Acts 13:19–20

Acts 13:19

And having destroyed seven nations in the land of Canaan, he gave them their land as an inheritance.

Paul is preaching in a synagogue at Antioch in Pisidia, and he has just walked his hearers from God's choice of Israel through the exodus and forty years in the desert. Now he reaches the conquest, and two questions come with it: why were those nations destroyed, and what do the "about 450 years" of the next line measure?

God as the actor

Paul is not giving a history lesson for its own sake. Every event he lists has the same subject: God. One commentator follows the titles God earns as the sermon goes on.

He spoke of God, and of His ways, full and varied as they were. God had chosen their fathers. God had exalted them in Egypt, and had brought them out with great power. God also had put up with their behaviour in the wilderness. He destroyed seven nations in the land of Canaan and divided it among the tribes by lot. Then He appeared as a Giver. He gave them judges and prophets. He gave them Saul as king. After that He was known as a Raiser-up. He raised up David first, then David's seed — Jesus in the incarnation — and last of all He raised Him up in resurrection. He had also proved Himself a Fulfiller of promises. A Giver, a Raiser up, a Fulfiller of His promises — what an announcement they heard that day! If God is like this, all can and should rest on His word.

C. E. Stuart

Why the seven nations fell

The destruction was not random. One commentator describes what these nations had become, and why God waited so long.

These nations were sunk in the most awful sexual immorality, and they practised the vilest evils. There are different reasons to believe that Satan had a special hold on them. God had put up with these nations for many centuries. In His mercy He waited before He drew the sword of justice. Now their wickedness had reached its full measure, and the time for judgment had come. The Lord called Israel to carry out that awful judgment.

Arno Clemens Gaebelein

An inheritance received, not earned

Paul says God "gave them their land." One commentator explains why it could only ever be a gift.

God had driven out the nations who occupied the land of promise, for Israel certainly did not have the power to do this. It was God who planted Israel in the land. It was God who brought trouble on those who had seized the land He meant to give to Israel. Israel did use their swords in conquering the land, but it was not their swords that won the victory.

L. M. Grant

Six books in miniature

Paul covers Abraham to Joshua in a few lines. One commentator names what that short summary holds.

First, God's dealings from His choice of the fathers are tied at once to the exodus of the people from Egypt. Then comes His care of them in the wilderness, until He gave them the land to inherit. It is the Pentateuch and the book of Joshua in miniature, with Israel at the centre, loved for the sake of the fathers. The gospel confirms God's love to Israel; it does not cancel it.

William Kelly

The 450 years

Part of the answer lies in the wording of verses 19 and 20.

In verses 19 and 20 there is a notable difference from the usual wording. The point is not that He gave the land by lot, though that is true in itself, but that He caused them to inherit their land… This connects the date of "about 450 years" with the carrying out of the promised inheritance.

William Kelly

A reference work gives the reading itself, and where the count may start.

In Acts 13:20 the King James Version reads that God gave them judges for about 450 years, until Samuel the prophet. This would not agree with the 480 years of 1 Kings 6:1. But there is a different reading in Acts 13, which editors of the Greek Testament and the Revised Version have adopted, apart from all questions of chronology. It reads, "He divided to them their land by lot, about 450 years; and afterwards he gave them judges." So the 450 years are not applied to the length of the judges. This period may be made up by counting from the birth of Isaac, because the promise was to the seed of Abraham, and Isaac was the child of promise.

Morrish Bible Dictionary

Summary

- God chose. The account begins with His choice of the fathers. Israel's story never starts with Israel.

- God cleared. He did not sweep the seven nations away on a whim. He waited centuries while their wickedness grew full, then used Israel to carry out the judgment.

- God gave. The land came as an inheritance. Israel used swords, but swords did not win it. They had no power to take the land themselves.

- God kept giving. Judges, prophets, a king, then David — at every stage He is the Giver, the Raiser-up, the Fulfiller of promises.

- God's word holds. The date problem clears up once the better reading ties the 450 years to the inheritance, not to the judges.

Acts 13:20

And after these things he gave [them] judges till Samuel the prophet, [to the end of] about four hundred and fifty years.

Paul is speaking in a synagogue in Antioch of Pisidia, retelling Israel's story to people who knew it well. This verse covers the years from the settling of Canaan to Samuel, and it raises two questions: what does the 450 years count, and why did God keep giving judges to a failing people?

