Genesis 1:3–31

Genesis 1:3

And God said, Let there be light. And there was light.

Commentary for this verse has not been generated yet.

Genesis 1:4

And God saw the light that it was good; and God divided between the light and the darkness.

God's first recorded act for our earth is not to clear away the dark. He speaks light into it. Then two things happen that shape everything after: God calls something good, and God draws a line.

(The writers below use an older translation. It reads "God saw the light, that it was good," and "divided" where the ESV has "separated.")

Light Before the Sun

Light is good on day one, but the sun does not appear until the fourth day. That order is backwards by human reckoning. One writer treats it as a mark of where the account came from.

Now who but an inspired man would have so written? The lower your view of Israel — an unlettered people, even rough and uncivilised — the greater the wonder. Did Egypt teach this, or Babylon? Did Greece or Rome? How did Moses come to declare the fact as he writes it? ... Any living man, judging by what everyone can see, has always regarded the sun as the great source of light. If the writing had been his, he would have spoken first of that bright orb. In other words, the work of the fourth day would more reasonably have taken the place of the first. That is what the philosophers taught for ages afterwards. But the truth is not so.

William Kelly

The First Verdict

Here God does more than make something. He looks at it and pronounces it good. That first moral verdict answers a darkness one writer traces back to angelic sin.

Darkness, no doubt through angelic sin, had entered His creation. As He moved with feeling over the scene, He commands, "Let there be light." This was creative power — the prerogative of God Himself. But it also says, "God saw the light, that it was good" — the first moral pronouncement of Scripture! "And God divided the light from the darkness."

F. A. Hughes

Why He Could Only Divide

God approves the light and says nothing over the darkness. So He never blends the two; He divides them. One commentator sees this happen inside a ruined life.

A wrecked life lies hopeless in a gloom that, as far as its own efforts go, must be eternal. Over that life the Spirit of God in brooding love flashes out the knowledge of the presence of God Himself: "God, who said, 'Let light shine out of darkness,' has shone in our hearts." The light here shows nothing but itself, in which God can find pleasure: "God saw the light that it was good." He can only divide it from all that is not light, calling the one "day" and the other "night."

Samuel Ridout

No Twilight

The line God draws is absolute. One writer names what it rules out, and what it produced: the first day.

So God divided the light from the darkness. There was to be no compromise, no mixture, no vague twilight. For a season the darkness was to give way fully to light, and so there was a division between them. So there was evening and there was morning — a first day.

F. B. Hole

What Is Never Called Good

Darkness does us real good in the natural world. Scripture still never calls it good, and one writer explains why.

Earlier in this book we noticed that God called the light good, but said nothing like this of the darkness. In nature, darkness is a real benefit. After the toil of the day comes the rest and peace of night. But in a spiritual sense, Scripture treats darkness as a picture of evil. That is why Genesis 1:4 does not call it "good," as it calls the light good.

A J Pollock

The Same Pattern in a Person

The same method appears when God starts work in a person. One writer also warns that nights still come.

God did not say, "Let darkness be removed," but "Let there be light." The positive radiance of light drives out the darkness. So too, the light of God entering someone's soul drives out his moral and spiritual darkness. "God saw the light, that it was good." ... Then God divided the light from the darkness. So we know there was light before God set the sun in its place to rule over the day. In a spiritual sense this reminds us that light has entered the soul of every believer. Even so, night experiences will still come, because the fleshly nature is still in us, and its very character is darkness.

L. M. Grant

Summary

- Light first. Light comes before the sun. No one writing from what he could see would have chosen that order, so the account reads as revealed, not reasoned.

- Light judged. "And God saw that the light was good" is the first moral pronouncement in the Bible. God's judgment enters Scripture the moment light does.

- Light alone approved. God calls the light good and says nothing of the darkness. He never approves it, so all He does is divide the light from it.

- Light unmixed. The division allows no compromise, no blend, no vague twilight — day and night are named apart.

- Light within. God treats a dark heart as He treated the dark earth. He does not say, "Let darkness be removed," but "Let there be light." Nights still come, because our fleshly nature remains.

Genesis 1:5

And God called the light Day, and the darkness he called Night. And there was evening, and there was morning -- the first day.

Genesis 1:5 closes the first day of God's work: God names what He has just separated, and time starts to be counted. It also opens questions readers still argue over — where does a day begin, and how can there be evening and morning before the sun appears on day four?

God Names What He Makes

Every act in this chapter is God's own.

All is divine. God said, God saw, God called. His thoughts, words, and acts are presented throughout. ... How noticeable it is, too, that God gives everything its name! He calls as well as makes all things. Night and day, heaven, earth, and seas all receive their names as well as their existence from Him. What was for man's use, and to be put under man's control, is left for him to name.

The Bible Treasury

God kept some names for Himself and left others to the first man.

We have now had five things before us that were named by God Himself. We note this because of what comes next. In the next chapter God brings to Adam the living creatures He had made on the fifth and sixth days, so that he might give them names... So God let Adam show his powers of discernment in many a smaller detail. But these five things he had to accept as named by God — Day, Night, Heaven, Earth, Seas.

F. B. Hole

Where the Day Begins

The order "evening... morning" sounds backwards to a modern reader.

Notice that the first day does not begin before the light, but with it. Otherwise it could not begin with evening, for evening implies light already there. But the light strangely comes only to fade and darken into night. Through that it reaches its morning by a kind of new birth, when (for that day, of course) the darkness is wholly past.

Frederick W Grant

The deep darkness of verse 2 is not this evening. One writer notes that the thick darkness "did not count for time." God brings light, calls it day, and "then came the evening and the morning with the light again" (J. N. Darby).

Light Before the Sun

Critics have long objected that this verse counts a day three days before God sets the sun in place.

For a long time unbelievers took great exception to this statement of verse 5, because the sun does not appear until the fourth day. But the sun is not the only source of light.

F. B. Hole

One writer answers with a question: "Think now, if I had been writing a book, would I ever have thought of creating a difficulty like this on purpose?" (J. N. Darby).

Twenty-Four Hours or Long Ages

How long is a day in Genesis 1?

The question is raised whether the days of Genesis 1 are literal, or figurative — vast periods of time... For ourselves, we believe it is to be understood literally. The figurative sense does occur in Scripture — "man's day," "the day of salvation." But that sense is clearly a secondary one. The literal sense is the primary... The repetition of "the evening and the morning" fits the primary meaning, and would have very little meaning in the secondary sense. Further, in verse 16 the sun is made to rule the day and the moon to rule the night, and we do not see how the primary sense can be avoided.

F. B. Hole

Evening First, Then Morning

This order reverses the way we speak of a human life.

If the Scriptures were uninspired, we would surely have reversed the order and written that the morning and the evening were the first day. Man's mind runs naturally to morning first and then evening. We speak of the morning of life, and of the evening of life. For man, darkness follows light.

A J Pollock

One writer traces the pattern to its end.

Practically, the day is not all light; "evening and morning" make it up. Yet though darkness in itself is "night," it is worth noticing something. Once light has come in, it is never simple, absolute night any more, but "evening." There are always some rays of the day. And in God's order, evening surely gives way to morning... its promise of the perfect "day" is never realised until God's work is finished and His Sabbath is reached. Then indeed there is no more evening, or morning either, but "day," without mixture or decline.

Frederick W Grant

Day and Night as Symbols

The two names given here become a pattern used across the whole Bible.

Here we have the two great symbols so widely used throughout the Word. The presence of light makes the day; its absence makes the night. So it is in the history of souls. There are "the sons of light" and "the sons of darkness." This is a very marked and solemn distinction.

C. H. Mackintosh

Summary

- Light first. The day does not begin in the dark. Evening only has meaning because light has already shone.

- Named by God. Day and Night are among five things man had to receive already named — God calls as well as makes.

- Then measured. The repeated "evening and morning" argues for a literal day. The figurative sense of "day" is secondary, built on that primary one.

- Evening, then morning. Man expects morning then evening. God writes evening then morning — darkness giving way to light.

- Ending in day. Once light has entered, it is never total night again, only evening. At God's rest comes day without decline.

Genesis 1:6

And God said, Let there be an expanse in the midst of the waters, and let it be a division between waters and waters.

On the second day God speaks again. He calls for a space in the middle of the waters, to divide them in two. Two questions follow: what is this "expanse," and why do the waters need dividing?

The Word Behind "Firmament"

Older English Bibles read "firmament," which sounds hard and fixed. One writer traces where that word came from:

The Hebrew word translated "firmament" would be better given as "expanse," as it is marked in the reference column in some editions of our Bibles. The word "firmament" comes from the Vulgate translation of the Bible in Latin by Jerome, and is unfortunate. The idea came to him from the ancients. Greek and Roman philosophies described heaven as forming a solid vault over the earth.

A J Pollock

The Bible itself never pictures a metal ceiling:

A solid vault is out of the question… The Scriptures really present the heavens as spread out, and the earth hung upon nothing. They nowhere support the crude idea of stars fastened like brass nails on a metal vault.

William Kelly

Which Heaven Is This?

Heaven was already named in the first verse of the chapter. So why does it appear again here? Scripture uses the word at more than one level:

On the second day God called a "firmament," or "expanse," into being; a further division, not now of light from darkness but of waters from waters. God called this expanse, Heaven. In verse 1 "the heaven" means what we should call the starry heavens. In verse 8 it means the atmospheric heavens… As a result of the work of the second day, an atmosphere surrounded the earth. He did it by His word, "God said … and it was so."

F. B. Hole

Kelly counts three heavens in Scripture:

The New Testament tells how Paul was caught up into the third heaven… Here God made another heaven, since man was about to be made. There is the heaven of His presence. There is the heaven of the stars, planets, and other objects in space. And there is the atmospheric heaven that man and living things here below need.

William Kelly

The Waters Above and Below

The two bodies of water are not alike, and one of them hangs over our heads every day:

The waters upon the earth are the salt, bitter waters of the ocean; while those above, though drawn from the ocean, are perfectly fresh. It is beautiful to see how these waters in vast and inconceivable volume are suspended in those "balancing clouds" which lift them above the earth and yet hold them in connection with it, ever ready to pour down in beneficent rain the treasures which they hold.

Samuel Ridout

A Work of Kindness, Not Just Order

Take away this arrangement and life on earth becomes impossible:

God drew man's attention to His thoughtful and almighty goodness when He separated "waters from waters." Otherwise endless mist would have filled the space above the earth, without the right mixture of gases that makes up the air every living thing needs. To the air's work, with other causes God set up, we owe clouds, rain, and evaporation. It also bends and reflects light, softening it, which adds much to the beauty and usefulness of creation. Without it a black sky would have cast a constant shadow over the earth.

William Kelly

Why No "It Was Good"

The words "and God saw that it was good," repeated through the chapter, are missing from the second day. One writer links that silence to the kind of work done:

Nothing new was made on the second day. God separated the waters above from the waters below, leaving the heavens free as an expanse between them. But no new substance was created, so the day is not said to be very good.

J. N. Darby

The Lesson of Looking Up

One writer draws a lesson from the shape of the day:

If the first day pictures God beginning His work in a soul by new birth, the second day shows a person made to look up. True blessing comes from above, and so does authority… All below may look like a watery waste with no order. Yet if the believer is refreshed by the pure water of God's word from above, in true subjection to the Lord Jesus, his life can change greatly from disorder into calm, orderly obedience.

L. M. Grant

Summary

- Expanse. The Hebrew word means an open, spread-out sky. "Firmament" came through the Latin and sounds hard, which the text never was.

- Above. The expanse lifts fresh water over the salt sea. It holds that water in clouds, ready to fall as rain.

- Named. God calls the expanse "Heaven." It is not the starry heaven of verse 1, and not the heaven of His presence, but the air made for creatures below.

- Given. Kelly reads the day as thoughtful goodness: without this air there is no rain, no softened light, no life.

- Upward. Earth is set under heaven and fed from it. So the day teaches the soul to look up: blessing, refreshment, and authority all come from above.

Genesis 1:7

And God made the expanse, and divided between the waters that are under the expanse and the waters that are above the expanse; and it was so.

On the second day God speaks, and an "expanse" splits one mass of water into two: some below, some above. Commentators ask what that word means, why God makes rather than creates here, and why a sky full of clouds matters so much.

The Word Behind "Expanse"

Older English Bibles say "firmament," a word that suggests something hard and fixed.

It is now widely known — and the most competent Hebrew scholars said so long before modern science existed — that "expanse" is the real force of the original word, not "firmament." That word came to us through the Latin Vulgate, and seems to come from the Greek Septuagint... The way the word is used in this chapter itself (verses 15, 17, 20, 28) proves that it means the open, transparent sky, whatever readers may have misunderstood at any time.

William Kelly

Made, Not Created

Genesis uses different verbs across the chapter. Verse 7 belongs to the group where God shapes what is already there.

From this point God begins to work again. We read not only of God creating (Gen. 1:21, 27) but of His making (Gen. 1:7, 16, 25), and finally of His forming man (Gen. 2:7). The last two words apply when the question is not producing something out of nothing. They speak of shaping matter that already exists into fresh forms of order and beauty.

F. B. Hole

Two Heavens, One Name

Verse 1 already mentioned the heaven. Genesis uses that word for two different things.

