And Jesse said to David his son, Take, I pray, for thy brethren, this ephah of parched [corn] and these ten loaves, and carry them quickly to the camp to thy brethren;
Israel's army is frozen in the valley of Elah, facing a giant who has shouted the same challenge for forty days. Just then a father in Bethlehem sends his youngest son to the camp with bread and grain, and commentators read that errand as the hinge the whole battle turns on.
The order is ordinary: carry grain and bread to your brothers. Yet writers point out that this plain errand is how God brought His champion onto the field, after letting the giant boast day after day.
William KellyDavid, then, sent by his father on a simple errand of duty, was to be in the grace of God the instrument of His victory... What astonishing patience on God's part! Every day, of course, increased the self-confidence of the uncircumcised champion. Every day added to the dismay of Israel. There was one heart at least that knew no such unworthy fear.
Faith like this does not appear on the day of battle. It is built in private, by doing the duty in front of you.
J. N. DarbyFaith counts on the strength of God and does not count on self. So it simply does the work that comes its way, and thinks nothing of it. Here, in the path of duty, David gathers up the sense that God's strength is with him, ready for the trial to come. The secret of strength, learned like this in private, prepares him for what the Lord has for him to do later.
Commentators read Jesse's act as a picture of a greater sending. Notice how the son answered it: he was up early, and no one had to push him.
C. KnappBut David leaves his place. His father sends him to his brothers. And Jesus left His place of bliss on high and came to earth. He was the One sent by the Father... And notice, too, that although David's father sends him to his brothers, he went willingly. "David rose early in the morning" (v. 20). He did not hesitate or drag his feet. He was not driven; he went gladly.
Who carries a gift adds to what the gift is worth. Jesse did not send a servant.
William John HockingSo the relationship of Father and Son was already there before the Son took up His great errand and came as a man. In the same way, as a picture of this, Jesse was father and David was son before David appeared in the camp of Israel with his gift of food (1 Sam. 17). How much more the gift was worth, because the one who brought it from Bethlehem was not the giver's servant but his son!
Then there is the load itself. Writers compare it to what Jesus brought when He came.
C. KnappNext we have therefore the refreshment David brought. His father did not send him empty-handed... Now, the good things David carried to the camp are like the earthly blessings Jesus brought to Israel. He raised the dead; He made the blind see and the deaf hear... He came loaded with grace and blessing, and right and left with a generous hand He freely gave these good things to the poor and needy.
One item in that load carries its own meaning. Writers tie the parched grain to fighting men, and to the food Israel ate on entering Canaan.
H. J. VineIt is the food of the heavenly warriors, of those in the conflict of Ephesians 6. As a picture of this, Israel ate it before their victorious fighting in Canaan (Josh. 5:11). David carried it to the trenches for his warrior brothers, who were facing the Philistines at Elah (1 Sam. 17:17). So this event shows us that Christ gives this food to those He is not ashamed to call His brothers!
David's obedience is careful as well as quick.
An Outline of Sound WordsIn his obedience, David takes care of every interest of his father's. On leaving the sheepfold, "he left the sheep with a keeper," and when he ran to the ranks to greet his brothers, "David left the things in charge of the keeper of the baggage." He carried out his father's will with diligence and eagerness, and he was faithful with everything put into his hands.
The errand names one audience — his brothers — but the outcome will reach a whole nation.
H. L. RossierAs for David, he presents himself here (v. 17) as the one sent by his father to his brothers; his service begins with them. But God's purpose is a deliverance extending far beyond this limited circle. Joseph had done likewise (Gen. 37:14) and had become not only the savior of his brothers, but also the savior and master of Egypt.
- Sent. A father in Bethlehem sends his son to a frightened camp. Commentators read it as a picture of the Father sending the Son.
- Son, not servant. The gift gains its worth from the one carrying it; Jesse sent the son of the giver.
- Loaded. David comes with his hands full, as Christ came bringing blessing freely to the poor and needy.
- Food for fighters. The parched grain is warriors' rations — the same food Israel ate before winning in Canaan.
- Faithful in the errand. David guards the sheep, guards the baggage, and runs when he is told. Small duty is where God's victory begins.
and carry these ten cheeses to the captain of the thousand, and visit thy brethren to see how they are, and take a pledge of them.
Jesse's orders here are ordinary household business. He sends cheeses to an army officer, asks for news of his three sons at the front, and wants proof they are alive. Yet this errand carries David from the sheepfold to the battle line. Commentators ask whether the small obedience or the great victory is the real subject.
One writer reads the gift of cheeses for the commander of a thousand men as a window into Jesse's family.
C KnappJesse seems to have had a soldier's outlook. We see it in his present of "ten cheeses" to the colonel his sons served under (1 Sam. 17:18). So minding the sheep counted as fit service for the youngest of the family. Nor was it a large flock, but being "faithful in a very little," God would entrust him with greater matters.
Nobody asks David what he thinks of the errand. His father tells him to go, and he goes. One writer looks at how he went.
An Outline of Sound WordsThere is no sign of David fretting among the sheepfolds. He does not resent being kept away from the armies of Israel. At his father's word he is content to be his messenger. He takes food to his brothers and a present to their captain, and brings back news of how his brothers are. The simplicity of David's obedience is very beautiful. His own will is nowhere in sight, and his father's will is the only reason for his mission.
Several writers see in this errand a picture of the Father sending the Son. One of them starts further back, with who the sender and the carrier already were.
William John HockingSo the relationship of Father and Son existed before the Son took up His great errand in incarnation. To illustrate: Jesse was father and David was son before David ever appeared in the camp of Israel with his present of food (1 Sam. 17). How much more valuable the gift became, because the one who carried it from Bethlehem was not the giver's servant but his son!
Another writer hears in Jesse's sending an echo of the Father sending His Son into the world.
W. T. P. WolstonThis father sends his son down to see how his brothers are doing. It reminds us of that lovely verse: "And we have seen and testify that the Father has sent His Son to be the Savior of the world" (1 John 4:14). God has looked down on this scene, where the devil has overcome every man. He has sent into it, as a Savior, His own blessed Son… The father then sends the son. David comes into the camp and greets his brothers, carrying in his hand the pledge of a father's love and care.
Jesse sends David to three brothers. One writer sets this beside another son once sent to check on his brothers in the field.
H. L. RossierAs for David, he presents himself here (v. 17) as the one sent by his father to his brothers; his service begins with them. But God's purpose is a deliverance extending far beyond this limited circle. Joseph had done the same (Gen. 37:14) and had become not only the savior of his brothers, but also the savior and master of Egypt.
