But to the king of Judah, who sent you to inquire of Jehovah, thus shall ye say to him Thus saith Jehovah the God of Israel touching the words which thou hast heard
Huldah's reply to Josiah's messengers came in two halves. The first announced judgment on the nation; this verse turns to the king who had sent to ask.
Josiah's response to the book had two sides. So did the answer that came back.
The reading of "the book" prompted a deep twofold reaction. Josiah tore his clothes and he inquired of the Lord. The word of God brings about repentance and dependence. The message comes in two parts. The first part begins with "tell the man" and states that the judgement will come and nothing can turn it aside any more. The second part speaks to "the king of Judah" and reassures Josiah that God had accepted his humiliation and would not bring the judgement in Josiah's day.
Hearing the words was one thing. Knowing what to do about them was another.
And now who will interpret this Word for us? How are we to "inquire of the LORD" about what we should do? This Word shows that we have brought His displeasure on ourselves. Only the prophet, the representative of the Spirit of Christ (1 Peter 1:11), can interpret it for us. Josiah does not turn to Shaphan the scribe for this, or even to Hilkiah the high priest; he seeks direct contact with the Word itself... But the Spirit of Christ speaks through Huldah, this servant of Jehovah, to confirm "all the words of the book that the king of Judah has read" (v. 16), and at the same time to reassure Josiah about his own future.
One man's devotion mattered to God, and it mattered for a whole nation.
God greatly valued the devotion of individual souls, above all in days of abounding evil. Should not both writer and reader aim to have a heart always tender and humble before God? Josiah's personal devotion was of immeasurable value to the nation. God had promised him that the judgements would not fall while he lived.
One thing in Josiah drew this answer from God.
God had regard to the king's deep humiliation... To humble himself was, in fact, the only thing needed. This marked Josiah, and it always marks the faithful remnant in the middle of evil... Today you can recognize the hearts of the faithful by the humiliation they feel at the state of things. Josiah's heart was very sensitive to this; he tore his clothes and wept.
The sentence on the nation still stood. That news did not stop Josiah; it moved him to act.
Josiah learned that nothing could revoke the sentence pronounced against Jerusalem and Judah. God did promise him personal exemption. It was then that he humbled himself still further before the Lord, and set about promoting a reformation with no parallel until then in the nation's history. The judgments could not be averted, and they were not. But God fully owned Josiah's repentance. The reformation God used him to bring about was a bright testimony for God on the very eve of the nation's overthrow. Oh for something of his spirit!
A man told that ruin is fixed could decide there is nothing left to do. Josiah reasoned the other way.
It teaches us the immense value, in God's estimation, of deep personal exercise of soul and a broken heart. Josiah might have thought the case hopeless. He might have said that nothing could turn back the great tide of wrath and judgement about to roll over the city of Jerusalem and the land of Israel. He might have said that any movement of his must prove useless, that God's purpose was settled, the decree had gone out, and that he had only to stand by and let things take their course. But Josiah did not reason like that. He bowed before God's testimony. He humbled himself, tore his clothes, and wept. God took notice of this. Josiah's tears of repentance were precious to Jehovah. The dreadful judgement had to run its course, yet the penitent escaped. And not only did he escape himself, he became the honoured instrument in the Lord's hand of delivering others too.
- Sent. Josiah did not argue with the book he heard. He sent to inquire of the Lord, past the scribe and the high priest, to get God's own mind.
- Split. The answer came in two parts. "The man" hears that judgment is fixed; "the king of Judah" hears that God has heard him.
- Tender. God valued the king's broken, humbled heart; writers call that the one quality to cultivate in days of abounding evil.
- Spared, not cancelled. Being heard did not revoke the sentence on the nation; it gave one man exemption and postponement.
- Stirred. Josiah knew the ruin was fixed. Still he humbled himself further and led the greatest reform in the nation's history, and God used him to deliver others.
Because thy heart was tender, and thou didst humble thyself before Jehovah, when thou heardest what I spoke against this place and against the inhabitants thereof, that they should become a desolation and a curse, and didst rend thy garments and weep before me, I also have heard [thee], saith Jehovah.
