But this [is true], he that sows sparingly shall reap also sparingly; and he that sows in [the spirit of] blessing shall reap also in blessing
Paul is urging the believers in Corinth to finish the collection they promised for poor believers in Jerusalem. He backs the appeal with a law from the farm: the question is not what you can spare, but what harvest you want.
The whole verse turns on one swap. What looks like spending is planting.
F. B. HoleFor instance, giving is sowing, so the laws of sowing and reaping apply to it. If seed is scattered with a sparing hand there is a scanty harvest; if with a bountiful hand, a bountiful harvest. It cannot be otherwise, whether in nature or in connection with the things of God. In giving to others we are sowing grace.
Paul did not invent the picture. He takes it from Proverbs.
Hamilton SmithQuoting from the Proverbs, he reminds them how true it is... that the bountiful sower will be a bountiful receiver (Prov. 11:24-25; Prov. 22:9).
A thin harvest says something about the sowing that came before it.
Frank WallaceWho can fail to understand this simple picture? It is a very pointed challenge. We might look back over our lives and say, "Well, there has not been much in my life for the Lord." Then we would need to apply this principle the apostle teaches and say, "Well, the reason is we have not sown bountifully. The reason why we have not reaped a good healthy crop is because we have not sown in a bountiful way."
Older translations render "bountifully" as sowing "with blessings." The word describes the giver's spirit before it describes the size of the gift.
William KellyHe that sows sparingly will also reap sparingly; and he that sows with blessings will also reap with blessings. It is no question of correspondence in kind, but it may be spiritually also, and so much the better... God does not despise what is given to the poor believers; but the spirit of giving is far more important than the gift.
Another writer ties that same spirit to a harvest of real blessing.
Leslie M. GrantAs to sowing "bountifully," some have observed that this puts special stress on the generous spirit shown in giving. It marks the person who is glad to give as to the Lord. The reaping will be that of true blessing also.
The return is real. It is not a fixed rate of interest on money.
F. B. HoleIt does not mean that a man who puts a pound into the collection box is sure to reap five pounds, or indeed any pounds at all. It means this. We may be ready to sacrifice ourselves for the welfare of God's people, for the progress of God's work, for the help of God's service. Then God is ready to let us reap blessing in our own souls.
The sowing is the giver's part. The size of the harvest is not.
A. PridhamSowing and reaping stand in the natural relation of cause and effect. Yet a secret moral tie also binds them together. The one is the act of man; the other is the gift of God. He watches the sowing, and assigns the measure of return. What is scattered freely by a heart that trusts in God, He gives back with overflowing increase. What leaves reluctant hands will disappoint expectant hands.
This verse states one half of a larger law. Another passage carries the other half.
F. B. HoleIt is, of course, true that we reap as we sow as to quantity. 2 Corinthians 9:6 emphasises this side of the question... That other passage enforces the truth that as surely as God is God, we reap as we sow as to character or kind. We cannot sow one kind and reap another kind... Men cannot sow thistles and reap wheat.
- Sowing. Money you give away is not money gone. It is seed planted, and the law of the harvest applies.
- Measure. The size of the sowing sets the size of the harvest. A bare life may point back to a closed hand.
- Spirit. "Bountifully" carries the idea of blessing. The heart behind the gift counts for more than the amount.
- Return. The harvest is often spiritual, not financial. This is no promise of pounds for pounds.
- God. Sowing is your act, reaping is His gift — He watches the scattering and fixes the increase Himself.
each according as he is purposed in his heart; not grievingly, or of necessity; for God loves a cheerful giver.
Paul is writing to the Corinthians about a collection for poor believers, and he tells them how to give: not under pressure, but by a decision each person makes in his own heart. So the verse answers two questions — who fixes the amount, and what God looks at when the gift comes.
No apostle and no church fixes the amount. Each giver settles it beforehand, in private, and the way he gives matters more than the sum.
William KellyGod does not despise what is given to the poor saints; but the spirit of giving is far more important than the gift. So the apostle follows up the saying he had just applied: each one gives just as he has decided beforehand in his heart, not out of sorrow or out of necessity. For God loves a cheerful giver… To grudge and grieve over a gift is unworthy of one of His saints. To demand it is no less unworthy of His servant.
Paul practised what he wrote. He even planned the timing of the collection with this in mind.
F. B. HoleHe told them that each one should give "as he has decided in his heart." He also took care to send some brothers ahead of his own arrival, to collect what they had planned to give. That way their gift would be ready as a willing blessing, not as something squeezed out of them… He did not want them to give under pressure — not in appearance, and not in fact. He had no wish to force out unwilling gifts, or to work them up into a generosity beyond the faith and grace they had, which they might later regret.
