Acts 17:4–15

Acts 17:4

And some of them believed, and joined themselves to Paul and Silas, and of the Greeks who worshipped, a great multitude, and of the chief women not a few.

Paul preached in the synagogue at Thessalonica, reasoning from Scripture. This verse names the result: a mixed group believed and openly sided with the preachers — Jews, Greek worshippers of God, and women of standing. Its wording shows how they were won, and what that choice cost them.

What Won Them

Paul argued from writings his hearers already accepted. He pressed two things: that the Christ had to suffer and rise, and that this Christ is Jesus.

Paul proved from the Scriptures that the Christ must suffer and rise. He did not present this only as a truth in what they acknowledged to be the word of God. He showed it was absolutely necessary because of man's sin, and the only adequate remedy in God's grace. Then came the clinching conclusion: "This Jesus, whom I proclaim to you, is the Christ." No miracle was needed here to catch attention. The Scriptures are a testimony beyond miracles, and the most lasting testimony of all.

William Kelly

Persuaded, And Joined

The verse says two things about the converts, and the second follows the first. The message persuaded them. Then they attached themselves to the men who preached it. Kelly links this to what Paul later wrote to the same people.

As the apostle wrote afterwards, "our gospel came to you not only in word, but also in power and in the Holy Spirit and with full conviction" (1 Thess. 1:5). The harvest was large, not only among the Jews, but far more among the Gentiles, including not a few women of rank. No church in the apostles' day showed greater simplicity, freshness, and power of the truth than the Thessalonians.

William Kelly

Who The Devout Greeks Were

"Devout" here names a known group of people, not a personal mood. The same word turns up in several scenes in Acts.

In Acts we often meet a Greek word used in the sense of "one who serves God." We point out this expression because it marks a class of people. They were not Jews, yet they avoided the emptiness and defilements of paganism, and took part in Jewish worship. See Acts 13:43, 50; 16:14; 17:4, 17; 18:7, 13.

J. N. Darby

Those Greeks made up most of the new church. The verse names three kinds of people who believed.

Some of the Jews became convinced that the Lord Jesus is the Christ, and they accepted Him as their Saviour and Lord. But most of the church were devout Greeks. These were not heathen. They were Greeks who had given up idols and had become converts to the Jewish faith. They were convinced that paganism was wrong. They wanted light, so they attended the synagogue services. Of this class a great multitude believed. The third class mentioned are women who held positions of distinction.

Arno Clemens Gaebelein

Sides Made Visible

The word "joined" describes a visible attachment. That attachment split the city into two camps at once.

The decisive moment had come. The believers showed themselves openly. They identified themselves with Paul and Silas and joined them. It was like the two disciples who heard John the Baptist say, "Behold, the Lamb of God!" (John 1:36). They followed Jesus and stayed with Him that day. It is always so when Christ is preached. The unbelievers show themselves too. They besieged the house of Jason, where Paul and his companion were staying.

The Bible Treasury

The Price Of Standing With Them

Coming out into the open had a price, and it came at once.

As a result of this preaching, "some" of the Jews and "a great many" of the Gentiles believed. They also proved their faith was real. They identified themselves in public with the Lord's servants, for we read that they joined Paul and Silas. They did not keep their faith to themselves. They did not try to escape shame by staying secret disciples. They believed in Jesus, and boldly confessed their faith. The result was that they had at once to face persecution.

An Outline of Sound Words

Encouragement Between Two Storms

Where this harvest falls in the story is part of its meaning.

Paul and his friends had just come from suffering and shameful treatment at Philippi. Far from being cowed by this, they had such confidence in God that again they spoke the Word with courage. Its power was such that even some of the Jews believed, along with a great many devout Greeks and not a few leading women. So God gave His faithful servants a time of much encouragement. It came after severe suffering, and before further troubles in Thessalonica itself.

F. B. Hole

Summary

- Persuaded — Scripture won them, not miracles. Paul proved from writings they already trusted that the Christ must suffer and rise.

- Joined — belief did not stay private. They attached themselves to Paul and Silas in public, and that was the proof their faith was real.

- Mixed — three groups believed: some Jews, a great many Greeks who had left idols for the synagogue, and not a few women of rank.

- Exposed — the same preaching that revealed the believers revealed their enemies. Standing with the preachers brought persecution at once.

- Timed — the harvest fell between the shame at Philippi and the riot at Thessalonica. It was God's encouragement to servants who kept preaching after being mistreated.

Acts 17:5

But the Jews having been stirred up to jealousy, and taken to [themselves] certain wicked men of the lowest rabble, and having got a crowd together, set the city in confusion; and having beset the house of Jason sought to bring them out to the people;

Paul's preaching in Thessalonica had won a wide response. This verse shows the backlash: envy, a mob off the streets, a city in uproar, and a raid on the house of a man named Jason.

Envy behind the uproar

The trouble did not start with the rabble. It started with people who knew the Scriptures and would not bend to them.

The success of the gospel always tends to rouse bitter opposition. That is true nowhere more than among the Jews. They felt keenly the bitter spite that is natural to people overwhelmed by their own Scriptures — Scriptures they could not explain, yet would not bow to.

William Kelly

Envy has done this before, and worse.

Envy led to the first murder, when Cain killed his brother. And envy led to the greatest murder, when the Jews crucified their Messiah. If men moved by envy will commit murder, we need not be surprised that respectable Jews stooped to use base, worthless men to carry out their ends.

An Outline of Sound Words

Strange partners against the truth

To stop the preaching, men who professed the fear of God recruited the godless. Kelly points out what that alliance exposed.

Here we see the usual lack of common honesty that marks the religious attackers of the truth. The Jews professed the fear of God. Yet out of jealousy they did not hesitate to form a party with wicked men of the lowest sort against the gospel. Godless pagans were good enough allies against the truth of their own Messiah. Worldly desires would not let them recognise Him in Jesus, who suffered and then rose. God was in none of their thoughts.

William Kelly

The same pattern appears elsewhere in Acts. There the opposition came from the top of society, not the bottom.

