Genesis 32:1–12

Genesis 32:1 · Darby

And Jacob went on his way; and the angels of God met him.

Jacob has left Laban and is heading back to the land God promised him. Ahead of him waits Esau, the brother he ran from; but first, on the road, God's angels meet him.

Grace still following him

Jacob's record up to this point is not impressive. The angels meet him anyway.

"Jacob went on his way, and the angels of God met him." God's grace still follows him, despite everything. "Nothing changes God's affection." Whom He loves, and as He loves, He loves to the end. His love is like Himself, "the same yesterday, today and forever."

Modernised from C. H. MackintoshOriginal wording

Just before this, Jacob had sworn an oath by "the Fear of his father Isaac."

Such was the respect given to parents and ancestors in those far-off days — very good in many ways. But there was the danger that the fear of Isaac, whom he could see, would crowd out the fear of God, whom he could not see. So he received the reminder of the unseen world that we find in the opening verse of Genesis 32.

Modernised from F. B. HoleOriginal wording

Angels — and not more than angels

At Bethel, on the way out, God Himself had spoken to Jacob. On the way back, only His servants appear, and one writer sees a reason for the difference.

Jacob now goes on his way, and angels of God meet him. How ready He is to assure us of His power! He waits only for the right moment to use it on our behalf. It must have reminded him of Bethel, and of the promise there — but there the LORD had appeared to him, even if only in a dream. Here He does not appear. Jacob the outcast and wanderer could have what Jacob returning in wealth and with a crowd could no longer receive. Then it was grace; now it would be fellowship, and for fellowship he was not yet ready.

Modernised from Frederick W. GrantOriginal wording

Mahanaim: two camps

The name Jacob gives the place means "two camps." How Jacob counted those camps shaped what he did next.

It was not God Himself who met him yet, but His angels. They were surely meant to encourage Jacob to keep going all the way back to the place the Lord had for him. Jacob recognized them as "God's host," and named the place "Mahanaim," meaning "two camps." Jacob had not yet learned that he ought to merge his interests with God's, so he thinks of God's "camp" as separate from his own. This has its unhealthy influence on his actions soon after, when he divided his own company into "two bands" (v. 7). How much better it would have been for him if he had prayed the prayer of the Psalmist, "Unite my heart to fear your name" (Psalm 86:11).

Modernised from L. M. GrantOriginal wording

Seeing the host and still being afraid

The sight of God's army did not settle Jacob's nerves.

He learns that Esau was coming to meet him with four hundred men, and he is afraid and greatly distressed. Providences and visions do not take away terror, nor give confidence in God.

Modernised from The Bible TreasuryOriginal wording

The cure is not a better sign but a different response to the danger itself.

God, to comfort and strengthen him, sends an army of His angels to meet him. Yet even after this encouragement from God, unbelief renews Jacob's fear when he faces his brother Esau. Deliverance from danger does not destroy unbelief. You do not escape the difficulties on the path of faith by avoiding them. You must overcome them by the power of God. Jacob had brought these difficulties on himself, because he had not trusted God. He forgot the host of God. Esau no longer held any hatred against his brother, yet his army frightened the weak Jacob.

Modernised from J. N. DarbyOriginal wording

Two hosts around us

A prophet and his servant once faced the same danger and saw two different things.

The servant saw the Syrians and was dismayed; the prophet saw the heavenly armies and was confident. In the same way, when the angels of God met Jacob, he called the name of the place Mahanaim — "two hosts." Danger may indeed be very near, but God is nearer to us than all our enemies. We may well ask ourselves which host we see today. Is it the crowd of those who hate us? Or the company of "ministering spirits sent out to serve for the sake of those who are to inherit salvation" (Hebrews 1:14)?

Modernised from W. W. FeredayOriginal wording

Summary

- Met. The angels come to a man with a poor record. Grace follows Jacob; it does not reward him.

- Measured. Angels appear, but God Himself does not. At Bethel it was grace; now it would be fellowship, and Jacob is not ready for that.

- Mahanaim. "Two camps" — Jacob counts God's host and his own as separate, and soon splits his own people into two bands out of fear.

- Missed. The sight of the angelic army did not steady him; a vision can impress the eye without producing trust in God.

- Mine. Which host am I looking at — the visible threat, or the ministering spirits sent to serve God's heirs?

Genesis 32:2 · Darby

And when Jacob saw them he said, This is the camp of God. And he called the name of that place Mahanaim.

Jacob is on the last stretch of his journey home, and Esau is waiting somewhere ahead. Before he meets his brother, an escort he never asked for meets him. What he sees makes him name the ground. The name he chooses tells us as much about Jacob as about the angels.

The place and its name

The name Jacob gave belongs to a real place on the map.

The spot east of the Jordan where Jacob met "the angels of God." He exclaimed "This is God's host," and named the place Mahanaim, "two hosts or camps." Scripture places it on the border of both Gad and Manasseh, which connects it with the brook Jabbok.

Modernised from Morrish Bible DictionaryOriginal wording

A welcome, not a ladder

Earlier, at Bethel, there was a ladder with angels going up and down it. Here the picture changes.

This was holy ground. God had fulfilled the promises of Genesis 28 and kept the pledges of Bethel. So we have no ladder here. His watchful care through angels had finished its work. He had kept Jacob in the far country and brought him home to his own land. The ladder may therefore come down. Instead of angels going up and down between heaven and Jacob, angels meet him. They stand before him, just to greet him, or to welcome him on his return.

Modernised from J. G. BellettOriginal wording

Why "two"?

Commentators differ on what the second camp is. Some take it as the sheer size of the angelic company:

Later, the angels of God met Jacob, and he called the name of the place Mahanaim, meaning two hosts or camps. This is interesting. It shows how many angels may take part in one particular work of great size.

Modernised from A. J. PollockOriginal wording

Another writer sees God's readiness to help, and a second camp that is Jacob's own:

How ready God is to assure us of His power, waiting only for the right moment to put it forth on our behalf!... Jacob calls the place "Mahanaim" — that is, "two hosts," or "camps." Here he must have counted in his own... How telling that in a little while we find him dividing this host of his into two camps! He says, "If Esau comes to the one camp and attacks it, then the camp that is left will escape." Such is our strength when we build on it, though perhaps we would gladly link God's power with it. In the time of need, our own — what is it? and God's — where shall we find it?

Modernised from Frederick W. GrantOriginal wording

A divided heart makes divided camps

If God's camp and Jacob's camp stay separate in his mind, the split spreads.