Josiah tears his clothes and weeps. He is not mourning a personal loss. He has just heard God's words read aloud against Jerusalem — words warning that the city and its people faced ruin. God's answer names one reason He listened: the king's heart was tender.
A tender heart is not how anyone starts out. Commentators trace Josiah's to God's own work in him.
The heart of man is naturally hard in relation to God. Note the Apostle's words in Eph. 4:18: "They are darkened in their understanding, alienated from the life of God because of the ignorance that is in them, due to their hardness of heart." In His parable of the Sower, the Lord Jesus spoke of the good seed of the Word falling on the hard path (Matt. 13:4). What ground could be harder, or less likely to bear fruit? Josiah's heart was different: it could be moved. That was surely a gracious work of the Holy Spirit of God. Jer. 23:29 compares God's Word to a hammer: "Is not My word like fire, declares the LORD, and like a hammer that breaks the rock in pieces?" The Philippian jailer needed that hammer when Paul and Silas first dealt with him. King Josiah did not. His heart was already tender.
The verse turns on what Josiah did when the words were read to him. He did not judge them. They judged him.
Josiah had no doubt at all that the words Shaphan read aloud to him were genuine and true. We do not read of him asking, "How am I to know that this is the Word of God?" No. He trembled at it. He bowed before it. It struck him down. He tore his clothes. He did not dare to sit in judgement on the Word of God. As was right and proper, he let the Word judge him.
Commentators say this is why people push Scripture away. It has that power over them.
If man is to judge Scripture, then Scripture is not the Word of God at all. But if Scripture really is the Word of God, then it must judge man. And so it is, and so it does… It holds up the only true mirror, and in it a man sees himself exactly as he is. This is why man does not like Scripture. He cannot bear it. He tries to set it aside… Men do not trouble themselves so much to discover and point out flaws and discrepancies in Homer or Herodotus, Aristotle or Shakespeare.
Josiah is remembered for clearing away the wrongs of his day. But the order matters: he judged himself first.
He did not rush out first to attack the errors of other people. No. He first tore his own clothes, as a man fully humbled and self-judged. Then he called his people together, so that they too might hear the same powerful testimony and take the same ground of self-judgment and brokenness. This, he felt, was the only true road to blessing.
Josiah had every excuse to do nothing. The judgement was already settled and the sentence had gone out. What he did instead shows what God makes of a broken heart.
Josiah might have thought the case hopeless. Nothing could stop the great tide of wrath and judgement about to roll over Jerusalem and the land of Israel. Any move of his must prove useless. God's purpose was settled, the sentence had gone out, and he had only to stand by and let things take their course. But Josiah did not reason like this… God took notice. Josiah's tears of repentance were precious to the LORD. The dreadful judgement still had to run its course, yet the man who repented escaped. And he did not only escape himself. He became the honoured instrument in the Lord's hand for delivering others too.
One king's godliness held back judgement from a whole nation. That put a weight on his life which Josiah later failed to guard.
God valued the godliness of individual people, above all in days when evil was everywhere. Should not both writer and reader aim to keep a heart that is always tender and humble before God? Josiah's own godliness was worth more to the nation than anyone could measure. God had promised him that the judgements would not fall while he lived… Oh, why did he not walk with care, knowing that so much depended on his life?
- Tender — no one is born with a soft heart toward God. Commentators read Josiah's as the Spirit's work. He needed no hammer to break him.
- Trembling — he never asked whether the book was genuine. He let it judge him. Men resist Scripture because it does exactly that, as no other book does.
- Torn — he tore his own clothes before he attacked anyone else's errors. Self-judgment came first. Then he called others to the same ground.
- Heard — the sentence on Jerusalem still stood, yet God answered the tears. Repentance is never wasted, even when it cannot change the outcome.
- Held back — one man's broken heart delayed a nation's ruin. So writers press the question home: is our heart tender?
Therefore, behold, I will gather thee unto thy fathers, and thou shalt be gathered to thy grave in peace; and thine eyes shall not see all the evil that I will bring upon this place. And they brought the king word again.
