And Amalek came and fought with Israel in Rephidim.
At Rephidim God had just split a rock to give water to a complaining people. Then an enemy attacked them — why does attack follow so soon after mercy, and who is Amalek?
The word "Then" ties verse 8 to verse 7. One writer traces the attack back not to the water from the rock, but to what Israel had said just before.
An Outline of Sound WordsVerses seven and eight give us not only the literal connection but also the moral connection. In verse seven Israel quarrelled and tested the Lord, saying, "Is the Lord among us or not?" The language of verse eight suggests a consequence. From this we can observe that the moral connection is not between the gift of water from the smitten rock and Amalek's attack, but between the unbelief of the people and Amalek's attack. God does not call to this conflict. He did not say, "Seek out Amalek and destroy him." Amalek seeks out Israel, and it was Israel's unbelief which exposed them to attack.
One writer names what that doubt costs.
C StanleyNothing gives the enemy more power than to doubt whether we are the children of God, or to doubt whether He is with us and for us.
Amalek's family tree is the key to what he pictures.
Samuel RidoutAmalek was Israel's first foe after leaving Egypt. The Amalekites were descendants of Esau, and this, combined with the assault in the wilderness, gives us a clear clue as to what they represent. Esau, the firstborn, stands for what is natural. Jacob, the younger, suggests the sovereignty of grace, which sets the firstborn aside. It is the flesh which is the firstborn in us, and only as born again is faith present. "The desires of the flesh are against the Spirit." You may cultivate it, refine it, improve it, and whatever else, but it remains unchanged.
Commentators differ here. Others see Amalek as the enemy behind the flesh, not the flesh itself:
J. N. DarbyAmalek is everything that was contrary to God — the power of Satan. They were in conflict with Satan always.
Until now Israel had only watched God fight for them. At Rephidim that changes.
C. H. MackintoshIsrael's conflict began when they stood in the full power of redemption. Until they met Amalek, they had nothing to do. They did not divide the sea or drown Pharaoh's armies beneath its waves. They did not bring down bread from heaven or draw water out of the hard rock. They neither had done nor could do any of these things — but now they are called to fight with Amalek. All the previous conflict had been between the Lord and the enemy. They only had to "stand still" and watch the mighty triumphs of the Lord's outstretched arm and enjoy the fruits of victory. The Lord had fought for them; but now He fights in them or by them.
Amalek did not fight like Israel's other enemies.
The Bible TreasuryEach of Israel's foes has its own typical character and method of warfare. The Amalekites represent those carnal and sinful principles which seek now in the wilderness to hinder and injure us. Their way of fighting was mean and cowardly, quite unlike that of the scheming Philistine or the brave Jebusite. They "attacked those who were lagging behind… all who were feeble… when you were faint and weary." This foe lies in wait for every subtle and unfair advantage against our souls. God has sworn to destroy him, and He has commanded, "You shall blot out the memory of Amalek from under heaven; you shall not forget." Other foes might be spared, but not this one. There must be no truce, no quarter.
The fighting happens in the valley. The hill decides it.
Edward DennettJoshua leads his warriors on the plain. Moses — with Aaron and Hur — goes up to the top of the hill. The fight below depends on the lifting up of Moses' hands above. Moses, seen this way, is a picture of Christ above in the value of His intercession. He leads His people in the power of the Spirit below. At the same time He maintains their cause by His intercession in the presence of God, and He secures for them mercy and grace to help in time of need. They therefore have no strength for conflict apart from His priestly intercession.
The day at Rephidim held both a rebellion and God's answer to it.
H Forbes WitherbyIsrael had tested God by their unbelief, saying, "Is the Lord among us or not?" Then Amalek came. But with the enemy came the God-given victory over him! Unbelief in God's faithfulness — God's answer of mercy. The enemy's attack — God's reply of victory. Such is the golden line of God's grace over man's sin, displayed in the glory of God in the wilderness.
- The door. Amalek comes right after Israel asks whether the Lord is among them — the attack follows the unbelief, not the mercy.
- The enemy. Amalek descends from Esau, the firstborn set aside. Commentators read him as the flesh, or as Satan's power working through it.
- His tactics. He strikes the stragglers, the feeble, the faint and weary — so God orders no truce with him at all.