On the second day God called a "firmament," or "expanse," into being. As a result a further division took place — not now of light from darkness, but of waters from waters. In verse 1 "the heaven" means what we should call the stellar heavens. In verse 8 it means the atmospheric heavens. There immense quantities of water float above in the form of clouds, divided from the far greater quantities lying on the earth beneath. The work of the second day surrounded the earth with an atmosphere. His word accomplished it: "God said … and it was so."

F. B. Hole

Two Kinds of Water

The two bodies of water differ in more than location.

The waters upon the earth are the salt, bitter waters of the ocean, while those above, though drawn from the ocean, are perfectly fresh. This is a true picture of what the expanse of the atmosphere is: a separation between the waters on the earth and those in the heavens, not a hard and fast line. It can be filled with vapour, and yet in general it arches above us, making a true separation, just as Scripture describes here.

Samuel Ridout

Why the Separation Was Kindness

The verse reads like plain physics. But one commentator asks what the world would be like if this single act had not happened.

God drew man's attention to His thoughtful and almighty goodness when He separated "waters from waters." Otherwise the space above the earth would have been filled with constant vapour. It would have lacked the right mixture of gases that makes up the air, which all life on earth needs. To the workings of that air, with other causes God set in place, we owe the forming of clouds, the fall of rain and evaporation. To its power of bending and reflecting light we owe that softening of light which adds so much to the beauty and the usefulness of creation. Otherwise a black sky would have cast its constant covering over the earth.

William Kelly

The Missing Verdict

The second day never gets the verdict "it was good." One explanation ties that silence back to the verb in verse 7.

Nothing was made the second day — that is, no new thing. The separation of waters above and below, leaving the heavens free as an expanse between, was not a new substance created, and so it is not said to be very good.

J. N. Darby

A Picture for the Soul

One writer also reads the days as a picture of how God works in a person.

If the first day pictures God beginning His work in a soul by new birth, the second day shows that one has reason to look up and see that true blessing comes from above. And so authority comes from above too... All below may seem a watery waste with no order. Yet when a believer is refreshed by the pure water of God's word from above, in true subjection to the Lord Jesus, his life may be greatly changed from disorder into calm, orderly obedience, even when surrounded by the swelling seas of the world's confusion.

Leslie M. Grant

Summary

- Expanse. The original word means open, transparent sky, not a hard dome. "Firmament" came in through later translations.

- Made. God shapes matter that already exists; He does not create from nothing here. One writer gives that as the reason no verdict of "good" is spoken over this day.

- Divided. One water becomes two: salt ocean below, fresh cloud above, with breathable air arching between them.

- Sustained. That one division gives rain, evaporation and softened light instead of a black sky. One writer calls it God's thoughtful and almighty goodness.

- Upward. Read as a picture, the day teaches that blessing and authority come from above. Under that authority, a soul's disorder turns into calm obedience.

Genesis 1:8

And God called the expanse Heavens. And there was evening, and there was morning -- a second day.

Day two ends with a name: God calls the expanse He stretched between the waters Heaven. Two questions follow — which "heaven" is this, and why is this the only day God never calls "good"?

Which Heaven Is Meant

Scripture uses "heaven" for more than one thing. Verse 1 and verse 8 do not point to the same place:

On the second day God brought a "firmament," or "expanse," into being. This made a further division — not light from darkness now, but waters from waters. God called this expanse Heaven. In verse 1 "the heaven" means what we would call the starry heavens. In verse 8 it means the atmospheric heavens. That is where huge amounts of water float above us as clouds, divided from the far greater amounts lying on the earth below. So the work of the second day left the earth wrapped in an atmosphere. He did it by His word: "God said … and it was so."

F. B. Hole

The Word Behind "Firmament"

English Bibles long read "firmament," a word that sounds solid. That is not the force of the Hebrew:

It is now widely known — and the best Hebrew scholars said so long before modern science existed — that "expanse" is the real force of the original word, not "firmament," which reached us through the old Latin translation, the Vulgate, and seems to come from the older Greek one, the Septuagint... The way the word is used in this very chapter (vv. 15, 17, 20, 28) is proof enough that it carries the idea of the open, clear sky, whatever readers may have misunderstood at any time.

William Kelly

The same word covers a wide range:

The Hebrew word is raqia, meaning 'expanse.' It covers both the sky we see when we look up and the air in which the birds fly. We read that God called the expanse 'heaven.' This is 'heaven' in a broad sense, for elsewhere we read of 'the stars of heaven,' but also of 'the birds of heaven.'

Morrish Bible Dictionary

Why God Does the Naming

The naming is not decoration. It marks out what belongs to God to define and what He later hands over to man:

We have now had five things before us, and God Himself gave the name to each. We note this because in the next chapter God brings the living creatures He had made on the fifth and sixth days to Adam, so that he might name them... God let Adam show his skill of discernment in many a smaller detail, but these five things he had to accept as named by God — Day, Night, Heaven, Earth, Seas.

F. B. Hole

The Kindness Hidden in a Division

That division wrapped the earth in air. One writer lists what hangs on it:

The air's workings, with other causes God set in place, give us the forming of clouds, the fall of rain, and evaporation. Because the air bends and reflects light, we get that softening of light which adds beyond measure to the beauty of creation, and just as much to its usefulness. Otherwise a black sky would have hung over the earth like a constant shroud... And if dry land had survived anywhere, it must have been a dry, barren waste with no animal life and not a blade of grass.

William Kelly

The Missing "It Was Good"

Every other day carries God's approval. This one does not, and commentators differ on the reason. One takes it as a matter of substance:

God made nothing on the second day — that is, nothing new. Dividing the waters above from the waters below, and leaving the heavens free as an expanse between, created no new substance, so Scripture does not call it very good.

J. N. Darby

Another writer finds the silence itself meaningful. He points to what fills these heavens so far:

Nothing fills these heavens as yet but "waters" — waters above as well as below — the very picture of instability... And it seems telling that on this second day there is no voice of God calling "good" what is still for good. In His providence He may be working blessing through what He cannot bless in itself.

Frederick W Grant

Earth Under Heaven

Once a sky exists, everything below depends on what is above it:

This heaven is clearly the atmospheric heaven, and the waters above are no doubt the waters held in the clouds... the second day shows us that we have reason to look up and see that true blessing comes from above, and so authority comes from above too. "The heavens do rule" (Dan. 4:26).

Leslie M. Grant

(The ESV reads "Heaven rules" in Daniel 4:26.)

Summary

- Named. God calls the expanse Heaven — one of five names He fixes Himself, leaving the animals for Adam to name later.

- Expanse. The Hebrew word raqia means an open, spread-out sky — not the solid dome that "firmament" suggests.

- Divided. Waters above, waters below, breathable air between — the arrangement that gives clouds, rain, and light we can live under.

- Unpraised. This is the only day God never calls good. Some writers say nothing new was made; others hear meaning in the silence.

- Above. With the sky in place, everything below depends on what is above it: blessing and authority come down from heaven.

Genesis 1:9

And God said, Let the waters under the heavens be gathered together to one place, and let the dry [land] appear. And it was so.

On the third day of creation God speaks to the waters, and land appears for the first time. Commentators read this as plain history: the shaping of the world we still live on. They also read it as a picture of how God brings order, stability and fruit out of what had no shape.

The World Takes Its Present Shape

Before this command, water covered everything. Writers point out that the land had to rise before it could appear at all. They also note that the one gathering place for the waters matches the world as we find it.

First He commands the waters under the heavens to gather into one place, so that dry land can appear. People have noticed that all the seas of the world connect with each other, while the land masses do not. Moses could not have known this unless God revealed it to him. For the dry land to appear, it had to rise above the level of the water. Deep water still covers much land. Dry land takes up less than a third of this planet's surface.

L. M. Grant

What was fixed on that day was not temporary. The continents and oceans described here are the same ones people still map and sail.

Sudden, extraordinary acts brought about what God then did for man. Slow, ordinary causes played their part too. But here we learn that God laid down the great landmarks that remain to this day.

William Kelly

From Motion To Solid Ground

The first two days brought divisions of light and of waters. This third division produces something new: a surface that stays put.

Again on the third day there was division. The waters above the expanse stayed as they were. God gathered the waters beneath into one place, and dry land appeared. Solid, fixed ground now appeared where everything had been unsettled and moving.

F. B. Hole

A Word That Takes Effect

God speaks, and it is done. Writers treat His word as the firmest ground a person can stand on.

We may well believe His word, since by the word of God all things came into being and continue... The word of God is the authority the believer needs, and the believer is called to obey it in faith. The ground of faith is: "The Lord has said."

The Bible Treasury

Separation As God's Method

Look back over the three days and one pattern keeps repeating. Each act of God draws a line between two things that were mixed.

This gathering of the waters into their own place begins the great period of earth's history that we still live in. Except for the flood, when water covered everything for a time, the dry land has always been visible... Notice that God's work from the beginning was work of separating. He separated light from darkness. He separated the waters above the expanse from the waters beneath. And here again He separates the dry land from the waves that had covered it and hidden it.

Samuel Ridout

The Sea Bounded, Not Removed

The waters are not destroyed. They are given a place, a limit, and — for the first time — a name from God.

The "third day" speaks of resurrection to the Christian heart. Here it is marked by resurrection power: the earth comes up out of the waters. What can be worked and made fruitful now rises from under the waste of sea that could never be reclaimed. The sea is not removed, but bounded and restrained; it cannot return to cover the earth. God acknowledges that the sea exists. He names it for the first time. In the new earth there will be no sea.

Frederick W. Grant

The same picture applies to a person. It explains why unrest inside us is limited instead of removed.

It was like this with the darkness, and now it is like this with the waters. God does not remove them completely. He controls them and sets their limits. The same is true of everything that causes uncertainty, unrest and barrenness in the soul. God does not remove it. He gives it limits it cannot pass, so it can never again cover the ground.

The Christian's Friend

Land And Sea As A Picture Of Nations

Commentators differ on how far to press the picture. Several read land and sea as a lasting symbol used later in Scripture.

This illustrates the relation of Israel to the nations. The sea is a picture of the nations, who are out of control. Daniel 7:3 tells us of four great beasts coming up from the sea. These are not real beasts or a real sea. They stand for four great world empires that rise up among the nations.

A. J. Pollock

Summary

- Command — God speaks, and the waters obey at once; His word is the reason the world has the shape it has.

- Separation — one method runs through all three days: light from darkness, waters from waters, land from sea.

- Stability — ground now stays fixed where everything had been moving. These landmarks remain to this day.

- Boundary — the sea is not abolished but named and limited, so it can never again cover the earth.

- Fruitfulness — dry land is the necessary first step; only once there is firm ground can anything grow on it.

Genesis 1:10

And God called the dry [land] Earth, and the gathering together of the waters he called Seas. And God saw that it was good.

The third day of creation ends with two names and a verdict. Behind those simple words lie real questions: what do the names cover, why does God divide at all, and what does the ordered world of land and sea picture?

The God Who Names

Here God gives names, not new acts of power. This naming runs through the whole chapter, and one writer shows how much it tells us.

Everything is divine. God said, God saw, God called. We see His thoughts, words, and acts all the way through. And so everything is very good. Sadly, it is when the creature begins to act that everything is spoiled. Notice too how God gives everything its name! He calls as well as makes all things. Night and day, heaven, earth, and seas all receive their names from Him as well as their existence. God left man to name what was for man's use and under man's control.

The Bible Treasury

The Verdict "It Was Good"

The closing words are a marker. They end the first block of God's work in this account.

There is another division in Genesis 1 besides creation and the days, made by the words "and God saw" and "it was good." First He creates. Then He separates the elements to make order out of disorder… Then water and dry land, giving each its name; and the world so prepared He pronounces "good." That is the first division — an ordered world.

J. N. Darby

What "Seas" Covers

Seas covers more than the oceans on a modern map. The landscape God named here is the one we still live in.

The earth was to have, for the most part, the shape God saw best fitted for His new purpose. There would be vast continents and vaster oceans, islands large and small, lakes salt and fresh, mountains and rivers, plains and valleys. Deep and sudden upheaval, not just slow erosion, often shaped those valleys. In Hebrew usage the "seas" take in all large collections of water — oceans, seas, lakes, and even rivers… here we learn that God laid down the great landmarks that remain to this day.

William Kelly

One writer points to a detail Moses had no way of checking.

It has been observed that all the seas of the world are connected, while all the land is not. Moses could never have known this unless God revealed it to him. For the dry land to appear it would have to be raised up above the level of the water. Some land remains covered by great depths of water, for the dry land on this planet takes up less than one third of its surface.

L. M. Grant

The Sea Bounded, Not Removed

God does not remove the sea on this day. He gives it a limit and a name.

The "third day" speaks to the Christian heart of resurrection. Resurrection power marks it here: the earth comes up out of the waters. What can be worked on and made fruitful is now brought up from under the hopeless waste of sea. That sea is not removed, but bounded and restrained; it cannot return to cover the earth. Its existence is indeed openly recognised; it gets its name from God for the first time; in the new earth there will be none (Revelation 21:1). Meanwhile He lays the foundations of the earth, so that it should never be moved.

Frederick W Grant

Land and Sea as a Picture

Commentators read the picture in two directions. One takes the restless water as a figure of what is unstable in people.

