2 Kings 23:1–20

2 Kings 23:1 · Darby

And the king sent, and they gathered to him all the elders of Judah and of Jerusalem.

46-word opener; unsourced detail; near-verbatim repeat of the featured verse

A summons, not a surrender

Josiah could have used that message as an excuse to do nothing. He drew the opposite conclusion.

Josiah did not sit down in despair because of the serious things which Huldah made known to him. The judgments would not fall just yet. In the meantime, the energetic young king would do all he could to lead the people back into "the old paths." It is never too late to obey the Word of God.

Modernised from W. W. FeredayOriginal wording

He would not be saved alone

God had promised Josiah personal escape. That promise did not settle his conscience, because it left everyone else where they were.

Josiah was a man thoroughly in earnest. He felt the power of truth in his own soul. He could not rest content until he gathered the people around him, so that the light which had shone on him might shine on them too. He did not, he could not, rest in the promise that he would be gathered to his grave in peace, and that his eyes would not see the evil that was coming on Jerusalem... No, he thought of others, he felt for the people around him.

Modernised from C. H. MackintoshOriginal wording

The same writer takes it further. Josiah's own escape rested on his repentance, so he used the very Word that had broken him to bring others to the same place.

The elders first, then everyone

The summons starts with the elders and spreads out from there. That order fits what a king is.

Josiah was king in Judah, and so he stood for all the people. He realised it was his responsibility to bring them all in to hear the Word of God. Beginning with the elders, he called the people to the house of the Lord. So elders, priests, prophets and ordinary people were gathered (vv.1-2).

Modernised from Leslie M. GrantOriginal wording

Earlier he had sent to inquire of the LORD "for me, and for the people, and for all Judah" — not for himself alone. One writer draws a rule from those words:

He recognized something that is often overlooked: God's word applies to everyone. He also saw that everything God has written is of equal importance in its place, and equally to be obeyed... God's word spoke to him as king on his throne, but it spoke just as much to the humblest of his subjects.

Modernised from The Christian's FriendOriginal wording

Where he gathered them, and around what

Two things stand at the centre of this gathering: the house of the Lord, and the book that had been found there.

What marks the spiritual revival under Josiah, as we have seen, is the importance of God's house on earth — the place where the Lord makes His name dwell — and the importance of the book of the covenant. Let us not hesitate to repeat: in the times in which we live these two things always characterize a true revival.

Modernised from H. L. RossierOriginal wording

Picture it: a head of state gathering a nation to read them Scripture.

"And the king went up to the house of the LORD... And he read in their hearing all the words of the Book of the Covenant that had been found in the house of the LORD." What a delight for God and the angels to watch! What a thrill it would be to read in the newspapers that kings and presidents were calling mass meetings in their capitals to read the people the badly neglected Word of God! They would point out, with all seriousness, the things the people had got wrong, and urge them to come back humbly to their God.

Modernised from W. W. FeredayOriginal wording

Real in the king, shallow in the people

The king's heart and the people's heart were not the same.

There can be no question that it was real in the king himself. But if we read the opening chapters of Jeremiah, we find that the people's devotion was only skin-deep. They did not return to the LORD with their whole heart, but in pretense (Jer. 3:10).

Modernised from Arno Clemens GaebeleinOriginal wording

Yet the record is not written off. One writer observes that Josiah could not have known how impossible it is for man in the flesh to keep such a covenant, and still it stands written that "all his days they departed not from following the Lord" — "God took account of the desires of the king's heart, and of those of a people who followed him."

Summary

- Sent. Bad news about the future did not stop Josiah acting now. It is never too late to obey the Word of God.

- Shared. A personal promise of escape did not content him — the light that had shone on him had to shine on others.

- Widened. Starting with the elders, the call reached priests, prophets and all the people. God's Word speaks to a king and to his humblest subject alike.

- Centred. He gathered them at God's house, around the book that had been found there. Commentators see those two marks in every real revival.

- Tested. The king's own obedience was real, yet the people's turning, as Jeremiah shows, went no deeper than the surface.

2 Kings 23:2 · Darby

And the king went up into the house of Jehovah, and all the men of Judah and all the inhabitants of Jerusalem with him, and the priests and the prophets, and all the people, both small and great; and he read in their ears all the words of the book of the covenant which had been found in the house of Jehovah.

Josiah had just learned that judgment was coming on Jerusalem, and that he himself would not live to see it. He did not keep the news to himself: he called the whole nation to the temple and read them the book that had humbled him.

A King Who Would Not Keep the Light to Himself

Josiah knew he was safe. Still, his mind was on the people around him.

Josiah was a man thoroughly in earnest. He felt the power of truth in his own soul. He could not rest until he had gathered the people around him, so that the light which had shone on him might shine on them too. He did not, he could not, rest in this: he would go to his grave in peace, and his own eyes would not see the evil that was coming on Jerusalem. No, he thought of others. He felt for the people around him. His own escape rested on his true repentance and humbling under the mighty hand of God. So he would use that same Word, which had worked with such power in his own heart, to lead others to the same repentance and humbling.

Modernised from C. H. MackintoshOriginal wording

Everyone Gathered, Small and Great

The verse lists elders, townspeople, priests, prophets and the ordinary crowd. No one was left out.

Being king in Judah and therefore the representative of all the people, Josiah realised his responsibility of involving them all in hearing the Word of God. Beginning with the elders, he called the people to the house of the Lord. So elders, priests, prophets and the common people were gathered. There Josiah himself read all the words of the Book of the Covenant, which would include the five books of Moses.

Modernised from Leslie M. GrantOriginal wording

One detail is easy to skip. The word "prophets" is plural, which raises a question about whom God chose to speak through.

Josiah convened a great national gathering in Jerusalem. Elders, priests, Levites, prophets, and a crowd of people small and great responded. The plural word prophets should be noted. Clearly other men besides Jeremiah were active in the land for God, yet He chose to speak through Huldah! We are quite unable to interpret every detail of the ways of God, but we want to be subject to His perfect wisdom.

Modernised from W. W. FeredayOriginal wording

What "the Book of the Covenant" Contained

Commentators differ on how much the book held. One writer traces it to Deuteronomy in particular.

This book of the covenant included the covenant of Sinai. It also included the one made in the plain of Moab — that is to say, all the words of Deuteronomy. It applied exactly to the people's condition as it now was. God had described that condition beforehand in this book. Deuteronomy spoke above all of obedience. God had redeemed this people from Egypt, and their blessing or cursing now depended on obedience to the Word.

Modernised from H. L. RossierOriginal wording

That is why the reading cut so deep. The book was not general religious teaching. It described the exact condition of the people standing there.

"All the Words" — a Long Reading

Josiah read all the words, not a selection. That had a practical result.

All the words of the law suggests a considerable amount of reading. The meeting was therefore a long one. What a contrast to the short sermons that are barely tolerated today! This is all the more sad, because we now have the complete Word of God. It reveals all His wonderful purposes of grace and glory, and they find their centre in Christ. Why are we satisfied with so little of the spiritual wealth that is within our reach?

Modernised from W. W. FeredayOriginal wording

Two Marks of a Genuine Revival

The verse sets two things side by side: the house of the Lord, and the book found there. One writer treats them together as the mark of a true revival.

What marks the spiritual revival under Josiah, as we have seen, is the importance of two things. One is God's house on earth, the place where the Lord causes His name to dwell. The other is the book of the covenant. Let us not hesitate to repeat it: in the times in which we live these two things always mark a true revival.

Modernised from H. L. RossierOriginal wording

Did the reading change the nation? One writer draws a line between the king's sincerity and the crowd's:

On the young king's part this was all real, no doubt, but one has only to read the earlier part of Jeremiah's prophecy to see how insincere it was with the mass of the people.

Modernised from C KnappOriginal wording

Summary

- Found. The lost book turned up in the temple. It described the people's condition so exactly that obedience or disobedience decided their blessing or ruin.

- Felt. Josiah could not keep this Word to himself. His own escape from judgment only sharpened his concern for everyone else.

- Shared. The reading reached elders, priests, prophets and ordinary people alike. The king made sure the nation he represented heard it.

- Whole. He read all the words, not a convenient extract, which made for a long meeting and a searching one.

- Tested. Where God's house and God's book hold first place, revival is real. In Josiah it was real; in the crowd, one writer says, it was not.

2 Kings 23:3 · Darby

And the king stood on the dais, and made a covenant before Jehovah, to walk after Jehovah, and to keep his commandments and his testimonies and his statutes with all [his] heart, and with all [his] soul, to establish the words of this covenant that are written in this book. And all the people stood to the covenant.

Josiah has just heard the long-lost book of the law read aloud. Now he gathers the whole nation into the temple to hear it too. Standing in his royal place, he binds himself to obey it — and the people join him. Two questions press on this scene: what did the covenant promise, and why did it fail?

The book behind the covenant

The covenant was not invented on the spot. It renewed terms already written down.

This book of the covenant included the covenant of Sinai. It also included the one made in the plain of Moab — that is, all the words of Deuteronomy. It applied exactly to the people's state as it now was, and God had described that state beforehand in this book. Deuteronomy spoke above all of obedience. God had redeemed this people from Egypt, and the book made their blessing or cursing depend on obedience to the Word.

Modernised from H. L. RossierOriginal wording

The king went first

Josiah did not just read the law to the crowd and tell them to keep it. He stated his own intention to obey it before asking anything of them.

This is excellent. An ounce of example is worth more than a ton of instruction. Joshua, in his final address to Israel, spoke in the same way: "But as for me and my house, we will serve the LORD" (Joshua 24:15). Paul urged Timothy to "set the believers an example in speech, in conduct, in love, in faith, in purity" (1 Timothy 4:12).

Modernised from W. W. FeredayOriginal wording

Sincere in one man, hollow in the crowd

The verse puts king and people side by side. What was real at the top was not real all the way down.

On the young king's part this was all real, no doubt. But read the earlier part of Jeremiah's prophecy, and you see how hypocritical it was with most of the people. They had eagerly entered into covenants with the Lord before. The outcome was always the same — breakdown, and a wider departure from God than ever before.

Modernised from C. KnappOriginal wording

Josiah did not stop at his own promise. He pressed the whole nation to stand with him.

Josiah went beyond stating his own intention; he made everyone present in Jerusalem and Benjamin join in the covenant. The king meant well, but how little he understood how changeable the human heart is! It was the old sad story of Sinai repeated. They had never learned the depths of their own evil, nor the holiness of God. At the burning mountain "all the people answered together and said, 'All that the LORD has spoken we will do'" (Exodus 19:8)… But outward correctness will not do for God. Jeremiah's sad pages tell us how little the people's hearts loved the will of God.

Modernised from W. W. FeredayOriginal wording

Why a covenant like this could not hold

The terms of the covenant itself explain the failure. And the failure served a purpose.

This covenant rested on the law. That is why people broke it as quickly as they broke the covenant of Sinai, and every other covenant made on the same terms. But these covenants give man a chance to learn in depth what the flesh is. That is why the law, as an obligation, is necessary.

Modernised from H. L. RossierOriginal wording

What the covenant did achieve

Even a covenant the people did not mean from the heart was not wasted. The faithfulness of one man held a whole nation in check for a generation.

