For Haman the son of Hammedatha the Agagite, the oppressor of all the Jews, had devised against the Jews to destroy them, and had cast Pur, that is, the lot, to consume them and to destroy them;
Esther 9:24 gives the official reason for a new yearly feast. In one sentence the Jews recorded where their enemy came from, how far his hatred went, and how he chose the date.
The verse does not call Haman a Persian official. It ties him to Agag, and commentators read that as a family line, not a job title. This also explains a refusal earlier in the book that looks, at first glance, like simple rudeness:
Morrish Bible DictionaryHaman was the son of Hammedatha the Agagite (Esther 3:1-10; Esther 8:3, 5; Esther 9:24). Fürst says that Josephus explains Haman's Gentile name as meaning "Amalekite by race," and Jewish tradition says the same. That is, Haman was an Amalekite. This explains why Mordecai refused to bow down before Haman. He belonged to the race the LORD had sworn to fight for ever, and the race Saul had orders to destroy completely.
Amalek was Israel's sworn enemy, under a standing verdict from God. Mordecai's refusal rested on that, not on personal pride.
The verse calls him "the enemy of all the Jews," and the plot matches the title. One man's slight was not enough for him:
J. G. BellettHe must have the blood of all the Jews; his heart will not be satisfied by the life of the one who had refused to honour him. He must have the lives of the whole nation. He breathes the spirit of the enemy of Israel. That enemy later says, "Come, let us wipe them out as a nation; let the name of Israel be remembered no more!" (Ps. 83).
The verse stops to translate the foreign word: Pur means "the lot." Haman did not work out a date. He gambled for one. Writers point out what that shows about him:
H. L. RossierThe Antichrist will rage against those who do not acknowledge his power and authority, and who refuse to bear his mark on their forehead and hands. Haman's fury is like it. It burns against a man who despises his person and refuses his yoke, and it knows no limits. But he would have scorned to put Mordecai alone to death. He must strike him down together with all his people. Haman cast Pur (that is, the lot) to learn when this extermination should take place. He believes in this superstitious practice. Later the Antichrist will do the same and consult the "god of fortresses" (Dan. 11:38). Even the most unbelieving man must have some religion: a fact we may observe every day.
The lot he consulted named the last month of the year. That left the threatened people a long window in which to escape:
H. L. RossierThe lot points to the twelfth month for the massacre of the Jews. Why not the third or the fourth month, to take away any chance of escape from the oppressed people? Is it not once again hidden Providence which directs everything as always? What can "the enemy of the Jews" (Esther 9:10, 24) do against the secret counsels of Providence? He must obey the lot he has consulted, and from that point his swift road to death and judgment begins.
The Jews could have named the holiday after Esther, or Mordecai, or the battle. They named it after Haman's dice. They knew whose hand had thrown them:
Leslie M. GrantThe two-day feast the Jews set up at this time was called Purim, after Pur, the lot Haman cast with the aim of destroying the Jews. Very likely the Jews knew Solomon's proverb, "The lot is cast into the lap, but its every decision is from the LORD" (Proverbs 16:33). Haman had expected demon power to back him up. But no doubt the Jews recognised that the Lord had stepped in with His own clear decision. The Jews did recognise the Lord's hand in this. Yet God still did not allow His name to be mentioned in public.
Some writers read Haman as a preview of an enemy still to come:
Arno Clemens GaebeleinAmalek is always the bitter enemy of Israel. His final overthrow will come with the second coming of Christ... This Haman, the Amalekite, is later called "the Jews' enemy" (verse 10). He foreshadows that final enemy. That enemy rises to trouble Israel and tries to wipe them out before the King of Israel appears.
- Ancestry. "The Agagite" ties Haman to Amalek, Israel's sworn enemy — he inherited his hatred, he did not invent it.
- Ambition. He wanted a nation, not a man; Mordecai's refusal was the excuse, extermination was the aim.
- Lot. Pur means "the lot." He trusted chance and dark powers to name the day — even the most unbelieving man keeps some religion.
- Overruled. The lot he obeyed gave him the twelfth month, and that delay opened his own road to death and judgment.