The land speaks of what is solid and stable, in contrast to the unstable mass of the waters of the oceans. The heaving waters speak of the flesh in its unstable emptiness, whether the flesh in unbelievers or in believers. In the same way, Revelation 17:15 speaks of the waters as "peoples, multitudes, nations and tongues." There you see the flesh in all its constant turmoil and disorder. These are the waters of the seas, in contrast to the waters from above — the rain that stands for the blessing of God by His word (Isaiah 55:10-11). This separation of earth from the waters God saw to be good.

L. M. Grant

Another writer asks what this division pictures.

No doubt in Genesis 1 the Earth refers to the whole land surface, just as the Seas refers to the oceans that circle the globe. But what does this division between the Earth and the Seas picture? The Earth stands for the land of Israel.

A J Pollock

Summary

- Separation. God makes order out of disorder by dividing. Light from darkness, then waters above from waters below, and here dry land from sea.

- Naming. He calls as well as makes. Earth and seas take their names from Him; man names only what God put under his control.

- Bounding. God limits the sea rather than removing it. It cannot return to cover the earth, and in the new earth there will be none.

- Picture. Solid land rising out of restless water speaks of resurrection, and of what is stable set against the unstable flesh.

- Verdict. With land and sea each in its place, God calls the ordered world good — and the landmarks He set then remain to this day.

Genesis 1:11

And God said, Let the earth cause grass to spring up, herb producing seed, fruit-trees yielding fruit after their kind, the seed of which is in them, on the earth. And it was so.

God's first word on the third day divided sea from dry land. His second word calls that bare land to clothe itself with life — plants that carry their own seed, each one true to its kind.

The Word That Produces

Nothing here grows out of what came before. Every stage begins again with God speaking:

Every stage is produced by His Word. Each time, God speaks. This is not simply the unfolding of what was already hidden in the earliest seed. Step by step, God puts out His power and carries out plans that are wholly His own. "We are His workmanship" — the patient, perfect work of the wisdom of God — "created in Christ Jesus."

Frederick William Grant

Tree Before Seed

The verse describes a fruit tree that already carries seed inside it. That order reverses what we watch in nature today:

On the third day God speaks a second time. He commands the earth to "sprout vegetation, plants yielding seed, and fruit trees bearing fruit in which is their seed, each according to its kind." This settles any objection that the tree could not be there until the seed was planted. If God had wanted to create the seed first, He could easily have done so. But He commanded the earth's fruit to come out before any seed went into the ground. That was just as simple for Him as doing it the other way round.

L. M. Grant

After Its Kind

The phrase "according to its kind" appears here for the first time, and it arrives with reproduction itself. Older translations render it "after his kind":

The second point is this. As soon as this chapter touches life — life of the kind that reproduces its species, whether plant, tree, fish, bird, creeping thing, or cattle — it lays down the unchanging law that governs all such reproduction in three words: "after his kind." This points us to a fact that keeps proving itself in a thousand ways. Breeding and selection may modify a species within certain limits, but nothing can alter the species.

F. B. Hole

Another writer asks what the repeated phrase was meant to teach:

But what did this often-repeated phrase, "After his kind," mean? The Spirit of God surely meant something very definite by it. It states plainly that each species in nature is distinct from every other. One species never blends into another. Nothing in nature changes from one species into another.

A J Pollock

A Table Laid Before the Guests

Plants come before any creature that could eat them. God dresses and stocks the land before a single creature is there to feed on it:

But there is a second part of His work to notice: plant life for the earth as it now is, the kingdom that stands between minerals and animals. God commanded the earth to bring out grass, plants producing seed, and fruit trees yielding fruit after their kind, with their seed in them — and Scripture says it here with great emphasis. This is the true origin of plant species for the earth of Adam. God had pronounced the dry land and the seas good; now He says the same of the beautiful clothing of the dry land and the rich supplies for man and beast — food that at first was the only food even for man.

William Kelly

The Third Day and Resurrection

Note which day this happens on. Commentators connect the third day with resurrection:

But God also stamped the third day at creation in a remarkable way. Before that day the waters of death covered everything. On that day the waters drew back, and living, fruitful things sprang out of the dry land... And twice on this day, and on this day only, we are told that "God saw that it was good." What could that be for, except to teach us that the third day — the day of life springing out of death — was good not only in creation, but also in resurrection?

H H Snell

Read that way, the seed hidden inside the fruit points forward to one Seed in particular:

On the third day He made the grass, the plants, and the fruit trees yielding after their kind, with their seed in them (Gen. 1:11; 2:5) — the day which points us to resurrection... The Seed of promise is CHRIST... and all in that line are "after their kind"; but death, being made alive, and resurrection were needed if lasting fruitfulness was to come.

H J Vine

Summary

- Word — every stage of creation starts with God speaking; nothing simply unfolds from an earlier seed.

- Order — the tree came before the seed, and God could as easily have done the reverse; He chose this one.

- Kind — where life reproduces, God fixes the law "according to its kind": a limit breeding can stretch but never break.

- Provision — God lays the table before the guests arrive; plants clothe the land and feed man and beast.

- Resurrection — on the third day life sprang from ground the waters of death had covered, and God called it good twice.

Genesis 1:12

And the earth brought forth grass, herb producing seed after its kind, and trees yielding fruit, the seed of which is in them, after their kind. And God saw that it was good.

On the third day the earth does what God told it to do. The report repeats His command almost word for word. Two things stand out: every plant and tree comes "according to their own kinds," and God calls the result good.

The Earth Obeys the Word

God spoke to the ground itself, and what came up was the plant life of the world we still live in.

God commanded the earth to bring out grass, plants that make seed, and fruit trees that bear fruit according to their kind, with the seed inside the fruit. The verse states this with great emphasis. This is the true origin of plant species for the earth of Adam. God had already called the dry land and the seas good. Now the beautiful clothing of that dry land is good as well, with its rich supplies for man and beast — at first the only food even for man.

William Kelly

"According to Their Own Kinds"

The phrase repeats through the chapter. Pollock counts how often it appears, and asks what it is there for.

In Genesis 1 the formula — "according to its kind" — appears ten times. It covers plants in verse 11, sea life and birds in verse 21, and last of all the beasts of the earth, the cattle and everything that creeps on the earth in verse 25. Why "according to its kind"? It leaves room for each species. The lion does not mate with the tigress. The eagle does not pair with the goose. The wasp does not breed with the bee. Man arranges the only hybrids in creation, and they are sterile and come to nothing.

A. J. Pollock

The Tree Before the Seed

Notice the order. Full-grown plants and trees come first, and the seed is inside them.

The passage quoted makes it clear that God created plant life full-grown and mature… So the tree came before the seed, not the other way round. But evolution insists on a universal law of progress from "low to high," from immaturity to maturity, from the structureless cell to the perfect organization. We are asked to accept either an unproved theory or an inspired history, and here the believer has no choice.

The Bible Treasury

Plant Life Before the Sun

Plants appear on day three. God does not set the sun in its place until day four.

God created life, and He keeps it going… We can see the wisdom of what He shows us in this day. How many wise men have dreamed and thought that the sun was the source of all life! Yet the plants were formed when the sun was not yet set to do its all-important work for the earth of man.

William Kelly

The Day of Life Out of Death

The third day has a shape to it. Water covered everything, then dry land appeared and life sprang from it.

Before that day the waters of death covered everything. On that day the waters drew back, and living, fruitful things sprang out of the dry land… Twice on this day, and on this day only, Scripture says that "God saw that it was good." What can this be for, if not to teach us that the third day — the day of life springing out of death — was good not only as creation, but also as resurrection?

H. H. Snell

Fruit That Carries Its Own Seed

The three forms — grass, seed-bearing plants, fruit trees — also picture stages of growth in a believer, from new faith to maturity.

The grass, the plants and the fruit tree illustrate the development of spiritual life in the child of God. The fresh green grass reminds us of the freshness of the faith of "little children"… The plant yielding seed is a picture of the energy of the "young men"… The fruit tree shows the maturity of "fathers," who know the Lord Jesus in a settled way and bear fruit for Him freely.

L. M. Grant

The seed sits inside the fruit, and that detail carries a lesson of its own.

There is progress; from grass and plant to "trees bearing fruit in which is their seed" — another beautiful picture. The fruit carries inside itself the power to reproduce. The fruit itself is for the Master's use, and it is well to remember that. The seed is in this fruit according to its kind — love to produce love, and so on. If we want to find love, we must show it. The riper the fruit is for the Master's taste, the riper the seed is too. The best ripe fruit is the fruit that has hung in the sun most.

F. W. Grant

Summary

- Kind — "According to its kind" appears ten times in the chapter. It fixes each species, so one kind never turns into another.

- Order — The tree comes before the seed, full-grown and complete. That is the reverse of what evolution needs.

- Source — Plants live before the sun is set in its place, so life comes from God, not from the sun.

- Sign — Land rises from the waters, and life springs out of it. Only on this day does God say twice that it was good — the mark of resurrection.

- Seed — Fruit carries its seed inside, so real fruit reproduces itself. Love produces love, and the ripest fruit has hung longest in the sun.

Genesis 1:13

And there was evening, and there was morning -- a third day.

The third day closes with the familiar words about evening and morning. But this day is unlike the others: twice on this day God calls His work good. Commentators read the day on two levels. It was a real day, when God gathered the waters and clothed the earth. It also pictures life rising out of death.

A real day, not an age

The repeat of evening and morning is the strongest clue to how long these days were.

People ask whether the days of Genesis 1 are literal days, or figures standing for immense periods of time... For ourselves, we believe they are literal. Scripture does use "day" in a figurative sense — "man's day," "the day of salvation," and so on. But that sense is clearly a secondary one, and the literal sense is the primary one... We must have the primary meaning settled before we can reach any secondary meaning at all, and Genesis 1 deals with primary things... The repetition of "there was evening and there was morning" fits the primary meaning, and would mean very little in the secondary sense.

F. B. Hole

The great landmarks that still stand

What God settled on this day did not pass away with it.

The earth was now to take, for the most part, the form God saw best fitted for His new purpose: vast continents and vaster oceans, islands large and small, lakes salt and fresh, mountains and rivers, plains and valleys. Those valleys were not merely worn down by slow erosion, but often broken open deeply and suddenly... In Hebrew usage the word "seas" takes in all large collections of water — oceans, seas, lakes, and even rivers... here we learn that God laid down the great landmarks which abide to this day.

William Kelly

Plants for man's table

Some have tried to match the third day with the long ages that produced the coal beds. Kelly answers by looking at what the text names: grass, seed-bearing herbs, fruit trees.

How absurd to take the third day before us and identify it with the Carboniferous age, the age that laid the basis for the coal beds! What real likeness is there between coal-plants and the grass, herb and tree, so clearly meant to feed animals, and above all man?... This is plainly not provision for coal, but for the food and refreshment of man and cattle, of bird and beast... For geologic eras it is a failure; for man's world it is the simple and fitting truth. It was plant-life for Adam's earth.

William Kelly

After its kind

The phrase attached to the herb and the fruit tree here returns again and again through the chapter, and writers see it as a fixed law stamped on living things.

This is confirmed in Genesis 1 where the formula — "after his kind" — is repeated ten times. It is applied to the vegetable kingdom in verse 11, to the marine world in verse 21, and again to the winged birds in the same verse, and finally to the beasts of the earth and cattle and everything that creeps upon the earth in verse 25. Why "after his kind"? That clearly leaves room for each species. The lion does not mate with the tigress. The eagle does not consort with the goose. The wasp does not breed with the bee.

A. J. Pollock

Life out of the waters

The double "good" belongs to this day alone. One writer sees in it a meaning that reaches past creation.

God also put a striking mark on the third day at creation. Before that day the waters of death covered everything. On that day the waters drew back, and living, fruitful things sprang out of the dry land... On this day, and on this day only, we are told twice that "God saw that it was good." Why twice? Surely to teach us that the third day, the day of life springing out of death, was good not only as to creation, but also as to resurrection.

H. H. Snell

Fruit that carries its own seed

Notice the order within the day: grass first, then herb, then the tree whose fruit holds seed inside it.

Then as to the fruit. There is progress; from grass and herb to "fruit trees bearing fruit in which is their seed, on the earth" — another beautiful figure that. The fruit carries within itself the power to keep itself going. The fruit is for the Master's use, and it is well to remember that. The seed is in this fruit according to its kind — love to produce love, and so on. If we want to find love, we must show it. And the riper the fruit is for the Master's taste, the riper the seed is also; the best ripe fruit is that which has hung in the sun most.

Frederick W. Grant

Summary

- Day — Evening and morning mark off an ordinary day. The figurative sense of "day" is only a secondary one.

- Boundary — God gathered the waters and raised the dry land. The landmarks He set that day still shape the earth.

- Provision — The grass, herb and fruit tree were not a fossil stage but food for man and beast.

- Fruit — Life rose out of the waters of death and bore fruit with the seed inside. The third day carries the mark of resurrection, and that life keeps reproducing itself.

Genesis 1:14

And God said, Let there be lights in the expanse of the heavens, to divide between the day and the night; and let them be for signs, and for seasons, and for days and years;

On the fourth day God sets lights in the sky and gives them work to do. Two old questions follow: is this the moment the sun was made, and what are the "signs"?

Set to Work, Not Brought into Being

The verse does not record the making of the sun and moon. Commentators point back to verse 1.