Despite that, those who are faithful hold a moral restraint over souls, even over souls that are in fact far from God. In 2 Chronicles 34:33 we see that Josiah made everyone present in Israel serve the LORD their God. All his days they did not turn away from following the LORD, the God of their fathers. It is in this way that all the people here enter into the covenant.

Modernised from H. L. RossierOriginal wording

The equivalent for us

Josiah's whole-hearted promise still has a counterpart today, though not in the form of a covenant.

Josiah is not satisfied with escaping the judgement himself. If there was grace for him there must be grace for others. He made "all the people great and small" hear the word. The king made a covenant to walk after the Lord "with all his heart" and "all his soul," and caused all to stand to it. We do not enter into a covenant with God. But we can have "steadfast purpose" and "remain faithful to the Lord" (Acts 11:23). We trust not in self but in His grace.

Modernised from Michael HardtOriginal wording

Summary

- Book first. The covenant renewed the words of Deuteronomy. There God tied blessing or cursing to obedience.

- King first. Josiah bound himself first, then called the nation to follow. Example weighs more than words.

- People after. The people said yes, as at Sinai. They were correct on the outside, with hearts far from God, as Jeremiah shows.

- Law breaks. The people broke this covenant as fast as every earlier one. The law is there so that people learn in depth what the flesh is.

- Grace holds. We make no covenant with God today. We stay faithful to Him with steadfast purpose, trusting His grace and not ourselves.

2 Kings 23:4 · Darby

And the king commanded Hilkijah the high priest, and the priests of the second order, and the doorkeepers, to bring forth out of the temple of Jehovah all the vessels that had been made for Baal, and for the Asherah, and for all the host of the heavens; and he burned them outside Jerusalem in the fields of Kidron, and carried the ashes of them to Bethel.

Josiah's reform starts inside the temple itself. Idol vessels had piled up in God's own house, and this verse raises two questions: how did they get there, and what made the king act now?

The state of the house

The shock is not just the list of idols but the place they sat.

If anyone wants a correct idea of the practical state of things in Josiah's day, let him think over 2 Kings 23. The record is perfectly appalling. There were vessels made for Baal in the temple of the Lord. There were idolatrous priests burning incense in the high places, in the cities of Judah, and in Jerusalem. They burned incense to Baal, to the sun, to the moon, to the planets, and to all the hosts of heaven.

Modernised from C. H. MackintoshOriginal wording

This idolatry came down from Josiah's own family line. The men told to clear it out were the high priest, the priests under him, and the doorkeepers.

At this time there was energy of faith, chiefly in Josiah, to get rid of the idolatry introduced by Josiah's fathers, Manasseh and Amon. Josiah gave orders to Hilkiah the high priest, to the priests under him, and to the doorkeepers. They were to bring out of the temple all the articles made for Baal and Asherah and other false gods.

Modernised from Leslie M. GrantOriginal wording

Why this cleansing went deeper than the first

Josiah had cleared the temple once before. Something changed between the two efforts.

We have already noticed that Josiah purged the temple before he repaired it (2 Chronicles 34:8). This appalling list of abominations was still in the house where the Lord had set His name. It suggests that the first purging was not very thorough. But the second purging cleared every vile thing out. Why was the second purging more thorough than the first? Because the Book of the law had come to light between the two movements. The King, at least, now saw the hideousness of things people had long tolerated.

Modernised from W. W. FeredayOriginal wording

Where the whole pile came from

One writer traces every item back to a single root. He also refuses the excuse that old and respected names stood behind these shrines.

All the mischief, all the corruption and confusion, all the shame and dishonour, all the reproach and blasphemy — it all began with neglect of the Word of God... It mattered little to Josiah that these things were old, or that the fathers of the Jewish nation stood behind them. Nor was he moved by the thought that people might see these altars and high places, these groves and images, as proof of a large heart, a broad mind, and a generous spirit.

Modernised from C. H. MackintoshOriginal wording

Knowing and then doing

Josiah heard the book read and acted at once. The same question falls on the reader today.

Energetic action must follow when the heart is going out towards God and His Word. "I hasten and do not delay to keep your commandments" (Psalm 119:60). Some believers today may stay in unscriptural associations because no one has set the Word of God before them about these things. Evil is no less evil when people fail to see its true character through inattention to the teaching of Scripture. But once the Word is brought to bear, God expects prompt action from His saints.

Modernised from W. W. FeredayOriginal wording

Kidron and Bethel

Josiah did not stop at emptying the temple. He chose where to burn the vessels and where to send the ashes.

Josiah cleanses Jerusalem, Judah, and Israel completely, as far as his arm could reach, in his zeal for God and for God alone. In the fields of Kidron he burns all the objects that had piled up in the temple for the worship of Baal, Astarte, and the stars. He carries their dust to Bethel, the original site of Jeroboam's idolatry.

Modernised from H. L. RossierOriginal wording

What the clearing made room for

This verse opens a list of removals that runs to verse 20. The passover comes only after it. One writer draws out the order as a pattern.

It was indeed a triumphant moment, but we need to be reminded of three things that led to such an achievement. First, Josiah thought of the house of the Lord. Second, he obeyed the word of the Lord. Last, he put away all that was evil... Without these three things, the passover would have been worthless in God's eyes, however solemnly people kept it.

Modernised from The Christian's FriendOriginal wording

Summary

- Found — The book of the law came to light between Josiah's two cleansings. That is why the second reached what the first left standing.

- Seen — Evil that people tolerate for years looks harmless. Scripture shows its true character.

- Acted — Once you know the Word, God looks for prompt action — no matter who set the evil up.

- Burned — Josiah burned the vessels outside the city at Kidron. He sent their ashes to Bethel, where Jeroboam's idolatry had begun.

- Restored — The passover that followed had worth for one reason: Josiah cared for God's house, obeyed His word, and cleared the evil out.

2 Kings 23:5 · Darby

And he abolished the idolatrous priests, whom the kings of Judah had ordained to burn incense on the high places in the cities of Judah, and the environs of Jerusalem; and them that burned incense to Baal, to the sun, and to the moon, and to the constellations, and to all the host of heaven.

Josiah's reform reached past the idols to the men who ran the worship. Where did those priests come from, and what gave a young king the courage to remove them?

Priests appointed by kings

So who put these priests in place? The verse says the kings of Judah did. Each of those kings had a duty in writing that made such an act inexcusable.

Reader, think about this! Only consider kings of Judah, successors of David, ordaining priests to burn incense to Baal! Remember too what each of these kings of Judah was responsible to do. He had to write out his own copy of the book of the law. He was to keep it beside him and read it all the days of his life, so that he would learn to fear the Lord his God, keep all the words of this law and these statutes, and do them (See Deut. 17:18-19). How far they had strayed from the words of that law, when they could set about ordaining priests to burn incense to false gods!

Modernised from C. H. MackintoshOriginal wording

The name behind these priests

These men carry a special Hebrew title: Chemarim. The same word appears in Zephaniah. One writer explains there why this arrangement was so offensive. The problem was not open paganism, but a blend.

Zephaniah names "the Chemarim" — that is, idolatrous priests, mentioned elsewhere only in 2 Kings 23:5 and Hosea 10:5 — alongside "the priests." What made this idolatry so offensive was the joining of the idols of the nations with Jehovah. To be a plain, outright idolater was not nearly so evil. The worse thing is to show that you know the true God and yet put false gods on a level with Him.

Modernised from William KellyOriginal wording

Sun, moon, and the signs of the sky

The list of things worshipped runs from Baal to the whole visible sky. The word translated "the constellations" is rare, and one reference work explains it.

The Hebrew word is mazzaloth. It is thought to refer to the twelve signs or constellations of the Zodiac, as the margin shows. The Israelites worshipped these, along with the sun, moon, and "all the host of heaven." 2 Kings 23:5. The word occurs nowhere else.

Modernised from Morrish Bible DictionaryOriginal wording

But the lights in the sky were never meant to hold anyone's worship. They point past themselves.

If they lifted their eyes to heaven, above the level of creatures on earth, they were to look higher still. They were to look above the sun, moon and stars to the One who created all these things, instead of worshipping these visible works of God's hands… God has created these wonderful heavenly bodies. But they are there only to turn our attention to their unseen Maker.

Modernised from Leslie M. GrantOriginal wording

The size of the problem Josiah faced

Verse 5 is one item in a long list, and the sheer quantity tells its own story about the state of the nation. One commentator draws a line from the wooden image in the temple to what churches tolerate.

But there was much more to do in cleansing Judah from the overflowing tide of idolatry that had invaded the land. Josiah removed the idolatrous priests from the high places in the cities of Judah, and all those who burned incense to Baal, to the sun, to the moon and to the constellations of stars in the whole heaven (v.5). Judah had multiplied her gods beyond measure. A wooden image had been put in the house of the Lord, just as many churches introduce images that look nice but are an insult to the Lord Jesus.

Modernised from Leslie M. GrantOriginal wording

What made this purge different

Josiah had already cleansed the temple once, earlier in his reign. Something happened in between the two efforts that changed how much he saw.

The house where Jehovah had set His name still held this appalling list of detestable things. That suggests the first cleansing was not very thorough. But the second cleansing cleared every vile thing out. Why did the second go deeper than the first? Because the book of the law had come to light between the two efforts. Now the King, at least, saw how hideous these long-tolerated things really were.

Modernised from W. W. FeredayOriginal wording

The standard he used

A young king pulling down what famous kings had set up could look like arrogance. But for Josiah the question was never about persons.

God enabled him to take his stand on the unchangeable truth of God. By that perfect standard he tested all the errors and evils he found around him, and he rejected them all. Josiah felt that there was no reason to go on for a single hour with anything contrary to the mind of Jehovah. He was right before God to feel it. It did not matter to him the weight of a feather — nor should it to anyone — who had first started the error or evil. It was enough for him that it was error and evil… It was not a question of Josiah versus Solomon, but of truth versus error.

Modernised from C. H. MackintoshOriginal wording

Summary

- Ordained — no foreign enemy installed these priests. Kings of Judah did, and every king was bound to write out God's law and read it daily.

- Mixed — the Chemarim stood beside the regular priests. To know the true God and still put false gods on His level is worse than open idolatry.

- Worshipped — Baal, the sun, the moon, and mazzaloth, the twelve signs of the zodiac. Every one of those lights points past itself to its Maker.

- Exposed — the book of the law came to light between Josiah's two cleansings. Then evil that had stood for years looked hideous.

- Removed — he judged by that standard, not by reputations. It was never Josiah against Solomon, only truth against error.

2 Kings 23:6 · Darby

And he brought out the Asherah from the house of Jehovah, outside Jerusalem, to the torrent of Kidron, and burned it at the torrent of Kidron, and stamped it small to powder, and cast the powder upon the graves of the children of the people.

Josiah's reform began in the hardest place of all: the temple, where an idol had stood with royal approval. He brought it out, burned it, ground it to dust, and scattered the dust over a public graveyard. What was this thing, and why did it have to be destroyed so completely?