Not everyone reads David's arrival at the camp as a figure of Christ coming into the world. One writer takes it instead as God stepping in to help at a moment of crisis.
Numerical Bible NotesSo David's visit to his brothers here should not be read like Joseph's, as the Lord taking flesh and coming into the world. We should take it instead as what men coldly call a providential visitation… The true David, the son of Jesse (of the living and unchanging God), did then visit His brothers with the bread of Bethlehem, the Father's house of bread.
Nothing in Jesse's instructions hints at a duel. The errand is domestic; what God does through it is not.
William KellyDavid's father sent him on a simple errand of duty. In the grace of God he was to be the instrument of His victory… What astonishing patience on God's part! Every day, of course, increased the self-confidence of the uncircumcised champion. Every day added to the dismay of Israel. There was one heart at least that knew no such unworthy fear; but what shame and grief!
- Sent. The errand starts with the father. He chooses the gift and the messenger.
- Son. The gift carried more weight because the giver's own son brought it, not a servant.
- Simple. David's own will drops out of sight. His father's will is the only reason he moves.
- Small. Cheeses for an officer, news of three brothers: the youngest drew the smallest task, and proved faithful in it.
- Wide. The errand covers three brothers; the rescue that follows covers a nation. Commentators differ on whether the scene pictures Christ coming into the world or a later rescue in God's providence.
Now Saul, and they, and all the men of Israel [were] in the valley of terebinths, fighting against the Philistines.
This verse is a stage direction dropped into a father's instructions to his youngest son. As the father tells David where to find his brothers, the verse pulls back to show the whole nation of Israel drawn up in one valley against the Philistines. The setting matters. Israel had no strength in this valley, and that is where God stepped in with a deliverer.
The name of the valley carries its own irony: Israel stood in a place named for strength, and had none.
Frederick W. GrantSaul and the army of Israel are camped in the valley of Elah, or "the terebinth," named like the oak for its strength — if it is not the oak itself. Spiritually, the "valley" is indeed the place to find the power that shows itself in life. But it is one thing to be in the position, another to have realized the blessing of it, and this, under their failed head, the Israelites have not done. In the presence of the enemy they have no strength.
One event has made this valley famous: David killed Goliath here, in full view of both armies (Morrish Bible Dictionary).
The verse says Israel was fighting. Each day brought noise, formation and retreat.
The Bible TreasurySaul might set the army in array. The armies might go out to the place of the fight and shout for the battle (1 Sam. 17:19-21). But "the champion, the Philistine of Gath, Goliath by name, came out from the ranks of the Philistines and spoke the same words as before... All the men of Israel, when they saw the man, fled from him and were much afraid" (1 Sam. 17:23-24). This happened just as David reached the camp.
The stalemate was not an accident.
C. H. MackintoshGoliath's challenge to settle the matter by single combat made the struggle in the valley of Elah very unusual. It was the very method by which one man could stand out. It was not army against army, as in ordinary cases. The question was which man in all the host of Israel would dare to stand before the terrible uncircumcised foe. It is plain that the blessed God was about to make clear again to Israel that, as a people, they were utterly powerless. Their only deliverance, as of old, was the arm of Jehovah. He was still ready to act in His wonderful character of "a man of war," whenever faith called on Him as such.
David does not arrive as a soldier. He arrives as a messenger, sent by his father with food for his brothers.
William KellyDavid, then, sent by his father on a simple errand of duty, was to be in the grace of God the instrument of His victory: "For forty days the Philistine came forward and took his stand, morning and evening." What astonishing patience on God's part! Every day, of course, increased the self-confidence of the uncircumcised champion. Every day added to the dismay of Israel.
Notice what is missing from the errand: any trace of David pushing for something bigger.
An Outline of Sound WordsThere is no sign of David fretting among the sheepfolds. He does not resent being away from the armies of Israel. At his father's bidding he is content to be his messenger, taking food to his brothers and a present to their captain, and bringing back news of how they were. The simplicity of David's obedience is very beautiful. His own will is completely out of sight. His father's will is the only reason for his mission.
The errand also carries a larger picture: a father sending his son into a battle where every man has failed.
W. T. P. WolstonThis father sends his son down to see how his brothers fared. It reminds one of that lovely verse, "we have seen and testify that the Father has sent his Son to be the Savior of the world" (1 John 4:14). God has looked down on this scene, where the devil has overcome every man, and has sent into it, as a Saviour, His own blessed Son.
The timing of David's arrival is part of the lesson. God let the crisis run its full course first.
W. T. P. WolstonThose forty days perfectly test the armies of Israel and show their weakness and utter incompetence. They are dismayed and deeply anxious. No deliverer appears until they have a true and deep sense of their feebleness. Then is the moment for God to step in. "For while we were still weak, at the right time Christ died for the ungodly" (Rom. 5:6). Yes, it is just then that the gospel comes out.
- The place. The valley's name meant strength. Under a failed king, Israel had none in front of the enemy.
- The paralysis. They lined up and shouted for battle, then fled when the champion appeared. God was showing them that their only deliverance was His own arm.
- The errand. David came on a simple errand of duty from his father, and grace made that errand the door to God's victory.
- The obedience. His own will was out of sight; his father's will was the entire reason for the journey.
- The timing. No deliverer came until Israel felt its weakness. Christ came the same way: He died for the ungodly while we were still weak.
And David rose up early in the morning, and left the sheep with a keeper, and took his charge and went, as Jesse had commanded him. And he came to the wagon-defence; and the host which was going forth to the battle-array shouted for the fight.
The Goliath story begins with an errand, not a sling: David carries food to his brothers because his father told him to. The verse reads like a travel note. Yet commentators find in it the shape of the man God had chosen — and of Someone greater.
David did not resent the errand. His father's word was reason enough to go.
An Outline of Sound WordsThere is no sign of David fretting among the sheepfolds, or resenting being away from the armies of Israel. At his father's bidding he is content to be his messenger. He takes food to his brothers and a present to their captain, and brings back news of how they were doing. The simplicity of David's obedience is very beautiful: his own will is entirely lost sight of, and his father's will is the only reason for his mission.
David had already been anointed. That did not make him restless.
H. L. RossierLike Christ, David is here a true servant. He rises up early in the morning (v. 20) and takes his charge, so as to do his father's will. Already anointed, he is the Spirit's man for this service, while at the same time keeping his character of humility in the pastures of the sheep.
The detail about the keeper is easy to skip past. One writer reads it as a habit of mind: David did not drop one duty to take up another.