Rule out sorrow and compulsion, and giving stops being a duty.
A. PridhamNeither sorrow nor constraint must have any place here. God is the centre and the final aim of all true kindness. As He has given, let each true child of His give. Believers should see giving not as a necessity, but as a privilege. For giving is God's own delight. We know Him only by His indescribable gift, and His heart is always toward those who copy Him in His ways. In a time of pure grace, no one is obliged to give, except by the sweet compulsion of His love. There are no task-masters in the house of God.
The Greek word behind "cheerful" is the root of an English word we still use.
G. C. WillisNote the joy we have here: the very opposite of giving grudgingly or of necessity. It reminds us of 2 Cor. 9:7, "God loves a cheerful giver." The word translated 'cheerful' is hilaros, and from it we get our word 'hilarious.' But of course it carries none of the bad sense that word has picked up in our day.
Someone is watching every gift.
Charles Henry MackintoshIt is worth thinking about this every time we are asked to give to the Lord's cause. Remember, as the box or the basket comes into my hand, that "Jesus is sitting opposite the treasury." His holy eye rests, not on the purse, but on the heart. He weighs, not the amount, but the motive. If the heart is right, the amount will be right, according to His judgment. Where the heart beats true to His person, the hand will be open to His cause.
Cheerful giving copies God's own character. And it grows from the state of the heart, not from effort.
F. B. HoleEvery man will purpose in his heart according to the state of his heart. If our hearts are right, and enlarged by living in the love of God, we shall give generously and cheerfully too. We shall give in the style of God Himself; and God loves those who are like Himself.
- Heart — the giver settles the sum inside, "as he has decided in his heart," before any basket comes round; the spirit of the gift matters more to God than its size.
- Free — two things spoil a gift: grief at parting with it, and pressure from outside. Paul collected the money in advance so that no one would feel pushed.
- Privilege — giving is not a bill to pay. There are no task-masters in God's house; the only compulsion is His love.
- Joy — the word for "cheerful" is hilaros, the root of our word "hilarious." Giving is meant to be glad, the very opposite of grudging.
- Likeness — a heart enlarged by God's love gives in God's own style, and God loves those who are like Himself.
But God is able to make every gracious gift abound towards you, that, having in every way always all-sufficiency, ye may abound to every good work
Commentary for this verse has not been generated yet.
according as it is written, He has scattered abroad, he has given to the poor, his righteousness remains for ever.
Paul is pressing the Corinthians to give, and he backs the appeal with a line from Psalm 112. That line describes a man with an open hand. It raises two questions. Why is generosity called righteousness and not kindness? And what is it that lasts forever?
The words come from Psalm 112, a portrait of the person who fears God and is blessed under His rule. One writer holds two things together. Christians have new and higher privileges. Yet God has not changed how He treats open-handed people.
William KellyIt is true that God has now revealed Himself in Christ according to His own nature, with heaven and eternity in view. It is true that He has given us life in His Son, redemption through His blood, and union with that glorified man at His right hand... But this does not stop the way God governs, or the pleasure He takes in blessing large and generous hearts. It was so of old; it is so now. Special privileges do not cancel His general principles.
Another writer looks at who this psalm describes.
Leslie M. GrantPsalm 112:9 is quoted in verse 9 for the generosity of the man that Psalm calls "a good man." It will be the character of the godly in Israel in a future day. They will be identified with their Messiah, and their hearts will be widened by grace toward others. The results abide forever.
Some have softened the word here into "benevolence." One writer resists that and defines the term instead.
William KellyThere is no need to change the meaning of "righteousness" here or anywhere else. It does not mean "benevolence"... but it includes it. Righteousness means acting in keeping with the relationship you are in. Those who admit that everything in their own case is of grace should generously remember the needs of others, above all in the household of faith. What could be more consistent than that?
That one word changes how a Christian should think about the money that leaves his hands.
F. B. HoleFirst of all, notice that giving is not a matter of charity. The Old Testament passage quoted in 2 Corinthians 9:9 reads, "He has distributed freely, he has given to the poor; his righteousness [not his charity, his righteousness] endures forever." That plainly shows that for a Christian to give is not charity in any sense. It is common, ordinary righteousness. God has poured in so much upon us that it is only righteous for us to hand out blessing to others.
The picture is of seed thrown wide, not stored up. One writer traces what God then does for the sower.
F. B. HoleHe who sows seed by dispersing abroad what he has to give has to do with a God "who is able to make all grace abound." ALL grace, note it — grace of every kind, grace in spiritual things and grace in material things. So the generous giver is "enriched in every way to be generous in every way." God enriches him so that his giving may go on and expand. This enrichment may not come in material things. God may choose to enrich him in spiritual things instead. Then the man who began by giving a little money may end by handing out a rich store of spiritual blessing.
