one could touch a hair of his head. So instead of looking at Simeon and Levi, or at the results of their rash action, he should have judged himself for being in that position at all. If he had not settled at Shechem, no one would have dishonoured Dinah, and his sons would never have shown their violence.
The offer was a merger. Both sides would marry, trade and live as one people. Writers hear the world making the same offer today.
G. C. WillisHamor also promised to give Jacob many things. He suggested that they might be one people, live in the land, trade and marry together. Just like the world of today; they want Christians to be one with them — no difference. Christians, be careful! The Lord says, "Go out from their midst, and be separate from them" (2 Cor. 6:17). The world says, "We may be one." The Lord says, "Let everyone who names the name of the Lord depart from iniquity" (2 Tim. 2:19).
Hamor and Shechem had to persuade every man in town to accept real pain. What they hold out in this verse is profit.
L. M. GrantThey all saw that circumcision had a religious meaning, so they had no suspicion at all of any hidden plan against them. On top of that, the wealth of Jacob's family would be a welcome addition to the area, and everyone would gain from them (vv. 20-23). These arguments won over the men of the city. They all agreed, and every one of them was circumcised.
Circumcision was never meant to be a trading licence. One writer names what this bargain really sold.
The Bible TreasuryIn crafty malice and greed, Israel's sons give men God's title to own the land. And he who counted that title so worthless that he based his claim on another man's rights would hardly hesitate to trade circumcision away for treasure in the world. Circumcision was the reproach of Christ, separation from the world of the ungodly, the seal of faith, the sign of God's inheritance.
The Shechemites were greedy, but the sons of Jacob were not sincere either. Commentators are blunt that the condition they set was never a genuine invitation.
William KellyThey had not the smallest thought or wish of inviting the Shechemites into the covenant. It was the basest treachery, meant to trap and massacre them. Jacob had nothing to do with the cruel secret. Their pride and revenge ignored God as it did their father. Shechem was guilty of a great wrong; but Dinah too was in fault... The condition was a lying and cowardly pretext to carry out their resentment to the very end. Hamor and Shechem fell into the trap. They had enough influence to persuade all their townsmen to join them in accepting the painful rite, with the unexpected danger it carried.
The men of Shechem asked whether Jacob's livestock would not become theirs. The answer came three days later, and it ran the other way.
G. C. WillisOn the third day, when they were all sore, Jacob's two sons Levi and Simeon boldly attacked the city. They killed all the men and took Dinah out of Shechem's house. They also took all the sheep, cattle and donkeys, and everything in the city and in the field. They took all their money, their children and their wives, even all that was in the house.
- Settle — the trouble began when Jacob settled at Shechem. He needed to judge his own position, not blame what happened there.
- Merge — the offer was to become one people, with no difference left. God's call runs the other way: go out, be separate, depart from iniquity.
- Price — money is the argument that persuaded a whole city. A sign of faith and separation changed hands because it looked profitable.
- Pretence — commentators blame both sides. The Shechemites wanted the wealth, and Jacob's sons never meant the covenant they offered.
- Loss — the men who asked whether Jacob's livestock would be theirs lost their own. What the world hopes to gain from God's people is not what it gets.
And all that went out at the gate of his city hearkened to Hamor and to Shechem his son; and every male was circumcised -- all that went out at the gate of his city.
The men of Shechem heard their prince's proposal and agreed to it. Every male in the city accepted circumcision, the sign of God's covenant. Two questions press here. Why would a whole city accept such a condition? And what did Jacob's sons want from it?
The proposal reached the men of Shechem through their own leaders. It came wrapped in both religion and profit:
L. M. GrantEveryone no doubt recognised that circumcision had a religious meaning. They would not suspect any hidden plan against them at all. On top of that, the wealth of Jacob's family would be a welcome addition to the area. Everyone would benefit from them.
On the other side of the bargain, Jacob's sons were handing over something that was never theirs to trade. The sign they put on the table carried a weight of meaning:
The Bible TreasuryIn crafty malice and greed for gain, Israel's sons give men God's title to possess the land. He counted it so worthless that he based his own claim on another man's rights. So he would hardly hesitate to barter circumcision away for treasure in this world. Yet circumcision was the reproach of Christ, separation from the world of the ungodly, the seal of faith, and the sign of God's inheritance.
No one should read this verse as a mass conversion. The brothers never meant to bring these men into God's covenant:
William KellyNot the smallest thought or wish did they have of inviting the Shechemites into the covenant. It was the basest treachery, meant to trap them and massacre them. Jacob had nothing to do with the cruel secret. Their pride and revenge ignored God just as it ignored their father. Shechem was guilty of a great wrong, but Dinah was at fault too. Hamor and Shechem fell into the trap. They had enough influence to persuade all their townsmen to join them in the painful ritual, and in its unexpected danger.