Just as in the days of the apostles, "wicked men of the rabble" and "devout and honourable women" found one point on which they could agree. These two classes were far apart, socially and morally. Yet both utterly rejected the word of God and those who faithfully preached it. (Compare Acts 13:50 with Acts 17:5.) So we always find that men who differ in almost everything else agree in their determined opposition to the Bible.

C. H. Mackintosh

Why Jason's house

The mob did not pick a random address. Jason had taken the missionaries in, and that hospitality made him the target.

The unbelieving Jews, moved with envy, got hold of wicked men of the lowest sort and gathered a crowd. They set the city in an uproar and attacked the house of Jason. Jason was one of the believers and a relative of Paul (see Rom. 16:21). Paul must have been staying with this relative, so they tried to bring him and his companions out.

A J Pollock

New believers in the city had also gone public with their faith. That came at a price.

They proved their faith was real by identifying themselves in public with the Lord's servants. We read that they "joined Paul and Silas." They did not keep their faith to themselves. They did not try to escape reproach by staying secret disciples. They believed in Jesus, and boldly confessed their faith. The result was that they had at once to face persecution.

An Outline of Sound Words

What the crowd intended

The mob was not only after Jason. They wanted the preachers brought out before the city.

Jason, Paul's host, was the special object of their hostility. They surrounded his house. They wanted to bring the Lord's servants out before the people — that is, the regular assembly of the city.

William Kelly

The search that failed

The plan collapsed at the one point the plotters could not control. Luke never says how.

Jealousy was aroused. Unbelieving Jews worked on the rabble — "vile fellows," as an older translation puts it — to make an uproar. The Jews would not eat with such people. Yet they had no qualms about calling in their help to stop the movement if they could. In this they partly succeeded, and they searched for Paul and Silas in the house of Jason, but in vain. They could not find them. The Lord watched over His servants, and on this occasion sheltered them in some way the historian does not explain.

C. E. Stuart

Summary

- Envy starts it. The riot began with men overwhelmed by their own Scriptures, who would not bow to them. The gospel's success roused their spite.

- Envy borrows. Men who would not eat with the rabble gladly joined its cause. That is the usual lack of honesty in religious attacks on the truth.

- Envy targets a door. Jason, Paul's host and relative, took the blow aimed at Paul. Sheltering the preachers made him the accused.

- Envy costs converts. The new believers joined Paul and Silas in public instead of staying secret disciples. Persecution came at once.

- Envy fails. The search of the house came up empty. The Lord sheltered His servants in a way Scripture does not describe.

Acts 17:6

and not having found them, dragged Jason and certain brethren before the politarchs, crying out, These [men] that have set the world in tumult, are come here also,

Jealousy over Paul's preaching in Thessalonica boiled over into a riot. The mob could not find the preachers, so it seized Jason, the man who had housed them, and shouted a charge that has echoed ever since.

The Alliance Behind the Charge

The men who raised the cry claimed to fear God. Their choice of allies gave them away:

Here we see the usual lack of common honesty which marks the religious opponents of the truth. The Jews claimed to fear God. Yet jealousy drove them to join forces with wicked men of the lowest sort against the gospel. Depraved pagans were good enough allies against the truth of their own Messiah. Worldly desires would not let them recognise Him in Jesus, who suffered and then rose again. God was in none of their thoughts. Their degradation showed in the company they kept to gather a crowd and set the city in uproar.

William Kelly

An Old Accusation

The wording was not new. Jesus faced the same charge before Pilate, and Paul faced it at Philippi:

This is an old accusation, and one which always comes from the wrong side. Pontius Pilate could find no fault in Jesus. Even so, the priests and the rulers insisted all the more: "He stirs up the people, teaching throughout all Judea, from Galilee even to this place" (Luke 23:5). What do they say against Paul and Silas at Philippi? "These men are Jews, and they are disturbing our city" (Acts 16:20). And at Thessalonica? "These men who have turned the world upside down have come here also" (Acts 17:6).

J. N. Darby

A Compliment Hidden in an Insult

The rioters meant the phrase as an insult. Their own words showed how far the message had spread:

At Philippi the riot began with money-making Gentiles who had been disappointed. At Thessalonica unbelieving Jews were behind even worse opposition and disorder. They branded Paul and Silas as "these men who have turned the world upside down." Without meaning to, they paid tribute to the mighty power of the gospel, preached with the Holy Spirit sent down from heaven. They might oppose it, but they could not stop its advance.

F. B. Hole

Two Views of the Charge

Commentators differ on this. Some take the charge as a fair description of what the gospel does:

The gospel still has the character it had when Paul preached it: it turned "the world upside down." Nothing was to stand before it. Nothing could be allowed alongside it. Judaism, pagan religion, and all the rest — it overturned them all. It pressed the claims of God on each person. It did more than teach truth about God. It showed its hearers where they stood before God. The gospel comes and says, "You are lost"; and it does turn the world upside down. It is a new thing for people to be told, You are all wrong.

J. N. Darby

Others call it a false charge. They mark out what the preaching did unsettle:

In Thessalonica people misrepresented him. They imagined he was turning "the world upside down" and "acting against the decrees of Caesar" (Acts 17:6-7). Neither claim was true. The gospel leaves the world-system untouched. But it calls individual people out of the world, and turns them right side up, according to God.

F. B. Hole

Men Without Resources

The men accused of overturning the world had no money and no powerful backers. One writer asks why the church ever lost that:

Those were blessed days. The church had no powerful backers and no wealth of its own. Its leading preacher had to say, "I have no silver and gold." Yet the church carried on all its work in simple faith in the name of Jesus, and in the awareness of the presence and power of the Holy Spirit. Why was such a state of things ever allowed to pass away? In those days penniless men "turned the world upside down," and their own enemies said so.

W. W. Fereday

The Cost to Jason

Paul and Silas were not found, so the man who had opened his home faced the rulers instead:

The Jews bring Jason before the rulers and charge him with sheltering Paul and Silas in his home. The rulers were troubled. But they were not as cruel and unjust as the rulers at Philippi, who had Paul and Silas beaten. They only take security from Jason and the others and release them.