- New orders. At the Red Sea the Lord fought for them; at Rephidim He fights by them, and Israel takes up the sword for the first time.
- The hill. Joshua leads the fight below. Moses' lifted hands above decide it — a picture of intercession, without which there is no strength for the fight.
And Moses said to Joshua, Choose us men, and go out, fight with Amalek; to-morrow I will stand on the top of the hill with the staff of God in my hand.
Israel had just drunk water from the rock at Rephidim when Amalek attacked. Moses splits the work in two. Joshua chooses men and fights in the valley, while Moses climbs the hill with the staff of God in his hand. Who fights, who leads, and where the victory is won — the whole scene turns on that split.
Until now Israel had watched God act while they stood still. The order to choose men marks a change.
C. H. MackintoshThis is the first time we see Israel in conflict with an outside enemy. Up to this point the Lord had fought for them. Exodus 14 says, "The LORD will fight for you, and you have only to be silent." But now the word is, "Choose for us men." True, God must now fight in Israel, as before He had fought for them. This marks the difference in the picture itself. And in what the picture points to, we know there is an immense difference between Christ's battles for us and the Holy Spirit's battles in us. The first, thank God, are all over, the victory won, and a glorious and everlasting peace secured. The second are still going on.
The timing of the attack is one clue to who Amalek is. His name is another.
L. M. GrantGod did not allow the Amalekites to attack until after Israel had been refreshed by the water from the rock. The water is a symbol of the Spirit of God, given by the Son of God as the result of His being struck down at the cross. But though the Spirit now lives in every believer, we quickly learn that there is another nature within us that is against the Spirit. Amalek speaks therefore of the lusts of the flesh. Its name means "licking up," for such lusts lick up all that is beneficial and necessary for our soul's welfare. This is not Satan's attack, but an attack from within us, fed by the desire to get what we want when we want it.
Commentators differ on how far that reading goes. Another writer calls it only half the picture, and points to what Amalek did to God's people:
Edward DennettWhat then is symbolised by Amalek? It is often said that it is the flesh; but this is only part of the truth… the point to be seen here is that Amalek sets himself in open opposition to the people of God, and seeks to hinder their progress, and even to wipe them off the face of the earth. It is therefore the power of Satan — acting through the flesh, it may be — that challenges the onward march of the children of Israel. Satan's cunning shows in the moment he chose for the attack. It came just after the people had sinned, when an enemy might have supposed they were under God's displeasure. But if God is for His people, He will let no enemy destroy them.
Moses hands the fighting to a man whose name shapes how writers read the whole scene.
Frederick W. GrantJoshua is Jesus. The names, as we know, are the same, and Christ in us is our Leader now. Joshua represents Christ acting by the Spirit. He is the Captain of our salvation, and He leads us into the practical grasp of our portion in the heavenly places where He has gone. For fighting the battles of the wilderness, we want such a Leader. We must keep up a real link with heaven to have successful conflict on earth.
Moses does not go up empty-handed. The staff in his hand already had a history.
An Outline of Sound WordsMoses had taken Aaron and Hur with him to the place of intercession, and also the staff of God. That staff had made a way through the Red Sea. It had been shown before Pharaoh as the staff of God's authority and power. Carrying it meant that Moses depended on the power of God in this conflict. Moses needed the support of God's priest, and of Hur, whose name means free or noble. He was unlike the One who intercedes in heaven for us, whose hands are never weary.
Joshua does the fighting. But his skill is not what settled the outcome.
The Bible TreasurySo from the first it was plain that neither strength, nor courage, nor skill, nor a righteous cause decided the victory. Intercession with God decided it. The success of His people depended wholly on His blessing from on high. Nor was it all over in one fight, but the LORD's war with Amalek must be from generation to generation. Moses prays, and Joshua acts.
The two halves of the scene are meant to be held together, not chosen between.
C. H. MackintoshWe have here two distinct things, namely, conflict and intercession. Christ is on high for us, while the Holy Spirit carries on the mighty struggle in us. The two things go together. It is as we enter, by faith, into the power of Christ's intercession on our behalf that we make headway against our evil nature.
- Occasion. The attack comes straight after the water from the rock. Conflict starts for God's people only once God gives the Spirit, not before.
- Enemy. Amalek pictures the appetites that "lick up" what feeds the soul. Others read him as the power of Satan working through the flesh.