Where does a free hand come from? One writer points to what the giver already owns.
James BoydLater in this letter we hear of the righteous man, who shows the moral characteristics of God. He scatters widely and gives to the poor, and his righteousness remains forever. Only wealthy people can afford to give away. We are made wealthy in the favour of God; there we are more than satisfied. And in the things of God, giving does not make you poor: "One gives freely, yet grows all the richer."
If giving is righteousness, then holding back is more than a missed opportunity.
F. B. HoleIf the Christian gives, no one should treat it as something wonderful and unexpected, deserving high praise. The case is rather that if he does not give he is unrighteous. It is plainly wrong for him to receive such a wealth of blessing from God and give out nothing as a result. It is not only wrong but dangerous. If a reservoir has a large intake and a choked-up outflow, a disaster of some sort is certain.
- Received — everything the believer holds came in as grace first. That intake is what makes giving normal, not heroic.
- Righteousness — the word means acting in keeping with your relationship. Remembering the needy is not charity; it is plain right dealing.
- Scattered — the giver is a sower, and God supplies him again. Sometimes with money, sometimes with a richer store of spiritual blessing.
- Blocked — a large intake with a choked outflow ends in disaster. Not giving is not neutral; it is unrighteous.
- Forever — God still blesses large and generous hearts, and the results of such giving last.
Now he that supplies seed to the sower and bread for eating shall supply and make abundant your sowing, and increase the fruits of your righteousness
Paul is finishing his appeal for a collection to help poor believers in Jerusalem. He steadies the Corinthians by pointing them away from their own accounts and toward God's supply. Two questions run through the verse. Is it a prayer or a promise? And what is the harvest God multiplies?
An older English translation reads the verse as a wish. Kelly says Paul is not wishing but stating a fact, and he points the reader to Isaiah 55:10.
William KellyThis is not a wish or a prayer, as the older English version makes it… Compare Isaiah 55:10. It is an assurance. The God who richly provides for us loves to give us both the means and the openings to bless others. He delights to acknowledge and reward these fruits of righteousness as if they were ours, though in truth they come from His grace and are His work through us.
Paul draws the picture from farming. A gardener knows how fast human effort runs out. One writer makes the point from an ordinary garden.
Frank WallaceIt is God who provides the seed so that things can grow and fruit can appear. God is the real source of all fruitfulness and blessing… We can provide the very best seed for our gardens. We can dig the ground. We can do everything the gardening books tell us. But if the rain does not come and the sun does not shine, nothing will happen.
Paul names two supplies: bread is for eating, seed is for scattering. So what God adds has a purpose beyond your own table.
The Bible TreasuryGod did not give these blessings to make His people comfortable in this world. He gave them so that they would be enriched in every way and made generous, so they would have something for anyone in need.
Here "righteousness" means the way a believer acts. The setting shows why giving to fellow believers counts as righteous and not just kind.
The Christian's FriendPaul is dealing with the care of poor believers in Jerusalem. Remember that the apostle John plainly ties that kind of care to love between believers… So when we acknowledge the duty to love God's people and act on it by meeting their need, as here, that is righteousness… This side of righteousness — practical righteousness, as it is sometimes called — is too often forgotten. Yet it fills a large place in Scripture.
What do "multiply" and "increase" promise? The reaping is real, but God chooses the currency, and the enrichment has a purpose — more giving.
F. B. HoleIf he gives sparingly, he reaps sparingly. If he gives generously, he reaps generously. Either way he reaps, and usually in spiritual things… God enriches him so that his giving can go on and grow. That enrichment may not come in material things. God may choose to enrich him in spiritual things instead, so that the man who began by giving a little money ends by handing out a rich store of spiritual blessing.
The harvest does not stop once the need is met. Kelly follows what such a gift produces in the people who receive it.
William KellyIt meets their needs, but it also overflows and rises into many thanksgivings to God. Those who receive it praise God, because such giving shows submission to His name… It stirs them to pray, with deep longing for the people who show such grace.
- Supply — God gives both the bread you eat and the seed you sow. The verse is an assurance about Him, not a wish about you.
- Sowing — The seed came from His hand, so scattering it is safe. He gives both the means and the openings to bless others.
- Separation — Bread is for eating; seed is for sowing. God gives more than you need so you will have something for someone else.
- Increase — The harvest is certain, but God does not measure it in money. He enriches the giver, often in spiritual things, so the giving can keep growing.
- Thanksgiving — The fruit does not stop when the need is met. It overflows into praise and prayer offered back to God.
enriched in every way unto all free-hearted liberality, which works through us thanksgiving to God.
Commentary for this verse has not been generated yet.