Leslie M. Grant

Summary

- Jealousy. The uproar came from people who claimed to fear God. They teamed up with the worst men in the city to fight the message.

- Borrowed charge. Enemies said "He stirs up the people" about Jesus before Pilate, and about Paul at Philippi. The accusation always comes from the same side.

- Hidden tribute. The rioters called the preachers world-upsetters. Without meaning to, they proved what the gospel was doing in the Spirit's power.

- Personal reach. Commentators differ on whether the charge was fair. Some say the gospel does overturn everything, because it tells each person they are lost. Others say it leaves the world-system untouched and turns people right side up, one by one.

- Costly witness. Penniless men with no backers shook whole cities. Those who housed them, like Jason, carried the risk.

Acts 17:7

whom Jason has received; and these all do contrary to the decrees of Caesar, saying, that there is another king, Jesus.

The riot at Thessalonica ended before the city rulers. Jason and some believers stood accused of sheltering men who defied Caesar by naming a rival king. The mob framed the charge as treason. Yet their words are a fair summary of what Paul had been preaching in the synagogue.

A charge with no substance

The charge sounded serious. But one writer points out that the gospel reaches every level of society while leaving civil government untouched:

That the preachers of divine grace "turned the world upside down" was natural to say, and became a standing reproach, however untrue. Yet it is understandable, because the gospel reaches among high and low, and separates people from the world by a divine bond to Christ in heaven. But for that very reason it does not interfere with the authority of the world. On the contrary, it commands every soul to be subject to that authority as God's ordinance here below.

William Kelly

Another writer notes how the accusers changed their politics to suit the moment:

It was even a threat to the authority and claims of Caesar. How loyal to the Imperial dynasty the Jews could become! At home, they wanted to shake off Roman rule. Abroad, when it suited their purpose, they played the part of Rome's fearless champions.

C. E. Stuart

The truth inside the charge

The words were malicious. But Paul had given a large place to the kingdom of God and to the return of the One who is to reign:

No doubt the insinuation was unfounded and malicious. But it had a show of evidence in the prominence given to the kingdom of God in which Jesus was to come. For He had gone, among other purposes, to receive that kingdom and to return. It is ill-willed folly to claim that this expectation stands against the rights of Caesar. Still, it is plain that the teaching was very far from modern doctrine, which no one could misread that way.

William Kelly

We learn the shape of Paul's synagogue teaching from the mouths of his opponents:

Paul first claimed that Jesus is the Messiah. Second, he asserts that this Jesus, the Messiah, was also King. We gather this from the challenge of his accusers.

J. G. Bellett

The King they named

The mob meant "another king" as a warning. Read next to Micah's promise, it is a description:

Do we not see divine greatness and shepherd care in one blessed Person? He can be none other than the One our verse calls "another king, one Jesus." "But you, O Bethlehem Ephrathah… from you shall come forth for me one who is to be ruler in Israel, whose coming forth is from of old, from ancient days" (Micah 5:2). He, the Eternal One, is the Ruler of His people!

F. A. Hughes

Christians soon learned what kind of rule this is:

People soon understood this about Christians: they had "another king, one Jesus." His sovereignty meant freedom in obedience — the sweetest possible absolute rule of a perfect and divine love.

Numerical Bible Notes

The man who opened his house

The mob attacked Jason for what he did, not for what he said. He had taken the preachers into his home.

Paul's host, Jason, was the special object of their hostility. They surrounded his house. They wanted to bring the Lord's servants out in front of the people — the public assembly of the city.

William Kelly

The court let him go on bail, but the pressure on the young believers did not stop:

They only take security from Jason and the others and release them… We know from Paul's first letter to the Thessalonians that the assembly left there suffered serious persecution after this. Though so young in the faith, they kept up an exemplary witness to Christ and the gospel without Paul and Silas to encourage them.

Leslie M. Grant

A kingdom that shapes today

The hope of that kingdom does its work in the present.

With His kingdom and glory before us, we can gladly bear present shame and suffering. Our whole way of life is lifted by it.

William Kelly

Summary

- The accusation. The charge of defying Caesar was false. The gospel binds people to Christ in heaven, and it tells every soul to submit to governing authority.

- The accusers. Those who pressed Rome's cause here resented Rome at home — loyalty used as a weapon, not held as a conviction.

- The truth inside it. The slander preserves Paul's message. Jesus is the Messiah, and this Messiah is King, gone to receive a kingdom and to return.

- The King. "Another king, one Jesus" is the eternal Ruler promised at Bethlehem. His sovereignty means freedom in obedience under a perfect and divine love.

- The cost and the comfort. Jason paid for opening his house, and the young assembly kept its witness under persecution. A King and kingdom in view lift the life that bears present shame.

Acts 17:8

And they troubled the crowd and the politarchs when they heard these things.

The mob could not find Paul and Silas, so they hauled Jason before the city rulers of Thessalonica. Their charge was that these men preach another king, Jesus — but did it hold any truth?

Who the City Authorities Were

Luke calls these officials politarchs — an unusual title. One commentator takes it as a mark of the historian's precision, not a slip.

Not finding them, they dragged Jason and certain brothers before the city rulers. That is a distinctive title for the local authorities. It confirms Luke's accuracy all the more, because the term appears in no known remains of Greek antiquity. But an inscription still survives on the marble arch of the western gate of Saloniki. It proves that this was the title of the Thessalonian magistrates, and that there were seven of them.

William Kelly

A Manufactured Alarm

These accusers were not defending Rome. They wanted one thing only.

The outcry of the attackers in verses 6 and 7 teaches us much, at least in its second half. It was natural to say that the preachers of divine grace "turned the world upside down." That became a standing reproach, however untrue... But we cannot look for truth in a foolish cry raised by envious Jews and idle loafers among the Gentiles. They only wanted an appearance convincing enough to arouse the fears of the magistrates, and so drive away the chief heralds of the truth.