- Memorial. The Jews named the feast Purim after the enemy's dice — they turned his weapon into their calendar.
and when [Esther] came before the king, he commanded by letters that his wicked device, which he had devised against the Jews, should return upon his own head; and they hanged him and his sons on the gallows.
Esther 9:25 is the short official summary of the whole story: Haman's plot, Esther's appeal, and the reversal that hanged the schemer on his own gallows. It raises the question the book never answers by name — who turned the plot around?
The verse looks back to the "Pur," the lot Haman threw to pick the day for the massacre. That day fell almost a year later. Commentators see God's hand behind the long delay.
J. G. BellettThe Amalekite and his company cast the lot, the Pur, only to fix the day for this act of extermination. But as we know, the lot may be "cast into the lap, but its every decision is from the LORD" (Prov. 16:33). And so it was here. Eleven long months stand between the two dates. The lot was cast on the thirteenth day of the first month, and it fixed the slaughter of the nation for the thirteenth day of the twelfth month. That time was given so that God would ripen His purposes toward both His people and their enemies.
The verse turns on a single moment: the matter came before the king. That hearing is where a private scheme became public knowledge.
Leslie M. GrantVerses 24-25 briefly retell the history of the plot of Haman the Agagite to wipe out the Jews. He cast Pur, that is, the lot, which in Haman's case meant consulting evil spirits. At first his scheme seemed to be working. Then Esther stepped in — the king not only respected her, he loved her — and the whole plot came out into the open. So Haman's wickedness recoiled on his own head, and he and his sons were hanged on the gallows he had put up for Mordecai.
"His evil plan... should return on his own head" is not only poetic justice. Writers point out that God's purpose and Haman's own choices are both fully real here.
Ernst-August BremickerGod does not only use circumstances or events to carry out His purposes. He also uses people — whether godly people like Mordecai and Esther, or ungodly and wicked people like Haman... God's dealings with people never contradict or remove man's responsibility. Man is not a puppet in His hand... In the book of Esther this is seen in connection with the great enemy and hater of the Jews called "this wicked Haman" (7:6). In the end, his wickedness resulted in his own destruction and their salvation. People may call this irony, but it is nothing of the kind. It was God's hand and purpose. It was also the outcome of Haman's own free decision, and he was fully responsible for all his decisions and actions.
Commentators see a settled rule of Scripture here, not a one-off.
Leslie M. GrantSo the evil Haman planned came back violently on his own head, as Ecclesiastes 10:8 warns, "He who digs a pit will fall into it."
Some writers find more than irony in the gallows Haman built.
Michael HardtIt is beautifully significant that Haman hangs on the gallows he had prepared for Mordecai. At the cross, Satan was defeated. Through death, the one who had the power of death was destroyed (Heb. 2:14). What looked like a great defeat turned out to be the greatest victory of all time — and the end of the adversary.
The feast takes its name from Haman's lot. Yet God is still not named, even in the letters that set up the feast. Commentators contrast what God's book leaves out with what man's own writings later put in.
William KellyHere again, notice, the book holds to its character all the way through. Even here it does not name Him whom it would normally be the highest duty to proclaim. Yet the complete contrast shows up in man's own word. The Talmud lays down that at the feast of Purim a man should drink until he cannot tell the difference between "Blessed be Mordecai" and "Cursed be Haman."
Others read the feast as pointing forward rather than backward.
H. L. RossierOnly one feast, the feast of Purim, is mentioned in this book: a new feast that will last forever in memory of the deliverance of God's earthly people... So ends this account. It brings us to the dawn of the glorious time that follows deliverance, and points us prophetically to the threshold of the millennial reign of Christ.
- Plot. Haman schemed to destroy a whole people, and the plan looked unstoppable.
- Lot. The "Pur" he cast set the date eleven months away — time in which God ripened His purposes.
- Return. The evil he devised came back on his own head; God's purpose and Haman's own responsibility both stand.
- Gallows. He died on the structure he built, a reversal some read as a picture of the adversary's defeat at the cross.
- Memorial. Purim keeps his lot in its name, so the deliverance would never be forgotten — yet God's name stays unspoken to the last.