It is certainly not the creation of the sun and so on. Moses does not say that. He says only that God now set the heavenly lights in place, after the plants and before the animals, for the earth that man would live in. Light had shone in another way since the first day of the great week. Now He set the light-bearers of the heavens to do their assigned work, but it is for the earth, and indeed for man. Verse 1 already implied their creation, for God did not create either heaven or earth empty. And what would heaven be without its host? … On the fourth day He gave the lights of heaven their unhindered place, to divide the day from the night.

William Kelly

Written from Where We Stand

The chapter measures the heavens by what they do for the earth below. Size is not the standard here.

It is only their relation to man on earth that shows the exact fitness of the phrase "the two great lights." He who created all things and inspired Moses knew the size of every body in heaven better than Newton or Laplace. But think of what helps man on earth, and Israel especially, and every creature under them. For giving light by day and night, what were all the rest compared to the sun and moon?

William Kelly

What "Signs" Does Not Mean

One misuse of the word is to read fortunes in the stars.

Scripture says the lights in the expanse of the heavens are for "signs" as well as for "seasons." People have wrongly used this passage, treating the varied positions of the sun, moon and planets as a way to foretell events. Of what, then, are they signs? Psalm 19:1-6 perhaps answers that. The huge distances between the heavenly bodies, and the wonderful regularity of their movements, are a sign of the glory of the One who created them.

Morrish Bible Dictionary

Signs at the Turning Points

The word carries a second sense. God has made the sky speak at key moments in Israel's history.

We see what a sign it was to Israel when Joshua said in their hearing, "Sun, stand still at Gibeon, and moon, in the Valley of Aijalon." In far different days the Lord spoke to sick Hezekiah, and gave him a sign in the shadow that went back ten steps on the dial of Ahaz. And what a sign again at the cross of the Messiah, when all was lost as far as man is concerned! Darkness covered all the land for three hours. A mere eclipse was impossible then.

William Kelly

Seasons, Days and Years

The word behind "seasons" carries more than one shade of meaning, and commentators weigh which one fits.

No comment is needed on "seasons": man alone on earth understands and values these fitting, recurring times. The same Hebrew word means "the congregation" and "the solemn feast," as well as the season or appointed time at which they kept it. So "seasons" may have a sacred sense, but the more ordinary sense seems confirmed by what follows. Very little astronomy is needed to know how "days and years" are marked out by these lights, but only for man.

William Kelly

A Picture of Christ and the Church

Commentators also read the fourth day as a picture, where light in the sky stands for light of another kind.

The lights set in the heavens speak very plainly of Christ and of the Church… Here Christ, revealed by the Holy Spirit, shines out for men in the word of His grace. The Church is the responsible reflector of Christ, His letter to the world… Let this scene preach to us that all true and divine light now is heavenly. To let our "light shine" is nothing else than to let men see we belong to another sphere.

Frederick William Grant

For a single believer, the fourth day points away from self.

The sun speaks of the Lord Jesus, "the Sun of Righteousness" (Malachi 4:2), whose brightness is so welcome, yet too dazzling for our eyes… The fourth day teaches us that we must have a proper Object outside of ourselves and of our fruitfulness. The person of the Lord Jesus is that Object. When we are blessed with the sight of His own glory, this lifts our hearts above our circumstances, and above our own spiritual state and experience.

L. M. Grant

Summary

- Appointed — God is not creating the sun here; He is setting it to work, dividing day from night.

- Aimed at earth — sun and moon rank as the great lights because the record measures them by what they do for man, marking his days, years and seasons.

- Signs upward — their steady order points to the glory of their Maker, not to fortunes read in the stars.

- Signs in history — the sun standing still for Joshua, the shadow going back for Hezekiah, darkness at the cross.

- Signs for us — Christ shines and the Church reflects Him; borrow all your light, and let others see where it comes from.

Genesis 1:15

and let them be for lights in the expanse of the heavens, to give light on the earth. And it was so.

On the fourth day God does not make new matter; He gives the lights of the sky a job, and that job is measured by the earth below. So were the sun and moon made here for the first time, or only set to work for us?

Appointed, Not First Created

One writer weighs what the text says and what it does not say.

It is certainly not the creation of the sun and the rest. The inspired historian does not say this. He says only that God now appointed the heavenly lights for the earth of Adam's day, after the plants and before the animals. Light had shone in another way since the first day of the great week. Now He set the light-bearers of the heavens to do their assigned work, but it is for the earth, and indeed for man. Their creation was implied in verse 1, for God did not create either heaven or earth empty; and what would heaven be without its host? ... The same design is repeated: they are to be lights in the expanse of the heavens. It was their effect, not their structure, that is meant.

William Kelly

Another writer names the opposite view, then gives his reason for rejecting it.

Some have thought that light was independent of the sun, that on the first day God created the light, and that on the fourth day He created the sun. But we are not told that on the fourth day He created the sun and the moon, but that He made two great lights... What proves that they were there from the beginning, we believe, is that there was evening and morning on the first day. That shows the daily motion of the earth in relation to the sun, which gives day and night.

A. J. Pollock

Written From Earth's Standpoint

The record measures the sky by what it does for the earth. The stars show how far that goes.

"He made the stars also" (v. 16, in an older translation). The record mentions this only in passing, as something of much lesser importance. Many of the stars turn out to be huge, much larger than the sun. Their number is beyond counting, and their distances range into billions of light years. Yet the sun and the moon are more important to us on earth, and God's revelation is for the benefit of human beings.

L. M. Grant

"And It Was So"

The verse closes with four words that come again and again through the chapter.

Six times in the chapter the words "And God said" have the fitting sequel, "and it was so." From the very start, the word of God shows itself powerful. It never fails of its effect. How encouraging to learn this in the first chapter of the Bible, for we may be sure it applies to every word that God has spoken. When we reach the end of the story we shall be able to say with triumph, "and it was so," about every promise He has made, every prediction He has uttered.

F. B. Hole

The Greater Light

One writer reads the sun as a picture of Christ, because of what sunrise does to a long night.

The sun is the great centre of light, and the centre of our system. The lesser bodies revolve around him and get their light from him. So we may rightly see him as a fitting symbol of Him who is soon to arise, with healing in His wings... The mists and shades of night are all scattered, and the whole creation seems to welcome the returning source of light.

C. H. Mackintosh

The Lesser Light

One writer applies the fourth day to the present.

The lights set in the heavens speak very plainly of Christ and of the Church... Christ, revealed by the Holy Spirit, shines out for people in the word of His grace. The Church is the responsible reflector of Christ, His letter to the world... Let this scene preach to us that all true and divine light now is heavenly. To let our "light shine" is nothing else than to let people see we belong to another sphere.

F. W. Grant

The moon carries a warning as well as a lesson.

The moon is a fitting illustration of the church, and it guards against the tendency to exalt the church at the expense of her Head. It is a dark body with no light of its own, and its only usefulness lies in reflecting the light of the sun. Moonshine, strictly, there is none — it is the reflected light of the sun. So the only use the church can be in this world is shedding the light of Christ during the night of His absence.

A. J. Pollock

Summary

- Set, not started. The fourth day gives the heavenly bodies their job, not their beginning. Verse 1 already implies their creation.

- Set for earth. The record measures everything by what reaches the ground. That is why stars far larger than the sun get one passing clause.

- Set by a word. Six times "God said" ends with "and it was so." That unbroken pattern stands behind every promise God has spoken since.

- Set as a picture. The greater light points to Christ, whose rising scatters the night. The lesser light points to His people, who shine in the night with borrowed light.

- Set to reflect. A dark body shines only with light it receives. That is the calling, and the limit, of any witness during the night of Christ's absence.

Genesis 1:16

And God made the two great lights, the great light to rule the day, and the small light to rule the night, -- and the stars.

On the fourth day God turns from shaping the earth to filling the sky. One verse hands the day and the night to two rulers, then adds the stars in a few words. That wording raises real questions. Were the sun and moon created here? Why "made" and not "created"? And why do the stars get so little space?

Made, Not Created

The verb here is not the verb of verse 1. One writer sets the two words side by side:

Notice that the word "made" (v. 16) is not the same as "created" (v. 1). The verse does not say that sun, moon and stars were created at the time of verse 16. It says that God then appointed them as lights for the earth. The Bible is not a textbook on astronomy, yet its language is exact: it never confuses creating things with setting them in their order.

Various

That reading answers an old objection — that light on day one without a sun is impossible:

The work of the fourth day has caused difficulty for many. Years ago, under mistaken scientific ideas, people thought light (v. 3) without the sun (v. 16) was impossible. And people did not read closely what verses 14 to 18 do say, and do not say. Sun and moon were created as given us in verse 1; they were only made as "two great lights" on the fourth day.

F. B. Hole

Written From the Earth's Point of View

Calling the sun and moon the two great lights is not a ranking by size. Something else sets the scale here:

Even here, where the subject is the heavenly bodies, the record looks at them only in view of man and this earth... On the fourth day He gave the lights of heaven their unhindered place, to divide the day from the night.

William Kelly

Two Lights to Rule

The word "rule" matters. Scripture uses these lights as a picture of authority in three levels.

In this symbolism the stars stand for subordinate authority. So the sun is supreme, the moon derived, and the stars subordinate. They are also light-bearers, and God Himself sets them in the expanse of heaven. Keeping these features in mind helps when the same symbol is applied to the angels of the churches.

The Christian's Friend

God's Timekeepers

The lights that govern day and night also mark out time. One writer follows that to its end:

Time is tied to the "two great lights" (Gen. 1:16), which God set in the heavens "for signs and for seasons, and for days and years" (v. 14). When these disappear, time stops and eternity begins.

A. J. Pollock

And the Stars

The verse gives the stars only three words.

One writer explains why the smaller bodies get the larger place:

The stars are mentioned as though they were incidental and of much less importance. Many of them are huge, far larger than the sun, their distances run into billions of light years, and no one can count them. Yet the sun and the moon matter more to us on earth, and God's revelation is for the benefit of human beings.

L. M. Grant

The Sun and the Moon as Pictures

Commentators also read the greater and lesser lights as a picture of Christ and the church:

Now, as the sun is a beautiful and fitting symbol of Christ, so the moon strikingly reminds us of the Church. The source of her light is hidden from view. The world does not see Him, but she sees Him; and she is responsible to reflect His beams upon a darkened world.

C. H. Mackintosh

The picture also sets a limit on what the church may claim:

The moon is a good illustration of the church, guarding against the tendency to exalt the church at the expense of her Head. It is a body with no light of its own, and its only usefulness lies in reflecting the light of the sun. Strictly, there is no such thing as moonshine — it is the reflected light of the sun. So the only use the church can be in this world is to shed the light of Christ during the night of His absence.

after_note: DISCUSS

A. J. Pollock

These pictures need care. One writer draws the line:

People often mistake how a symbol is applied for what it means. Christ is called the Sun of Righteousness; but Sun does not mean Christ. The sun is only a symbol of glory and supreme government. God made the sun to rule the day (Gen. 1:16). It is a mistake to drop that general idea and take the sun to mean Christ.

J. N. Darby

Summary

- Made — the verb is not "created". Here God appointed the sun and moon as lights for the earth; He did not bring them into being.

- Measured — the record speaks from the earth's standpoint. "Great" means great to us, which is why huge stars get only three words.

- Ruling — the lights govern: the sun supreme, the moon derived, the stars subordinate. They also mark out time itself.

- Reflecting — the moon has no light of its own. Commentators see in it the church, shining only with light borrowed from Christ.

- Restrained — how a symbol is used is not what it means. The sun pictures supreme government, so calling the sun Christ goes too far.

Genesis 1:17

And God set them in the expanse of the heavens, to give light on the earth,

God's fourth day of work ends with an act of placing. He puts the lights where they belong and gives them a job to do. So what does it mean that God "set" them? And why does Scripture describe this work in the heavens by what it does for the earth below?

The word "set"

The verb "set" means more than putting something in place. One writer looks at its form:

This word first appears in Genesis 1:17, where we read that God set "two great lights" in the expanse. The verb here is in the middle (reflexive) voice, so the glory of the action belongs to the One who performed it.

F. A. Hughes

Appointment rather than creation

Commentators read this day as the ordering of things already made, not the first making of sun and moon. Scripture mentions the stars almost in passing, and that restraint has a purpose:

I fully believe that God set the sun and the moon at this time to be for signs and seasons and years, and to make day and night. But the account looks at them here only in what they do for the earth, and only as lights. God made the two great lights, and God gave them as such. There is no creation of the bodies here. What we have is the setting up of how they appear and work, and their purpose. So when he speaks of the stars, he only reminds us that God had made them too. Instead of men worshipping them, God had distributed them to all men under heaven.

J. N. Darby

God set them in "the expanse of the heavens." That word carries a range of meaning:

The Hebrew word is raqia, meaning 'expanse.' It stands for the sky we see when we look up, and also for the air in which the birds fly. We read that God called the expanse 'heaven.' This is 'heaven' in a broad sense. Elsewhere we read of 'the stars of heaven,' but also of 'the birds of heaven.'

Morrish Bible Dictionary

Everything measured by the earth

The whole account of this day is written from the ground up. What God pronounced good was not the newness of these bodies but the work He handed them:

God gave sun and moon to rule over the day and over the night. They were His creatures and gifts for man's use, dividing between the light and the darkness. "And God saw that it was good" — not as if they had just been created, but in the assigned work He gave them to do.