William Kelly

Notice how these same accusers behaved at home.

How loyal to the imperial dynasty the Jews could become! At home they wanted to shake off the Roman yoke; abroad, when it suited their purpose, they played the part of Rome's brave champions. These accusations, once made, troubled the crowd and the rulers. The politarchs could not ignore them.

C. E. Stuart

The Gospel and Civil Power

There was a reason such talk sounded believable. The same writer explains it, and then shows where the charge collapses.

Yet it is understandable. The gospel reaches both high and low, and it separates people from the world by a divine bond to Christ in heaven. But for that very reason it does not interfere with the authority of the world. On the contrary, it commands every soul to obey that authority, which God has set in place here below. It ties the hearts of believers, simply and completely, to the rejected One, now glorified in heaven.

William Kelly

Another writer traces the tactic back to the Pharisees:

As to their accusation against Paul and Silas, they claim the two were breaking Caesar's decrees. Not that the accusers had any regard for Caesar. They used the same contemptible tactics the Pharisees had used in accusing the Lord Jesus. Their only specific charge is that these men say there is another king, Jesus.

Leslie M. Grant

Why the Slander Had a Grain of Truth

The charge was false. Yet something in Paul's preaching gave it the look of evidence.

The insinuation was groundless and malicious, without doubt. But it had a show of evidence in the prominence given to the kingdom of God in which Jesus was to come... Paul and his companions kept the constant expectation of Christ's coming reign before the believers. This was no secret for insiders. It was a powerful hope that shaped conduct as well as doctrine, and they pressed it from first to last through the whole Christian life. The opening chapter of the first letter shows that it marked the Thessalonian converts from their very starting point. They turned to God from idols to serve the living and true God, and to wait for His Son from heaven, whom He raised from the dead, Jesus who delivers us from the wrath to come.

William Kelly

How the Magistrates Handled It

Being shaken did not make these rulers reckless.

The rulers were troubled along with the people. Yet they were wiser than those of Philippi, for they took security from Jason and let them go.

J. N. Darby

But the quiet did not last for the new believers left behind.

But the world was hostile... Persecution soon fell heavily on the young converts, as the letter shows.

William Kelly

Summary

- Trouble manufactured. The mob wanted just enough show of rebellion to scare the magistrates and drive the preachers out.

- Trouble misdirected. The gospel does not interfere with civil authority. It tells every soul to obey it, while binding the heart to a Christ in heaven.

- Trouble half-earned. The charge was malicious. Yet Paul had preached a coming King, and that hope marked these converts from day one.

- Trouble contained. A surviving inscription confirms Luke's title for these seven officials. Unlike the rulers at Philippi, they took security from Jason and let them go.

- Trouble inherited. The bail money ended the hearing, not the hostility. Persecution soon fell hard on the young believers left in the city.

Acts 17:9

And having taken security of Jason and the rest, they let them go.

Verse 9 ends the riot at Thessalonica with a bond, not a beating. Three questions follow: what was this "security", why did the rulers go so easy, and what did the bond cost the young church left behind?

What the security was

The word behind "security" is a legal term. One commentator calls it bail, and notes the exact wording Luke chose:

The world was hostile. Yet at that point the rulers did nothing more than take bail from Jason and the rest and let them go, since they had not found the preachers. [Footnote:] Luke does not use the older Greek technical term for bail. He uses a phrase that matches the Latin legal term satisdatio — giving sufficient security.

William Kelly

So Jason went free under a money pledge. The men the crowd wanted were never in custody at all.

Rulers who kept their heads

Set beside the last city Paul had visited, the rulers here come off well:

The Jews dragged Jason and some other believers before the city rulers. They accused them of teaching things against Caesar's authority, and of saying that there was another king, Jesus. But the rulers, though troubled along with the people, were wiser than those of Philippi. They took security from Jason and let them go. Paul and his companions, the main accused, were not there, so they were not found. The believers saw the door shut against the work for the moment, and sent Paul and Silas to Berea, a nearby city.

J. N. Darby

The bond closed the case. It also closed the work in that city for now, so the believers sent the preachers on.

The charge that frightened the court

One writer answers the cry that stirred the court, and names what the accusers were really after:

That the preachers of divine grace "turned the world upside down" was natural to say, and became a standing reproach, however untrue... But for that very reason the gospel does not interfere with the authority of the world. Instead it tells every person to submit to that authority, because God has set it up here on earth. It simply but fully binds the heart of those who believe to the One the world rejected, now glorified in heaven... They only sought an appearance strong enough to arouse the fears of the magistrates, and so drive away the chief heralds of the truth.

William Kelly

So the bond rested on a pretext. The rulers were calming a fear, not punishing a crime.

The cost landed on the local believers

Paul and Silas escaped the hearing entirely. Jason paid. And the pressure did not stop when the court adjourned:

The Jews bring Jason before the rulers and charge him with sheltering Paul and Silas in his home. The rulers were troubled, but they were not as harsh and unjust as the rulers of Philippi, who had Paul and Silas beaten. They only take security from Jason and the others and release them. The Lord had seen fit that the persecutors should not find Paul and Silas... We know from Paul's first letter to the Thessalonians that the church left in Thessalonica suffered serious persecution after this. Yet though they were so young in the faith, they kept up an exemplary witness to Christ and the gospel without Paul and Silas there to encourage them.

Leslie M. Grant

A church still new in the faith held its witness while its host stood under bond and its teachers were gone.

A shut door that God used

Something kept Paul from going back to Thessalonica. One writer names it, and names the God who overruled it:

This passage shows plainly that God allows Satan to harass and hinder the servants of the Lord. Yet set the story beside the history recorded in Acts, and it is very clear that God knows well how to overrule Satan's hindering work for good. Satan hindered Paul from returning to Thessalonica just then, but God led him to Corinth — and He had many people in that city!

F. B. Hole

The closed door in one city became an open one in another.

Summary

- Security. The word is a legal one: bail, a money guarantee. It was the mildest ruling the court could reach, since the men it wanted were never found.

