2 Samuel 8:15–18

2 Samuel 8:15

And David reigned over all Israel; and David executed judgment and justice to all his people.

Chapter 8 closes the account of how God established David's throne, and verse 15 turns from David's wars to the way he ran his kingdom. How close did his reign come to the King it pictures?

A Dividing Line in the Book

These verses mark where the book turns. They also show that David's kingdom had not yet reached its final form.

We have now come to one of the divisions of this book. Verses 15 to 18 of our chapter, 2 Samuel 8, mark this division. We find these verses again, with some changes, in 2 Samuel 20:23-26. They present the order of David's reign, and 2 Samuel 8 ends the history, strictly speaking, of the king's establishment as a picture of the Messiah. But Joab at the head of the army, and two high priests serving at once, prove that the final order has not yet come. It will come under Solomon's reign.

H. L. Rossier

The view now moves inside the kingdom, and justice is only the first part of it.

We now look at the kingdom from the inside. First comes the administration of righteousness, and the order set up for it. Then, at greater length, comes its character of salvation. Mephibosheth is a beautiful illustration of that.

Numerical Bible Notes

Over All Israel

David ruled the whole nation, not one part of it. One writer sees in that a picture of a reunion still ahead.

David united Judah and Israel and reigned over the whole nation (2 Sam. 5:1; 2 Sam. 8:15; 1 Chr. 29:26). The hostility and division were healed under his wise leadership. His Greater Son will gather the scattered ones of Israel and bring Judah and Israel together as one, never to be divided again (Isa. 11:11-13).

Truth & Testimony

Judgment and Justice as the Mark of the Reign

The ESV says David "administered justice and equity"; the older wording these writers quote is "judgment and justice". That pair is what David is remembered for — and what he sometimes broke.

A united Israel is under his hand, and he gives judgment and justice to all his people. This, above all, is the character David represents to us, as we have seen. Sadly, we know that at times he fails badly in this. But it is the general character of his reign, and what he stands for as a picture. We will find the lessons of his failure in full elsewhere. Here, for the sake of that picture, all of this is left out.

Numerical Bible Notes

The same pairing runs through the reigns of other kings and forward into prophecy.

Righteousness and judgment are the foundation of God's throne (Ps. 89:14). Carrying out righteousness and judgment marked David (2 Sam. 8:15; 1 Chron. 18:14), Solomon (1 Kings 10:9; 2 Chron. 9:8) and Josiah (Jer. 22:15). A king will yet reign at Jerusalem, carrying out judgment and righteousness.

C E Stuart

How Close Does the Picture Come?

Commentators weigh the picture differently. One sees in the verse the closest a human king could come to Christ:

But David has now reached the place God called him to. "So David reigned over all Israel, and executed righteousness and justice among all his people." The prophet Isaiah says of the Branch out of Jesse's roots that righteousness will be the belt of His waist, and faithfulness the belt of His loins. And if David carried out judgment and justice, can any human picture come nearer to Him?

The Bible Treasury

Another writer measures the same reign against the kingdom still to come. He also points to the men David put in office.

Verses 15-18 give a summary of David's government in its righteousness and justice for all the people. Compared with other nations, his reign was far fairer than usual. Yet David was guilty of sad failure too, so he is only a faulty picture of the Lord Jesus, who will reign in perfect righteousness. … David also gave his sons places of some prominence in government, as "chief ministers," though some of them were not fit for such positions. … In the kingdom of the Lord Jesus no one will be favoured over another: all will be perfect justice and truth.

Leslie M. Grant

Summary

- Order. Verse 15 opens the last section of chapter 8. The story turns from David's wars to the running of his kingdom. His throne now stands established.

- Character. Judgment and justice are what David stands for. He gave them to all his people. This passage leaves his failures out, for the picture's sake.

- Reach. He ruled all Israel, one nation under one hand. That points ahead to the day his Greater Son gathers Israel and Judah for good.

- Shortfall. The same writers who admire the reign call David a faulty picture. Some of his officials were unfit for their posts. Justice with no favourites waits for another King.

- Fulfilment. The prophets carry the same words forward to the Branch from Jesse's roots. A King will yet reign at Jerusalem in judgment and righteousness.

2 Samuel 8:16

And Joab the son of Zeruiah was over the host; and Jehoshaphat the son of Ahilud was chronicler;

The chapter has just told of David's wars and victories. Now the account slows to a list of names and jobs, and we may ask what an army commander and a keeper of records have to do with the glory of David's throne.

