Exodus 32:4–5

Exodus 32:4

And he took [them] out of their hand, and fashioned it with a chisel and made of it a molten calf and they said, This is thy god, Israel, who has brought thee up out of the land of Egypt!

Israel had been out of Egypt only a few months. Moses was still on the mountain, so the people asked Aaron for something they could see. He gave them a calf of melted gold. The words spoken over it give that image the credit for the rescue from Egypt. Commentators keep asking one question: was this a rejection of God, or a way of picturing Him?

Gold from Their Ears

The gold came from ornaments brought out of Egypt. One writer draws a lesson from where the people wore them.

Aaron did not have the energy of faith his brother Moses had, to boldly stand against them. He weakly gave in to their foolish demands. He told them to break off the golden earrings, which were clearly common among them, taken from the Egyptians. There is a serious lesson here. Our idols, whatever they are, take their character from what decorates or pampers the flesh — the golden earrings. Ears are given for hearing, but Israel was not hearing the first commandment God had given them, "You shall have no other gods before me."

L. M. Grant

"This Is Your God"

Not everyone reads the offence the same way. The verse reads "These are your gods." One reference work explains how the calf was made, and argues the words should be singular.

The calf was cast as a molten image first, and then fashioned with a graving tool. It was probably meant as a representation of God. That would place the sin under the second commandment, not the first. Aaron said, "This is your god, O Israel, who brought you up out of the land of Egypt" (as it should read); and "Tomorrow shall be a feast to the LORD."

Morrish Bible Dictionary

A Help to Devotion

On either reading, the intention behind the image does not soften what happened to them.

Let us not suppose that either Aaron or Israel intended to abandon Jehovah. It is no unworthy stretch of imagination to picture their indignation at such a charge. In Israel's mind the calf stood for the God no one can see, and Aaron said in plain words that it stood for Jehovah. As people say of all images, it was "a help to devotion," "a symbol of the unseen" — and in this sense, the God who had brought them out of Egypt! But none the less had they really returned in spirit to paganism.

H. Forbes Witherby

Below the Beasts

An image does something to the worshipper, not only to the truth.

The people are plainly taught that in making any image and bowing down to it, they in reality lowered and corrupted themselves. So when they made the golden calf, the Lord said to Moses: "Go down, for your people, whom you brought up out of the land of Egypt, have corrupted themselves." It could not be otherwise. The worshipper must be lower than the object of his worship. So in worshipping a calf, they put themselves below the level of the beasts that perish.

C. H. Mackintosh

The Man Left in Charge

Moses left Aaron in charge while he was away. Aaron later defended himself: he only gave the people what they wanted.

How subtle is sin! When Moses challenged him, Aaron excused himself: he was only humouring the people. Think what evil a good man may cause by acting unfaithfully in an emergency. Aaron was left in charge of the people, to meet any difficulty that might arise. But the leader goes along with what the people want, and leads them into idolatry without meaning to. In vain was Aaron's proclamation, "Tomorrow shall be a feast to the LORD." The calf, and not Jehovah, had the homage of their hearts.

The Bible Treasury

His Glory, Not Our Intention

Neither Aaron nor the people set out to abandon God. So how does God weigh what they did?

At the very outset we are taught a solemn and searching truth — that God does not measure things by the intention of human agents, but by His own glory. Before God there is no such thing as innocence of intention, when a man takes it on himself to decide how God should be honoured, or how God's work should be carried forward. In such cases the means used are quite as important as the end intended.

The Bible Treasury

The Law That Never Reached the Camp

The timing matters. The people had already broken with God before the law itself arrived.

But it was all over with the covenant of the law. The people had broken the first and basic link — that of having no other gods. The tables of the covenant never even came into the camp on the simple ground of law. The people had made a complete separation between themselves and God.

J. N. Darby

Summary

- Delay. With Moses out of sight, the people wanted something visible. The leader who should have held the line gave way "in an emergency."

- Gold. The idol came from what had decorated them — ears made for hearing paid for an image instead.

- Image. Nobody meant to abandon God; the calf was "a symbol of the unseen." Commentators differ on whether this broke the first commandment or the second.

- Exchange. Crediting the calf with the rescue from Egypt put the worshippers "below the level of the beasts that perish."

- Ruin. God measures by His own glory, not by our intentions. The covenant was finished before the tablets ever entered the camp.