- Restraint. The crowd troubled the magistrates, yet they acted more wisely than the rulers at Philippi. They released the accused instead of beating them.

- Pretext. The accusers raised the charge of another king only to alarm the court. The gospel tells every person to submit to the rulers of this world, and binds the heart to Christ in heaven.

- Cost. The price fell on Jason and the believers there. They suffered on after Paul left, and still held an exemplary witness while new in the faith.

- Overruled. The shut door sent Paul on to Berea. Satan's hindering was real, but God turned it toward Corinth, where He had many people.

Acts 17:10

But the brethren immediately sent away, in the night, Paul and Silas to Berea; who, being arrived, went away into the synagogue of the Jews.

Trouble in Thessalonica boiled over, and Paul's persecutors came looking for him. That same night the believers moved Paul and Silas out of the city to Berea. Was leaving in the dark a retreat? And what did God do with a work that looked cut short?

A door shut for the moment

The decision to move was not Paul's alone. The mob hunted for Paul and never found him. The believers in the city then acted for him.

Paul and his companions were the ones chiefly wanted, but they were not found there. The believers saw that the door was shut against the work for the moment, so they sent Paul and Silas to Berea, a nearby city.

J. N. Darby

God's hand was there before any plan was made. The church left behind in Thessalonica is worth noting too.

The Lord had seen fit that their persecutors did not find Paul and Silas. The believers, however, thought it unwise for the two men to stay any longer, so they sent them away by night to avoid further trouble. We know from Paul's first letter to the Thessalonians that the church left behind in Thessalonica suffered serious persecution after this. Yet, young in the faith as they were, they kept up an outstanding witness to Christ and the gospel without Paul and Silas there to encourage them (1 Thess. 1).

Leslie M. Grant

Obedience, not retreat

Paul had a rule for moments like this, and it came from Jesus Himself.

"Always forward" was the great apostle's motto. He obeyed the Lord's instruction: "When they persecute you in this city, flee to another" (Matt. 10:23). So Paul and Silas left for Berea, now called Verria, or Kara Verria. It lay in another division of Macedonia — Macedonia Tertia — and so under a different government.

C. E. Stuart

Refusing to walk into danger is not weak faith.

Everyone knows that it is easy to be a martyr in theory, and that those who are martyrs in theory are seldom martyrs in practice… Faith never teaches anyone to go looking for danger and trouble. It teaches us to walk the path of Christ in peace and thankfulness. The Lord has not called His servants to leave that path. Some of us may have been struck by this: the Lord told them that when they were persecuted in one city, they should flee to another. That is not chasing martyrdom. It is the very opposite.

William Kelly

Straight back to the synagogue

On arrival they did not lie low. They walked into the synagogue, the Jewish meeting place, and started again.

It is a blessing to notice the tireless zeal of the Lord's servants. They had only just escaped the hatred stirred up by the Jews at Thessalonica. Yet the moment they reached Berea, we see them walking boldly into the synagogue. There they met a readiness of heart in searching the Scriptures that showed greater simplicity and real nobility of soul.

William Kelly

The change of city brought a change of atmosphere.

There they found a delightful change from Thessalonica. Instead of being met with bigotry and persecution, they found in the frequenters of the synagogue a readiness to hear the Word of God.

A. J. Pollock

The enemy's success is God's route

Paul's enemies got what they wanted. The result was not what they wanted.

Nothing is more wonderful than the way God often chooses to carry out His purposes… To human eyes it might look as if the enemies of the gospel had blocked the work by putting a stop to Paul's labours. But once again they only helped to spread the good news in other regions. Happy is the servant who has no will of his own and sees the Lord's hand in all his changing circumstances.

The Christian's Friend

The letter we owe to that night

Paul left Thessalonica before he could finish teaching. That unfinished work stayed with him.

He felt there was something lacking in their faith, and he wanted to supply it (1 Thess. 3:10), because his work among them had been cut short. The hostility of the Jews had forced him out in a hurry (Acts 17:10). This, with many other reasons, gave him a special concern for them.

J. G. Bellett

Summary

- Shut door. The believers saw the way closed in Thessalonica and moved Paul and Silas out. The Lord had already kept the mob from finding them.

- Night road. Leaving was obedience, not fear. The Lord told His servants to flee to another city when persecuted.

- Open synagogue. Fresh from a mob, they walked straight into the synagogue at Berea and started again. The people there tested what they heard against Scripture.

- Wider spread. Enemies cut Paul's work short in one city, and the good news only travelled further.

- Lasting letter. Paul never finished teaching the young believers he left behind, so he wrote to them instead.

Acts 17:11

And these were more noble than those in Thessalonica, receiving the word with all readiness of mind, daily searching the scriptures if these things were so.

After the jealousy and uproar at Thessalonica, Paul and Silas came to Berea and went straight into another synagogue. There they met a very different response. What exactly made these hearers "noble," and can anyone copy it?

Two Cities, Two Receptions

The verse compares two cities that heard the same two preachers. The difference lay in how each city received them:

Not put off by what they had already been through, they looked for the Jews in that city and went into the synagogue. Here the people who attended gave them a better reception. They were not ready to receive the Word just on the authority of two strangers. So they searched the Scriptures daily, and proved that the new teaching was correct. Thessalonica had shown jealousy and uproar. Berea showed a readiness to weigh matters and fairness in listening.

C. E. Stuart

Who "These" and "Those" Are

So who exactly does the verse praise? Not a church. These were synagogue hearers who had not yet believed:

The context makes it clear that "these" and "those" refer to two groups of Jews. We read that Paul and Silas "went into the synagogue of the Jews. These were more noble than those in Thessalonica" (verses 10 and 11)... It could not have been a comparison of one set of Christians with another. At the time, there were no Christians in Berea. Verse 12 makes it very clear. Their faith in the gospel came after their searching of the Scriptures: "Therefore many of them believed."

