2 Samuel 23:8–39

2 Samuel 23:8 · Darby

These are the names of the mighty men whom David had Joseb-Bassebeth, Tachkemonite the chief of the captains he was Adino the Eznite; he [fought] against eight hundred, slain [by him] at one time.

This verse opens the roll call of David's mighty men. It gives a name that is hard to read, a spear, and eight hundred enemies killed at one time — details God chose to keep.

A name that is hard to read

The same man appears in 1 Chronicles under a different name. One reference work lists the options without forcing a solution:

In 1 Chronicles 11:11 the chief of the captains is Jashobeam a Hachmonite, or son of Hachmoni. It is difficult to reconcile the two passages. Some think that Jashobeam and Josheb-basshebeth are the same name, varied by a copyist. Others take the passage in Samuel to be incorrect, and make "Adino the Eznite" not a proper name but 'he swung his spear.' The two passages may refer to different persons. Note that Jashobeam is said to have killed three hundred men, and Adino killed eight hundred. Jashobeam is also named when David came into power, and Adino in connection with 'the last words of David.' So Jashobeam may have died, and Adino become chief in his place.

Modernised from Morrish Bible DictionaryOriginal wording

Another writer gives up on settling the wording and looks for help elsewhere:

Out of all this it is hard to gather any meaning we can fully rely on. The spiritual meaning is what should give us the largest help among difficulties as great and as many as we find here.

Modernised from Numerical Bible NotesOriginal wording

Eight hundred at one time

He holds first place for more than the size of the victory. He also refused to stop:

The first, Josheb-basshebeth, had brandished his spear against eight hundred men. He killed them at one time. He did not stop until there were no opponents left. Hence his pre-eminence, for his name translated means: "He who sits in the first place."

Modernised from H. L. RossierOriginal wording

Sitting in the seat

The name can also be read as "one sitting in the seat." That reading points to where a believer's strength in conflict comes from:

The picture here is of Christian warfare at its highest. For an account of that warfare we must go to the letter to the Ephesians. First, Ephesians brings us into the place itself — the very place of the conflict. God "has raised us up" with Christ from the dead, says the apostle, and "seated us with him in the heavenly places in Christ Jesus." This is beyond doubt the "sitting in the seat" that the highest warfare, the Christian warfare, requires. Keeping this place — abiding in it — is the great necessity for spiritual triumph. The place every believer has. The practical abiding in it — how little is this to be seen!

Modernised from Numerical Bible NotesOriginal wording

Strength borrowed from the king

One writer traces their staying power back to a single fact:

Where did their perseverance come from? Alone, they would have weakened. But all three were "with David" and under his eyes during the fight. He inspired them with courage and patience in their efforts.

Modernised from H. L. RossierOriginal wording

Whose names are written

David's army commander does not appear on this list at all:

Joab held the top position as head of the army until the end of David's reign. Yet the list of David's mighty men leaves him out. He may have performed more brilliant actions than all the others. He showed much courage, and even a certain outward devotion to the king. But these qualities in themselves do not give anyone a place in God's register. What marked David's mighty men was this: grace had joined them to the Lord's anointed. Joab served David for his own interest, and his actions never sprang from fellowship with his head. His name is passed over in silence.

Modernised from H. L. RossierOriginal wording

Every detail remembered

The record is exact: the weapon, the number, the one occasion. That exactness carries a promise:

His service stands out in all its worth, and the detail is exact. The record gives the exact character of his victories. And no doubt one day we will see this: many servants of Christ have defeated many hard-hearted enemies of God by the power of the gospel. They have brought them as willing captives to the feet of Jesus. All this service and its detail will not be forgotten.

Modernised from H H SnellOriginal wording

Summary

- Seated first — the chief man's name means "he who sits in the first place." He kept fighting until no enemy was left.

- Still seated — read as "sitting in the seat," the name points to the place God has already given every believer. Holding it is what makes victory possible.

- With David — the three did not weaken because they fought under the king's eye. Nearness to him was the source of their courage.

- Not brilliance — Joab may have outdone them all, yet the list leaves him out. Success without fellowship with the king earns no place in God's register.

- Written down — the weapon, the number, the one occasion. God keeps the details of service, and they will not be forgotten.

2 Samuel 23:9 · Darby

And after him, Eleazar the son of Dodo the son of an Ahohite he was one of the three mighty men with David, when they had defied the Philistines that were there gathered together to battle, and the men of Israel were gone up.

Commentary for this verse has not been generated yet.

2 Samuel 23:10 · Darby

He arose and smote the Philistines until his hand was weary, and his hand clave to the sword; and Jehovah wrought a great deliverance that day; and the people returned after him only to spoil.

David's list of mighty men gives one sentence to Eleazar. He kept fighting after everyone else had left the field. The verse holds three things worth weighing: a hand worn out, a hand that could not let go, and a victory that goes to the Lord, not the swordsman.

Standing when the rest have gone

Verse 9 says the men of Israel had gone away. He stood with no one beside him. One commentator notes what God does with faith like that.

Eleazar holds the second place of honour (vv. 9-10). He did not retreat when the rest of Israel retreated. He carried on the battle with the Philistines alone, and for so long that his hand stuck to the sword he was using. By his energy of faith the Lord accomplished a great victory. The Lord honours the faith of a man who will not let the enemy frighten him, even when no one else stands with him.

Modernised from Leslie M. GrantOriginal wording

A weary hand is still a fighting hand

One writer points to where Eleazar's confidence came from, and to where his strength ran out.

He expected no help from the men of Israel, because he did not count on man's strength. Being with David (v. 9) was enough for him to defy the Philistines. He struck them and did not stop until "his hand was weary" (v. 10). There may be limits in the fight of faith, because God uses imperfect instruments, and they can reach the limits of their strength. But Eleazar kept on until "his hand clung to the sword" (v. 10). It was impossible to separate him from the weapon he was using. May Eleazar's victory be ours as well! Our weapons are not the weapons of the flesh; we have the sword of the Spirit, which is the Word of God. Let us use it in such a way that we are, so to speak, one with it even after the battle.

Modernised from H. L. RossierOriginal wording

The sword that leaves its mark

A hand fused to a hilt also pictures what long use of Scripture does to a person.

The same is true of any faithful and devoted follower of Christ. Through long experience in the ways of God, and by sticking closely to His word, he answers the arguments of men and defeats the enemies of God's people. The more he uses "the sword of the Spirit, which is the word of God," the more sure he is that it is enough for every situation. His delight in the law of the Lord will match his desire for it. He feels its worth more each day. His heart keeps the mark of the word of God, just as the hilt of the sword left its mark in Eleazar's hand.

Modernised from The Christian's FriendOriginal wording

The victory is credited elsewhere

The verse does not end with the swordsman. The Lord works the victory, and Eleazar's own name points the same way.

His very name, "God is help," turns from the man to God. What could he do on his own against the enemy's whole army? His arm grows weary, but the weary hand clings to the good sword. We no longer see the weak arm of a man. We see the power of God behind that weary arm, carving out victory with that sword. The man has become one with the sword, and God can use a man like that.

Modernised from Frederick W GrantOriginal wording

The men came back only for the spoil

The last line of the verse belongs to the men who left. They came back for the spoil once the fighting was won, and one writer sees the same pattern now.

The Spirit records his persevering faithfulness. We are told that he "struck down the Philistines until his hand was weary, and his hand clung to the sword." It is also noted that he won a great victory, and that because of him others came after only "to strip the slain." So it is now. At times almost all have turned away from standing for the truth. Then some brave servant of the Lord has stood against the enemy, his hand clinging to the sword of the Spirit, which is the word of God, and has won a great victory. Many a child of God coming after him has reaped precious fruit from it.

Modernised from H H SnellOriginal wording

A later man who fought alone

The same picture appears again in Paul — deserted and writing from prison.

There is no greater sight than Paul — deserted, alone, in prison — keeping by grace his confidence in the Lord and in the truth entrusted to him. Though faint, he was still pressing on; and though he was weary in his lonely fight, his hand still clung to his sword (see 2 Sam. 23:10).

Modernised from Edward DennettOriginal wording

Summary

- Alone. The men of Israel had gone away. God honours the faith of a man who will not fear the enemy, even when nobody stands with him.

- Weary. The fight of faith has limits. God uses imperfect people, and their strength does run out.

- Welded. His hand clung to the sword. He kept on until nothing could part him from it, and the hilt left its mark in his hand.

- Won. The credit goes past the swordsman to God — even his name, "God is help," turns attention away from the man.

- Wealth. Others returned only to strip the slain. Later believers still reap fruit from ground won by those who stayed and fought.

2 Samuel 23:11 · Darby

And after him, Shammah the son of Agee the Hararite the Philistines were gathered into a troop, and there was there a plot of ground full of lentils, and the people had fled before the Philistines;

Tucked into the roll of David's warriors is a farmer's field. The Philistines massed for a raid and Israel's army ran. One man stayed, alone in a bean patch. Why was that small piece of ground worth a life?

The man and the crop

The verse names a soldier no one would otherwise know, and a crop no one would think to fight over. Lentils were cheap, everyday food.

The small seeds of different kinds of vetch used for food. When ground, the meal can be made into a tasty red stew. Genesis 25:34; 2 Samuel 23:11. Lentils were part of the food supply for David and his followers when Absalom rebelled. 2 Samuel 17:28. They were also used in a time of scarcity, and among the poor, as an ingredient in their bread.

Modernised from Morrish Bible DictionaryOriginal wording

Why the field mattered

The size of the prize is the point — a scrap of land, and the food growing on it.

The thing they were fighting over was "a plot of ground full of lentils." It was a very small part of the inheritance that God had given Israel, but it held food for the people. The enemy was trying to take the field and its crop away from them. Shammah stood in the middle of the field and kept it for God's people. This deed speaks to our consciences. Our inheritance and our "plot of ground" are heavenly. We must defend them, and our heavenly food too — the Word which God has entrusted to us. God's people run from the enemy like cowards, admitting to their shame that unbelief has the right to treat the Word of God as nothing.

Modernised from H. L. RossierOriginal wording

Holding ground, not taking it

Shammah's deed differs from the two exploits just before it. Adino attacked; Eleazar fought for spoil; Shammah refused to move.

In the conflicts of the Lord's people we see these different forms of service. There are times when the Lord calls for an attack on the forces of evil, as with Adino. There are times when there is spoil to be gained through conflict, as on the day of Eleazar's victory. And there are times when we are called to stand our ground and act on the defensive, as on the day of Shammah's mighty deed.

Modernised from Hamilton SmithOriginal wording

When everyone else has gone

The people fled; he stayed. Writers make this faithfulness at its hardest — staying where others have given up.

Shammah "remained behind." Shammah "endured." There are perhaps few things harder than to endure. When others have given up, staying behind is not easy. I suppose Shammah's friends and fellow soldiers told him it was hopeless. They would say that staying where he was meant certain death, and that a field of lentils was not worth remaining behind for. And you and I have been given a field of lentils to defend, and our Lord has placed us in the middle of it. Our field of lentils may be our home, or the office, or the shop. It may be the small, weak company of two or three gathered to our Lord's own Name, that others have despised and left for something bigger and more attractive.

Modernised from G C WillisOriginal wording

A New Testament Shammah

Writers trace the same pattern into the New Testament: the others give way, and one man holds the ground alone.

Peter had failed. Even Barnabas, who had stood so bravely with Paul in Jerusalem, had turned aside through fear. Paul is left to fight the battle single-handed. It reminds us of Shammah in 2 Samuel 23:11-12. All the people of Israel were afraid and ran away as the Philistines came. But Shammah stood in a piece of ground full of lentils, and he defended it all alone, single-handed: "and the Lord worked a great victory."

Modernised from G C WillisOriginal wording

Whose victory it was

Shammah was defending David's claim, not his own patch. And when the record honours what he did, it hands the credit elsewhere.

Shammah's service could not go unnoticed either. It was only a piece of ground full of lentils that he defended and secured for David, yet he was determined not to yield even that right of David to the enemy. It is worth noticing that the courage and faithfulness of this man came out at a time when the people, instead of standing firm, actually "fled from the Philistines." But in both verse 10 and verse 12 the Holy Spirit carefully records that "the Lord worked a great victory." God accepts the brave deeds of His servants and puts them to their account. Yet it is all done in His strength, and by the grace He gives, so that all the glory is due to Him.

Modernised from H H SnellOriginal wording

Summary

- Small ground. A lentil patch was a scrap of Israel's inheritance — but it was the people's food, and the enemy wanted it.

- Stand, don't chase. Attacking, gaining spoil, and holding ground are all service. Shammah's was defence.

- Stay put. The people fled; the whole exploit was that one man remained behind and endured.

- Your patch. Home, work, or a small gathering of believers may be the ground the Lord has set you in to defend.

- His victory. Shammah held David's ground, and the record gives the Lord the great victory. The strength was His; the glory is His.

2 Samuel 23:12 · Darby

and he stood in the midst of the plot and delivered it, and smote the Philistines, and Jehovah wrought a great deliverance.

Shammah was one of David's mighty men, and the army around him had just fled from the Philistines. He stayed in a small field of lentils and held it, yet the verse gives the great victory to the LORD, not to him.

The Small Plot and Its Food

A field of lentils looks too small to fight over. Its size was not what mattered.

The object they were contesting was "a plot of ground full of lentils," a very little part of the inheritance that God had given Israel, but one containing food for the people. The enemy was seeking to deprive them of the field and its crop. Shammah stood in the middle of the field and preserved it for God's people. This deed speaks to our consciences. Our inheritance and our "plot of ground" are heavenly, and we must defend them as well as our heavenly food, the Word which God has entrusted to us.

Modernised from H. L. RossierOriginal wording

The same reading is applied directly to the life of a church:

This illustrates the faithfulness of a believer in fighting to keep the food of the word of God from being stolen from God's people. May we stand firmly and decidedly against anything that will deprive the saints of God of the food of His word that is so necessary for their sustenance.

Modernised from Leslie M. GrantOriginal wording

Standing as a Form of Service

Not every battle calls for an advance. One writer compares Shammah's stand with the work of the two men named before him.

In the conflicts of the Lord's people we see these different forms of service. There are times when the Lord calls for an attack upon the forces of evil, as in the case of Adino. There are occasions when there is spoil to be gained through conflict, as in the day of Eleazar's victory. So too there are times when the Lord calls us to stand our ground, and act on the defensive, as it was in the day of Shammah's mighty deed.

Modernised from Hamilton SmithOriginal wording

Holding ground brings a danger of its own:

Shammah, one of David's mighty men, stood in the middle of a plot of lentils and delivered it out of the enemy's hand. He withstood the enemy, secured the plot, part of God's inheritance given to His people, and stood there in possession. In this warfare there is no chance to take off our armour; our foes are cunning and watchful... if we overcome him in the Lord's strength, we should watch in case he tries to win back from us the ground he was forced to give up.

Modernised from An Outline of Sound WordsOriginal wording

The Cost of Staying

One writer imagines what Shammah's friends said as they left him there.

Shammah "remained behind." Shammah "endured." There are, perhaps, few things more difficult than to endure. When others have given up, to remain behind, is not easy. I suppose Shammah's friends and fellow-soldiers told him it was hopeless, it was certain death to stay where he was, and anyway for a field of lentils it was not worth remaining behind... And you and I have been given a field of lentils to defend... Our field of lentils may be our home, or the office, or the shop. It may be the small, weak gathering of two or three in our Lord's own Name, which others have looked down on and left for something greater and more attractive.

Modernised from G C WillisOriginal wording

A Field Worth Contending For

The crop itself carries a lesson. One writer sets Shammah's watchfulness beside two later calls to guard the truth.

The vigilance of Shammah in defending the piece of ground full of lentils recalls the anxiety of the apostle of the Gentiles that the truth of the gospel should remain with them, and his zeal in defending it (Gal. 2:5). It recalls the warning of Jude also to believers, "to contend for the faith that was once for all delivered to the saints," a needful warning even in that day; for the enemy was already in the field. And is there not a voice for us in this too? What "the piece of ground" produced in such quantity, lentils, is the same food that Esau ate when he was faint. He then revived, "rose up, and went his way" (Gen. 25:30).

