Ecclesiastes 2:7–8

Ecclesiastes 2:7 · Darby

I acquired servants and maidens, and had servants born in my house; also I had great possessions of herds and flocks, above all that had been in Jerusalem before me.

Solomon's list of possessions keeps growing: servants, herds, flocks. Why was a king piling all this up? And did any of it satisfy him?

Why the list is so long

Solomon's throne gave him the means to test what most people can only guess at.

Solomon was lifted high, so that from his position and resources he could inspect and test the vanity of all human conditions. Everything that business or pleasure could provide for him was within his reach. So was everything that wealth, position, or learning commanded. And he challenged it all to say what it was worth.

Modernised from The Bible TreasuryOriginal wording

Where this verse falls in the search

One writer traces a pattern through the opening verses of the chapter. The servants and possessions come at one stage of it.

He experimented, so to speak, with what belongs to the natural man, a fallen nature. That nature holds three things: the lust of the flesh, the lust of the eyes and the pride of life. We can trace these three things in the opening verses. The lust of the flesh comes in verses 1-3. The lust of the eyes in verses 4-6. The pride of life in verses 7-8… To all this he added servants and maidens, with great possessions.

Modernised from Arno Clemens GaebeleinOriginal wording

What the servants cost the nation

Where did all these servants come from, and who paid for them?

Solomon pressed the Amorites, Hittites, Perizzites, and others left in the land into service (1 Kings 9:20). He built new cities and rebuilt others (1 Kings 9:17-19). But all this meant heavy taxation. In time the people groaned under the burden, while Solomon groaned with heart disappointment. The load of taxation probably made the people ask Rehoboam to make their service less harsh and their yoke lighter (1 Kings 12:4). Men will not complain like that when the Lord reigns in Zion.

Modernised from W. W. FeredayOriginal wording

Heaping things up for self

Behind the herds and flocks stands the man. One writer names the aim of the whole collection.

He turned to wine — a dangerous thing. He married wives. He carried out great works. He gathered riches. He did not only sip; he drank deeply from every sparkling cup. He tried every pleasure he could imagine. He not only ruined his testimony; he wrecked much of his kingdom too. He heaped up every delightful thing for himself and made everything serve himself. His aim in all this self-gratification was to be able to say, "So I was great."

Modernised from F. B. HoleOriginal wording

Multiplying against instruction

God had set limits for Israel's kings. The same writer shows what ignoring them cost.

He multiplied horses and wives and riches. He did the three things the king was told not to do, and did them openly and without shame. All this building up of self rests on one idea: that the way to live is to get everything possible for your own pleasure. The consequence is solemn. It traps you in disobedience, and you forfeit the support of God. Solomon did not act in ignorance of God's Word. It was simply staring him in the face, which made what he did all the more shocking.

Modernised from F. B. HoleOriginal wording

The verdict on the whole section

Solomon put real energy and skill into these works. Here is how it ended.

Might activity in great works do better? Solomon attempted this and carried it out with extraordinary diligence and splendour. But then he reviewed all the work he had done and all the toil it had cost him. He could rest in none of it. The whole thing was vanity, a chasing after the wind, with nothing to be gained under the sun (verses 4-11).

Modernised from William KellyOriginal wording

Why nothing acquired could fill him

Why could none of it satisfy him?

To him, self was seeking its own satisfaction. So here was no rest, no peace; it could not be otherwise. No human object could satisfy an immortal soul, and a dying man could get no rest in something he was going to die out of. When he thought of himself, it was all I, I, I — I did it, and I found it vanity. But in the Song of Songs we see all his blessedness, because there he speaks of Christ being everything to him. As someone has said: in Ecclesiastes the heart was too great for the object; in the Song the object is too great for the heart.

Modernised from J. N. DarbyOriginal wording

Summary

- Scale. Solomon had resources no ordinary person has. His verdict on wealth is tested, not guessed.

- Possession. The servants, herds and flocks mark the pride-of-life stage of his search. He gathered them all so he could say, "So I was great."

- Cost. Forced labour and heavy taxes paid for the splendour. The people groaned under the burden while the king groaned with disappointment.

- Consequence. Solomon did the very things God told Israel's kings not to do. Building up self traps a man in disobedience and forfeits God's support.

- Verdict. He looked over it all and could rest in none of it. An immortal soul cannot be filled by what a dying man must leave behind. The heart was too great for the object.

Ecclesiastes 2:8 · Darby

I gathered me also silver and gold, and the peculiar treasure of kings and of the provinces; I got me men-singers and women-singers, and the delights of the children of men, a wife and concubines.