The Asherah

Older English Bibles call this idol a "grove," which hides what it really was. A Bible dictionary traces the word, the object, and what it was made of:

asherah, asherath. The word "grove" suggests a row of trees. But that cannot be the meaning, since people set up groves "under every green tree" (1 Kings 14:23; 2 Kings 17:10). Manasseh set a carved image of the grove that he had made in the temple (2 Kings 21:7). Josiah removed it, burned it, and ground it to powder (2 Kings 23:6). This was doubtless made of metal, but the groves were of wood, as we learn from the fact that they were cut down and burned (Judges 6:25-26; 2 Kings 23:14-15). They are always associated with idols and images, and Judges 3:7 speaks of them being served along with the Baals.

Modernised from Morrish Bible DictionaryOriginal wording

An idol in God's own house

The place is what shocks. This idol stood in the house God had chosen for His name:

Scripture makes a point of noting that "he brought out the Asherah from the house of the LORD … and burned it at the brook Kidron and beat it to dust." "The grove" appears to have been an image of Astarte. Imagine such a horror standing in the house of Jehovah! God had once said of that house that His eyes and His heart would be there always (2 Chron. 7:16). How low Israel had fallen, that such a thing stood in the most sacred spot on earth!

Modernised from W. W. FeredayOriginal wording

Why the brook Kidron

Where he took it mattered too. The valley east of Jerusalem was already treated as unclean ground, and Josiah was not the first king to burn an idol there:

This is the valley, or wide dry riverbed, between the east of Jerusalem and the west of the Mount of Olives… In Old Testament times people treated it as a defiled place. Asa burned his mother's idol there (1 Kings 15:13). Josiah also burned the symbols of idolatry there (2 Kings 23:4, 6, 12). From 2 Kings 23:6 and Jeremiah 31:40 it appears to have been the common burial ground.

Modernised from Morrish Bible DictionaryOriginal wording

Dust on the graves

Josiah did not stop at burning it. Where the dust landed passed its own verdict on what people had worshipped:

A wooden image had been put in the house of the LORD, just as many churches introduce images that look nice but are an insult to the Lord Jesus. Josiah burned the image at the brook Kidron and threw the ashes on graves (v.6), signifying that the idolatry was worthy only of the corruption of death.

Modernised from Leslie M. GrantOriginal wording

Age was no defence

The idol was old, and old things can claim respect. One writer names the single cause behind all this error, and what Josiah refused to be impressed by:

Our devoted young king was able to "grind into dust, and beat into powder" an enormous pile of error. All of it had its origin in the gross neglect of this most precious sentence: "IT IS WRITTEN." It mattered little to Josiah that all these things could boast of age, and the authority of the fathers of the Jewish nation.

Modernised from C. H. MackintoshOriginal wording

Josiah had cleared the temple once before this. Something happened in between that made the second clearance go deeper:

The appalling things still left in the house where Jehovah had set His name suggest that the first cleansing was not thorough. The second cleansing cleared every vile thing out. But why was the second cleansing more thorough than the first? Because the Book of the law had come to light between the two. The ugliness of things people had long tolerated was now clear, at least to the King.

Modernised from W. W. FeredayOriginal wording

Summary

- Neglect — every item in Josiah's clean-up list began with one thing: God's people letting go of what was written. Error accumulates where Scripture is ignored.

- Intrusion — the Asherah was a carved image of the idol Astarte. An earlier king, Manasseh, set it up in the very place where God had promised His eyes and heart would rest.

- Light — Josiah had purged the temple once already. The deeper second clearance came only after they found the Book of the law. It showed him the ugliness of what everyone had tolerated for years.

- Removal — the image was carried out to the Kidron, a valley already treated as defiled ground, where King Asa had once burned his mother's idol.

- Verdict — Josiah burned the idol, beat it to dust, and scattered it over public graves. That marked it as fit for nothing but the corruption of death. Age and royal approval bought it no protection.

2 Kings 23:7 · Darby

And he broke down the houses of the sodomites, which were in the house of Jehovah, where the women wove tents for the Asherah.

Josiah's reform reaches the worst place of all. Rooms inside the temple area served cult prostitution, and women wove hangings there for the Asherah image. Two questions follow. How did such filth get into God's house? And what does a faithful man do when he finds it?

Filth in the holiest place

The scandal is not only the sin but its address. One writer sets it beside God's own promise about that house. He then turns to later church history.

The record makes a point of saying that "he brought the Asherah out of the house of the LORD ... and burned it at the brook Kidron and beat it to dust" (2 Kings 23:6). The Asherah, which older translations call "the grove," appears to have been an image of Astarte. Imagine such a horror standing in the house of the LORD! Of that house He once said that His eyes and His heart would be there always (2 Chron. 7:16). Next to the temple stood the houses of the male cult prostitutes! Horror upon horror; how low Israel had fallen, to have such depravity in the most sacred spot on earth! The history of Christendom has been just as fearful.

Modernised from W. W. FeredayOriginal wording

The word behind "cult prostitutes"

Some have taken this word to mean a holy woman or a seer. One writer tests that against how the word is used elsewhere.

Few serious readers, I think, will agree with the notion that this word means a holy woman or seer. Far more probable is the ordinary view, which takes it as a "consecration" to the corrupt Astarte, or Venus, of early and later idolatry. … The masculine form of the word occurs in Deut. 23:17; 1 Kings 14:24; 2 Kings 23:7; Job 36:14. Can it be argued that holy men, or seers, are intended here? They are forms of the same word, and the idea of holiness, or consecration, of course runs through both. … Terrible to say, prostitution was an almost universal element of heathen sanctity!

Modernised from William KellyOriginal wording

What the women were weaving

The women's weaving was not decoration. A reference work explains what the Asherah was and what the women made.

On the whole it seems most probable that the groves were wooden symbols of a goddess. They took the form of images or pillars, or plain tree trunks set in the earth. In 2 Kings 23:7 we read that women wove "hangings" for the groves. The word really means "houses" or "tents." So these coverings enclosed the groves, probably for impure purposes, since immorality went almost always with idolatry.

Modernised from Morrish Bible DictionaryOriginal wording

Who installed it

Who put this inside the temple? One writer, quoting another, names one king.

"The account of Josiah's later reformation shows both the extent and the shameless immorality of the idolatry now common (2 Kings 23:4-8). Earlier kings had brought in practices of their own. But one thing must have been the work of Manasseh. He placed a class of priests, probably in the outer court of the temple, whose unnatural vice combined a kind of madness with the deepest moral degradation. Beside them, and in fellowship with them, he placed priestesses of Astarte."

Modernised from Arno Clemens GaebeleinOriginal wording

Why worship and vice ran together

How could anyone call this worship? One writer answers, and turns the question on us.

Look with the prophet through the hole in the wall, into the rooms full of images in the idol's temple. See the almost unbelievable horrors pictured there; human corruption in its lowest forms. You say, how could a people think that was religious worship? Dear friends, it is just what all men do. They turn away from God as He has revealed Himself to us in Christ. They make a god of their own imagination. They give free rein to the desires of their own hearts. That is why there is so much corruption in the name of religion. It should make us tremble to think that if you or I leave the path of obedience to God, and begin to serve a god of our own imagining, God will give us up to the desires of our own corrupt hearts.

Modernised from Samuel RidoutOriginal wording

Breaking down, not tidying up

Josiah pulled the buildings down; he did not put them to some other use. One writer holds up that thoroughness and contrasts it with a church slow to judge evil among its own.

No one ever rooted out idolatry as thoroughly as Josiah did, right across the land of Israel. He killed all the priests, burned their bones on their altars, and then destroyed the altars themselves, grinding them to powder. Such thoroughness God loves. The Corinthian believers were very slow to deal with wickedness in the assembly. Yet they were active in avenging their personal wrongs, even taking one another to the world's courts (1 Cor. 5:6).

Modernised from W. W. FeredayOriginal wording

Summary

- Location — The offence is the address. Cult prostitution sat inside the house where God said His eyes and His heart would always be.

- Language — The word means "consecrated." Among the nations, prostitution was part of religion, so vice arrived dressed as holiness.

- Loom — The women's "hangings" were tent-like coverings around the Asherah, a wooden symbol of a goddess. Ordinary daily work fed the corruption.

- Legacy — Commentators trace the arrangement to Manasseh. One reign can plant evils that a later king has to tear out.

- Levelling — Josiah did not renovate the houses. He broke them down. God loves that thoroughness, and it shames slowness to judge evil in the church.

2 Kings 23:8 · Darby

And he brought all the priests out of the cities of Judah, and defiled the high places where the priests had burned incense, from Geba even to Beer-sheba; and he broke down the high places of the gates, those at the entrance of the gate of Joshua the governor of the city, [and] those on the left hand of any [going in] at the gate of the city.

Josiah's reform moves out of the temple and into the countryside. He clears the priests out of Judah's towns, ruins the shrines they served from Geba to Beersheba, and pulls down even the shrines at the city gate. Two questions follow. What were these "high places"? And why did a king who loved God destroy them?

What the High Places Were

The shrines Josiah attacked were not all pagan. Some honoured Israel's own God.

We are speaking of the high places used for worship, which seemed to be everywhere in the Lord's land… The time soon came, sadly, when Israel chose high places for themselves. Some of these were for idolatrous worship, and some for the worship of the Lord. But all the high places were offensive in His sight, whatever the motives of those who set them up. They were the expression of creative self-will, of hearts not subject to His commandments.

Modernised from W. W. FeredayOriginal wording

They also had a history.

The high place was, we might say, a kind of necessity, brought in by the failure and disordered state of the people at large… They were not always connected with idolatry. In fact, at the beginning they were devoted to the true worship of God. To some extent they were places where He Himself in grace recognised the need and met with His people, though not according to the order He Himself had provided. Later on, however, He established His centre. He placed His name at Jerusalem, and the temple of His glory was there. From that time the worship of the high places was direct disobedience to His will.

Modernised from Samuel RidoutOriginal wording

Why Sincere Worship in the Wrong Place Is Still Wrong

Josiah's action rests on a principle that runs through Scripture: the worshipper does not get to pick the terms.

Clearly man is not to determine his own ways as a worshipper. Willingness in worship is right; wilfulness destroys it all… We are to worship "in spirit" — that is most true — in the grace and liberty of the Holy Spirit given to us. But we are to worship "in truth" also, according to God's revelation of Himself and of His worship. The keeping up of groves and high places in Israel was always the witness that the people had not properly prepared their hearts to seek the Lord God of Israel. He is the only true God, and He had set His name at Jerusalem.

Modernised from J. G. BellettOriginal wording

The Priests Who Lost Their Work

Josiah did not kill the priests he brought out of Judah's towns. He removed them from office but left them a living. Commentators read this in two ways. One sees discipline with mercy in it:

The energetic Josiah cleared away all the high places, and he brought away from them all the priests who had burned incense on them. But they had disobeyed the Word of the Lord, so they could not carry out priestly duties in Jerusalem. "The priests of the high places did not come up to the altar of the Lord in Jerusalem, but they ate unleavened bread among their brothers" (2 Kings 23:8-9). Even unfaithful men must not be left to starve!

