and said O my God, I am ashamed and blush to lift up my face to thee, my God; for our iniquities are increased over [our] head, and our trespass is grown up to the heavens.
The people who came back from exile have married into the surrounding nations, and the priests and leaders led the way. Ezra sat stunned until the evening sacrifice, then prayed — not asking for anything, but in shame, saying "our" for a sin that was not his.
Ezra was not one of the offenders. Yet he refuses to stand apart from them. One writer sees in that refusal the very thing that made him fit to plead for the nation.
Edward DennettHe does not separate himself, even in spirit, from those who had sinned. He and they — indeed, all the people — are one before God, counted together as one people. God Himself saw it this way. When Achan sinned, He said to Joshua, "Israel has sinned." Ezra understood this, and that is what qualified him to become an intercessor for the people with God. Unless we grasp our oneness with God's people — that their sin and sorrow are our sin and sorrow — we cannot truly carry them on our hearts before the Lord in their time of need.
A faithful man can meet failure another way: by telling God it is someone else's fault. Commentators contrast Ezra with Elijah, who told God how unfaithful Israel had been while he alone stayed true.
Leslie M. GrantInstead of this, Ezra prayed as though he was just as guilty as the rest of Israel in this sad mixing of the Jews with the nations. He confessed the sin of all as though it had been his own, though he was not personally involved in it. He saw this: Israel had sinned, and he was part of Israel. As God's priest, he was eating the sin offering (Lev. 6:25-26). That means feeling before God how serious Israel's sin was, and the priest was to count himself involved in it.
The same writer sees this most clearly in words the Lord Jesus speaks in Psalm 69:5.
Leslie M. Grant"O God, you know my folly; the wrongs I have done are not hidden from you." The Lord Jesus certainly had no sins of His own. But He took the responsibility on His own shoulders for the sins of Israel, confessed them before God, and in fact bore them "in His own body on the tree" (1 Peter 2:24).
The verse gives two measurements: sin risen higher than the head, guilt piled as high as the sky. One writer reads them as showing how far the trouble had gone, and how long it had run.
Leslie M. GrantTheir sin was far beyond their control or their ability to check it. But he does not limit his thoughts to the guilt of that moment. He confesses that it had been there "since the days of our fathers" (v. 7). Speaking this way, he remembered that such guilt had led to their captivity. Their kings and priests were handed over to foreign kings because of it, and brought down to shameful humiliation.
Ezra says he is too ashamed to raise his face, and in the same breath calls God "my God" twice. One writer pictures a person weeping over sin, dreading to look at the God he had wronged.
William J. HockingThe truth he had not grasped was that God, to whom he was answerable as a sinner, was ready to pardon. A divine invitation went out to him and to every other guilty person: "Turn to me and be saved, all the ends of the earth! For I am God, and there is no other" (Isa. 45:22). Ezra the priest confessed his own sin and the sins of his people. He acted on this invitation and lifted up his eyes to God despite his sense of guilt.
Ezra could have answered the crisis with a plan. He answered it with feeling instead.
F. B. HoleEzra called together no committee; he laid no elaborate plans for reforming this abuse; he just FELT things before God, and as they affected God. He felt things so much that he tore his clothes, pulled out his hair, and sat down astonished. Then, realising the full extent of it all, he fell on his knees and began a memorable prayer of confession: "O my God, I am ashamed and blush to lift my face to you, my God."
- Ours. Ezra does not separate himself from the offenders, even in spirit. Before God the people are one, as when God said of Achan's sin, "Israel has sinned."
- Not theirs. Elijah reported Israel's unfaithfulness and his own loyalty. Ezra prays as though the guilt were all his own — the priest eating the sin offering.
- Higher. Sin had risen past the head, and guilt to the heavens. It was past their power to control, and it reached back to the days of their fathers.
- Upward. Too ashamed to raise his face, he raises it anyway, acting on the invitation of a God ready to pardon.
- Deeper. No committee, no reform plan — he felt the failure as God felt it, and that is where his power to help his people began.
Since the days of our fathers, we have been in great trespass to this day; and for our iniquities we, our kings, our priests, have been given into the hand of the kings of the lands, to the sword, and to captivity, and to spoil, and to confusion of face, as it is this day.
Commentary for this verse has not been generated yet.
And now for a little space there hath been favour from Jehovah our God, to leave us a remnant to escape, and to give us a nail in his holy place, that our God may lighten our eyes, and give us a little reviving in our bondage.