Huldah's reply to Josiah's messengers has two halves: doom on Jerusalem, and a personal word for the king who wept over the book. This verse is the personal half. It raises two hard questions: why did one man's grief change anything, and how could a king promised burial "in peace" die in battle?
The promise rests on what came just before: Josiah's tender heart and his humbling of himself. One writer notes how easily Josiah could have judged mourning pointless once the sentence had gone out:
Josiah might have thought the case hopeless. He could have said that nothing would turn back the great tide of wrath and judgment about to roll over the city of Jerusalem and the land of Israel. He could have said that any move of his must prove useless, that God's purpose was settled and the decree gone out, and that he had only to stand by and let things take their course. But Josiah did not reason this way. No; he bowed before God's testimony. He humbled himself, tore his clothes, and wept. God took knowledge of this. Josiah's penitential tears were precious to the Lord, and though the dreadful judgment had to take its course, the penitent escaped.
The verse spares Josiah's eyes, not the city. His repentance bought time. What happened when that time ran out is plain:
The piety of Josiah had delayed the divine judgment, but the sin of his sons brought it on swiftly.
Neglect does not weaken what Scripture says:
People may neglect Scripture, but no one can break it. The Lord answers Josiah that he himself, because his heart was tender and he trembled at the word, will be gathered to his fathers in peace and will not see the evil. But the curses read out of the book will certainly take hold.
"Your eyes shall not see all the disaster" turns an early death into a mercy. Commentators see a pattern here:
Because the Lord had taken full account of his repentance, He assured Josiah that death would take him away before Judah's solemn calamity... How often God takes away a godly person before some great trouble that would be most painful for him to witness!
Turned around, the removal of the godly warns those left behind:
If the godly are taken away it is a solemn sign that judgment is about to fall... So it has always been in the history of the world. As one has said: "When Lots are taken out of Sodom, it signals a shower of wrath. Methuselah was taken away a year before the flood. When Noahs are taken into their arks, we may conclude that a deluge is coming. God gathers His harvest before the world's storm. He calls labourers home before the dark night comes on."
Josiah fell in battle against Pharaoh Neco. Commentators do not smooth this over. They treat it as a lesson in how God governs His servants in detail:
As to further detail of God's government, look at the case of Josiah. He fell by the hand of Pharaoh Neco, although the Lord had said, "You shall be gathered to your grave in peace." But God took him away from the evil to come. The circumstances were painful, for it seems he should have listened to Pharaoh. Josiah was chastened personally, but he did not see, as Daniel did, all that came upon Jerusalem: what a sparing from sorrow that was!
The same hand is seen in both the kindness and the wound:
Mercy took him away from the evil to come; but there was judgment in the way it happened, while the judgment that fell on the guilty city was unmixed.
The messengers carried the word back to the king. What Josiah did with it cuts both ways. Knowing the end was fixed did not slow him down:
Josiah, warned by the Lord, knew perfectly well that his work would not stop the course of judgment. He also knew that he would be gathered to his fathers before the evil came, and that his eyes would not see it. But he had only one thought... he was pressed to honour Him in the ruin of Israel, in the very place where He had been so dishonoured.
Yet he threw away the life that so much depended on:
He had God's promise that the judgments would not be poured out while he lived. He was twenty-six when Huldah spoke... Oh, why did he not walk carefully, knowing that so much depended on his life? Why did he, at thirty-nine, plunge into a quarrel that did not concern him, and risk — yes, sacrifice — his precious life?
- Tenderness counted. God had already settled the sentence on Judah. Yet He answered the one man who trembled at His word, and took knowledge of his tears.
- Delay, not escape. Josiah's repentance postponed the judgment but did not cancel it. His sons brought it down swiftly.
- Shelter in death. Not seeing the disaster was the gift; God often takes a godly person home before a trouble too painful to watch.
- Peace with a wound. He died fighting a war he should have avoided. God chastened him in the way he died, yet still spared him the sight of Jerusalem's ruin.
- No fatalism. Certainty about coming judgment left Josiah working harder, not less. The same promise should have made him walk with more care.