William Kelly

That arrangement still steadies ordinary human life, right down to navigation:

We see the wisdom and kindness of our faithful Creator in these lights above us, and we enjoy them and give thanks for them. Life would be impossible without them. They bring order, method, variety and guidance into our lives. Anyone who wants to live well and long must not ignore "the signs and seasons and days and years" for which these lights were made. The shipmaster steers his ship safely if he can take his bearings by the lights in the sky. Many a fine ship has been lost because her crew steered by dead reckoning.

J. T. Mawson

Light and rule together

God placed the lights above the earth they serve. One writer sees a pattern there for how the earth is governed:

The fourth day of creation showed that earth was to be ruled from heaven, and that the authorities were to have their place there.

James Boyd

The sun and the moon as a picture

One writer takes the two lights as a picture of Christ and the church:

As the sun is a beautiful and fitting symbol of Christ, so the moon strikingly reminds us of the church. The source of her light is hidden from view. The world does not see Him, but she sees Him; and she is responsible to reflect His beams upon a darkened world. The world has no other way to learn anything of Christ except through the church. "You," says the inspired apostle, "are our letter … known and read by all."

C. H. Mackintosh

Read that way, the lights in heaven show where a believer's light must come from:

Let this scene preach to us that all true and divine light now is heavenly. To let our "light shine" is nothing else than to let people see that we belong to another sphere, and that we are not of the world, even as Christ was not. It is to let them see our faces brightened with the joy of what He is. Our hearts are satisfied with Himself, and so independent of the broken cisterns from which they try to draw refreshment.

Frederick William Grant

Summary

- Set. The verb points back to the One acting; the glory of placing the lights belongs to God Himself.

- Purposed. This is not the first making of the sun and moon but the fixing of their work — and it rules out worshipping them.

- Given. They are gifts for human use, and what God calls good is the work He assigns them, not their bare existence.

- Ruling. The lights stand above the earth they light, marking out that the earth is ruled from heaven.

- Reflected. Applied to us, the light we shine is borrowed light, and its whole worth lies in showing others the One it comes from.

Genesis 1:18

and to rule during the day and during the night, and to divide between the light and the darkness. And God saw that it was good.

Made, Not First Created

The wording here is careful, and readers often miss it. The fourth day sets the lights in place; it is not when they first came into being.

The work of the fourth day has caused difficulty for many. Partly because years ago, under mistaken scientific ideas, light (v. 3) without the sun (v. 16) was thought impossible. Partly because people did not carefully notice what verses 14 to 18 actually say, and do not say. Sun and moon were created as given to us in verse 1; they were only made as "two great lights" on the fourth day. Further, they were set in relation to the earth — or the earth to them, as the case may be — so that they ruled over the day and over the night. In this way they divided the light from the darkness.

F. B. Hole

The Verdict "Good" Falls on Their Service

God's approval here is attached to something specific. It is not admiration of newly minted objects but satisfaction in the work assigned to them.

God gave sun and moon to rule over the day and over the night. They were His creatures and gifts for man's use, dividing between the light and the darkness. "And God saw that it was good" — not as if they had just been created, but in the assigned work He gave them to do.

William Kelly

The word "good" is repeated across the chapter, and one writer draws a large conclusion from that.

All that God made was good. This is said five times (in verses 10, 12, 18, 21, and 25) about matter, whether living or not. These are important statements, because the ordered scene of creation was so soon invaded by evil. It proves that the evil was an invasion from outside and not produced from within. All as it left God's hand was perfect and undefiled.

F. B. Hole

Rule That Comes From Above — and Its Perversion

The word "rule" is not decorative. From the start, the earth takes its light and its order from above. That pattern says something about how God governs.

Then again, they were to rule, one over the day and one over the night. From the outset God placed the earth under the rule and control of heaven, even in the working of lifeless matter. So these heavenly bodies become a sign that "Heaven rules" (Dan. 4:26), and a faint prophecy of "the kingdom of heaven," which we read of in the Gospel of Matthew. Sadly, fallen man soon twisted all this. He began to worship these lights as though they were creator and not creature, and so changed God's truth into a lie. Romans 1:25 refers to this, we believe.

F. B. Hole

Two Lights, Two Kinds of Light

Now, as the sun is a beautiful and fitting symbol of Christ, so the moon strikingly reminds us of the church. The source of her light is hidden from view. The world does not see Him, but she sees Him; and she is responsible to reflect His beams on a darkened world. The world has no other way of learning anything of Christ except through the church. "You yourselves are our letter ... known and read by all," says the inspired apostle. And again, "You show that you are a letter from Christ." (2 Cor. 3:2-3.)

C. H. Mackintosh

The same writer's grammar is worth noticing: the lesser light is given a rule of its own, not merely a glow. One writer draws that parallel out, and adds that the present arrangement is temporary.

His is a full, unchanging, underived light; hers a reflected, unsteady one. Yet it is said, "The moon to govern the night," just as it is, "The sun to rule the day." "You are the light of the world," just as "I am the light of the world." But Christ is absent, and it is now night — although, thank God, "the night is far spent, the day is at hand."

The Christian's Friend

The Safeguard Built Into the Picture

If the church is the moon, the picture itself corrects anyone who makes her the source of the light instead of the channel.

But here we are on ground that has its dangers. The Roman Catholic system exalted the church at the expense of her Head, and this tendency is clearly seen in quarters where it was least expected. The moon is a fitting illustration of the church, and it guards against this tendency. It is a dark body with no light of its own. Its only usefulness lies in reflecting the light of the sun. Strictly speaking there is no such thing as moonlight — it is the reflected light of the sun. So the only use the church can be in this world is shedding the light of Christ during the night of His absence.

A. J. Pollock

Summary

- Made — sun and moon were created in verse 1. On the fourth day God made them "two great lights," set in relation to the earth to govern and divide.

- Given — they rule as creatures and gifts for man's use, never as powers in their own right.

- Ruled — the earth takes its light and order from above, a sign that "Heaven rules." Man's sin was to worship the lights instead of their Maker.

- Reflected — the sun pictures Christ, the moon the church. Her light is all borrowed, and her one use is to shine it into the night of His absence.

- Good — God's approval rests on the work He assigned, not on the objects. Creation is called good five times, so the evil that later spoiled it came from outside.

Genesis 1:19

And there was evening, and there was morning -- a fourth day.

Genesis 1:19 closes the fourth day, the day God set the sun and moon in the sky to mark signs, seasons, days and years. Its last words raise three questions: did God make the lights then or only give them a job, why call the work "good", and why does evening come first?

Appointed, Not First Created

So did the sun and moon begin on day four? One writer says no.

It is certainly not the creation of the sun and the rest. The inspired historian does not say that, but only that God now appointed the heavenly lights, after the plants and before the animals, for the earth of Adam's day. Light had shone in another way since the first day of that great week. Now He set the light-bearers of the heavens to do their assigned work, but it is for the earth, and indeed for man.

William Kelly

Signs for a People on Earth

A sign needs a reader. The same writer names times when Israel saw these lights act as signs.

Suppose this happened an age before Adam — thousands, millions of years. What sense would there be in light-bearers "for signs and for seasons, and for days and years"? ... We see what a sign it was to Israel when Joshua said in their hearing, "Sun, stand still at Gibeon, and moon, in the Valley of Aijalon." In far different days the Lord spoke to sick Hezekiah, and gave him a sign in the shadow that went back ten steps on the dial of Ahaz. And what a sign again at the cross of the Messiah, where everything was lost as far as man is concerned! There darkness covered the whole land for three hours.

William Kelly

"Good", and an Ordinary Day

God's "good" here is not praise for something new. He approves the work He gave the lights — and day four then runs like any day since.

The stars only come in as an aside. God made them too, even if blind man turned them into gods. But God gave sun and moon to rule over the day and over the night. They were His creatures and gifts for man's use, dividing between the light and the darkness. "And God saw that it was good" — not as though they had just been created, but good in the work He gave them to do. "And there was evening and there was morning, the fourth day." No one can honestly deny it: that day's work must give us the ordinary alternation of night and day. The same daily turning followed for the fifth and sixth days, as for every day since, including the seventh. If so, consistency surely requires the same for the three days before.

William Kelly

Why Evening Comes First

Why does the verse name evening before morning? One writer traces the order back to day one.

As to the day, evening and morning: God called the light created out of darkness "day". But there was no morning then. So evening comes first — the disappearance of light. ... Genesis does not count the night, except by implication. It was the original state — absence of light — not a creation. God's works are in the light. If darkness came on, light appeared again — the dawn — there was morning. Evening is named first because it closed the day that the incoming light had just created, or ordered.

J. N. Darby

The Two Lights as a Picture

The two lights are not equal, and one writer reads that difference as a picture.

The great light of the day is the source of heat and light to the earth. Its light is its own. It never changes, and it is as constant as the day it brings. It clearly shows us the Heavenly One, back in the glory He came from. The lesser light rules the night, and its light is borrowed from His. At its best it is cold and dull by comparison. It also changes — full-faced or shrunken, depending on whether it fully faces Him or is turned away from Him. How easily we read that too.

Frederick W. Grant

Another writer weighs a second difference: the two lights never shine at once.

Of what are they typical? The answer is Christ and the church. The sun and the moon do not shine at one and the same time. The sun shines by day. The moon by night. That is the present relation between Christ and His church. Our Lord, in His earthly life, was the light of men, but wicked men led by religious rulers crucified Him. While He is absent, the church is to shine for Him in this world.

A. J. Pollock

Summary

- Set — Day four gives the sun and moon their task; it does not make them. Light had shone since day one.

- Aimed — Day four aims at earth and man. Signs, seasons, days and years matter only to people who live under that sky.

- Approved — "Good" praises the work God gave the lights, not their newness. They rule as His gifts, never as gods.

- Ordered — Evening comes first because darkness closed the day that light began. Then dawn answers it. The night is not a creation.

- Reflected — The sun's light is its own. The moon's light is borrowed and changing, bright only while it faces the source. So Christ shines, and His people shine for Him in the night of His absence.

Genesis 1:20

And God said, Let the waters swarm with swarms of living souls, and let fowl fly above the earth in the expanse of the heavens.

On the fifth day the world stops being empty scenery. Life swarms in the seas, and wings fill the sky. This one verse raises two questions. What new order of life begins here? And did God really say the water produced the birds?

Life of a New Order

Up to now God had made light, sky, sea, land and plants. Day five brings in something new, and one writer finds the sign of it in a single word. He quotes the verse in older English wording.

In verse 21 we get the word "created" for the second time. It appeared in verse 1, the original creation of the heaven and the earth. The intervening verses have told us what God made out of His original creation. Why does the word occur again here? We believe it is because here God commanded the waters to bring forth "the moving creature that has life." Plants show nutrition, growth and reproduction. Here we see a completely different order of life: creatures that can feel and move by their own will. Indeed the word translated "creature" in verses 20 and 21 really means "soul." So on this fifth day God brought in a higher form of life, a life that involves soul. That is why this was creation in the full sense.

F. B. Hole

Did the Waters Produce the Birds?

Older English Bibles read as though the sea gave birth to birds. One writer traces the objection to the translation, not the text.

Chapter 2 shows that birds were made out of the earth; but Genesis 1:20, critics say, means that birds were made out of the waters. Genesis 1 says nothing of the sort. It agrees perfectly with Genesis 2:19. The objection shows the danger of reasoning from a mistake that has crept into a translation, instead of from Scripture itself. This verse does not teach that the waters were to bring forth birds, though our English version makes it look that way. It reads, "Let the waters bring forth abundantly the moving creature, and let birds fly about the earth in the open expanse of heaven." The point is that the birds fly in that sphere. The verse never says the waters gave birth to them.

William Kelly

Answering the same objection elsewhere, he shows the two clauses stand apart:

Nothing really is said or intended about the waters bringing forth birds: the latter are spoken of in a distinct clause... The true rendering is, "Let the waters bring forth abundantly, etc. and let birds fly, etc." There is no discrepancy in this case to be reconciled.

William Kelly

The ESV above follows this reading: the waters swarm, and the birds fly.

Home Before Inhabitant

The order of the six days is not random.

The waters now teem with life, and birds fly in the air... It is beautiful to see God's goodness at work in all this! He first creates a setting where His creatures can live. Plant life, for instance, needs dry land to grow on. So God first brings the dry land up out of the waters. Animals need plant food, so He supplies plenty of it before He brings these creatures into being.

Samuel Ridout

The First Blessing in the Bible

The first blessing in the Bible does not fall on man.

The first blessing of creation was when God made the creatures that filled the waters and the air of Adam's world. They were the first to enjoy animal life in that world. God takes pleasure in blessing His creatures. Their life is lowly, yet it can still enjoy the fruits of His goodness. He blesses them above all with a view to their reproducing and multiplying within their own sphere.

William Kelly

Souls — But Not Like Man's

Fish and birds are called "living creatures," where older Bibles read "living souls." Some argue from this that man is no different from an animal. The reply turns on how each one received life.