Modernised from The Christian's FriendOriginal wording

The LORD's Great Victory

The verse ends with another name. One writer points out where the same words appear two verses earlier.

It is worth noting also that the courage and faithfulness of this man came out at a time when the people, instead of standing true, actually "fled from the Philistines." But in both verse 10 and verse 12 the Holy Spirit carefully notices that "the LORD worked a great victory." God does accept the brave deeds of His servants, and puts them to their account. Yet it is all done in His strength, and by the grace He gives, so that to Him all the glory is due.

Modernised from H H SnellOriginal wording

Another sees the added name as the real headline of the whole list:

After this a name is added of far more importance than all the rest, and with it the secret of the warrior's success: "And the LORD worked a great victory." ... It also shows how He identifies Himself with His servants, and lends His strength to those who fight His battles against the enemy.

Modernised from The Christian's FriendOriginal wording

Summary

- The ground — a small plot, but part of God's inheritance and the food of His people; that is why the enemy wanted it.

- The stand — not attack, not spoil, but holding ground; and once you hold it, guard it, because the enemy comes back.

- The loneliness — the crowd fled first. Staying behind when others call it hopeless is the hardest courage of all.

- The application — your field may look ordinary: a home, a workplace, a small gathering, the truth handed to you. Defend it anyway.

- The credit — the LORD worked the victory, not Shammah. God counts the servant's brave deeds, but He supplies the strength, so the glory goes back to Him.

2 Samuel 23:13 · Darby

And three of the thirty chiefs went down, and came to David in the harvest time to the cave of Adullam, when the troop of the Philistines was encamped in the valley of Rephaim.

Three of David's thirty chief men leave the harvest behind and go down to a cave, with a Philistine force camped nearby. Why trade the richest season of the year for a hiding place with a rejected man?

The Man in the Cave

David had killed Goliath and saved Israel. Now he was disowned and hiding, and only a few men still wanted to be where he was.

David was in the cave of Adullam at this time, rejected and disowned, though he was the conqueror of Goliath and the deliverer of Israel. There are a few, and only a few, who care so much for David that they will tie their future to his. And they do so at a moment when, at least to the eye, everything is as dark as it can be. How does it show? Where he is, there they will be. David is the one they are thinking of; they want to be near him. They refuse everything except what connects them with him. If they are to share his triumphs and honours later, they will share his reproach and shame now.

Modernised from W T TurpinOriginal wording

Harvest Time

The timing matters. They came when the fields were full.

These three mighty men "came about harvest time to David at the cave of Adullam" (13). It seems as if they left the world in the day of its plenty, to identify themselves with David in the day of his poverty and reproach.

Modernised from Hamilton SmithOriginal wording

The Cave Made the Men

The cave was not a place of disgrace for those who went there. It was where greatness was produced — and one famous name is missing from the record.

David is now the outcast, hidden in the cave of Adullam. Will Jonathan join him there and own him in the day of his rejection? Sadly, Jonathan's name is missing from the record of those whose loyalty and devotion drew them to David in the cave! ... The men who gathered to David in Adullam were, it is true, a mixed group. But they gathered to the right person, and in the right place, as the outcome proved. The cave gave birth to the mighty men of renown who are recorded in 2 Samuel 23.

Modernised from The Bible TreasuryOriginal wording

David did more than gather men there. He remade them.

David is able to create, to form, the most wretched beings in his own image. The reflection of his moral beauty falls on those who have nothing to bring him but their misery. In the dark cave of Adullam the light shining out from David shines on these four hundred men around him. In the day of glory, which is already approaching, every eye will recognize and every mouth will acclaim what grace made of them in the day of trouble.

Modernised from H. L. RossierOriginal wording

Why These Three Are Not Named

The verse counts these three men but never names them. One writer finds a reason for that silence.

Why this remarkable leaving out of their names in the account of their exploit? It is because here it is no longer a matter of energy and perseverance, but one of the devotion of faith. And this devotion springs naturally from the hearts of servants who know and value their Master. By its very nature devotion is something obscure. What man has the right to boast of devotion? ... Danger did not frighten them when they went to draw water from the well at Bethlehem. The one they loved was thirsty here at harvest time. ... God records this devotion in His book.

Modernised from H. L. RossierOriginal wording

Being There Is What Made the Rest Possible

Coming down to the cave was not the famous act — but it was the act that made the famous one possible. Only men inside the cave could hear what David said next, and what he said was not an order.

It is not a command that demands obedience; it is not a call for service; it is only the expression of his longing desire. And yet this spoken desire calls out this devoted act of love in a way that no command would have done.

Modernised from Hamilton SmithOriginal wording

The Enemy Stood in Between

The Philistines in verse 13 are not scenery. They held the ground the three would have to cross.

The garrison of the Philistines had taken possession of Bethlehem while David was in exile in the cave of Adullam. Saul did not have the energy to drive the Philistines out of Bethlehem, which means the house of bread. David expressed the longing for a drink of water from the well of Bethlehem.

Modernised from Leslie M. GrantOriginal wording

Summary

- Person. They went down because David had eclipsed everything else in their affections. The pull was a person, not a cause.

- Price. They came at harvest, leaving the world in its season of plenty to share a rejected man's poverty and reproach.

- Place. The cave looked like the end of a career. It became the birthplace of the mighty men. Jonathan stayed away, and his name is missing from the list.

- Position. Standing near David let them hear a longing he never turned into a command. Devotion answers a desire; duty waits for an order.

- Proof. The record leaves their names out, because devotion by its nature is obscure. But God writes it in His book, and the day of glory will acclaim what the cave produced.

2 Samuel 23:14 · Darby

And David was then in the stronghold; and the Philistines' garrison was then at Bethlehem.

This verse fixes two points on a map. Israel's anointed king is shut up in a stronghold, while enemy troops hold the town he was born in.

The king in the stronghold

Israel had a king on the throne, and he was not David. Every man in the land had to choose between the two.

The choice lay between Saul and David — Saul a picture of the natural, fleshly man, and David a picture of Christ. Saul is in the palace. He sits on the throne. The kingdom is at his feet. David is in the cave of Adullam. A band of men has gathered round him. Affection draws them, and they are devoted to his cause.

Modernised from A J PollockOriginal wording

Rejection is not the same as failure.

David was in the cave of Adullam, rejected and disowned at this time, though he was the conqueror of Goliath and the deliverer of Israel. There are a few, and only a few, who care so much for David that they will link their destiny with his. And they do it at a moment when, to all appearances, everything is as dark as it can be.

Modernised from W T TurpinOriginal wording

Bethlehem under a garrison

The second half of the verse reports an occupation. Enemy soldiers held David's home town, and the king on the throne left them there.

The garrison of the Philistines had taken possession of Bethlehem while David was in exile in the cave of Adullam. Saul did not have the energy to drive the Philistines out of Bethlehem (the house of bread). And David expressed the longing for a drink of water from the well of Bethlehem.

Modernised from Leslie M. GrantOriginal wording

The town's name matters as much as its position.

David was anointed in the house of Jesse the Bethlehemite. So Bethlehem was apparently the place of David's birth. This explains why Luke 2:11 calls it the city of David. It was also the birthplace of Jesus. Though the town was little among the clans of Judah, that fitted His humiliation better. Bethlehem means "house of bread." It is a very fitting name for a place from which the Saviour should come as a man — He who was the living bread that came down from heaven.

Modernised from Morrish Bible DictionaryOriginal wording

Who came down to the hold

Reaching David cost these men something.

These three mighty men came "about harvest time to David at the cave of Adullam." It seems they left the world in the day of its plenty. They chose to identify themselves with David in the day of his poverty and reproach.

Modernised from Hamilton SmithOriginal wording

Their aim was not a cause but a person.

They want to be with him. They refuse everything except what connects them with him. And while all around outside is dark, they within will keep him company. They are in the place to know his wishes. Had they not been in the cave with David, they never would have heard his longing for water from the well of Bethlehem.

Modernised from W T TurpinOriginal wording

An army standing in the way

Put the two halves of the verse together and an obstacle appears. The water David wanted lay behind enemy lines.

The Philistine army camped in tight ranks between the hold and the well. These three devoted men did not count the cost of the simple act of satisfying David's desire. They wanted to please David. Nothing pleased them so much as pleasing him.

Modernised from A J PollockOriginal wording

The same choice today

Commentators see David's rejection as a picture of Christ's place today.

Next we find him in the cave of Adullam, a name meaning a witness. Here a strange company gathers around the rejected king. It was made up of 400 men, and he became their captain. Some of them were in distress, others in debt, and others discontented. It was a blessed scene, pointing forward to Him to whom all can come who are in distress, who feel their debt, their sinfulness, their sorrow and their need. And a greater One than David is here. Our Lord is rejected, but those who admit their need acknowledge Him, and He has power to meet it all in the riches of His grace. They and their captain, the Lord's anointed, were outside the camp. Such a place there is today for all who know Him, who is rejected by men. "Therefore let us go to Him outside the camp and bear the reproach He endured" (Hebrews 13:13). And later those who had gathered around David in the cave, and suffered with him, were remembered in a special way (2 Samuel 23:8-39). "If we endure, we will also reign with him" (2 Timothy 2:12).

Modernised from Arno Clemens GaebeleinOriginal wording

Summary

- Stronghold — David is the anointed king, yet he hides while another man sits on the throne. Every Israelite had to choose between the two.

- Garrison — enemy troops hold Bethlehem, the "house of bread." It is David's birthplace, and later the birthplace of Jesus. Saul had no energy to drive them out.

- Nearness — three men came down to the hold at harvest time and traded plenty for reproach. Being inside is how they heard what David longed for.

- Cost — the Philistine army stood between the hold and the well. The three did not count the cost, because nothing pleased them like pleasing David.

- Crown — the rejected king still gathers the distressed today. Those who suffered with David in the cave are the names honoured in this chapter.

2 Samuel 23:15 · Darby

And David longed, and said, Oh that one would give me to drink of the water of the well of Bethlehem, which is in the gate!

Philistine troops hold Bethlehem, the town David grew up in. David himself is shut up in a stronghold. A memory of the water by the town gate draws a sigh out of him. Three men overhear it. What they do with a sigh, not an order, makes this small scene one of Scripture's clearest pictures of devotion.

A wish, not an order

Nothing in David's words obliges anyone. That is exactly the force of them.

David was in the stronghold, while a Philistine garrison held the place of David's early home. David thinks of the well by the gate of Bethlehem. He had no doubt often drawn water from it in his youth, and now he expresses his longing for a refreshing drink from that well. "Oh," he says, "that someone would give me water to drink from the well of Bethlehem that is by the gate!" It is no command that needs obedience. It is no call for service. It is only the expression of his longing desire. And yet this expressed desire calls forth this devoted act of love in a way that no command would have done.

Modernised from Hamilton SmithOriginal wording

The wish hung in the air, addressed to no one.

There was no command issued. No one in particular was singled out and commissioned to go. There was the simple utterance of the desire, and this it was which gave the opportunity for genuine affection and true devotedness.

Modernised from C. H. MackintoshOriginal wording

Heard because they were close

These men wanted David himself — his shame now, not just his honours later.

David was in the cave of Adullam, rejected and disowned at this time, though he was the conqueror of Goliath and the deliverer of Israel. David is the one they are thinking of; they want to be with him. If they are to share his triumphs and honours later on, they will share his reproach and shame now... If they had not been in the cave with David, they never would have heard his longing for water from the well of Bethlehem. And they never would have been in Adullam at all, if David had not overshadowed everything else in their affections.

Modernised from W. T. TurpinOriginal wording

Service with no one else in view

The earlier victories in this chapter had the good of the whole nation in view. This one did not.

When we come to the three mighty men who drew the water from the well, we have a very different form of service. If the victories we have considered had the blessing of the people in view, this touching act of service was wholly for the benefit of the King.

Modernised from Hamilton SmithOriginal wording

Love that does not calculate

A cooler head would have pointed out that the errand was unnecessary.

Prudence would have said that water taken from some other spot would have satisfied David's thirst just as well. That would have been quite true. Water is water wherever it is, and there was no special virtue in the water of the well of Bethlehem.

Modernised from A. J. PollockOriginal wording

Why he would not drink it

David would not drink it. That refusal was not ingratitude.

This is a refreshing picture of the faith that delights to please the Lord in a spirit of willing self-sacrifice. David, however, valued their devotion more than he wanted the water. He judged that he was not worthy of such great devotion. So he poured the water out as a drink offering to God, who alone is worthy of such sacrifices.

Modernised from Leslie M. GrantOriginal wording

Unnamed in the act, remembered forever

Scripture leaves the three unnamed in this deed.

Why this remarkable omission of their names in the account of their exploit? It is because here it is no longer a matter of energy and perseverance, but one of the devotion of faith. This devotion flows naturally from the hearts of servants who know and appreciate their Master. By its very nature devotion is something obscure. What man has the right to boast of devotion?

Modernised from H. L. RossierOriginal wording

Yet the deed itself was not lost.

Little did those three mighty men imagine that God would record their act of loving devotion on the eternal page of inspiration, for millions to read there. They never thought of this... Had they acted to get a name or place for themselves, it would have robbed their act of all its charm.

Modernised from C. H. MackintoshOriginal wording

The question it leaves with us

One writer turns from David to the Lord Himself.

The three mightiest needed no command! David desired the water, that was enough! Is there not something He desires from our hearts? Should we not stand with those who share His rejection? That may mean being in "the cave," to use the picture — the place where His mighty men learn in His company what He longs for.

Modernised from H. J. VineOriginal wording

Summary

- Nearness first. The three heard David's wish only because they had already joined him in the cave. Distance would have kept them ignorant of it.

- Desire, not duty. David gave no order. A wish spoken aloud drew out what a command never could have.

- Devotion, not calculation. Other water would have quenched his thirst just as well; they wanted the well he named, whatever it cost.

- Poured out, not consumed. David judged the gift too costly for himself and gave it to the Lord as a drink offering.

- Hidden, yet kept. They sought no name, and the record leaves their names out — but the deed itself stands written for millions to read.

2 Samuel 23:16 · Darby

And the three mighty men broke through the camp of the Philistines, and drew water out of the well of Bethlehem, which is in the gate, and took it, and brought it to David; however he would not drink of it, but poured it out to Jehovah.

Philistines hold Bethlehem, David's childhood town, and three of his men cross enemy lines to bring him a drink from its well. What follows is stranger than the raid itself: the king will not touch the water, but pours it out before the LORD.

A wish, not an order

Everything in this scene turns on how David asked:

No command went out. David singled out no one and sent no one. He simply said what he wanted, and that opened the way for genuine affection and true devotion. A direct command would only have given someone a chance for ready obedience. The spoken desire drew out that deep attachment to David himself, which is so lovely to see.

Modernised from C. H. MackintoshOriginal wording

That difference carries over to how Christ speaks to His own:

David's expressed wish was never a command, and was never meant to be. If we are to reach any worthy thoughts at all, we must tell two things apart in the same way. There are commands laid on us, and such commands do exist. And there is His "word," which shows us what is in His heart. In receiving it we come into intelligent communion with Himself. The Lord makes this same distinction plainly in His last words to His disciples (John 14:21, 23). Commands may be given to servants only, and servants are never let into the secrets of the heart. But words spoken to friends also ask for a response, and the truly devoted will give it. Attachment to His Person does not ask, "What must I do?" but "What may I do?"

Modernised from F. W. GrantOriginal wording

Nothing gained but his pleasure

The earlier feats in this chapter won battles and saved Israel. This one won a cup of water:

Such mighty deeds matter greatly in their own time and place. But whether in David's day or in ours, one thing marks them: they benefit people, as well as bringing glory to the King. The three mighty men who drew the water show us a very different kind of service. The victories we have looked at had the blessing of the people in view. This touching act of service was wholly for the benefit of the King.

Modernised from Hamilton SmithOriginal wording

That love did not stop to weigh the risk against the prize. One writer asks where such devotion is found today:

They did not calculate or hesitate. Once they knew David's desire, meeting it was the only thing in their minds. There may have been objectors; some may have said, "Why this waste?" That meant nothing to them. Carrying out David's desire was their only thought. Yet look around and ask, "Where do I see this?" and the honest answer troubles you. Too many believers, if not most, are only benefactors of people. They neither know the desires of Christ nor seek to know them. They are thinking of man and his good, not of Christ and His glory.