- Leader. Joshua's name is Jesus. Christ in us leads the fight by the Spirit, and for the wilderness we want such a Leader.
- Support. The staff in Moses' hand is God's own staff of authority, and even Moses needed the support of God's priest and of Hur.
- Outcome. Victory in the valley hangs on intercession on the hill. Moses prays, Joshua acts, and the war with Amalek runs from generation to generation.
And Joshua did as Moses had said to him, to fight with Amalek; and Moses, Aaron and Hur went up to the top of the hill.
Commentary for this verse has not been generated yet.
And it came to pass when Moses raised his hand, that Israel prevailed; and when he let down his hand, Amalek prevailed.
Israel had to fight Amalek, yet the day turned on Moses' raised hand rather than on the strength of the army. Why should a real battle hang on that?
after
Fighting the Lord's battle was not, by itself, enough to win it.
after
They fought the Lord's battle. But even fighting the Lord's battle is not enough, unless the Lord stretches out His hand to help them.
after Otherwise "Amalek prevailed." Israel might have reasoned about how they fought, about the strength of the enemy, and about ten thousand other things. But in the end, their success depended on Moses holding out his hands. It is very hard for us to see ourselves and Satan as nothing, and God as everything. The moment we get out of dependence on God, we find out our own weakness.
after
The Bible records no prayer from Moses here. His posture said everything.
after
He knew full well that the outcome of the conflict lay with the Lord. It was more important to be before God than to have powerful forces to meet the enemy.
after The record gives no word spoken to the Lord, but the uplifted hands of Moses showed his attitude. It was a sign that he looked to God for the victory, and the Lord acknowledged it. When the hands of Moses were lifted, Israel prevailed. When they fell, Amalek prevailed... Moses also took the rod of God to the place of intercession. That rod had opened a way through the Red Sea, and it had been shown before Pharaoh as the rod of God's authority and power. It signified that Moses depended on the power of God in this conflict.
after
Commentators differ on what Amalek pictures. One takes the name itself as the clue:
after
The Spirit now lives in every believer. But we soon learn that there is another nature within us, and it is against the Spirit...
after Amalek speaks therefore of the lusts of the flesh. Its name means "licking up," for such lusts lick up all that is beneficial and necessary for our soul's welfare. This is not Satan's attack, but an attack from within us, fed by the desire to get what we want when we want it.
Another writer calls that only half the story, and points to the timing of the assault:
It is often stated that it is the flesh; but this is only part of the truth... So the power that challenges the onward march of the children of Israel is the power of Satan, perhaps acting through the flesh. And Satan's subtlety in the time he chose for the attack is plain. The attack came just after the people had sinned. At such a moment an enemy might suppose that they were under the displeasure of God.
after This is always his method.
after
The fighting and the praying are not two separate stories.
after
We have here two distinct things, namely, conflict and intercession. Christ is on high for us, while the Holy Spirit carries on the mighty struggle in us. The two things go together. By faith we enter into the prevailing power of Christ's intercession for us. That is how we make headway against our evil nature.
after
The hand came down through plain weakness. And weakness needs help.
after
Weakness made him "let down his hand," and then Amalek prevailed... In themselves, believers are powerless. The strain of battle is more than they can bear, and their hands hang down.
after Aaron and Hur go up with Moses, and they support and hold up his weary hands... So Aaron, a figure of God's High Priest, holds up the hand which would otherwise droop. Christ, as our High Priest, maintains our faith. As He once said to Peter, "I have prayed for you that your faith may not fail." This is what He does for us now. His intercession assures us of victory, so we have boldness against the enemy.
after
Moses' hands failed. There is One whose hands never do.
after
W. T. P. WolstonWe depend on the continual intercession of our blessed Lord Jesus Christ. Do you think His hands ever hang down? No! Do they ever grow weary? Impossible! "And he led them out as far as Bethany, and lifting up his hands he blessed them. While he blessed them, he parted from them and was carried up into heaven" (Luke 24:50-51). He was seen going up into heaven with His hands raised in blessing, and so they are to this day.