Ezra prays this right after owning his people's sin, and the first thing he does next is count the mercies. The verse holds two things together: a people still in slavery, and a people given a firm place, brightened eyes, and a small revival.
Ezra recites God's kindness for a reason.
Edward DennettHe has owned the sins of his brothers, and has declared God right in His ways with His people. Next he magnifies the grace that had visited them in their low state. That grace had brought them back to the land — only a remnant — and had allowed them once again to set up the house of their God. But why does he recite this proof of the Lord's grace and mercy? It was to show the character of His people's sin.
Where the ESV reads "a secure hold," older versions read "a nail." One writer reads it as God Himself fixing them in place.
Arno Clemens GaebeleinThe remnant through His mercy had escaped, and God had given them "a nail in His holy place" (Isaiah 22:23). Like a nail in the wall, fixed and immovable, so God had established them in Jerusalem.
Another writer reads the word differently.
F. A. HughesThe word "nail" is really "tent peg." It is a small item that looks unimportant, in a place almost out of sight. Yet how vital it is to the safety of the structure!
Either way the point stands: what God gave them was small, but it held.
The exiles were back in the land. But no king ruled again in Jerusalem, and a foreign empire still held them. God blessed them inside that situation.
J. N. DarbyThe authority and the throne at Jerusalem, with the power to appoint that went with them, were not set up again. God gave no public seal of approval. Still, God blessed the remnant of His people when they were faithful. And the main thing, the thing that should stay on our hearts, is the grace that could still bless His people — grace in the middle of such ruin, and while the throne of a foreign power stood, set up because of Israel's sin.
Ezra is not describing a slavery he has escaped. One writer notes that the next verse is better read in the present tense.
Leslie M. GrantEzra deeply appreciated the great kindness of God in the small measure of recovery He had given His people, though only a remnant. He had given them "a peg" in His holy place, a small support on which to hang their confidence. The peg was to give them enlightened eyes to see the truth of God more clearly, and some measure of reviving, though they were still in bondage. Verse 9 is rightly translated, "we are slaves." Even so, God had not forsaken them in their bondage. He had extended mercy to them in the sight of the kings of Persia. His aim was that they might at least rise in spirit above their circumstances, and have the temple of God repaired and the wall of Jerusalem rebuilt. Does this not show us that even in a sadly confined state God is able to provide grace to worship Him rightly? The temple speaks of that worship. He also gives grace to be in some true measure separate from the world, which the wall pictures.
So the reviving comes to people who are still slaves.
Ezra asks only for "a little reviving." Small numbers were nothing new for his people.
Other AuthorsIsrael began as "the fewest of all peoples" (Deut. 7:7)... In the days of the exile, God raised the spirits of some (Ezra 1:5), but the revival was very limited in scope.
One writer sees Ezra's conditions in his own day.
F. A. HughesHow our hearts long to see affections stirred in loyalty and devotion to Christ and to the truth of His Word! We do not look for spectacular movements of outward greatness. We want our prayers to mingle with Ezra's, "that our God may brighten our eyes and grant us a little reviving" (Ezra 9:8). Conditions in Ezra's day were like ours in a moral sense. God's throne was no longer set up in Jerusalem. His rights were disowned, His people scattered and in captivity.
- Little. Ezra names the mercy for what it is: a remnant, a peg, a little reviving — not a full restoration.
- Fixed. The "nail" is a peg: fixed in a wall, or hidden in a tent. Either way, what God gives holds.
- Inside. The reviving comes while they are still slaves. God gives grace before He mends the ruin.
- Enough. Even in a confined state, God supplies grace for real worship (the temple) and real separation from the world (the wall).
- Convicting. Ezra recites the mercy to expose the sin. The greater the grace, the darker the sin against it.
For we are bondmen; yet our God hath not forsaken us in our bondage, but hath extended mercy unto us before the kings of Persia, to give us a reviving, to set up the house of our God and to repair the ruins thereof, and to give us a wall in Judah and in Jerusalem.
Ezra prays this after learning that the returned exiles had married into the surrounding nations. Instead of pleading their good record, he says plainly where they stand: still slaves because of sin, yet still receiving God's mercy.
The force of the verse turns on one small word. Some older English versions read "we were bondmen." Commentators say the sense is present: Ezra describes the day he lives in, not a chapter he has closed.