Modernised from W. T. TurpinOriginal wording

Why he would not drink

Refusing the water was not ingratitude. David valued it too highly to swallow it:

It was a sacrifice too costly for any except the LORD Himself. So David would not let the sweet fragrance of it be interrupted on its way up to the throne of God.

Modernised from C. H. MackintoshOriginal wording

The act has a name in Israel's worship — the offering that is poured out and kept back from the offerer entirely:

David however appreciated their devotion more than he desired the water. He considered that he was not worthy of so great devotion, and he poured the water out as a drink offering to God, who alone is worthy of such sacrifices.

Modernised from Leslie M. GrantOriginal wording

The road to that well is still guarded

Anyone who acts in this spirit today will find the road still blocked:

If we act in this spirit — if we have this spirit — we shall find the world a hostile world to Christ. And not the world only. Right in the way, blocking the road to the well of Bethlehem, we shall find the Philistine camp: the crowd of natural men who have pushed their way into spiritual things. We must be ready to break through the defences of tradition, formality and worldliness dressed up as religion, if we are to satisfy the Lord's longing for us.

Modernised from F. W. GrantOriginal wording

Where the picture breaks

David could not accept what was offered. One greater than David can, and does:

His act of piety revealed two things. He judged the water too valuable for himself, and fitting for the LORD alone. It showed too that the fear of the LORD was always before him. But One greater than David does drink the springing water brought to Him now. He is the Son of God, David's Son according to the flesh, and He drinks it before He takes the throne of His glorious kingdom and dominion.

Modernised from H. J. VineOriginal wording

Summary

- Desire heard. David gave no order. He spoke a longing, and love that was listening acted on it.

- Devotion unasked. Earlier exploits helped the nation. This one helped nobody but the king — service for his pleasure alone.

- Danger crossed. They did not weigh the cost. The enemy army was just an obstacle between David and what he wanted.

- Drink refused. David judged the gift too costly for himself. He poured it out to God as a drink offering, since God alone is worthy of such sacrifice.

- David's greater Son. Tradition and worldliness still block the road to the well. But the One we break through for drinks what we bring Him.

2 Samuel 23:17 · Darby

And he said, Be it far from me, Jehovah, that I should do this thing! is it not the blood of the men that went at the risk of their lives? Therefore he would not drink it. These things did the three mighty men.

David and his men are in hiding, and a Philistine force holds Bethlehem. Three of his soldiers cut through the enemy to fetch him water from the well there — and this verse tells us why he would not drink it.

A sacrifice too costly for man

The water had cost three men the risk of their lives. David treated it as a gift fit only for God:

It was a sacrifice too costly for anyone except the Lord Himself. So David would not let anything interrupt its sweet smell as it rose to the throne of God.

Modernised from C. H. MackintoshOriginal wording

"The blood of the men"

David does not call the water a gift or a favour. He calls it blood, because of what the men had already been willing to lose:

The waters won this way were too precious for their gracious and loving master to drink. He calls the water their blood, or their life, because they had not counted their lives dear to themselves. The waters were as their life to him.

Modernised from The Bible TreasuryOriginal wording

A king who would not profit from his men's risk

The same king who drew out such devotion refused to consume it. What his men gave him, he handed straight on to God:

God records this devotion in His book. The king valued it, but did not want to take advantage of it: "Shall I drink the blood of the men who went at the risk of their lives?" He draws out the devotion of his men, yet his own character is to devote himself for them. The water offered to him only passes through his hands. He presents it as a drink offering "to the Lord," for whatever is done for Christ is done for God. God accepts it, offered up by Christ, as an excellent sacrifice. A simple cup of water given to "one of these little ones" for Christ's sake passes from His heart to the heart of God Himself.

Modernised from H. L. RossierOriginal wording

Faith that refuses what it wanted

One writer points past the courage of the three to what David did with the cup:

I am not thinking now of the brave men who broke through the Philistine army and brought David the water of Bethlehem he longed for. I speak of the grace that refused to touch it once they brought it. I speak of the faith that could look at that water, much as he had longed for it, and see the blood of those mighty men who had risked their lives. Oh for more of this self-renouncing power of faith!

Modernised from William KellyOriginal wording

Why their names are missing

The verse credits "the three mighty men" but gives no names. One writer finds the reason in the kind of act it was:

Why is there this striking omission of their names in the account of what they did? It is because here it is no longer a matter of energy and perseverance, but of the devotion of faith. By its very nature devotion is something hidden. What man has the right to boast of devotion?

Modernised from H. L. RossierOriginal wording

Something done wholly for the King

Some service wins no battle and takes no ground. It answers nothing but the desire of the one who is loved:

When we answer that desire, we are not fighting the Lord's battles. We are not gaining spoil. We are not defending the truth. We are doing something wholly for Christ. We are ministering to His heart by responding to His love. May we know better what it is to draw water from the well and pour it out before the Lord for the joy of His heart.

Modernised from Hamilton SmithOriginal wording

Poured out, the water was gone; yet the men who fetched it lost nothing. What decided their standing was not the size of the deed but what moved them to do it:

No wonder this simple act stirred David's heart. No wonder he poured the water out to the Lord as a drink offering. The three had won it at the risk of their lives, and it showed the devotion of these dear men. What turned that simple act into something greater was the motive behind it. It set those three men at the very top of the kingdom's roll of honour, when the fighting was over, the kingdom was secure, and the day of rewards had come.

Modernised from A. J. PollockOriginal wording

Summary

- Costly — three men risked their lives, so the water arrived carrying a worth no ordinary drink ever has.

- Blood — David names it their blood. The men had not counted their lives dear, so the cup held their life, not just water.

- Poured — too costly for a man to drink, it was the right gift for God, so it passed through David's hands to the Lord.

- Refused — the striking act is not the courage of the three but the grace that would not touch what it had wanted.

- Recorded — the water was gone, but the deed stayed. It set those three at the top of the kingdom's roll on the day of rewards.

2 Samuel 23:18 · Darby

And Abishai, the brother of Joab, the son of Zeruiah, was the chief of three; and he brandished his spear against three hundred and slew them; and he had a name among the three.

David's roll of warriors names Abishai first by his family: brother of Joab, son of Zeruiah. Then it tells what he did alone against three hundred men. So what earns a name in the king's record — family, or devotion?

Identified by His Brother

The verse ties Abishai to Joab before it mentions his spear. One writer finds both a likeness and a difference between the two men.

Abishai is called "the brother of Joab" because he was like him in many ways and showed the same traits. Even if he shared his brother's graceless hardness of heart, he was still ready to obey David's word. That obedience kept him from most of Joab's mistakes. So although he did not reach the first three, honour and distinction are given to him without reserve.

Modernised from H J VineOriginal wording

That readiness to obey faced a hard test. Abishai believed God had handed David's enemy to him, and only a word held him back.

Abishai listened to the word, and it kept him from this sin, though he thought God had delivered David's enemy into his hand. We may face a similar test today, but the word of the Lord will preserve us.

Modernised from H J VineOriginal wording

Family Ties Earn Nothing

Abishai was closely related to the king, and brother to the commander of the army. Neither fact put him in this chapter.

He might have claimed a place of special distinction because of his family ties. He was brother to Joab, the commander of the army, and a close relative of the king. But family ties do not secure a place in the kingdom for him, or for us. Abishai secures his distinguished place by his own courage... We cannot reach the faithfulness and spiritual power that marked the Apostle Paul and other great servants of the Lord. But the same divine grace can mark us with the same spirit, in our own measure.

Modernised from An Outline of Sound WordsOriginal wording

The Brother Who Is Absent

Joab is named here only as a marker for his brother. He never appears in the honour roll himself, and one writer gives the reason.

Abishai, the brother of Joab, has a significant place as chief of these three men. Sadly, this final summary of David's mighty men gives Joab himself no honor at all. He was a capable warrior who gained many victories, but his one fatal flaw was that his motives proved selfish. It was not God's honor that he sought, but his own.

Modernised from Leslie M. GrantOriginal wording

Chief, and Still Second

The verse gives Abishai a high place and a limit in the same breath. Where the ESV says "chief of the thirty", the older translation reads "chief of three". The writers quoted here take him as head of a second group of three. One writer compares him with the man listed just before him.

These three men's deeds of valor did not attain to those of the first three. First there is Abishai. Like Joseb-Bassebeth, he brandished his spear against three hundred men and killed them. But he did not have the same perseverance of faith.

Modernised from H. L. RossierOriginal wording

The differences between these men are part of the record itself.

Out of the many thousands of Israel... only a few stood out by personal devotedness and wholehearted consecration. Even among those few there were marked differences. There were "the thirty," "the three," and "the first three." Each gets his own specific place... according to what he was or what he had done. We are also told exactly what each one did and how he did it. Nothing is forgotten. It is all recorded faithfully, and no one can ever get another's place.

Modernised from C. H. MackintoshOriginal wording

The Name He Won

Reputation now is not the final word.

Right now we know very little about how far people are true to the Lord. But the time will come when everyone will be shown for what they are... Some who are thought much of now may be missing then from the list of the faithful. Many whose service is valued little now may shine out then to the abundant praise and honour of the Lord Jesus... At the end the worthy men appear, each according to the real worth of his service and the character of his devotedness to David.

Modernised from H H SnellOriginal wording

One writer sets the deed beside the reward.

He faced no fewer than three hundred of David's enemies alone! He did not stop until he had killed them all! After the hardship and trial he went through with David during the time when David was rejected, we may be sure he learned much and enjoyed a place near the king in his glory. David might well say to him, as another will say to His mighty men one day, "Well done, good and faithful servant!"

Modernised from H J VineOriginal wording

Summary

- Not by likeness. Abishai was much like Joab, but he obeyed David's word, and that obedience kept him from Joab's mistakes.

- Not by blood. Close family ties to the king and to the commander secured him nothing. His own deeds did.

- Not by rank. Joab outranked everyone, yet the roll leaves him out, because he sought his own honour, not God's.

- Not by equal measure. Abishai led the second three, yet never reached the first three. He lacked their perseverance of faith.

- But by record. Nothing is forgotten, each gets his own place, and no one can ever take another's.

2 Samuel 23:19 · Darby

Was he not most honourable of three? and he was their captain; but he did not attain to the [first] three.

Abishai led the second group of David's warriors, honoured above the thirty and set over them. So why did a man of such courage stop short of the first three, and what won him the honour he did receive?

Honoured, Yet Short of the Three

Abishai was Joab's brother and a relative of the king. One writer asks what that family tie secured for him, and what it did not.

After the first three, we have Abishai. He might have claimed a place of special distinction because of his family ties. He was Joab's brother, and Joab was the commander of the army. He was also a close relative of the king. But natural relationships do not secure for him, or for us, a place in the kingdom. Abishai secures his distinguished place because of his own prowess. His great feat did not reach the height of the Tachmonite's. Even so, he was marked by the same spirit of power. We cannot reach the faithfulness and spiritual power that marked the Apostle Paul and other great servants of the Lord. But the same divine grace can mark us with the same spirit, in our own measure. Another mighty deed of Abishai's appears in 2 Samuel 21:16-17. He rescued David when one of the giants tried to kill him, and he killed the giant.

Modernised from An Outline of Sound WordsOriginal wording

What He Lacked

So what kept Abishai out of the first three? One commentator points not to strength, but to something that has to last.

These three men's deeds of valour did not reach those of the first three. First there is Abishai. Like Joseb-Bassebeth, he brandished his spear against three hundred men and killed them. But he did not have the same perseverance of faith.

Modernised from H. L. RossierOriginal wording

What He Gained

Scripture names Abishai as Joab's brother, and the likeness ran deeper than blood. Another writer traces his honour to one habit.

Abishai, "the brother of Joab", is so described because he was like him in many ways, showing similar traits. But even if he shared his brother's graceless hardness of heart, he was still ready to obey David's word. That obedience kept him from most of Joab's mistakes. So although he "did not attain to the first three", the record gives him honour and distinction without reserve. He was chief of the three (that is, the second three), we are told, and he was "more honourable" than the other two. This was the result of heeding the word of David while staying close to him. When a servant of our Lord Jesus Christ heeds His word and keeps near to Him, there may still be a great deal to try him. Even so, his service will hold much that pleases God.

Modernised from H J VineOriginal wording

Translations differ on one word here. The ESV calls Abishai "the most renowned of the thirty". Older versions read "most honourable of three", so the writer above compares him with the other two men in his group.

The Brother Who Is Missing

One name is missing from this list of honoured men. Its absence makes Abishai's place stand out.

Abishai, the brother of Joab, has a significant place as chief of these three men. Sadly, Joab himself is not mentioned as being given any honour at all in this final summing up of David's mighty men. He was a capable warrior who won many victories. But he had one fatal flaw: his motives proved selfish. He did not seek God's honour, but his own. David knew this, and told Solomon that Joab must be put to death (1 Kings 2:5-6). Joab's treachery could not be overlooked because of his many victories.

Modernised from Leslie M. GrantOriginal wording

Ranks That Last

The chapter ranks servants and records their honour. One writer asks what place rewards should have in our own service.

It is not a question of working for rewards, for a crown or for a place, though we fully believe in the doctrine of rewards. No! The very moment we make rewards our object, we are below the mark. We believe that service rendered with the eye on the reward would be defective. But we also believe that Christ will reward every bit of true service in the day of His glory. Each servant will get his place in the record and his place in the kingdom, according to the measure of his personal devotedness here.

Modernised from C. H. MackintoshOriginal wording

Summary

- Honour named. The record puts Abishai first among the second three. His limit never cancels his distinction.

- Honour earned. Being Joab's brother and the king's nephew secured nothing; his place came from what he himself did.

- Honour bounded. His deed matched the first three in daring. One commentator finds him short in perseverance of faith.

- Honour kept. He heeded David's word and stayed close to him. That obedience spared him the mistakes that ruined his brother.

- Honour recorded. Joab's many victories won him no mention, because his motives were selfish. God weighs service by devotedness, not by results.

2 Samuel 23:20 · Darby

And Benaiah the son of Jehoiada, son of a valiant man, great in exploits, of Kabzeel he it was that smote two lions of Moab; and he went down and smote a lion in the midst of a pit on a snowy day.

The names carry the story

The verse gives three names: the man, his father, and his hometown. One writer reads them together as a portrait of the fighter God prepares.

We must be very careful when we interpret the meaning of Scripture names. Yet they often hold very instructive lessons. In this passage the combination of the different names is remarkable. Benaiah means "Whom God has built"; Jehoiada, "The Lord knows"; and Kabzeel, "God has gathered." Put these meanings together, and we learn this. Benaiah was the son of one whom the Lord knew ("I know my sheep"). He had been built up in the truth by God Himself. And he knew his place in God's assembly.

Modernised from Edward DennettOriginal wording

Three enemies in one verse

Commentators see the believer's three great opponents in the foes Benaiah met.

He is specially singled out for his victories over (1) two men of Moab; (2) a lion; and (3) an Egyptian. How these three remind us of (1) the flesh; (2) Satan; and (3) the world. It is a great day when, in the service of our Lord Jesus Christ, we accept the condemnation of the cross upon sin in the flesh. From then on we walk and war after the Spirit.

Modernised from H J VineOriginal wording

Translators have read the phrase behind "two ariels of Moab" in more than one way. Older translations rendered it "two lion-like men."

In 2 Samuel 23:20 and 1 Chronicles 11:22 we read that Benaiah killed two "lion-like men." Some prefer to translate this "two sons of Ariel." The Hebrew is literally "two lions of God."

Modernised from Morrish Bible DictionaryOriginal wording

What the two foes picture

The same writer draws out what each enemy stands for.

Moab means "progeny." That which is born of the flesh is flesh. Since these men were lion-like, this was the flesh under full Satanic power. He also killed a lion in the middle of a pit in the time of snow. Peter compares Satan to a roaring lion, and so Benaiah was able to overcome Satan himself on his own ground.

