Colossians 2:8–18

Colossians 2:8 · Darby

See that there be no one who shall lead *you* away as a prey through philosophy and vain deceit, according to the teaching of men, according to the elements of the world, and not according to Christ.

Paul warns the Colossians about what could carry them away from Christ. He names three dangers — philosophy, human tradition, the elements of the world — and one test that exposes them all: they are "not according to Christ."

Taken as Prey

The older translation reads "spoil you." One writer draws out the picture:

"Beware lest any man spoil you". It means "make a prey of you". It is like a captured animal, unable to move where it would normally move, taken out of its own surroundings. And all through philosophy and empty deceit — there is nothing in it at all.

Modernised from George DavisonOriginal wording

Some minds are caught more easily than others:

Nothing captures intellectual people more easily than the philosophy of the world's teachers, because it is so hard to follow and so involved. It stands for the highest flights of human thought and imagination. But here Paul joins it to "vain" or "empty" deceit. That shows us clearly what it really is as God sees it.

Modernised from F. B. HoleOriginal wording

Philosophy That Is Empty Deceit

The two words are not two separate dangers. They describe one thing from two sides:

The first of these is philosophy and vain deceit. As we understand it, this is philosophy that is nothing but empty deceit. It has to be described that way. It comes from man's mind. Human reason shapes it into a system. Its aim is to corrupt the revelation God has been pleased to give by His Spirit in His inspired Word. It is Rationalism, pure and simple, judging everything by its own idea of what suits man. So sinful man would sit in judgment on the thoughts of God!

Modernised from The Christian's FriendOriginal wording

Faith will not even use philosophy as a helper:

Faith rejects philosophy, not only as a rival but as an ally. It rests on God's Word alone. It takes that Word as absolute and as the only authority.

Modernised from William KellyOriginal wording

Human Tradition

Scripture does not condemn every tradition. What matters is the source:

Tradition may be described as teaching handed down by word of mouth. It may come from God… teaching handed down before the word of God was complete. Or it may come from man, like the tradition of the elders of Israel. The Lord condemned that tradition strongly. He said it overturned the commandments of God… In Colossians 2:8 it is the mere teaching of the moralists, and much of that has survived to this day. What man sets up, man holds on to most tightly.

Modernised from Morrish Bible DictionaryOriginal wording

The Elements of the World

This phrase covers wide ground:

The rudiments or elements of the world are every subtle principle and motive that comes from the world, apart from God. They take in everything that makes up the spirit and character of the world, whether religious or not.

Modernised from The Christian's FriendOriginal wording

Commentators differ. Others tie the phrase to religious forms: "the elements of the world" are "the religious ordinances invented by men or borrowed from Judaism" (Hamilton Smith).

Reason and Religion Working Together

Philosophy and tradition look like opposites. This verse sets them side by side:

Here, I take it, we have the mixing of natural man's philosophy with religious man's tradition. At first sight these two look far apart, but they are not so in the end… Nothing shows an active spirit of evil at work in the world more than the way he draws up and combines these two armies, which on the outside look like enemies… They may look completely hostile to each other. In fact both are hostile only to the truth.

Modernised from William KellyOriginal wording

The Test: Not According to Christ

One test detects every trap in this chapter:

The apostle now names certain traps the believers faced. They were opposed to full Christian teaching, and ruinous to souls: philosophy (verse 8), teaching that pressed the Jewish law (verse 16), and Gnostic speculations (verse 18). The test that detects each of them is the teaching about the Lord Jesus Christ. Apply that test, and the evil is exposed.

Modernised from The Christian's FriendOriginal wording

Reasoning alone will not catch false teaching:

Our reasoning powers do not detect evil doctrine, since false doctrine always enlists them on its side. Its harmful character may not show at first. Yet a God-fearing soul refuses it, because it is not "as it is written" — "not according to Christ."

Modernised from H H SnellOriginal wording

The Antidote

Paul does not leave us staring at the danger:

Then, as if he did not want us to dwell too long on the evil, he points us at once to the Divine Source of all good… He sweeps aside every rival and sets us in the presence of Christ, the all-sufficient One… Here then is the great antidote! The fullness of the Infinite One dwells in Him in whom we are complete.

Modernised from H J VineOriginal wording

Summary

- Captured — "Spoil" means to make a prey of you: carried out of your own element, held where you cannot move freely.

- Empty — Paul calls this philosophy vain deceit. It rises from man's mind and sets human judgment over God's revelation.

- Handed down — Tradition can come from God or from men; what man invents, man clings to hardest.

- Combined — Human reason and human religion look like enemies. Yet they work together, and both fight the truth.

- Christ — One test exposes it all: is this according to Christ? The cure is not watchfulness alone. It is the fullness that dwells in Him, in whom you are complete.

Colossians 2:9 · Darby

For in him dwells all the fulness of the Godhead bodily;

Paul has just warned the Colossians about teaching that runs "according to human tradition... and not according to Christ" (Col. 2:8). This verse gives his reason: everything God is now lives in one Man, in a body. It raises three questions: what "deity" means here, why Paul says "bodily", and what that leaves for philosophy to add.

(Older translations read "in Him dwells all the fulness of the Godhead bodily" — the wording the writers below use.)

The Test Every Teaching Must Pass

The warning in verse 8 ends with three words: "not according to Christ."

But God answers the whole deception with three words of contrast: "not after Christ." Christ is the exact opposite of it all, the pattern and the test — "for," it says, "in Him dwells all the fulness of the Godhead bodily." There is not a lack, not a gap, not one single quality that goes to make up that fullness, that is not found bodily in Christ... So what room is left for poor human philosophy, or teaching, or worldly elements? Nothing can be added to God's fullness! It is enough for Him, and therefore enough for faith.

Modernised from J Wilson SmithOriginal wording

The Word Behind "Godhead"

Paul had a milder Greek word for "divine" available, and did not use it.

It is well known that theiotes (from theios, meaning divine), also translated "Godhead" in the Authorized Version, has a completely different force from theotes (from Theos, meaning God) in Colossians 2:9. In this second case it would fall far short of the apostle's aim to say only that the person of Christ is divine: all the fulness of the Deity, or Godhead in the strictest sense, he says, dwells in Him bodily.