The Bible Treasury"For," he said, "we are slaves" (verse 9). The context, and even the verse itself, requires this — not "were," as some versions have it. People are quick to read it that way, forgetting God's ways and His people's sin. Not for a moment did he think the Jews of that day could do all that Moses or Joshua, David or Solomon, did in their days. He sought to do all that God's word authorised them to do in their actual circumstances. The all-important condition is a right sense of where God's people are, and a heart humbly set on obedience. It is not our own ideas and self-confidence trying to put everything right.
Persia's rule over them was not an accident of politics. Their own sin had put them there, and they were meant to keep that fact in view.
H. L. RossierThey were subjected to the nations because of their sins. They were to stay aware of their state until the glorious restoration of the people through the promised Messiah. … This is what irritated the proud spirit of the people in the days of Jesus. It made them dare to say to Him: "we have never been enslaved to anyone!" (John 8:33). The consciousness of our ruin should mark us today, as it marked the people in the days of Ezra. We cannot and should not deny it or shrug the burden off our shoulders.
God did not first remove the foreign empire that ruled them and then bless. He blessed them under it — and that, one writer says, is the thing to hold on to in the whole scene.
J. N. DarbyStill, God blessed the remnant of His people when they were faithful. The most prominent thing, the thing that should stay on our hearts, is His grace. In the middle of such ruin, and with the Gentile throne set up through Israel's sin, that grace could still bless His people — even though they acknowledged that throne, which God had established in judgment on them. Their position is clearly and touchingly stated in Ezra 9:8-9.
The mercy has two aims in the verse: the house of God repaired, and protection for Judah and Jerusalem. Older versions read that protection as "a wall." One writer takes both the house and the wall as pictures of what God still gives a small, limited people.
Leslie M. GrantVerse 9 is rightly translated, "we are slaves." Despite this, God had not forsaken them in their bondage. He had extended mercy in the sight of the kings of Persia, so that He might at least lift them in spirit above their circumstances, to have the temple of God repaired and the wall of Jerusalem rebuilt. Does this not show us that even in a sadly confined state, God can give grace to worship Him rightly? That is what the temple speaks of. He can also give grace to be separate from the world in some true measure. That is what the wall pictures.
Ezra is not comforting himself here. The next verse shows why he brought up the mercy at all.
Edward DennettBut why does he recite this proof of the Lord's grace and mercy? It was to show the character of His people's sin. He goes on, "And now, O our God, what shall we say after this? For we have forsaken your commandments." Then he confesses that they had sinned against both light and grace. He conceals nothing and excuses nothing.
The wall in the verse was a gift and a job at once. The years after Ezra show what became of it.
H. L. RossierEzra had foreseen that rebuilding the walls of Jerusalem had to be the next step after building the temple, if the people were to continue in the spirit of the revival (Ezra 9:9). But this had not been the case. Long years passed with no sign of activity or energy. There was nothing except growing affliction and reproach.
- Slaves. The verb is present: they are still in bondage, and Ezra refuses to pretend the past is past.
- Yet. Bondage is not desertion. God's mercy reaches them under the very Persian throne He set over them in judgment.
- Reviving. The gift is not full restoration. It is breathing space — enough to lift their spirits above their circumstances.
- House and wall. The reviving has two aims: worship restored, and a real measure of separation from the world.
- Then what? Ezra recites the mercy to expose sin, not to excuse it. The unbuilt wall shows how fast a reviving can stall.
And now, what shall we say, our God, after this? for we have forsaken thy commandments,
God had just brought a small group of exiles home from Babylon and let them rebuild the temple. In the same breath, Ezra confesses that the people have broken the very commands that set them apart. He asks a question and leaves it unanswered, because sin after such mercy has no defence to offer.
Ezra sets the sin beside the mercy that came just before it. That comparison is the point of his question.
Edward DennettBut why does he recite this proof of the Lord's grace and mercy? It was to show the character of His people's sin; for he goes on, "And now, O our God, what shall we say after this? for we have forsaken your commandments;" and then he confesses that they had sinned against both light and grace. He conceals nothing, and excuses nothing, but spreads it all out before God. He owns what would follow if they broke God's commandments again after all this mercy, and joined with these peoples in their abominations. God might well be angry with them until He had destroyed them, so that no remnant would be left.
Ezra quotes the broken commands in the verses that follow. Those who learned Scripture from him had learned something about God first.
