God therefore, having overlooked the times of ignorance, now enjoins men that they shall all everywhere repent,
Paul speaks on Mars Hill in Athens, a city proud of its learning. His words turn on a change in history: what God once passed over, He now confronts. Two questions follow. What did God overlook? And why does "now" put every person, everywhere, under a command?
Older translations read "winked at" and "all men" where the ESV has "overlooked" and "all people." One writer explains the phrase. He also notes how little it flattered Athens:
W T Turpin"And the times of this ignorance" — that was no great compliment to their polish, learning, philosophy, wisdom, or education. Whether sage or savage, they are all put in one lump there. "The times of this ignorance God winked at" — that is, He did not take account of it. "But now commands all men everywhere" — mark those words — "to repent."
Overlooking was not approval. For those long years He held back judgment:
J. N. DarbyDuring the times of ignorance, God had put up with the wanderings of man. He had passed them over without judgment. Now He was calling to all men everywhere to repent, because a day was appointed in which He should judge the world.
The word "now" splits history in two. What ended the darkness was a Person:
William KellyThe Gentiles, during God's dealings with Israel, were in the dark. Those were the times of ignorance, and God overlooked their ways. But now, says the apostle, He commands all men everywhere to repent. There is no excuse for ignorance any longer. The Light shines, the true Light. Christ was that Light.
The command levels every distinction Athens prized. It bypasses debate and goes straight for the conscience:
William KellyClearly there is a thrust at conscience. This is why he insists here on God's call to repent. It is no use to talk of science, literature, politics, religion. Old or new speculations in philosophy are equally empty. God is now requiring all everywhere to repent. So he puts the sage down with the savage, because God is brought in as the judge of all. Divine truth must be aggressive. It cannot help dealing with every conscience that hears it, anywhere in the world. The law might thunder its claims at one particular people. But the truth deals with everybody as he is before God.
Some narrow the word "all" to a smaller group. One writer will not allow it:
Charles Henry MackintoshIf God commands all men, everywhere to repent, does He mean what He says, or merely all the elect? What right have we to add to, or alter, to pare down, or to accommodate the Word of God? None whatever.
A command can sound harsh. This one carries God's love to people who had dishonoured Him:
William KellyThe apostle keeps to one fact here: God did not judge those times of terrible and inexcusable ignorance. In His goodness He overlooked the past, and now He calls people to repent. ... How true it is that the message of God's love in salvation to everyone who believes is His own command! ... The Gentiles ignored the true God. They set up idols to His dishonour and their own shame. God no longer ignores them. "The true light already shines." Coming into the world, it gives light to every man. It is true that the world was so blind it did not know Him. But the God of all grace does not leave them to their folly. He sends them this charge: they should "all everywhere repent." What compassion for "all everywhere," and what concern!
Repentance has never been optional. It has marked every turning to God from the earliest days:
William KellyNo sinner, no child of fallen man, ever turned to God in faith — as all did from Abel onward — without repentance. ... Its character is self-judgment before Him. Not only one's ways, but one's self, is laid bare as seen by His holy eyes, with whom we have to do.
One writer says the common definition stops short:
J. N. DarbyThe definition that it is merely a change of mind is not enough; that would reduce it entirely to faith. It is the soul judging itself before God — the eye turned inward, not outward, by the Spirit of God.
The command drew three answers. The final question turns to the reader:
C E StuartOn Mars Hill the coming judgment was announced. A fixed day was made known, and the Judge was pointed out. How was this divine communication received? Some mocked, some put it off, a few believed. That was the effect on the hearers. What has been the effect in the reader's case?
- Overlooked — God passed over past ignorance. He did not approve it, and He did not judge it then.
- Now — The Light has come. The excuse of ignorance is gone, and a day of judgment is fixed.
- Everywhere — The command flattens every rank. It puts the scholar beside the savage, because God judges all.
- Commanded — The charge is not harshness. It is God's love reaching people who had dishonoured Him.
- Repent — Not a change of opinion, but the soul judging itself before God. Athens gave the three answers still given today: mockery, delay, faith.
because he has set a day in which he is going to judge the habitable earth in righteousness by [the] man whom he has appointed, giving the proof [of it] to all [in] having raised him from among [the] dead.