Therefore they called these days Purim after the name of Pur. Therefore, according to all the words of this letter, and for what they had seen concerning this matter and what had happened to them,
The verse looks back and explains a name. The Jews called their two days of feasting Purim, after "Pur" — the lot Haman cast when he picked a date to wipe out the Jews. It also ties the yearly feast to three things: a letter, what the people had faced, and what had happened to them.
The name comes straight from "Pur," the lot Haman cast. It fixes the feast to the very moment his plot began.
Morrish Bible DictionaryA feast, meaning 'lot or lots.' Haman cast lots to find a favourable day for the destruction of the Jews. When that danger passed, the Jews kept a yearly feast to remember their deliverance. Esther 3:7; Esther 9:24-32. It fell on the 14th and 15th of Adar.
So the Jews named their rescue after the lot that was meant to destroy them.
Naming the feast after Pur only makes sense if the lot itself was not random. Commentators point to the delay the lot produced. That gap is where the whole rescue happened.
Morrish Bible DictionaryGod overruled among His people how the lot should fall... He could also direct it among the nations to work out His own purposes, as He did in the case of Haman. The result delayed his plan for so long that Esther had time to act. New decrees could go out all over the kingdom, so that the Jews might be saved from destruction. Esther 3:7; Esther 9:24.
What Haman read as a lucky day, the Jews traced to the Lord.
Leslie M. GrantVery likely the Jews were familiar with Solomon's proverb, "The lot is cast into the lap, but its every decision is from the Lord" (Proverbs 16:33). Haman had expected demonic power to back him up. But no doubt the Jews recognised that the Lord had intervened with His own clear decision. Yet, even though the Jews surely did recognise the Lord's hand here, God did not allow His name to be even mentioned publicly.
The book of Esther never mentions God, and the founding of Purim does not break the silence either. Writers see that silence as deliberate.
William KellyIn the book of Esther we have no more than the witness of secret providence in the face of the most extreme dangers. It looks on to that grand public outcome. Meanwhile it produces a striking and lasting ordinance of Him who delivers though unseen.
The verse grounds the feast in what "was written in this letter" — Mordecai's instruction to the Jews.
H. L. RossierIt is Mordecai who, like the future Messiah, orders joy and rest. The Jews submit themselves to the written word of a man who had been unknown and ignored by all, including themselves. God had now exalted him in the sight of everyone.
The verse gives two more reasons: what they had faced, and what had happened to them. Word and experience agree.
Purim is the only feast this book records, and it reaches far beyond its own day.
H. L. RossierThe memory of these days lives on from age to age. This book mentions only one feast, the feast of Purim: a new feast which will last for ever in memory of the deliverance of God's earthly people. Esther and Mordecai are in perfect harmony with the people; what Esther and Mordecai establish, the people establish for themselves... This account ends by leading us to the dawn of the glorious time that follows deliverance, and it leads us prophetically to the threshold of the millennial reign of Christ.
Readers sometimes ask whether this feast turns up again later in the Bible.
Morrish Bible DictionaryThe New Testament never mentions this feast by name. Some suppose John 5:1 refers to it, but there is no hint of that, and such a feast did not call the Lord to go to Jerusalem.
A memorial can survive for centuries and still lose its point. Later Jewish tradition shows how.
William KellyThe Talmud lays down that at the feast of Purim a man should drink until he cannot tell the difference between "Blessed be Mordecai" and "Cursed be Haman." "Stop regarding man in whose nostrils is breath, for of what account is he?" Judaism, and Christendom where Christ is ignored, both sink into the driest ditch of paganism. Both dare to approve a wild carnival where there had once been a holy feast.
- Pur — the feast carries the name of the enemy's lot, so each year the rescue recalls the plot that failed.
- Overruled — God directed how the lot fell. The delay it created gave Esther and the new decrees time to work.
- Unnamed — God is never mentioned, in the book or in the feast; Purim stands as a lasting ordinance of the One who delivers unseen.
- Written — the Jews kept the days because of a letter, what they had faced, and what had happened to them; word and experience together.