H. L. RossierKnowing the word of God through Ezra, they have discovered in it the character of God who can in no way associate Himself with impurity. Has He not said, "You shall be holy, for I am holy" (Lev. 11:44)? And so in his prayer Ezra refers to the word of God, which he knows so well: "For we have forsaken your commandments, which you have commanded by your servants the prophets, saying, The land which you go to possess is an unclean land through the filthiness of the peoples of the lands."
Ezra had not married a foreign wife. Yet every pronoun in his prayer includes him.
The Bible TreasuryEzra was a man of prayer. His prayer held confession, thorough and holding nothing back. In a day of ruin, when we look at the state of God's people, there can be no true prayer without true confession. And true confession is not saying, "They have sinned," but, "We have sinned." "Behold, we are before you in our guilt, for none can stand before you because of this."
Something is missing from this prayer.
F. B. HoleAt the time of the evening sacrifice, the offering gave a small picture of the sacrifice of Christ. Ezra got up with his torn garments and fell on his knees to come near to God in the remarkable prayer recorded in verses 6-15. In that prayer he made no actual request. From first to last it was humble and heartbroken confession of sins in which he personally had no share.
What he holds back from asking, he leaves with God.
Leslie M. GrantNotice that Ezra does not ask forgiveness for the people, but simply confesses Israel's guilt before the Lord, leaving God to do as He sees fit with them.
Israel's separation from the nations reached into whom its people married. The Christian's position is not the same.
William KellyThe serious question was mixed marriages. Of two people already married, one had been won to Christ by the gospel and the other had not. In this the grace of Christianity stands in striking contrast to the strictness of Judaism. One of the ways Israel remained a holy people was by refusing to mix with the nations in marriage. Those who married in this way, or took foreign wives, were polluted, and their children were unclean. When they felt and judged the sin, they proved it by offering a ram for the trespass and by putting both away.
The pattern did not end with Israel.
F. B. HoleThis prayer of Ezra contains a solemn warning for us, so we do well to consider it. God has shown great mercy in the history of Christendom. Since the time of the Reformation revivals have come, but each one has been marked by the same tendency to go back to former evils. It would indeed be good if every true believer today knelt before God with words like Ezra's. Such words spring from convictions and a heart like his.
- Grace given — God left a remnant, revived them, and let them rebuild. That mercy is the measure of the sin.
- Grace forsaken — the broken commands kept Israel from mixing with the nations, for God will not associate Himself with impurity.
- Grace owned — Ezra says "we," not "they." In a day of ruin there is no true prayer without that confession.
- Grace trusted — he makes no request and asks no pardon; he states the guilt and leaves the outcome with God.
- Grace repeated — mercy, then drift back to old evils, is the recurring story. Ezra's words still fit today.
which thou hast commanded by thy servants the prophets, saying, The land, unto which ye go to possess [it], is an unclean land through the filthiness of the peoples of the lands, through their abominations with which they have filled it from one end to another through their uncleanness.
Commentary for this verse has not been generated yet.
Now therefore give not your daughters to their sons, neither take their daughters to your sons, nor seek their peace or their prosperity for ever; that ye may be strong, and eat the good of the land, and leave it for an inheritance to your children for ever.
Ezra has learned that God's people have married into the surrounding nations. Priests and leaders led the way. In his prayer he quotes God's own words back to Him. This verse is the heart of that quotation. It holds a command about marriage, a warning about seeking the good of the nations nearby, and a promise for those who obey.
Ezra does not invent a rule for the crisis in front of him. He reaches for what God had already said, and those who gathered to him had learned the same thing from him.
H. L. RossierThe first effect of Ezra's self-humbling is to gather around him those who tremble at the words of God. They are marked by what they have learned under Ezra's guidance. Through him they know the word of God, and in it they have found the character of God, who can in no way tie Himself to impurity. Has He not said, "Be holy, for I am holy" (Lev. 11:44)?
Marriage can look like a private matter. One writer shows what an Israelite gave up by marrying outside the nation.
William Kelly"You have broken faith," he says, "and have married foreign women." For an Israelite, as far as the people were concerned, this was the great mark of falling away. It was falling away from God, in taking a foreign god. It was falling away from the people, in taking foreign wives. It meant completely giving up their holy place of separateness to the Lord.
The command does not stop at marriage. It also rules out working for the comfort of the nations nearby. One writer applies this to believers today, and then adds what has changed since Ezra's day.