An Outline of Sound WordsIn his obedience, David is careful to look after every interest of his father's, for on leaving the sheepfold "he left the sheep with a keeper." And when he ran into the army to greet his brothers, "David left the things in charge of the keeper of the baggage." Diligence and eagerness marked him in carrying out his father's will. He was also faithful with everything put into his hands, whether the sheep or his father's goods. Does this not remind us of Him who said, "And this is the will of Him who sent me, that I should lose nothing of all that He has given me, but raise it up on the last day" (John 6:39)?
Jesse sent David; but the early start says something the command did not require.
C. KnappDavid leaves his place, and Jesus left His place of bliss on high and came to earth. He was the sent One of the Father. "For God so loved the world, that He gave His only Son." … And notice too that though David's father sends him to his brothers, he went willingly. "David rose early in the morning" (v. 20). He did not hesitate or set out with dragging feet. He was not driven; he went gladly. And Jesus, though sent by God, came willingly.
The army David walked into was shouting. One writer sets it beside an earlier shout, when the ark arrived in Israel's camp.
C. KnappThere were great shouts in the camp when the ark arrived. It was the same at a later time. Israel was again in conflict with the Philistines, and when David came in, "they shouted for the battle" (1 Sam. 17:20). But neither shout was "the sound of shouting for victory," nor was "the shout of a king" among them. It was the expression of a vain and fatal confidence. It was much easier to shout than to fight. In the same way, it is easier today to catch fire at big meetings, stirring talks and exciting music than to live in real devotion to God.
(Older translations read "shouted for the battle"; the ESV has "shouting the war cry.")
The shouting collapsed as David arrived. It exposed the one man who was not afraid.
James L. HarrisSaul might set the army in array, but there came up the champion, Goliath of Gath, out of the armies of the Philistines… This happened just as David reached the camp. Their loud shout for the battle was soon over, and all the people were in complete panic. But David was calm and undismayed through it all.
The years with the flock were not wasted. They were the training for that day.
The Bible TreasuryWhen his presence was no longer needed at Saul's court, he returned to his original work of keeping his father's sheep in the wilderness (1 Sam. 17:15). He knew his place, and kept it. In that place he learned about God in a way others had not, and that lesson fitted him for future usefulness. … Who would say he had wasted his energies in the sheepfold, when as a shepherd he experienced the deliverance of God? Now the time had come, and the occasion arose, for which God had been training His servant in the wilderness.
- Sent. David goes because his father said go; his own will is out of sight, and the command alone is his reason.
- Willing. He was not driven. Rising early shows he went gladly, as Christ came willingly when the Father sent Him.
- Faithful. He leaves the sheep with one keeper and the baggage with another. He drops nothing along the way.
- Prepared. The wilderness years were the training, not the delay — he learned God there in a way others had not.
- Contrast. He arrives to an army shouting for a fight it will not take; the shouting stops, and the quiet shepherd is the only calm man there.
And Israel and the Philistines put the battle in array, rank against rank.
Two armies stand facing each other across the valley, drawn up in full battle order. Yet the battle that follows will not be fought by those ranks at all.
The armies line up as if a normal battle is coming. But Goliath's challenge had already changed the terms.
C. H. MackintoshGoliath's challenge to settle the matter by single combat made the struggle in the valley of Elah very unusual. It was exactly the way in which one individual might be singled out. It was not army against army, as in ordinary cases. The question was who, in all the host of Israel, would dare to stand before the terrible uncircumcised enemy. In fact, it is plain that God was about to show Israel again that, as a people, they were completely powerless. Their only deliverance, as in earlier days, was the arm of the Lord, who was still ready to act in His wonderful character of "a man of war," whenever faith called on Him as such.
The ranks did more than stand still; they raised the battle cry. The noise, though, outlasted nothing.
James L HarrisSaul might set the army in array; the hosts might go out to the place of fighting and shout for the battle (vv. 19–21); but the champion came up out of the armies of the Philistines and spoke the same words as before, and all the men of Israel, when they saw the man, fled from him and were much afraid. This happened just as David reached the camp. David heard the proud defiance of Goliath, and he saw the dismay and dishonour of Israel. Their loud shout for the battle was soon over, and all the people were in complete consternation.
Another writer compares that cry to the shouting in the camp when the ark arrived years before, and turns it on the reader.
C KnappThere were great shouts in the camp when the ark arrived. Israel shouted again later, when they were in conflict with the Philistines and David came in (1 Sam. 17:20). In neither case was it "the voice of those who shout for victory," nor "the shout of a king" among them. It was the expression of a vain and fatal confidence. In both cases there was more shouting than real or effective fighting. It was much easier to shout than to fight. Today it is easier to grow excited under the influence of big meetings and stirring talks with exciting music than it is to live a life devoted to God.
Meanwhile God's answer was already on its way to the camp. It came as an errand, not as an army.
William KellyDavid, then, sent by his father on a simple errand of duty, was to be in the grace of God the instrument of His victory... "For forty days the Philistine came forward and took his stand, morning and evening." What astonishing patience on God's part! Every day, of course, increased the self-confidence of the uncircumcised champion. Every day added to the dismay of Israel. There was one heart at least that knew no such unworthy fear; but what shame and grief!
The ranks gave Israel no real strength. And no one could see any strength in David either.
The Bible TreasuryNo one could see any reason in David why he should step forward to meet the Philistine, when no one else dared to do so. Men judge by "the outward appearance," and they could see no power in him — quite the opposite. Human nature sees power in "the host," in numbers, in armour, or in the mighty Goliath. It never sees power in the young man just come from his "few sheep in the wilderness!"
So the drawn-up armies had one part left to play: to watch.
F. B. HoleThe conflict lay between the champions of Israel and Philistia, David and Goliath. The two armies stood on either side of the valley in battle array. Yet the battle lay wholly between the two men who represented them.
Their own freedom hung on how he fared.
F. B. Hole"And the men of Israel and of Judah arose and shouted." Every doubt and fear vanished at the return of their victorious representative. His victory was their victory. They were as clear and as free from the Philistine oppressor as he was.
- Array — Two armies drew up in perfect order. But this was not army against army; Goliath's challenge had reduced it to one man against one man.
- Shout — The ranks raised the battle cry, but there was more shouting than fighting. The confidence behind it was empty.
- Powerless — God was showing Israel that as a people they could do nothing. Their only deliverance was His arm.
- Representative — The armies could only watch. The battle lay wholly between the two champions.
- Shared victory — When the victor returned, every fear vanished. His victory was their victory, and they were as free as he was.
And David left the things he was carrying in the hand of the keeper of the baggage, and ran into the ranks, and came and saluted his brethren.