The irony of the verse is sharp. The uncircumcised city obeyed; the family that held the sign had already given away what it stood for:
J. G. BellettSurely it is rather an uncircumcised Jacob we see here, and not circumcised Shechemites. It is all miserable. Is this a son of Abraham? Is this a saint of God? Is this one of God's strangers in a world that has revolted from Him? This is like the religious energy of Christendom. It has put the name of Christ in the company of the world that is under His judgment. It is as if Israel had agreed with Pharaoh and promised to give the Lord an altar in Egypt. But such altars are no altars.
The terms accepted at the gate aimed at making the two peoples one. One writer hears the same offer in the world today:
G. C. WillisJust like the world of today — they want Christians to be one with them, with no difference. Christians, be careful! The Lord says, "Go out from their midst, and be separate" (2 Corinthians 6:17). The world says, "We may be one." The Lord says, "Let everyone who names the name of the Lord depart from iniquity" (2 Timothy 2:19).
The circumcision of verse 24 opened the way to the slaughter in the next verses. The damage did not stop with Shechem. Yet God can reverse a sentence:
F. B. HoleThe shameful story of Genesis 34 made Jacob "stink among the inhabitants of the land." That was a dreadful position for him, since he was the only man in the land with the true knowledge of God. It also brought judgment on the two who led the violence. Later the tribe of Levi acted in a way that gained a special blessing. In this we see how God can turn what began as a curse into a blessing. The word had been, "I will divide them in Jacob and scatter them in Israel" (49:7). They were divided — but God divided them by calling Levi to special service and scattering that tribe through all the others.
- Persuade — circumcision sounded religious and Jacob's wealth sounded profitable, so no one at the gate suspected a trap.
- Mingle — the world still makes Shechem's offer: be one with us, no difference. God's word answers, "Go out from their midst, and be separate."
- Barter — circumcision was the seal of faith and separation from the ungodly world, and Jacob's sons traded it for gain. What we see is an uncircumcised Jacob, not circumcised Shechemites.
- Reap — the city's obedience opened the door to its massacre. Jacob's name stank in the land, and judgment fell on the two who led the violence.
- Redeem — God turned the curse "I will divide them" into Levi's calling, a blessing scattered through every tribe.
And it came to pass on the third day, when they were sore, that two of the sons of Jacob, Simeon and Levi, Dinah's brethren, took each his sword, and came upon the city boldly, and slew all the males.
Jacob had settled beside a Hivite city and built a house there, and the cost of that choice now arrives with drawn swords. Two of his sons turn a sacred sign into a trap and kill every male in the town, which leaves us asking what God does with such men.
The killing does not begin at verse 25. It begins with a plot of land and a house.
William KellyOne wrong step away from our true position before the Lord leads to many a sin, scandal, and sorrow. That is what we find here, and it came from Jacob buying the land of the Hivite and building himself a house. His stay at Succoth and Shechem covers some ten years.
The condition the brothers set was no invitation into God's covenant. They chose it to leave the men of the city helpless.
William KellyThen Jacob's sons stepped in with a trick: every male must be circumcised. They had not the slightest thought or wish of bringing the men of Shechem into the covenant. It was treachery of the lowest kind, meant to trap them and massacre them. Jacob had nothing to do with the cruel secret. Their pride and revenge ignored God just as it ignored their father.
The third day is not a stray detail. It is the day the men of the city could not fight back.
L. M. GrantThen the cruel treachery of Jacob's sons comes to the surface. Only Simeon and Levi are mentioned here, brothers of Dinah, though Reuben and Judah were also her brothers. The two, however, attack the unarmed city, killing every male while they were still sore from surgery. This came as a complete surprise, and the men had no defence. No men were left to organize a counter attack.
The brothers had an answer ready: their sister's honour. One writer weighs it against what they did.
L. M. GrantJacob's sons, however, only answered defiantly, "Should he treat our sister like a prostitute?" That was not fair-mindedness. Shechem had not dealt with her that way. Even if he had, did that justify Simeon and Levi in killing all the men of that city and plundering their houses? What they did to the city was far worse than Shechem's sin.
No judgment fell at the time. The verdict came at the end of Jacob's life.
F. B. HoleThe anger came to a head in the terrible violence of Simeon and Levi. Jacob never forgot it, and neither did God. At the end of his life Jacob spoke as a prophet about his sons. He foretold the future of the tribes and gave certain blessings. But he condemned these two sons and cursed their anger, as recorded in Genesis 49:5-7.
The sentence was to divide them and scatter them. God carried it out, but on one of the two brothers it fell as a privilege.
F. B. HoleIt is worth noting that later on the tribe of Levi acted in such a way that they gained a special blessing. So we are allowed to see how God can turn what began as a curse into a blessing. The word had been, "I will divide them in Jacob, and scatter them in Israel" (49:7). They were divided. But Levi's division came through a call to special service, which scattered him among all the tribes.
Levi carries a sword a second time, and this time Simeon is not beside him.
C. H. MackintoshIt is true that here too we see him with his sword at his side. But oh, for what a different purpose, and in what a different cause! He is not now killing a man in anger and self-will. He acts in holy jealousy and care for the honour of the Lord God of Israel, and in simple obedience to His command… And Levi is no longer seen "joined" with his brother Simeon. He might join with him in the days of his wickedness for deeds of blood. But here a new scene opens, and so he is seen "joined" with the Lord and His servant Moses, to carry out righteous judgement on idolatry.