Modernised from Edward DennettOriginal wording

Everything was against him

The snow tells you the odds. One writer sets that against the first battle ever lost.

Benaiah's killing of the lion in the pit surely speaks to us of one who has overcome the wicked one... This happened on a snowy day. The circumstances of the fight were all against Benaiah, yet he was victorious. When Adam fell, the circumstances of Eden were all in his favour. But when Christ met the foe — in the temptations, in Gethsemane, at the cross — how different the circumstances were from those of the first man when he fell before the enemy.

Modernised from An Outline of Sound WordsOriginal wording

Going down to fight

Benaiah did not wait for the lion to come out. He went down into the pit — and writers see Christ in that descent.

He went down into a pit to kill a lion. This is surely a lovely picture of the One who descended into the lower parts of the earth, having gone down into death... When Benaiah went down into the pit it was "the time of snow." Everything was in the grip of winter, without a trace of life anywhere. So it was with the blessed Lord Jesus when He went down into death to destroy the one who had the power of death... Benaiah came up out of the pit victorious, having killed the lion. In the same way the blessed Lord rose out of death, having burst its iron gates and destroyed its power for ever.

Modernised from Scripture QuarterlyOriginal wording

The same fight, now ours

One writer brings Benaiah's fight into the present.

He did not hesitate on a snowy day to go down into a pit and kill a lion. He is like the faithful today. They sometimes have to enter into the closest conflict with Satan under the most distressing circumstances, and overcome him by the sword of the Spirit.

Modernised from H H SnellOriginal wording

The reward of a faithful walk

Benaiah's deeds copy his king's own history. One writer notes what that walk earned him.

Benaiah walks faithfully in his master's steps. His great affection for David leads him to copy his model's traits. Such a walk finds its reward: "David set him in his council" — a place of confidence, intimacy and communion. Benaiah shares his master's secrets, is told his plans, and sees the king's face at all times.

Modernised from H. L. RossierOriginal wording

Summary

- Built — the name Benaiah means "whom God has built." God gave the strength this verse celebrates.

- Three — Moab, the lion, the Egyptian stand for the flesh, Satan and the world. Believers meet the same three, and overcome by the sword of the Spirit.

- Snow — the worst possible conditions. Adam fell with everything in his favour; Christ won with everything against Him.

- Down — Benaiah did not wait at the edge. He went down into the pit, onto the enemy's own ground, as Christ went down into death.

- Council — the reward of copying the king was nearness to him: a seat in his confidence, and his face always in view.

2 Samuel 23:21 · Darby

He also smote the Egyptian, an imposing man and the Egyptian had a spear in his hand; and he went down to him with a staff, and plucked the spear out of the Egyptian's hand, and slew him with his own spear.

David's list of mighty men gives this soldier a fuller record. Benaiah goes down against an armed Egyptian with nothing but a staff, and kills the man with his own weapon. Commentators read the scene as a picture of victory over the world, won through what looks like weakness.

The Man Behind the Deed

The record opens with three names: Benaiah, his father Jehoiada, and his home town Kabzeel. One writer reads them together as a description of the man:

Benaiah means "Whom God has built"; Jehoiada, "Jehovah knows"; and Kabzeel, "God has gathered." Put these meanings together, and we learn this. Benaiah was the son of one whom the Lord knew ("I know my own"). God Himself had built him up in the truth. And he knew his place in God's assembly (Kabzeel).

Modernised from Edward DennettOriginal wording

Why an Egyptian

Why does the verse name the man's nation instead of just calling him an enemy? One writer answers from what Egypt stood for, and links this fight to a victory Christ had already won:

The third exploit we see here is Benaiah's victory over the Egyptian. Do we not see the glory of the world, and its bondage for the people of God in Egypt? But we read of One Who said, "I have overcome the world" (John 16:33)... Benaiah kills the Egyptian with his own spear, just as we read of the Lord's great triumph in Hebrews: "that through death he might destroy the one who has the power of death" (Heb. 2:14). If the Lord has overcome the world, He can enable us to overcome it also.

Modernised from An Outline of Sound WordsOriginal wording

A Staff Against a Spear

The verse sets the two weapons side by side. One writer sizes up that mismatch and links Benaiah's bare staff to the cross:

The Egyptian was a huge man, and he carried a spear like a weaver's beam. Yet Benaiah defeated him with only a staff in his hand... We get the victory over the world through the cross of Christ. It comes by faith in the Son of God, who makes the Father's love known to us. The world lifted up its hand against Christ. Yet the death He died defeated the world for faith.

Modernised from H J VineOriginal wording

The Spear as a Symbol

Benaiah does not bring a weapon of his own; he takes the enemy's. Commentators compare this with David beheading Goliath with the giant's sword, and see in the spear what death itself became in God's hands:

He also killed an Egyptian, a handsome man — the picture of the world at its most attractive... The spear, like the sword, is a symbol of the power of death. As another writer has remarked, "Death is the best weapon in the arsenal of God when it is wielded by the power of life." This was Benaiah's experience in his conflict with the world (the Egyptian).

Modernised from Edward DennettOriginal wording

The Same Thing Still Happens

The detail of the captured spear is not left in the past. One writer reads it as something believers may still watch unfold:

He also killed an Egyptian with the Egyptian's own spear. We can sometimes see the same thing now. A worldly man opposes God's servants and God's truth, and the very weapon he used against them defeats him. So God turns the wrath of man to praise Him.

Modernised from H H SnellOriginal wording

Copying the Master, and the Reward

Benaiah does not invent his tactic. He fights the way David fought, and that likeness brings him a reward:

He killed the Egyptian just as David had struck down Goliath. David took the giant's own sword and cut off his head; in the same way, Benaiah put the Egyptian to death with his own spear. Benaiah walks faithfully in his master's steps, and his deep love for David leads him to copy the traits of the man he follows. Such a walk finds its reward: "David set him in his council" (v. 23), a place of confidence, intimacy, and communion.

Modernised from H. L. RossierOriginal wording

Summary

- Built — Benaiah's name means "Whom God has built." God built him up in the truth before he ever fought.

- Faced — the Egyptian pictures the world: its glory, its beauty, and its power to hold God's people in bondage.

- Weak — he went down with a staff against a spear like a weaver's beam. The victory comes through the cross, not through strength.

- Turned — the enemy's own spear killed him. Death is the best weapon in God's arsenal when the power of life wields it.

- Rewarded — Benaiah fought as David fought, so David set him in his council. Likeness to the master ends in nearness to him.

2 Samuel 23:22 · Darby

These things did Benaiah the son of Jehoiada, and he had a name among the three mighty men.

Benaiah's record closes with a summary: everything he had done won him a name. Yet that name stands beside the three mighty men, not among them. So what was it worth? And why write down a lion, a pit and a snowy day at all?

Deeds shaped by his master

Each of Benaiah's exploits has a twin in David's own life. One writer reads them that way, and follows where such copying led.

Next we find Benaiah the son of Jehoiada. He fought the enemies from outside, Moab and Egypt. He killed two Moabite heroes. Like David, he fought a lion all by himself. He killed the Egyptian just as David had struck down Goliath. David had cut off the giant's head with the giant's own sword, and in the same way Benaiah put the Egyptian to death with his own spear. Benaiah walks faithfully in his master's steps, and his great love for David leads him to reproduce his model's traits. Such a walk finds its reward: a place of confidence, closeness and fellowship. Benaiah shares his master's secrets, knows his plans, and sees the king's face at all times. If we love the Lord Jesus, and obey and serve Him, we will be rewarded with a nearness like that of John, the beloved disciple, whose place was at Jesus' side.

Modernised from H. L. RossierOriginal wording

The enemies behind the record

One writer reads the victories as a picture of the enemies a believer faces. Moab stands for the flesh. Satan is the lion, waiting in his own stronghold.

Satan acts upon the flesh, and the two men of Moab were "lion-like", but the one who was "with David" killed them both. The lion himself lived in a pit, and no doubt went about looking for what he could devour when he was not in his stronghold. Benaiah would win the gratitude of many for his victory on that snowy day.

Modernised from H J VineOriginal wording

The Egyptian stands for the third enemy: the world. The same writer traces the pattern of that fight into the Lord's own triumph, and then into ours.

Do we not see the glory of the world, and its slavery for the people of God, in Egypt? The Egyptian is killed with his own spear. We read the same in the Lord's great triumph in Hebrews: "that through death he might destroy the one who has the power of death" (Heb. 2:14). If the Lord has overcome the world, He can enable us to overcome it also. Of this we have divine assurance in 1 John 5:4-5.

Modernised from An Outline of Sound WordsOriginal wording

Why the snow matters

The weather is not decoration. Everything was against Benaiah that day. One writer sets that beside Adam's day in Eden.

A good many years ago, I remember a well-known man saying this: "You see Benaiah going down to where the lion was. The Lord Jesus went down into death in the same way, to meet the power of the enemy. Who is going to be triumphant? Who is coming up out of the pit? Is it to be Benaiah or the lion? It was Benaiah! So it was with Christ: He rose triumphant from the grave, and He annulled the power of the enemy." It happened on a snowy day. Everything about the fight was against Benaiah, yet he won. When Adam fell, everything in Eden was in his favour. But when Christ met the foe — in the temptations, in Gethsemane, at the cross — the circumstances were nothing like those of the first man when he fell before the enemy.

Modernised from An Outline of Sound WordsOriginal wording

Honour in your own measure

Benaiah's name stands beside the three without joining them. One writer makes the same point about Abishai, who ranked below the top three.

Abishai secures his distinguished place by his own courage and skill. His great feat did not reach the height of the Tachmonite's, yet the same spirit of power still marked him. We cannot attain to the faithfulness and spiritual power that marked the apostle Paul and other great servants of the Lord. But the same divine grace can mark us with the same spirit, in our own measure.

Modernised from An Outline of Sound WordsOriginal wording

Why the record exists

No human record keeper would have saved a fight in a pit on a snowy day. The list exists because the King remembers.

David's men had to bear much toil and weariness because they belonged to him. But love made it all light and easy to them. Their names and deeds were written down and faithfully remembered when David was at rest in his kingdom. None were forgotten… These acts may not be seen, known, or thought of by men; but Jesus knows them, and will publicly declare them from the throne of His glory. Who would ever have known the acts of David's worthy men if the Holy Spirit had not recorded them? Who would have known of the slaying of a lion in a pit, in the time of snow?

Modernised from C. H. MackintoshOriginal wording

Summary

- Love copies. Benaiah's exploits mirror David's own — the lion, the giant, the enemy's weapon turned back on him. Love for a person reproduces that person's character — and it brought Benaiah close to the king.

- Love fights. The three victories answer the three enemies: the flesh, Satan, the world.

- Love wins on bad days. The snow marks a day when everything was against him. Eden was the opposite. Christ went down into death and came up.

- Love has its measure. A name beside the three is real honour. No one has to match Paul; grace can mark us with the same spirit.

- Love is recorded. The Holy Spirit wrote down deeds no one else would have heard of. The King will declare them from His throne.

2 Samuel 23:23 · Darby

He was honoured above the thirty, but he did not attain to the [first] three. And David set him in his council.

Benaiah's record ends with a ranking and a promotion, not with another exploit. Two questions follow: why do some servants rise higher than others, and what was the post David gave him?

Rank Among The Mighty

The chapter grades David's heroes. It keeps the second group of three clear of the first.

Benaiah is another one of the second three, a man who showed unusual courage whether he fought men or beasts. We are not told the name of the third man in this group. But verse 23 reminds us that the first three receive higher honour than the second three or all that follow them.

Modernised from Leslie M. GrantOriginal wording

The gap is not about raw achievement. Abishai matched a first-three feat and still fell short:

These three men's brave deeds did not match those of the first three. First there is Abishai. Like Joseb-Bassebeth, he raised his spear against three hundred men and killed them. But he did not have the same perseverance of faith.

Modernised from H. L. RossierOriginal wording

Walking In The King's Steps

Benaiah did not just fight bravely. He fought the way David fought.

Like David, he fought a lion all by himself. He killed the Egyptian just as David had struck down Goliath, and just as David had taken the giant's sword to cut off his head, so Benaiah put the Egyptian to death with the Egyptian's own spear. Benaiah walks faithfully in his master's steps and his great affection for David leads him to reproduce his model's traits. Such a walk finds its reward: "David set him in his council" (v. 23), a place of confidence, intimacy, and communion. Benaiah shares his master's secrets, hears his plans, and sees the king's face at all times. What a blessed portion! If we love the Lord Jesus, obey Him and serve Him, He will reward us with a nearness like John's — the disciple Jesus loved, whose place was close to His heart.

Modernised from H. L. RossierOriginal wording

Rossier's version reads "in his council" where the ESV has "over his bodyguard". Benaiah never climbed over anyone to reach that place.

Still, this man has no ambition except to stay faithful to his king and to imitate him. He is not like Joab who takes the stronghold of Zion to win first place. No, he is humble, because his whole purpose is to reproduce David in the way he lives.

Modernised from H. L. RossierOriginal wording

Guard Or Council

Translations split on the last phrase: a seat in the king's council, or command of the royal bodyguard. The word behind it has a telling root:

Mishmaath, from a word for "obedience": a bodyguard. 2 Sam. 23:23; 1 Chr. 11:25.

Modernised from Morrish Bible DictionaryOriginal wording

Either way, David gave the post to a man he had tested for years.

Benaiah was with David when many were against him, and he was with him when the crowds acknowledged him as king and bowed before him. His fellowship with God's anointed seems never to have broken. It held in hard times and in good, in the cave and on the throne, in wars with countless enemies and in the governing of God's people. No wonder David set him over his guard. He would be glad to have such a man close to himself.

Modernised from H J VineOriginal wording

What The Post Led To

The bodyguard post was not Benaiah's ceiling. It was his proving ground.

"With David" in his rejection and his battles. "With David" as captain of his bodyguard. "With David" in his kingdom in positions of honour. Now he was raised higher still, to be captain of the army of Israel with David's son Solomon, sharing his glorious reign when the wars were over. Tried and proved trustworthy, he reaped a rich and blessed reward.

Modernised from H J VineOriginal wording

Different Ranks, One Nearness

A verse that ranks servants raises a question: is God's love rationed too? No:

Each will receive his own reward according to his own labour (1 Corinthians 3:8). In the kingdom, as the parable teaches (Luke 19), one is to have authority over ten cities, another over five. But the Father's house rises far above such differences, and His children share it alike with Christ. It is the answer, not to their services, but to His redemption, His infinite love and His glory.

Modernised from William KellyOriginal wording

Summary

- Ranked — verse 23 puts the first three above the second three and all who follow. Courage alone does not close the gap.

- Perseverance — Abishai matched a feat of the first three, but not their perseverance of faith. The list rewards staying power, not one great day.

- Imitation — Benaiah fought a lion and killed a champion as David had. Love for his master shaped him, and he reached for no first place of his own.

- Nearness — that walk won him a place of confidence, intimacy and communion. He saw the king's face at all times.

- Forever — tested in the cave, the guardroom and the throne room, he ended as captain of the army in the reign of peace.

2 Samuel 23:24 · Darby

Asahel the brother of Joab was one of the thirty; Elhanan the son of Dodo of Bethlehem,

This verse opens the long list of "the thirty" — names with no deeds attached, starting with Asahel, Joab's brother, and Elhanan of Bethlehem. Why does Scripture record soldiers we know almost nothing about, and what does the order of the list tell us?

Asahel: first in rank, empty in record

Asahel stands at the head of the thirty, yet unlike the men before him he has no exploit written beside his name. One writer traces this silence back to Asahel's chase after Abner:

Scripture makes no special mention of Asahel. He might have performed some act of bravery, but his confidence in himself and in his own speed cost him his career very early, in his encounter with Abner.

Modernised from H. L. RossierOriginal wording

Kinship at the head of every list

Three lists, three leaders, and all three are sons of David's sister. Another writer sees more than family favouritism in that pattern:

Asahel's name stands at the top of the list of the thirty captains. His time as a soldier was short, as we have seen. But we cannot help noticing that David's sister's sons head all three lists. Joab was chief and captain; Abishai was chief of the second three; and Asahel was first of the thirty. This was not mere favouritism. It proves instead that knowing you are related to God's Anointed makes a good soldier. The letters of the New Testament say this again and again. We are called companions of the Christ, "the Anointed" — and more than that, we are His brothers. He is "not ashamed to call us brothers".