Modernised from William KellyOriginal wording

"Bodily" — a Real Body, Then and Now

The word "bodily" rules out the idea that God filled only Christ's spirit.

We know God in Christ as a living Person who once lived bodily in this world, who still has His body above the world... in the Person of Christ "dwells all the fulness of the Godhead bodily," not only in His spirit, but really in Him bodily, though He is now glorified. He had a real, true body from the incarnation, and in that body all the fullness of the Godhead dwelt. The fullness of the Godhead never dwelt in the Father bodily, or in the Holy Spirit, but only in Christ.

Modernised from William KellyOriginal wording

Colossians 1:19 says something very close, but about a different time.

There is a strong likeness between Col. 1:19 and verse 9 of our chapter; only there it refers to that which was true of Him in the days of His stay on earth, while here it stands true of Him today. It is hard to imagine a stronger statement of His deity. Yet the word "bodily" plainly implies that He is still Man.

Modernised from F. B. HoleOriginal wording

God Brought Within Reach

Because the fulness dwells in a body, knowing God stops being a search and becomes a meeting.

There is something wonderfully blessed here. It is not seeking after God, hoping that we might feel after Him and find Him... but, as John says, "which we have heard, which we have seen with our eyes, which we looked upon and have touched with our hands, concerning the word of life" (1 John 1:1) — something brought home to the senses of men. Instead of working up our feelings to seek after something, God has come down to us, poor wretched creatures that we are... There is not a trouble, not a distress, not a feeling in the heart of man, that is not met in Christ... not as a doctrine only, but bodily.

Modernised from J. N. DarbyOriginal wording

This also decides who can grasp it.

Christ has taken a body and appeared in flesh. So the fulness of the Godhead is shown in a way the simplest people can know. It may take a giant mind to understand even the words in which philosophy struggles to express its guesses. Yet simple fishermen of Galilee can see the fulness of God in Christ, and so enter into truths the greatest natural mind cannot grasp.

Modernised from Hamilton SmithOriginal wording

The Two Sides of the Statement

The next verse adds a second truth to this one.

First, all the fulness of the Godhead dwells in Him bodily. Instead of the misty speculations of men, we have the fulness of God bodily, in a real human body, and so with real effect for us, in the Person of Jesus Christ. Second, we are complete in Him; we need nothing outside of Christ. On one side, we have in Him God perfectly presented in all His fulness. On the other side, we have in Him perfection and completeness before God.

Modernised from J. N. DarbyOriginal wording

Summary

- Fulness — the cause. Paul answers "not according to Christ" with a Person. No quality of that fulness is missing in Him, so nothing can be added.

- Fulness — the word. He uses the strictest term for Deity, not the milder word meaning "divine", so nothing less than God Himself is meant.

- Fulness — in a body. "Bodily" means a real body from the incarnation. It is true of Him still, now that He is glorified — He remains Man.

- Fulness — within reach. God did not wait for us to search Him out. He came down to be heard, seen and touched, so simple fishermen see what philosophy cannot reach.

- Fulness — the result. The fulness dwells in Him, and believers are complete in Him: God fully revealed on one side, the believer complete before God on the other.

Colossians 2:10 · Darby

and ye are complete in him, who is the head of all principality and authority,

Some were telling these believers to add something to Christ: philosophy, rules, respect for angels. Paul's answer is not a longer list of duties. It is a Person. The verse states two facts. It says what the believer already is in Christ, and what Christ already is over everything else.

"Filled Full"

Older translations say "complete in Him." Newer ones say "filled." Both translate one Greek word. Its root ties this verse to the fullness of God named just before it.

The word comes from a Greek verb meaning "to fill full." The believer is complete in Christ, or filled full. This points to all fullness dwelling in Christ. The fullness of the Godhead is in Christ, as toward the believer. And the believer, as toward God, is complete in Him.

Modernised from Morrish Bible DictionaryOriginal wording

Another writer names where that fullness now dwells: in a Man on high.

Here then is the grand antidote! The fullness of the Infinite One dwells in Him in whom we are complete. He came down beneath all for our salvation, and He is now above all in exaltation. He is the glorified Man who glorified God on earth and is now crowned on high. In Him the Godhead fullness dwells bodily, and we too are filled full in Him.

Modernised from H J VineOriginal wording

Nothing To Add

If the word means "filled full," the answer to every proposed add-on is already given. One writer lists the extras people were pressing on these believers, then asks what any of them could contribute.

"You are complete in Him." This surely covers everything. What can anyone add to a person who is already "complete"? Take philosophy, human tradition, the basic principles of the world, food and drink, festivals, new moons and Sabbaths, "Do not touch" this, "do not taste" that, "do not handle" the other, the commandments and teachings of men, days and months and seasons and years. Could any of these things, or all of them put together, add the smallest thing to one whom God has pronounced "complete"?

Modernised from C. H. MackintoshOriginal wording

A Fact, Not A Feeling

The verse states where the believer stands, not how far they have progressed. So it does not measure how complete anyone feels.

This is not experience, but a fact which all believers have title to enjoy. Also, Christ is the Head of all rule and authority. That is, the highest ranks and powers are under Him and depend on Him. So we do not depend on them. We depend on Him.

Modernised from Leslie M. GrantOriginal wording

Nothing Between

The second half of the verse meets one particular error: treating angels as go-betweens. Christ is Head over every rule and authority, so no middleman has any place.

"You are complete in Him." Notice this: far from having anyone between us and Christ, we are in Him who is the Head of all rule and authority. We lose our standing if we allow an angel to come between Christ and us, even though an angel, as a creature, is far above us. There is no mediator between us and Christ. There is one between us and God, and that mediator is Christ Himself.

Modernised from J. N. DarbyOriginal wording

The same principle covers any figure put between the believer and Christ. It also shows where spiritual growth comes from.

To bring angels, or any other creature, whether the Virgin or saints, between our souls and Christ is to deny our direct union with Christ. He is the head of all rule and authority. As Head to the body, He Himself gives all spiritual nourishment, through the spiritual help that the members of the body supply. In this way the soul's spiritual growth is kept up, and the body of Christ grows with the increase of God, quite apart from any ministry of angels.