Leslie M. GrantEzra went on in his prayer to recall that God had warned Israel not to intermarry with the nations of the land. God had even warned them not to seek the peace of those nations — that is, not to make them comfortable about living together. This is a warning for believers today. We are not to marry unbelievers. We are not to make unbelievers feel that there is no difference between us and them. Today, though, we have a positive gospel for unbelievers. We seek to win them to the Lord, so that they may be saved and share the same blessings we have.
The verse ends with a promise of three things: strength, the good of the land, and an inheritance for the children. An earlier generation lost all three.
H. L. RossierTo join themselves to the nations was to give up being set apart for Him. Ezra's companions had valued this holiness, and it had guided them up to that day (8:28). This was the very thing their predecessors had failed to keep. Such alliances — which for us match worldliness — had taken them over. They spread like gangrene from the priests and leaders of the people down to the common people themselves. They had forgotten that when separation goes, three great things go with it: strength, the enjoyment of the good things of the land of Canaan, and a lasting inheritance for themselves and their children (v. 12).
Other people broke the commands named in this verse. Yet Ezra's prayer never sets him apart from the guilty.
F. B. HoleOne striking feature runs through the whole confession. He identified himself with the people, and confessed the evils as though they were his own. From start to finish he says "we" and "us", where we might have expected "they" and "them". He also owned that the evils in front of him were old sins coming back to life — sins that had stained his people from the very beginning, or, as he put it, "since the days of our fathers". What made it worse was this: they were repeating those sins after God had shown such mercy. He had already freed them from the consequences their former sins had brought.
Confession is not the end of the matter. One writer warns about praying when action is what is needed.
The Christian's FriendAnd yet how often Satan deceives the Lord's people when evil has come out into the open. He suggests, through one person or another, "Let us pray about it." We must confess our sins. But even then we confess only as we seek grace and strength to deal with the evil and to separate ourselves from it. In this chapter Ezra lies before the Lord, owning his people's guilt. In the next chapter we see him acting with energy against the sin he had confessed, refusing to rest until he had put it away.
- Command — Ezra prays God's own words back to Him. Those who stood with him trembled at what God had said. They had learned that He cannot tie Himself to impurity.
- Cost — Marrying into the nations meant giving up their separateness to the Lord. It was a double turning away: from God, and from His people.
- Loss — When separation went, three things went with it: strength, the good of the land, and the inheritance left to their children.
- Reach — The ban on seeking the nations' peace warns against blurring the line. Today the gospel goes out to win outsiders into the same blessing.
- Response — Ezra confessed as "we", not "they". Then he acted, refusing to rest until he had put the evil away.
And after all that is come upon us for our evil deeds and for our great trespass, seeing that thou our God hast punished us less than our iniquities [deserve], and hast given us such deliverance as this,
Ezra has just heard that the exiles who returned have married into the nations around them, and he tears his clothes and kneels to pray. His prayer asks God for nothing; it weighs the guilt, the captivity and the return, and says what they show about God.
The verse sits at a hinge in the prayer. Before Ezra names the present sin, he retells God's kindness. One writer explains why he takes that order.
Edward DennettThe order of Ezra's confessions is most instructive. He first owns the sins of his brothers and declares God right in His ways with His people. Then he magnifies the grace that visited them in their low estate, brought them — a remnant — back to the land, and let them set up the house of their God once again. But why does he recite this proof of the Lord's grace and mercy? It was to show the character of His people's sin... and he confesses that they had sinned against both light and grace. He conceals nothing, and excuses nothing, but spreads it all out before God.
The heart of the verse is Ezra's verdict on the exile itself. He does not call the punishment harsh. He calls it restrained. One writer explains what it was aiming at.
Leslie M. GrantAfter all Israel's disobedience and guilt, Ezra considered that God had punished them less than their iniquities deserved (v. 13). God had indeed punished them. But His purpose was to drive them back to Himself, not merely to punish them. Then He wonderfully delivered them from the harshness of that punishment by restoring them to their land.
The verse ends with what God gave: "such a remnant as this." One writer explains the picture behind that gift.
Arno Clemens GaebeleinThe remnant through His mercy had escaped, and God had given them "a nail in His holy place" (Isaiah 22:23). Like a nail in the wall, fixed and immovable, so God had established them in Jerusalem.
Ezra is not confessing a new failure. He is confessing the return of an old one, and mercy makes the repeat worse.