Modernised from H J VineOriginal wording

Fixed ranks, and no one displaced

The chapter sorts David's men into ranks, and no man in it ever takes another man's place:

There were "the thirty," "the three," and "the first three." Each man gets his own place in the book of responsible, practical life, according to what he was or what he had done. And we are told exactly what each one did and how he did it. Nothing is forgotten; the record is faithful. No one can ever take another's place. Each does his own work, fills his own niche, and gets his own reward.

Modernised from C. H. MackintoshOriginal wording

The lesser-known men, and the name of Uriah

The thirty are the least celebrated men in the chapter. Their list ends with the man David had killed:

Last we find the "thirty," less famous than the six men before them, though the Lord forgets none of His own. When David looked over the list of His servants, how his eyes must have paused in sorrow at the name of Uriah the Hittite, which ends the list. Uriah was among the mighty men, and not the least of those hearts devoted to the king and his people. Yet David had had him put to death to satisfy his own lust! His name stayed there as a witness against the man he had served.

Modernised from H. L. RossierOriginal wording

Why obscure names were written down at all

These men bore hardship with a rejected king, and their deeds went on record only after he was at rest in his kingdom. One writer sees the same pattern in service done for Jesus today:

Because David's men belonged to him, they had to bear much toil and weariness. But love made it all light and easy to them. Their names and their deeds went on record and were faithfully remembered when David was at rest in his kingdom. None were forgotten... Men may never see these acts, know them, or even think of them; but Jesus knows them, and He will declare them openly from the throne of His glory. Who would ever have known the acts of David's mighty men if the Holy Spirit had not recorded them?

Modernised from C. H. MackintoshOriginal wording

An honest word about the list itself

One writer admits how little these bare names give us. He also notes that the list in 1 Chronicles 11 differs in detail. He turns that gap into a call to study:

The thirty (really thirty-one) are known only by their names. Little can be said about them until they have been studied more closely. Chronicles gives much the same list (1 Chron. 11), with extra names at the end, but it differs a great deal in the details... Let the people of God study His word. Dig deep, and expect much. Then we shall soon have few such wide gaps in our knowledge as the ones we must regret here.

Modernised from Numerical Bible NotesOriginal wording

Summary

- Named. Asahel heads the thirty with no exploit beside his name. Confidence in himself cut his career short in the chase after Abner, yet the list still carries him.

- Related. David's sister's sons head all three lists. Knowing your relationship to God's Anointed is what makes a good soldier.

- Ranked. The thirty, the three and the first three are fixed ranks. No one ever takes another's place. Each has his own work, his own niche, his own reward.

- Recorded. The thirty are the least famous men in the chapter, yet the Lord forgets none of His own. The same list ends with Uriah, whose name stands as a witness against the king he served.

- Rewarded. Their deeds went on record only when David was at rest in his kingdom. What men never see, Jesus knows — and He will declare it from the throne of His glory.

2 Samuel 23:25 · Darby

Shammah the Harodite, Elika the Harodite,

Verse 25 sits inside the roll of David's mighty men and gives two names with nothing attached: Shammah and Elika, both from Harod. No exploit, no speech, no battle — so why does the Spirit of God record them at all?

Who These Two Men Were

The only thing the verse adds to each name is a place: Harod. A Bible dictionary explains that label, and flags a puzzle in the parallel list in Chronicles:

The designation of Shammah and Elika, two of David's mighty men, probably from some place called Harod. 2 Samuel 23:25. It seems the first of them is called Shammoth the Harorite in 1 Chronicles 11:27.

Modernised from Morrish Bible DictionaryOriginal wording

Harod appears in an earlier story too: Gideon camped at that spring and tested his army by the way the men drank (Morrish Bible Dictionary). Another writer faces the gap between the two lists head on:

We can say little about the thirty (thirty-one), known only by their names, until we study them more closely. Chronicles, as everyone knows, gives almost the same list, with additions at the end, yet it differs a great deal in the details. In lists like this one — dry and barren as our neglect has left them — we may expect to find many textual errors... Let the people of God study His word; dig deep, and expect much.

Modernised from Numerical Bible NotesOriginal wording

Why the List Exists at All

The list is not an afterthought. God turns from the king to the men who stood with him:

If God honours and glorifies David, He does not forget those whom the energy of David's faith had brought around him. The Holy Spirit lists the mighty men of David, and recounts their deeds of valour and devotion. Those deeds win them a name and a place when God writes up the people (Psalm 87). Joab is not among them.

Modernised from J. N. DarbyOriginal wording

Ranks Within the Roll

Shammah and Elika belong to "the thirty," not to the smaller inner circles. One writer sets this roll beside a New Testament list and draws out what both mean for every servant of God:

Turn to the twenty-third chapter of 2 Samuel and to the sixteenth of Romans, and you will find two similar pages. In the first, we have the names and the deeds of David's worthies. In the second, the names and the deeds of Paul's friends at Rome... Each one has his own special place on the roll, and each one his place in the Master's heart; and all will come out by and by. Amongst David's mighty men, we have "the first three" — "the three" and "the thirty." Not one of "the thirty" ever reached a place among "the three." And not one of "the three" ever reached "the first three."

Modernised from C. H. MackintoshOriginal wording

Names Without Recorded Deeds

Earlier in the chapter each man comes with a story. From verse 24 on, the list gives bare names:

Many other names are also ranked among David's worthies, though Scripture records no special mark of devotion or victory for them.

Modernised from H H SnellOriginal wording

Being less celebrated is not the same as being overlooked:

At the end we find the "thirty." They are less renowned than the six men before them, yet the Lord forgets none of His own.

Modernised from H. L. RossierOriginal wording

The Missing Names

Who is missing matters as much as who is there:

Other names are completely missing from the list of mighty men, and Scripture is not entirely silent about the reason why. Notice who is absent from the list of the king's worthies: the greatest warrior, the wisest counsellor, and one of the chief religious officials. We mean Joab, Ahithophel, and Abiathar.

Modernised from H H SnellOriginal wording

What the List Points To

One writer reads these names forward, to the judgment seat of Christ:

They were the men who loved David, stood by him, and showed their loyalty and devotion to the King. Others are named too, with no definite deeds recorded... At the judgment seat of Christ everything will be brought to light. He will come as the righteous Ruler, to bring in the morning without clouds. Then He will remember those who were loyal and devoted to Him while He was rejected. No name and no deed, even the smallest, will then be forgotten.

Modernised from Arno Clemens GaebeleinOriginal wording

Summary

- Named. Shammah and Elika carry only their home town, Harod. Chronicles lists one of them under a different form of his name.

- Ranked. They belong to "the thirty," not "the three" — each man has his own place on the roll, and no one can take another's.

- Unrecorded. Scripture records no deed for either man. Many of David's worthies stand in the list with no exploit beside their names.

- Remembered. Less renowned is not the same as forgotten. God does not forget those whom faith drew around His king.

- Rewarded. When Christ comes to reign, He will bring to light every loyalty shown to Him while He was rejected. No name and no deed, however small, will be lost.

2 Samuel 23:26 · Darby

Helez the Paltite, Ira the son of Ikkesh the Tekoite,

Second Samuel keeps a roll of names: David's mighty men, each listed with his home town. Two of them appear in this verse with no deed attached — Helez and Ira. Why does Scripture preserve names whose stories it never tells, and what does a place on such a list mean?

The roll itself

One writer ties this list of men to God's honouring of David himself.

If God honours and glorifies David, He does not forget those whom the energy of David's faith had brought around him. The Holy Spirit lists the mighty men of David, and tells of their deeds of courage and devotion — deeds that win them a name and a place when God writes up the people (Psalm 87). Joab is not among them.

Modernised from J. N. DarbyOriginal wording

Who Helez and Ira were

"Paltite" tells us where Helez came from. Chronicles labels him differently.

Designation of Helez, one of David's mighty men. 2 Sam. 23:26. Connected by some with Beth-palet; but in 1 Chr. 11:27 Helez is called 'the Pelonite.'

Modernised from Morrish Bible DictionaryOriginal wording

The same dictionary gives Ira's father and town, and points to two later mentions of him:

Son of Ikkesh a Tekoite, and one of David's mighty men. 2 Sam. 23:26; 1 Chr. 11:28; 1 Chr. 27:9.

Modernised from Morrish Bible DictionaryOriginal wording

That last reference points to another duty these men held:

These names are the captains of the monthly divisions, except for Abishai; and Dodai is named there instead of Eleazar son of Dodo.

Modernised from J. N. DarbyOriginal wording

No recorded deed

Helez and Ira belong to "the thirty." The chapter records no deed of theirs. One writer warns against reading that silence as neglect.

Last of all we find the "thirty." They are less renowned than the six men before them, though the Lord forgets none of His own.

Modernised from H. L. RossierOriginal wording

Another writer notes that such men still count among David's best:

Many other names also rank among David's worthies, with no special mark of devotedness and no victories recorded.

Modernised from H H SnellOriginal wording

Why the lists differ

One writer admits how little we know about the thirty, and suggests why Chronicles does not match:

We can say little about the thirty (thirty-one), known only by their names, until we study them more closely. Chronicles gives much the same list (1 Chronicles 11), with additions at the end, yet it differs a great deal in the details. It is just in lists like this, dry and bare as our neglect has left them, that we may expect textual errors to abound… Let the people of God study His word. Dig deep, and expect much. Then we will soon have few such complete gaps in our knowledge as the ones we have to regret here.

Modernised from Numerical Bible NotesOriginal wording

Ranks that no one else can fill

The chapter sorts its men into ranks. One writer draws out what that means for anyone who serves.

Out of the many thousands of Israel — circumcised members of the congregation, children of Abraham — only a few stood out by personal devotion and wholehearted dedication. Even among those few there were marked differences. There were "the thirty," "the three," and "the first three." Each man has his own place in the record of responsible, practical life, according to what he was or what he had done… Nothing is forgotten. All is recorded faithfully, and no one can ever take another's place. Each does his own work, fills his own niche, and gets his own reward.

Modernised from C. H. MackintoshOriginal wording

What the list looks forward to

One writer finds a forward-looking meaning in the whole roll, bare names included.

And others are given, of whom we read no definite deeds. The last name is Uriah the Hittite. The spiritual meaning is not hard to find. Before the judgment seat of Christ all will be made manifest. When He comes to be the righteous Ruler, to usher in the morning without clouds, those will be remembered who were loyal and devoted to Him in His rejection. No name and no deed, even the smallest, will then be forgotten.

Modernised from Arno Clemens GaebeleinOriginal wording

Summary

- Named. Two men, with nothing recorded but a father's name and a home town. Chronicles even labels Helez differently, and writers record both labels without settling the question.

- Numbered. They belong to "the thirty," the least renowned group in the chapter. The record tells nothing more of them.

- Not forgotten. Being less renowned is not the same as being overlooked; the Lord forgets none of His own.

- Not interchangeable. Each man gets his own place according to what he was and what he did, and no one can ever take another's place or reward.

- Not finished. The roll points ahead. Everything will be made manifest, and loyalty to a rejected king will be remembered when He reigns.

2 Samuel 23:27 · Darby

Abiezer the Anathothite, Mebunnai the Hushathite,

Two names, and nothing else: no exploit, no number of enemies killed, no battle described. Yet the Spirit of God wrote them down in the roll of David's mighty men. Why keep a name when there is no deed to tell?

A Roll God Chose to Keep

The chapter moves straight from David's last words to a list of soldiers. One writer connects the two: the king's honour does not crowd out the men who stood with him.

If God honours and glorifies David, He does not forget those whom the energy of David's faith had brought around him. The Holy Spirit lists the mighty men of David, and recounts their deeds of valour and devotedness — deeds which win them a name and a place when God writes up the people (Psalm 87). Joab is not among them.

Modernised from J. N. DarbyOriginal wording

Joab was the commander of the army, and his name is missing. Abiezer and Mebunnai are here.

Names Without Deeds

Our verse belongs to the part of the list where the record thins out to names only. That silence is itself the point.

The records and the names of David's mighty men fit perfectly with this last great prophetic word of the King. They were the men who loved David, stood by him, showed their loyalty and devotion to the King. Others are listed, and we read of no definite deeds for them... He will come as the righteous Ruler, to bring in the morning without clouds. Then He will remember those who were loyal and devoted to Him in His rejection. No name and no deed, even the smallest, will then be forgotten.

Modernised from Arno Clemens GaebeleinOriginal wording

Abiezer of Anathoth

Anathoth was not a random village. Later it would be Jeremiah's home town, and earlier still it was the place Abiathar the priest came from.

Although known as a prophet, Jeremiah belonged to the family of "the priests who were in Anathoth in the land of Benjamin." His village of Anathoth lay a little over three miles northeast of Jerusalem. It had been given to the priests, descendants of Aaron, of the family of the Kohathites (Josh. 21:18; 1 Chron. 6:60). Abiathar the priest was from Anathoth (1 Kings 2:26).

Modernised from Georges AndréOriginal wording

Anathoth lay in Benjamin — Saul's own tribe. Chronicles records the men who came to David while Saul was still hunting him. That list begins with Benjamin:

The first men that are named were the very last that man would have expected — the men of Benjamin... God showed His sovereignty and His gracious purpose by calling "Saul's kinsmen" out of that very tribe... So we must never lose heart. We must never suppose that any circumstances can hinder the way of God.

Modernised from William KellyOriginal wording

Mebunnai the Hushathite

The second man carries a family title, not a record of deeds. Another of David's soldiers carries the same title.

Hushathite. Designation of Sibbecai and Mebunnai, two of David's mighty men, probably of the family of Hushah. 2 Sam. 21:18; 2 Sam. 23:27; 1 Chr. 11:29; 1 Chr. 20:4; 1 Chr. 27:11.

Modernised from Morrish Bible DictionaryOriginal wording

Where Such Men Began

None of these soldiers arrived as heroes. They came to David in the cave of Adullam when he was an outlaw, and what he made of them is the real marvel of the list.

David is able to create, to form, the most wretched beings in his own image. The reflection of his moral beauty falls on those who have nothing to bring him but their misery. In the dark cave of Adullam the light shining from David shines on these four hundred men who surround him. Grace made something of them in the day of trouble. In the day of glory, which is already approaching, all eyes will recognize it and every mouth will acclaim it. All these outlaws will surround the king's throne and will be called "David's mighty men."

Modernised from H. L. RossierOriginal wording

The Day the List Is Read Out

Standing with David cost his men something. One writer follows their reward forward, to another King and another day.

David's men were called, because of their link with him, to undergo much toil and fatigue, but love made it all light and easy to them. Their names and exploits were recorded and faithfully remembered when David was at rest in his kingdom. None were forgotten. Men may not see, know, or even think of such acts; but Jesus knows them, and will declare them openly from the throne of His glory. Who would ever have known the acts of David's worthies if the Holy Spirit had not recorded them?

Modernised from C. H. MackintoshOriginal wording

Summary

- Written up. God "writes up the people" — Abiezer and Mebunnai have a name and a place in His record, while Joab, the famous commander, has none.

- Gathered. They came out of Adullam with nothing but their misery; grace formed them into the king's mighty men.

- Placed. Abiezer's Anathoth was a priests' town in Benjamin — Saul's tribe — the last place men would look for David's loyalists, and the first place God names.

- Unrecorded. Some names carry no deed at all, and that is the comfort: no name and no deed, even the smallest, will be forgotten.

- Declared. What no one saw, Jesus knows, and will announce publicly from the throne of His glory.

2 Samuel 23:28 · Darby

Zalmon the Ahohite, Maharai the Netophathite,

Two names sit deep in the roll of David's warriors, with no battle, no exploit, just a family and a home town. Why does Scripture keep men whose deeds it never tells, and what does that say about service no one sees?

Two names among the thirty

Both men belong to the last and largest group of the list, placed after the more famous few. That lower place is not neglect.

