Exodus 19:16–18

Exodus 19:16 · Darby

And it came to pass on the third day, when it was morning, that there were thunders and lightnings and a heavy cloud on the mountain, and the sound of the trumpet exceeding loud; and the whole people that was in the camp trembled.

On the third day God comes down on the mountain. The God who had carried Israel out of Egypt arrives in storm, cloud and a trumpet blast, and the whole camp shakes. Why does a rescued people tremble at the coming of their own Deliverer? And what is God saying through thunder instead of words?

The signs and what they meant

One writer takes the storm, the cloud and the trumpet each in turn, then presses the question the trembling raises:

There were thunders and lightnings. They expressed judicial power — the way God in His holiness must act when He comes into contact with sinners. There was also a thick cloud on the mountain, showing that He stayed at a distance and hidden from view. The sound of the trumpet was very loud. It announced that God was coming, and it called the people together. All the people in the camp trembled, in spite of the preparations they had gone through. If they had confidence in themselves before, it was now badly shaken, if not swept away. For if they were ready to meet God, why should they fear?

Modernised from Edward DennettOriginal wording

A trumpet that grew louder

The trumpet did not fade; it swelled. That rising volume, one writer says, was God taking the floor and leaving Israel nothing to say:

Along with other awe-inspiring displays, the blast of the trumpet not only continued long, but became louder and louder. This simply means that God was speaking to Israel so loudly as to totally silence any speaking on Israel's part, whether promises or anything else. The trumpet was an announcement for everyone to hear. Here God was announcing the giving of the law, which He was about to lay on the nation Israel as a stern demand. From the very start God was showing that He knew the law was a yoke of slavery Israel would not be able to carry.

Modernised from L. M. GrantOriginal wording

Why the tone changed

God had just spoken of carrying them to Himself. The change of tone goes back to Israel's own promise to obey:

The moment Israel undertook to "do," everything changed... The One who had just said, "I bore you on eagles' wings and brought you to myself," now wraps Himself in a thick cloud and says, set limits for the people all around. The sweet tones of grace and mercy give way to the thunder and lightning of the fiery mountain. Man had presumed to talk of his miserable doings in the presence of God's magnificent grace. Israel had said, "we will do," and so God put them at a distance, where everyone could see clearly what they are able to do.

Modernised from C. H. MackintoshOriginal wording

Fear without self-knowledge

The camp shook, but trembling by itself taught them little. Their alarm stands against a very different response — that of a man who truly saw God:

God showed Israel His terrifying majesty there and then, in a way this world has never known before or since. So the Jews boasted that no other religion began like theirs. Only their ancestors stood around that mountain of God. But were they not standing there in utter fear and trembling? Where was there shown the least real knowledge of God? Where was there any true sense of their own state in His sight? What a contrast with Job, who said, "I had heard of you by the hearing of the ear, but now my eye sees you; therefore I despise myself, and repent in dust and ashes" (Job 42:5-6). How little they admitted that they were guilty sinners, and that there could be no approach to God until their sins were judged and taken away.

Modernised from William KellyOriginal wording

Moses' own fear

The terror reached the one man who went up the mountain:

Hebrews 12:21 gives a detail that Exodus does not mention: "So terrifying was the sight that Moses said, 'I tremble with fear.'" Exodus tells us that the people trembled, but that Moses, along with Aaron, went up into the mountain. Hebrews tells us how he shook as he did so.

Modernised from F. B. HoleOriginal wording

Sinai and Zion

The New Testament sets this mountain against another one:

Israel had come to Sinai, and that was the mountain that marked their whole course from beginning to end. And what was the result of it? As it began with darkness and distance, so it ended with misery and death. Being what they were, and Sinai being what it was, they could not help shrinking back from God. There God stood in His majesty of judgment. He was not there in the love that comes down, takes the burden on itself and carries it away... "But you have come," says the Spirit, "to Mount Zion" — the mountain of God's intervention in grace, as Sinai was of man's responsibility.

Modernised from William KellyOriginal wording

Summary

- Promise — Israel offered to "do," and the tone changed at once. Eagles' wings gave way to a thick cloud, and God took a place of distance.

- Distance — thunder and lightning showed judicial power, and the cloud showed a God who stayed hidden. The limits round the mountain told sinners to keep back.

- Silence — the trumpet grew louder and louder. God announced the law so loudly that no human promise could compete.

- Trembling — the whole camp shook, and so did Moses; yet fear alone gave them no true sense of God or of themselves.

- Zion — Sinai began in darkness and distance and ended in misery. Believers, the New Testament says, have come instead to the mountain of grace.