Animals have living souls as part of their creation. About them God said, "Let the waters bring forth," or, "Let the earth bring forth." But God formed man of the dust of the ground, and "breathed into his nostrils the breath of life; and man became a living creature." So man was unlike every other creature in two ways. God created him in His own image, and he "became a living soul" because God breathed into him.

H. H. Snell

The Same Voice, Heard Again

One writer hears the voice of this verse again in the Gospels. A man standing before Jesus recognized it.

He felt that he was in the presence of the One whose voice said ages before, "Let the waters swarm with swarms of living creatures" (Gen. 1:20). He realized that God had come down from heaven to earth. His sinful condition rose up before him — his unfitness to stay in the divine presence. So he fell at Jesus' knees saying, "Depart from me, for I am a sinful man, O Lord."

W. W. Fereday

Summary

- Word — God speaks, and the seas and skies fill with life. The same voice later brought a man to his knees before Jesus.

- Soul — "Creature" here means "soul": life that feels and moves. It stands above plants, so the word "created" returns.

- Order — God prepares the home before He brings in the tenants. His goodness shows in the sequence, not just the result.

- Blessing — God's first recorded blessing falls on fish and birds, so they may multiply and fill their sphere.

- Distinction — Animals received life by a command to the waters. Man became a living soul when God breathed into him.

Genesis 1:21

And God created the great sea monsters, and every living soul that moves with which the waters swarm, after their kind, and every winged fowl after its kind. And God saw that it was good.

The fifth day of creation fills the seas and the sky with life. Here the Bible uses the word "created" for only the second time since verse 1. That word, and the phrase "according to their kinds," carry the weight of the verse.

Why "Created" Returns Here

At verse 21 the word "created" returns, and one writer ties it to something the plant world never had.

In verse 21 we get the word "created" for the second time. It appeared in verse 1, the original creation of the heaven and the earth. The intervening verses have told us what God made out of His original creation. Why does the word occur again here? We believe it is because here God commanded the waters to bring forth "living creatures that move." In the vegetable kingdom we see nutrition, growth and reproduction. Here we see an entirely different order of things: creatures with the power to feel and to move by their own will. Indeed the word translated "creature" in verses 20 and 21 is really "soul."

F. B. Hole

Where this word appears next, and where it does not, shows where the real dividing lines fall.

God had created the heavens and the earth before. Now He creates animate life, another order of creation entirely. So Scripture does not use the word when God brought in the animals on the sixth day. It uses it again when we are told, "God created man in His own image" (v. 27), for man is a completely different order of creation. There is a link between sea creatures, birds and animals, but none of these have any such link with mankind.

L. M. Grant

The "Great Sea Creatures"

Older translations read "great whales" here. The Hebrew word is far broader than that, and the same term shows up elsewhere for very different animals.

The word tannin, used in Genesis 1:21, Job 7:12 and Ezekiel 32:2, refers to any sea monsters, without defining any particular one. … The Hebrew word tannin is also translated in the Authorised Version 'dragon,' 'sea monster,' and 'serpent.'

Morrish Bible Dictionary

Commentators differ over whether whales in particular are meant. One writer notes how carefully the account marks them off from the fish.

Moses clearly separated fish, which are cold-blooded animals, from the warm-blooded creatures of the sea. Those creatures nurse their young, and they must come to the surface of the sea to breathe. … What could Moses know of such things? … And yet Moses made no mistakes in his narrative.

A. J. Pollock

Where the Birds Came From

Some have read this passage as saying the sea produced the birds. A correct translation removes the error.

A correct translation here, as the reader can see, destroys the error that commentators, both Jewish and Christian, have tried to explain. The sense is not that the waters produced the birds. It is that God made them fly in the open expanse of the heavens. Compare Genesis 2:19, which plainly teaches that God formed the birds out of the ground, just as He formed the beast of the field.

William Kelly

"According to Their Kinds"

The phrase appears twice in this one verse: once for the sea life, once for the birds. Older translations read "after his kind," and one writer traces that formula through the chapter.

In Genesis 1 the formula — "after his kind" — is repeated ten times. It covers the plants in verse 11, the sea life and the winged birds in verse 21, and the beasts, the cattle and everything that creeps on the earth in verse 25. Why "after his kind"? That leaves room for each species. The lion does not mate with the tigress. The eagle does not consort with the goose. The wasp does not breed with the bee.

A. J. Pollock

Written for Man's World

The record covers sea life and bird life as a whole, and it looks ahead to what God places under man's rule.

The clear intention was to impress on all who heed the written word that the fifth day's work covered the whole circle of water animals, as well as all the bird life known to mankind… If the inspired writer speaks of what concerns man in daily life, this agrees with the blessing God spoke: "Be fruitful and multiply and fill the waters in the seas, and let birds multiply on the earth." Verses 26 and 28 confirm it strongly, for there God gives man dominion over the fish of the sea, no less than over the birds of the air.

William Kelly

A Lesson from Sea and Sky

One writer draws a personal lesson from this day for the believer.

The waters of turmoil, distress and unrest — that is, our experiences of deep trial — will bring forth abundant blessing in a way only God can do. … The power and grace of God produces some of our greatest blessing through our greatest trouble and sorrow. The birds flying in the heavens teach us that by faith our spirit may rise high above the level of our circumstances.

L. M. Grant

Summary

- Created. The word returns for the first time since verse 1. Creatures that feel and move by their own will are a new order of life, not a rearrangement of what was there.

- Soul. The word for "creature" here is really "soul." These are living souls, a step above the plant world.

- Kind. Twice in one verse God fixes life "according to their kinds," leaving room for each species.

- Distinguished. The great sea creatures stand apart from the swarming life beside them, and God formed the birds from the ground, not from the waters.

- Blessed. God calls the work good and tells it to multiply — filling the very seas and skies He would later place under man's rule.

Genesis 1:22

And God blessed them, saying, Be fruitful and multiply, and fill the waters in the seas, and let fowl multiply on the earth.

The Bible's first recorded blessing falls not on man but on fish and birds, spoken over creatures made on the fifth day. What does it mean for God to bless them, why does the blessing come as a command, and why do these creatures receive it first?

The first blessing in Scripture

One writer compares this blessing with the one given to man six verses later, and notes a difference in the wording of each:

This is the second benediction of creation. The first was when God made the creatures that peopled the waters and the air of Adam's world, the first to enjoy animal life in that world. God takes pleasure in blessing His creatures, whose life, though lowly, can still enjoy the fruits of His goodness. He blesses them above all with a view to their reproducing and multiplying within their sphere. Here, a second time, He blessed mankind, male and female. In verse 22 we have only "saying," but here "God said to them, Be fruitful."

William Kelly

So the blessing is spoken over the fish and birds; only man is spoken to directly. Still, blessing is the Bible's first word over any creature. The opposite word comes later, and for a reason:

Sadly, we have to hear the voice of cursing as well as the voice of blessing, because God must give expression to what He hates. So as soon as man falls away from Him we hear the curse pronounced. It is as clear and as strong as the blessing ever was: "Cursed," God says, "is the ground because of you" (Gen. 3:17)... Blessing, however, is the first thing we read of.

James Boyd

Blessing in the form of a command

The blessing comes as an order: be fruitful, multiply, fill. One writer notes this as the first command in the chapter, and ties it to the creative power that had just brought these creatures into being:

Then we first get the imperative used. They now exist through creative power. So He commands them, through reproduction, to "be fruitful, and multiply, and fill the seas." And He declares that "the birds shall multiply" — again a future tense, not a present.

G. V. Wigram

Increase, then, is not something matter achieves on its own. The same writer applies this against the idea that life or growth arises from within nature: "the power and the wisdom of the originator is what settles the lines of extension."

Why these creatures are blessed

God had already made grass and herb, yet He blessed neither. Something new appears on the fifth day:

The fifth day brings another change of scene... But now even here the power of God is working; the waters swarm with swarms of living creatures, and birds fly in the open expanse of the heavens. It is still progress in the great creative plan, and life reaches new and higher forms than before. It is not now grass and herb, but the "living soul," and God blesses them, and bids them multiply.

Frederick W Grant

Goodness that prepares before it fills

The blessing comes after God has made sea and sky ready to hold what would fill them:

See how beautifully God's goodness works in all this! He first creates a place where His creatures can live. For instance, plant life needs dry land to grow on. That, therefore, is first brought up out of the waters. Animals need plant food, and He first supplies it in abundance before He brings these creatures into being. God's whole work, as we have already said, is always a prophecy of the good things to come.

Samuel Ridout

The creatures man would rule

The blessing names the seas and the earth — the spheres later handed to man. One writer reads the account as written for what concerns man in practice:

If, on the other hand, the inspired writer speaks of what concerns man in practice, that agrees with God's spoken blessing: "Be fruitful and multiply and fill the waters in the seas, and let birds multiply on the earth." Verses 26 and 28 confirm it strikingly. There God gives man dominion over the fish of the sea, no less than over the birds of the air, and beast and cattle and all that creep on the earth.

William Kelly

A picture read forward

One writer offers a picture, not a settled reading. He links the filling of the seas with the gospel going out beyond one nation:

In Revelation 17:15 we have seen that the waters John saw in his vision stood for peoples and multitudes and nations and tongues. Does it not seem that the peopling of the seas is symbolic of God's gracious work among the Gentiles through the Gospel? The Old Testament testimony kept very largely to the children of Israel... The great feature of the New Testament is, however, the Gospel of God going out world-wide to the very ends of the earth.

A J Pollock

Summary

- Blessing first. God's first word over any creature is blessing. Cursing enters Scripture only after man falls away.

- Blessing prepared. God builds the environment before He fills it — sea and sky are ready before anything is told to fill them.

- Blessing given. The creatures exist by God's creative power, and they multiply at His command.

- Blessing received. It falls on "living souls," a higher order than herb and tree, able to enjoy the goodness God gives.

- Blessing spreading. The command to fill the waters and the earth points forward: to man's rule over both, and — as one writer suggests — to a gospel that reaches every nation.

Genesis 1:23

And there was evening, and there was morning -- a fifth day.

The same words close the fifth day that closed each day before it. They raise two questions commentators press hard: is this an ordinary day, and why does a day start in the evening?

A day, not an age

The repetition itself is the argument.

Why the repetition of "there was evening and there was morning" (vv. 5, 8, 13, 19, 23, 31)? All plain enough if an ordinary day is meant — remember, the Jewish day began at 6 p.m. On the larger scale it would only say that the period had a beginning and an ending — an obvious fact, not worth mentioning, much less repeating.

F. B. Hole

Why evening comes first

The order of the words matters. It sets how the Bible counts a day, and missing that has tangled readers up in the Gospels.

Next the day is counted from the evening and the morning. That statement is of great importance for other parts of Scripture. The Spirit of God never forgets it, but modern readers almost always let it slip. That forgetfulness has been a great source of the difficulties that burden efforts to line up the Gospel accounts... People have found such puzzles, for instance, over our Lord's keeping of the Passover compared with the Jews', and over the crucifixion. The reason is that they forget that the evening and the morning made up the first day, the second day, or any other.

William Kelly

The day life began

Until now the earth had been shaped, lit and covered with plants. The fifth day adds life — and God does more than make it. He blesses it.

The fifth day brings another change of scene. We might have thought we had left the barren waste of waters behind for good. Yet here we come back to it. But now even here the power of God is working; the waters swarm with swarms of living creatures, and birds fly in the open expanse of heaven. It is still progress in the great creative plan, and life reaches new and higher forms than before. It is not now grass and herb, but the "living soul," and God blesses them, and bids them multiply.

Frederick W. Grant

The word "created" also returns on this day.

This chapter uses the word "created" for the second time (v. 21). God had created the heavens and the earth before. Now He creates animate life — a wholly different order of creation.

Leslie M. Grant

Written for man's world

Some try to match the fifth day to a geological age. The text has a different aim: the sea and sky life people know.

The clear intention was to impress, on all who heed the written word, that the fifth day's work covered the whole circle of water animals and all the bird life known to mankind... Verses 26 and 28 confirm this strongly. There God gives man dominion over the fish of the sea, no less than over birds of the air, and beast and cattle and all that creep on the earth. The only detail, in fact, sets out the origin of what was put under man's rule.

William Kelly

What the day pictures

Commentators differ over what the fifth day pictures. Some read it as a coming time of trouble, with the faith of God's people rising out of it.

The period that will follow the Church's time on earth is that brief but troubled time which fills so much of the book of Revelation. Out of this fearful time of trouble, the faith of Israel will reach a clearness and energy perhaps not known even in Israel's best days. It will be found in the feeble remnant that turns in penitence to God. Out of that turmoil will rise a spiritual life such as Israel never had before: a life which, in the birds flying in the open expanse of heaven, suggests a liberty and a power that promise well for the glories of the coming age.

Samuel Ridout

Others read the waters as the nations, and the day as the gospel spreading beyond one people.

We have seen in Revelation 17:15 that the waters John saw in his vision stood for peoples and multitudes and nations and tongues. Does it not seem that the peopling of the seas pictures God's gracious work among the Gentiles through the gospel? The Old Testament testimony went mainly to the children of Israel... The great feature of the New Testament is the gospel going out worldwide to the very ends of the earth.

A. J. Pollock

The refrain that stops

The formula runs through six days. Then it stops.

In the first six days we read of the evening and the morning. On the seventh day there is no mention of this, for time is not counted in eternity.