Order as the Crown of the Kingdom

The list is not an extra note added after the wars. It comes at the right moment: with the enemies beaten, the account turns to how the kingdom was run.

Last of all, at the right moment, the account sets before us David's order and government, along with his own place as supreme ruler… It sets before us the priests, the scribes, and the various other officers, each in his place.

William Kelly

These verses also mark a break in the book. One commentator points to where else they appear, and to what is still missing here:

Verses 15 to 18 of our chapter, 2 Samuel 8, mark this division. We find these verses again, with some changes, in 2 Samuel 20:23-26. These verses present the order of David's reign. With 2 Samuel 8 the history of how the king was established as a type — a picture — of the Messiah really comes to an end. But Joab stands at the head of the army, and two high priests share the priesthood. This proves that the final order has not yet come, as it will come under Solomon's reign.

H. L. Rossier

A Portrait Deliberately Kept Clean

Readers who know how some of these men later behaved may find the list flattering. One commentator explains why the record here stops at the names:

As for detail here, we have only the names of the men put in charge of their various departments… We already know, and will see more fully as we read on, how different the actions of these men could be from the beauty of their names. But at this point the history is idealized on purpose, because Christ is before the mind of the Spirit. So the Spirit keeps His inspired writer from letting in anything that would spoil the picture.

Numerical Bible Notes

The same writers, tracing the whole list, draw out what it is a picture of — and admit plainly that the real history will read differently.

All these names, it is evident, speak as with one consent of righteous, wise, and beneficent government… As has been said, the history is carefully idealized that the type may not be marred. When we come to the details of actual history, things will be seen far otherwise; but the Spirit will not be hindered from presenting to us this view of a perfect kingdom, which Christ alone will actually consummate.

Numerical Bible Notes

What "Recorder" Means

The second job in the verse is harder to pin down than the first. One commentator weighs the word itself, and then the two names beside it:

The office meant here is not certain, but the word literally means "remembrancer." It might match, or include, the work of a historian, but it seems first of all to be that of the king's referee and counselor. Jehoshaphat means "Jehovah has judged," and fits his office well: Jehovah's judgment is the rule for guidance at all times. But Jehoshaphat is himself the son of Ahilud, which means "the brother," or "kin of the one born." Just as man is by nature the "offspring of God," so God is in that sense kin to the weak creature He has made. His judgments are the fruit of this kinship: He remembers this tie of His own making in all His dealings with them.

Numerical Bible Notes

The same work has a place among Christians today, though not as the keeping of our own story:

Our task is not so much to write down "our" history… but the "history" of our Lord's ways with His people, and His principles for His people today… Such a ministry is much needed today: to bring back to memory the principles of the "true David" and His ways with His people.

Michael Vogelsang

Joab: Where Commentators Differ

Not everyone reads the first name in the list the same way. Some take it typically, as a name meaning "Jehovah is Father" standing at the head of the kingdom's wars. Others weigh the man himself, and find in his high post the flaw in David's rule.

When it came to righteousness, David failed badly. He let Joab murder both Abner and Amasa and go unpunished. David's own sons Amnon and Absalom were guilty of grievous sins, and they also went unpunished… But Joab was an able military commander, and so useful to the state. This is far from the only time the sins of public men have been excused. But it is not righteousness.

W. W. Fereday

David's rule fell short of its own standard. That is why the picture points past David:

Compared with other nations, his reign was far fairer than is common. Yet David was guilty of sad failure too, so he is only a faulty type of the Lord Jesus, who will reign in perfect righteousness. Joab was David's commander in chief of the army, a soldier through and through, hard and determined, not the kind of servant the Lord Jesus would choose… In the kingdom of the Lord Jesus no one will be shown favoritism: all will be perfect justice and truth.

Leslie M. Grant

Summary

- Order — the verse finishes the conquest account: with the enemies beaten, each officer takes his own place under the king.

- Names — the record shows the kingdom at its best on purpose, because Christ is in view; the beauty of these names outran the men's conduct.

- Remembrancer — "recorder" means one who brings things to remembrance, and likely the king's adviser too. The same work today means recalling the Lord's ways, not our own history.

- Joab — David let Joab's murders go unpunished because he was useful to the state; useful is not the same as righteous.

- Result — David is only a faulty picture. The perfect kingdom, with no favouritism and perfect justice, waits for the reign of Christ.