F. B. HoleOne remarkable feature of the whole confession is that he identified himself with the people, and confessed the evils as though they were his own. From beginning to end he uses "we" and "us," where we might have expected "they" and "them." He also acknowledged that the evils confronting him were a revival of the sins that had defiled his people from the start — or, as he put it, "since the days of our fathers." But they were made worse because they were being repeated after God had shown such mercy in relieving them of the governmental consequences of their former sins.
The next verse spells out the fear behind this one. What if such mercy meets the same sin again? Ezra asks whether God would then consume them and leave no remnant at all — the very thing verse 13 says He had not done (H. L. Rossier).
One detail is easy to miss: Ezra never asks God to forgive them. One writer draws a principle from that silence.
Edward DennettIt should also be observed that Ezra does not once pray for forgiveness. With any understanding of the mind of God, it was impossible that he should do so. Suppose there is known evil in our hearts or among God's people. Our first responsibility is to judge it, not to pray for forgiveness. So when Joshua lay on his face before the Lord after Israel's defeat by the men of Ai, the Lord said, "Get up! Why have you fallen on your face? Israel has sinned."
The pattern still fits today. Hole applies it to any time of revival that has drifted back. He says believers now would do well to kneel with words like Ezra's — usually confessing as people caught up in the failure themselves, not only as people standing with those who failed (F. B. Hole).
- Deserved. Ezra weighs the exile and calls it mild. God punished them less than their iniquities deserved.
- Given. What followed the punishment was pure gift: a remnant brought home, fixed in place like a nail driven into a wall.
- Weighed. He recalls that mercy not to comfort himself, but to show what his people's sin really is.
- Owned. He says "we" and "us" throughout, confessing his people's evils as though they were his own.
- Judged. He asks for no forgiveness. Where evil is known, the first duty is to judge it, not to pray about it.
should we again break thy commandments, and join in affinity with the peoples of these abominations? wouldest thou not be angry with us till thou hadst consumed us, so that there should be no remnant nor any to escape?
Ezra has just recited God's mercy in bringing a remnant home from exile. Now he turns that mercy into a question: after such kindness, dare they break God's commandments again and marry into the nations God condemned?
The order of Ezra's prayer matters. He recites God's kindness before he names the sin.
Edward DennettFirst he owned the sins of his brothers, and justified God in His ways with His people. Next he magnifies the grace which had visited them in their low estate. That grace had brought them — a remnant — back to the land, and had let them set up the house of their God once again. But why does he recite this proof of the Lord's grace and mercy? It was to show the character of His people's sin... he confesses that they had sinned against both light and grace. He conceals nothing, and excuses nothing, but spreads it all out before God.
Intermarrying with the nations around them sounds like a social matter. For an Israelite it was a double desertion.
William KellyYou have transgressed, he says, and have taken foreign wives. For an Israelite, as far as the people were concerned, this was the great mark of apostasy — apostasy from God in taking a foreign god, and apostasy from the people in taking foreign wives. It was a complete giving up of their holy place of separation to the Lord.
The wrong was not only in what they lost, but in what they denied God.
The Bible TreasuryIn itself this broke a basic requirement of the Lord's will. It gave up that separation to Himself from the nations, which was essential to their standing as His people. They were not only surrendering their own privilege as the sole nation of His choice. They were rebelling against the rights and glory of God, Who had so favoured them.
Behind the word "again" stands what Ezra had just said. The punishment they had already borne was lighter than their guilt deserved.
Leslie M. GrantAfter all the disobedience and guilt of Israel, Ezra considered that God had punished them less than their iniquities deserved. God had indeed punished them, but His purpose was to drive them back to Him, not simply to punish them. Then He gave them a wonderful deliverance from the severity of that punishment: He restored them to their land.
Ezra names what God would be right to do, and leaves it standing.
Leslie M. GrantAfter such kindness shown by God, Ezra asks whether they should break His commandments again and intermarry with the peoples who practice these abominations. He saw this as a most ungrateful way of responding to God's grace. So he expected God to act in anger, and to consume Israel until no remnant at all was left.
Notice who Ezra puts inside the question. He is not accusing others from a safe distance.
The Bible TreasuryHis prayer held confession in it, thorough and unreserved. In a day of ruin, when we look at the state of God's people, there cannot be true prayer without true confession. And true confession is not saying, "They have sinned," but, "We have sinned."
One writer turns the same charge on Christians today, and puts it as questions rather than a verdict.