Modernised from Hamilton SmithOriginal wording

The Test Today

The extras on offer today have different names. The verse answers them the same way.

There is a Man upon the throne of God in whom all the fullness of the Godhead dwells. All the mighty resources of God are in Him for us; we are complete in Him. That means there is no necessity to go outside Him for anything we need. We do not need philosophy, the wisdom of man, religious organizations, or anything men can produce.

Modernised from J T MawsonOriginal wording

Summary

- Full — "Complete" translates a word meaning "filled full." All the fullness that dwells in Christ is the measure of what the believer has in Him.

- Fact — This is standing, not experience. Every believer already has title to enjoy it, whatever their feelings say.

- Finished — Nothing adds to one God has called complete: not philosophy, tradition, food rules or holy days.

- First — He in whom we are filled is Head over every rule and authority. So no creature, angel or human, may stand between Him and us.

- Free — All the resources of God are in Him. So we need nothing outside Him, and we can draw everything from Him.

Colossians 2:11 · Darby

in whom also ye have been circumcised with circumcision not done by hand, in the putting off of the body of the flesh, in the circumcision of the Christ;

Circumcision was an outward rite, cut into the body by a human hand. This verse tells believers they already have a circumcision no hand performed — and the question is what it cut away, and when.

Nothing to add, nothing to cut off

The verse opens with "in him." That phrase leans on the verse before, which says believers are filled up in Christ. One writer draws both halves together:

"In Him," says the apostle, "the whole fullness of deity dwells bodily." All is in Christ, nothing is lacking in Him. But in verse 10, it is we who have all in Him. Nothing is lacking for us: "You have been filled in Him." So we cannot seek to add anything to ourselves apart from Him. Now we come to circumcision. Not only, says the apostle, is there nothing to add, but there is nothing to cut off from those who are in Him. The body of the flesh is judged, you are deprived of it; it is a thing done, it is the circumcision of Christ… Here, then, we have two great truths: we are complete before God in Christ, and perfectly delivered from all that we are in ourselves.

Modernised from H. L. RossierOriginal wording

Made without hands

A human hand did the old rite on a human body. This one is different, and the difference goes deeper than method.

This stands in clear contrast with the outward rite of circumcision. It should be "putting off the body of the flesh," not the body "of the sins" of the flesh. The true reading makes it a fuller thing. It is not a question of sins, but of sin in the nature… It does not refer to the literal act of circumcising, but to Christ's death. When we believe in Christ, all the value of His death is made true of us… We are brought into association with His death. When we receive Him by faith, we have all its value in parting with our own ruined condition, "the body of the flesh." This circumcision supersedes all others, which in no way stripped off our evil state as man in the flesh.

Modernised from William KellyOriginal wording

Older English Bibles read "the body of the sins of the flesh." Commentators say the shorter reading is the true one, and the ESV follows it.

The circumcision of Christ

Whose circumcision does the verse mean? One writer traces the outward rite forward:

This outward rite — a cutting around and off of man's flesh — pointed forward to what the death of Christ accomplished, as Colossians 2:11 shows… As Christians we are to recognise that we have put off the flesh in its totality in the death of Christ. We are "circumcised" in His "circumcision"; that is, His death.

Modernised from F. B. HoleOriginal wording

Not a trimming of the flesh

Philippians 3 sets a counterfeit against the real thing:

The word translated "concision" means a mere lopping off, in contrast to the complete cutting off of death, which was pictured in circumcision. The men Paul calls "the concision" believed in lopping off the uglier outgrowths of the flesh. But they would not have that bringing in of death, "by the circumcision of Christ," which is the truth of Christianity… Men cannot really boast in the grosser expressions of the flesh. So they aim at lopping them off, to encourage more likeable and refined expressions in which to make their boast. But it is still boasting in the flesh.

Modernised from F. B. HoleOriginal wording

Another writer names where this instinct starts:

In his religious hopes, man looks to cut this and that evil thing away from himself, and so make himself fit for God's service. But in Christ we are complete. In Him we are also circumcised, and by nothing less than the putting off of the body of the flesh itself!

Modernised from H Forbes WitherbyOriginal wording

A finished fact, then a daily practice

The letter states this as already done. Yet it also tells believers to put to death what is earthly. One writer shows how the two fit:

Circumcision means that I disown and put the flesh to death, I will have nothing to do with it and put it off. It is the practical working out of what I have in title in Christ (Col. 2:11), being a figure of having put off the old man, not that one has to put him off. Having Christ as my life, Christ dead and risen, I can say that this is not I, but sin in the flesh… "Put to death therefore what is earthly in you." This assumes power in Christ. It means, not that I am to die, but that I am to put to death.

Modernised from J. N. DarbyOriginal wording

Summary

- In Him — those who are complete in Christ have nothing to add to themselves, and nothing left to cut off.

- Without hands — a human hand did the old rite. This circumcision is God's work, and it supersedes every rite that never touched our real condition.

- His cutting off — "the circumcision of Christ" is His death, and we are "circumcised" in it.

- The whole flesh — not sins picked off one by one, but the body of the flesh in its totality. False religion only lops off the uglier growths, so it can still boast in what remains.

- Title, then practice — what is already true in Christ is the ground for putting to death what is earthly. We disown the flesh because His death has already put it off.

Colossians 2:12 · Darby

buried with him in baptism, in which ye have been also raised with [him] through faith of the working of God who raised him from among the dead.

Paul has just spoken of a circumcision made without hands. Now he shows how that cutting off reaches us. We are buried with Christ, and we rise with Him by God's power. Two questions follow: what does baptism picture, and where should faith look?

Burial: Done with the Old Order

The first half of the verse describes an ending. One writer sums up baptism in a single word:

Baptism means, in one word, separation. It is only an outward ceremony, yet it has a meaning, and that is its meaning. It rests on the death and resurrection of Christ, for we are "baptized into His death" (Rom. 6:3), and so we are "buried with Him" (Col. 2:12). Nothing cuts our links with the world, and separates us from the present order of things, more completely than death and burial.