Modernised from W. W. FeredayOriginal wording

The other reads their acceptance of the bread as a poor substitute for repentance:

It is clear they had no energy of faith to break completely with the idolatry they were used to. Yet they ate unleavened bread among their brothers (v.9). Was this not a way of covering their sin with a show of religious zeal? For the unleavened bread stands for separation from evil, but the show without the reality of separation is hypocrisy.

Modernised from Leslie M. GrantOriginal wording

The Reach of the Clean-Up

The two place names mark out a whole country, not a district.

Josiah, in firm decision for the Lord, brought all the priests from the cities of Judah and defiled the high places where the priests had burned incense, making the places unusable, from Geba to Beersheba, not a short distance.

Modernised from Leslie M. GrantOriginal wording

He kept going even where there was no population left to protect, because he was working toward something still ahead.

The king also goes through all the cities of Israel, destroying the temples of the high places. He shows no pity to their idolatrous priests, whom he puts to death. By then the Assyrians had carried the people away, so the influence of these priests seemed to be gone. He acts in view of a future restoration, and his heart, fervent in the service of the Lord, is set on it.

Modernised from H. L. RossierOriginal wording

The Cost of Small Departures

How did God's own people reach this state?

What we have seen is enough to show the fearful lengths to which even the people of God may go. They need only turn aside, in the smallest measure, from the authority of Holy Scripture… The moment a man departs a hair's breadth from Scripture, there is no accounting for the monstrous extravagance into which he may rush.

Modernised from C. H. MackintoshOriginal wording

Summary

- Self-will. The high places were not all pagan shrines. Some honoured Israel's God. Yet all were offensive, because they expressed hearts choosing their own way.

- Centre. God had set His name at Jerusalem. Keeping the high places was the standing witness that the people had not properly prepared their hearts to seek Him.

- Drift. What began as a concession to a broken situation became plain disobedience once God had chosen His place. Small departures add up.

- Mercy. The displaced priests lost their office but not their bread. Commentators differ: was that bread kindness to them, or hypocrisy in them?

- Reach. Josiah cleansed from Geba to Beersheba and on into the emptied north. He worked for a restoration still in the future.

2 Kings 23:9 · Darby

Nevertheless the priests of the high places came not up to the altar of Jehovah in Jerusalem, but they ate of the unleavened bread among their brethren.

Josiah has just pulled down the high places across Judah and brought away the priests who had burned incense at them. This verse tells us what happened to those men next: barred from the altar in Jerusalem, yet still fed among their fellow priests.

Who These Priests Were

The chapter names two different sets of priests. One writer keeps them apart: these men had been offering sacrifices to the LORD, not to idols.

He puts down the Chemarim — the priests set up by the kings of Judah to burn incense before false gods… He gathers together the priests who, under a repentant Manasseh, had gone on offering sacrifices to the Lord on the high places (2 Chron. 33:17). He does not treat them like the Chemarim, but he does not allow them to go up to the altar of the LORD at Jerusalem.

Modernised from H. L. RossierOriginal wording

Why They Were Refused

God had chosen His own centre for worship, and these men had chosen another. One writer traces their exclusion to that disobedience, then turns the question on the reader.

The Word alone must govern God's people in all matters of worship. The LORD would choose His own centre, and His people must come there with their burnt offerings and sacrifices… All the high places were offensive in His sight, whatever the motives of those who set them up. They expressed self-will — hearts not subject to His commandments… Josiah cleared away all the high places, and he brought away from them all the priests who had burned incense on them. But they had disobeyed the Word of the LORD, so they were not allowed to carry out priestly duties in Jerusalem… Even unfaithful men must not be left to starve! Should we not learn from all this that God expects His Word to be obeyed by His people? Or is it possible that some choose for themselves where and how they will worship and serve their God?

Modernised from W. W. FeredayOriginal wording

One Centre, Or None

These men had left idolatry behind, yet they still worshipped at a centre of their own choosing. One writer reads Josiah's answer as a lesson for today.

This religion had left idolatry behind, yet it had dared to despise the only gathering centre for the people. So all fellowship with it is firmly broken off. There is instruction here for our own day. This act of Josiah's shows us that a true revival cannot be joined to worship offered away from the Lord's Table, the only gathering centre for His own.

Modernised from H. L. RossierOriginal wording

Bread Without The Altar

The verse both refuses and provides. The same writer holds the two together: Josiah honours what these men are, and refuses what they do.

All the same, Josiah acknowledges the right of these priests to eat "unleavened bread among their brothers" (v. 9). The Lord had consecrated these men, and their personal holiness is fully recognised. But for the present, if not for ever, they are not allowed to serve in Israel's worship.

Modernised from H. L. RossierOriginal wording

A Darker Reading

Commentators differ on how to read the eating. Another writer sees no faith in these men, and treats their meal as a cover-up.

The priests of the high places lost their occupation, but they did not come up to the altar of the Lord in Jerusalem. They clearly had no energy of faith to break completely with the idolatry they were used to, but they ate unleavened bread among their brothers (v.9). Was this not an attempt to cover their sin with a show of religious zeal? For the unleavened bread stands for separation from evil. But a show without the reality of separation is hypocrisy.

Modernised from Leslie M. GrantOriginal wording

The Long Shadow Of The Past

The same principle appears elsewhere. One writer describes men who keep their service in God's house, yet are kept out of the priestly office because of what they had done before.

The Levites, apart from the family of Zadok, are given the guard and the service of the house, but are kept out of the priestly office. In the government of God they are shut out from this higher place because of their previous history. They had followed the people into idolatry. Instead of resisting the evil that was coming in, they became a stumbling block that led others into sin… God calls the past to account. In His ways of holy government such departure from His revealed and known will must be remembered in judgment, though those subject to it are personally safe.

Modernised from F. W. GrantOriginal wording

Summary

- Place. Their sin was not another god but another altar. They worshipped the right God in a place He had not chosen.

- Centre. A true revival cannot be joined to worship offered away from the one gathering centre.

- Bread. They lost the altar but kept the table. Josiah still honoured what the Lord had consecrated in them, and would not leave them to starve.

- Show. Commentators differ. One sees provision for men who had failed. Another sees unleavened bread eaten without real separation from evil — a show, and so hypocrisy.

- Government. God remembers past departure from His known will. It can cost a man the higher place of service, even though he himself is safe.

2 Kings 23:10 · Darby

And he defiled Topheth, which is in the valley of the sons of Hinnom, that no man might cause his son or his daughter to pass through the fire to Molech.

Josiah's cleanup of Judah reaches a valley just outside Jerusalem. Parents had been burning their own children there as worship, and the king wrecked the place.

What "pass through the fire" meant

Older translations read "pass through the fire" where the ESV says the children were burned as an offering. One writer refuses to let that phrase be softened:

Here is that most inhuman rite, in which parents were so blinded by Satan that they gave their children as sacrifices to Molech or Moloch, and probably Malcham or Milcom. It was the guardian god of the Ammonites. From Jeremiah 19:5 it appears that Baal was worshipped in this way. Some have reasoned about "passing through the fire," here and elsewhere, so as to deny that they burned their children. But this seems a kindly attempt to soften the reality of the wickedness. It was the fullest, though not the only, profanation of the name of Israel's God. The Lord accepted a sheep or an ox, or even a much smaller sacrifice; Satan, under these names, demanded their sons.

Modernised from William KellyOriginal wording

Another writer describes how it worked, and what drove it:

People called this a sacrifice. But it did not come from unselfish love for Molech. It came from the selfish evil of wanting to get rid of a child... Molech was an image with its arms outstretched, and people would place their children in its arms while a fire was lit beneath. Then, with drums and noisy music, the cries of the child were drowned out as it was burned to death. So this religious wickedness made the torture and murder of an unwanted child look holy.

Modernised from Leslie M. GrantOriginal wording

The valley itself

The place had a name and a history long before Josiah reached it:

Topheth stood in these gardens, where the valleys of Hinnom and Kidron meet. Its name meant "the spitting out," or place of abomination. There an Ahaz, a Manasseh, and an Amon sacrificed their sons and daughters to Baal-Moloch, and burned incense to foul idols. Hinnom meant "moaning," and its name Gehinnom (valley of Hinnom — Gehenna) was rightly taken as the name for the place of final suffering.

Modernised from Arno Clemens GaebeleinOriginal wording

Sincere but deceived

The cruelty is plain. The sincerity behind it is harder to explain, and one writer names its source:

Josiah also defiled Topheth, where idol worshippers offered their children to Molech by fire (v.10). How can people feel spiritual zeal while doing such disgusting things? But they are totally deceived by Satan.

Modernised from Leslie M. GrantOriginal wording

Ruined, not just banned

One writer quotes a description of when the idol went and what the place was called afterwards:

The idol was a hideous ox-headed human figure of Moloch. It stood in the valley until less than thirty years before the Chaldeans destroyed Jerusalem. Then the good king Josiah swept away the idol and everything that went with it, and defiled the place so that it could never again be used for that frightful worship. But the horrors of the past had printed themselves so deeply on people's minds that from then on the spot bore the name Tophet — the abomination, the place to be spat upon.

Modernised from A. J. PollockOriginal wording

From rubbish heap to a picture of hell

One writer traces where the name of this valley ended up:

The Valley of Hinnom was the refuse dump outside Jerusalem. Fires always burned there, and maggots never stopped their work. People knew it as Gehenna. On the Lord's lips this word became a picture of the home of the lost that fits all too well. Truly hell will be the great refuse heap of eternity. There everything that is beyond correction will be kept apart from the good, and will lie forever under the judgment of God. This terrible fact reaches us from the lips of Him who loved sinful men and wept over them.

Modernised from F. B. HoleOriginal wording

A cleansing that stopped at the surface

Josiah could defile Topheth, but he could not change Judah. One writer weighs what the reform did not reach:

The king's power brought about a great reformation, but it left the hearts of most people untouched... But why could God not rest in the outwardly improved state of the kingdom of Judah in Josiah's day? He looked beneath the surface. He looked for reality, for tenderness of conscience, for a heart subject to His word — and He did not find them. God will never be satisfied with anything short of thoroughness.

Modernised from The Bible TreasuryOriginal wording

Summary

- Deception. Burning children looked like devotion, but Satan had deceived the people completely.

- Demand. God asked for a sheep or an ox; under the name of Molech, Satan asked for their sons — the counterfeit always costs more.

- Defilement. Josiah did not just ban the site; he spoiled it so completely that it could never serve that worship again.

- Destiny. The ruined valley kept its name. It became Jerusalem's burning rubbish heap, and gave the Lord His own word for hell — Gehenna.

- Depth. One man's thoroughness cleansed a valley, not a nation. God still looks beneath the surface for a real conscience.

2 Kings 23:11 · Darby

And he abolished the horses that the kings of Judah had appointed to the sun at the entrance of the house of Jehovah, by the chamber of Nathan-melech the chamberlain, which was in the suburbs, and burned the chariots of the sun, with fire.

Josiah's reforms reach the temple gate itself, where earlier kings had dedicated horses and chariots to the sun. How did sun-worship get through that door, and why had no one removed it?

