but now, knowing God, but rather being known by God, how do ye turn again to the weak and beggarly principles to which ye desire to be again anew in bondage?
God had brought the Galatians out of idol worship into the knowledge of Himself. Now they were drifting into Jewish law-keeping, and Paul treats that as a return to the slavery they had left.
Paul starts to say they know God, then corrects himself and points to God's knowledge of them.
An Outline of Sound WordsWith loving appeal he writes to them, "But now that you have come to know God, or rather to be known by God." What an appeal, to turn from their knowledge of God to His knowledge of them! At best our knowledge of God is very imperfect. But He has taken us up in the perfect knowledge of all that we were and all that we would be. He has justified us by His grace as a free gift, through the redemption that is in Christ Jesus.
Their conduct gave him little to rest on. So he turned from what he saw in them to the God who had called them.
A. PridhamWhen people fall away, he does what David did and finds his strength in God (1 Samuel 30:6). He turns for comfort from the work to the Workman: from sheep who were called but are changeable and careless, to the One who called them and never takes back His call. That they were "known by God" assured his own spirit more than anything he ever saw in them.
The ESV calls them "elementary principles" and "weak and worthless"; older translations say "elements" and "beggarly." The word is not an insult in itself — it points to first lessons.
Morrish Bible DictionaryThe word applies to children at the start of their training. It applies also to the law, the early way God dealt with Israel. But now the law is called "beggarly": it has lost its glory through the failure of man and the coming of Christ Himself.
Calling the law weak and beggarly sounds harsh until you ask what it is being measured against.
F. B. HoleThe law was holy, just and good. Yet the moon is a weak and beggarly thing next to the sun, and so is the law next to the grace and power of the gospel. Think of the great story in Luke 15. The Father had welcomed the Galatians into His house and given them the place of a son, not the place of a hired servant. Yet here they were, going back with false humility — not quite to the care of the pigs in the far country, but to the drudgery of kitchen servants. They acted as if that were the way to keep the love the Father had showered on them.
These readers were Gentiles. They had never kept the law of Moses, so the word "again" is startling.
William KellyThis must have shocked the Galatian saints. Turning again to idolatry! How could this be? They might say, We are only taking up the principle of the law: do you call this the weak and beggarly elements? The apostle answers: before your conversion you worshipped false gods — idols. But if you, as Christians, take up Jewish principles, even these feast days or other principles of the law, then in principle you are idolaters. You are turning back to the very idolatry God rescued you from. It is not that the law in itself could be idolatrous. But these things had lost all their meaning, and a Gentile had nothing to do with them. They had their value as a shadow of Christ, before Christ came. To turn back from Christ risen from the dead to these mere shadows was, in God's sight, going back to idolatry.
The next verse names what Paul had noticed. Each item traces back to something God Himself had once commanded Israel.
G. C. WillisThe sabbath day is the seventh day of the week, the day God commanded in the law. Who would have suspected that keeping it was so evil a thing? Yet it was just this that frightened the apostle Paul about the Galatians. It meant slavery under the law. That is what made it so evil.
Religion of that kind misses something about God's own character.
An Outline of Sound WordsPeople still think that God must be served by human hands, as though He needed something. They do not know Him in His character as Giver, and so they do not come to Him to receive.
- Known. Your standing rests on God's grasp of you, not your grasp of Him. He took you up knowing all you were and all you would ever be.
- Freed. God brought them out of the service of false gods and set them in the place of sons in the Father's house.
- Weak. The law was holy. But beside the gospel it is moonlight beside the sun, and its glory is gone now that Christ has come.
- Backwards. Taking up law-keeping after Christ is not progress. Paul calls it going back, in principle, to the idolatry they had left.
- Bondage. Even the sabbath, a day God once commanded, becomes slavery when you keep it to secure His love.
Ye observe days and months and times and years.
Paul points to one thing the Galatians were doing: they were keeping a religious calendar. Why should that alarm an apostle, when God Himself once commanded those days?
The list is not vague. Each term points to a fixed part of Israel's calendar. One writer names them one by one, then says what going back to them meant:
Alfred E. BouterFor example, the days would be keeping the Sabbath. The months would be the new moon. The seasons would be the different festivals we find in Leviticus 23. The years would be the sabbatical year every seven years, or the year of jubilee. They wanted to put themselves under all these regulations... The shadows given in the Old Testament pointed to Christ. But here the Galatians were going back to shadows Christ had already fulfilled. They were turning their backs on the sun and looking at the moon instead.
These were not invented customs. God Himself commanded them once, which is why the danger here is easy to miss:
G C WillisWho would have suspected that keeping the sabbath day was so evil a thing? It was the seventh day of the week, the day God commanded in the law. Yet it was just this that frightened the apostle Paul about the Galatians. It meant slavery under the law; that is what made it so evil.
The Galatians were taking up a system God Himself once set up. One writer still gives that move a hard name:
W. W. FeredayJudaism was a system set up and once owned by God, being an expression of Christ in all its parts... But now Christ has come, and the substance of it all is here. Heavenly realities have come in. So a Judaism kept going by self-willed, blinded men is now idolatry. It is a religion of the senses, one the flesh can join in and enjoy. Things that once spoke of Christ are now weak and worthless elements, and the whole atmosphere is one of bondage.
Treating some days as holier carries a hidden assumption. It also changes how a person treats every other day:
Leslie M. GrantThis is formalism, designed to draw attention to themselves. It assumes that God required more righteousness of them at some times than at others. Such actions quietly excuse unrighteousness on "ordinary" days. How much of this we see in Christendom today! There are holy days and holy seasons, kept with great claims of spirituality — a spirituality thrown to the winds in ordinary life, and even in wild parties just before the holy days.
The same practice did not carry the same weight for every believer:
A. PridhamA Jewish believer might be excused for holding on to the customs of his forefathers, though the Spirit of grace still warns him (Rom. 14:3 and following). But for a converted Gentile to take them up was to show a basic ignorance of the grace in which he stood... Christ, the body and fullness of everything those shadows pictured, is the one continual festival of the saints. Days, months, seasons and years have dropped away, with all other legal burdens, from the cleansed conscience of the true worshipper of the Father.
Outward religion proves nothing about the heart. Anyone at all can keep a ritual:
Hamilton SmithIf the Apostle looked at these Galatians only by what they were doing, he might well doubt whether they were true Christians. You do not have to be converted to observe days and seasons. This is a solemn thing for Christendom. Much of it has fallen into the same Galatian error, turning back again to outward ceremonies and to man-made holy days.
The verse frees the Christian from a sacred calendar. But one writer marks off the first day of the week as standing on different ground:
C. H. MackintoshThe believer is completely free from keeping "days and months and seasons and years." Being joined to a risen Christ has taken him right out of all such superstitious observances. Yet while this is wonderfully true, we see that "the first day of the week" has a place in the New Testament that no other day has. Let the Christian give it that place. It is a sweet and happy privilege, not a grievous yoke.
- Shadow — days, months, seasons and years meant sabbath, new moon, the feasts of Leviticus 23, and the sabbatical year. They were shadows pointing to Christ before He came.
- Substance — Christ has come, so going back to the shadow means turning your back on the sun to stare at the moon. He is now the one continual festival of His people.
- Slavery — even a day God Himself once commanded turns into bondage once you keep it as law.
- Idolatry — a system God once owned, kept up after Christ has come, is now idolatry — a religion of the senses that the flesh can enjoy.
- Liberty — anyone can keep a calendar without being converted, so the outward act proves nothing. The first day of the week remains, not as a yoke, but as a privilege.