David reaches the valley of Elah with food from his father, hands the load to a keeper, and runs to his brothers. Commentators read this small act as a window into his obedience and eagerness — and into a father sending his son into a scene of defeat.
Some older translations call the load here a "carriage," which misleads readers today. It does not mean a vehicle:
Morrish Bible DictionaryThis word never seems to be used in the Bible in the modern sense of the word. It means "the thing carried," or "baggage." Judges 18:21; 1 Sam. 17:22; Isa. 10:28; Acts 21:15.
David does not dump his load and dash off. He places it with someone responsible, just as he had done earlier with the flock. One writer sets the two acts side by side:
An Outline of Sound WordsIn his obedience, David is careful to look after every interest of his father's. On leaving the sheepfold, "he left the sheep with a keeper." When he ran into the army to greet his brothers, "David left his carriage in the hand of the keeper." Diligence and eagerness marked him in carrying out his father's will, and so did faithfulness about everything put into his hands, whether the sheep or his father's goods. Doesn't this remind us of Him who said, "This is the will of him who sent me, that I should lose nothing of all that he has given me, but raise it up on the last day" (John 6:39)?
The same writer traces this care back to David's attitude toward the whole errand:
An Outline of Sound WordsThe simplicity of David's obedience is very beautiful. He completely loses sight of his own will, and his father's will is the only reason for his mission.
Several commentators see in the sending of David a picture of a greater sending. The son carries his father's gift into a scene of total defeat:
W. T. P. WolstonThis father sending his son down to see how his brothers fared reminds one of that lovely verse, "And we have seen and testify that the Father has sent his Son to be the Savior of the world" (1 John 4:14). God has looked down upon this scene, where the devil has overcome every man. He has sent into it, as a Saviour, His own blessed Son... The father then sends the son. David takes in his hand the pledge of a father's love and care, comes into the camp, and greets his brothers.
David came to deliver food and bring back news. He had no commission to fight. Yet the errand is the doorway to everything that follows:
William KellyDavid, then, sent by his father on a simple errand of duty, was to be in the grace of God the instrument of His victory.
Another writer traces this strength back to David's contentment in the place of duty:
J. N. DarbySimplicity of faith keeps him in the place of duty. He is content there, with no desire to leave it, because the approval of God satisfies him. As a result he can there count upon the help of God, as thoroughly secured to him; he acts in the strength of God.
David's run brings him to the exact spot and the exact moment when the giant steps out again. One account puts the sequence tightly together:
The Bible TreasuryHe runs into the army, comes, greets his brothers, and talks with them. As he talks, the stranger from Gath — Goliath by name — comes forth and utters his defiance, and David hears.
David heard the same challenge as everyone else. He judged it differently:
An Outline of Sound WordsBut David was not dismayed. He saw the giant's challenge as aimed not at Saul and his armies, but at the armies of the living God. Bringing God in between the enemy and His people made all the difference.
- Sent. The verse belongs to an errand, not a campaign. A father sends his son with food. Commentators read it as a picture of the Father sending His Son into a scene where the devil had overcome every man.
- Entrusted. "Baggage" means the load he carried — the food his father sent. David hands it to a keeper instead of dropping it.
- Faithful. He left the sheep with a keeper and the supplies with a keeper. He lost nothing his father gave him.
- Eager. He secured what his father gave him, then ran — arriving just as the giant stepped out and shouted his defiance.
- Used. A simple duty, done well, became the instrument of victory in God's grace. David stayed in that place because God's approval was enough for him.
And as he talked with them, behold there came up the champion, the Philistine of Gath, Goliath by name, out of the ranks of the Philistines, and spoke according to the same words; and David heard [them].
David arrives at the battle line with bread and cheese for his brothers. As he is speaking with them, the giant steps out and repeats the challenge he has made every day for six weeks. The verse ends on four words — "And David heard him." Everyone else had heard the same speech and done nothing.
Two things meet here. One is a defiance no one would answer. The other is a young man who has just walked into camp. One writer notes the timing.
The Bible TreasuryWhat a fearful enemy Israel had in Goliath! Morning and evening he defied their armies. No one answered him, for they were dismayed and terrified... This happened just as David reached the camp. David heard the proud defiance of Goliath, and he saw the dismay and dishonour of Israel. Their loud shout for battle was soon over, and all the people were in complete panic. But David was calm and undismayed through it all.
Goliath says nothing new. He has repeated the same challenge for forty days, and God has let him.
William KellyWhat astonishing patience on God's part! Every day, of course, increased the self-confidence of the uncircumcised champion. Every day added to the dismay of Israel. There was one heart at least that knew no such unworthy fear; but what shame and grief!
Israel's terror had a real cause. One writer reads the giant as a picture of a greater enemy, and the sword in his hand as the reason men run.
C. KnappI take Goliath here to be a kind of picture of Satan holding "the power of death." A massive sword is in his hands. With it he terrifies the Israelites. They were terrified, yet as a nation they were the Lord's people. Outwardly they were near to Him and in relationship with Him. Now, Hebrews 2:14-15 tells us that before the cross Satan had "the power of death." It says God's saints, "through fear of death were subject to lifelong slavery." That passage throws a flood of light on this chapter. Unconverted men, and even unsettled Christians, are afraid to die... "The sting of death is sin" (1 Corinthians 15:56). Conscience accuses. Men fear to die because they know that they are sinners, and that God must punish sin.
Another writer, speaking of the same valley, is blunt about the mismatch: the enemy pictured there "is too much for man, he is too much for you and me."
The same sound reached every ear in the camp. David heard a different thing in it — not an insult to a nation, but an insult to God, and that is where the giant's confidence broke.
H. L. RossierSure of his strength, he presents himself before the assembled people and challenges them. Once he has struck terror into those he wants to conquer, he cries out, "I defy the ranks of Israel this day!" He does not know that he is not dealing with Israel, but with God. In defying His people he is defying God Himself. This is his downfall.
David's calm did not come from nerve. It came from time already spent with God, out of sight.
C. H. MackintoshHe trains in secret those whom He is about to use in public. He lets His servants come to know Him in the solemn quiet of His sanctuary. He makes His greatness pass before them, so that they can face the difficulties of their path with a steady gaze... Goliath's forty days of proud boasting had fully proved the emptiness of man. Saul could do nothing. Jesse's three eldest sons could do nothing. Even Jonathan could do nothing. All was lost, or seemed to be, when the young David entered the scene. He came clothed in the strength of Him who was about to lay the pomp and glory of the proud Philistine in the dust.
David is on the field because his father sent him with food for his brothers. One writer sees in that errand the shape of a far greater sending.