Idols at the Door, the Ark Out of the Sanctuary

The place matters as much as the object. One writer sets the two side by side: what the kings brought in, and what the sanctuary lost:

The horses which the kings of Judah have given to the sun stand stabled at the entrance of the house of the Lord, while the ark of the Lord has been cast out of the sanctuary.

Modernised from The Christian's FriendOriginal wording

Kings Put Them There

These shrines were not left by foreign invaders. The men who set them up sat on David's throne.

The record gives special mention to the pile of abominations which Josiah's predecessors of David's royal line had set up in and near Jerusalem… But worse still! We are not surprised at the terrible deeds of men like Ahaz and Manasseh. But one of the greatest of Israel's royal offenders was Solomon, the man who built the temple of the Lord, and whose prayer at its dedication seemed to anticipate every evil and danger that might arise!… Yet godly kings like Asa, Jehoshaphat, and Hezekiah left all this untouched! Neglect of the Word of God is the only possible explanation of this.

Modernised from W. W. FeredayOriginal wording

The same writer names the command those kings ignored. God gave it to kings alone:

Before Israel entered the land, the Lord made a rule for the time when the people would have a king: "when he sits on the throne of his kingdom, he shall write for himself in a book a copy of this law… And it shall be with him, and he shall read in it all the days of his life, that he may learn to fear the LORD his God" (Deut. 17:18-20). Suppose each ruler in Israel had obeyed this instruction. Suppose each had prepared his own copy of the law and had read in it all the days of his life. Then the formidable array of evils Josiah had to deal with would never have existed. Nor would the original of God's holy law have lain buried under rubbish, so that finding it was a real discovery!

Modernised from W. W. FeredayOriginal wording

A King Working Almost Alone

Josiah removes the horses and burns the chariots. Notice how little help he had, and how far he still carried the work:

He took away the "horses that the kings of Judah had given to the sun, at the entrance to the house of the LORD, by the chamber of Nathan-melech the chamberlain… and he burned the chariots of the sun with fire."… He seems to have had few sympathizers, or supporters, in his reforms, and supervised some of the work himself. A king's command cannot produce genuine repentance, but he did all that lay in his power, and did not permit a single visible trace of idolatry to remain in his realm.

Modernised from C KnappOriginal wording

Not Ancient History

These idolaters were not pagan outsiders. One commentator puts the weight on who they were:

We should not marvel at the kings of other nations burning incense to Baal, ordaining idolatrous priests, and worshipping the host of heaven. But these were kings of Judah, the sons and successors of David, children of Abraham. They had access to the book of the law of God, and they were responsible to make that book the subject of their deep and constant study. When we see such men falling under the power of dark and degrading superstition, it sounds a warning voice in our ears. We cannot safely refuse to give heed… "Now these things happened to them as an example, but they were written down for our instruction, on whom the end of the ages has come." (1 Cor. 10:11)

Modernised from C. H. MackintoshOriginal wording

The Same Door in Ezekiel's Vision

Sun-worship appears at that same door again in Ezekiel's vision of the temple. There the worshippers stand between the porch and the altar, and their number points to the priests:

But worse is still to come, because of both the place and the people engaged in worshipping the sun, the great object of ancient star-worship and later of Persian idolatry. "And behold, at the entrance of the temple of the LORD, between the porch and the altar, were about twenty-five men, with their backs to the temple of the LORD, and their faces toward the east, worshiping the sun toward the east." The prophet notes their number, which matches the courses of the priesthood and the high priest. Their backs were toward the Lord's temple, and their faces toward the east.

Modernised from William KellyOriginal wording

Summary

- The door. Horses dedicated to the sun stood at the entrance of the Lord's house, while the ark had been cast out of the sanctuary. The false held the place of the true.

- The hands. Kings of Judah, David's own line, set them up, and Solomon began the pattern. Godly kings like Asa, Jehoshaphat and Hezekiah left parts of it standing.

- The root. God commanded every king to write out his own copy of the law and read it all his life. Neglect of that one command is the only explanation offered for all Josiah had to clear away.

- The fire. Josiah removed the horses and burned the chariots. He supervised some of the work himself, with few supporters behind him, and left no visible trace of idolatry standing.

- The warning. These men owned the book of God's law and still fell. That is why the record stands as our instruction — and why sun-worship fills that same doorway again in Ezekiel's vision.

2 Kings 23:12 · Darby

And the king broke down the altars that were on the roof of the upper chamber of Ahaz, which the kings of Judah had made, and the altars that Manasseh had made in the two courts of the house of Jehovah, and he shattered them, [removing them] from thence, and cast the powder of them into the torrent of Kidron.

Josiah's cleansing of Judah did not stop at the temple gates. It climbed to a palace roof and reached into the temple courts, where Judah's own kings had built altars. Two questions press on this verse. How did such altars get there? And why did the king grind them to dust instead of just carting them away?

Altars in the Wrong Place

Altars are not neutral furniture. One writer explains what the temple's own altars pictured, and what building more of them said:

On the roof there were altars made by the kings of Judah, certainly an insult to God whose altar outside and that inside the temple both spoke of Christ. Other altars expose men's desire to have other gods. Beside these Manasseh had made altars in the two courts of the house of the Lord. All of these Josiah broke down and pulverised, throwing their dust into the brook Kidron.

Modernised from Leslie M. GrantOriginal wording

Kings Who Never Read the Law

The builders named here are not foreign invaders but Judah's own rulers. One writer traces the whole heap of evil back to a command God gave every king:

Before Israel entered the land the Lord decreed that once the people had a king, "he shall write for himself in a book a copy of this law... And it shall be with him, and he shall read in it all the days of his life, that he may learn to fear the Lord his God" (Deuteronomy 17:18-20). Suppose each ruler in Israel had obeyed this instruction. Suppose each had prepared his own copy of the law, and had read it all the days of his life. Then the huge mass of evils which Josiah had to deal with would never have existed. God's holy law itself would never have ended up buried under rubbish, so that finding it was a real discovery!

Modernised from W. W. FeredayOriginal wording

Why Manasseh's Altars Were Still Standing

Manasseh repented and tore down what he had built. Yet altars he made in the temple courts were still standing for Josiah to demolish. One reign in between explains the gap:

Amon had re-established all that Manasseh had abolished at the time of his repentance. Josiah, in his zeal for God and for God alone... completely cleanses Jerusalem, Judah, and Israel, as far as his arm could reach.

Modernised from H. L. RossierOriginal wording

Others make the same point about the limits of what one repentant man could undo. Manasseh's later reforms were real, but they could not reach everything:

He demolished the idols which he had erected, and the altars which were consecrated to them, and sought to bring the people back from the wrong way in which he had driven them; a difficult work and necessarily incomplete!

Modernised from Truth & TestimonyOriginal wording

The Valley Chosen for the Dust

Josiah did not dump the dust just anywhere. The Kidron valley, between Jerusalem and the Mount of Olives, already had a reputation:

In Old Testament times people treated it as a defiled place. Asa burnt his mother's idol there. 1 Kings 15:13. Josiah also burnt there the symbols of idolatry. 2 Kings 23:4, 6, 12; and from 2 Kings 23:6 and Jeremiah 31:40 it would appear to have been the common burial ground.

Modernised from Morrish Bible DictionaryOriginal wording

Thoroughness God Loves

Grinding altars to powder can look extreme. One writer praises it, then turns it on believers who moved too slowly:

Nowhere was idolatry ever rooted out as thoroughly as Josiah rooted it out across the whole land of Israel... He destroyed the altars themselves, reducing them to powder. Such thoroughness God loves. The Corinthian believers were very slow to deal with wickedness in the assembly. Yet they were quick to avenge their personal wrongs, even taking one another into the world's courts.

Modernised from W. W. FeredayOriginal wording

Cleared Ground, Then Worship

Pulling down the altars was not the end of the story. One writer puts that clearance third in an order of three:

First, the house of the Lord had been thought of; second, the word of the Lord had been obeyed; and last, all that was evil had been put away... For us the Lord's supper has taken the place of the passover. But can we remember the Lord in His death just as we please, however we please, in any fashion we like?

Modernised from The Christian's FriendOriginal wording

Summary

- Neglect builds. Kings who never wrote out and read God's law left a heap of altars for a later king to clear.

- Rivals insult. Extra altars on a palace roof and in the temple courts did not add to God's worship. They told God plainly that Judah's kings wanted other gods.

- Limited repentance. Manasseh pulled down his own altars, yet Amon put them all back. One man's turnaround could not secure the next generation.

- Dust, not storage. Josiah ground the altars to powder and threw the dust into a valley already known as defiled. Nothing was left to rebuild.

- Clearance first. God loves this thoroughness. Only after the evil was gone did Judah keep the passover. That same order still tests how we remember the Lord.

2 Kings 23:13 · Darby

And the high places that were before Jerusalem, which were on the right hand of the mount of corruption, which Solomon the king of Israel had built for Ashtoreth the abomination of the Zidonians, and for Chemosh the abomination of the Moabites, and for Milcom the abomination of the children of Ammon, did the king defile.

Josiah's reform reaches a ridge east of Jerusalem, where he finds shrines no king had dared touch — Solomon built them. So how did the man who built the temple come to raise altars to foreign gods, and what right did a later king have to pull them down?

The hill that took its name from its shrines

The hill east of Jerusalem carries a name, and the name comes from what Solomon built there:

Josiah also defiled other high places east of Jerusalem and south of the Mount of Olives. The hill is called the mount of Corruption because Solomon had corrupted it. He built high places on it for Ashtoreth the abomination of the Sidonians, Chemosh the abomination of the Moabites and Milcom the abomination of the Ammonites (v.13). Josiah cared about God's approval, and what offended God had to be destroyed.

Modernised from Leslie M. GrantOriginal wording

How Solomon came to build them

The shrines were not Solomon's first step away from God. A small departure from Scripture led to them:

The moment a man departs from Scripture, even by a hair's breadth, there is no telling what monstrous extremes he may rush into. We may wonder how a man like Solomon could ever be led to build high places for Ashtoreth, Chemosh and Milcom, the abominations of Sidon, Moab and Ammon. But it is easy to see how it happened. First he disobeyed the Word of his Lord by going to those nations for wives. From there he fell easily into the deeper error of adopting their worship.

Modernised from C. H. MackintoshOriginal wording

The same hands raised both the temple and these altars, and the two projects said opposite things:

He very likely took the attitude of broad-minded people today. He thought it right to tolerate every religion, and even to support evil religions, because that was what his wives preferred. His unbelief in building these high places was a shameful contradiction of his faith in building the temple! In building the temple he stressed the supreme authority of the living God. In building the high places he was guilty of challenging God's authority!

Modernised from Leslie M. GrantOriginal wording

Centuries of untouched evil

Between Solomon and Josiah stood kings remembered as godly. Not one of them touched this hill:

One of the greatest of Israel's royal sinners was Solomon — the man who built the temple of the LORD, and whose prayer at its dedication seemed to anticipate every evil and danger that might arise! Josiah defiled the high places east of Jerusalem that Solomon had built for Ashtoreth, Chemosh and Milcom. Yet godly kings like Asa, Jehoshaphat and Hezekiah left all of it standing! Neglect of the Word of God is the only possible explanation of this.