Jacob had not yet learned to merge his interests with God's, so he treats God's "camp" as separate from his. This has its unhealthy influence on his actions soon after, when he divided his own company into "two camps" (v. 7). How much better if he had prayed the Psalmist's prayer: "Unite my heart to fear your name" (Psalm 86:11). We only resort to divisions among God's people because our hearts are not wholly devoted to Him.

Modernised from L. M. GrantOriginal wording

Seeing angels is not the same as trusting God

The angels were a welcome. Jacob's answer was not.

This was music for Jacob, and Jacob should have danced. He should have been in triumph before the battle was even fought... If the hosts of heaven waited on him like this, what had he to fear from the hosts of Esau? "If God is for us, who can be against us?" But it was not so with him. He mourns rather than dances at this music. He trembles, and prays, and calculates.

Modernised from J. G. BellettOriginal wording

Another writer records what came next.

Jacob learns that Esau was coming to meet him with four hundred men, and he is afraid and greatly distressed. Providences and visions do not take away terror, nor give confidence in God.

Modernised from The Bible TreasuryOriginal wording

The same two hosts today

One writer sets Mahanaim beside Dothan, where a servant and a prophet faced the same danger and saw different things.

There were two hosts around Dothan that day. The servant saw the Syrians and lost heart; the prophet saw the heavenly armies and was confident. In the same way, when the angels of God met Jacob, he called the name of the place Mahanaim — "two hosts."... Danger may be very near, but God is nearer to us than all our enemies. We may well ask ourselves: which host do we see today? Is it the crowd of those who hate us, or the company of "ministering spirits sent out to serve for the sake of those who are to inherit salvation" (Hebrews 1:14)?

Modernised from W. W. FeredayOriginal wording

Summary

- Two camps named. Mahanaim means "two hosts." Jacob saw God's camp and named the ground for it, east of the Jordan near the Jabbok.

- Two camps welcomed. No ladder now. The angels stand still and greet him — God's own welcome home from the far country.

- Two camps counted separately. Jacob keeps God's camp beside his own instead of joined to it. Commentators differ: some read the "two" as the size of the angel army, others as God's host plus Jacob's.

- Two camps multiplied. A heart divided from God soon divides everything else: a few verses later Jacob splits his people into two camps, hoping one may escape.

- Two camps still. Mahanaim and Dothan set the same choice before us. Look at the crowd that threatens, or at the ministering spirits sent out to serve the heirs of salvation.

Genesis 32:3 · Darby

And Jacob sent messengers before his face to Esau his brother, into the land of Seir, the fields of Edom.

Jacob is on his way home, and the one obstacle he cannot avoid is the brother he wronged. God has just met him with a host of angels — and the very next thing Jacob does is send out a delegation of his own.

God's Messengers and Jacob's

The word for "messengers" here is the same word used for angels. The context decides which one is meant.

The Hebrew word usually used for angel, and the matching Greek word in the New Testament, simply mean "a messenger." Our word "angel" comes from that Greek word, angelos. Sometimes the word means an ordinary human messenger, as for example when "Jacob sent messengers before him." (Gen. 32:3).

Modernised from A. J. PollockOriginal wording

Heaven's messengers had just met him. He answers by sending out his own.

"And Jacob went on his way, and the angels of God met him." Still God's grace follows him, despite everything. "Nothing changes God's affection." Whom He loves, and as He loves, He loves to the end… But his actions here show how little effect "God's host" had upon Jacob. "And Jacob sent messengers before him to Esau his brother in the land of Seir, the country of Edom." He feels uneasy about Esau, and he has reason to. He had treated him badly, and his conscience was not at ease. But instead of casting himself fully on God, he goes back to his usual planning to head off Esau's anger. He tries to manage Esau, instead of leaning on God.

Modernised from C. H. MackintoshOriginal wording

Why Esau Surfaces Now

Watch the timing of this message.

It is remarkable too that it is just when he has met God's messengers that he sends his own to Seir to Esau. But God and Esau are evidently mixed up in his mind all through. This is not strange. It is bound to happen. Whatever brings God back to mind also brings back the person we have sinned against and never put things right with — maybe with no chance now of putting them right.

Modernised from Frederick William GrantOriginal wording

The Response Faith Would Have Given

Seir was Esau's country, and Jacob sends to it like a man expecting trouble. He had every reason to travel differently.

This was "piping" to Jacob, and Jacob ought to have "danced." He should have breathed an exulting spirit. He should have been in triumph already, before the fighting began, and even before the armies lined up… If the hosts of heaven waited on him like this, what had he to fear from the hosts of Esau? "If God is for us, who can be against us?" But this was not so with him. He laments, rather than dances, at this piping. He trembles, and prays, and calculates. He marshals his forces, as though the battle were his. This is all religious, but it is all unbelief too.

Modernised from J. G. BellettOriginal wording

Careful Words, Uneasy Heart

The instructions he gives the messengers reveal what is really driving him.

Jacob was migrating with wives, children, servants and many animals, so he formed a large band. He now became aware that there was a second band, standing on his behalf. Even this did not free him from the fear of Esau, and his approach to him, as given in verses 3-5, though very diplomatic, bears traces of the working of a bad conscience.

Modernised from F. B. HoleOriginal wording

The flattering titles in the message are the giveaway — and worth welcoming, since a working conscience is a mercy.

He sends messengers to Esau, who are to say, "My lord Esau; your servant Jacob says," and so on. What a message to his brother! Esau, "my lord"; and Jacob "your servant." Sin always brings its fruit, and wrong its repayment. The man is perfectly aware of the harm he has done to Esau… It is a fine thing when the conscience begins to work. Friend, has your conscience begun to work before God about the evil of your life?

Modernised from W. T. P. WolstonOriginal wording

God's Faithfulness, Not Jacob's

Jacob had already watched God deal with Laban.

Again he turns to his own schemes. He divides the people and the livestock into two companies, saying, If Esau comes to the one and strikes it, then the other will escape. How short and sad man's prudence is! God stopped Laban when he meant harm, and made him leave with a kiss all round. Could He not bring Esau to Jacob with an embrace, and even with tears? The Holy Spirit records Jacob's state here for our lasting profit: do not be anxious about tomorrow, but cast everything on the God of all grace, because He cares for us. Jacob had a bad conscience as yet, and had never faced it all out in God's presence. Yet God was faithful to him, not he to God.

Modernised from William KellyOriginal wording

Scripture records the failure for a reason.

God gives us the history of Jacob in such full detail in order to show how His grace could meet a man of that kind, rise above all his failures, and bless him.

Modernised from W. T. P. WolstonOriginal wording

Summary

- Escort. God's messengers met Jacob first. Grace arrives before the crisis does.

- Errand. Jacob answers heaven's messengers by sending his own to Seir. He manages Esau instead of leaning on God.