Leslie M. Grant

Summary

- Counted — the closing words mark off a real day. For a vast age, saying it had a start and an end would be too obvious to repeat six times.

- Evening first — the day runs from evening to morning. Forget that, and the Gospel accounts turn puzzling.

- Created — the word used of the heavens and the earth returns on this day, because animate life is a new order. The day covers the sea and sky life man was later given to rule.

- Blessed — God does not only make the sea creatures and the birds. He blesses them and tells them to multiply. Some read that spreading life as a picture of the gospel reaching the nations.

- Unending — the refrain runs through six days, then stops. The seventh day has no evening, because eternity is not counted in days.

Genesis 1:24

And God said, Let the earth bring forth living souls after their kind, cattle, and creeping thing, and beast of the earth, after their kind. And it was so.

The sixth day opens with a command to the earth, and the dry land fills with animal life. Two questions run through the verse: what is a "living creature," and why does the making of man, later the same day, read so differently?

Living Creature Means Living Soul

The same Hebrew words describe the sea creatures earlier in the chapter. One writer follows that word through the chapter.

In verse 20 God spoke of the sea creatures that have life — and the Hebrew word behind "creature" there is "nephesh," soul. Verse 21 uses the same word again: every living creature that moves is a living soul. Verse 24 says it once more of the land: "Let the earth bring forth living creatures according to their kinds." So by His word God made them living souls on the earth.

The Christian's Friend

Three Classes, Not A Scientific List

The verse names three groups. One writer takes each word in turn and shows what it covers.

It is not out of place to name "cattle" first in verse 24. These are the animals that can be tamed, even if they were not tamed yet, and they suit the use of man. "Creeping thing" comes next, in its more literal sense. "Moving," used earlier, described more fully how the creatures of the waters act, so it took in not only serpents and the like but insect life. "Animal of earth" means the wild beast.

William Kelly

The verse also names cattle apart from the wild beasts. One writer sees a purpose in that.

We notice too that both verse 24 and verse 25 keep the "beast of the earth" separate from the "cattle." We gather from this that at the first, before sin came in, God designed certain animals for the upkeep and benefit of the man He was about to create. After sin came in, the beasts developed their wild and savage nature, while the cattle stayed fairly tame and useful to man.

F. B. Hole

After His Kind

The verse repeats "according to their kinds" twice. One writer sees a line God has drawn through every living thing.

Notice that each creature is "after his kind." God made the plants and the sea animals the same way on the earlier days. This establishes that species are fixed... One thing is certain: "after his kind" stamps each class of plant and animal life with its own identity. So this Scripture gives evolution no support. Yet we must be careful. In turning away from that extreme theory of unbelief, we must not fall into the opposite error of making endless classes.

Samuel Ridout

Another writer points to what we can see in the animal world.

The lion does not mate with the tigress. The eagle does not pair with the goose. The wasp does not breed with the bee. The only hybrids in creation are of man's arrangement and they are sterile, and come to nothing.

A. J. Pollock

Man Is The Great Exception

The animals come at a command spoken to the ground. When God turns to make man, the words change.

The creation of man was not a mass movement, as the creation of the lower creatures was. Verse 24 describes a mass movement. It takes in the whole of living things on earth, yet there is one great exception — MAN... "And the LORD God formed man of the dust of the ground, and breathed into his nostrils the breath of life; and man became a living soul." There is no mass movement here. A single individual was in view.

A. J. Pollock

Pollock quotes Genesis 2:7 from an older translation, which reads "a living soul." The difference is not only in numbers. It is in the way God acts.

The animals came out of the earth at His will. He had said, "Let the earth bring forth living creatures according to their kinds," and it was so. It was not like that with man. God takes solemn counsel about creating him, and decides to make man in His image, after His likeness.

J. N. Darby

Preparation For What Comes Next

This verse is the first half of the sixth day. Everything in it points to what God does next.

We can compare God's work up to this point to an architect who designs and builds a palace for a royal person to live in. So God prepared all the beautiful world around: sun, moon, stars, clouds, non-living matter, plant life, animal life, with their countless astounding wonders. All of it was ready for this moment of supreme importance, when God created man — a creature He could have fellowship with.

A. J. Pollock

Summary

- Word — The land creatures appear at a command spoken to the earth. No process, no ancestry — "and it was so."

- Soul — "Living creature" translates living soul. Animals are living souls made by God's word. That is why the breath God breathed into man stands out.

- Kind — Twice in one verse God sets a boundary. Each kind keeps its own identity, and no kind turns into another.

- Line — Livestock, creeping things and beasts of the earth are everyday words. They describe animals in relation to man, not a scientific list.

- Crown — This verse finishes the palace. Its royal occupant arrives before the day ends, made by God's counsel, not by a command to the ground.

Genesis 1:25

And God made the beast of the earth after its kind, and the cattle after their kind, and every creeping thing of the ground after its kind. And God saw that it was good.

The sixth day opens not with man but with the land filling with animals: cattle, creeping things, and wild beasts, each held inside its own kind. Two questions run through the verse: why God made these animals rather than created them, and what the phrase about kinds fixes for all of nature. (Writers below quote it as "after his kind," an older translation.)

Made, Not Created

Genesis 1 does not use the same word every time. One writer notices which word is missing here:

In the early part of the sixth day God filled the earth with living souls — beast and cattle and also creeping things. Notice that God made them. It does not say that He created them. They looked very different from the creatures of the waters and the air, yet they were still only "living souls." So the word created appears only when God first created "soul" as something distinct from matter.

F. B. Hole

Three Classes Named

The three names are not a scientific catalogue. One commentator takes each term in turn and warns against forcing science onto them:

Bringing in the herbivores, the reptiles, and the carnivores here is straining after a scientific gloss… Naming "cattle" first in verse 24 is no anachronism. These are the animals that can be tamed, even if not yet tamed, and they suit the use of man. "Creeping thing" follows in its more literal sense… "Animal of earth" means the wild beast. All of them are terms in constant use where man lives and reigns.

William Kelly

The verse also names cattle apart from the beast of the earth. One writer reads that as a clue about the man not yet made:

Notice too that both verse 24 and verse 25 keep the "beast of the earth" separate from the "cattle." We gather from this that at the first, before sin came in, God designed certain animals to support and benefit the man He was about to create. After sin came in, the beasts developed their wild and savage nature, while the cattle stayed tame and useful to man.

F. B. Hole

Boundaries That Hold

The phrase about kinds falls three times in this one verse. Writers read it as a fixed law, and one adds a warning against pushing it too far:

Notice that each creature is "after his kind." This establishes the fixity of species. Scripture does not say what those species were, or how far variety might later develop inside them. In many animal species that variety is so great it is scarcely believable. One thing is certain: "after his kind" stamps its own mark on each class of plant and animal life. So evolution finds no encouragement from this Scripture. Yet in reacting against the extreme of unbelieving theory, we must be careful not to fall into the opposite extreme of making endless classes. A common unity underlies all animal creation. Each class is specially fitted for the work it has to do. Just as plainly, though, barriers that cannot be crossed separate the classes from one another.

Samuel Ridout

Another points to what anyone can watch happening in the fields and the air:

Why "after his kind"? That clearly leaves room for each species. The lion does not mate with the tigress. The eagle does not consort with the goose. The wasp does not breed with the bee. The only hybrids in creation are of man's arrangement, and they are sterile, and come to nothing.

A. J. Pollock

Where the Ordinary Creation Stops

God's verdict of "good" closes this stage of the work. The next verse opens something different:

As to the life we have by nature, God's word formed the beasts out of the ground. There the ordinary creation ended, and God pronounced the beasts good (Gen. 1:25). And then God proceeds in solemn consultation to form man as His image, as lord of all He had created, and in His likeness.

J. N. Darby

A Picture of Men

One writer also reads the three classes as a picture of mankind:

Acts 10:1-15 and verse 28 show that all these animals are typical of mankind. Domesticated animals would speak of the cultured and refined classes of men. Creeping things speak of the more despised classes, in places of lowly humiliation. The beasts of the earth remind us of men in their wild, rebellious state — a third class even more common than the other two. But this work of God on the sixth day was only a preparation for a more important work the same day.

L. M. Grant

Summary

- Made — God made these animals; He did not create them. Scripture keeps the word "created" for the first making of soul, distinct from matter.

- Kind — Three times this one verse draws the same boundary. Variety inside a kind can be great, but no creature crosses out of its kind.

- Cattle — Naming cattle apart from the wild beast points to animals designed from the start for man's use. Wildness came in after sin.

- Good — With this verdict the ordinary creation ends, approved by God before man is even mentioned.

- Then Man — The next verse turns from the ground bringing forth animals to God's own solemn counsel. The whole day was preparing for the greater work still to come.

Genesis 1:26

And God said, Let us make man in our image, after our likeness; and let them have dominion over the fish of the sea, and over the fowl of the heavens, and over the cattle, and over the whole earth, and over every creeping thing that creepeth on the earth.

God does not simply speak man into being as He did the light, the seas and the animals. He stops and takes counsel with Himself. Then He makes a creature who both resembles Him and rules for Him. That raises three questions: who is the "us", what do "image" and "likeness" mean, and what happened to that rule?

A pause before man is made

Every earlier day ends with a verdict of approval. Then the pattern breaks. One writer points out that God finishes the setting before its ruler appears.

God has finished creation as creation. Now He begins to take counsel, in the most solemn way, saying that He will make man in His image and give him rule. So the creation is complete as the setting and the scene. Then God makes man in His own image and sets him over it all. Man stands entirely alone. Everything is finished, and then he is given rule over it.

J. N. Darby

Nothing before this came after God deliberating. He never said "let the earth bring forth" a man.

One thing set man apart from every other creature. God took counsel about him before He made him. What was coming was not a new animal. It was a moral being with wonderful gifts and possibilities.

W. W. Fereday

Who is "us"?

The plural "us" sits beside the singular "His image" in the next verse. Commentators read this as fitting with God being three Persons in one.

That God should say, "Let US," is worthy of note. Elohim is, as we have said, a plural Name. The Old Testament does not reveal the three Persons in the Godhead. But now that God has revealed Them, we can see that the language of our chapter, given by God, fits that truth. In verse 26 it is "Our image". In verse 27 it is "His image". There is no clash here, because the eternal "Three in One" is the One speaking.

F. B. Hole

Writers differ on how much weight the wording can carry. One is more careful:

Think of the plural form of the word and how it goes with singular verbs. Would it not be close to the truth to say this? We cannot treat it as a revelation of the Trinity. Yet it is a way of speaking that shows the Spirit had that truth in mind. He is the third Person there, and He used words whose full force we could only grasp once that teaching had been revealed.

The Bible Treasury

Image and likeness are not the same word

The verse uses two terms. Most writers keep them apart. One writer treats "in our image as our likeness" as saying the two are the same.

"Image" represents. "Likeness" resembles. An image does not have to look like the thing or person it stands for. The coin they showed the Lord Jesus in Matthew 22:20 may not have carried a "likeness" of Caesar, but it did carry an "image" of him. Man is made in the "image" of God. So God places him in this world to represent Him to the lower creatures, in rule and in blessing. That word is about man's position. "Likeness" points to his moral being. He can enter into relationships and carry responsibilities.

W. W. Fereday

The distinction explains why one of the two words is never applied to the Son.

Scripture never says the Son is in the likeness of the invisible God. He is God. To call Him like God might suggest He is not truly God. Still, the Son is "the image of the invisible God". In His own Person He represents God in His character and moral attributes, before the whole universe.

Hamilton Smith

Dominion given, then lost

Being God's image and holding rule belong together.

This is man as the head of creation… He was to represent God here below. Besides that, he was to be like God. He was to have a mind, a spirit able to know God, with no evil in him at all.

William Kelly

That rule did not survive the entry of another power.

God creates the man and the woman. Then He gives them rule "over the fish of the sea and over the birds of the heavens and over the livestock and over all the earth". Move on to Genesis 3, and there Satan has come in. He has gained this headship for himself through the man who had fallen.

The Bible Treasury

What the fall did not erase

Human life is still protected on this ground, long after Eden.

Man is in the image of God, now as always, fallen or not. But sin cost him the likeness of God. When the question is the guilt of taking a man's life, the reason given is that God made him in His own image. This, it is plain, was never lost; it abides, whatever man's state.

William Kelly

The Man the first man pointed to

Adam is read as a picture of Christ, with the dominion passing to Him on a far larger scale.

God created Adam in His own image and set him to rule over the works of His hands. Adam stood at the centre of a vast system placed under him. He was, the apostle says, a picture of the One who was to come. The rule of the Second Adam reaches much further than the rule of the first. He created all things Himself, so He is to inherit all He has created.

J. N. Darby

For the believer, the likeness lost in Eden is remade by a fresh act of creation.

To be true to the image, there must be moral likeness. For us that means a new creation. So Colossians 3:10 says we "have put on the new self, which is being renewed in knowledge after the image of its creator".

Morrish Bible Dictionary

Summary

- Counsel — God deliberated before making man alone, rather than commanding the earth to produce him. He finished the stage first, then brought in its ruler.

- Image — To be God's image is to represent Him. To be His likeness is to resemble Him. Writers differ on whether the two words carry different force.

- Dominion — The image carries a job: to rule the lower creation on God's behalf.