Modernised from W. W. FeredayOriginal wording

Solomon did not sin in ignorance. God had spoken to him in person:

God had not only given warnings and clear instructions in the Law; He had also appeared to Solomon in person twice and commanded him not to go after other gods. Wife after wife seems to have persuaded him to build a high place for her idol. Before long these high places defiled the hill east of Jerusalem, the Mount of Olives, and they stayed there 350 years, until the reign of Josiah.

Modernised from Eugene P. Vedder Jr.Original wording

Not Josiah against Solomon

The obvious objection to Josiah was Solomon's reputation:

People might have said to Josiah, when he broke down the high places Solomon had built: Who are you to set yourself up against Solomon, and against what a great man like him established? But it was not a question of Josiah versus Solomon. It was a question of God versus error.

Modernised from C. H. MackintoshOriginal wording

The safeguard every king ignored

One standing command would have prevented all of it. Every king of Israel was to write out his own copy of the law and keep reading it:

Suppose every ruler in Israel had obeyed this command. Suppose each one had written out his own copy of the law and read it all the days of his life. Then the huge mass of evils that Josiah had to deal with would never have existed. And the original of God's holy law would never have lain buried under rubbish, so that finding it was a real discovery!

Modernised from W. W. FeredayOriginal wording

The same neglect shows up in ordinary lives:

We tolerate things in ourselves, and we take things over from our fathers without question. We would judge and abandon those things if we knew the Scriptures better, and if the Scriptures had supreme authority over our souls.

Modernised from W. W. FeredayOriginal wording

Summary

- Small start. Solomon's shrines began with one act of disobedience. He married wives from other nations, and their worship followed.

- Long shadow. What Solomon set up on the hill outside Jerusalem stood for 350 years, through the reigns of kings remembered as godly.

- Silent cause. Neglect of God's Word is the only explanation offered. Godly men left standing what they never measured by Scripture.

- Real question. Josiah was not setting himself against a greater king. The issue was God against error, whoever had built it.

- Only test. Josiah acted on God's approval, not on a great name. The safeguard those kings ignored, reading God's law all their days, is open to any reader now.

2 Kings 23:14 · Darby

And he broke in pieces the columns, and cut down the Asherahs, and filled their place with the bones of men.

Josiah is tearing down the places of idol worship one by one. Here he smashes what stood on the high places — and then fills the ruined sites with human bones.

What He Broke

Writers explain the word behind "Asherim" — older translations call them "groves" — as wooden objects, not woods of trees:

On the whole it seems most probable that they were wooden symbols of a goddess. They took the form of images or pillars, or were simply tree-stems set in the ground… The many references to the idols, images, and groves show how far Israel had departed from the living God and fallen into idolatry.

Modernised from Morrish Bible DictionaryOriginal wording

Evil With A Great Name On It

A famous name stood behind these shrines. One writer pictures the objection Josiah faced, and suggests whose bones may have filled the sites:

We can well imagine people objecting to Josiah. They would say that these high places were long established, and had the dignity of King Solomon's approval. But Josiah cared about God's approval, and whatever offended God had to be destroyed. Josiah also broke in pieces the sacred pillars and cut down the wooden images and filled their places with the bones of men (v.14). This may refer to those who defended the idolatry and suffered death for this.

Modernised from Leslie M. GrantOriginal wording

Why It Had Stood So Long

Other godly kings had left this hill alone. One writer names them and explains why:

We are not surprised at the terrible deeds of men like Ahaz and Manasseh. But one of the greatest of Israel's royal sinners was Solomon. He built the temple of the LORD, and his prayer at its dedication seemed to foresee every evil and danger that might arise!… Yet godly kings like Asa, Jehoshaphat, and Hezekiah left all this untouched! Neglect of the Word of God is the only possible explanation of this.

Modernised from W. W. FeredayOriginal wording

From Disapproval To Demolition

Josiah acted; he did not just disapprove. One writer weighs that against the excuses we make:

There must be separation from the evil that led to their departure from the Lord. Idolatry must be judged and "put away." This is more than a protest against evil; it involves dealing with the evil. We are often willing to protest against evil, while shrinking from dealing with it. We may plead that it is difficult. We may fear the result. We shrink from any shame it may bring. So, under one excuse and another, we dodge our plain responsibility.

Modernised from Hamilton SmithOriginal wording

Josiah did not stop at the pillars. One writer describes how far he went, and what God thinks of it:

No one ever wiped out idolatry as thoroughly as Josiah did, right across the land of Israel. He killed all the priests, burnt their bones on their altars, and then destroyed the altars themselves, grinding them to powder. Such thoroughness God loves. The Corinthian believers were very slow to deal with wickedness in the assembly. Yet they were active in avenging their personal wrongs, even taking one another into the world's courts (1 Cor. 5:6). The Lord Jesus will carry out a world-wide clearance at His appearing.

Modernised from W. W. FeredayOriginal wording

Not Our Axes

So should readers today pick up hammers of their own?

In this day we are not called upon to be image-breakers. It is not our duty to go round with axes and hammers and destroy images and other things which we know to be hateful to God. The Lord Jesus will deal with all this when He shows Himself from heaven in Kingdom-power and majesty. Our present duty has two parts. First, to get our own souls right by testing all our ways and associations by the written Word. Second, to use our influence to help others return to the "old paths" (Jeremiah 6:16).

Modernised from W. W. FeredayOriginal wording

Hills Cleared, Hearts Untouched

Josiah's reform was real, and yet God was not satisfied with Judah:

The king's power brought about a great reformation. But it left the hearts of most of the people untouched… So why could God not rest in the improved outward state of the kingdom of Judah in Josiah's day? He looked beneath the surface. He looked for reality, for a tender conscience, for a heart that bowed to His word. He did not find them… Nothing less than thoroughness will ever satisfy God.

Modernised from The Bible TreasuryOriginal wording

Summary

- Thorough in naming. The Asherim were wooden symbols of a goddess — images, pillars, or tree-stems set in the ground.

- Thorough about reputation. A famous name backed these shrines. Josiah wanted God's approval, so he destroyed them.

- Thorough where others stopped. Asa, Jehoshaphat and Hezekiah all left this hill alone. One writer blames neglect of God's Word.

- Thorough in action, not just opinion. Josiah smashed the altars and ground them to powder. Protest is not enough; deal with evil, past the excuses of difficulty, fear and shame.

- Thorough to the heart. God looked past the cleared hillsides for reality and a tender conscience. He will not settle for less.

2 Kings 23:15 · Darby

Moreover the altar that was at Bethel, the high place that Jeroboam the son of Nebat, who caused Israel to sin, had made, both that altar and the high place he broke down; and burned the high place, stamped it small to powder, and burned the Asherah.

Josiah's reform now moves outside his own kingdom, into what had been the northern kingdom of Israel. There he pulls down the altar at Bethel — and behind that demolition stands a prophecy spoken at the altar itself, long before he was born.

What Josiah Did at Bethel

Bethel lay just outside Judah, in land the ten tribes no longer ruled. One writer traces what Josiah did there, including the wooden image the verse calls the Asherah:

Bethel was only 12 miles from Jerusalem. Jeroboam had taken it in his rebellion against Rehoboam, but of course the ten tribes had no authority left in Israel. So Josiah broke down the altar and the high place that Jeroboam had set up. He crushed the high place to powder and burned the wooden image there (v.15). He also saw graves on the mountain, clearly the graves of people who had joined in the worship at the high place. He had the bones taken from the graves and burned on the altar. This fulfilled the prophecy of the man of God who had come to Jeroboam while he stood at his idolatrous altar (1 Kings 13:1-2).

Modernised from Leslie M. GrantOriginal wording

The Man Named in the Verse

The verse does not only say Jeroboam built the altar. It adds that he made Israel sin — a description Scripture repeats again and again:

Jeroboam stands out in the Old Testament as the great division maker. Under him the great mass of God's people, ten of the twelve tribes, broke away from God's centre at that time. Like a funeral bell, the sad words the Spirit uses to mark this man out are repeated again and again: "Jeroboam, the son of Nebat, who made Israel to sin." In one chapter alone they come four times (2 Kings 15:9, 18, 24, 28). There is something appalling about it. This special way of speaking shows how terrible his sin is in God's sight, and every true heart feels how awful it is. Personal sins are bad enough, but to turn away God's people from the centre which He has set up — what could be worse?

Modernised from H J VineOriginal wording

Why the Altar Was the Target

Long before Josiah arrived, God sent a message to Bethel. It spoke against the altar, not against the idol:

The man of God cries out against the altar (1 Kings 13:2), not against the idol. For a man to imagine that he can replace God's altar is more hateful in God's eyes than anything else he can do. God's altar is the only one, and He has said so openly to all. Believers have just one altar, Christ, the Lamb of God (Heb. 13:10). God will judge wicked men who want to set up another altar beside His own. A worship set up by man cannot last forever; God's judgment will fall on it.

Modernised from H. L. RossierOriginal wording

A Word Spoken Centuries in Advance

God announced this demolition, and named the man who would carry it out, generations before Josiah was born. One writer sees no difficulty in that:

Now this is prophecy. Why make a difficulty about it? If God is God, if He really is the "I am," it is easy for Him to speak about men and their doings centuries in advance, if He chooses to do so. We live for a day, and can only speak of things happening in front of our eyes. Tomorrow is completely unknown. This prophecy is very precise, because it names the man who would destroy Jeroboam's altar. In the same way the Lord named Cyrus hundreds of years before his birth (Isa. 45:1).

Modernised from W. W. FeredayOriginal wording

The long wait, however, was a real test. Another writer imagines what the passing generations made of it:

Scoffers long may have asked, "Where is the promise of this coming prince, this child of the house of David, named Josiah?" And as generation after generation passed, and no prince of that name appeared, even the righteous may have questioned in their minds and wondered if God had forgotten, or doubted if the prophecy were really true… and at last the time had come when he should rise of whom the prophet had spoken; and the prophecy was now fulfilled — as all God's word must be.

Modernised from C KnappOriginal wording

Thoroughness, and What It Pictures

Josiah left nothing standing and nothing that could be used again:

Nowhere was idolatry ever rooted out as thoroughly as Josiah rooted it out across the whole land of Israel. He killed all the priests, burned their bones on their altars, and then destroyed the altars themselves, grinding them to powder. God loves such thoroughness… The Lord Jesus will make a world-wide clearance at His appearing.

Modernised from W. W. FeredayOriginal wording

Acting Where He Had No Authority

Josiah held no crown over these northern towns. One writer names what drove him to clean them out:

Finally, the king goes through all the cities of Israel and destroys the temples of the high places. He shows no pity to their idolatrous priests, and wipes them out. Yet by all appearances these priests had already lost their influence, since the Assyrians had carried the people away. He acts with a future restoration in view, and his heart, burning to serve the Lord, is set on it.

Modernised from H. L. RossierOriginal wording

Summary

- Word spoken. At this very altar God named Josiah before he was born. Naming a man centuries ahead is no trouble for the God who calls Himself "I am."

- Word aimed. The message struck the altar, not the idol. A worship invented by man cannot last, because believers have only one altar, Christ.