- Conscience. Nearness to God brings back the memory of the person we wronged. "My lord" and "your servant" expose guilt that is not yet healed.

- Unbelief. Heaven's armies surround him, yet he trembles, calculates and lines up his forces. That is religious activity, but it is still unbelief.

- Faithfulness. The God who turned Laban aside could turn Esau; Jacob was not faithful to God, but God stayed faithful to Jacob.

Genesis 32:4 · Darby

And he commanded them, saying, Thus shall ye speak to my lord, to Esau Thy servant Jacob speaks thus -- With Laban have I sojourned and tarried until now;

Jacob is heading home to Canaan, and the angels of God have just met him at Mahanaim. His next move is not worship but strategy. He sends a message ahead to the brother he wronged, and he speaks to him like a subject addressing a king.

Where the message went

Seir and Edom are not two different destinations. The names belong to the same rugged country that Esau's family made their own:

The early name of the long range of mountains, extending from about eight miles south of the Salt Sea to near the Gulf of Akaba. It is also called "the land of Seir." It was occupied at first by the Horites, and afterwards by the descendants of Esau, and acquired the name of EDOM.

Modernised from Morrish Bible DictionaryOriginal wording

From God's camp to a message of fear

What Jacob did after the angels met him shows how little that sight steadied him:

"Jacob went on his way, and the angels of God met him." Still God's grace follows him, despite everything. "Nothing changes God's affection." Whom He loves, and as He loves, He loves to the end… It is clear that he feels uneasy about Esau, and with good reason. He had treated him badly, and his conscience was not at ease. But he does not throw himself fully on God. He goes back to his usual planning, to head off Esau's anger. He tries to manage Esau, instead of leaning on God.

Modernised from C. H. MackintoshOriginal wording

Why God and Esau came to mind together

God's messengers met him, and at once he sent messengers of his own. One writer explains why the two go together:

It is remarkable too that just when he has met God's messengers, he sends his own to Esau. But all the way through, God and Esau are mixed together in his mind. This is not strange but unavoidable. Whatever brings God back to our souls also brings back the one we have sinned against — sinned without making it right, and perhaps with no way to make it right.

Modernised from Frederick W. GrantOriginal wording

"My lord" and "your servant"

The wording of the message is the point. Jacob is speaking to his own brother, yet he calls him lord and calls himself a servant:

All this shows a soul very much off its centre in God. "My lord," and "your servant," is not the language of a brother, or of someone standing in the conscious dignity of God's presence. But it was the language of Jacob — and of Jacob with a bad conscience.

Modernised from C. H. MackintoshOriginal wording

A guilty conscience produced the phrase, and a stirred conscience is not itself a bad thing:

Sin always brings its fruit, and wrong its payback. The man is fully aware of the harm he has done to Esau. He knows that perfectly well, and now his conscience begins to work. It is a fine thing when the conscience begins to work. Friend, has your conscience begun to work before God about the evil of your life?

Modernised from W. T. P. WolstonOriginal wording

The inventory he leaned on

The message goes on to list livestock and servants — Jacob's own "camp," set beside the camp of God he had just named:

"This is God's host," he says, and he calls the place "Mahanaim" — that is, "two hosts," or "camps." Here he must have been counting in his own, and at once he dwells on it in his message to Esau… How telling that a little later he divides this host of his into two camps! He says, "If Esau comes to the one camp and attacks it, then the camp that is left will escape." Such is our strength when we build on it.

Modernised from Frederick W. GrantOriginal wording

What faith would have done instead

Jacob already had God's promise and God's host behind him. Fear of Esau's men outweighed both:

Instead of remembering God's word, "I will be with you," and that God's host had met him, he turns back to his own schemes. He wants to "find favor in the sight of" and to "appease" "my lord Esau." To faith, what would it matter if Esau had four thousand men instead of four hundred? "If God is for us, who can be against us?" Besides, what right or claim had Esau? But we put ourselves under the men of the world when we use worldly, deceitful ways in dealing with them.

Modernised from The Christian's FriendOriginal wording

Summary

- Guilt — Jacob had wronged Esau and never put it right. Remembering God brought back the man he had sinned against.

- Grace — God saved him from Laban and met him with angels on the road. His affection does not change, and He loves to the end.

- Language — "my lord," "your servant" is not how a brother speaks; it is how a bad conscience speaks.

- Leaning — he counted his own camp and tried to manage Esau instead of leaning on God. Then fear made him split that camp in two.

- Loss — God's promise, "I will be with you," made four hundred men beside the point. Worldly ways put us under the world.

Genesis 32:5 · Darby

and I have oxen, and asses, sheep, and bondmen, and bondwomen; and I have sent to tell my lord, that I may find favour in thine eyes.

Jacob is heading home, and the one man he must pass is the brother he wronged. The message he sends ahead lists his wealth, calls Esau his lord, and asks for favour — and commentators read every phrase as a window into his heart.

The words of a bad conscience

The wording Jacob chooses is not how brothers speak to each other. He puts Esau above himself and takes the place of a servant. Writers trace this to the state of his soul, not to good manners.

All this shows a soul very much off its centre in God. "My lord" and "your servant" is not the language of a brother, or of someone with the conscious dignity of God's presence. But it was Jacob's language — and Jacob with a bad conscience.

Modernised from C. H. MackintoshOriginal wording

Yet a conscience at work is not all loss.

Sin always brings its fruit, and wrong its payment. The man is fully aware of the harm he has done to Esau. Now his conscience begins to work. It is a fine thing when the conscience begins to work. Friend, has your conscience begun to work before God about the evil of your life?

Modernised from W. T. P. WolstonOriginal wording

Counting his own camp

Jacob had just seen the angels of God and named the place Mahanaim, "two camps." What he sends Esau is a count of his own camp.

"This is God's camp," he says; and he calls the place "Mahanaim" — that is, "two camps." Here he must have counted in his own, and so we find him dwelling on it at once in his message to Esau: "I have oxen, donkeys, flocks, male servants, and female servants. I have sent to tell my lord, in order that I may find favor in your sight." How telling that a little later we find him dividing this camp of his into two, saying, "If Esau comes to the one camp and attacks it, then the other camp which is left will escape"! Such is our strength when we build on it. In the time of need, our own — what is it? And God's — where shall we find it?

Modernised from Frederick W. GrantOriginal wording

Favour sought from the wrong hand

The list of animals and servants tells Esau that Jacob needs nothing from him. The closing words then ask for favour — and the news that comes back undoes him.