Modernised from F. B. HoleOriginal wording

Burial reaches further than bad behaviour. It touches a whole standing before God:

Since we are circumcised, or cut off, in "the circumcision of Christ" (Col. 2:11), we have lost the old position we once held before God as men in the flesh linked with Adam. Now that we are risen with Christ, grace has given us a new standing with Him, completely different from the old one.

Modernised from F. B. HoleOriginal wording

Why Colossians Says More Than Romans

Romans 6 also speaks of burial with Christ, but stops short of saying we are risen. The difference is deliberate:

Here the doctrine carries one a little farther than either Romans 6 or 1 Peter 3. There is death and burial of all we were; but there is here at least resurrection with Christ — death and resurrection. In Romans the emphatic point is simply death, because the argument of the apostle in chapter 6 does not admit of going beyond the truth that the baptized believer is alive from the dead — not exactly risen, but alive unto God. In Colossians the argument requires that our resurrection with Christ, as well as death and burial, should be distinctly stated.

Modernised from William KellyOriginal wording

Another writer traces the same step and shows where it leads: baptism here is not just the end of the old, but an entrance.

In Colossians baptism does more than show what the death of Christ means for our old state. It is the door through which, by faith in God's working, we come into association with Him who is in a new and risen state. In Romans baptism is tied to justification from sin. Justification frees me. Here it is tied to being complete in Him.

Modernised from The Christian's FriendOriginal wording

The Working of God

The rising comes not from the water but from "the powerful working of God." That is the same power that raised Christ, and it brings full forgiveness with it.

Baptism was the sign and expression of this. Faith in the working of God who raised Him is the means that brings about in us this wonderful resurrection with Christ, into a new state and scene… But it is the power of God Himself, the same power that worked in Christ, that works in us to give us the new standing in life. Seen together with our resurrection with Christ, it means — by the very fact that we receive it — that we are forgiven perfectly and for ever… Raised up with Him, sharing the life He has as risen from the dead, we have left behind — like Him and with Him — all that burden of sin and condemnation, along with the death from which we have been set free.

Modernised from J. N. DarbyOriginal wording

Where Faith Looks

Notice where the verse points faith. It points to God raising Christ, not to my own experience.

Notice how this comes in. The faith is not faith in my being risen, but faith in Christ's having been raised. That difference matters greatly. Many a sincere soul keeps turning inward to find out whether it is risen. But that is not "faith in the powerful working of God, who raised Him from the dead."

Modernised from The Christian's FriendOriginal wording

Commentators differ over how closely resurrection may be tied to baptism itself. One writer keeps the two apart:

This leaves baptism with its own true meaning: the person baptized is buried to death… Faith in God's working comes in at that point and frees baptism from the thought of resurrection — though resurrection does follow where there is faith in God's working.

Modernised from The Christian's FriendOriginal wording

A Standing, Then a Summons

Chapter 3 opens with a command to seek what is above. That command rests on this verse, not the other way round:

"If then you have been raised with Christ, seek the things that are above" (Col. 3:1) — that is, since you are risen with Christ, let the power of resurrection show in daily life. "Raised with Him" (Col. 2:12) is the reality, and the appeal calls us to live up to it.

Modernised from F. B. HoleOriginal wording

Summary

- Buried — Baptism means separation. Death and burial cut the believer's links with the world.

- Cut off — What ends is a position, not just habits. The old standing before God in Adam is gone.

- Raised — Baptism is a door: by faith we are joined to Christ in His risen state.

- God's working — The power that raised Christ gives the new standing. It brings perfect, lasting forgiveness with it.

- Faith's object — Faith rests on Christ being raised, not on checking yourself. That settled fact is the ground for the call to seek the things above.

Colossians 2:13 · Darby

And you, being dead in offences and in the uncircumcision of your flesh, he has quickened together with him, having forgiven us all the offences;

Verse 13 turns from what God did in Christ to what He did in the readers themselves. He made dead people alive, and He forgave them everything.

The State We Were In

The verse describes the readers twice over before it says anything about God's action. One writer reads the double description as covering both conduct and condition:

As we begin verse 13 we pass from what has been accomplished in Christ to something accomplished in us. As to our spiritual state we were dead; dead in our sins — what we had done; dead in the uncircumcision of our flesh — what we were. But now made alive — made to live — together with Christ; our new life being of the same order as His.

Modernised from F. B. HoleOriginal wording

Another commentator explains why that second phrase matters, and what it rules out:

Verse 13 reminds us of our sad previous condition. We were dead in sins, with no spark of life toward God. We were also in "the uncircumcision of your flesh" — that is, in the state of unjudged corruption. A person in such a condition is totally unfit for God. Out of such a state God has made alive together with Christ every believer. This is God's own direct gift of eternal life. It reminds us of the words of the Lord Jesus: "the dead will hear the voice of the Son of God, and those who hear will live" (John 5:25). This being made alive is tied to the full forgiveness of all trespasses. So the work done in us and the work done for us go hand in hand.

Modernised from Leslie M. GrantOriginal wording

Not Just Made Alive — Made Alive With Him

Life alone would have met our need. But the verse says more. One writer draws the line between what our case demanded and what God chose to give:

We meet with it both in Ephesians 2:5 and Colossians 2:13 — we have been made alive "together with Christ." Both letters describe us as dead — "dead in the trespasses and sins" (Eph. 2:1), and "dead in your trespasses and the uncircumcision of your flesh" (Col. 2:13). Nothing short of being made alive would meet our case. So being made alive was a necessity. But there was no necessity that we should be made alive together with Christ. That is the fruit of the counsels of God in grace.

Modernised from F. B. HoleOriginal wording

One writer shows where that new life begins, and what got left behind:

Instead of its being a question of the flesh getting better, not only is it condemned already, but we have been made alive together with Christ. This is no mere doctrine: Christ is our life. I am in this new man before God. And what has become of all my sins? They are gone. He has made me alive out of Christ's grave, and they are left behind. Christ went down with my sins into the grave. They were put away on the cross — "He himself bore our sins in his body on the tree" — and the grave is the expression of that. When He rose again they were all gone.