W. T. P. WolstonThis father sends his son down to see how his brothers are doing. That reminds us of a lovely verse: "And we have seen and testify that the Father has sent his Son to be the Savior of the world" (1 John 4:14). God has looked down on this scene, where the devil has overcome every man. Into it He has sent His own blessed Son as a Savior... God instructed Samuel, and Samuel anointed David as king over Israel. But his people did not know their anointed king. Israel's deliverer did not come on the scene until this moment. All Israel was then in desperate straits because of the power set against them.
- Hearing — Every man in the camp heard the same challenge. One heart alone knew no such fear, and the verse ends by naming him.
- Waiting — God's patience let the boasting run forty days. Each day grew the giant's confidence and drained Israel of hope in itself.
- Training — David built his calm in secret with God. God prepares in private the people He uses in public.
- Sending — The deliverer came on a father's errand. He arrived when no one else could help.
- Breaking — The giant's own challenge ruined him. He thought he faced a nation. He was facing God Himself.
And all the men of Israel, when they saw the man, fled from him and were greatly afraid.
Goliath steps out and repeats the challenge he has made morning and evening. The whole army of Israel turns and runs. The verse shows what an army does when it can see nothing but the problem. It also raises the question the rest of the chapter answers: if no one in Israel can face this man, who can?
Israel went out to the battle line shouting for war. The shout did not last. One man in the camp stayed calm.
James L HarrisMorning and evening he defied their armies, and no one answered his defiance, for they were dismayed and much afraid. Saul might set the army in order. The army might go out to the place of the fight and shout for the battle. But the champion came up out of the armies of the Philistines and spoke the same words as before. This happened just as David reached the camp. David heard the proud defiance of Goliath, and he saw the dismay and dishonour of Israel. Their loud shout for the battle was soon over, and all the people were in complete panic. But David was calm and undismayed through it all.
Seeing the man is what started the flight. Israel did a sum, and it came out against them.
An Outline of Sound WordsThe king of Israel, and all the mighty men of Saul's forces, were unable to meet the giant in his impressive armour. They measured the power of the champion of the Philistines against their own strength. They felt themselves to be powerless, and so were much afraid.
The mistake was not that they measured. It was what they set side by side. David, arriving that same hour, compared something else.
J. N. DarbyWhat unbelief does is to compare ourselves and our own strength with circumstances. What faith does is to compare God with circumstances... How did David reason? He did not go and reason about the height of Goliath and about his own smallness of stature; he brought God in.
One writer reads Goliath as more than a large soldier. He sees him as a picture of Satan holding the power of death. That is why fighting men who belonged to God still ran.
C KnappI take Goliath here to stand for Satan, holding "the power of death." He has a massive sword in his hands, and with it he terrifies the Israelites. They were terrified, yet they were the Lord's people as a nation. They stood in outward nearness and relationship to Him. Now, Hebrews 2:14-15 tells us that Satan, before the cross, had "the power of death." It says God's saints "through fear of death were subject to lifelong slavery." That passage throws a flood of light upon this chapter. Unconverted men and even unsettled Christians fear to die. Now, why is this? One verse from the New Testament supplies the answer. "The sting of death is sin." Conscience accuses.
Their flight was not only a failure. Had Israel felt equal to Goliath and gone down to fight him, the story would have ended worse.
The Bible TreasuryNo victory, no spoil for Israel so long as Goliath could defy them; they were no match for him. Presumption would have led them to utter defeat. Their sense of powerlessness opened the way for God to step in, for He was the Lord of hosts, the God of the armies of Israel. The cause was God's and therefore the power must be of God.
Every man on that field ran. One writer points to the only Man this enemy has never beaten.
W. T. P. WolstonAnd now, my dear friend, do you have the sense that you cannot meet Satan? He has overcome every man but One, the Man who, in lowly grace, had come uncalled and unwanted into this scene. Jesus met him in the wilderness first of all. He refused his temptations and overcame him. Then He met him in the garden of Gethsemane, and again was the victor. Then on the cross He bore Satan's attack and conquered. He went by the pathway of death right down into his stronghold, so that "through death he might destroy the one who has the power of death, that is, the devil, and deliver all those who through fear of death were subject to lifelong slavery."
- Seeing — the men saw the man and ran. One sight emptied a battle line that had just been shouting for war.
- Measuring — they weighed the giant against their own strength. Unbelief compares self with circumstances. Faith compares God with circumstances.
- Bondage — one writer reads Goliath as the enemy who holds the power of death. Conscience is what makes death terrible, since "the sting of death is sin."
- Powerlessness — their helplessness was not their ruin but their opening. Confidence would have destroyed them. Having no answer left room for God to act.
- Deliverance — every man fled except One. He went down into death itself to free those held all their lives by the fear of it.
And the men of Israel said, Have ye seen this man that comes up? for to defy Israel is he come up and it shall be, that the man who smites him, him will the king enrich with great riches, and will give him his daughter, and make his father's house free in Israel.
Day after day a giant walks out and challenges Israel, and the soldiers back away in fear. All that is left in the camp is talk of the king's reward — which raises the question the chapter answers: what moves a man to fight?
The men of Israel are not rallying the troops here. They are answering a question David had just asked, and one writer hears fear in their words:
Leslie M. GrantAs they were talking together Goliath appeared, voicing his daily challenge against any man of Israel who would fight with him. This only made the men of Israel recoil in fear. Their words in verse 25 express this fear, but are an answer to David's question recorded in verse 26. David shows no fear of the giant in his questioning, for he asks, "Who is this uncircumcised Philistine, that he should defy the armies of the living God?" His formidable size makes no difference to David: when he defies God's armies, it is God whom he is defying.
Saul's offer was public and generous, and it produced no volunteer:
The Bible TreasurySaul had openly offered any man who would meet the giant and kill him three things: freedom for his father's house in Israel, the king's daughter as his wife, and great riches. The people David spoke to in the camp knew these offers well. Yet the offers failed to stir one single man to volunteer for such dangerous work. And no wonder. What are promises of passing favours and earthly pleasures to a man who thinks he must face certain death to earn the right to them? Such things shrink to nothing before the power of the enemy, with death standing in front of him.
The reward has three parts, and one writer reads them as a picture of Christ's reward:
C. KnappThe reward promised to the man who killed the Philistine had three parts — great riches, freedom for his father's house, and a bride. David killed the giant, so he had a right to this great reward. And Jesus at Calvary triumphed over sin and death and Satan, and must be rewarded for His victory.
One writer connects the third promise to a question Saul asks after the battle:
Leslie M. GrantDavid is told that the man who would fight and kill Goliath would be greatly enriched by the king, given the king's daughter as wife, and have his father's house made free in Israel. Perhaps this third reward was the reason Saul later asked whose son David was.