- Word against a man. Scripture keeps repeating that Jeroboam made Israel sin. He turned God's people away from the centre God had set up.

- Word executed. Josiah broke the altar down and ground the high place to powder. He burned bones on it, matching the prophecy point for point.

- Word ahead. Josiah cleansed land he did not even rule, with a future restoration in view. God loves such thoroughness, and the Lord Jesus will make a world-wide clearance at His appearing.

2 Kings 23:16 · Darby

And Josiah turned himself, and saw the sepulchres that were there on the mount; and he sent and took the bones out of the sepulchres, and burned [them] upon the altar, and defiled it, according to the word of Jehovah, that the man of God had proclaimed, who proclaimed these things.

Josiah's war on idolatry took him north to Bethel, to the altar Jeroboam had built generations earlier. There he burned bones from the nearby tombs on it, matching words a prophet had shouted at that altar three and a half centuries before.

The Altar Was the Target

The original message at Bethel was aimed at a structure, not a statue. One writer draws out why a rival altar provokes God so sharply, and what its end must be:

The man of God cries against the altar (1 Kings 13:2), not against the idol. For man to imagine that he can replace God's altar is more hateful in God's eyes than anything else he can do. God's altar is unique; this He has proclaimed before all. Believers have but one altar, Christ, the Lamb of God (Heb. 13:10). God will judge wicked men who want to set up another altar alongside His own. A worship instituted by man cannot last forever; divine judgment shall fall upon it... But God will not destroy it without at the same time putting the priests of this profane religion to death upon their own altar.

Modernised from H. L. RossierOriginal wording

A Name Spoken Before the Birth

The prophecy did not merely describe a future king in general terms. It named him. That detail is exactly where modern readers stumble, and one writer meets the objection head on:

Now this is prophecy. Why make a difficulty about it? If God is God, if He is indeed the "I am," He can easily speak about men and their doings centuries in advance, if He chooses to. We, creatures of a day, can only speak of things happening before our eyes. Tomorrow is quite unknown. This prophecy is very precise in that the man who would destroy Jeroboam's altar is named. In the same way the LORD named Cyrus hundreds of years before his birth (Isa. 45:1).

Modernised from W. W. FeredayOriginal wording

Delay Is Not Failure

Three centuries is long enough for a warning to become a joke, or to be lost entirely. The gap between the spoken word and the burning bones is itself part of the lesson:

So the prophecy came true, the one the man of God from Judah had spoken more than three hundred years earlier (1 Kings 13:2). The prophecy may have been forgotten, and unbelievers may have laughed at the idea of its fulfilment. But when God's time came He saw to the literal fulfilment of His own Word. It is so today. Rationalists scoff at the Word of God. Others treat the Bible's predictions as symbols only, and do not believe God will ever fulfil them.

Modernised from Arno Clemens GaebeleinOriginal wording

The people of Bethel had not forgotten either:

The memory of it lingered in the district, and the people recognised the fulfilment of the words of the man of God in the terrible doings of Josiah.

Modernised from W. W. FeredayOriginal wording

Half Measures Were Not Taken

Josiah did not merely close the shrine down. He emptied the graves, burned the bones on the altar, and ground the site to dust. That completeness is held up as a pattern, and it points forward:

Nowhere was idolatry ever rooted out as thoroughly as Josiah rooted it out across the whole land of Israel. He killed all the priests and burned their bones on their altars. Then he destroyed the altars themselves, grinding them to powder. Such thoroughness God loves... The Lord Jesus will carry out a world-wide clearance when He appears. "The Son of Man will send his angels, and they will gather out of his kingdom all causes of sin and all law-breakers, and throw them into the fiery furnace. In that place there will be weeping and gnashing of teeth" (Matt. 13:41-42).

Modernised from W. W. FeredayOriginal wording

One Grave Left Untouched

Josiah dug up every other tomb on that hillside. One grave he ordered left alone: the grave of the prophet who had first spoken against the altar, and of the old prophet buried beside him. One writer reads that as a picture of how God treats His own people:

We are allowed to see this. God in His holiness may have to chasten His people for their failure and unfaithfulness. Even then He does not unrighteously forget any work or labour of love shown toward His Name. So, three hundred and fifty years after these events, Josiah carries out the word of the LORD given through the man of God. He burns the bones of the false prophets. But he spares the tomb of the man of God who came from Judah, and of the old prophet of Bethel. Through their unfaithfulness, the people of God may come under His chastening. But through the faithfulness of God they will not share in the judgment that overtakes the world.

Modernised from Hamilton SmithOriginal wording

Summary

- Word spoken. A prophet cried against Jeroboam's altar and named Josiah as its destroyer, long before he was born.

- Word doubted. Three centuries of silence tempt people to forget a prophecy, or to laugh at it. Delay is not failure.

- Word kept. God's time came, and His Word came true to the letter — down to the bones, the altar and the king's own name.

- Word obeyed. Josiah burned the bones, broke the altar and ground it to powder. God loves that thoroughness, and Christ will bring the same clearance to the whole world.

- Word remembered. The same word that emptied every other grave protected one, because God does not forget work done for His Name.

2 Kings 23:17 · Darby

Then he said, What tombstone is that which I see? And the men of the city told him, It is the sepulchre of the man of God who came from Judah and proclaimed these things which thou hast done against the altar of Bethel.

A man of God once spoke God's judgment against the altar at Bethel, and he named the king who would carry it out. Three and a half centuries later that king, Josiah, stood among the graves of that town and asked about one stone.

The scene at the graves

Josiah was at work against the altar at Bethel. One grave there caught his eye.

When looking around the graves in Bethel, one in particular attracted Josiah's attention… A remarkable story is here recalled. The men of Bethel were speaking of a visit to their city three and a half centuries earlier. The memory of it lingered in the district, and the people recognised the fulfilment of the words of the man of God in the terrible things Josiah was doing.

Modernised from W. W. FeredayOriginal wording

What Josiah saw was a gravestone, and the men of the city could still read off what the buried man had said.

Seeing another gravestone, he asked about the person buried there, and was told this was the grave of the man of God who had prophesied of what Josiah had just done (v.17). So his grave was left unmolested.

Modernised from Leslie M. GrantOriginal wording

A word kept alive

Three hundred years is long enough for any message to be forgotten. This one was not.

It proves, however, that after at least three hundred years the prophecy of the prophet from Judah was still fresh in people's minds. God lets none of His words fall to the ground. He also takes care that, one way or another, the people involved keep those words in memory. The inscription on the man of God's tomb would no doubt help to keep the event from being forgotten.

Modernised from C. KnappOriginal wording

What the discovery did for Josiah

Josiah was not only fulfilling a prophecy. In the middle of the work, he learned that God had named him for it 350 years earlier.

The king of Judah must have been strengthened in heart and encouraged when he found that God had spoken of him by name 350 years earlier. God had appointed him to do the very work he was busy with (2 Kings 23:17). This settled his soul in the confidence that he was God's servant, with his work planned out for him.

Modernised from The Bible TreasuryOriginal wording

Honour for a servant who failed

The man in that grave had a record of unfaithfulness of his own. Josiah still protected his bones.

However, he spares the tomb of the man of God who had spoken these things. Whatever this man's unfaithfulness had been, Josiah recognizes what he had done for God. He spares the bones of the prophet from Samaria too — the man who caused his fall, but who had humbled himself for his mistake. In the same way, every true Christian heart recognizes what men of God in past times have done to serve Him. It respects their work, even when failure marred it and made it lose its power or spoiled its result.

Modernised from H. L. RossierOriginal wording

Another writer sees in those spared bones a picture of how God deals with His own people.

Still, we are allowed to see this. If God, in His holiness, has to discipline His people for their failure and unfaithfulness, He is not unrighteous. He does not forget any work or labour of love shown toward His Name… Through their unfaithfulness, God's people may come under His discipline. But through the faithfulness of God, they will not share the judgment that falls on the world.

Modernised from Hamilton SmithOriginal wording

A grave that warns

The tomb marks a man who let a fellow servant lead him away from God's word. The warning runs both ways — to older believers and to younger ones.

An older believer can become a spent force. Should we not guard against this? Old age does not always bring more spirituality… The old prophet — a man God could seemingly no longer use — trapped a younger man and ruined him. Younger men today must not overlook this danger. Respect for age and experience is good. But our only authority for action, in any area of life, is the Word of God. "A fellow believer advised me," or "an angel spoke to me," will not sound well at the judgment seat of Christ.

Modernised from W. W. FeredayOriginal wording

Josiah himself did not take the lesson home.

With the tender heart that marked him, Josiah should have gained from the story. But sadly, a few years later his own life — so valuable to the nation — ended in shame. Like the man of God, he stepped off the path of full obedience to the Word of the Lord.

Modernised from W. W. FeredayOriginal wording

Summary

- Word spoken — a man of God stood at Bethel 350 years earlier. He named Josiah, and he named the very act the king was now carrying out.

- Word remembered — God lets none of His words fall to the ground. The inscription on the tomb kept the prophecy fresh in people's minds for three centuries.

- Word confirmed — the discovery steadied Josiah. He was God's servant, and his work was already planned out for him.

- Word-bearer spared — God disciplines failure, but He does not forget love shown to His Name. Josiah left the bones untouched. Honour past service, even where failure spoiled its result.

- Word obeyed — the grave also warns. Respect age and experience, but act on one authority only: the Word of God. Josiah's own end shows the cost of leaving that path.

2 Kings 23:18 · Darby

And he said, Let him alone; let no man move his bones. And they saved his bones, with the bones of the prophet that came out of Samaria.

Josiah is at Bethel, burning bones from nearby graves on Jeroboam's altar. Then he stops at one tomb and orders it untouched. Two men lie there: a man of God who had failed, and the old prophet who had ruined him.

The tomb that proved God's word

The men of the city could still name that grave, centuries after the burial. One writer draws out what that meant to the king.

It proves that after at least three centuries, the prophecy of the prophet from Judah was still fresh in people's minds. God lets none of His words fall to the ground. He also makes sure that, in some way, the people they concern still remember them. The inscription on the man of God's tomb would no doubt help to keep the event from being forgotten. How awed and encouraged King Josiah must have felt! God had named him and appointed him for this work, so many generations before.

Modernised from C KnappOriginal wording

Why two sets of bones lie together

Two men are spared here, not one. The prophet called "out of Samaria" is the same man who lived at Bethel.

Seeing another gravestone, he asked who was buried there. They told him this was the grave of the man of God who had prophesied what Josiah had just done. So his grave was left undisturbed. This also covered the bones of the prophet who lived in Bethel. This verse tells us he had come from Samaria. He had buried the first prophet in his own grave and told his sons to bury him there too.

Modernised from Leslie M. GrantOriginal wording

Chastened, yet not forgotten

The man of God buried here had failed. Yet his grave is the one place in Bethel that Josiah's fire does not touch.

If God, in His holiness, has to chasten His people for their failure and unfaithfulness, He is still not unrighteous to forget any work or labour of love shown toward His Name. Through their unfaithfulness, the people of God may come under His chastening; but through the faithfulness of God they will not share in the judgment that overtakes the world.

Modernised from Hamilton SmithOriginal wording

A picture of the day of judgment

One writer sees the scene as a picture of the day God judges the world.