Michael Hardt

Readiness of Mind

"Readiness" cost these hearers something. What they had to give up was their standing as a privileged nation:

As Jews they were used to exclusive national privileges. The Gentiles were "far" from God but the Jews, at least outwardly, were near. But the gospel shows Jews and Gentiles on an equal footing: both are lost and in need of a Saviour. To accept this, a Jew would need to set aside national pride and privilege and bow to God's thoughts... This willingness to set aside prejudices, preconceived ideas, long cherished thoughts, and so on, in favour of God's word is a mark of true nobility.

Michael Hardt

One writer turns this on the reader, with a warning about the opposite fault:

We want him to "search the Scriptures" with an unbiased mind. We do not want him to form his convictions in the darkness of misrepresentation and prejudice. We want him to form them in the pure and holy light that Scripture sheds around him. And we lovingly urge him to watch against the tendency to think people are wrong just because their position differs from his own.

C. H. Mackintosh

The Weight of "Daily"

The verse does not only say they searched. It says they searched daily:

The Bereans won special commendation not simply for searching the Scriptures, but because they did so daily. It is easy to be diligent for one day. To be diligent day after day calls for perseverance. Daily is a hard and testing word... One great effort, or one heroic sacrifice, is easier by comparison. To keep following Christ day after day, without fuss, is the real test. It is not the man who starts well who wins the race, but the man who keeps going.

Hamilton Smith

Testing Even an Apostle

Notice who they tested. Not some unknown teacher — the apostle Paul:

Paul then carries the gospel to Berea, and Scripture tells us the Bereans were more noble than those in Thessalonica. And why? Because they held that the Scriptures (then the Old Testament) were the only balance God had given to test everything by. So they were "examining the Scriptures daily to see if these things were so." Yes — and God commended them for testing even the ministry of an inspired apostle by the Scriptures. Oh that people would do the same in our day!

H. H. Snell

Why This Way Works

Bowing to the word and testing the word are not rivals. Together they led many to believe:

Here they met such readiness of heart in searching the Scriptures that it showed a greater simplicity and real nobility of soul. To bow to the word, and to receive it as God's word — which it truly is — is the truest condition of divine blessing. Yet they still examined Scripture daily, to see whether the things preached agreed with the things written. Therefore many from among them believed. There is no way so sure or good.

William Kelly

Summary

- Noble — The word describes people in a synagogue who had not yet believed. God commends this state of mind before anyone believes.

- Ready — Nobility starts with a mind ready to drop pride, prejudice and long-held ideas when God's word says otherwise.

- Searching — Readiness alone is not nobility. They checked what they heard against the only authority that can settle anything.

- Daily — The commendation hangs on one word of perseverance. One day of diligence is easy. Day after day is the real test.

- Therefore — Ready hearing plus daily searching ended in faith. No surer or better way exists — even when an apostle is the one speaking.

Acts 17:12

Therefore many from among them believed, and of Grecian women of the upper classes and men not a few.

At Berea, Paul found a synagogue full of people willing to check his message against the Scriptures. Verse 12 is what came of that checking. Faith broke out, and it did not stop with the Jews.

The Word "Therefore"

The verse opens with a link back to the daily searching of verse 11. One writer draws out how demanding that searching was, and what it earned:

They verified what they heard based on the only true authority, the word of God. They searched the Scriptures. This was not a casual read, nor was it occasional. It was daily searching; diligent and constant seeking of the mind of God in His word. They did not have the luxury of online Bibles or Bible apps. They had to work through scrolls of handwritten text. But their zeal brought them a great reward: "Many of them therefore believed" (verse 12).

Michael Hardt

These hearers needed no miracles. One writer explains why:

With disciples such as these, miracles are not needed and would rather distract than help. The Word is itself the greatest of miracles. It is the voice of the Living God. That voice has sounded on through the ages, never silent, wherever there was an ear to hear. So the readiness to receive the gospel ripens into faith in these Bereans, as they search the Scriptures with vigorous determination, day by day.

Numerical Bible Notes

The Surest Way

They measured the preaching against the written word. One writer says no way of hearing is better:

To bow to the word, and to receive it as God's word — which it truly is — is the truest condition of divine blessing. Yet they still examined Scripture daily, to see whether the preaching agreed with the written word. Many of them therefore believed. There is no way so sure or good.

William Kelly

Who "These" Were

Verse 11 calls the Bereans "more noble." More noble than whom? Verse 12 helps settle it:

The context makes it clear that "these" and "those" refer to two groups of Jews — those in Berea and those in Thessalonica. It could not have been a comparison of one set of Christians with another. At the time, there were no Christians in Berea. Verse 12 is clear: their faith in the gospel followed their searching of the Scriptures. "Many of them therefore believed."

Michael Hardt

Past the Synagogue Door

The verse names two more groups beyond the Jews:

Here again women of prominence are mentioned (Greeks) and men also, not a few. In this case, as in Thessalonica, though the work began in the synagogue, it was by no means confined to Jews. The Spirit of God has not thought it necessary to tell us, however, how the work progressed in Berea later.

Leslie M. Grant

For those Greek converts, believing meant a break with the whole shape of the life they had been living:

It was surely a deliverance beyond words. It freed them from degrading immorality and from empty myths. It turned them from a life of selfishness to serve the one and only true God, and to wait for His Son from heaven.

William Kelly

Noble and Honourable

Two words of praise stand side by side here. One is for the searchers. One is for the women who believed:

Where there is uprightness of heart, and a true valuing of the Scripture, divine blessing will come. God does His work by His word received into the heart. God calls the Jews who searched the Scriptures "noble," and the women who believed were "honourable."

An Outline of Sound Words

Summary

- Therefore — The verse hangs on one connecting word. Faith at Berea came after the daily searching, not instead of it.

- Tested — They weighed Paul's preaching against the written word. No way of hearing is surer or better.

- Proof — Faith followed the searching. So the people called "more noble" in verse 11 were not yet believers when Paul arrived.

- Reach — The work started in the synagogue. It did not stay there. Greek women of rank and Greek men believed too.

- Honour — God calls the searchers noble and the women honourable. His praise rests on hearts that value His word.