- Guarded — a feast can outlive its meaning. Drinking until Mordecai and Haman sound alike turns a holy day into a carnival.
the Jews ordained and took upon them, and upon their seed, and upon all such as joined themselves to them, so that it should not fail, that they would observe these two days according to their writing and according to their fixed time, every year;
Commentary for this verse has not been generated yet.
and that these days should be remembered and observed throughout every generation, in every family, every province, and every city, and that these days of Purim should not fail from among the Jews, nor the memorial of them cease from among their seed.
Two days of rescue could have faded with the people who lived through them. Instead they became a yearly feast for every generation and every place. Two questions follow. What were the Jews remembering? And why does a feast the Lord never appointed still stand?
The days carry the name of the weapon the enemy used against the Jews. A dictionary entry gives the facts:
Morrish Bible DictionaryA feast, meaning "lot" or "lots." Haman cast lots to find a favourable day for the destruction of the Jews. When that plan was stopped, the Jews marked their deliverance with a yearly feast. It fell on the 14th and 15th of Adar. The Jews still keep the feast. They read the Book of Esther, and they pronounce curses on Haman and on his wife, and blessings on Mordecai and on Harbonah.
Naming the feast after the lot raises the question of who really controlled it. One writer answers that, and points to what God still kept out of public view:
Leslie M. GrantThe two-day feast the Jews established at this time was called Purim. The name refers to Pur, the lot Haman cast in order to destroy the Jews. Very likely the Jews knew Solomon's proverb, "The lot is cast into the lap, but its every decision is from the Lord" (Proverbs 16:33). Haman had expected demon power to back him up. But no doubt the Jews recognised that the Lord had stepped in with His own clear decision. They surely did recognise the Lord's hand in this. Yet God still did not allow anyone to even mention His name publicly.
The verse describes a duty the Jews took on and handed to their children:
Leslie M. GrantSo the Jews established the feast of Purim and imposed it on themselves and their descendants. They took on the urgent responsibility of celebrating these days every year. The feast continued in every family of the Jews, wherever they were, so that they would never let the memory of this great occasion fade from their minds (vv. 26-28).
The verse names every province and city. That reach was the whole empire — and the keeping went further still:
Leslie M. GrantMordecai sent letters to all the Jews in the 127 provinces of the kingdom of Persia. His aim was to confirm the yearly observance of the Feast of Purim at the appointed time. Esther was joined with this decree as well. From that time Israel has gone on observing the Feast of Purim, even where Jews are scattered in other lands.
Reading the book kept the memory alive, and it did its work in the hardest times:
Arend RemmersThe Jews read Esther during the Purim feast, on 14th and 15th Adar (February/March). So it is one of the best-known Old Testament books among the Jews. It also has the oldest surviving copies. The book of Esther has supported the Jewish people in their national hope, above all in days of persecution.
Purim is not listed among the feasts God appointed. Commentators note the distinction and see something telling in it:
Leslie M. GrantSo the history here speaks of Purim as a feast of the Jews, not a "feast of the Lord." Leviticus 23:1 speaks of "The Feasts of the Lord." But in John 2:13 the Passover is called "the Passover of the Jews," and another feast of the Lord was called "the Jews' Feast of Tabernacles" (John 7:2). Why? Because the Jews were not seeking the Lord's honour first of all, but their own enjoyment.
Later tradition turned the memorial into something else:
William KellyThe Talmud lays down that at the feast of Purim a man should drink until he cannot tell the difference between "Blessed be Mordecai" and "Cursed be Haman." "Stop regarding man in whose nostrils is breath, for of what account is he?" (Isaiah 2:22). Judaism, and Christendom where Christ is ignored, both sink into the driest ditch of heathenism. Both dare to sanction a drunken carnival where there had been a holy feast.
One writer reads this lasting feast as a signpost to what comes after deliverance:
H. L. RossierThe memorial of these days is carried on from age to age. This book mentions only one feast, the feast of Purim. It is a new feast which will last for ever, in memory of the deliverance of God's earthly people... So ends this account. It leads us to the dawn of the glorious time that follows deliverance, and leads us prophetically to the threshold of the millennial reign of Christ.
- Threat — The days are named after Pur, the lot Haman cast to pick a day to destroy the Jews. The name of the weapon became the name of the celebration.
- Rescue — Behind the lot stood the Lord. His decision overturned Haman's. Yet God kept His own name out of public view.