The Lord comes to carry out through Josiah the judgment He had pronounced through the man of God. The power of His hand makes good the declarations of His Spirit, and the day of the world's doom arrives. At that moment the hand of God respects the old prophet just as it respects the man of God. Josiah saves the tomb of these men. He keeps their bones from the punishing burning he was giving all the others found in that unclean place around the altar at Bethel.

Modernised from J. G. BellettOriginal wording

Honouring what was real in flawed servants

One writer turns Josiah's restraint into a pattern for us, covering even the man who caused another's fall.

He spares the tomb of the man of God who had pronounced these things. Whatever this man's unfaithfulness had been, Josiah recognises what he had done for God. He also spares the bones of the prophet of Samaria. That prophet caused his fall, but he had humbled himself for his error. In this way every true Christian heart acknowledges what men of God in the past have done to serve Him. It respects their work, even where failures marred it and robbed it of power or spoiled its result.

Modernised from H. L. RossierOriginal wording

The warning the tomb still carries

Respect for the grave is not approval of the lives. One writer draws out the danger for older and younger believers alike.

It is possible for an older believer to become a spent force; should we not guard against this? Growing older does not always mean growing more spiritual... The old prophet — a man God apparently could no longer use — trapped a younger man and ruined him. Younger people today must not overlook this danger. Respect for age and experience is good; but our only authority for action in any area of life is the Word of God. "Another believer advised me," or "an angel spoke to me," will not sound well at the judgment seat of Christ.

Modernised from W. W. FeredayOriginal wording

Summary

- Word kept. People still remembered a three-hundred-year-old prophecy at this graveside. God does not let His words fall to the ground.

- Word disobeyed. The man in this tomb was ruined when he took an older man's word above God's own.

- Work remembered. God chastens failure, yet He does not forget work done in love — so the altar burns while the grave stands.

- Judgment passed over. Everything around these bones burned; the bones stayed untouched. God's people do not share the world's doom.

- Pattern set. Honour the real service of those who went before you. Do not excuse the failures that spoiled it.

2 Kings 23:19 · Darby

And all the houses also of the high places that were in the cities of Samaria, which the kings of Israel had made to provoke [Jehovah] to anger, Josiah removed, and did to them according to all the acts that he had done in Bethel.

Josiah's demolition work does not stop at the border of Judah. It crosses into the towns of the old northern kingdom, whose own kings had built the shrines he pulls down. Two questions press. By what right did a king of Judah act there? And why did shrines outside his own land matter so much to him?

Reform That Refused to Stop at the Border

One writer traces where the cleansing started and how far it went.

Starting at his very doors, he began to purge Judah and Jerusalem of everything connected with idolatry. Then he carried this cleansing work on into the cities of Manasseh, Ephraim and Simeon, as far as Naphtali, and cut down all the idols throughout the land of Israel. With God-given wisdom the young king realised that he must remove every trace of idolatry — not from his own kingdom only, but from the whole inheritance of God, which the kings of Israel had defiled.

Modernised from An Outline of Sound WordsOriginal wording

One People, However Divided

The ten tribes had been carried off, and the state of the nation was humiliating. Josiah still treated Israel as one people.

Josiah, like Hezekiah and Elijah, recognised the unity of the twelve tribes. He acted on the truth of it, even though the state of things was deeply depressing and humiliating. He acted on the unchanging truth of God, not on the actual state of God's people. He carried his work of reform into all the cities that belonged to Israel.

Modernised from C. H. MackintoshOriginal wording

What Made the High Places Offensive

A high place was a place of worship set up on a hill. Not all of them honoured foreign gods, which makes the verse's charge sharper than it first looks.

The time soon came, sadly, when Israel chose high places for themselves. Some of these were for idolatrous worship, and some for the worship of Jehovah. But every high place offended Him, whatever the motives of those who set it up. They expressed self-will — hearts that were not subject to His commandments.

Modernised from W. W. FeredayOriginal wording

How a King of Judah Could Act There

Samaria was no longer Israelite territory. So how could a king of Judah tear down shrines there? One writer answers from the politics of the day.

It may surprise some that Josiah could act so freely in northern Palestine. For about a hundred years it had been a province of the kingdom of Assyria. The explanation is that Assyria was declining; its day was drawing to a close.

Modernised from W. W. FeredayOriginal wording

When Assyria deported the ten tribes, it filled the emptied towns with settlers:

…colonists from Babylon and other provinces, who brought with them their heathen gods. From that time the land which Jehovah loved held a strange mixture — Israelites and Gentiles, paganism and Judaism. What confusion as the result of disobedience to God!

Modernised from W. W. FeredayOriginal wording

A Sentence Spoken Three Centuries Earlier

Long before, a prophet had cried against Jeroboam's altar at Bethel, and a second, older prophet — the man who had earlier misled him — added a dying word that stretched the judgment wider than Bethel alone. That wider word is precisely what this verse carries out.

God restores his soul before he dies. He seals his brother's testimony against the altar of Bethel with his own, and extends that testimony to all the high places in the cities of Samaria. Whatever our unfaithfulness may be, God will not leave Himself without a witness. The weakest, the most guilty among us may become its bearer, if he repents.

Modernised from H. L. RossierOriginal wording

Thorough — and Short-Lived

The verse says Josiah treated these shrines as he had treated Bethel. One writer sums up how thorough that was, and what happened in the next generation.

Josiah's purging of the land extended to all the cities of Samaria. From these he took away all the shrines of the high places introduced by the kings of Israel. He executed all the priests of the high places, and defiled their altars by burning men's bones on them. So, as far as it was possible, Josiah completely cleansed the land of Israel from their idolatry. We would expect the faith of this young king to so influence his son that he would follow his father's steps. But sadly Jehoahaz went back to the same evil the previous kings of Judah had been guilty of.

Modernised from Leslie M. GrantOriginal wording

Summary

- Word — A dying prophet widened an earlier testimony against Bethel's altar to every high place in the cities of Samaria. This verse carries that word out.

- Reach — Josiah did not treat the north as someone else's problem. The whole land was God's inheritance, so he cleansed all of it.

- Ground — He acted on the unity of the twelve tribes. He measured his duty by the unchanging truth of God, not by the broken state of the people.

- Offence — Every high place offended God, whoever it honoured. Each one expressed self-will instead of obedience.

- Limit — The cleansing was as thorough as one man could make it. His own son undid it. Being faithful in one generation guarantees nothing in the next.

2 Kings 23:20 · Darby

And he sacrificed upon the altars all the priests of the high places that were there, and burned men's bones upon them. And he returned to Jerusalem.

This verse is the sharpest act of Josiah's whole reform. It raises two questions: why such severity, and why a king of Judah was acting in land that was not his.

The Depth of Evil Behind the Sentence

This verse ends a long list of what Josiah destroyed. One writer reads that list as a measure of how far God's own people had fallen.

The account of the cleansing of Judah and Jerusalem from all the detestable things (verses 4-20) shows the terrible depths of filth and wickedness the people who still claimed to be God's had sunk into. Every immoral practice tied to the worship of Baal and Asherah, and much else, flourished in the land.

Modernised from Arno Clemens GaebeleinOriginal wording

Why He Crossed the Border

These altars stood outside Josiah's own kingdom, among people who were not Israelites. One writer raises the obvious objection and answers it.

Josiah sends men to destroy every visible trace of idolatry, both in Judah and in the cities of Manasseh… Why should Josiah interfere with people who were foreigners to Israel? It was enough for Josiah to know that these foreigners were living in God's land, and the land had to be purged.

Modernised from The Bible TreasuryOriginal wording

A Sentence Passed Three Centuries Earlier

Josiah was not improvising. A prophet had announced this act generations earlier, and one writer weighs what that would have meant to the king.

God lets none of His words fall to the ground. He also makes sure that they stay in the memory of the people they concern… How awed and encouraged Josiah the king must have felt, to know that God had named him and appointed him for this work so many generations before. He saw how exactly the prophecy of the man of God came true. So he and all his people would be sure that the prophecies of Huldah and Jeremiah against themselves would come true in the same way.

Modernised from C KnappOriginal wording

Another writer sets the words of that prophecy beside what Josiah did, and carries the thought forward to every believer.

More than three hundred years before Josiah was born, king Jeroboam stood burning incense at his idolatrous altar at Bethel. A man of God from Judah cried out against the altar by the word of the LORD: "O altar, altar, thus says the LORD: 'Behold, a child shall be born to the house of David, Josiah by name, and he shall sacrifice on you the priests of the high places who make offerings on you, and human bones shall be burned on you'" (1 Kings 13:1-2). This prophecy came true to the letter, as 2 Kings 23:15-18 shows. God can name His servants long years before they are born, as in the case of Josiah. And this is the God who has chosen us in Christ "before the foundation of the world" (Eph. 1:4).

Modernised from An Outline of Sound WordsOriginal wording

Nothing Left Standing

The verse leaves no survivors and no altar fit for use. One writer sees that completeness as the point, not an excess.

Idolatry was never stamped out anywhere as completely as Josiah stamped it out across the whole land of Israel. He killed all the priests. He burned their bones on their altars. Then he destroyed the altars themselves, grinding them to powder. God loves that kind of thoroughness… The Lord Jesus will carry out a world-wide clearance at His appearing. "The Son of Man will send his angels, and they will gather out of his kingdom all causes of sin and all law-breakers, and throw them into the fiery furnace. In that place there will be weeping and gnashing of teeth" (Matt. 13:41-42).

Modernised from W. W. FeredayOriginal wording

He Returned to Jerusalem

The verse ends with a journey home, and the Passover waits there. One writer points out the order: first judge the evil, then obey Scripture, then keep the feast.

The good work began with the judgment of what was evil in God's sight. They firmly cleared Judah and Jerusalem of the high places, the sacred groves, and the carved and cast images, and they broke down the altars of the Baals… They had cleansed themselves of what dishonoured the LORD. They had gone back to what was there from the beginning, "the law of the LORD by Moses." Then they kept a Passover to the LORD in Jerusalem.

Modernised from H H SnellOriginal wording

What Even This Could Not Reach

The thoroughness was real, but the next generation showed its limit.

He executed all the priests of the high places and defiled their altars by burning men's bones on them (v.20). So, as far as it was possible, Josiah completely cleansed the land of Israel from their idolatry. You would expect the faith of this young king to shape his son, so that he would follow his father's steps. Sadly, Jehoahaz went back to the same evil the kings of Judah before him had been guilty of.

Modernised from Leslie M. GrantOriginal wording

Summary

- Cause — the verse ends a list showing how deep the corruption had gone among people who still claimed to be God's.

- Word — a prophet named Josiah and described this act three hundred years before he was born. God lets none of His words fall to the ground.

- Reach — Josiah acted outside his own kingdom. The ground was God's land, whoever lived on it.

- Thoroughness — priests, bones, altars: he left nothing. God loves that completeness. It is a small picture of the clearance the Lord Jesus will make at His appearing.

- Return — he goes home to keep the Passover. The order is fixed: judge the evil, obey what is written, then worship. Yet the cleansing reached the land, not his own son, who turned back.