We see the lesson of faith poorly learned. Again he falls back on his plans, and sends messengers to his brother in Seir, with words skilfully framed to win over "my lord Esau" and "your servant Jacob." Esau was not to fear that Jacob needed to take anything from a brother or a father. He had plenty of resources of his own, and only wanted favour in his sight. But no answer came back from Esau, and that filled Jacob with alarm and distress. His fear grew when the messengers told him that Esau was coming to meet him with four hundred men. Why, except to overwhelm him? It was unbelief of Him who cannot forget His promise, and who can control and turn even the most hostile spirit.

Modernised from William KellyOriginal wording

Praying and planning

This message is one of Jacob's moves; he will also pray. Mackintosh says the two habits cannot share one heart.

Jacob's first thought was always a plan, and in this we have a true picture of the poor human heart. True, he turns to God after making his plan, and cries to Him for deliverance; but as soon as he stops praying he takes up the planning again. Now praying and planning will never do together. If I plan, I am leaning more or less on my plan; but when I pray, I should lean on God alone. So the two are completely incompatible; in effect they destroy each other.

Modernised from C. H. MackintoshOriginal wording

What met him instead

The story's ending shows how little the careful message achieved.

Just see how useless Jacob's plans were to buy a pardon with a gift! Yet he perhaps claims the credit for the happy outcome. Jacob said, "I will appease him with a present" … "I have sent to tell my lord, in order that I may find favor in your sight." But Esau had not even seen the female servants and male servants, or flocks, donkeys and oxen, until he had wept on his brother's neck. Then "he lifted up his eyes and saw the women and children, and said, Who are these?" As for the droves, he did not know what they meant until Jacob told him. He took them not as the price of pardon, but as Jacob's blessing.

Modernised from The Bible TreasuryOriginal wording

Summary

- Conscience — "my lord" and "your servant" is not how a brother speaks. It is the language of a man whose soul is off its centre in God, with an old wrong catching up with him.

- Camps — Jacob named one place "two camps" after seeing God's host. His list of oxen, donkeys, flocks and servants shows which camp he counted on.

- Cracks — he soon split that strength in two, hoping half would escape. Our own resources come to nothing in the hour of need.

- Cry — he prays, then goes straight back to scheming. You cannot lean on a plan and lean on God at the same time.

- Coming — Esau wept on his neck before he saw a single animal. The favour Jacob worked so hard to buy was never for sale.

Genesis 32:6 · Darby

And the messengers returned to Jacob, saying, We came to thy brother, to Esau; and he also is coming to meet thee, and four hundred men with him.

Twenty years earlier Jacob wronged his brother Esau. Now he sends a humble message ahead to him, and the reply that comes back is not really a reply at all.

A report with no answer in it

The messengers carried a message but brought none home. What frightened Jacob was as much the silence as the size of the company.

We see the lesson of faith only feebly learnt. Again he falls back on his plans. He sends messengers to his brother in Seir, with words carefully framed to win over "my lord Esau" from "your servant Jacob." But no answer came back from Esau, and that filled Jacob with alarm and distress. It was worse still when the messengers told him that Esau was coming with four hundred men. Why, except to overwhelm him? It was unbelief of the One who cannot forget His promise, but can control and turn even the most hostile spirit.

Modernised from William KellyOriginal wording

What the messengers left out mattered as much as what they said.

The messengers bring back word that Esau is coming with four hundred men to meet Jacob (v.6). They say nothing about whether Esau was glad to hear of Jacob or not; and Jacob is thrown into a panic.

Modernised from Leslie M. GrantOriginal wording

Twenty years of unjudged sin

The dread had a second source, inside Jacob himself.

For twenty years we have no record that Jacob had judged himself, or humbled himself before God, over his sin against Esau. So when the report of Esau's approach came, it struck his conscience, and he was "greatly afraid and distressed." This was a searching moment. God knew how to reach the sore spot. It put Jacob thoroughly to the test, and was enough to show him to himself and to others.

Modernised from H H SnellOriginal wording

There is a reason a fresh sense of God revives an old, unsettled wrong.

It is striking that he sends his own messengers to Esau in Seir just after meeting God's messengers. God and Esau run together in his mind all through. That is not strange. It had to be so. Whatever brings God back to our souls also brings back the person we wronged — wronged without putting it right, and perhaps with no way now to put it right.

Modernised from Frederick W GrantOriginal wording

The forgotten host

God's messengers had met Jacob just before this. The four hundred cancelled them out in his reckoning.

This was music played for Jacob, and Jacob should have danced. He should have breathed a triumphant spirit. He should have been in triumph before any fighting started, before the armies even lined up. If the hosts of heaven were waiting on him like this, what did he have to fear from the hosts of Esau? "If God is for us, who can be against us?" But this was not how it was with him. He mourns instead of dancing to this music. He trembles, and prays, and calculates. He marshals his forces, as if the battle were his.

Modernised from J. G. BellettOriginal wording

Planning first, praying second

Jacob's first move after the news was not prayer.

But what does he do first? Does he throw himself on God at once? No; he starts to manage… Jacob's first thought was always a plan, and in this we have a true picture of the poor human heart. True, he turns to God after making his plan, and cries to Him for deliverance; but the moment he stops praying, he goes back to planning. Now praying and planning will never work together. If I plan, I am leaning to some degree on my plan; but when I pray, I should lean on God alone.

Modernised from C. H. MackintoshOriginal wording

A fear without a cause

The man Jacob was bracing himself against had already stopped being an enemy.

The host of God was forgotten; and the army of Esau, who no longer held any hatred in his heart against his brother, frightened the feeble Jacob. He could then use every kind of means to soothe the anger of his brother, which he assumed and dreaded. He sends flock after flock across; and this does more to show the state of Jacob's heart than to change Esau's.

Modernised from J. N. DarbyOriginal wording

This story also speaks to anyone facing trouble they brought on themselves.

Sometimes our own wrongdoing has landed us in the trouble we face, and we rightly dread what comes next. Even that we can take to God, once we have confessed our sin. We can cast all the worry of it on Him. Jacob and Esau show how God can and will turn dreaded events into blessing, when we wait on Him in brokenness.

Modernised from E. J. ThomasOriginal wording

Summary

- Silence. The report said nothing about Esau's heart, so Jacob's fear filled the gap.

- Conscience. Twenty years without self-judgment left a sore spot, and God knew where to press.

- Amnesia. Jacob forgot the host of angels the moment he heard of a human army.

- Order. He planned, then prayed, then planned again — and leaning on a plan is not leaning on God.

- Groundless. The brother he tried to buy off no longer hated him, and dread taken to God turns into blessing.

Genesis 32:7 · Darby

Then Jacob was greatly afraid, and was distressed; and he divided the people that were with him, and the sheep and the cattle and the camels, into two troops.