- Record — The Jews bound themselves and their children to keep these days every year. The memory of the rescue must not fade.
- Reach — Letters went out to 127 provinces. The feast has been kept ever since, wherever the people were scattered. The book, read aloud, held up their hope under persecution.
- Reign — Commentators weigh Purim differently. It is a feast "of the Jews," not one the Lord appointed, and it later slid into a drunken carnival. Yet it is also read as a memorial that points on to the reign of Christ.
And queen Esther the daughter of Abihail, and Mordecai the Jew, wrote with all authority to confirm this second letter of Purim.
Chapter 9 ends not with a battle but with a letter from Queen Esther and Mordecai, fixing the feast of Purim for every generation. Why is the feast named after the enemy's lot, and why does this book never name God?
Mordecai had already written once. Here the queen's authority stands behind his instruction too.
Arno Clemens GaebeleinThe final part of this chapter tells of a message that Mordecai sent to the Jews in the provinces of the Persian kingdom. He told them to observe these days, the feast of Purim. Queen Esther also wrote with all authority confirming this second letter of Purim.
The weight of the letter rests on who sent it. Mordecai had once been ignored by everyone; now the nation bows to his written word.
H. L. RossierIt is Mordecai who, like the future Messiah, orders joy and rest. "The Jews undertook to do as they had begun, and as Mordecai had written to them." They submit to the written word of a man who had been unknown and ignored by everyone, including themselves. God had now exalted him in the sight of all.
The name of the feast comes from the enemy's own method.
Morrish Bible DictionaryA feast, meaning 'lot or lots.' Haman cast lots to find a good day to destroy the Jews. When that plan came to nothing, a yearly feast marked their deliverance instead. It fell on the 14th and 15th of Adar. The Jews still keep the feast. They read the Book of Esther, curse Haman and his wife, and bless Mordecai and Harbonah.
The book of Esther never mentions God, and the letter of Purim does not correct that. Yet the lot Haman trusted was not neutral.
Leslie M. GrantVery likely the Jews were familiar with Solomon's proverb, "The lot is cast into the lap, but its every decision is from the LORD" (Proverbs 16:33). Haman had expected demonic power to back him up. But no doubt the Jews saw that the Lord had stepped in with His own clear decision. The Jews surely did recognise the Lord's hand in this. Yet God still did not allow His name to be mentioned in public at all.
Queen, Mordecai, and the people were of one mind about keeping the day.
H. L. RossierThis book mentions only one feast, the feast of Purim. It is a new feast that will last forever in memory of the deliverance of God's earthly people. Esther, Mordecai, and the people are in perfect harmony. What Esther and Mordecai set up, the people set up for themselves. So this account ends. It leads us to the dawn of the glorious time that follows deliverance, and points us on to the threshold of the millennial reign of Christ.
Commentators see a picture in each of these two names. The verse gives Esther her father's name, and Mordecai is still called "the Jew."
Michael HardtMordecai is a Jew who acts fully in the king's interest, and in the end the king exalts him. He represents Christ… Esther represents the true bride: the future faithful Jewish remnant.
A day can be kept for centuries and still lose its meaning. One writer sets God's silence in the book beside what people later made of the feast.
William KellyHere again the book keeps to its character. Even now it does not name Him whom it would normally be the highest duty to proclaim. Yet man's word makes the full difference plain. The Talmud lays it down that at the feast of Purim a man should drink until he does not know the difference between "Blessed be Mordecai" and "Cursed be Haman." … Judaism, and Christendom where Christ is ignored, each sink to the lowest depths of paganism. Both dare to approve a drunken carnival where there had once been a holy feast.
- Letter. Mordecai wrote first. Here Esther adds her full authority to confirm that second letter of Purim.
- Lot. "Purim" means 'lot or lots.' Haman cast lots to pick a day to destroy the Jews, so the feast carries the name of his failed plan.
- Hidden. God is never named in the book or in the letter. Yet every decision of the lot came from Him, and He worked for His people unseen.
- Lasting. Queen, Mordecai, and people agreed. What the two set up, the nation took up — a memorial that points on to the deliverance and reign still to come.