Modernised from J. N. DarbyOriginal wording

Life As the Proof of Pardon

The verse sets life and forgiveness side by side. One writer shows why they cannot be separated:

The very life we have received as believers is the token that our trespasses are gone. If God has made us alive with the life of Christ, He has forgiven us all trespasses. It is impossible that life in Christ dead and risen could have anything against it. Once there was everything against the believer. But having life in a risen Saviour is itself the proof that all is righteously forgiven to the one who believes.

Modernised from William KellyOriginal wording

"All Trespasses" — Nothing Held Back

The word all is not decorative. One writer presses it into assurance:

Every believer in Christ is completely and eternally forgiven. He can never again, during his whole life, be in a place where sin can be laid to his charge, as to his salvation. He is out of that place forever… Our union with a risen Christ is tied to our forgiveness. If we are a people made alive, if we have life with Christ risen, we are out of the place where sin is charged to our account, and we are out of it forever.

Modernised from Samuel RidoutOriginal wording

One writer marks this pardon off from the forgiveness a believer asks for day by day:

The Father always greets the confession of His child with forgiveness of sins and cleansing (1 John 1:9). That is quite distinct from the forgiveness spoken of in Col. 2:13. That forgiveness was granted once, and for that reason it is never repeated.

Modernised from C J DavisOriginal wording

Written to Former Outsiders

The change from "you" to "us" in the following verse is deliberate, and one writer traces it to who the readers were:

He applies the truth to the case in hand after this… He does not say "against you," because, in truth, the Colossian saints had never been under the law and its ordinances; they had been Gentiles. But whereas he said, "you, being dead," were now thus raised, so he says, "cancelling it against us"; for all that we, poor Jews, could boast — the ordinances — were against us instead of being for us, and they are gone now.

Modernised from William KellyOriginal wording

Summary

- Dead — the verse names what we had done (sins) and what we were (uncircumcised flesh). It was a state with no spark of life toward God, unfit for Him.

- Made alive — nothing less could meet that case. God raised us out of the grave Christ left, and our sins stayed behind.

- Together — our need never called for life with Christ. That is the fruit of God's counsels in grace, and it gives us life of the same order as His.

- Forgiven — the life itself is the receipt for the pardon, because life in a risen Christ cannot have anything standing against it.

- All — the pardon is complete: granted once, never repeated. It puts the believer outside the place where sin is charged to his account, and he never returns to it.

Colossians 2:14 · Darby

having effaced the handwriting in ordinances which [stood out] against us, which was contrary to us, he has taken it also out of the way, having nailed it to the cross;

Teachers at Colossae were urging Christians to take up religious rules. Paul answers them from the cross, where God dealt with a written record that stood against us.

The Language of a Cancelled Document

Older translations call that record "the handwriting of ordinances." One commentator explains the two key words:

The word translated "blotted out" is one "used for annulling a decree of law." "Handwriting" carries the idea of an "obligation to which a man is subject by his signature." Paul used a very graphic figure. We had bound ourselves by our signature to Jewish ordinances. Christ's death has cancelled that document. As far as we are concerned it was nailed to the cross when He was nailed to the cross.

Modernised from F. B. HoleOriginal wording

Our Own Signature Against Us

The document was not forged by an enemy. The people bound by it had signed it themselves:

All the ordinances were blotted out too. They belonged to the basic principles of this world and applied to man in the flesh. They weighed on the Jews as an unbearable yoke, and the Jews tried to bring others under it as well. They kept the conscience always under the burden of a service man had never completed, and a righteousness that never satisfied God. In them the Jew had put his signature, so to speak, to his own guilt. But God destroyed that obligation and nailed it to the cross of Christ. We receive liberty as well as life and pardon.

Modernised from J. N. DarbyOriginal wording

Another writer traces the signing back to a specific moment in Israel's history:

"The handwriting of requirements that was against us" points to a legal document that binds a person by his own signature. Israel fully committed themselves to keep the law in Exodus 19:8: "All that the Lord has spoken we will do." Every honest conscience knows it should obey some standard of conduct, such as the ordinances of the law of Moses. But we find the law is against us because of our disobedience.

Modernised from Leslie M. GrantOriginal wording

What Was Blotted Out, and What Was Not

Commentators are careful here. The verse does not say God erased His own law. He cancelled its claim on us:

So the "handwriting in ordinances" stood against us and was contrary to us, and He has taken it out of the way. Paul is not speaking of the law itself, but of our obligation to it. That is what the "handwriting" means, and that is what the cross wipes out for us, since it was nailed there. The law is not dead, as we have seen in Romans, but we have died to it.

Modernised from Numerical Bible NotesOriginal wording

The cross did not push the law aside as worthless:

The cross blotted out our sins truly, but it did more than this: it also blotted out the whole system of legal ordinances which had been against us. The law was not blotted out — far from it, for it was vindicated and magnified in the death of Christ. We died from under the law in His death, and we are now under grace.

Modernised from F. B. HoleOriginal wording

Why Paul Says "Us" and Not "You"

The change of pronoun matters. Paul had just told the Colossians what God had done for them. Now he speaks as one of a people who had lived under those rules:

He does not say "against you," because the Colossian believers had never been under the law and its ordinances. They had been Gentiles. He had said, "that you, being dead," were now raised; so now he says, "blotting it out against us." All that we, poor Jews, could boast in — the ordinances — were against us instead of being for us. And they are gone now.

Modernised from William KellyOriginal wording

The benefit is not locked inside one nation:

Their sins are discharged, like an account settled for ever. Christ has taken that record out of the way, "nailing it to His cross" (Col. 2:14). This is true of the Jew. It is just as true of every man who has put himself under law and then turned to Christ to have his debt to God discharged.

Modernised from An Outline of Sound WordsOriginal wording

The Nail Through the Document

One writer points to the nail itself:

"Taken out of the way," with the nail run through it, so that it can never appear again against the believer.

Modernised from The Bible TreasuryOriginal wording

The Practical Edge

Paul's aim is not history but freedom. One writer applies that to religious acts:

Christ has taken ordinances out of the way; it is the flesh that performs them. Let it be penance — it is the flesh that does it. But the flesh is dead. The same thing that put away sin put away ordinances. The man who had the sin and was to keep the ordinances is dead, because Christ has died. I do not need to gain a standing before God through any ordinance. Suppose I had to perform the smallest act to be complete before God. That would deny the perfection of the Lord Jesus Christ.