Exodus 19:17 · Darby

And Moses brought the people out of the camp to meet with God; and they stood at the foot of the mountain.

Israel had promised to do everything the Lord commanded, and now the meeting day comes — thunder, a trumpet, and a burning mountain. Moses leads the nation out of the camp toward God, then halts them at the foot of the mountain — why call a people to meet Him and then fence them off?

The Meeting

The verse holds two things together that pull in opposite directions. Moses brings the people out to meet God, and at the same moment God shuts them out from the mountain.

All these details are solemn. They show that man cannot stand before God on his own merits. They teach at the same time that if a sinner dares to come into contact with Him on that footing, it can only end in his own destruction. Apart from atonement, God cannot meet the sinner on the ground of righteousness without destroying him... Seen in this light it is a moving scene. God was on Sinai in all the awful majesty of His holiness. The people stood in all their distance and guilt, trembling at what they saw and heard. They were shut off from the mountain, yet brought out of the camp to meet with God, and to receive the requirements of His righteous law which they had promised to obey.

Modernised from Edward DennettOriginal wording

The Cause of the Distance

The distance was not where God started with this people. It followed their own promise to obey.

The moment Israel made their vow, the moment they undertook to "do," everything changed... This was a very marked change. The One who had just said, "I bore you on eagles' wings and brought you to myself" now wraps Himself in a thick cloud. He says, "Set bounds around the people." The sweet tones of grace and mercy give way to the thunder and lightning of the burning mountain. Man had dared to talk about his wretched doings in the presence of God's magnificent grace. Israel had said, "we will do," so God set them at a distance, to show in full what they were able to do.

Modernised from C. H. MackintoshOriginal wording

The Foot of the Mountain

Standing at the base, and no closer, was not a punishment but a protection.

Their safety lay in distance. God set bounds around them. They were not to go up the mountain or touch its border — "not a hand shall touch it."

Modernised from An Outline of Sound WordsOriginal wording

No Retreat

The trembling of verse 16 might have sent the camp backwards. Moses moved them forward instead.

On the third day there was thunder and lightning and a thick cloud on the mountain. Then a trumpet sounded very loud, and the people trembled (v. 16). Yet Moses did not let them draw back. He brought them near to the foot of the mountain, to meet a God who was hidden behind the forbidding cloud... So God met their promise to obey Him!

Modernised from L. M. GrantOriginal wording

Moses Alone

Everyone else stopped at the border. Commentators read this single exception as a picture pointing forward.

This is shown from the outset. The people cannot draw near, not even through their representatives. The One who has come down to dwell among them must still hold them at a distance. God calls Moses alone to approach, as a picture of a greater Mediator.

Modernised from Numerical Bible NotesOriginal wording

Sinai and Zion

Later Scripture looks back at this mountain and sets the Christian's place against Israel's.

In Hebrews 12 the Holy Spirit contrasts the position of Israel with that of the Christian. Israel had come to Sinai, and that was the mountain that marked their whole course from beginning to end. And what came of it? As it began with darkness and distance, so it ended with misery and death. Being what they were, and Sinai being what it was, they could not help shrinking back from God. There God was in His majesty of judgment — not in the love that comes down, takes the burden on Himself, and so takes it away. "But you have come to Mount Zion," says the Spirit — the mountain of God's intervention in grace, as Sinai was of man's responsibility.

Modernised from William KellyOriginal wording

What Sinai refused, the blood of Christ gives:

The people were far off, the leaders were not to come near, and had to worship at a distance. The blood of the Lord Jesus Christ, however, brings us near, and we can draw near. The legal covenant always puts man at a solemn and guilty distance from God; the covenant of grace brings man near to God.

Modernised from Arno Clemens GaebeleinOriginal wording

Summary

- Promise. Israel's "we will do" changed the terms. Grace that carried them on eagles' wings gave way to a mountain wrapped in cloud.

- Distance. The bounds were mercy, not cruelty — their safety lay in not touching what they could not survive.

- Meeting. Moses led them out to meet God and stopped them at the foot of the mountain: summoned and shut out in the same breath.

- Mediator. The people could not go up. God called Moses alone to approach — a picture of a greater Mediator to come.

- Nearness. Sinai began in distance and ended in death; the blood of Christ does what the mountain could not, and brings us near.

Exodus 19:18 · Darby

And the whole of mount Sinai smoked, because Jehovah descended on it in fire; and its smoke ascended as the smoke of a furnace; and the whole mountain shook greatly.

Commentary for this verse has not been generated yet.