Jacob is on his way home after twenty years away. Word comes back that the brother he cheated is riding toward him with four hundred men. He has just seen the angels of God, and he still reaches first for a plan.

A Debt That Was Never Settled

The fear in this verse did not begin with the messengers' report. It began years earlier, with a wrong Jacob had never dealt with before God.

All through those years we have no record that Jacob judged himself, or humbled himself before God, about his sin against Esau. So the report of Esau's approach struck his conscience, and he was "greatly afraid and distressed." This was a searching moment. God knew how to reach the sore spot. It put Jacob fully to the test and showed him what he was, to himself and to others.

Modernised from H. H. SnellOriginal wording

Notice what Jacob assumes. The report says only that Esau is coming; Jacob supplies the motive himself.

The news that Esau was coming to meet him with four hundred men awoke his sharpest fears. He had seen the band of angels. Even so, his working conscience made him assume at once that Esau was on his way to take revenge.

Modernised from F. B. HoleOriginal wording

Two Camps, and the Wrong Two

Jacob's own name for an earlier place comes back on him here.

"This is God's host," he says. He calls the place "Mahanaim" — that is, "two hosts," or "camps." He must have counted his own company in as the second one, and in his message to Esau he dwells on it at once... How telling that in a very little while he divides this host of his into two camps! Such is our strength when we build on it, even though we would like to link God's power with it. In the hour of need, our own — what is it? And God's — where shall we find it?

Modernised from Frederick W. GrantOriginal wording

Praying and Planning

Jacob does pray. But the plan comes first, and it comes back again afterwards.

But what does he do first? Does he at once cast himself on God? No; he begins to manage... Jacob's first thought was always a plan, and in this we have a true picture of the poor human heart. True, he turns to God after he makes his plan, and cries to Him for deliverance. But as soon as he stops praying, he takes up the planning again. Now, praying and planning will never work together. If I plan, I am leaning more or less on my plan; but when I pray, I should lean on God alone... It is not asking God to bless my means; it is asking Him to do it all Himself.

Modernised from C. H. MackintoshOriginal wording

Sacrificing Half to Save Half

Jacob is willing to write off half of everything he has.

He is so frightened that he does not first appeal to the Lord. Instead he divides his company into two bands, thinking one band may escape if Esau attacks the first. Of course such human reasoning was not God's leading. God does not divide His saints to sacrifice one part of them for the protection of the other. He loves all His saints, and will not sacrifice any of them to the enemy.

Modernised from L. M. GrantOriginal wording

Afraid of a Man Who Meant No Harm

Jacob's terror had nothing behind it.

You do not get rid of the difficulties on the path of faith by trying to avoid them. You must overcome them by the power of God. Jacob had brought these difficulties on himself, because he had not trusted God. Jacob forgot the host of God. Esau no longer held any hatred in his heart against his brother, but his army frightened the feeble Jacob.

Modernised from J. N. DarbyOriginal wording

Jacob had just watched God handle Laban for him.

How short and sad man's own planning is! God stopped Laban's hostile plans and made him leave with a kiss all round. Could He not bring Esau to Jacob with an embrace, and with tears too? The Holy Spirit records Jacob's state here for lasting profit. We are not to be anxious about tomorrow. We are to cast everything on the God of all grace, because He cares for us. Yet God was faithful to him, though he was not faithful to God.

Modernised from William KellyOriginal wording

When Distress Is a Kindness

Not every commentator treats this fear as only a failure.

If your conscience is working before God, and you are greatly afraid and distressed, all I can say to you is that I am thankful. Better to be in that state now, with your conscience at work and in distress about your sins. Far worse to wake up in eternity and find that your whole life has been one huge mistake.

Modernised from W. T. P. WolstonOriginal wording

Summary

- Conscience. Twenty years of silence did not erase the wrong. The news about Esau reached the one spot Jacob had never brought to God.

- Forgotten. He had just named a place "two camps" after seeing God's angels. Then he made two camps of his own and trusted those instead.

- Divided. His scheme meant sacrificing half his household to save the other half; God does not deal with His people that way.

- Groundless. Esau's heart already held no hatred. Unbelief manufactured the whole terror.

- Faithful. God stayed faithful to the man who was not faithful to Him. That is why the story stands written: so we cast everything on Him, because He cares for us.

Genesis 32:8 · Darby

And he said, If Esau come to the one troop and smite it, then the other troop which is left shall escape.

Jacob has just heard that Esau is coming toward him with four hundred men. He answers by splitting everything he owns into two camps, hoping half will survive. This verse is his reasoning out loud, and commentators treat it as a study in fear that acts before faith does.

Fear after the angels

God had just met Jacob with a company of angels on the road. It made no difference to his nerves.

The vision of two bands of angels did not deliver Jacob from fear for himself and his two bands. He was not at ease with God, though a believer. All that hindered communion was not yet judged; and so came his utter dread of Esau. He had no idea that Esau's feelings toward him had changed.

Modernised from William KellyOriginal wording

The dread had an older root than Esau's four hundred men.

Despite the host of God, he is greatly afraid and distressed when the news about Esau reaches him. His guilt, half forgotten, stings him into fear. It brings his soul into bondage before God.

Modernised from The Bible TreasuryOriginal wording

Two camps of the wrong kind

The place where the angels met him he named Mahanaim — "two camps." A few verses later he has made two camps of his own.

He called that place Mahanaim — two hosts — God's host and his host. If God is there, so is Jacob. But when the day of trial comes, God vanishes from his thoughts and Jacob alone remains. He divides the people with him, and the flocks, and herds, and the camels, into two bands, and they fill the whole field of his vision.

Modernised from The Bible TreasuryOriginal wording

What is that strength worth when the test comes?

Such is our strength when we build on it, though perhaps we would like to link God's power with it. In the time of need, our own — what is it? And God's — where shall we find it?

Modernised from Frederick W. GrantOriginal wording

Praying and planning

The order of Jacob's actions matters.

But what does he first do? Does he at once cast himself upon God? No; he begins to manage... Jacob's first thought was always a plan, and in this we have a true picture of the poor human heart. True, he turns to God after he makes his plan, and cries to Him for deliverance; but as soon as he stops praying he takes up the planning again. Now, praying and planning will never do together. If I plan, I am leaning more or less on my plan; but when I pray, I should lean only upon God. So the two things are completely incompatible; in effect they destroy each other.

Modernised from C. H. MackintoshOriginal wording

A plan God never needed

The plan was also unnecessary. God had already dealt with Laban.