Modernised from J. N. DarbyOriginal wording

Summary

- Signed — the "handwriting" is a written obligation that binds a person by his own signature. Israel signed it when they promised to do all the Lord had spoken.

- Against — that same signature became a record of guilt. It kept the conscience under a service never finished and a righteousness never satisfied.

- Cancelled — God did not blot out His law but our obligation to it. The law stands, and we have died to it.

- Nailed — the record was not filed away. The nail went through it, so it can never appear against the believer again.

- Free — the result is liberty along with life and pardon. Adding any religious act to complete your standing denies the perfection of Christ's work.

Colossians 2:15 · Darby

having spoiled principalities and authorities, he made a show of them publicly, leading them in triumph by it.

The cross looked like Christ's defeat, yet Paul calls it the moment He stripped unseen enemies and paraded them as beaten. Two questions follow: who are these rulers and authorities, and who watched the shaming?

Note: the writers below use an older translation. Where the ESV says Christ "disarmed the rulers and authorities," it says He "spoiled principalities and powers" and "made a show of them openly."

What the Cross Looked Like

How the cross looked to onlookers and what it actually did are two different things.

Whatever these spiritual powers may be, from Satan downwards, in the cross the divine triumph has been shown. On the surface it looked like the triumph of the powers of evil. Really it was their undoing. Since this is so, we can see what verse 10 meant when it called the Lord Jesus "the Head of all principality and power." That was true not only on the ground of creation, but also on the ground of what He accomplished at the cross.

Modernised from F. B. HoleOriginal wording

The Words Themselves

The words behind "rulers and authorities" have more than one use.

The word can describe those who hold the first place, as rulers among men (Titus 3:1). But it especially refers to the spiritual high powers in the unseen world, whether good or bad. They were created by the Lord, and He is head of them all. Col. 1:16; Col. 2:10. Some fell from the position of trust given them: they did not keep their first estate or principality. Jude 6. Others contend against the heavenly position of the saints. Eph. 6:12.

Modernised from Morrish Bible DictionaryOriginal wording

"Spoiled" means to plunder — to take from a strong man what he was holding.

One stronger than Satan spoiled his kingdom. The Lord Jesus did it when He cast demons out of the people they held, and above all when He brought Satan's power to nothing on the cross. Matt. 12:29; Mark 3:27; Col. 2:15; Heb. 2:14. The Colossians were warned in case anyone should spoil them — make a prey of them — through philosophy (Col. 2:8), a caution surely needed today.

Modernised from Morrish Bible DictionaryOriginal wording

Openly — But Before Whom?

The display had an audience, though not a human one.

It was a far greater sight when the seemingly defeated Man rose from the dead, not only rebuking but scattering His spiritual foes... It was all done in the open. The triumph was over opposing evil spiritual powers, and it was public in the sight of all the holy spiritual powers.

Modernised from F. B. HoleOriginal wording

What Was Taken Back

The loss goes back to the first man, Adam. The "Second Adam" below is Christ.

When Satan defeated the first Adam, he became master of Adam's possessions and of his inheritance: "the creation was subjected to futility." Then the Second Adam defeated Satan and spoiled him of all that he had taken from the first Adam.

Modernised from J. N. DarbyOriginal wording

Compared with Ephesians 4

Kelly compares the cross with what Ephesians 4 says about Christ going up on high.

Here we have the effect of the work of Christ upon these powers — He led them in triumph on the cross. It is not so high a tone of triumph as in Ephesians 4, where it says that Christ "led a host of captives." The powers that led believers into captivity were themselves defeated... Here we hear of what was done on the cross, the power of the cross. There it is the public showing of the victory, in His going up on high. The great battle was won.

Modernised from William KellyOriginal wording

The Practical Point Paul Is Making

The verse is not a detour. It arms the reader against the error named a few lines later in verse 18.

We come in verse 18 to what we may call the ritualistic snare. We shall easily see that it is a snare if we go back to the truth of the cross as it was presented to us in verse 15. The only angels that desire to have our homage are evil ones. The holy angels always refuse human worship, ascribing all worship to God... Now the evil angels have been stripped and defeated at the cross. Who then would wish to worship them?

Modernised from F. B. HoleOriginal wording

Where the Believer Feels It

This defeat reaches daily life: accusation, temptation and death.

Does Satan come and accuse me? It is all true, but my sins are gone. God has said He will remember them no more. "Resist the devil, and he will flee from you." Why flee? Because he has already met Christ. Is it temptation through the agreeable things of the world, or the sorrows and trials of life, or the power of death? He has been "spoiled," and as far as faith is concerned his power is gone. Death, to the believer, is only a departing to be with Christ.

Modernised from J. N. DarbyOriginal wording

Summary

- Undoing — What looked on the surface like the triumph of evil powers was in fact their undoing.

- Spoiled — The word means plundered. The stronger One took back what Satan had seized from the first Adam.

- Openly — Men saw nothing of the parade; it was public in the sight of all the holy spiritual powers.

- Therefore no angels — The evil angels were beaten at the cross, so none of them deserve our worship.

- Therefore no fear — Accusation, temptation and death lose their grip. The one behind them has already met Christ.

Colossians 2:16 · Darby

Let none therefore judge you in meat or in drink, or in matter of feast, or new moon, or sabbaths,

Paul has just said that the cross cancelled the record of debt that stood against us. Now he draws the practical result: rules about food and holy days, once given by God Himself, have no hold on a believer's conscience.

Where the Warning Sits

Three times in this chapter Paul puts up a caution sign, and each one points at a different danger.

The Apostle's warnings seem to fall under three headings. Look at verses 8, 16 and 18. Each opens with a word of caution about the activities of men. Those activities run in different directions, but all are hostile to the truth. The first danger comes from philosophy, the second from Judaism, the third from superstition.

Modernised from F. B. HoleOriginal wording

The Cross Is the Reason

The word "therefore" points back to what the cross did to the whole system of legal rules.