- Warning. A commanded day can still be spoiled. Tradition turned a holy feast into a drunken carnival, in Judaism and in Christendom alike.
And he sent letters to all the Jews, to the hundred and twenty-seven provinces of the kingdom of Ahasuerus, words of peace and truth,
Commentary for this verse has not been generated yet.
to confirm these days of Purim in their fixed times, according as Mordecai the Jew and queen Esther had enjoined them, and as they had decreed for themselves and for their seed, as to the matters of the fastings and their cry.
Esther 9:31 turns a rescue into a calendar. Two days in the month of Adar are set at a fixed time each year. Mordecai and Queen Esther confirm them, and the people take them up for themselves and their children. The verse carries an odd note too. The fasting and the crying of the crisis go into the record beside the feasting. And God is never named.
The obligation runs in two directions. Mordecai and Esther lay it down, and the people accept it as their own — not for one generation, but for every one that follows.
Leslie M. GrantThe Jews set up the feast of Purim and laid it on themselves and their descendants. They took on the urgent responsibility of celebrating these days every year. The feast continued in every family of the Jews, wherever they were, so that the memory of this great occasion would not fade from their minds.
These days also keep alive the fasting and the crying, not only the rescue. And the account ends by looking forward.
H. L. RossierEsther and Mordecai are in perfect harmony with the people. What Esther and Mordecai establish, the people establish for themselves (v. 31). Every generation celebrates what was "written in the book" (v. 32) on the occasion of their fasting and their cry. So ends this account. It leads us to the dawn of the glorious time that follows deliverance, and it leads us in prophecy to the threshold of the millennial reign of Christ.
By this point in the book the Persian king has faded from view. The letters that fix the feast carry Mordecai's name, and the people submit to them.
H. L. RossierThe king of the nations no longer appears on the scene except in dependence on Esther and Mordecai. They alone are in question until the end of the chapter. It is Mordecai who, like the future Messiah, orders joy and rest. "The Jews undertook to do as they had begun, and as Mordecai had written to them." They submit to the written word of a man who had been unknown and ignored by everyone, including themselves. God had now exalted him in the sight of all.
Purim was not one of the feasts of the law. It grew out of a rescue that came with no miracle at all.
William KellyHow this danger was turned aside by secret providence, without a miracle, and even turned into the destruction of their enemies, is the story of this book… So here is the ground of a feast, added to the original feasts of the law. That feast carried its own special record of a merciful intervention, on a day so evil that everything most excellent and cherished by faith went unmentioned.
Kelly finds the same silence at the very point the feast is set up:
William KellyNotice again that the book keeps to the character stamped deeply on it. Even now it does not name Him — the One whom it would normally be the highest duty to proclaim.
Grant ties that silence to the state of the people who were keeping the feast.
Leslie M. GrantIn all of these instructions it seems strange that God is not mentioned. Yet it is clear that God's hand of protecting care had been over the Jews, to deliver them from their enemies. Very likely the Jews did include God's name in their celebration. But Scripture says nothing of this, because the Jews at that time showed no evidence of obedience to God. In effect He was disowning them in public, while caring for them behind the scenes.
The words chosen for these days say what they mark. They also reach far past Esther's own time.
Michael HardtThe language of verse 22 is beautiful and full of meaning. The Jews were to celebrate the 14th and the 15th day "as the days on which the Jews rested from their enemies", "the month that was turned to them from sorrow to joy", and "from mourning into a good day"… Finally, the time of Jacob's trouble (Jer. 30:7) will be over. The Jews — long scattered and persecuted — will "rest from their enemies", and Israel will enter its sabbath rest.
- Rescue — no miracle, and no name of God in the decree, yet His care ran under the whole story.
- Record — the fasting and the crying were written down with the joy, so the feast never forgets the trouble.
- Rhythm — the two days are set at a fixed time, so each generation hands the rescue on instead of letting it fade.
- Received — Mordecai and Esther lay the obligation down, and the people take it up for themselves and their children.
- Rest — the month turned from sorrow to gladness points to a greater rest still ahead for Israel.
And the decree of Esther confirmed these matters of Purim; and it was written in the book.
Commentary for this verse has not been generated yet.