- Hand up. Success did not rest on how Israel fought or how strong the enemy was, but on Moses holding out his hands to God.
after
- Hand as sign. Moses said nothing; his raised hands declared that he looked to God for the victory.
after
- Hand down. The moment dependence on God stops, we find out our own weakness — and Amalek gains ground.
after
- Hand held. Moses' hands grew heavy, so Aaron and Hur held them up. Christ our High Priest now holds up faith that would droop.
after
- Hands unwearied. Our Lord went into heaven with hands lifted in blessing, and they have never come down. Victory in the fight rests on an intercession that never tires.
after
And Moses' hands were heavy; then they took a stone, and put [it] under him, and he sat on it; and Aaron and Hur supported his hands, one on this side, and one on that side; and his hands were steady until the going down of the sun.
Israel has just drunk water from the rock. Now Amalek attacks the camp at Rephidim, and this time the people must fight. Yet the day is not won in the valley where the swords are. It turns on the hilltop, where an old man's arms grow tired.
Joshua leads real soldiers against a real enemy. Yet the swing of the day tracks Moses' arms, not Joshua's skill.
J. N. DarbyThey fought the Lord's battle: but it is not enough even to be fighting the Lord's battle unless the Lord stretches out His hand to help them. Otherwise "Amalek prevailed." Israel might have reasoned about how they fought, about the strength of the enemy, and about ten thousand other things. But in the end, their success depended on Moses' hands stretched out. It is very hard for us to see ourselves and Satan as nothing, and God as everything.
At the Red Sea, God told Israel to stand still. Here He tells them to fight. Commentators read the change as a change of enemy.
W. T. P. WolstonWhen it was a question of Pharaoh, the word was, "The LORD will fight for you, and you have only to be silent." If the question is deliverance from the power of Satan, God does all the fighting. But the flesh is a different matter — and mark you, you always have the flesh in you. Then there must be conflict, and the order is, "Fight with Amalek." What is the power for the conflict? It is the Holy Spirit.
This unsettles anyone who expects the struggle to be over once they are saved.
C. H. MackintoshHad Israel imagined that when Pharaoh's armies were gone their conflict was at an end, they would have been badly shaken when Amalek came upon them. The fact is, theirs only then began.
The scene runs on two levels at once.
C. H. MackintoshWe have here two distinct things: conflict and intercession. Christ is on high for us, while the Holy Spirit carries on the mighty struggle in us. The two things go together. It is as we enter, by faith, into the power of Christ's intercession on our behalf, that we make headway against our evil nature.
The verse does not hide Moses' weakness. Aaron and Hur stand for what their names and roles carry.
Edward DennettBut no one man could be a perfect picture of Christ. Moses' hands were heavy, so Aaron and Hur held them up. This only brings out the truth of Christ's intercession more fully. Aaron, though not yet formally set apart, represents the priesthood, and Hur, if the meaning of the name may guide us, pictures light or purity. Together, then, they mean the priestly intercession of Christ, kept in holiness before God. That intercession rests on all that Christ is and has done. So it is always effective, and it always prevails.
Moses needed help. Another writer turns to Christ going up into heaven.
W. T. P. WolstonHe goes up with His hands lifted in blessing — as a priest. Have they ever been let down? Surely not. No Aaron and Hur are needed to hold up the hands of the blessed One I am speaking of. His hands have never grown heavy. He has been blessing ever since — carrying on a ministry of love that makes the heart dance with joy.
The stone is not an incidental prop. It carries the weight so the hands can stay up.
C StanleyAt such a time it matters more than anything to remember that great stone — no, the Rock of Ages — supports you… The stone was not put under Moses so that he could let his hands hang down. It was put there so that his hands could be held up steadily. I do not show you this Rock so that you may grow careless and stop trusting God for victory over sin. I show it to encourage your faith in the darkest hour.
The same writer reads "one on one side, and the other on the other side" as help from two directions at once.
C StanleyThere is the exalted Son of God on the one side — that is, in the very presence of God — holding up the hands of faith, making intercession. And on the other side, that is, down here, in the believer, is the Holy Spirit making intercession. How doubly held up!
The verse ends by marking the time: the hands held out until the sun went down.
J. N. DarbyWe have this comfort: whatever the circumstances, through the priesthood and the righteousness of the Lord Jesus, our blessing is kept up for us — and this until the going down of the sun.
- Enemy. The conflict starts after deliverance, not before. God fought Pharaoh for Israel; the flesh Israel must fight.
