But the rumour of this having spread, the multitude came together and were confounded, because each one heard them speaking in his own dialect.
A sound from heaven drew a crowd of visiting Jews to the spot. Each man there heard his own home speech from the mouths of Galileans — so where does the wonder lie, and why languages at all?
No one arranged this gathering. A sound reached them, and the surprise came after they arrived.
The sound drew them to the spot. There they heard the disciples speaking in the tones and accents that belonged to each one. Many of them were far from home. In that country Aramaic was the language of the common people, and Greek was fairly well understood as the language of trade in that day. Yet they heard voices that spoke to them in their own mother tongue, and told of the mighty works of God.
The gift fitted each hearer more closely than a national language would. It also turned an old event in Genesis on its head.
News of what had happened spread, and the crowd came together. They were bewildered, because each one heard the disciples speaking in his own language. This completely reversed what happened at the tower of Babel (Gen. 11). There the Lord confused the language of the people so that they would not understand one another's speech. And it was not only that each heard in his own tongue, but in his own dialect.
Some explanations shift the wonder from the disciples to the listeners. Others reduce the speech to excited noise. Writers have long answered both.
Some have tried to find in the account the same kind of senseless jargon... others argue for a highly excited or ecstatic style of speech, suited to telling out the marvels of grace... The older rationalists supposed it was no other than their native tongue. Others, from Gregory of Nyssa and Cyprian to Erasmus and men of our own day, added to this the strange idea that the Spirit caused the crowd of foreigners to hear, each in his own tongue! But Gregory of Nazianzus rejects that notion. It makes the marvel lie with the hearers rather than the speakers, and that is contrary to the clear statement of Scripture.
God's judgment at Babel left the nations divided by speech. Grace does not undo that division; it goes out to men where the judgment left them.
God's judgment had inflicted these various tongues on them. It had completely broken up their ambitious plan to join together and build a unity of their own through the tower of Babel. But the grace of God went out exactly where His judgment had placed them. If a crushing blow laid their pride in many separate ditches, then the grace of God went out to those ditches. It blessed them where they lay, and raised them out of their fallen state.
The many languages marked a change. They showed who God's word was now going out to.
But the languages were as real as they were different from their mother tongue, or from any language learned in the ordinary way... God had given His law to Israel, and that law was in itself the expression of man's moral duty. What could testify more clearly that He was now about to make known His grace in the gospel to every race and tongue? ...This was not the wiping out of difference in language. Nor was it the power that will one day make the whole earth of one lip and the same speech. It was grace lifting its objects and instruments above the effects of that judgment at Babel.
God had already made dealings between nations hard. Luke then gives three words for the crowd, and each answers to something different.
By an exercise of His power He had made dealings between nations difficult, in some measure. By power joined with grace He made provision that different nations, and those speaking different tongues, should hear about His Son and about salvation in their own language, with nothing to hinder them. Bewildered, amazed, and in doubt (or, perplexed) — this is how Luke describes the crowd. Bewildered, when each man heard his own language. Amazed, as they remembered that those addressing them were Galileans. Perplexed, since they could not understand what it meant. Something new, something strange, had undoubtedly happened.
- Sound gathers. The noise from heaven brought the crowd. The languages held them.
- Language reaches. Not just a national tongue, but each hearer's own dialect. It was the speech he was born into, so no one could call it someone else's message.
- Speakers, not hearers. The wonder was in the Galileans who spoke, not in the ears that heard. Explanations that reverse this contradict the account.
- Grace follows judgment. Babel scattered men by confusing their speech. Now God's grace goes to the very ditches His judgment dug, and blesses men where they lay.
- Law to one, grace to all. The many tongues announced the change: God gave His law to one nation, and now He makes His grace known to every race and tongue.
And all were amazed and wondered, saying, Behold, are not all these who are speaking Galilaeans?
The crowd at Pentecost did not doubt what they heard. They could not explain it. Their question turns on one word — "Galileans" . It shows what they expected of such men, and what God had just done through them.
Luke stacks three reactions on top of each other, and each has its own cause:
Confounded, amazed, and in doubt (or, perplexed) — this is how Luke describes the crowd. Confounded, when they heard each man his own language. Amazed, as they remembered that those who addressed them were Galileans. Perplexed, since they could not understand what it meant.
The word was not a compliment. Galilee had a reputation, and its people gave themselves away when they spoke:
It is likely that the Galileans pronounced words differently, or that the language spoken in Galilee was not as refined as the language spoken at Jerusalem. That is what gave Peter away when he spoke. But the voice of that same Peter, under the power of God, was mighty on the day of Pentecost. Even so, the hearers said, "Are not all these who are speaking Galileans?" They were surprised to hear such men speak in foreign tongues. They were all the more surprised because no prophet was ever expected from there, nor any good thing from Nazareth.
That the speakers were country people is not an embarrassment in the story. It is the point:
God will have a wonderful witness going out from His House. But He will have that witness carried out by His own witnesses. And His witnesses are for the most part the poor and feeble of this world. So in Acts 2 we read, "Are not all these who are speaking Galileans?" Galileans, of course, were the simple country folk — the peasantry. And Peter, "an unlearned and ignorant man," was their leader.
Some have argued that the tongues at Pentecost were unintelligible sounds. The crowd's own words rule that out — foreigners recognised their own speech:
But there is an awkward difficulty in the way of calling them imaginary tongues. All the different nations whose languages these were understood them. "Are not all these who are speaking Galileans? And how is it that we hear, each of us in his own native language?" And then Peter speaks to the Jews in theirs. Now this fact is the substantial point of the whole affair. It was what struck the multitude. It converted three thousand people. The Church begins its existence, and it was formed because this multitude understood what was said.