Scripture never softens this story, and there is a reason.
C. H. MackintoshHere is a truly humbling view of human nature seen in the light of God's holiness. It is as if the Lord would say to us: Look here! Look at a man dressed in nature's blackest clothing… Look closely, so that you may see what man is when stripped of all the false clothing that ignorance or empty self-righteousness would put on him — and so may know the rich abundance of My grace.
- Settling. The killing grew out of a settled life beside Shechem. One step away from our place before the Lord opens the door to sin, scandal and sorrow.
- Scheming. They used the covenant sign as bait — treachery dressed as religion, with no wish to bring anyone to God.
- Slaying. They struck on the third day, when no man in the city could fight: planned, one-sided killing, not justice for Dinah.
- Sentence. God did not act at once, but Jacob's dying words cursed their anger and decreed they be divided and scattered.
- Salvation. Levi's sword is drawn again in the Lord's cause, and the scattering itself becomes his service — where man is at his blackest, God shows the rich abundance of His grace.
And Hamor and Shechem his son they slew with the edge of the sword; and took Dinah out of Shechem's house; and went out.
Two brothers walk into a city whose men cannot fight back. They kill its ruler and his son. Then they take their sister and go. The rescue is real, but the means are murder — and the rest of Scripture never lets the deed go unanswered.
One writer traces this bloodshed back to a much earlier failure in Jacob's own walk.
F. B. HoleThe whole of Genesis 34 shows the unhappy results that sprang from the lowering of Jacob's separation from the world. Its effects for evil were not seen in Jacob himself but in his family. The tide of evil runs in two broad channels: violence and corruption. The world is just the same today. How often we have to hang our heads in shame and admit the truth. A little living on the border of the world on our part, as Christian parents, has led to sorrow and even disaster in our families.
Jacob's sons had set one condition on the city: every male must be circumcised. That left the men unable to fight. One writer names that condition for what it was.
William KellyNot the smallest thought or wish had they for inviting the Shechemites into the covenant. It was the basest treachery, meant to trap them and slaughter them. Jacob had nothing to do with the cruel secret. Their pride and revenge ignored God as they ignored their father. Shechem was guilty of a great wrong; but Dinah too was at fault. The condition was a lying and cowardly pretext to carry out their resentment to the very end.
Two of Dinah's brothers did this, and the men they killed could not lift a hand.
L. M. GrantOnly Simeon and Levi are mentioned here, brothers of Dinah, though Reuben and Judah were also her brothers. The two attack the unarmed city, killing every male while they were still sore from surgery. Of course this was totally unexpected and the men had no defence. No men were left to organise any counter-attack. Hamor and Shechem also, who had been considerate of Jacob's family, were killed.
The brothers later defended themselves by pointing to their sister's disgrace. That defence does not survive examination.
L. M. GrantThis was not fair-mindedness, for Shechem had not actually dealt that way, and if he had, did that justify Simeon and Levi in killing all the men of that city and plundering their houses? Their dealings with the city were far worse than was Shechem's sin.
Under the appeal to their sister's honour, another writer hears greed.
The Bible TreasurySimeon and Levi say, "Should he treat our sister like a prostitute?" — making her honour cover their covetousness. At least Jacob is honest, for he says, "You have brought trouble on me by making me stink … I shall be destroyed, both I and my household."
Years later, on his deathbed, Jacob cursed the anger of these two sons. He said they would be divided and scattered. One writer notes that the sentence stood, yet God changed what it produced.
F. B. HoleThe shameful story of Genesis 34 caused Jacob "to stink among the inhabitants of the land." That was a dreadful position for him, since he was the only man in the land who truly knew God. It also brought judgment on the two who promoted the violence. In later days the tribe of Levi acted in a way that gained a special blessing. So we are allowed to see how God can turn what was at first a curse into a blessing. The word had been, "I will divide them in Jacob and scatter them in Israel." They were divided. But God did it by calling Levi to special service and scattering him throughout all the tribes.
Levi carries a sword again later in Israel's story. This time the cause is different.
C. H. MackintoshIt is true we see him here again with his sword by his side, but for what a different purpose, and in what a different cause! He is not now killing a man in anger and self-will. He acts in holy care for the honour of the Lord God of Israel, and in simple obedience to His command. He is no longer "joined" with his brother Simeon. In the days of his wickedness he might join him for deeds of blood. But here a new scene opens, and he is "joined" with the Lord and His servant Moses.
- Drift. Jacob's lowered separation from the world set the stage; the evil broke out not in him but in his children.
- Deceit. Jacob's sons offered the sign of God's covenant as bait, not as welcome — a lying pretext to disable a city.
- Disproportion. They avenged a real wrong with a far greater one, and plundered the houses too. Their sister's honour covered their greed.
- Divided. Jacob's dying words cursed their anger. His sentence scattered their descendants through Israel.
- Redeemed. Levi lifted his sword again, this time for God's honour. The scattering then became the tribe's service.