Paul ends his address at Athens not with philosophy but with a date, a Man, and a proof. Everything hangs on one word — "because." God calls people to repent now because the day is fixed, the Judge is chosen, and the proof is already given.
Paul has just called for repentance. This verse gives the reason, and that reason puts every listener on one level.
William Kelly"And the times of this ignorance" (what a way to treat the boasting men of Athens!) "God overlooked; but now commands all men everywhere to repent." Clearly there is a thrust at conscience. This is why he insists here on God's call to repent. It is no use to talk of science, literature, politics, religion. Old or new speculations in philosophy are alike empty. God is now commanding all everywhere to repent. So he puts the scholar down with the savage, because he brings God in as the judge of all.
The word behind "world" here means the inhabited earth. Commentators stress that this is the judgment of living people when Christ appears, not the judgment of the dead.
William KellyHere the common thought of Christendom is a serious mistake. The Jews used to look for a judgment of living men, and perhaps in some measure they still do. Most Christians, despite the Creeds, look almost only for a judgment of the dead before eternity. Here and elsewhere the apostle pressed the judgment of this inhabited world at our Lord's appearing, when He comes to bring in His kingdom in open power and glory.
Two things are already settled and named in the verse — a day and a Person. The one the world condemned is the one it must face.
James BoydFrom that day to this God has been showing His patient mercy. But the day of that judgment is appointed, and the Man is also appointed who is to carry out the judgment. The world that judged Him is to be judged by Him.
Commentators point to the act that revealed what the world truly is.
J. N. DarbyBut the central sin of the world, the one that stamped its true character, is the rejection and death of Christ. But the One whom the world rejected, God has raised from the dead, and to Him all judgment is committed. Every knee shall bow to Him; and the more boldly they have rejected and opposed Him, the more terrible will be their judgment.
God's standard for that day is not new. Paul is repeating a line from the Psalms:
J. N. Darby"He shall judge the world in righteousness" — Acts 17:31 quotes this line; it matches the Greek Old Testament word for word.
This righteousness is more than pardon for individuals. It is God putting right every area that sin has spoiled.
F. B. HoleThe point here is not the forgiveness of sins and justification for us, as it is in Romans 3. The point is righteousness set up in public in every area that sin has touched and spoiled. Christ's death was the supreme act of the world's unrighteousness. His glorification was the supreme act of God's righteousness, and the guarantee that righteousness will at last prevail everywhere, in keeping with Paul's words in Acts 17:31.
"Assurance" here is evidence — something God has put in front of everyone. Kelly renders the clause this way:
William Kelly"because He had appointed a day in which He is about to judge the inhabited earth in righteousness by a Man whom He had marked out, having given assurance [or, ground of belief] to all in that He raised Him out of the dead."
The same event that guarantees judgment for the world settles the opposite for those who believe — which is why the argument runs differently at Athens than in a letter to Christians.
William KellyThe resurrection of the Lord is the pledge that He will one day be the Judge of those who do not believe. To the believer the resurrection is God's sign and witness that his sins are all blotted out... They were not believers, so he does not speak of anyone being justified. He tells them that the resurrection of the Lord is God's proof and pledge: He is going to judge all the inhabited world by that Man whom He has raised from the dead.
This verse marks a line. God offers grace today. On that day He will not.
W. T. TurpinThere is not a single cloud of judgment in the present grace, and there will not be one single ray of grace in the future judgment. He will judge it by the Man whom the world spat on and trampled under its feet, by that Man whom He has ordained — and He has given the most undeniable proof of it in raising Him from the dead.
- Appointed — the day is set and the Judge is named. Nothing about that day is still open.
- Ordained — the Judge is a Man, the same One the world rejected. The world that judged Him will face Him as Judge.
- In righteousness — the standard is God's own. He showed it in public when He glorified the Christ that men condemned.
- Assurance — the resurrection is God's proof, given to everyone. It means judgment for the world, and for the believer it means sins blotted out.
- Therefore repent — the command reaches every person everywhere. It puts the scholar on the same ground as the savage.