The cross blotted out our sins truly, but it did more: it also blotted out the whole system of legal ordinances that stood against us. The law itself was not blotted out. Far from it — the death of Christ vindicated and magnified the law. On the other hand, we died out from under the law in His death. We are now under grace, and all the old legal ordinances no longer stand. Verse 16 gives samples of them. The word translated "blotted out" is one "used for annulling a decree of law."

Modernised from F. B. HoleOriginal wording

The rules ended at the cross, so anyone who presses them now has no claim on you.

Do not allow anyone to put you again under these legal ordinances, for the death of Christ has ended them.

Modernised from George DavisonOriginal wording

What the Items in the List Meant

The items named cover the year, the month and the week. Each one was a picture of something still to come.

Take eating and drinking, or ordinances about the year, month, and week. The Apostle takes particular care to speak not merely of feast or new moon but of sabbaths. Remember that these things are only pictures of the body — the real good found only in Christ. In fact, these times and seasons point mainly to what God will give His people later on. The new moon was a striking picture of Israel renewed after fading away. The sabbath pictured the rest of God, which He will yet enjoy and share.

Modernised from William KellyOriginal wording

A festival was a day set above other days. Bringing such days back is no small matter.

A "holy-day" — it is worth calling it that, since the name shows its meaning — was a day God had made to be regarded above another. That day, and the foods, drinks, various washings, and outward ordinances of Judaism, all had their time and use. "The body is of Christ." In Him we have what they were designed to picture. If I take them up now, I take up the shadow and not the substance; it is a mere shadow, but by setting it up again, I make it the real thing and deny Christ.

Modernised from J. N. DarbyOriginal wording

Why the Shadow Cannot Satisfy

The shadows were accurate as far as they went. But they could not show the whole.

It was true that the instructions about new moons and sabbaths, and the rules about food and drink, came from God. They really were shadows of things to come. The body, however, of which they were true shadows, is of Christ. As shadows they were correct, outlining truth about the One who has come. But they could not even hint at all that He is… Why turn to the shadow after the substance has appeared?

Modernised from The Christian's FriendOriginal wording

The Liberty This Gives — and Its Guard

Freedom from another's judgment is real, and it comes with a responsibility.

We have everything in Christ, and nothing outside of Him: completeness in the presence of God, and perfect deliverance from all that we are in ourselves, and from everything that is or could be used against us. What perfect liberty! We need to see that we use it in a holy way, but it is a perfect liberty.

Modernised from The Christian's FriendOriginal wording

The Verse Today

The pressure Paul described has not disappeared; it has changed clothes.

Someone may ask what these things have to say to us today, since no active Judaizing party is at work in the church now. The answer is that they are still very much to the point. There is not much active Judaizing because the professing church itself has been so largely Judaized for centuries… The word here is not exactly "sabbath days," but "sabbaths" — covering sabbaths of all kinds, whether of days or of years.

Modernised from F. B. HoleOriginal wording

The sabbath named here is not the day Christians gather.

They prove that the Lord's day occupies a place that is quite unique, quite heavenly, quite divine. But they equally prove that the Jewish Sabbath and the Lord's day are entirely distinct. The New Testament keeps the two days as distinct as we keep Saturday and Sunday.

Modernised from C. H. MackintoshOriginal wording

Summary

- Cross — The cross annulled the decree of legal ordinances. That work is finished, so no one may put it back on you.

- Shadow — Food, drink, festival, new moon and sabbath were God-given outlines of what was coming. "Sabbaths" here covers every kind, days or years.

- Substance — Shadows could sketch Christ, but never show all He is. Taking one up again makes the shadow the real thing and denies Him.

- Liberty — Completeness in Christ brings perfect liberty. Use it in a holy way.

- Today — The same pressure survives in a church long since Judaized. The Lord's day stands apart from the Jewish sabbath, as distinct as Sunday from Saturday.

Colossians 2:17 · Darby

which are a shadow of things to come; but the body [is] of Christ.

Some people were pressing Jewish food rules and sacred days on the believers at Colossae. Paul does not call these things worthless — he calls them a shadow, an outline cast ahead of a Person who has now arrived.

Shadows God Himself Appointed

The rules about food, new moons and sabbaths were not human inventions. They came from God, and they really did sketch what was coming.

It was true that the instructions about new moons and sabbaths, and the rules about food and drink, came from God. They really were shadows of things to come. But the body, of which they were true shadows, is of Christ. As shadows they were correct, and they outlined truth about the One who has come. Yet they could not even foreshadow all that He is. Judaism could never give those raised in it the full truth about Christ.

Modernised from The Christian's FriendOriginal wording

What "Body" Means Here

Older translations read "the body is of Christ," where the ESV has "the substance belongs to Christ." The word does not mean a physical body. It means the solid reality that casts the shadow.

"Body" here is plainly substance in contrast to shadow — that is, "All that was shadowed had its origin as well as its fulfilment in Him," as has been well said.

Modernised from J. A. TrenchOriginal wording

One writer pictures it from daily life. The shadow arrives first; then the person does.

I am standing at a street corner, waiting for a friend. The sun is shining behind him as he comes round the corner. The first thing I see is his shadow. I have the body, the Person, and I am occupied with Him. What a Person! Where is there room for food and drink, and the sabbath?

Modernised from A. P. CecilOriginal wording

Things To Come — And What Believers Have Now

Israel's calendar was prophetic. The monthly and weekly cycles pointed to blessings God still intends to give, and one writer marks off the Lord's day from all of it.

The new moon was a remarkable type of Israel being renewed after fading away. The sabbath was the type of the rest of God which He will yet enjoy and share... The Jew had the shadow, and by God's grace he will have the things to come under the new covenant by and by. We are given the substance of Christ now. It is a question here of Jewish days. The Lord's day has nothing to do with Judaism; it is not only separate from that system, but in contrast with it.

Modernised from William KellyOriginal wording

Why Reviving the Shadow Denies Christ

These ordinances had their time and use. So what happens if someone takes them up again now?

The food, the drink, the various washings, and the outward ordinances of Judaism had their time and use. "The body is of Christ." In Him we have what they were designed to picture. If I take them up now, I take up the shadow and not the substance. It is a mere shadow, but by setting it up again I make it the real thing and deny Christ.