God the Giver in Paul's Sermon

Paul's summary tells what God did, not what Israel achieved. One commentator lists the names the sermon gives Him.

He spoke of God, and of His ways, full and varied as they were… Then He appeared as a Giver. He gave them judges and prophets. He gave them Saul as king too. After that they knew Him as a Raiser-up. He raised up David first, then David's descendant — Jesus, when He came into the world as a man. Last of all He raised Him up from the dead. He also proved Himself a Fulfiller of promises. A Giver, a Raiser up, a Fulfiller of His promises — what an announcement they heard that day!

C. E. Stuart

The Question of the 450 Years

The older English reading ties the 450 years to the judges themselves. That clashes with the 480 years of 1 Kings 6:1. Commentators differ on the answer. Some look to the oldest manuscripts:

In the common text of 13:20, Paul marks the period of the Judges as about 450 years… But this cannot be squared with 1 Kings 6:1. That verse fixes the start of the Temple building — in the fourth year of Solomon — at 480 years after the Exodus… Now the earliest Greek manuscripts, along with the Latin and Egyptian versions, read the passage another way: "He divided the land among them by lot about the space of 450 years. And after that He gave them judges." So the years mentioned would come before the time of the Judges.

C. E. Stuart

Others keep the usual wording and explain the number another way. The judges did not all rule one after another, and the figure is a round one.

The "450 years" in Acts 13:20 looks like a round figure. It covers the time from the entry into the wilderness to the end of the reign of Saul… We must also remember that the Judges often ruled over only part of the people. So Ehud and Shamgar worked among the tribes in the south, while Deborah and Barak brought deliverance in the north.

J. N. Darby

Where the earlier manuscripts are followed, the number then measures something else entirely — the time it took God to make good His word about the land.

If the oldest witnesses are accepted, it was in about 450 years that Israel was made to inherit this land, after the promise to "our fathers," that is, counting from the birth of Isaac as the starting point… It cannot therefore be assumed that Paul assigns a duration of 450 years to the judges, and so invalidates the date in 1 Kings 6:1 of 480 years from the Exodus to the founding of Solomon's temple.

William Kelly

Why Judges Were Needed at All

One word, "judges," stands for a whole book of Israel's history. It runs in a cycle: failure, misery, rescue, then failure again.

Their unfaithfulness brought misery on them, and that misery moved the compassion of God. His mighty grace raised up deliverers by His Spirit among the fallen and wretched people… But Israel did not change. "And yet they would not listen to their judges." "When the judge died, they turned back and became more corrupt than their fathers." This is the sad history of the people of God. It is also the history of the grace of God, and of His compassion towards His people.

J. N. Darby

The Men God Gave

Paul says God gave them judges. The gift lay in the giving, not in the quality of the men given.

We read, for instance, that God gave the people of Israel judges (Acts 13:20), that is, certain men who became leaders and rulers of the people. But there was nothing in Gideon, Samson, or any of them to magnify the love of God. These servants in themselves had little moral worth. They did not make their office great by their own excellence. Instead, their office made them great.

William J Hocking

"Until Samuel the Prophet"

The verse ends with a name. Samuel judged Israel and was also the first prophet, and with his sons the era of the judges ran out.

Samuel, the first prophet (Acts 3:24; Acts 13:20), was also a judge over Israel (1 Samuel 7:6). He thought he could set up his sons as judges after him (1 Samuel 8:1), but their unfaithfulness ended that arrangement. The period of the judges was also short-lived by nature. The judges gave only brief relief to the misery of a guilty people. Israel had let the enemies of the Lord live instead of destroying them.

H. L. Rossier

Summary

- Gave. One verb carries Paul's whole story. God gave judges, gave Saul as king, raised up David, and then raised up David's descendant, Jesus.

- Grace. The judges came out of Israel's collapse. Their history records the people's failure and God's compassion together.

- Gideon. No judge earned his place. The office lifted the man, not the man the office, so the credit stays with the Giver.

- Chronology. The 450 years fits either an older reading that ties it to gaining the land, or judgeships that overlapped. Either way, it does not overturn 1 Kings 6:1.

- Samuel. He is the hinge. After him the brief relief of the judges gave way to kings — and through David's line, to Jesus.