Again he turns to his devices, dividing the people and the stock into two companies, saying that if Esau comes to the one and attacks it, the other will escape. How short and sad is man's prudence! He who stopped Laban's hostile intentions and made him leave with a kiss all round — could He not bring Esau to Jacob with an embrace, and not without tears? The Holy Spirit records his state here for lasting profit: that we should not be anxious about tomorrow, but cast everything on the God of all grace, because He cares for us... Yet God was faithful to him, not he to God.

Modernised from William KellyOriginal wording

Half the household written off

Jacob's arithmetic gives up one half to save the other.

God does not divide His saints to sacrifice one part of them for the protection of the other. He loves all His saints, and has no intention of sacrificing any of them to the enemy. But what about ourselves when trouble of any kind threatens us? Every believer surely knows that our only true resource is in the Lord. Yet our first impulse is to try something to relieve us, instead of going first to the One who can really help.

Modernised from L. M. GrantOriginal wording

The mixture we must judge

The same trouble runs through our own day.

The trouble today is that people — even Christians — put policy side by side with faith. A godly young man once said, "Policy I hate; but faithfulness to God I love." ... God looks for this: that we be anxious for nothing, pray about everything, and exercise faith in our gracious God who raised up Christ from among the dead. He also looks for us to have no confidence in the flesh — in its ability, resources, or righteousness.

Modernised from H. H. SnellOriginal wording

Summary

- Two camps. Jacob named a place after God's host, then made two hosts of his own. The moment he counted his own strength as a second camp, God's camp dropped out of view.

- Bad conscience. Esau's approach only exposed an old wrong never judged before God. Angels on the road could not calm a heart that was not at ease with Him.

- Plan then pray. His first thought was a plan, his second a prayer. Commentators press the point: leaning on a plan and leaning on God cancel each other out.

- Needless. The God who had already turned Laban aside could bring Esau to an embrace. Jacob guarded himself against a danger that was no longer there.

- Policy or faith. The scheme wrote off half the household as an acceptable loss. God divides no part of His people to save another. Scripture tells us to judge this mixture of faith and scheming in ourselves.

Genesis 32:9 · Darby

And Jacob said, God of my father Abraham, and God of my father Isaac, Jehovah, who saidst unto me Return into thy country and to thy kindred, and I will do thee good,

Esau is coming with four hundred men, and Jacob has just split his camp into two bands. Now he prays, quoting God's own command back to Him — real faith, or one more move in his plan?

Prayer that comes after the plan

Jacob makes his plan first, then prays. One writer says the two cannot live together.

True, he turns to God after he makes his plan, and cries to Him for deliverance. But as soon as he stops praying, he goes back to planning. Praying and planning will never work together. If I plan, I am leaning more or less on my plan; but when I pray, I should lean only on God. So the two things are incompatible; they destroy each other. When my eye is full of my own management of things, I am not ready to see God acting for me. Then prayer is not the voice of my need. It becomes a mere superstitious ritual, or a request that God would bless my plans. I should not be asking God to bless my methods, but asking Him to do it all Himself.

Modernised from C. H. MackintoshOriginal wording

The ground he pleads

Jacob does not ask on the strength of his own record. He goes back to the command that sent him home. (Jehovah, in the quote below, is the name the verse gives as "the LORD".)

He reminds Jehovah, the God of his fathers Abraham and Isaac, that he was returning to his country and family at God's own command. He owns that he is unworthy of the least of all His mercies and of all His truth... We can easily see that it was faith, but as yet mixed with human schemes.

Modernised from William KellyOriginal wording

One writer turns this into a pattern anyone can copy.

He told God that He Himself had told him to return home, and had promised to do him good... If you plead God's promises, and confess you are not worthy, but only a lost sinner, He will hear your prayer.

Modernised from G. C. WillisOriginal wording

"God of my father Abraham" — but not yet "my God"

At Bethel, Jacob had vowed to take the LORD as his own God. Here he names God twice as his father's God, and once as the LORD who spoke to him. One writer sees that vow still unpaid.

It is all Jacob here, and not Jehovah; Jehovah's glory set aside and only Jacob's blessing thought of... I, I, I, fills the scene, and is the whole subject of his prayer. So in this hour of trial he fails to keep his vow. He owns Jehovah only as the God of his father Abraham, the God of his father Isaac, the Jehovah who spoke to him — but not as his own God.

Modernised from The Bible TreasuryOriginal wording

Another writer presses the danger on anyone who leans on a godly family.

He was trying to draw on the piety of his father and grandfather. He thought the godly lives of his forefathers would add weight to his prayer. What a serious mistake! Every man must stand on his own responsibility before God. Your mother's prayers will not do you the slightest good, unconverted prodigal, unless you trust the Lord Jesus for yourself.

Modernised from A. J. PollockOriginal wording

Growth, but not full trust

Still, this is not the Jacob of Bethel. The man who once bargained now opens with God's promise and closes with his own unworthiness.

But where was Jacob's faith to be sure that God would deal well with him in his own land? He should have had perfect confidence that God would do this, because God said He would. Still, he has learned more than he had when he made his vow at Bethel. He had thought then that he would prove fully worthy of whatever blessing God would give him. Now he confesses, "I am not worthy of the least of all the mercies and all the truth which You have shown Your servant." At least he is giving up the self-confidence he showed before. But he has not yet learned to have total confidence in the living God.

Modernised from L. M. GrantOriginal wording

Why the answer came through wrestling

Commentators differ on how much faith this prayer holds. Some find almost none in it. Others say Jacob was right to make the God of Abraham and Isaac his refuge. They agree the answer had to wait until Jacob's own resources were gone.

He was greatly troubled, full of fear, and rightly enough made the God of Abraham and of Isaac his refuge. His prayer, as recorded in Genesis 32, was humble, earnest, and pleading. But along with it there was some reckoning on his own policy... So God had to deal sharply with His servant before answering his prayer. That way Jacob would give the glory to the One who alone deserved it.

Modernised from H. H. SnellOriginal wording

Summary

- Plan — Jacob's first move was to manage the danger himself, not to seek God. Praying and planning cancel each other out, because a plan gives you something else to lean on.

- Plead — the ground he takes is right. He pleads God's command to return and God's promise to do him good, and claims nothing for himself.

- Personal — he calls God his father's God, not yet his own God. The vow made at Bethel is still unpaid, and no one else's faith will stand in for yours.

- Progress — "I am not worthy" is real growth in the man who once bargained at Bethel. Full confidence in God is still missing.

- Prevail — he still leaned on his own policy while he prayed. So God had to break him before answering, and the glory went where it belonged.

Genesis 32:10 · Darby

-- I am too small for all the loving-kindness and all the faithfulness that thou hast shewn unto thy servant; for with my staff I passed over this Jordan, and now I am become two troops.