Modernised from J. N. DarbyOriginal wording

This is not only an ancient problem. Writers trace the same mistake in religion today.

The Colossian believers faced this snare, and it has developed into the ritualism of our day... Sadly, Christendom has fallen into this snare. In turning back to the shadows it has lost much of the Substance.

Modernised from Hamilton SmithOriginal wording

The Right Use of the Old Pictures

Refusing to live under the shadows does not mean throwing them away. Once a believer knows Christ, the old ceremonies start to speak.

Now that the body, Christ, had appeared, the shadow received a meaning and an interest. By itself it had been uninteresting and unbearable. We can now use the shadows with profit to show the reality: the many riches of the graces of Christ. This is so because "the body is of Christ." But to impose them again as duties would deny Christ.

Modernised from J. N. DarbyOriginal wording

A Second Reading of "Body"

Commentators differ here. Some take "body" in the wider Colossian sense of the body joined to Christ as Head, stressing that it did not grow out of the old system at all.

The body is not a development of the shadows. Neither is it a product of man's philosophy — "the body is of Christ." The body is derived from Christ...

Modernised from Norman AndersonOriginal wording

Summary

- Shadow given. The food rules, new moons and sabbaths came from God. They outlined what was coming, but an outline cannot show all that Christ is.

- Shadow explained. "Body" means substance, not shadow. Everything the old system pictured has its origin and its fulfilment in Christ.

- Substance owned. The shadows pointed to blessings still to come for Israel. Believers have the substance, Christ Himself, now.

- Shadow refused. Setting the ordinances up again treats the outline as the reality, and so denies the One who has come. Commentators trace today's ritualism to this step.

- Shadow reread. Kept in its place, the old picture displays the riches of Christ. Use it to show the reality; never impose it as a duty.

Colossians 2:18 · Darby

Let no one fraudulently deprive you of your prize, doing his own will in humility and worship of angels, entering into things which he has not seen, vainly puffed up by the mind of his flesh,

Paul warns the Colossians about a teaching that looks humble and reverent while it robs them. Three questions follow: what prize does it steal, what makes its humility false, and why is prying into the unseen so serious?

A word used only once

The verse opens with a verb found nowhere else in Scripture. The ESV renders it "disqualify you"; older versions read "beguile you of your reward."

The verse could be translated, "Let no one get round you," or "cheat you." It is as if he said: do not let such things into your mind. If you do, a self-chosen humility and the like will cheat you out of what Christianity has given you in Christ. The passage has no separate word for "reward," but you need that word to bring out the full sense of the verb. Those extra English words all stand for a single word in the original: "Let no man beguile you of your reward." That word appears nowhere else in Scripture.

Modernised from F G PattersonOriginal wording

The picture is of a prize stolen by fraud. Even true believers can be the victims.

One translation of the verse's opening reads: "Let no one fraudulently deprive you of your prize, doing his own will in humility and worship of angels." That makes the whole position clear. The procedure all looks very humble. It is really self-will, a thing very hateful to God. Those who fall for it may well be true believers. But the fraud turns them away from Christ, and they lose their prize.

Modernised from F. B. HoleOriginal wording

Humility that is really pride

The humble tone is the disguise. Talk about heavenly beings sounds modest, but it puffs up the very mind it claims to lower.

I may talk a lot about saints and angels in heaven, about their glories and the like, and call this humility. It is not humility. It is the very opposite: my own fleshly mind, puffed up over nothing. What do I know about them? Have I been in heaven? While I intrude into things I have not seen, I am losing knowledge needed by all saints. The weakest believer is as much one with Christ as an apostle, and as complete in Him. It might seem more humble to say, I am this, that, or the other thing; but can we do without Christ? Do you reply, I have not arrived at such a position? Then you are expecting to attain it — that is presumption.

Modernised from J. N. DarbyOriginal wording

Why angels attracted worship

The error had a logic to it. Paul rejects it anyway.

Verse 16 deals mainly with a Jewish form of the evil; but verse 18 goes further and shows a prying into the unseen. It is not so much the religious use or misuse of what can be seen, which was the Jewish trap, but dabbling with philosophy, especially eastern philosophy. There was a great appearance of humility in all this, as there always is in false systems. The worship of angels seemed right and proper, especially since it used no word that belongs only to the worship of God... It is true there are such beings; but it is the prying into such subjects that is so evil. They have to do with us, but not we with them. Our business is with God. Now it seemed a reasonable conclusion. If angels have to do with us, then we must have to do with them. And since they deal with God directly, why should we not turn to them to approach Him?

Modernised from William KellyOriginal wording

Curiosity as a symptom

Reaching after what God has not revealed is no harmless extra. It says something about the heart that reaches.

Prying into what God has not revealed, and man has not seen — speculation about angels, for example — is the clear proof of one thing. The heart is not satisfied with its portion. This is not holding the Head. He who keeps hold of Christ, in conscious union with Him, could never be craving after angels. In Christ the saint is above them, and leaves them to God without anxiety or envy.

Modernised from William KellyOriginal wording

What is stolen

The loss falls twice: now and later.

Legalism is not true law-keeping. It thinks it humble to use angels as go-betweens, as if we were not worthy to approach God directly in worship. This is completely false humility. It intrudes into what a person does not understand, and it puffs up the mind of the flesh... God warns His people strongly against this. It is a cheat. It robs a person of true blessing now and of reward in the future, because it puts something other than Christ between the soul and God.

Modernised from Leslie M. GrantOriginal wording

Summary

- Cheated. The warning word means to defraud. No one argues you out of your prize; someone steals it.

- Disguised. The theft wears a costume of humility. Choosing your own way to God is self-will, and it puffs up the flesh it pretends to lower.

- Diverted. Angels look like a reasonable stepping-stone to God. But the traffic runs one way: they have to do with us; we do not have to do with them.

- Dissatisfied. Prying into the unseen is a symptom: a heart content with Christ has no craving for what God has left unrevealed.

- Deprived. Whatever comes between the soul and Christ costs twice: blessing now, reward later. The safeguard is holding the Head.