Finally we find the "thirty," less renowned than the six men before them, although the Lord forgets none of His own.

Modernised from H. L. RossierOriginal wording

The name David never erased

This same list ends with a name that shamed the king who kept it.

When David looked over the list of his servants, his eyes must have paused with sorrow at the name of Uriah the Hittite, which ends the list. He was among the mighty men, and not the least of those hearts devoted to the king and his people. And David had him put to death to satisfy his own lust! His name stayed there as a witness against the man he had served... But David condemned himself and honoured the grace that had restored him. He would never have dreamed of erasing that name from the book where it was written.

Modernised from H. L. RossierOriginal wording

A family and a home town

Everything known about the first man fits in one line.

An Ahohite, one of David's mighty men. 2 Samuel 23:28. Apparently called Ilai in 1 Chronicles 11:29.

Modernised from Morrish Bible DictionaryOriginal wording

The entry for the second man is just as short, but his name turns up three times in Scripture.

The Netophathite, one of David's mighty men. 2 Samuel 23:28; 1 Chronicles 11:30; 1 Chronicles 27:13.

Modernised from Morrish Bible DictionaryOriginal wording

Two lists, and honest gaps

The same roll appears again in Chronicles, with differences. Commentators admit that a bare name like this one leaves questions open.

Of the thirty (thirty-one), known only by their names, little can be said until they have been studied more closely. Chronicles, it is well known, gives practically the same list (1 Chronicles 11), with additions at the end. Yet it differs considerably when we come to details... Let the people of God study His word; dig deep, and expect much; and we shall soon have few such gaps in our knowledge as we have to lament here.

Modernised from Numerical Bible NotesOriginal wording

Each man keeps his own place on the roll

The chapter reads like an official register, and the ranks in it are fixed — a man of the thirty stays in the thirty.

Each one has his own special place on the roll, and each one his place in the Master's heart; and all will come out by and by. Among David's mighty men we have "the first three" — "the three" and "the thirty." Not one of "the thirty" ever reached a place among "the three."

Modernised from C. H. MackintoshOriginal wording

What put these men on the list

The list praises neither man for strength or skill. They are here because they stood by a king others rejected.

The mighty men of David shared in his glory just as they had shared in his rejection. They had suffered with him, and now they reigned with him. That is the divine order. Before the day of Christ's glorious reign dawns, we are allowed to suffer with Him. Then, like David's soldiers, we shall know our Lord Jesus Christ and His perfections in a special way, and prove Him to be "our life, our all."... The mighty men were David's. They knew the one to whom they belonged. They had confidence in the one they served and suffered with. That is the secret.

Modernised from H J VineOriginal wording

A list still to be read out

This roll appears at the end, after the years of conflict. One writer says a similar reckoning is coming, and it may reverse today's reputations.

Right now we know very little about how far people are true to the Lord. But the time will come when everyone will be shown for what they are. Every hidden thing will be unmasked, and every secret matter brought to light. Then everything will appear in its true value. Those who are thought much of now may be absent altogether from the list of the faithful. And many whose service is valued at little now may then shine out to the abundant praise and honour of the Lord Jesus... So with David's men. From the start at Adullam's cave they went through many a conflict, endured many a danger, fought many a battle. But at the end the worthies appear, according to the real worth of their service and the character of their devotion to David.

Modernised from H H SnellOriginal wording

Summary

- Recorded, not forgotten. These two stand in the lowest group of the roll, yet the Lord forgets none of His own — grace even kept Uriah's name there.

- Recorded by origin. One is known by his family and appears elsewhere as Ilai. The other is known by his home town, and his name appears three times.

- Recorded with gaps. Samuel and Chronicles differ in detail. When a name tells us little, dig deeper into God's word rather than invent.

- Recorded in order. Each servant has his own place on the page and his own place in the Master's heart. No one of the thirty ever moved up into the three.

- Recorded to be read out. This roll came at the end, after these men had shared David's rejection. A coming day will do the same: it will bring hidden service to light, and it may overturn many of today's reputations.

2 Samuel 23:29 · Darby

Heleb the son of Baanah, the Netophathite, Ittai the son of Ribai of Gibeah of the children of Benjamin,

Two more names close the middle of the roll of David's fighting men: Heleb of Netophah, and Ittai of Gibeah in Benjamin. Scripture records no deed for either man — only a name, a father, and a home town. So why does God keep them on the list at all?

A Roll God Keeps

This list belongs to God, not to David. One writer ties it to the honour God was giving David:

If God honours and glorifies David, He does not forget those whom the energy of David's faith had brought around him. The Holy Spirit lists the mighty men of David, and recounts their deeds of valour and devotedness. Those deeds win them a name and a place when God writes up the people (Psalm 87). Joab is not among them.

Modernised from J. N. DarbyOriginal wording

Names Preserved, Deeds Untold

The two Bible records of this list do not agree on every detail. One commentator faces that squarely, and says what to do about it:

Of the thirty (thirty-one), known only by their names, little can be said until we study them more closely. Chronicles, as is well known, gives practically the same list (1 Chron. 11), with additions at the end, yet differs considerably when we come to details. It is just in such lists as this, left dry and barren by our neglect, that we may expect to find plenty of textual errors... Let the people of God study His word; dig deep, and expect much. Then we shall soon have few such gaps in our knowledge as we have to regret here.

Modernised from Numerical Bible NotesOriginal wording

Heleb is a case in point. A reference work, under the entry for his father Baanah, gives both spellings:

Father of Heleb, or Heled, one of David's mighty men. 2 Sam. 23:29; 1 Chr. 11:30.

Modernised from Morrish Bible DictionaryOriginal wording

A Man Out Of Saul's Own Tribe

Ittai comes from Gibeah in Benjamin. The same reference work gives his tribe and the other spelling of his name:

Son of Ribai a Benjamite, and one of David's mighty men. 2 Sam. 23:29. Called ITHAI in 1 Chr. 11:31.

Modernised from Morrish Bible DictionaryOriginal wording

That tribe matters. Another commentator writes about the men of Benjamin who came to David while Saul still hunted him:

The first men named were the very last that anyone would have expected — the men of Benjamin. It is not that there were many of them. They were slow afterwards. Even when David came to the throne, the men of Benjamin still clung to the house of Saul. As a tribe they were slow. But God showed His sovereignty and His gracious purpose by calling "Saul's kinsmen" out of that very tribe... So we must never be discouraged; we must never suppose that any circumstances can hinder the way of God. God will bring out people for the name of the Lord Jesus in the very last place you expect.

Modernised from William KellyOriginal wording

Ranks, And No One Displaced

Heleb and Ittai belong to the thirty, the lowest of the three ranks in this chapter. That rank is no slight:

Out of the many thousands of Israel... there were relatively few who stood out by personal devotedness and wholehearted consecration. Even among those few there were clear differences. There were "the thirty," "the three," and "the first three." Each gets his own place on the page of the book of responsible, practical life. The place matches what he was, or what he had done... Nothing is forgotten, but all is faithfully recorded; and no one can ever take another's place. Each does his own work, fills his own place, and gets his own reward.

Modernised from C. H. MackintoshOriginal wording

Shared Hardship, Shared Joy

These men joined a king while others still refused him. One commentator looks ahead from their joy to the day of Christ's glory:

Besides those already named, thirty more appear in the list of David's mighty men... Then we read of others who shared David's rejection, "while he could not move about freely because of Saul the son of Kish." ... When the time of conflict and strain was over, their hearts would rejoice! They had the honour of sharing those days of struggle with David. And when the day of Christ's glory dawns in heavenly beauty, the joy will be great indeed. It will be the joy of those who have shared today in the conflicts for His name's sake and for the good of all His own.

Modernised from H. J. VineOriginal wording

Summary

- Gathered. The energy of David's faith drew these men around him while others refused him, and God did not forget them.

- Named. Heleb and Ittai have no recorded deed — only a name, a father, a home town. God keeps the names anyway, and commentators urge us to dig deeper into such lists.

- Unexpected. Ittai came from Gibeah in Benjamin, Saul's own tribe; God calls people out of the very place you would least expect.

- Ranked. The thirty stand below the three, but no one loses by it. Each has his own place, his own work, and his own reward.

- Rewarded. Those who share the rejection of the true King now will share the joy when His glory dawns.

2 Samuel 23:30 · Darby

Benaiah a Pirathonite, Hiddai of the brooks of Gaash,

This verse gives us two names and two places, and nothing else: a man from Pirathon, and a man from the valleys of Gaash. Both belong to "the thirty" who fought for David. They are named and nothing more. So why did God write them down at all?

Two names, two homes

A Bible dictionary ties the first man to his town and lists where his name appears:

One of David's valiant men, a Pirathonite. 2 Sam. 23:30; 1 Chr. 11:31; 1 Chr. 27:14.

Modernised from Morrish Bible DictionaryOriginal wording

The second man takes his name from a valley. Elsewhere he appears under another name:

A hill in the district of mount Ephraim, on the side of which Joshua was buried. Joshua 24:30; Judges 2:9. Hiddai, or Hurai, was of or from "the brooks [valleys, margin] of Gaash." 2 Sam. 23:30; 1 Chr. 11:32.

Modernised from Morrish Bible DictionaryOriginal wording

So Hiddai's home lay near Joshua's burial place.

Why the list exists

One writer ties the whole list to God's memory of the men David's faith had drawn around him. He also points out who is missing — Joab:

If God honours and glorifies David, He does not forget those whom the energy of David's faith had brought around him. The Holy Spirit lists David's mighty men and records their deeds of courage and devotion — deeds that win them a name and a place when God writes up the people (Psalm 87). Joab is not among them.

Modernised from J. N. DarbyOriginal wording

Named, with no deed attached

These two men get no exploit. Other names in the chapter carry a record of what they did; these two carry only a name and a hometown. One writer finds a clear meaning in that silence:

Others are named too, and of them we read no definite deeds. The last name is Uriah the Hittite. The spiritual meaning is not hard to find. Before the judgment seat of Christ everything will be brought to light. When He comes as the righteous Ruler, to bring in the morning without clouds, He will remember those who were loyal and devoted to Him while He was rejected. No name and no deed, even the smallest, will be forgotten then. What an incentive this should be, especially in the solemn days in which we live, as we see the day approaching! It should stir us to serve Him, and to be as devoted to our absent but coming Lord as David's mighty men were to him.

Modernised from Arno Clemens GaebeleinOriginal wording

Each man in his own rank

The chapter sorts these men into grades, and this verse sits in the last group. One writer sees God's own record-keeping in that order:

Each one has his own special place on the roll, and each one his place in the Master's heart; and all will come out by and by. Among David's mighty men we have "the first three," "the three," and "the thirty." Not one of "the thirty" ever reached a place among "the three," and not one of "the three" ever reached "the first three."

Modernised from C. H. MackintoshOriginal wording

A fixed rank is no demotion.

Near the king, and owing him everything

The thirty lived close to David and learned from him. One writer follows that loyalty through to the present day:

The thirty mighty men who were with David had a place close to him. No doubt they learned lessons from him that won them the distinctions they received. They owed all to David. They were right to respect Joab and the other captains, but David stood first in all their hearts and minds. He was God's anointed one. There must be no rival. All others are fellow-helpers in the war. It is just so today. We are to hold those who lead in the Lord's service in the highest esteem because of their work. But there is only One who is to have the first place. God has decreed concerning the Son of His love, the Head of all things and Head of the church, that in all things He should have the pre-eminence. Every true heart answers: He is worthy! He alone is worthy!

Modernised from H J VineOriginal wording

The same honour promised again

One writer reads these records as something God delights to do — and will do again:

God loves to mention what brings honour to His people. So after each of their names we find a record of their deeds. The Lord will do this and more for those who now, and at any time, have lived and suffered for the name of the Lord.

Modernised from William KellyOriginal wording

Summary

- Named. Benaiah's town was Pirathon. Hiddai came from the valleys of Gaash, near the hill where Joshua was buried; Chronicles calls him Hurai.

- Remembered. God does not forget the men David's faith drew around him. Joab's name is missing, while these two are kept.

- Recorded. Some men, like these two, appear with no deed attached. Writers point ahead to the judgment seat of Christ, where no name and no deed will be forgotten.

- Ranked. First three, three, thirty — each man keeps his own place on the roll and in the Master's heart, while only One holds the first place of all.

- Rewarded. God loves to mention what honours His people. He will do this and more for those who suffer for the name of the Lord.

2 Samuel 23:31 · Darby

Abi-albon the Arbathite, Azmaveth the Barhumite,

This verse names two men, each tied to a home village. No deed is recorded for either. They belong to "the thirty" — the wider band of men who stood by David while he was still a hunted, rejected king. Why does Scripture bother to keep such a list, and what does it mean to be on it with nothing recorded beside your name?

Names Worth Keeping

Abi-albon appears again in a second list of the same warriors, under another name. A Bible dictionary traces the overlap:

One of David's mighty men, 1 Chronicles 11:32; he is called Abi-Albon in 2 Samuel 23:31.

Modernised from Morrish Bible DictionaryOriginal wording

These names survive because God chose to write them down. David's rise did not push his companions into the background:

If God honours and glorifies David, He does not forget those whom the energy of David's faith had brought around him. The Holy Spirit lists the mighty men of David. He recounts their deeds of valour and devotion — deeds which win them a name and a place when God writes up the people (Psalm 87). Joab is not among them.

Modernised from J. N. DarbyOriginal wording

Ranks Within the List

The chapter sorts these men into grades, and this verse sits in the lowest of them. Those grades never changed, yet every man had his own place:

Each one has his own special place on the roll, and each one his place in the Master's heart; and all will come out by and by. Among David's mighty men, we have "the first three" — "the three" and "the thirty." Not one of "the thirty" ever reached a place among "the three;" nor did one of "the three" ever reach the first three.

Modernised from C. H. MackintoshOriginal wording

No Deeds Attached

Earlier men in the chapter have their battles described in detail. Abi-albon and Azmaveth have none. That silence is itself part of the record, and it points forward:

They were the men who loved David, stood by him, and showed their loyalty and devotion to the King. Others are listed too, and we read of no definite deeds of theirs... The judgment seat of Christ will bring everything to light. When He comes as the righteous Ruler, to bring in the morning without clouds, He will remember those who were loyal and devoted to Him in His rejection. No name and no deed, even the smallest, will then be forgotten.

Modernised from Arno Clemens GaebeleinOriginal wording

What Put Them There

What marked these men was closeness to the king, and letting no one rival him:

The thirty mighty men who were with David had a near place to him. No doubt they learned lessons from him which secured the distinctions that became theirs. They owed everything to David. They would rightly esteem Joab and the other captains, but David was first in all their hearts and minds. He was God's anointed one. There must be no rival... God has decreed concerning the Son of His love, the Head of all things, the Head of the assembly, "that in everything he might be preeminent."

Modernised from H J VineOriginal wording

The Names That Are Absent

The roll is as striking for the names it leaves out as for those it keeps. Three of the most prominent men in the kingdom never appear:

Whatever we make of Jonathan, who so loved David, other names are completely absent from the list of mighty men. And Scripture is not quite silent about the reason why. Notice that the greatest warrior, the wisest counsellor and one of the chief religious officials are all absent from the list of the king's worthies. We refer to Joab, Ahithophel, and Abiathar.

Modernised from H H SnellOriginal wording

These omissions carry one warning:

These omissions in the list of David's faithful ones are painfully significant. They remind us with force of the prophet's words: "Let not the wise man boast in his wisdom, let not the mighty man boast in his might, let not the rich man boast in his riches, but let him who boasts boast in this, that he understands and knows me, that I am the LORD who practices steadfast love, justice, and righteousness in the earth. For in these things I delight, declares the LORD." (Jeremiah 9:23-24)

Modernised from H H SnellOriginal wording

Summary

- Written — God writes up His people by name; we know Abi-albon and Azmaveth only because the Spirit kept the record.

- Ranked — the chapter has "the first three," "the three" and "the thirty." Each man holds his own place on the roll and in the Master's heart.

- Silent — some names carry no recorded deed, yet the judgment seat of Christ will forget nothing, not even the smallest act.