Twenty years after fleeing home, Jacob is back at the border, and Esau is marching toward him with four hundred men. He prays, and this verse is not a request but a confession: he weighs his life between a walking stick and two companies, and says he has earned neither.

The writers below quote an older translation. Where they say "mercies and truth" and "two bands," the ESV says "steadfast love and faithfulness" and "two camps."

The first prayer on record

Jacob has heard God speak before. Here we finally hear Jacob.

God had stepped in before, and Jacob had made a vow, but this is the first prayer of his that Scripture records. It does not have the closeness to God and the prayer for others that marked Abraham in Genesis 18. It was simply a plea to be kept safe, while acknowledging God's mercies to him in the past. Yet notice how rightly he took a low place, though not as low as Abraham, who said, "I … am but dust and ashes" (18:27). Jacob says, "I am not worthy of the least of all Your mercies," which was true, though it did not go far enough. In every age, the closer a person comes to God, the deeper their sense of unworthiness and nothingness grows.

Modernised from F. B. HoleOriginal wording

Prayer after the plan

The order of the chapter matters. Jacob divides his camp first, and only then turns to God.

Jacob's first thought was always a plan, and in this we have a true picture of the poor human heart. True, he turns to God after he makes his plan, and cries to Him for deliverance. But as soon as he stops praying, he goes back to planning. Now, praying and planning will never do together. If I plan, I am leaning more or less on my plan; but when I pray, I should lean only on God. So the two things are completely incompatible; in effect they destroy each other.

Modernised from C. H. MackintoshOriginal wording

From a bargain to a confession

Years earlier at Bethel, Jacob made a vow. What he says now shows how much has changed.

He has learned more than he had when he made his vow at Bethel. He had thought then that he would prove fully worthy of whatever blessing God would give him. Now he confesses, "I am not worthy of the least of all the mercies and all the truth which You have shown Your servant" (v.10). At least he is giving up the self-confidence he showed before. But he has not yet learned to trust the living God completely.

Modernised from L. M. GrantOriginal wording

The staff and the two companies

The two halves of the verse are the two ends of twenty years, and the second half carries its own danger.

He is on his way back to Canaan, but it is a different Jacob and a different journey. He was an empty Jacob at Bethel; he is a full Jacob at Peniel. He has become two bands. Flocks and herds and servants and wives and children tell of his prosperity. Twenty years before he had been on that road, friendless and alone, with a staff in his hand. Now we see him surrounded by all this. He has become a rich man. He has a stake in the world. He has something to lose.

Modernised from J. G. BellettOriginal wording

Seeing yourself in God's light

Behind these words is a past that Jacob could now see clearly.

He had been false and crooked. But Jacob was now before God, and he saw himself in the light of heaven. He saw how he had deceived his old father, cheated his brother, made bargains with God, and deceived his uncle. You and I are not worthy, but God shows His mercy and truth to us bad, crooked sinners. Let us come and tell it all to God.

Modernised from G. C. WillisOriginal wording

A prayer God will not ignore

Jacob rests his case on mercy rather than on any claim, and that is exactly the ground God honours.

Their hope is not in His justice, but in His mercy. This is what Jacob depended on when he prayed, "I am not worthy of the least of all the mercies and of all the truth which You have shown Your servant" (Gen. 32:10). Can God possibly ignore such a prayer? No: He delights in the confessed weakness and failure of a believing heart, and His mercy is fully extended to them.

Modernised from L M GrantOriginal wording

The question of faith

Commentators differ on how much faith this prayer shows. One finds none in it.

Where is faith in this? There is none. If he had only had in his soul the sense that God was with him, he could not have prayed like this. There is nothing more blessed for a man than to have in his soul the sense that God is for him and with him. But Jacob did not have that.

Modernised from W. T. P. WolstonOriginal wording

Another sees real faith in it, mixed with something else.

He owns his unworthiness of the least of all His mercies and of all His truth. He compares how poor he was when he first crossed the Jordan with the two companies he has now… We can see that it was faith, but faith still mixed with human schemes. So he was far from resting calmly on God, and was even in sheer terror of Esau.

Modernised from William KellyOriginal wording

Summary

- Unworthy. Jacob's first recorded prayer takes a low place. The closer we come to God, the smaller we feel.

- Unlearned. At Bethel he thought he would prove worthy. Now his self-confidence is gone, though his trust in God is still not complete.

- Unmixed. Planning and praying cancel each other out — leaning on a scheme is not leaning on God.

- Unearned. A staff at the start, two companies at the end. Everything in between was mercy to a false and crooked man.

- Unashamed. God shows mercy and truth to crooked sinners, so come and tell Him everything.

Genesis 32:11 · Darby

Deliver me, I pray thee, from the hand of my brother, from the hand of Esau; for I fear him, lest he come and smite me, [and] the mother with the children.

Jacob is heading back to his own country with his wives, children and flocks. Word has just reached him that Esau — the brother he wronged years before — is coming to meet him with four hundred men.

Faith That Is Real but Mixed

The prayer is real. It also comes from a man who has already worked out a plan of his own.

After the trembling man had made his plan, he turns to God, and we can trace the work slowly going on in his soul. He reminds the LORD, the God of his fathers Abraham and Isaac, that God Himself had told him to return home. He owns his unworthiness of the least of all His mercies and of all His truth... He begs God to deliver him from the hand of his brother Esau, whom he dreaded both for himself and for the mother with the children... We can readily see that it was faith, but as yet mixed with human schemes. So he was far from resting peacefully on God, and was even in abject terror of Esau.

Modernised from William KellyOriginal wording

Why He Was Afraid

Esau was not the real problem. God had already promised to keep Jacob, so the fear came from somewhere else.

God had said to Jacob, "Behold, I am with you and will keep you" (Gen. 28:15). Esau would not have been able to touch him. If Jacob's ways had not been deceitful, he would not have been afraid of Esau. But you see, his conscience is working... He was afraid of his brother, whom he counted as his enemy. Esau was not his enemy, though he might have been. It was Jacob's own conscience that suggested Esau was against him. God was for him, but he had lost the sense of it.

Modernised from W. T. P. WolstonOriginal wording

What Jacob Forgot

God had already sent Jacob encouragement. Jacob lost sight of it, and Esau's four hundred men filled his whole horizon.

Still, despite this encouragement from God, unbelief renews Jacob's fear when he faces his brother Esau. Rescue from danger does not destroy unbelief. You do not get rid of the difficulties in the path of faith by trying to avoid them. You must overcome them by the power of God. Jacob had brought these difficulties on himself, because he had not trusted God. God's army was forgotten. Esau no longer held any hatred in his heart against his brother, but his army still frightened the feeble Jacob.