Acts 17:13

But when the Jews from Thessalonica knew that the word of God was announced in Berea also by Paul, they came there also, stirring up the crowds.

Paul had just escaped Thessalonica by night, and Berea welcomed his preaching — until his old opponents heard and travelled after him. Why would people who refuse a message go out of their way to stop others from hearing it?

Opposition that follows the preacher

Driving Paul out of one city was not enough for his opponents. One commentator notes where the trouble in Berea came from:

But Jewish anger was not content to drive the apostles out of Thessalonica. From Thessalonica the hostile Jews came to Berea to work against the preached word, stirring up and troubling the crowds there too.

William Kelly

This was not a short walk. Another writer gives the distance they covered, and sees the effort backfire:

When the Jews of Thessalonica heard of the success in Berea, they followed Paul to that town, about fifty miles away, and stirred up the people. The Devil always defeats himself, for he only drove the servants of Christ to other places, where they spread the gospel.

A J Pollock

Refusing the message and blocking it

News that Paul was preaching in a new place was enough to set them moving:

How long they were there we are not told. But it was clearly only a short time before the militant Jews of Thessalonica heard of the Word preached in Berea, and came there to stir up the people against the Lord's servants. They not only rejected the message of grace themselves, but they were determined that others must not even hear it.

Leslie M. Grant

What Paul was preaching

The verse calls the message "the word of God." One writer shows how Paul preached that word in the synagogues:

Acts 17:13 clearly shows the method the apostle used in his preaching. In the synagogues he found copies of the Law and the Prophets, which served his purpose. So he sought out the synagogues and proved to the Jews, from their own Scriptures, that Jesus of Nazareth was indeed the "Christ" to whom they bore witness. He it was who had suffered, as had been foretold, and had risen again from the dead.

William J Lowe

Why old religion resists new truth

Commentators give more than one reason for this hatred. One writer sees a pattern that repeats far beyond Berea:

But the unhappy Jews carry on their work, and come from Thessalonica to stir up the people against Paul and the others. It is sad to see their permanent hatred of the gospel. But it is always like this when truth sets aside an old religion and its followers refuse that truth.

J. N. Darby

Another traces it to pride in what is already held, and says it hardens when grace reaches outsiders:

Knowledge of old revelation gives no security for receiving the truth God is actually sending or using most at any given time. On the contrary, as we see in these Jews here and elsewhere, if there is pride in what someone already has, that pride will work powerfully to reject what God means to test the heart with now. This is especially so when grace is at work to open the door of faith to those who had no religious standing from of old. So of all things the gospel is the most repulsive to God's ancient people, who madly refused the mercy that waited on them first of all, before it was preached to the Gentiles.

William Kelly

The believers who carried Paul on

Paul had to move on again, and new believers went with him. One writer counts what that escort cost them:

We can, however, pause to admire the devotion of those believers who escorted Paul, and did not leave him until he reached Athens. The sea voyage to Athens would take three to six days... So we may reckon the journey from Berea to Athens and back to have kept these believers away from home for between two and three weeks. But we are sure they grudged neither the time, the expense, nor the tiredness in caring for one who had ministered such blessings to their souls, cheering him and helping him on his way.

C. E. Stuart

Summary

- Word preached. Paul proved from the Law and the Prophets that Jesus of Nazareth is the Christ who suffered and rose. That is the message his opponents stirred the crowds against.

- Word resented. Pride in truth already held can turn a person against the truth God is pressing now. It hardens further when grace reaches people with no religious standing.

- Word hunted. These opponents refused the message. Then they travelled fifty miles to stop others from hearing it.

- Word protected. New believers took Paul to safety, spending weeks and money to see him all the way to Athens.

- Word spread. The effort to silence Paul only moved him on to fresh ground — the enemy defeats himself.

Acts 17:14

And then immediately the brethren sent away Paul to go as to the sea; but Silas and Timotheus abode there.

Persecution from Thessalonica followed Paul fifty miles to Berea, and the believers there rushed him out of the city. Why did Paul run, what does the phrase about the sea mean, and why were Silas and Timothy left behind?

Why Paul left

One writer sees Paul's flight as obedience to an instruction given long before:

Long before, the Lord had also laid down a general principle: "When they persecute you in one town, flee to the next" (Matt. 10:23). Paul and his companions plainly carried out this principle later, even to shaking the dust off their feet (Acts 14:6, Acts 17:10-14).

W. W. Fereday

The same wisdom shaped his route out of Berea and his choice of companions:

Again wisdom says Paul should leave Berea. He went toward the sea with others who seem to have known the area, but left Silas and Timothy behind.

Leslie M. Grant

"To the sea": decoy or destination

Some texts read "as if to the sea," which hints at a trick to send the pursuers down the wrong road. Commentators differ here. One argues from the oldest manuscripts that no trick is in the text at all:

"As far as to the sea" they went. That is how the oldest manuscripts read. They do not say "as if to the sea." Some could take that other reading as a decoy to throw pursuers off the scent. At what point they embarked for Athens is not stated.

C. E. Stuart

Another writer keeps the idea of a trick, and sees the hostility aimed at Paul in particular:

The Thessalonian Jews hated the Word of God so much that they chased Paul all the way to Berea. Faced with more trouble, Paul slipped away to Athens and outwitted his pursuers with a simple trick. Silas and Timothy stayed at Berea, since the hostility now fell on Paul in particular.

F. B. Hole

The cost carried by the Bereans

Escorting Paul cost the Bereans more than a walk to the city gate:

The believers in Berea, new converts as they all were, cared for Paul and sent him away as far as the sea. Some even went with him to Athens... We can pause to admire the devotion of those brothers who escorted Paul. They did not leave him until he reached Athens. The sea voyage to Athens would take a little time, say from three to six days... So the journey from Berea to Athens and back would have kept these brothers away from home for two to three weeks. But we are sure they grudged none of it — not the time, not the cost, not the weariness. They cared for this man, cheered him, and helped him on his way. He had brought such blessing to their souls, and his weak eyesight may also have made him more dependent on others. Brotherly love was active in them.