Edward DennettThe place of confession is always the place of restoration and of spiritual power. So it is always a sign of a bad condition when that place is rarely taken. Let us then challenge ourselves for a moment... Is it not true that we have largely "joined in alliance" with the people of the world? Have we not submitted ourselves to their habits, ways, and customs? Is not worldliness our ruin?
- Mercy first. Ezra names God's kindness first. That sets the measure of the sin: it was sin against grace.
- Mercy restrained. God had punished them less than their guilt deserved. He punished them to bring them back, not to make them suffer.
- Mercy repaid badly. To marry into the nations again would be apostasy twice over. It leaves God, and it leaves the separated place He gave them.
- Mercy exhausted. Ezra names the outcome himself. God would have reason to consume them, leaving no remnant and no one to escape.
- Mercy applied. True confession says "we have sinned," not "they have sinned." And the same question about mixing with the world stands over believers now.
Jehovah, God of Israel, thou art righteous; for we are a remnant that is escaped, as [it is] this day. Behold, we are before thee in our trespasses; for there is no standing before thee because of this.
Ezra's long prayer over the exiles who had married into the nations around them ends with a verdict, not a request: God is righteous, and the guilty have no ground to stand on. So the closing words raise a hard question — if my guilt leaves me unable to stand before God, what happens next?
The prayer has an unusual shape. The time of day matters, and so does what is missing from it.
F. B. HoleAt the time of the evening sacrifice, when there was a small picture pointing to the sacrifice of Christ, Ezra arose with his torn garments. He fell on his knees to approach God in the remarkable prayer recorded in verses 6-15. In it he makes no request at all. From first to last it is humble and heartbroken confession of sins he had not shared in himself.
What Ezra leaves out matters as much as what he says. He hands the whole case over to God and suggests no outcome.
Leslie M. GrantNotice that Ezra does not ask forgiveness for the people, but simply confesses Israel's guilt before the Lord, leaving God to do as He sees fit with them. He declares that God is righteous in leaving only the few Jews as a remnant. Yet because God is righteous, no one in that remnant could stand before Him, because of their guilt.
Ezra calls God righteous. He is taking sides, and he has just recalled the mercy that spared them. One writer explains why he brings that mercy up.
Edward DennettBut why does he recall this proof of the Lord's grace and mercy? It was to show what His people's sin really was. He hides nothing and excuses nothing, but spreads it all out before God. He then ends by justifying God once more, and by taking His part against himself and the people.
To stand is a word about judgment. Scripture ties it to God's throne, and to whether a sinner can hold his ground there.
C E StuartThese passages connect the thought of standing with the throne of God. Its action must go out in judgment against the sinner, unless God can forgive the guilty one. "But with you there is forgiveness," we read, "that you may be feared." Before that throne, then, the sinner in his sins cannot stand. Scripture does not teach that his standing is a bad one that he must change. It states plainly that as a sinner he has no standing before a God of judgment. He does not need a better standing, because by nature he has none at all. Apart from redemption and atonement the sinner has no standing before God's throne. What he needs is to gain one.
Ezra had not married a foreign wife. Yet from start to finish he says "we." Commentators treat this as the mark of true confession.
The Bible TreasuryConfession, thorough and unreserved, was in it. In a day of ruin, when you look at the state of God's people, there cannot be true prayer without true confession. And true confession is not saying, "They have sinned," but, "We have sinned."
Standing before God "in our guilt" sounds like a dead end. Writers on this chapter read it as the place where recovery starts and spreads.
H. L. RossierIs restoration possible at this moment for these poor escaped souls? Yes. It is found in the attitude of those who had no part in this defilement. They still take responsibility for it so fully that they identify themselves with those who remain under God's judgment. We shall see what this does. Held with a sincere heart before God, this attitude and this thorough confession of evil work on those who had sinned and bring them back.
One writer adds what it means when people stay away from that ground.
Edward DennettThe place of confession is always the place of both restoration and spiritual power. So it is always a sign of a bad condition when people seldom take that place.
- Righteous — Ezra's verdict on God comes first. He takes God's part against himself and his people instead of defending them.
- Remnant — the survivors are alive by mercy, not by merit. Ezra points to that mercy to show how serious the sin is.
- Cannot stand — before God's throne a sinner has no ground at all. Only forgiveness can give him one.
- We, not they — Ezra confesses sins he never committed. Writers call this the test of real prayer in a day of ruin.
- Restoration — the ground where no one can stand is where recovery starts. One person who takes it draws the guilty back with him.