2 Samuel 8:17

and Zadok the son of Ahitub, and Ahimelech the son of Abiathar, were the priests; and Seraiah was scribe;

The last verses of 2 Samuel 8 turn from the battlefield to the men who ran David's kingdom. Verse 17 names two priests and the royal secretary. The names raise a puzzle about who is who, and the order they stand in raises a bigger question about the kingdom they picture.

Where the List Belongs

These four verses close a section of the book. One writer points out that two details in the list show the order was not yet final.

Verses 15 to 18 of our chapter, 2 Samuel 8, mark this division. We find these verses again, with some changes, in 2 Samuel 20:23-26. They present the order of David's reign, and 2 Samuel 8 ends the history, strictly speaking, of how the king was set up as a type of the Messiah. But Joab still stands at the head of the army, and two high priests still carry out the priesthood. These things prove that the final order has not yet come, as it will under Solomon's reign.

H. L. Rossier

The Puzzle of the Names

This verse calls Ahimelech the son of Abiathar. Commentators differ on how to read that, and one summary sets out the options.

There is a difficulty in 2 Samuel 8:17 and 1 Chronicles 18:16, where "Ahimelech (or Abimelech) the son of Abiathar" is named as priest with Zadok in David's time. Some think the names should be swapped, and that Abiathar is meant. But this Ahimelech may have been a son of the Abiathar named above. It was not at all unusual to name a son after his grandfather, and for some reason these passages name him as priest instead of his father.

Morrish Bible Dictionary

Another explanation is that both men carried both names:

It is not an unlikely explanation that the priest who helped David carried the two names Ahimelech and Abiathar, and that his son, who escaped the massacre at Nob, carried the same two names... People have often noticed many cases of double names in the Old Testament: Reuel, Jethro, and Hobab; Esau and Edom; Benjamin and Benoni... But few have noticed that the priests in particular seem to have carried double names, and that father and son were often called by the same names.

The Bible Treasury

Why Zadok Is Named First

Zadok did not yet hold the leading place in David's reign. One writer explains why the list still puts him first.

Eleazar's line is given the first place in Zadok. That fact shows this is an ideal picture, for Zadok only gained the first place at the start of Solomon's reign, after Abiathar had joined Adonijah's conspiracy. Yet for the type Zadok had to come first. As the "righteous" one, he reminds us, from this angle, of the Melchizedek character of priesthood in Christ.

Numerical Bible Notes

The Scribe

The ESV calls Seraiah the "secretary," while older translations say "scribe." One dictionary explains both uses of the word.

In the Old Testament this word is used for the officer who handled the letters for a king, the army, and so on — what we now call a secretary. 2 Samuel 8:17... It is also used for those who wrote and explained the Scriptures. So Ezra was a scribe skilled in the law, even a scribe of the words of the commandments of the Lord, though he was also a priest.

Morrish Bible Dictionary

The secretary's name says something too: Seraiah means "Jah rules" (Numerical Bible Notes).

A Kingdom Sketched, Not Yet Seen

Taken together, the names of these officials point one way. One writer admits that the actual history did not match that picture.

All these names clearly speak with one voice of righteous, wise, and kind government... As has been said, the history is carefully idealized so that the type is not spoiled. When we come to the details of the actual history, things look very different. But nothing will stop the Spirit from setting this view of a perfect kingdom before us, and Christ alone will bring it to completion.

Numerical Bible Notes

These Offices Today

One writer applies both roles — priest and scribe — to Christian service today. First, the priesthood:

Even though the priests are not mentioned first in these lists, we want to begin with them, because priesthood is surely one of the most important parts of service. It is also a service open to every believer, which could not be said of all the other kinds of service we are going to look at.

Michael Vogelsang

And of the scribe's work: "It is not so much our task to write down 'our' history... but the 'history' of our Lord's ways with His people and His principles for His people today" (Michael Vogelsang).

Summary

- Seam. Verses 15–18 close the account of David's rise as king. The same list comes back, changed, in 2 Samuel 20.

- Puzzle. The verse calls Ahimelech the son of Abiathar. Commentators differ: swapped names, a son named after his grandfather, or double names in priestly families.

- Order. Zadok stands first before he held first place, because the picture points past David to Christ.

- Office. The scribe is the king's secretary, and his name, Seraiah, means "Jah rules."

- Outcome. The list pictures a righteous government David never fully gave. Christ alone will complete it, and priesthood is service open to every believer now.