- Near — the thirty were marked by closeness to the rejected king; they gave him first place and let no one rival him.

- Missing — the strongest soldier, the wisest adviser and a leading priest are all absent. So boast in knowing the Lord, not in might, wisdom or position.

2 Samuel 23:32 · Darby

Eliahba the Shaalbonite, of the sons of Jashen, Jonathan,

This verse sits near the end of the roll of David's warriors. It gives three entries with no story attached: a man from Shaalbon, a set of sons, and a Jonathan. So why does God's word record men whose only claim to fame is that they were there?

The Thirty

These three names fall in the last and lowest band of the list. Rossier sets that low rank beside the Lord's memory.

Finally we come to the "thirty." They are less famous than the six men before them. Yet the Lord forgets none of His own.

Modernised from H. L. RossierOriginal wording

Who Wrote the List

Who put these names on the page? Darby names the Author behind the record, and points to a day when God writes up His own people.

If God honours and glorifies David, He does not forget the men that David's energetic faith had gathered around him. The Holy Spirit lists David's mighty men. He records their deeds of courage and devotion. Those deeds get them a name and a place when God writes up the people (Psalm 87). Joab is not among them.

Modernised from J. N. DarbyOriginal wording

Names Without Deeds

Eliahba, the sons of Jashen and Jonathan have no recorded deed. Gaebelein reads that silence as a pointer to the future.

They were the men who loved David, stood by him, showed their loyalty and devotion to the King. And others are given, of whom we read no definite deeds. The spiritual meaning is not hard to find. Before the judgment seat of Christ all will be made manifest. He will come as the righteous Ruler and bring in the morning without clouds. Then He will remember those who were loyal and devoted to Him while He was rejected. No name and no deed, even the smallest, will be forgotten then. What an incentive this should be to serve Him — especially in the serious days we live in, as we see the day approaching! We should be as devoted to our absent but coming Lord as David's mighty men were to him.

Modernised from Arno Clemens GaebeleinOriginal wording

Each in His Own Rank

The chapter ranks its men: the first three, the three, the thirty. Mackintosh sees in that order a picture of how God weighs each servant's work.

Israel had many thousands of people, circumcised members of the congregation, children of Abraham. Only a few of them stood out for personal devotion and wholehearted dedication to God. Even among those few there were marked differences. There were "the thirty," "the three," and "the first three." Each gets his own place on the page of the book of responsible, practical life. That place matches what he was and what he had done. Nothing is forgotten. Everything is written down faithfully, and no one can ever take another's place. Each does his own work, fills his own niche, and gets his own reward.

Modernised from C. H. MackintoshOriginal wording

The Jonathan Who Is Not Here

A Jonathan stands in this verse — but not the Jonathan most readers expect. Saul's son is missing from the whole chapter, and Wolston asks why.

Notice carefully what happens when David speaks of his mighty men. He records the deeds of the men who stayed faithful to him while he was rejected. The name of Jonathan is strikingly absent (2 Sam. 23). David could not rightly place his name among the mighty men as one who had stood out for loyalty during his exile. And I learn this lesson, that the Lord counts upon our hearts being true to Himself.

Modernised from W. T. P. WolstonOriginal wording

Still Waiting to Be Read

What can honestly be said about three names and nothing more? One writer admits the limit, then turns it into a challenge.

We know the thirty (really thirty-one) only by their names. Little can be said about them until they have been studied more closely. Chronicles gives almost the same list (1 Chron. 11), with extra names at the end. But it differs a great deal in the details. Let the people of God study His word. Dig deep, and expect much. Then we will soon have far fewer of the total gaps in our knowledge that we have to regret here.

Modernised from Numerical Bible NotesOriginal wording

Summary

- Recorded by God — the Holy Spirit lists these men. The record is His, and it gives each man a name and a place.

- Recorded though obscure — Eliahba, Jashen's sons and Jonathan sit in the thirty, the lowest rank. They are less famous than the six before them. Yet the Lord forgets none of His own.

- Recorded without deeds — some names carry no exploit at all. At the judgment seat of Christ no name and no deed, however small, will be forgotten.

- Recorded in rank — the first three, the three, the thirty: each keeps his own place, and no one can ever take another's.

- Recorded for loyalty in rejection — Saul's son Jonathan is missing from this chapter. The list honours hearts that stayed true to the king while he was rejected.

2 Samuel 23:33 · Darby

Shammah the Ararite, Ahiam the son of Sharar the Ararite,

This verse sits inside the long roll of David's warriors. It gives two men and almost nothing else: a name, a father, and a home town. Why does Scripture record soldiers whose deeds it never tells? And why does one of these names appear earlier in the same chapter?

The thirty, and the God who forgets none

These two men belong to the last and largest group in the list. They rank below the famous few whose feats fill the opening verses. One writer shows what that lower rank does not mean:

At last we come to the "thirty." They are less renowned than the six men before them, but the Lord forgets none of His own.

Modernised from H. L. RossierOriginal wording

Ahiam is one of many names here with no deed attached:

Many other names are also ranked among David's mighty men, with no special mark of devotion and no victories recorded.

Modernised from H H SnellOriginal wording

Shammah appears twice

A Shammah already stands earlier in the chapter, among the very greatest. One commentator links that earlier mention to a deliberate gap. Joab, the army's commander, is missing from the roll, and Shammah stands where Joab might have been:

Shammah the Hararite is placed after the other two instead, though Scripture does not say he was one of the three mightiest. He is named again in the ordinary list, in the proper order, in verse 33. But his devotion to David shone where even Joab, the greatest, failed. This honourable mention should encourage every servant of Christ to serve Him sincerely. He knows how to value true service for Himself.

Modernised from H J VineOriginal wording

What the names carry

One writer gives the meaning of the name Shammah and of the word "Hararite":

His own name means "astonishment," and he is the son of Agee, perhaps "sprout," the Hararite, or "mountaineer." Words like these fit together easily with the lesson of his acts. The power of revival is found in the man who has learned, on a rough and difficult path, the awe of the God of resurrection.

Modernised from Numerical Bible NotesOriginal wording

The parallel list in 1 Chronicles 11 does not match this one at every point. The same writer treats the differences as an invitation to study:

Of the thirty (thirty-one), known only by their names, little can be said until they have been studied more closely. Chronicles gives much the same list (1 Chron. 11), with additions at the end, yet it differs a great deal in the details… Let the people of God study His word. Dig deep, and expect much. Then we shall soon have few such wide gaps in our knowledge as we have to lament here.

Modernised from Numerical Bible NotesOriginal wording

Why the list exists

The chapter has just recorded David's last words and his own honour. What follows shows that God's memory does not stop with the king:

If God honours and glorifies David, He does not forget those whom the energy of David's faith had brought around him. The Holy Spirit lists the mighty men of David and tells of their brave and devoted deeds. Those deeds win them a name and a place when God writes up the people (Psalm 87). Joab is not among them.

Modernised from J. N. DarbyOriginal wording

A list still being written

One writer reads this roll of loyal men forward to the day when Christ rewards His own:

They were the men who loved David, stood by him, and showed their loyalty and devotion to the King. Others are named too, whose deeds we never read… At the judgment seat of Christ everything will be brought to light. When He comes as the righteous Ruler, to bring in the morning without clouds, He will remember those who were loyal and devoted to Him while He was rejected. No name and no deed, even the smallest, will then be forgotten.

Modernised from Arno Clemens GaebeleinOriginal wording

Summary

- Remembered. Ahiam has no recorded deed, yet his name stands in the roll — "the Lord forgets none of His own."

- Ranked. He belongs to the thirty, "less renowned" than the first six. Honour has degrees, but no one is dropped.

- Repeated. Shammah is named again here, "in the proper order," after standing earlier in the place where Joab's name is missing.

- Researched. The gaps and the differences from Chronicles are a call to "dig deep, and expect much," not a reason to skip the chapter.

- Rewarded. Loyalty to the king in his rejection secures "a name and a place." No deed, "even the smallest," will be forgotten.

2 Samuel 23:34 · Darby

Eliphelet the son of Ahasbai, the son of the Maachathite, Eliam the son of Ahithophel the Gilonite,

Two names close verse 34: Eliphelet of Maacah and Eliam, whose father was Ahithophel the Gilonite. The second name carries a whole story. Ahithophel was David's own counsellor, and he later turned against him. This quiet line in the roll of honour keeps that history on record.

A place among the thirty

Verse 34 sits near the end of the list. Here the names come fast, and the record tells no stories of their deeds. One writer points out what that lower rank does not mean:

Last we find the "thirty." They are less famous than the six men before them, though the Lord forgets none of His own.

Modernised from H. L. RossierOriginal wording

The list has fixed ranks, and no man moves from one to another:

Each one has his own special place on the roll, and each one his place in the Master's heart. One day it will all come out. Among David's mighty men we have "the first three," "the three," and "the thirty." No one of "the thirty" ever reached a place among "the three." And no one of "the three" ever reached "the first three."

Modernised from C. H. MackintoshOriginal wording

A son named, a father missing

Eliam is here. Ahithophel appears only as his father. Commentators read that absence as a verdict on a gifted man whose loyalty failed:

Ahithophel, David's counsellor, and highly praised for his wisdom, is also absent from this list of worthies, though Eliam his son ranked among them. He was David's companion and close friend. Yet when temptation came he fell away completely. He showed that, for all his shrewdness, his heart was not true to God's anointed... no amount of wisdom will make up for a lack of uprightness and real devotion.

Modernised from H. H. SnellOriginal wording

Who Ahithophel was

The verse calls him "the Gilonite." A reference summary gathers his story:

A Gilonite, grandfather of Bathsheba, and a very wise counsellor of David... He joined in the rebellion of Absalom, and advised him to go in publicly to David's concubines, and to let Ahithophel himself make an immediate attack on David. Absalom did not follow that second piece of advice. He preferred the advice of Hushai, who was acting for David. So Ahithophel returned to his house, set his household in order, and hanged himself... He has generally been taken as foreshadowing Judas of the New Testament.

Modernised from Morrish Bible DictionaryOriginal wording

Why the family link matters

The name Ahithophel ties this verse to David's great sin. One writer traces Absalom's success in recruiting him back to a family wound:

How was it that Absalom had the nerve to send for David's trusted counsellor? This was another piece of sorrowful reaping of former sin. Ahithophel appears to have been Bathsheba's grandfather. We can well understand that he had never forgiven David for the way he treated his granddaughter.

Modernised from George C. WillisOriginal wording

The name that Chronicles leaves out

1 Chronicles 11 repeats the same roll of mighty men, but Eliam's name is missing there. Two omissions in that account point the same way:

Uriah the Hittite, who closes the list in 2 Samuel 23 as a testimony against David's sin and fall, appears here hidden among the other mighty men (v. 41). His name is not highlighted as the accuser of David and of what was the shame of his kingdom. In the same way, this account says nothing at all about the terrible fall of the Lord's anointed. Eliam too is left out of our chapter. He was the son of Ahithophel (2 Sam. 23:34), and his father was closely bound up with the consequences of David's sin.

Modernised from H. L. RossierOriginal wording

Summary

- Remembered. Eliam stands among "the thirty" — the least celebrated rank of David's men — yet Scripture keeps his name, because the Lord forgets none of His own.

- Ranked. Each man keeps his own place on the roll and his own place in the Master's heart. No one of the thirty ever rose to the three.

- Missing. Ahithophel appears only as a father, never as a worthy. Brilliance in counsel could not make up for a heart that was not true to God's anointed.

- Reaping. Ahithophel was Bathsheba's grandfather. He never forgave David, and his turn to Absalom was a sorrowful reaping of former sin.

- Covered. 1 Chronicles 11 repeats the list, but drops Eliam's name and hides Uriah in the crowd. That account keeps silent about the king's shame.

2 Samuel 23:35 · Darby

Hezrai the Carmelite, Paarai the Arbite,

Two more names close the roll of David's warriors, and each one gets a home town and nothing else. Why would God keep a bare name in His record when no story goes with it?

Two Names, Two Spellings

Both men appear again in a parallel list, which spells their names differently. A Bible dictionary notes the other form of the first name:

Hezro. A Carmelite, one of David's valiant men. 1 Chronicles 11:37. Doubtless the same as Hezrai.

Modernised from Morrish Bible DictionaryOriginal wording

The same source is less sure about the second man:

Naarai. Son of Ezbai and one of David's mighty men. 1 Chronicles 11:37. Perhaps, as in the margin, the same as Paarai the Arbite in 2 Samuel 23:35.

Modernised from Morrish Bible DictionaryOriginal wording

A Register Kept by God

The list is not David's private honours board. One writer sees the Spirit of God Himself keeping it:

If God honours and glorifies David, He does not forget those whom the energy of David's faith had brought around him. The Holy Spirit lists the mighty men of David, and recounts their deeds of valour and devotion. These deeds win them a name and a place when God writes up the people (Psalm 87). Joab is not among them.

Modernised from J. N. DarbyOriginal wording

Names Without a Deed Attached

Verse 35 sits in a long stretch of the chapter that gives names and nothing more. One commentator takes that silence as part of the point:

They were the men who loved David, stood by him, showed their loyalty and devotion to the King. The record gives others too, and we read of no definite deeds for them... Before the judgment seat of Christ everything will be brought to light. He is coming to be the righteous Ruler and to bring in the morning without clouds. Then He will remember those who were loyal and devoted to Him while He was rejected. No name and no deed, even the smallest, will then be forgotten.

Modernised from Arno Clemens GaebeleinOriginal wording

Short notices like this are not unique to the chapter. Another writer finds the same habit right through Scripture:

As I close, I would only note how short the notice given to all these worthy men; hardly any of them appear again in Scripture... But is this not God's usual way? How short the account of Onesiphorus visiting the apostle in the Roman dungeon — yet Paul made such striking notice of the refreshment it brought.

Modernised from The Christian's FriendOriginal wording

What Put a Man on the List

If the roll rewarded achievement, the best soldier in the kingdom would head it. He is missing. That tells us what the list really measures:

What marked out David's mighty men, then, was the link grace had given them with the Lord's anointed. Joab never had such a link, and this book has shown that fully. He served David for his own advantage, and his actions never came out of fellowship with his head. His name is passed over in silence.

Modernised from H. L. RossierOriginal wording

From the Cave to the Roll of Honour

Men like Hezro and Paarai did not begin as heroes. The same writer traces the list back to the men who first gathered to David in the cave of Adullam:

David is able to create, to form, the most wretched people in his own image. The reflection of his moral beauty falls on those who have nothing to bring him but their misery. In the dark cave of Adullam the light shining from David falls on these four hundred men around him. What grace made of them in the day of trouble will be recognized by all eyes and acclaimed by every mouth in the day of glory, which is already approaching. All these outlaws will surround the king's throne and will be called "David's mighty men" (2 Samuel 23:8).

Modernised from H. L. RossierOriginal wording

Why the Record Was Written Down

For a reader today, the point lands on service that no one sees:

Their names and deeds were recorded and faithfully remembered when David was at rest in his kingdom. None were forgotten... Men may never see these acts, know them, or think about them; but Jesus knows them, and will declare them openly from the throne of His glory. Who would ever have known the acts of David's worthy men if the Holy Spirit had not recorded them? Who would have known of the three who drew water from the well of Bethlehem? Who would have known of the killing of a lion in a pit, in the time of snow?

Modernised from C. H. MackintoshOriginal wording

Summary

- Cave. The men on this roll started as outcasts around a rejected king. Grace, not rank, made them mighty men.

- Company. A place on the list comes from being joined to the anointed king. That is why the roll leaves out Joab, the ablest soldier of all.

- Record. The Holy Spirit, not David, keeps the register. Such deeds win a name and a place when God writes up the people.

- Brevity. A short notice, or a name with no deed at all, is God's usual way. A brief record loses nothing.

- Reward. Jesus will declare from the throne of glory what no one sees now. No name and no deed, even the smallest, will be forgotten.

2 Samuel 23:36 · Darby

Igal the son of Nathan of Zobah, Bani the Gadite,

Two names sit side by side in the long roll of David's warriors, and Scripture tells us nothing else about either man. The chapter that began with David's last words ends with a list of the men who stood by him, which raises one question: why record names attached to no famous deed?