The same writer goes further with the middle promise, freedom for the father's house:
C. KnappNext there was freedom for the conqueror's father's house. From then on it was to be a house held in special honour. They may stand for the elect of God. All who come to Christ are given to Him by the Father... By nature and by practice they were slaves of Satan and of sin, but they have been set free. Christ died so that they might be free. By His glorious victory over death He won freedom for every member of His "Father's house."
David hears the terms, but his own question points somewhere else:
H. L. RossierDavid asks what will be done for the man who kills the Philistine and takes away the reproach from Israel. He learns that the king will make that man rich with great riches, give him his daughter, and set his father's house free. But he does not enter the fight to win this reward. He fights for God, for Israel's rescue, to make the Lord known in all the earth... No doubt his victory does give him, like Christ, great riches, a bride, and freedom for his father's house. But this is the result of his work, not its purpose.
What David does after the giant falls confirms what he was after before it:
The Bible TreasuryThe honours and riches promised to the man who killed Goliath were not what moved him. After the victory we do not find him claiming them, flattering and splendid as they were — the very prizes a man seeking his own glory would have wanted. Instead we hear him say, "Who am I, and what is my life, or my father's family in Israel, that I should be son-in-law to the king?"
- Fear speaks. Frightened men repeat the king's offer. Their words express fear, not courage.
- Reward fails. Riches, a royal bride and a free household moved no one. Gain shrinks to nothing when a man thinks he must die to win it.
- Cause moves. David asks about the same prize. But his question names the real issue: Israel's reproach, and a Philistine defying the living God.
- Victory wins. One man's fight settles it for everyone. Writers read the three prizes as riches, a bride, and a household set free by Christ's triumph.
- Reward follows. David never claimed his prize; the reward came as the result of the work, not the reason for it.
And David spoke to the men that stood by him, saying, What shall be done to the man that smites this Philistine, and takes away the reproach from Israel? for who is this uncircumcised Philistine, that he should defy the armies of the living God?
David comes to the camp and finds a whole army frozen by one man's challenge. His question is not about Goliath's size. It asks who Goliath thinks he has been shouting at.
David refuses to describe his enemy by his height or his armour. The name he gives him is a statement about where the man stands in relation to God.
An Outline of Sound WordsHe does not speak of Goliath as a giant, but as an "uncircumcised Philistine" — a man with no link to God, and in fact an enemy of God and His people. He also sees Israel in their true dignity as "the armies of the living God," a people God had set apart to act for Him with power He gave them.
The camp heard Goliath insult Israel. David heard the same words and named a different target.
C. H. MackintoshMen reported Goliath's words to David, and in them he at once recognised a blasphemous defiance of the living God. "Who is this uncircumcised Philistine," he said, "that he should defy the armies of the living God?" In the trembling crowd in front of him, David's faith recognised the army of the living God. He made it at once a question between the Lord and the Philistine.
Saul had offered rewards to any man willing to fight. Those offers moved nobody.
The Bible TreasuryThe people, to whom David spoke in the camp, knew these offers well, yet they failed to nerve one single man to volunteer for such dangerous service. And no wonder. For what are promises of temporary favours and earthly enjoyments to a man who has to face what he thinks is certain death to earn them? But David looked at the matter in another light.
The army David spoke up for was fainting with fear. Faith looked past what they had become.
C. H. MackintoshNo change of circumstances can ever rob the people of God of their dignity in the eye of faith. In the eyes of man they may be brought low, as Israel was on this occasion. But faith always recognises what God has given. So David, as he watched his poor brothers fainting before their terrible enemy, could still acknowledge those with whom the living God had identified Himself. No uncircumcised Philistine, then, ought to defy them.
The crisis did not create this confidence. David brought it in from years nobody had watched.
J. N. DarbyIn the simple path of duty with the God of Israel, when no eye was on him, he had learnt that God is faithful. So now, when he comes and sees the people of God with Goliath against them, he is astonished to find them all afraid... His business as a shepherd was to guard the sheep. If the lion came, he took it by the beard and killed it, and he killed the bear the same way. He did it without display and without boast. These were simply matters of duty, and he leaves them untold until there is a real need to mention them.
One word in David's question carries his whole argument. A man who threatens death cannot outmatch a God who lives.
C E StuartSuppose the giant was as strong as he looked, and his armour could stop any human weapon. What was he really? A man who had defied the armies of the living God. So he must fall. The power of death could not overcome the living God... The living God was for David not a formula, an abstraction, a theological expression. He was a reality.
David's question has a second half. What does the man who takes away Israel's shame receive?
H. L. RossierHe learns that the king will enrich him with great riches, will give him his daughter, and make his father's house free. But he does not enter the fight to get this reward. He fights for God, for Israel's deliverance, to make the Lord known in all the earth, and so that all the people should know how the Lord saves. His victory does give him, like Christ, great riches, a bride, and the freeing of his father's house. But that is the result of his work rather than its purpose.
- Living. David's whole case rests on one word. Death's champion cannot stand against a God who lives. For David that title was a reality, not a phrase.
- Named. David renames both sides. Goliath is a man with no link to God. Israel is God's own army. Those names settle the fight.
- Dignity. A people brought low in men's eyes still keep the standing God gave them. Faith sees it even in a frightened crowd.
- Hidden. David learned his courage with the sheep. There the lion and the bear were duty, not a story to tell.
- Reward. Riches, a bride and a free father's house followed the victory. But David fought for God and Israel's deliverance. The reward was the result, not the reason.
And the people told him after this manner, saying, So shall it be done to the man that smites him.
The men around David repeat the king's standing offer: riches, the king's daughter, and freedom for the victor's family. Their answer shows what the army prized. It also shows what no prize could make them do.
Everyone in the camp knew the offer. Yet the army that knew its terms stayed where it was.
The Bible TreasurySaul had openly offered a reward to any man who would meet the giant and kill him: freedom for his father's house in Israel, the king's daughter as his wife, and great riches. The people David spoke to in the camp knew all about these offers, yet they failed to stir one single man to volunteer for such dangerous service. And no wonder. Such promises offer favours and pleasures in this life. What are they worth to a man who must face what he thinks is certain death to earn them?
David puts the question, gets the answer, and asks again. Something in the reward did not fit the way he saw the situation.
William KellyDavid could hardly take it in. He is amazed that anyone would offer such a reward for what seemed to him such a simple business… David did not measure himself against Goliath. He saw that this was a question between God and the Philistine. That is what filled him with astonishment as he watched the utter terror of the men of Israel. He talked with them and heard it all over again. He needed to be sure they were serious in saying such things.