2 Samuel 8:18

and Benaiah the son of Jehoiada was over the Cherethites and the Pelethites; and David's sons were chief rulers.

This verse ends the list of officers in David's government. It names the captain of the royal guard, and then the king's own sons. Two questions come with it. Who were the Cherethites and Pelethites? And why does the Hebrew call David's sons by the word for priests?

The men who guarded the king

The guard named here was not made up of Israelites. One writer points that out:

The Cherethites and Pelethites serve as King David's bodyguards, foreigners like the Gittites.

William Kelly

Names that describe a kingdom

Benaiah's name comes with his father's name, Jehoiada. Both mean something, and one commentator reads the whole list of officers as a picture of government:

Fifth in the list comes Benaiah the son of Jehoiada, set over the Cherethites and Pelethites — or, as Gesenius says, probably "executioners and couriers." Here again the names of God stand out. Benaiah means "Jah has built"; Jehoiada means "Jehovah knows." Do these names show us that His purpose to build up and bless governs how judgment is carried out? And that this building up grows out of His own perfect knowledge? Clearly all these names agree in speaking of a government that is righteous, wise, and good.

Numerical Bible Notes

Sons called priests

The ESV calls David's sons priests. Other translations say "chief rulers." One writer explains the problem:

This brings us back to where we started, because the word used here is usually translated "priest." But these men (for example, David's sons) were clearly not from the priestly tribe. They had another job at the palace. The German Elberfelder translation gives the marginal rendering "intimate counsellor."

Michael Vogelsang

The same writer records how rare this usage is, and one suggested reason for it:

The Hebrew word for a priest is "cohen" all through the Old Testament, except in three places. In 1 Kings 4:5 the Authorised Version translates it "principal officer"; in 2 Samuel 8:18 and 20:26 it translates it "chief rulers" (margin, "Princes"). "Possibly the way the word is used in these passages is a leftover of its first meaning, from a time when one man held both the priestly and the kingly office" (R. B. Girdlestone, Synonyms of the Old Testament).

Michael Vogelsang

A picture of a kingdom yet to come

The list of officers also looks ahead. One writer sees in it a sketch of a greater reign:

Benaiah had charge of the Cherethites and Pelethites; these two names mean "executioners and runners," while David's sons were also ruling with him. Order ruled in everything. When that true kingdom is set up on earth, there will also be men who rule under the King, with charge over five or ten cities (Luke 19:17-18). David's sons who ruled with him may represent, as a type, believers who are sons of God in Christ and fellow heirs with Him.

Arno Clemens Gaebelein

Why the picture stops short

Yet David's reign falls short of what it pictures. One writer shows where:

These verses show the order of David's reign. 2 Samuel 8 closes the account of how the king was established as a type of the Messiah. But Joab still stands at the head of the army, and two high priests still serve. That proves the final order has not yet come, as it will under Solomon's reign.

H. L. Rossier

The list of appointments has a weak point of its own:

David also gave his own sons prominent places in government, as "chief ministers," though some of them were not fit for such posts. Samuel's sons did not walk in Samuel's ways (1 Sam. 8:3), and Absalom certainly did not walk in David's ways (2 Sam. 13:28-29). In the kingdom of the Lord Jesus there will be no favoritism shown: all will be perfect justice and truth.

Leslie M. Grant

The guard's work today

A bodyguard protects one person. One writer sees the same task for us now:

Doesn't this remind us that even today, perhaps more than ever, we need men of God who take special care to "guard" the holy person of our Lord? They make sure that all the basic truths about His person are held fast and defended: His eternal sonship, His virgin birth, His sinless humanity, His divine person, His atoning death, His resurrection and ascension, His second coming, and more.

Michael Vogelsang

Summary

- Foreigners. The Cherethites and Pelethites were David's bodyguards. They were outsiders, like the Gittites, yet the king trusted them with his life.

- Names. Benaiah means "Jah has built." Jehoiada means "Jehovah knows." The whole list of officers speaks of government that is righteous, wise, and good.

- Priests. The word used of David's sons is the ordinary word for priest, though they were not of the priestly tribe — hence renderings like "chief rulers" and "intimate counsellor."

- Order. The king's sons ruled under him. That sketches the coming kingdom, where those who serve the King will have charge over cities.

- Shortfall. Joab still led the army, two high priests served, and some of the sons were unfit. The picture stops short. In the kingdom of the Lord Jesus there will be no favoritism, only perfect justice and truth.