- Dependence. The valley never decides the day; lifted hands do. We and Satan are nothing, and God is everything.
- Intercessor. Christ is on high for us; the Holy Spirit fights in us. Faith in that intercession gains ground.
- Support. Weak hands need a stone and two helpers — priesthood and purity. Christ's hands need neither, and have never come down.
- Sunset. Through the priesthood and righteousness of the Lord Jesus, our blessing is kept up — steady until the sun goes down.
And Joshua broke the power of Amalek and his people with the edge of the sword.
Israel's first battle after leaving Egypt ends in a single line: Joshua defeats Amalek in the valley. But the chapter has already shown where that strength came from: not the swordsmen below, but the hands lifted on the hill.
The timing matters. The fight breaks out right after the rock is struck and the water flows.
F. B. HoleIn type, Israel had been sheltered from judgment by the blood of the lamb, and redeemed from the world and Satan at the Red Sea. They had been miraculously fed, and now through the smitten rock the gushing water, a picture of the Spirit, had been given. Immediately afterwards Amalek appears, a picture of the flesh. How fitting all this is!… So it is not until we as believers receive the Holy Spirit that this conflict begins. In our unconverted days the flesh reigned supreme, and its power in our lives was unchallenged.
The name itself tells you what this enemy does.
L. M. GrantAmalek speaks therefore of the lusts of the flesh. Its name means "licking up," for such lusts lick up all that is beneficial and necessary for our soul's welfare. This is not Satan's attack, but an attack from within us, fed by the desire to get what we want when we want it.
Commentators differ here. Some say that naming the flesh does not go far enough:
Edward DennettWhat then does Amalek symbolise? It is often said that he is the flesh; but this is only part of the truth… The point to be seen here is that Amalek sets himself in open opposition to the people of God. He seeks to hinder their progress, and even to destroy them from the face of the earth. It is therefore the power of Satan — acting through the flesh, it may be — that challenges the onward march of the children of Israel.
The man at the head of the fighting men points past himself.
Edward DennettJoshua represents Christ, in the energy of the Spirit, leading His redeemed to the conflict. What a consolation! If Satan marshals his forces to attack the Lord's people, Christ leads out His chosen men to meet the foe. The battle therefore is the Lord's… It would help us to stop depending on man, and to count upon the Lord.
Being on the right side of the war was not enough on its own.
J. N. DarbyThey fought the Lord's battle: but it is not enough even to be fighting the Lord's battle unless the Lord stretches out His hand to help them. Otherwise "Amalek prevailed." Israel might have reasoned about the way they fought, about the strength of the enemy, and about ten thousand other things. But in the end, their success depended on Moses' hands being stretched out. It is very hard for us to see ourselves and Satan as nothing, and God as everything.
Two things happen at once here, and they belong together.
C. H. MackintoshChrist has fought for us; the Holy Spirit fights in us… The comfort is that we are victors before we enter the field of conflict at all… We have here two distinct things: conflict and intercession. Christ is on high for us, while the Holy Spirit carries on the mighty struggle in us. The two things go together. It is as we enter, by faith, into the power of Christ's intercession on our behalf, that we make headway against our evil nature.
The weapon itself matters. (Older translations read "with the edge of the sword" where the ESV has simply "with the sword.")
Frederick W GrantLet us remember, too, that it was "with the edge of the sword" that Joshua defeated his enemies. And the "sword of the Spirit is the word of God."… It is this which enables self-judgment — the judgment of the foes of our peace and blessing. Our Amalek is within. Our battleground is that of our own hearts.
Joshua won the day, but the enemy was not wiped out. That difference matters for how a believer reads his own experience.
F. B. HoleAmalek was driven back and defeated, but he was not yet utterly destroyed, as he will be… There is power for us to keep the sentence of death on the flesh, so that we do not fulfil its lust. We are kept from doing the things we otherwise might. But the flesh still remains in us, though we have received the Spirit.
- Water, then war. The conflict starts only once the Spirit comes. Struggle inside a believer is a sign of new life, not proof against it.
- Amalek named. Some writers read him as the lusts of the flesh. Others see Satan's power working through the flesh. Either way, he is an enemy who wants to stop God's people moving forward.
- Joshua below. Christ leads His redeemed into the fight by the Spirit. So the battle is the Lord's, not ours.