Modernised from J. N. DarbyOriginal wording

Praying and Planning

Jacob asks God to deliver him, then goes straight back to his own arrangements.

Jacob's first thought was always a plan, and here we have a true picture of the poor human heart. True, he turns to God after he makes his plan, and cries to Him for deliverance. But as soon as he stops praying he starts planning again. Now, praying and planning will never work together. If I plan, I am leaning more or less on my plan; but when I pray, I should lean on God alone. So the two things are completely incompatible; they destroy each other. When my eye is filled with my own management of things, I am not ready to see God acting for me.

Modernised from C. H. MackintoshOriginal wording

The Answer to a Weak Prayer

The trouble was of Jacob's own making, and God still met him in it.

We may be in trouble that our own wrongdoing has brought on us, and we may rightly dread the consequences. Even that we can take to God, if we have sincerely confessed our sin... Jacob had deeply wronged Esau, and now, after years apart, he has to face him... Jacob's conscience naturally makes him fear Esau's resentment. He learns that Esau is coming to meet him with four hundred men. But he lays it before God in prayer (v. 11). The result was remarkable. The man whose revenge he feared "ran to meet him and embraced him and fell on his neck and kissed him, and they wept"!

Modernised from The Bible TreasuryOriginal wording

What the Fear Was For

The prayer did not settle Jacob, and his gifts did not settle Esau. What came next went deeper than either.

The fact is that he was dissatisfied with himself, and feels the need of drawing near to God in a way he had never yet known... His plans did nothing to soften Esau, any more than to relieve his own dread. But he was now to be alone with God. God took him up in a way worthy of Himself. He laid the basis for the deepening work in his soul ever after, and for a blessing which at last shone in Jacob's later years beyond his father or even his grandfather.

Modernised from William KellyOriginal wording

Summary

- Conscience — The dread is not about Esau's four hundred men. It comes from Jacob's own wrong against his brother.

- Forgetting — God had just encouraged Jacob with His own army, and unbelief erased that the moment a threat appeared.

- Divided trust — He prays for deliverance, then goes back to his own plan. Leaning on a plan and leaning on God cancel each other out.

- Answered anyway — Esau had no hatred left in his heart, and the meeting Jacob dreaded ended in an embrace and tears.

- Purpose — The fear drove Jacob to be alone with God, and there began a blessing greater than his father's or his grandfather's.

Genesis 32:12 · Darby

And thou saidst, I will certainly deal well with thee, and make thy seed as the sand of the sea, which cannot be numbered for multitude.

Jacob is on the way to meet his brother Esau, and he is afraid Esau will kill him. His prayer ends with no new argument, only an old one — a sentence God Himself had spoken, and the verse turns on two words: "you said."

The prayer that ends on God's word

One writer traces the steps of the prayer, from Jacob's appeal to the God of his fathers down to this closing plea:

He reminds the Lord, the God of his fathers Abraham and Isaac, that he was going back to his country and family because God told him to. He admits he is unworthy of the least of all His mercies and of all His truth. He compares how poor he was when he first crossed the Jordan with the two companies he has now. He begs God earnestly to save him from his brother Esau. He dreaded Esau both for himself and for the mother with the children. Then he reminds Him of His promise — to surely do him good, and to make his descendants as countless as the sand of the sea.

Modernised from William KellyOriginal wording

That way of praying is open to anyone who has a Bible:

You will find it the very strength of your soul to go before God with a text and say, "This is written in Your word. Because You cannot lie, I know that I have that thing."

Modernised from G. V. WigramOriginal wording

What Jacob was really arguing

The verse sets God's promise and Esau's threat side by side, and asks how both can stand.

"For You said," he adds, "I will surely do you good, and make your offspring as the sand of the sea," and so on. He was in effect saying to God, "You said this, but now Esau might kill me, and what will happen to Your promise?" Did he need to plead with God to keep His promise?

Modernised from L. M. GrantOriginal wording

The sand of the sea

Commentators differ over Jacob's wording. One reads it as a mistake:

He did make an error in saying that God had told him He would make his descendants as the sand of the sea. God had said this to Abraham (Genesis 22:17). To Jacob He had promised descendants "as the dust of the earth" (Genesis 28:14).

Modernised from L. M. GrantOriginal wording

Another finds meaning in the change:

Isaac pictures the heavenly company and Jacob the earthly. So God speaks of the stars to Isaac and of the dust to Jacob. Yet in Genesis 32:12, Jacob says God had also promised to give him descendants as the "sand of the sea." In this chapter Jacob is about to meet Esau and make peace with him. That is a picture of the Gentiles brought into blessing through the Jew in a day still to come. It is striking that just here Jacob should mention the sand.

Modernised from George DavisonOriginal wording

Prayer alongside the schemes

The prayer sits between the plans Jacob made and the gift he sent.

Jacob arranges his plans, though not without prayer (Genesis 32:7-12). He sends his presents (Genesis 32:13-23) to appease his brother — a brother God had already appeased, since Esau was coming to meet Jacob with family affection. In his appeal to God he recalls His promises, for he had faith, however feeble.

Modernised from The Bible TreasuryOriginal wording

Another writer turns that mixture on the reader:

The trouble of the present day is that people, even Christians, rank policy side by side with faith. A godly young man used to say, "Policy I hate; but faithfulness to God I love." Surely nothing is more clearly stated in Scripture than that "without faith it is impossible to please God." But this mixture of faith and contrivance is what is before us here. The truth urges us strongly to judge ourselves about it.

Modernised from H. H. SnellOriginal wording

The promise does not depend on the man

The words Jacob quotes were never a bargain he had to secure. They were God binding Himself.

Here we have the blessed statement of what the God of Abraham, Isaac, and Jacob promised to do for Jacob and for his descendants. It is crowned by these memorable words: "I will not leave you until I have done what I have spoken to you of." These are the terms by which God binds Himself to Jacob. And these terms, blessed be His name, God has kept and will keep to the letter, though earth and hell should try to prevent it.

Modernised from C. H. MackintoshOriginal wording

Summary

- You said — Jacob's strongest plea is a quotation. He brings God nothing of his own at the end, only what God had already spoken.

- Faith, however feeble — the prayer is real faith, mixed with human scheming. The praying and the planning run side by side.

- Already answered — Esau was coming in family affection before Jacob ever sent the gifts. God had moved first.

- Sand or dust — God promised countless descendants in more than one form. Writers differ: was Jacob's "sand" a mistake, or a reach toward the blessing of the nations?

- Bound by His word — the promise Jacob leaned on rests on God binding Himself, and He will keep it to the letter. Judge the scheming in yourself; the promise itself never wobbles.