Names without stories

Most of this chapter's fame belongs to a handful of heroes. The list runs far past them, and at this end of it the men appear as names only.

The records and the names of David's mighty men fit this last great prophecy of the King. They were the men who loved David, stood by him, showed their loyalty and devotion to the King. And others are given, of whom we read no definite deeds... Before the judgment seat of Christ everything will be brought to light. He will come as the righteous Ruler, to bring in the morning without clouds. Then He will remember those who were loyal and devoted to Him while He was rejected. No name and no deed, even the smallest, will then be forgotten.

Modernised from Arno Clemens GaebeleinOriginal wording

What made a man "mighty"

Igal and Bani count as mighty men on the same basis as the rest. That basis was not ability. Joab served David, yet the chapter never names him.

So what marked out David's mighty men was the link grace had given them with the Lord's anointed. Joab never had such a link; this book has shown that fully. He served David for his own interest, and his actions never sprang from fellowship with his leader. His name is passed over in silence.

Modernised from H. L. RossierOriginal wording

The same writer asks what kept three of these men from giving way.

Had they been alone they certainly would have weakened, but all three were "with David" and under his eyes during the combat. He inspired them with courage and patience in their efforts.

Modernised from H. L. RossierOriginal wording

Room on the list for outsiders

The verse ties Igal to Zobah, not to an Israelite tribe. That fits a roll which makes room for men from outside Israel.

The Lord did not overlook "the sons of the stranger" at a time when He was blessing Israel so richly. For the Spirit of God, "when He writes up the people," graciously includes in the list of David's mighty men, Zelek the Ammonite (1 Chron. 11:39), Uriah the Hittite (verse 41), and Ithmah the Moabite (verse 46).

Modernised from The Bible TreasuryOriginal wording

The Gadite

Bani carries only his tribe: Gadite. One writer says this tribe had chosen less than what God offered them.

They had chosen what suited themselves and their flocks (Numbers 32), instead of the land flowing with milk and honey... They had sunk far below the height of their calling. For that very reason it is all the more striking that God was still working in power among them. The very words used to describe this company show the mighty effects of grace... "men trained in war, expert with shield and spear, whose faces were like the faces of lions and who were swift as gazelles upon the mountains." ... For David's sake they had abandoned home and everything.

Modernised from The Christian's FriendOriginal wording

Ranks, and no one left off

The chapter sorts its men into grades, and no one moves between them. Yet the sorting leaves no one off the page.

Each servant of God has his own special place on the roll, and each one his place in the Master's heart; and all will come out by and by. Among David's mighty men we have "the first three," "the three," and "the thirty." Not one of "the thirty" ever reached a place among "the three." And not one of "the three" ever reached "the first three."

Modernised from C. H. MackintoshOriginal wording

Why the record exists

The record came when the fighting was over and the king they had suffered with was at rest.

Because they belonged to David, his men had to go through much toil and weariness. But love made it all light and easy to them. Their names and deeds were recorded and faithfully remembered when David was at rest in his kingdom. None were forgotten... Men may never see these acts, know them, or even think of them. But Jesus knows them, and He will declare them openly from the throne of His glory.

Modernised from C. H. MackintoshOriginal wording

Summary

- Named — Igal and Bani have no recorded exploit, yet they are on the roll. No name and no deed, even the smallest, will be forgotten.

- Counted — what qualified a man was the link grace gave him with the anointed king. Joab served David for himself, and his name is missing.

- Sustained — the men who did not weaken were the men who fought "with David," under his eye.

- Welcomed — the list reaches out to the stranger, and to a tribe that had settled for less than God offered.

- Ranked and rewarded — the thirty never became the three. Yet each has his own place on the roll and in the Master's heart, and Jesus will declare his work from the throne of His glory.

2 Samuel 23:37 · Darby

Zelek the Ammonite, Naharai the Beerothite, the armour-bearer of Joab the son of Zeruiah,

Two more names appear on the roll of David's warriors: a man from Ammon, and the man who carried Joab's armour. Both raise the same question — who gets a name in God's list of the mighty, and why?

The roll God keeps

This list is more than a war record. One writer reads it as God's own memory of the men David's faith drew to him:

If God honours and glorifies David, He does not forget those whom the energy of David's faith had brought around him. The Holy Spirit lists the mighty men of David. He recounts their deeds of courage and devotion — deeds that win them a name and a place when God writes up the people (Psalm 87). Joab is not among them.

Modernised from J. N. DarbyOriginal wording

Zelek the Ammonite

The law had a standing ruling about Ammonites:

"No Ammonite or Moabite shall enter the assembly of the LORD. Even to their tenth generation none of them shall enter the assembly of the LORD forever." … The LORD does not forget where it is a matter of government. He does forget — and that is exactly what He does — when it is a question of grace.

Modernised from William KellyOriginal wording

Yet Zelek stands in the list. He is one of several outsiders God kept a place for:

The sons of the stranger were not overlooked at a time when the Lord so generously blessed Israel. For the Spirit of God, "when He writes up the people," graciously includes in the list of David's mighty men Zelek the Ammonite (1 Chron. 11:39), Uriah the Hittite (verse 41), and Ithmah the Moabite (verse 46).

Modernised from The Bible TreasuryOriginal wording

Naharai the Beerothite

The second name points to a town, not a nation. Beeroth came into Israel by deception:

One of the four cities of the Hivites which deceived Joshua into making a treaty of peace. It was given to Benjamin… The inhabitants of the city were called BEEROTHITES (2 Sam. 4:2-9; 2 Sam. 23:37; 1 Chr. 11:39).

Modernised from Morrish Bible DictionaryOriginal wording

Armour-bearer to Joab

Naharai has no feat of his own in the list. His job is his entry — and that job was not a small one:

An attendant on a warrior, filling a place of trust and honour. When Saul loved David he made him his armour-bearer (1 Sam. 16:21).

Modernised from Morrish Bible DictionaryOriginal wording

The servant made the list. His master did not. One writer fills in who that master was:

Joab was David's nephew (1 Chronicles 2:18), and commander-in-chief of his forces. He showed much courage in war, but he was revengeful, and all through he seems not to have been in communion with the king's mind. So instead of Joab being in the list of David's worthies (though his brother Asahel and Joab's armour-bearer were there), this man of rank and power, famous among men, fell under the judgment of Solomon. Solomon took his great power and ruled the kingdom in righteousness.

Modernised from H. H. SnellOriginal wording

Why Joab's name is missing

So why is Joab's servant in the list while Joab is not? One writer points to what the list measures:

What characterised David's mighty men was the association that grace had given them with the Lord's anointed. Joab never had such a relationship; this book has fully shown it. He sought his own interest in serving David, and his actions never came out of fellowship with his head. His name is passed over in silence.

Modernised from H. L. RossierOriginal wording

From the cave to the list of honour

None of these men started out as heroes. They came to David while men rejected him, and he made them what they became:

All these found a sure refuge with David, as is found today with a rejected Christ. But they found much more. David is able to form the most wretched beings into his own image. The reflection of his moral beauty falls on those who have nothing to bring him but their misery. … All these outlaws will surround the king's throne and will be called "David's mighty men."

Modernised from H. L. RossierOriginal wording

Summary

- Grace names. Zelek is an Ammonite. The law barred his nation from the assembly for ever — yet God writes his name among the mighty. Government remembers; grace forgets.

- Grace reaches. Naharai comes from Beeroth, a town that got into Israel by deceiving Joshua. God does not overlook the sons of the stranger.

- Grace honours the small place. Naharai's entry is that he carried Joab's armour — an attendant's role, but a place of trust and honour. God records the servant.

- Grace, not rank, decides. Joab's armour-bearer is in the list; Joab is not. Rank and victories do not qualify a man. Closeness to the rejected king does. Self-interest gets silence.

- Grace finishes what it starts. The men of the cave brought David nothing but their misery, and he formed them into his own likeness. The roll of the mighty is the last chapter of that story.

2 Samuel 23:38 · Darby

Ira the Ithrite, Gareb the Ithrite,

Two men appear side by side near the end of the roll of David's champions. No exploit, no enemy killed, no battlefield — just two names and one family label, set among warriors whose deeds fill the earlier verses.

A list the Spirit chose to keep

One writer reads the list as God's answer to the men whom David's faith had drawn around him.

If God honours and glorifies David, He does not forget those whom the energy of David's faith had brought around him. The Holy Spirit lists the mighty men of David and records their brave and devoted deeds. Those deeds win them a name and a place when God writes up the people (Psalm 87). Joab is not among them.

Modernised from J. N. DarbyOriginal wording

What "Ithrite" tells us

The word marks a family. It ties both men to one place and one tribe.

The family name of Ira and Gareb, two of David's mighty men. They are counted among "the families of Kirjath-jearim," which links them with Judah. 2 Sam. 23:38. 1 Chr. 2:53; 1 Chr. 11:40.

Modernised from Morrish Bible DictionaryOriginal wording

Watch the name Ira. Earlier in the same chapter a different man carries it: "son of Ikkesh a Tekoite, and one of David's mighty men" (Morrish Bible Dictionary). Two Iras, two families, one list.

Names we still cannot explain

One writer admits that these last names cannot yet be explained. He turns that gap into a call to study.

Of the thirty (thirty-one), known only by their names, little can be said until they have been studied more closely. Chronicles gives practically the same list (1 Chronicles 11), with additions at the end, yet differs a great deal when we come to the details. These lists have been left dry and barren through our neglect, and it is just in lists like this that we should expect to find many errors in the text... Let the people of God study His word. Dig deep, and expect much. Then we will soon have few of the complete gaps in our knowledge that we have to regret here.

Modernised from Frederick W. GrantOriginal wording

Least famous, not forgotten

Ira and Gareb belong to the last and least famous group in the list. One writer sets that low rank beside the name that ends the roll.

Finally we find the "thirty," less famous than the six men before them, although the Lord forgets none of His own. When David looked over the list of His servants, his eyes must have stopped in sorrow at the name of Uriah the Hittite, which ends the list. He was among the mighty men, and not the least of those hearts devoted to the king and his people. And David had him put to death to satisfy his own lust! His name stayed there as a witness against the man he had served... But David condemned himself and exalted the grace that had restored him; he would never have dreamed of erasing his name from the book where it was recorded.

Modernised from H. L. RossierOriginal wording

Names left off the list

Some of the most powerful men in Israel are missing from the roll. One writer names all three.

Notice that the greatest warrior, the wisest counsellor, and one of the chief religious officials are all absent from the list of the king's honoured men. We mean Joab, Ahithophel, and Abiathar.

Modernised from H. H. SnellOriginal wording

So two unknown Ithrites with no recorded feat stand in the list, and those three famous men do not.

Why the list points forward

One writer sees in the record a picture of a coming day, when Christ returns as Ruler and forgets no loyal service.

They were the men who loved David, stood by him, showed their loyalty and devotion to the King. And others are given, of whom we read no definite deeds... Before the judgment seat of Christ all will be made manifest. When He comes to be the righteous Ruler... those will be remembered who were loyal and devoted to Him in His rejection. No name and no deed, even the smallest, will then be forgotten.

Modernised from Arno C. GaebeleinOriginal wording

Summary

- Named. The Holy Spirit put Ira and Gareb in the record. Their deeds "win them a name and a place when God writes up the people."

- Placed. "Ithrite" is a family name. It counts both men "among the families of Kirjath-jearim," and so links them with Judah.

- Unexplained. Of these closing names "little can be said until they have been studied more closely." The honest answer is to dig, not to invent.

- Remembered. They rank among the least famous of the thirty, "although the Lord forgets none of His own." The same list keeps Uriah's name, which David "would never have dreamed of erasing."

- Rewarded. Of some in the list "we read no definite deeds." Yet "no name and no deed, even the smallest, will then be forgotten" when Christ returns to reign.

2 Samuel 23:39 · Darby

Uriah the Hittite thirty-seven in all.

Second Samuel closes its list of David's heroes with a count and one last name: Uriah, the man David had put to death. The list rewards the loyal, and that last line also accuses the king.

The Record God Keeps

This list is God's record, not just David's.

If God honours and glorifies David, He does not forget those whom the energy of David's faith had brought around him. The Holy Spirit lists David's mighty men and tells of their deeds of courage and devotion. Those deeds gain them a name and a place when God writes up the people (Psalm 87). Joab is not among them.

Modernised from J. N. DarbyOriginal wording

Those named here were not latecomers. One writer connects them with the men who stayed near Jesus through His whole ministry.

David had met other devoted men too, such as Ittai and Shobi, when he fled from Jerusalem. But those mentioned here were with him from the very beginning. In the same way the twelve disciples were marked out because they had been with the Lord "all the time that the Lord Jesus went in and out among" them (Luke 22:28-29; Acts 1:21).

Modernised from H. L. RossierOriginal wording

The Last Name

The verse names Uriah last. Picture David reading over his own list.

When David looked over the list of his servants, with what sorrow his eyes must have paused at the name of Uriah the Hittite that ends the list. He was among the mighty men, and not the least of those hearts devoted to the king and his people. And David had had him put to death to satisfy his own lust! His name stayed there as a witness against the one he had served. This single name of Uriah reminded David of all his past shame and chastening. But he condemned himself and exalted the grace that had restored him. He would never have dreamed of erasing that name from the book where it was recorded.

Modernised from H. L. RossierOriginal wording

The Same List In Chronicles

The verse ends with a number. Another record of these same men gives a different one.

1 Chronicles lists the mighty men at the start of its account; 2 Samuel 23 lists them at the end. Chronicles refers to 81 mighty men; 2 Samuel 23 names 37 of them. In Samuel they stand as supporters whom David needed to confirm his throne. In Chronicles they only acknowledge what God had done in making David His anointed. Uriah the Hittite, who closes the list in 2 Samuel 23 as a witness against David's sin and fall, appears in Chronicles hidden among the other mighty men (v. 41). His name is not highlighted as the accuser of David and of what was the shame of his kingdom. In the same way, everything to do with the terrible fall of the Lord's anointed is passed over in complete silence.

Modernised from Henri L. RossierOriginal wording

The Hittite

"The Hittite" marks Uriah as a foreigner, not an Israelite.

Later, in the days of David, the foreigner is kept honourably in view. We see this first in Uriah. He was a Hittite. Yet his faithfulness to the God of Israel and his self-giving zeal for Israel's cause shine out beautifully. They stand in contrast with even Israel's chief and noblest and best son in that day. This poor remnant of the defiled Gentiles rebukes no less a son of Israel than king David himself.

Modernised from J. G. BellettOriginal wording

Forgiven, Yet Still Governed

David was forgiven long before this list. The last name shows what forgiveness does not remove.

Full and everlasting forgiveness, however, does not free those who receive it from God's dealings with them in government. David had to experience that, right to the end of his life. The child born to him by Uriah's wife must die, and the sword would never depart from his house. Bathsheba was still regarded as Uriah's wife. Amnon, Absalom and Adonijah were examples of it. Governmental dealing, however, ends with this life. God's favour to us, based on the sacrifice of Christ, lasts for ever.

Modernised from C. E. StuartOriginal wording

Thirty-Seven, And A Day Of Reckoning

The list also has a meaning that points forward.

David's last words were a great prophecy, and the records and the names of his mighty men fit well with it. They were the men who loved David, stood by him, and showed their loyalty and devotion to the King. Others are named, though we read of no particular deed of theirs. The last name is Uriah the Hittite. Before the judgment seat of Christ everything will be made manifest. He will come as the righteous Ruler and bring in the morning without clouds. Then He will remember those who were loyal and devoted to Him in His rejection. No name and no deed, even the smallest, will then be forgotten.

Modernised from Arno Clemens GaebeleinOriginal wording

Summary

- Remembered — thirty-seven in all, and God does not forget one of the men who stood by His anointed.

- Named — Uriah is on the roll as one of the devoted, so the list also witnesses against the king he served.

- Owned — David left the name there. He condemned himself and magnified the grace that had restored him.

- Governed — forgiveness was full, but the sword stayed in David's house. God's government runs its course in this life.

- Rewarded — at the judgment seat of Christ no name and no deed, however small, will be forgotten.