C. E. Stuart

Silas and Timothy, and what followed

Their later movements show how Paul kept using them for churches he could not reach himself:

Paul had been driven by persecution from Thessalonica, then from Berea to Athens. Alone at Athens for a time (Acts 17), he sent word for Silas and Timothy to come to him with all speed (17:15). Evidently Timothy at least had done so. As to Silas, it does not seem clear. But Paul then sent Timothy from Athens to Thessalonica. He could not go himself, and no doubt he hated losing Timothy's help. Later both Silas and Timothy rejoined Paul at Corinth (Acts 18:5). As for where Silas was in the meantime, Scripture seems to give no hint.

Leslie M. Grant

Opposition that spread the gospel

The work at Berea was cut short. One writer reads that interruption the other way round:

To human eyes, the enemies of the gospel seemed to have stopped the work by cutting Paul's labours short. But once again they only helped spread the good news into other regions. Happy is the servant who has no will of his own. He sees the Lord's hand in all his changing circumstances. He can discern His mind in everything that comes up in his path.

The Christian's Friend

Another writer states it briefly:

But with all this, the enemy does nothing but order the path of the gospel, according to the will of God.

J. N. Darby

Summary

- Hostility starts the path. Jews from Thessalonica came to Berea to stir up the crowds, and their hostility fell on Paul in particular.

- Wisdom chooses the path. Leaving obeyed the Lord's own instruction to flee to the next town.

- Love escorts along the path. New believers in Berea gave two to three weeks, their money and their strength to bring Paul to Athens.

- Co-workers hold the ground behind. Silas and Timothy stayed at Berea and rejoined Paul later. Paul then sent Timothy back to Thessalonica and stood alone.

- God ordered the path all along. The enemy seemed to stop the work. In fact he drove the gospel where God wanted it next.

Acts 17:15

But they that conducted Paul brought him as far as Athens; and, having received a commandment to Silas and Timotheus, that they should come to him as quickly as possible, they departed.

This verse reads like a travel note. Behind it lie a violent expulsion from Berea, a servant left waiting alone in a strange city, and the moves that led to Paul's letters to Thessalonica.

Enemies Who Move the Gospel Along

Paul is in Athens because his enemies drove him out of Berea. One writer sees those enemies serving God's plan without meaning to.

A few brothers conduct Paul to Athens, and he sends an order to Silas and Timothy to join him there at once. But with all this, the enemy does nothing but arrange the path of the gospel, according to the will of God.

J. N. Darby

Another writer draws out how a servant should read such setbacks:

To human eyes, it might seem that the enemies of the gospel had stopped Paul's labours and so hindered the work. But once again they only helped to spread the good news in other regions. Happy is the servant who has no will of his own! He sees the Lord's hand in all his changing circumstances, and he can discern His mind in everything that comes up in his path.

The Christian's Friend

The Escort

The verse does not say how many men went with Paul, or how far they walked. One writer supplies both.

More than one person went with Paul to Athens, over 200 miles away. On their return they brought an order for Silas and Timothy to join him with all speed.

A. J. Pollock

Athens was where Paul was heading, and where he called his companions to meet him. One writer looks ahead to what the visit produced:

Athens, as we shall see, was not destined to be a fruitful field for the incorruptible seed, the living and abiding word of God.

William Kelly

Waiting Instead of Preaching

Paul told his companions to come fast. Then he waited in Athens instead of preaching. One writer treats that pause as a real question about the servant's motives.

It is a remarkable thing that the apostle's mind does not seem to have been set on service in Athens. Even in his coming to the place, those who accompanied him seem to have decided where he went. And now that he has arrived, he did not begin preaching at once, as at Thessalonica and Berea. He waited for Silas and Timothy. Had he left Berea unwillingly? We cannot tell; but one thing is certain: the servant is often in danger of being governed by his affections rather than by the Lord's will.

The Christian's Friend

The same writer does not leave it as a criticism. Whatever Paul felt, he adds, the Lord was controlling His devoted servant and preparing him for new work in His own way.

Left Without His Companions

Why did Paul have to send for Silas and Timothy at all? One writer explains why they had stayed behind.

Silas and Timothy remained at Berea, because clearly the hostility was now aimed especially at Paul. So on his visit to Athens, Paul was solitary and alone as far as his service went. Athens was the great centre of Greek culture and wisdom.

F. B. Hole

What the Summons Led To

The order in this verse starts a chain of travels. Scripture traces only part of it.

Alone at Athens for a time (Acts 17), he sent word for Silas and Timothy to come to him with all speed (17:15). Evidently Timothy at least had done so. As to Silas, it does not seem clear. But Paul then sent Timothy from Athens to Thessalonica. He could not go himself, and he was no doubt reluctant to be without Timothy's help. Later both Silas and Timothy rejoined Paul at Corinth (Acts 18:5). As for Silas's movements in the meantime, Scripture seems to give no indication.

Leslie M. Grant

Out of these travels came Paul's first letter to Thessalonica. Where did he write it? One writer weighs the old claim that it came from Athens:

The Authorized Version has a postscript, "written from Athens." … Paul wrote the Epistle after Timothy had returned from his visit to Thessalonica. … Timothy came from Thessalonica with the good news of the happy state of the Thessalonian church and joined the apostle in Corinth (Acts 18:5). From Corinth Paul wrote this first Epistle.

Arno Clemens Gaebelein

Summary

- Driven. Opponents forced Paul out of Berea. The enemy only arranged the gospel's route, according to the will of God.

- Escorted. Believers travelled more than 200 miles with him, then carried his order back to Berea.

- Charged. Paul sent for his fellow workers at speed, then waited instead of preaching. One writer warns that a servant can be governed by his affections rather than by the Lord's will.

- Alone. The hostility now targeted Paul, so he faced the great centre of Greek culture on his own.

- Fruitful anyway. The summons set off Timothy's travels, and out of them came Paul's first letter to Thessalonica — written, one writer argues, from Corinth.