David asks about the reward before the fight. The reasons he gives on the battlefield later are different ones.
H. L. RossierDavid asks what will be done for the man who kills the Philistine and takes away the reproach from Israel (v. 26)… But he does not enter the campaign to get this reward. He fights for God, for Israel's deliverance, to make the Lord known in all the earth, and so that the whole assembly should know how the Lord saves (vv. 46-47). His victory does give him, like Christ, great riches, a bride, and freedom for his father's house. But that is the result of his work, not its purpose.
The soldiers' answer has three parts. One writer carries all three forward to Christ.
C KnappThe reward promised to the man who killed the Philistine had three parts: great riches, freedom for his father's house, and a bride. And David killed the giant, so he was entitled to this great reward. And Jesus at Calvary triumphed over sin and death and Satan, and must be rewarded for His victory.
Great riches raise a question: how can One who owns everything gain more? The answer comes in a picture of a prince.
C KnappThere is a mighty prince who by birth has come into vast treasures and estates. These are his by natural inheritance; they are his because of who he is. But he goes out as a warrior. He conquers everywhere, and wins extra wealth and glory such as he would never have had if he had stayed at home. What he has done wins him these. Now he has a twofold glory — one essential, the other gained. And so it is with Jesus. As the eternal Son of the Father, He has a glory all His own. It is His essential Godhead glory, in which no creature can share. But as Man in this world He has won honours, glories and riches such as He can and does share with His own redeemed and loved ones.
The people's reply rests on what Saul will give. One writer finds the weakness there.
Numerical Bible NotesThe more you examine this, the closer the application becomes. Was not the answer in those days too much the assurance of what the king would do for Israel's deliverer?… The Davids were the champions of the truth whom God raised up. They went down alone into the valley. The Sauls — yes, and Israel too — crouched in their shelters and watched the victory being won for them.
- Reproach — David names the real problem: not a tall enemy, but a disgrace lying on God's people that no one will lift.
- Reward — The answer he gets is threefold: great riches, a bride, and freedom for the victor's family.
- Refusal — The prizes moved no one. They mean nothing to a man who expects to die collecting them.
- Reason — David fought for God and for Israel's deliverance. The reward followed his work; it was never his motive.
- Realisation — Calvary wins Christ riches He shares, a bride, and freedom for His own. Israel's answer only sketched that reward.
And Eliab, his eldest brother, heard while he spoke to the men; and Eliab's anger was kindled against David, and he said, Why art thou come down? and with whom hast thou left those few sheep in the wilderness? I know thy pride and the naughtiness of thy heart; for thou art come down that thou mightest see the battle.
David comes to the camp on his father's errand, and his own eldest brother attacks him before Goliath ever does. Eliab names David's motives for him, but the verse leaves open whose heart was really on show. (Older translations word the charge "pride and naughtiness of heart," which the writers below follow.)
Eliab's anger had a cause, and the cause was fear.
An Outline of Sound WordsBringing God in made David bold, but it made Eliab angry. Eliab, like Saul and all Israel, was afraid of Goliath. David's confidence in God exposed how little confidence in God everyone who feared the giant had. This was the real cause of Eliab's opposition.
The flesh — the natural self — has one name for a power greater than its own.
James L HarrisBut the language of faith instantly stirs up the flesh. So it was with Joseph, when he told his brothers his dreams. So it is here with David and his brothers. We see this in Eliab's words: "I know your pride, and the naughtiness of your heart." Eliab sees such a power in David. When the flesh sees a power greater than its own, all it can do is call that power pride. Now Eliab was the eldest brother, and he stands here in the prominence the flesh always loves and seeks. He was a man of striking looks, but God had refused him. The Lord's anointed was not the man people admired… David was speaking the language of faith. The living God, the Lord God of the armies of Israel, filled his sight. He measured the Philistines and their champion by Him. Eliab had no such standard. He spoke and felt as a man. So the language of faith sounded to him like "pride and naughtiness of heart."
Eliab makes four accusations, and each one collapses when tested.
An Outline of Sound WordsDavid could have answered the first question, "Why have you come down here?" with the words, "To do my father's will." As for the sheep, they were well cared for by the keeper. The pride was not in David's heart, but in Eliab's. It was wounded when his weakness came to light. His envy of his brother's confidence in God made his anger explode. There was no naughtiness in David's heart; the evil was in Eliab's, and it came out in his false accusations. Nor was there a battle for David to watch. There were only the men of Israel shrinking in fear from one who defied the armies of the living God.
Eliab read his brother as a spectator. He had it backwards.
William KellyHis elder brother overheard, and his anger was kindled against David… People who think much of themselves are always ready to take offence at others. Even the closest relationship will not prevent this. Instead it gives opportunities for it… In fact David was there for much more than watching the battle. He had come down to fight it — but Eliab did not know this.
Eliab was quick to judge his brother. He was not quick to fight.
C. H. MackintoshDavid was carried forward by an energy quite unknown to Eliab, and he was not concerned to defend his course to his proud brother. Why had Eliab not acted himself in defence of his brothers? Why had Abinadab or Shammah not acted? Because they had no faith; that is the whole answer.
The sneer at the sheep is a sneer at David himself — useful for what he brought, unwanted as a person. Writers see in that a picture of a greater Rejected One.
C KnappHe is suspected and misunderstood. He was not wanted there. They were glad to get his loaves and cheeses. I am sure of that. They cared for them, but not for David. And when Jesus came, men took His temporal blessings. They were glad to get the "loaves and fishes." They were willing to have their sick healed and their dead raised. But they did not want Himself. "He came to His own, and His own people did not receive Him."
David neither argues nor retaliates — and that restraint was not his natural temperament.
The Bible TreasuryHis brother Eliab charged him in public with pride and naughtiness of heart as his motives for coming to the camp. That scorn stirred no resentment. He simply said, "What have I done now? Was it not but a word?" and turned away. Such calmness of spirit, when insulted without cause, was far from natural to him. He was a man with passions like ours. We see this when Nabal provoked him. His fiery temperament showed itself at once.
And the same treatment should be expected by anyone walking the same road.
H. L. RossierHe comes into the camp, where his brothers accuse his confidence in God and his faith of being pride and naughtiness of heart (v. 28). We too can always expect the same treatment ourselves when we follow the simple path of faith. Our relatives can no more understand our motives than the Lord's brothers could understand His.
- Exposure — David's confidence in God showed up the fear of the whole camp. That exposure, not any fault in David, kindled Eliab's anger.
- Mislabelling — the flesh has one name for a power greater than its own: it calls faith pride.