- Hands above. Fighting on the right side is not enough on its own. The battle below turned on the hands held up above. Conflict in us rests on intercession for us.
- Sword in hand. Victory came by the sword: the word of God turned on our own hearts. The win is real, but the enemy is not wiped out yet.
And Jehovah said to Moses, Write this [for] a memorial in the book, and rehearse [it] in the ears of Joshua, that I will utterly blot out the remembrance of Amalek from under the heavens.
Israel had just beaten back the Amalekites at Rephidim. God's first answer to the victory was not a monument but a command to write. He tells Moses to write the event in a book and read it aloud to Joshua. To it He attaches a sentence He will carry out Himself: Amalek's memory will be wiped out completely.
This is where the written word of God begins.
A J PollockThe first mention of writing in the Bible is when "the Lord said to Moses, write this as a memorial in a book" (Ex. 17:14). That small beginning is God putting His thoughts in writing for man. From it grows the full development we have in the Bible, where God makes known all His counsels and glories.
Amalek's family line shapes what he stands for.
F. B. HoleAmalek came from Esau, the man of bodily appetite, who sold his birthright for a meal. So he makes a fitting picture of the flesh.
Commentators differ on how far that picture reaches. One writer says that calling Amalek "the flesh" stops short of the full meaning. Amalek came out to block a whole nation's march and wipe it off the earth.
Edward DennettWhat, then, does Amalek stand for? Many say he stands for the flesh, but that is only part of the truth… The point to see here is that Amalek sets himself in open opposition to the people of God. He seeks to hinder their progress, and even to destroy them from off the face of the earth. So it is the power of Satan — perhaps acting through the flesh — that challenges the forward march of the children of Israel.
Amalek attacked by stealth. The sentence God passes on such an enemy is not correction but removal.
F. B. HoleAmalek was a very cunning foe, as we discover when we read Deuteronomy 25:18. In our experience the flesh acts in just this way. It attacks us at what we may call our weak points — though these are often the points we imagine to be our strong ones! God then passed the sentence of death on Amalek in its most extreme form, as we see in verse 14. In the same way God has "condemned sin in the flesh" in the death of Christ.
What God writes down for His people looks in two directions.
Edward DennettThis memorial combined two things: the record of their rescue from Amalek, and the pledge of his final overthrow. Every display of the Lord's power on behalf of His people has this double character. If He steps in and defends them against their enemies' attacks, that same act assures them of His continual protection and care. So every time He comes between them and their foes, it should be repeated in their ears and written on their hearts — a memorial of the past, and a guarantee of His unchanging defence.
The promise to blot out Amalek is not a promise that the fighting stops soon.
J. N. DarbyI dare say many of us have thought, when we have seen the necessity of dependence on the Lord, that one good battle with Satan, and all will be over; but no such thing. We have security and the certainty of victory. But we have no promise that conflict will stop while we are in the wilderness… God told Israel He would utterly blot out the memory of Amalek from under heaven; yet still the Lord will have war with Amalek from generation to generation. Until Christ comes, until Satan is bound, until we have the full result of victory, we must count on conflict. Not slavery to Pharaoh, but war with Amalek. Our comfort is this: it is the Lord who makes war, though He does it through Israel, and so Israel has to fight.
Centuries later God acted on this word.
The Bible TreasuryGod had not forgotten what Amalek did to Israel, as told in Exodus 17:8-16. Now the time had come to carry out divine vengeance. God entrusted Saul with the duty of fulfilling the purpose He had announced long before (Ex. 17:14). Generations had come and gone since the Lord swore that He would utterly blot out the memory of Amalek from under heaven. Had He forgotten His oath? No. The lapse of time made no change in His mind.
- Written. God's command to Moses is the Bible's first act of writing. Everything He later made known in Scripture grows from it.
- Written against an enemy. Amalek came from Esau, who sold his birthright for a meal. He pictures the flesh — and some see behind him the power of Satan opposing God's people.
- Written as a death sentence. God's verdict on Amalek was removal, not reform, matching how He "condemned sin in the flesh" at the cross.
- Written as a pledge. The record holds both a past rescue and a guarantee of the final overthrow still to come.
- Written for the fight ahead. Victory is certain, but the conflict continues. God's oath waited generations for Saul to act, and time never weakened it.