Solomon's list of possessions peaks here: silver and gold, tribute from kings and provinces, trained singers, and more. Two questions follow. What does the last phrase describe? And did a man who could buy anything end up owning anything worth having?

The word behind "treasure"

Older versions call this "the peculiar treasure." The term is not a general word for wealth. It marks a possession valued above all others.

Ecclesiastes 2:8 is the one exception, where Solomon gathers "the peculiar treasure of kings." Everywhere else, in the Old Testament and in the New Testament, these expressions refer to what God's people are to Him: Exodus 19:5; Deuteronomy 14:2; Psalm 135:4; Titus 2:14. The terms describe a possession of specially choice value.

Modernised from Morrish Bible DictionaryOriginal wording

Solomon takes the word Scripture uses for God's own people and puts it on his treasury.

Pride of life

One writer traces three appetites of the fallen nature through the chapter. This verse falls in the last of them.

In that fallen nature there are three things: the lust of the flesh, the lust of the eyes and the pride of life. We can trace all three in the opening verses. The lust of the flesh comes in verses 1-3, the lust of the eyes in verses 4-6, and the pride of life in verses 7-8… He gathered silver and gold and treasures that only kings could get. These were gifts, probably from other rulers, perhaps the ones the Queen of Sheba brought. He also paid attention to music, had men singers, women singers, and an orchestra. Then, self-satisfied, he leans back and says, "So I was great."

Modernised from Arno Clemens GaebeleinOriginal wording

Commentators differ over the closing words. The ESV reads them as "many concubines, the delight of the sons of man." One writer gives both options: music, or many wives.

…the delights of the sons of men, that is, musical instruments of all sorts [or, as it may also be translated, and perhaps more correctly, "a wife and wives," that is, many wives].

Modernised from C. E. StuartOriginal wording

A law he knew and ignored

If that second reading stands, this verse shows Solomon breaking the rules written for Israel's kings.

He multiplied horses and wives and riches. He openly did the three things the king was told not to do. All this self-glorifying rests on the idea that the way to live is to get everything you can for your own pleasure. The result is solemn. You are trapped into disobedience and you lose the support of God. Solomon did not act in ignorance of God's Word. It was staring him in the face, so what he did was outrageous.

Modernised from F. B. HoleOriginal wording

Everything aimed at himself

Read the surrounding verses aloud and one small word keeps returning. The verbs change; the object never does.

The result was that Solomon became very selfish. This too comes out clearly in Ecclesiastes 2. Read the passage again, and note how he puts it: "I made me… I built me… I planted me… I got me… I gathered me… So I was great." His life became one of self-gratification. He might almost have said, "For me to live is — SELF." And the Apostle Paul? In Philippians we have his word, "For to me to live is — CHRIST" (Philippians 1:21). Nothing contrasts more sharply than a life lived for self and a life lived for Christ.

Modernised from F. B. HoleOriginal wording

The verdict on the whole collection

Solomon did not guess at the results. He ran the trial with resources no one else has ever had.

Thank God, before Solomon ended his career his eyes were opened. He was led to write this striking book, which records the results of the experiment. God did not inspire him in doing what he did, but He did inspire him to record the result. Listen to what he says: I have investigated on a grand scale, a scale that others can never touch. Others might have one per cent of it; I have had the whole hundred per cent. The verdict is that there is not a bit of profit in it. There is "no profit under the sun."

Modernised from F. B. HoleOriginal wording

The failure was not in the quality of what he gathered. It was in what a human heart is built to hold.

You could pour every river of earthly pleasure into discontented human hearts, and they would still be empty and unsatisfied. Men hunt for satisfaction where it never can be found. An iceberg yields no heat, salt no sweetness, and wine cannot be pressed from turnips. Man's heart was made for God, and only God, in Christ, can fill and satisfy it. Riches, fame, pleasure, all fail to bring contentment to the heart.

Modernised from C KnappOriginal wording

Summary

- Gathered — the word for "treasure" is the one Scripture keeps for God's own prized people. Solomon used it for his vaults.

- Grand — singers and royal tribute mark the peak of the pride of life. The closing phrase means either music or many wives.

- Forbidden — horses, wives and riches were the three things Israel's king was told not to multiply. Solomon knew the text.

- Self — every line runs "I made me… I got me," and the whole life adds up to "So I was great."

- Empty — the man who had one hundred per cent of what money can buy returned the verdict "no profit." Only God fills a heart made for God.