- Ruin — The fall cost man the likeness, and the rule passed to Satan. The image remains, which is why murder counts as an offence against God.

- Recovery — The rule Adam lost belongs to Christ on a wider scale. The likeness returns in those made new after the image of their Creator.

Genesis 1:27

And God created Man in his image, in the image of God created he him; male and female created he them.

The creation account moves through light, sea, sky and living creatures. Then it stops for something different. Here God makes a creature in His own image, male and female. Commentators ask two questions here. What does "image" mean? And how much of it survived the fall, when Adam sinned?

The one creature God took counsel over

Every earlier act of creation came by a word of command. The making of man reads differently. Writers point to the planning behind it.

God did not create man as He had done in every previous case, by a simple order from His lips. The creation of man was the subject of divine counsel. "Let us make man," etc. Notice here that man was to be, and was, made in the image and likeness of God. This is his first great difference from everything God had created before. The second is that he was to rule over all of it.

The Bible Treasury

Image means representation

"Image" is not a word about resemblance in the first place. One writer follows the word through the Bible and points to the coin Jesus asked for.

How the Bible uses the word, in both the Old and New Testaments, seems to show that "image" represents, while "likeness" resembles… In the New Testament, the coin our Lord asked for had the image and inscription of Caesar on its face. It might have been a poor likeness, but it was an unmistakable image of the Roman emperor. It expressed his authority and represented his claim.

William Kelly

The second word, "likeness," adds something the first does not.

God made man, then, to represent Him to the lower creation that He put under him. But he was also made after the likeness of God; that is, he was really like God in certain important respects. Not in all respects of course, for God is infinitely holy and man was merely innocent. Still, man was God's "offspring" (Acts 17:28-29). He is a spirit being, though dressed in a body of flesh and blood. So he has intelligence and a moral sense, and these reflect what exists on an infinite scale in God Himself.

F. B. Hole

A divine pattern, not a human projection

Kelly sets the verse against the theory that man rose from the animals.

How far this is from the brute finally evolving into man, a theory suggested by Satan to brutalise the race! Here is the simple yet wonderful truth. No one brought God down to the human level; God created man, and man alone, after a divine pattern.

William Kelly

What survived the fall

Kelly notices that Scripture later changes the wording when it speaks of Adam's son.

Man is no longer in the likeness of God, but he is always in the image of God. For man, now as ever, fallen or not, is in the image of God; but the likeness of God was lost through sin. Seth therefore was born in Adam's own likeness, not in God's. He was like Adam fallen, not only his representative.

William Kelly

Commentators differ here. Others hold that both terms still stand.

The fall has not cost man either the image or the likeness of God (Gen. 9:6; James 3:9).

W. W. Fereday

Why murder is a crime against God

Both sides agree on what God Himself says about murder. This verse is the reason He guards human life.

The murderer does more than meddle with man and injure him to the worst degree. By killing a man he also defaces God's image, and God sentences him to die. Murder seizes what belongs to God, and no man has that right.

The Bible Treasury

Male and female, one "man"

The verse shifts from "him" to "them" without changing subject.

Verse 27 says that man is twofold… the few words here show us how closely Scripture ties male and female together. The word "man" covers both, and jointly they were to have the dominion.

F. B. Hole

Jesus later answered a question about marriage by pointing back to the beginning.

Christ brings out God's glory in these things, and He shows how it was at the beginning. God did not make one man and two women, but "male and female he created them." So from the very forming of man, God's mind was clear.

William Kelly

The image in its perfection

God made Adam in the image. Christ is the image. Writers weigh that difference in wording.

God created man in His own image and likeness. But no one could call Christ, "who is God over all, blessed forever," the likeness of God, since He is God. But He can be the image of God, for "image" is what represents another, and Christ did this for God perfectly.

The Christian's Friend

One writer says what it takes for anyone else to hold the two words together.

To be true to the image, there must be moral likeness. For us that means a new creation. So Col. 3:10 says the new self "is being renewed in knowledge after the image of its Creator."

Morrish Bible Dictionary

Summary

- Counsel — God took counsel before making man. Everything else came by command.

- Image — The word means representation. Man stands in creation as God's appointed stand-in.

- Likeness — The word means resemblance. Man has a moral and mental capacity like God's, and is God's "offspring." Commentators differ on whether sin destroyed it.

- Life — The image remains. So killing a man defaces God's own representation, and God claims the murderer's life.

- Restoration — Adam was made in the image; Christ is the image. Real likeness is regained only in the new man, renewed after Him.

Genesis 1:28

And God blessed them; and God said to them, Be fruitful and multiply, and fill the earth, and subdue it; and have dominion over the fish of the sea, and over the fowl of the heavens, and over every animal that moveth on the earth.

Commentary for this verse has not been generated yet.

Genesis 1:29

And God said, Behold, I have given you every herb producing seed that is on the whole earth, and every tree in which is the fruit of a tree producing seed it shall be food for you;

Commentary for this verse has not been generated yet.

Genesis 1:30

and to every animal of the earth, and to every fowl of the heavens, and to everything that creepeth on the earth, in which is a living soul, every green herb for food. And it was so.

On the sixth day God hands out food: seed-bearing plants and fruit to man, and every green plant to the animals, the birds and the creeping things. It pictures a world where nothing yet killed to live, and it raises hard questions about fossils, predators, and what changed.

A world without predators

The verse describes a diet. One writer draws the conclusion, and notes which creatures it names:

"To every beast of the earth I have given every green plant for food." This would imply that animals were not carnivorous. There is a difference between cattle and beasts; but in that statement the cattle are left out; the "beasts" are what we call wild beasts. It is perfectly within God's power to have restricted them for the time, or to have changed them.

J. N. Darby

Death and the fall

This diet belongs to a state that did not last. One writer marks what ended it:

Man still has his distinctive place in God's commission and plan; but it is in the state of innocence. After the fall came corruption and violence. Animal food was not permitted to man till after the flood. Herbs and fruit were given at first to man, and to the subject creation every green plant. Death was not in the Adamic earth till sin. True, Romans 5:12-21 goes no further than the human race, fallen under death through sin. But Romans 8:19-22 looks at "all the creation" as ruined through the fall of its head.

William Kelly

What about the fossils?

Did death exist before the fall? One writer limits Genesis to the world of which Adam is head, and leaves everything earlier open:

So I conclude that death was not in the creation of which man was the head until his fall. But scripture says nothing about what may have happened between the creation of the heavens and the earth and the forming of the present world out of chaos... So geologists may find as many fossil giants and sea reptiles as they please. They do not touch the statements of scripture one way or another, because scripture makes none about it. Death entered only into the creation connected with man, and by man's sin. Scripture states that, though it does not deal with what it meant for the beasts. Genesis 1:30 confirms it, for it gives the green grass to the beasts of the earth.

J. N. Darby

A statement made against all experience

But lions do not eat grass. One writer meets that objection head-on:

Scripture states plainly that herbs were given for food to the beasts of the field. This was not written out of ignorance, for lions were eating men in Moses' time. Moses wrote it with the deliberate intention of claiming a revelation, and so he contradicts the whole existing order of facts about animals... He declares that at first they were given the green plant for food. Scripture gives us to understand they ate that in the ark... It is a direct contradiction of universal experience, and claims to be a revelation. To say that it cannot be true is absurd.

J. N. Darby

Animals as living souls

The verse calls these creatures "everything that has the breath of life." An older translation reads "in which is a living soul." What then separates them from man?

The beast also is, and has, a living soul. Genesis 1:30 describes every beast of the earth, every bird of the air and every creeping thing that creeps on the earth as "everything in which there is a living soul." "Likeness" to God cannot be said of such a one as this, for God is not "soul," but "spirit," and the "Father of spirits." So man stands alone in relationship to God, because he has not only soul but also spirit.

Frederick W. Grant

After the flood, new terms

After the flood God changed the terms, and set a limit:

God now first gave every moving thing that lives to be food for man (Genesis 9:3), as freely as He had first given green plants to beast and bird and reptile (Genesis 1:30). But He put a marked restriction on the blood... It was the life, and this God reserved for Himself.

The Bible Treasury

The return of that peace

This peace is not gone for good. One writer points to the day it returns:

Creation at large will be restored. No longer will the strong prey upon the weak. Even the wolf will dwell with the lamb, the leopard will lie down with the kid, and the lion will eat straw like the ox (Isaiah 11:6-7)... When the sons of God are revealed, that will be the signal for the complete deliverance of all from the bondage of corruption (Romans 8:19-21).

W. W. Fereday

Summary

- Gift. God feeds every creature from the ground: herbs and fruit for man, every green plant for the beasts, birds and creeping things.

- Peace. The verse implies animals did not eat meat, and that death had no place in Adam's world until sin.

- Loss. Man fell, and the creation of which he was head fell with him — Romans 8 views all creation as ruined through its head.

- Limit. Genesis speaks only of the world connected with Adam; on any earlier state, and on fossils, it makes no claim either way.

- Restoration. The same peace returns when the sons of God are revealed: creation goes free, and the lion eats straw like the ox.

Genesis 1:31

And God saw everything that he had made, and behold it was very good. And there was evening, and there was morning -- the sixth day.

God's account of the six days ends with a survey and a verdict: He looks over the whole finished work and calls it very good. That verdict raises three questions: what makes it very good, what happened to it, and whether God will ever say it again.

The Final Verdict

Earlier in the chapter God repeatedly calls His work good. The last verdict is different because of what God has just added to the scene.

With the creation of man, God's work had reached its high point. Up to now we have read the same words four times over: "And God saw that it was good." That covered all the rebuilding and creating, apart from the creation of man. But on the sixth day God surveys the whole scene, including man and woman in their ordered place with dominion over it all. Then we read, "And God saw everything that He had made, and behold, it was VERY good."

A J Pollock

The verdict covers material things — soil, sea, animals, human bodies. That rules out a whole way of thinking about the physical world.

Take note of this, for it destroys at one blow the whole system of error wrongly called "Christian Science." One of its most basic teachings is the idea that matter is evil and only spirit is good. The truth is the exact opposite, for when evil entered it came in by way of spirit, not matter.

F. B. Hole

Why Only Scripture Can Report It

Nobody watched the world in its first condition. No study of the world as it is now can rebuild that picture for us. This verse comes to us as revelation.

Here experience must fail us. Only the Bible could give us the truth about the first condition of man and the creatures around him. But once it is revealed, it proves itself at once. It is the only state we can imagine in which the Creator could have placed creation and its head in a way that fits His own goodness. That is the force and moral beauty of His final survey in the last verse. With the one exception of the second day, He had called each thing "good"; now, as a whole, it was good in the highest degree in His eyes.

William Kelly

Kelly presses the point against those who assume the world has always looked as it does now:

It is illogical, and unbelieving too, to assume that the present state is the normal one, or that God made men sinful, vain, proud and selfish… Clearly the state of the world is offensive to God, and it has been so as far back as man's records reach. This is a fact, Bible or no Bible.

William Kelly

Satisfaction, Then Rest

The verdict leads straight into the seventh day. It also tells us what God's rest is like.

This led to creation rest, with its two marks. First, God was satisfied with all that He had made, as we read, "And God saw everything that He had made, and behold, it was very good." Second, He stopped all His creation work completely, as it is written, "he rested on the seventh day from all his work that he had done." (Gen. 1:31; Gen. 2:2).

Hamilton Smith

How Quickly the Verdict Changed

The world we live in no longer matches this description. The man God set over it is the reason.

Sin broke God's Sabbath, His rest in creation. From then on the verdict He had just pronounced had to change from "very good" to very bad. Man, the masterpiece, fell, and dragged down with him the creation God had placed him over. The beautiful work of God's hand was spoiled, as it were, in a moment.

J Wilson Smith

The point is not that God's work was faulty, but that He tied its wellbeing to the obedience of one man:

It pleased God to make that first creation dependent on its head, the first Adam. He listened to a voice which he ought not to have listened to; sin came in by him, and by sin death, and now the whole creation groans in bondage. (Rom. 5 and Rom. 8)

William Kelly

The Verdict Recovered

Genesis 1:31 is not God's last word on His creation. Writers point forward to a day when the same delight returns.

Sin has marred the fair creation, so that now the whole creation groans and suffers pain. But the saints in heaven share the mind of the Lord, and they can see that all the evil will be dealt with in judgment. Then God can take pleasure in His creation once again, just as He did long ago, when the creation work was finished: "And God saw everything that he had made, and behold, it was very good" (Gen. 1:31).

Hamilton Smith

The first verdict came by a word. The satisfaction still to come is reached through suffering:

He declared the work of His hand to be very good, but in the anguish of His soul He will find satisfaction. The first creation, for all its beauty, was quickly marred by sin.

J Wilson Smith

Summary

- Verdict. Earlier statements call the work "good"; only after man and woman stand in place over the whole does God survey everything and call it very good.

- Vindicated. Matter is not the source of evil; evil came in by way of spirit. And no study of today's world can tell us what the first world was like. Only Scripture reports it.

- Rest. The verdict produces the seventh day: satisfaction in the result, then the complete end of the work.

- Ruin. Sin broke God's rest: man, the masterpiece, fell and dragged down the creation he had been set over, and "very good" became very bad.

- Restored. The verdict returns — God will take pleasure in His creation once more, and the One who spoke it will find satisfaction through the anguish of His soul.