Others have suggested the miracle happened in the ears of the listeners, not in the mouths of the speakers. One early answer rejects that:
Gregory of Nazianzus rejects that idea. It places the marvel with the hearers rather than the speakers, and that goes against the clear statement of Scripture. So do all these empty theories.
Commentators link this scene to the scattering of languages at the tower of Babel. One traces the reversal to Christ's own lowliness:
There had been a Man on earth who never thought of Himself, but only of God and His glory. He "humbled himself by becoming obedient to the point of death, even death on a cross." As a result, God has put Him in the place that man in Genesis 11 could not reach. And the Holy Spirit comes down and reverses the judgment of Genesis 11 for a time. The difference of language did not disappear. But the divine grace and power that will one day make the whole world speak one language lifted the disciples above the effects of Babel's judgment. They had never learned those languages, yet they could speak in as many languages as their hearers had.
Three thousand people joined the believers that day. One writer names the cause, and it was not the wonder of verse 7:
This happened because the word spoken and received was the incorruptible seed. It did not happen because the preacher spoke it in a language new to him, one he had never learned in the ordinary way. The living and energetic word of God awakened sleeping consciences. The speeches in other tongues only awakened surprise and wonder in the hearers. That wonder converted no one, and it left the great mass in Jerusalem more hardened than ever.
- Amazed at whom. The languages confounded the crowd. The speakers amazed them. The meaning left them perplexed. Their amazement came from remembering these men were Galileans.
- Galileans. Their accent once gave Peter away. People expected no prophet and nothing good from their region. Yet that same voice was now mighty.
- Chosen weakness. God's witnesses are for the most part the poor and feeble of this world; "unlearned and ignorant" Peter led them.
- Real speech. Foreigners heard the language they were born in. The marvel was in the speakers, not in the ears. For a moment, grace lifted the disciples above Babel's judgment.
- Wonder is not faith. The tongues produced surprise. The incorruptible word produced the three thousand. Those who only marvelled went away harder than before.
and how do *we* hear [them] each in our own dialect in which we have been born,
The crowd in Jerusalem had come from many countries, and each person heard the message in the speech he grew up with. Their question raises two things at once: what this miracle was, and why God chose to work it this way.
Two different Greek words for speech run through this chapter, and each fits a different point.
The two words dialektos and glossai are by no means synonymous. When the Spirit wished to express the language of each individual, the first was the right word. When the point was the sum total of many different languages, the second was the fitting expression.
That distinction shows in what the crowd actually heard.
It was not only that each heard in his own tongue, but in his own dialect.
So where did the miracle happen — in the speakers, or in the hearers?
Interpreters have given strange and conflicting explanations of this. There is no need to notice them. Though it was a miracle, the fact is simple. It is plain that this crowd of people of many languages heard these men, who were obviously Galileans, speaking in these tongues. The miracle, as someone long ago remarked, was with those who spoke, not with those who heard; and therefore the speakers used real languages.
That fact carried the whole day.
But treating them as imaginary tongues runs into an awkward difficulty. All the different nations whose languages these were understood them. Now this fact is the substantial point of the whole affair. It was what struck the crowd. Three thousand people were converted by it. The Church begins its existence; it took form because this crowd understood what was said.
Galilean speech was easy to recognise, and people looked down on it. It had once given Peter away.
The Galileans probably had a different way of pronouncing words. Or the language spoken in Galilee was not as refined as the language spoken in Jerusalem. That is why people detected Peter by his speech. Matt. 26:69, 73; Mark 14:70. But the voice of that same Peter was mighty on the day of Pentecost, under the power of God. The hearers still said, "Are not all these who are speaking Galileans?" Acts 2:7.
God divided human language at Babel and scattered a proud project. Pentecost does not undo that scattering. Grace works through it.
The judgment of God had inflicted these various languages on them. It had shattered their ambitious plan to join together and set up a unity of their own through the tower of Babel. But the grace of God went out exactly where His judgment had placed them. If a crushing blow had laid their pride in ever so many separate ditches, then the grace of God went out to those ditches. It blessed them where they lay, and raised them out of their fallen state.
God gave the law one way and announced the good news another.
The Holy Spirit enabled the messengers of grace to deliver their message in the very tongue in which each was born. What precious proof that God wanted to reach man's heart with the sweet story of grace! The law from the fiery mountain was not published like that. When God was telling what man ought to be, He spoke in one tongue; but when He was telling what He Himself was, He spoke in many.
The choice of each person's birth-language was tender, not just practical.
The God of all grace would have each one hear of full salvation. And hear of it in those very words in which his infant ears had listened to the earliest whispers of a mother's love — in "his own native language." It did not matter whether the language was soft or harsh, refined or rough. The Holy Spirit would use it to carry the precious message of salvation right home to the poor heart.
The many languages of the world were also a practical problem for the men sent out with the message.
In the time of the apostles, so many different languages in the earth were a serious obstacle. They made it hard to carry out their commission to go into all the world and preach the gospel quickly and easily. But at the very start these servants of the Lord saw that this difficulty was nothing when met by the energy of the Spirit of God. In a moment He was able to give the disciples power to speak to men in their own dialect about "the mighty works of God."
- Dialect, not just language. The wording marks the dialect each hearer knew from birth, not just a national tongue.
- Miracle in the speakers. The wonder was on the lips of the disciples, so what they spoke were genuine languages.
- Unlikely speakers. God showed His power through the very men the crowd looked down on.
- Grace to the ditches. Where judgment at Babel had scattered people into many tongues, grace went out and found them there.
- Straight to the heart. God gave the law in one language, but told what He Himself is in many — reaching each heart in the language it was born into.