Exodus 32:5

And Aaron saw [it], and built an altar before it; and Aaron made a proclamation, and said, To-morrow is a feast to Jehovah!

The scene is a religious one: an altar, a proclamation, a named day of worship — all of it set up in front of a metal calf. Does God's name, spoken over something He never asked for, make that thing acceptable?

An altar built in front of an idol

Aaron does not destroy the calf when he sees it. He builds it an altar, sets a day for a feast, and puts the Lord's name on it.

Besides this, Aaron built an altar before the idol, then announced that the next day they would have a feast "to the Lord"! (v. 5). Can we dare to think we can sanctify an idol by attaching the Lord's name to it? This is gross wickedness.

L. M. Grant

The name left in place

The Lord's name is still in use here. Notice what the devil does with that.

When Israel made the golden calf, the devil did not take away the name of Jehovah. They still said, "Tomorrow is a feast to Jehovah." So the name of God is not thrown out. Instead, something comes in that hides the truth. All Satan's aim is to blot out the Mediator. As long as Satan can block that, he will allow the name, and call it Christianity. But his aim is to keep our souls at a distance from God.

J. N. Darby

(Older translations print "Jehovah" where the ESV has "the LORD.")

A holy label on a forbidden thing

God had told Israel to make no images. Aaron built this altar to honour that same God.

Aaron's proclamation shows the strange blindness that follows disobedience to the plain letter of God's Word. He said, "Tomorrow shall be a feast to Jehovah." And to make their sin holy — the golden calf! (Deut. 9:21) — he built an altar to God's glory in front of it. This mixture is still popular: plain disobedience to God's Word, then a human effort to make it holy. Call the sin holy, and people will hold the abomination in religious awe. They dedicated the image to God, who had commanded them to make no image and to bow down to no image.

H. Forbes Witherby

Watch how the celebration was actually kept.

Calling the festival by Jehovah's name did not touch its real nature. A demon may be dressed in clothes of light, but its true nature still shows. They kept the feast in true pagan style. The camp rang with loud songs sung back and forth, and was wild with sensual dancing. In this way Israel grafted idolatry onto the worship of Jehovah, and so brought the wrath of God down on their camp.

H. Forbes Witherby

Aaron's intention

Aaron later told Moses he was only managing the crowd. His intention did not change the result.

How subtle is sin! When Moses challenged him, Aaron excused himself: he was only humouring the people. What a lot of evil a good man may cause by acting unfaithfully in an emergency! Moses had left Aaron in charge of the people, to meet any difficulty that might arise. But the leader gives in to what the people want, and leads them into idolatry without meaning to. He had no idolatrous aim in what he did, and neither did the people. Aaron's proclamation, "Tomorrow is a feast to Jehovah," was useless. The calf, and not Jehovah, had the homage of their hearts (see Acts 7:41). On this rests the solemn warning to us: "Do not be idolaters as some of them were" (1 Cor. 10:7).

The Bible Treasury

Why anyone wanted a calf at all

The craving behind the calf is common to people everywhere.

The human spirit always tends to materialize what is spiritual. It must have a visible form, an object that can be at least revered, if not worshiped. This was Aaron's problem. In their thoughts, Aaron and the people lowered the Lord to the level of the gods of Egypt, saying, "Here is your God."

Various

The same instinct without the gold

Hands are not the only tool that shapes an idol.

The root of all idolatry is self-will; it is making a god of our own. It starts with self and makes a god — not always out of silver, and not always with our hands. There is a tool more cunning and skilful than the hands, and that is the intellect of man. Wherever self takes the place of God's will, you will find the human mind busy making a god to please itself. And it does this in the name of the Lord, in the name of the true God.

Samuel Ridout

Summary

- Name kept. At Sinai the devil did not erase God's name. He left it in place and slipped an object in front of it. The name stays; the truth is hidden.

- Name misused. An altar and a proclamation cannot make an idol holy; calling the sin holy only wins it religious awe.

- Name exposed. The songs and wild dancing showed what the feast really was, and grafting idolatry onto worship brought God's anger on the camp.

- Name excused. Aaron meant no idolatry and still caused it. A good man was unfaithful in an emergency and led a nation astray.

- Name today. Self-will still makes gods. The tool now is the mind, not our hands. And it still works in the name of the true God: "Do not be idolaters as some of them were."