- Reversal — the pride and the evil sat in the accuser's heart, not the accused. The false charges exposed the man who made them.
- Blindness — Eliab said David came to watch a battle. David had come to fight it. The brothers who mocked had done nothing themselves, because they had no faith.
- Meekness — David did not defend himself or hit back, though he was fiery by nature. Expect the same misreading from those closest to you.
And David said, What have I now done? Was it not laid upon me?
David has come down to the camp on his father's errand, and his eldest brother has just accused him of pride and of coming only to watch the battle. His reply is one short question, and in every translation it is the answer of a man who knows why he came.
Translations render the question in different ways: "Was it not but a word?", "Is there not a cause?", "Was it not laid upon me?" One writer reads it as a plain question about motive. David had a reason for being there, and it was not the one Eliab gave him.
H. L. RossierDavid answers Eliab: "What have I now done? Was it not laid upon me?" (v. 29). What had he done to deserve being insulted? Did he not have a reason for going down to his brothers, when the God of Israel was daily being insulted by the enemy?
The reason traces back two directions at once — to the errand his father gave him, and to what the giant's challenge was doing to God.
F. A. HughesHe showed humility and a conscious sense of his father's will and the need of others, and that while facing the cruel and angry reproach of his brothers. "What have I now done? Is there not a cause?" (or, "was it not laid upon me"), vv. 28, 29 — this refers to his father's will (v. 17). He could discern not merely the desperate position of the people, but how the situation affected God: "this uncircumcised Philistine … has defied the armies of the living God." The word "defied" or "reproach" carries the double thought of blaspheming and placing in jeopardy.
Eliab charged David with pride and a bad heart. One writer finds those faults in the accuser instead.
An Outline of Sound WordsThe pride was not in David's heart, but in Eliab's. The display of his own weakness had wounded that pride. He envied his brother's confidence in God, and that envy caused the explosion of his anger. There was no wickedness in David's heart; the evil was in Eliab's and was exposed in his false accusations. Nor was there a battle for David to watch. There was only the cowardly shrinking of the men of Israel from one who defied the armies of the living God.
One writer says the same mistake repeats itself whenever we speak of confidence in God.
The Bible TreasuryAnd the flesh always mistakes faith this way. The flesh angrily replies to us, "It is pride," as often as we speak of confidence in the living God. That very confidence, which is the deepest humility, is always condemned by the flesh as pride. For no humility goes deeper than setting self aside so that the living God may come in. David, in the whole of this action, loses sight of himself, seeing only God and the armies of God.
David does not argue his case or explain himself. He asks a question and moves on.
The Bible TreasuryHe does not resent his elder brother's accusation. He knows his own motives are honest, so he leaves his character and himself in the hands of God, to be shown for what they are in God's good time.
Others hear this moment behind one of the Psalms, where the same man answers the charge of a lofty heart by describing himself as a weaned child.
J. G. BellettIt was possibly the feeling of the truly meek David, on turning away from the reproach of Eliab. (1 Sam. 17:28-29) But it could have been used happily afterwards by ransomed Israel, who were then free and confident in the salvation of God. And this assured "hope in the Lord" is always, when real and spiritual, combined with the quietness and subjection of a weaned child.
David's calm did not come from comparing himself with Goliath. And Eliab had misread why he was there at all.
William KellyIt was not that David measured himself against Goliath. He saw it to be a question between God and the Philistine. This was what filled him with astonishment, as he watched the abject terror of the men of Israel. … Indeed he was there for much more: he had come down to fight the battle. But Eliab did not know this, any more than he knew the lowly faith of David's heart.
David's own name was never the point.
The Bible Treasury"David said, What have I done? Is there not a cause?" Had David gloried in himself? No, indeed. And was there not a cause for his speaking as he did? If ever the name of the living God is brought into question, there is always a cause. We are left here in the world for this very purpose: to confess the name of Jesus before men, and to set aside our own name.
One writer hears the same question spoken now by the Saviour in glory.
W. T. P. WolstonI think David's answer to Eliab here is beautiful. "What have I now done? Is there not a cause?" (1 Sam. 17:29). Friend, listen! From the glory tonight the Saviour says to you, "Is there not a cause?" Indeed there is, for if Christ does not intervene there is no salvation for anyone. The cause was clear; the foe was too strong for us.
- Cause. David came at his father's word and found God's name defied. That, not curiosity, was his reason for being there.
- Charge. Eliab named pride and a bad heart, but neither was in David. The charge exposed Eliab's own envy and wounded pride.
- Confusion. The flesh calls confidence in the living God pride. It cannot see that such confidence is the deepest humility.
- Calm. David neither resents nor defends; he leaves his character with God to clear in God's time.
- Christ. Where God's name is in question there is always a cause. The same question now comes from the glory: the foe was too strong for us, and only Christ can save.
And he turned from him to another, and spoke after the same manner; and the people answered him again after the former manner.
His oldest brother has just accused him of pride and a bad heart, and the whole army is too afraid to fight. David neither argues nor gives up — he turns to the next man with the same words, so what was he saying that no one else would say?
David's move away from Eliab is not retreat. Commentators see a man carried along by something his brother knew nothing about. He owed Eliab no defence.
C. H. MackintoshAn energy quite unknown to Eliab carried David onward, and he was not concerned to defend his course to his haughty brother. Why had Eliab not acted himself in defence of his brothers? Why had Abinadab or Shammah not acted? Because they were faithless; simply that. Those three men had remained powerless. So had the whole congregation, terror-stricken in the presence of the enemy. Now one man appeared among them whom God was about to use in a marvellous way, and not one could understand him.
His answer is gentle, and he points back to the father who sent him. That matters for anyone whose own family stands in the way.
Leslie M. GrantDavid, however, uses a soft answer. He had come because his father had sent him: was there anything offensive in what he had done or said? In the same way the Lord Jesus did not answer angrily when Israel, His brothers according to the flesh, treated Him with unjust contempt. Yet He did not give up doing what God had sent Him to do. We must not be intimidated by relatives or friends, any more than by enemies.
The repeated words were not bravado about himself. Everyone else in the camp described the fight one way. David described it another way, and he kept his own wording with the soldiers and later with the king.
The Bible TreasuryGoliath called his opponents the servants of Saul. The people, speaking to David, said Goliath had come to defy Israel. David, however, remembered who Israel really were — the armies of the living God. That is how he answered them, and he spoke to Saul the same way. He sought to rally all Israel, so that they should no longer be afraid. Could the armies of the living God be overthrown?
That is also why he kept moving through the ranks with the same question.
William KellyIt was not that David measured himself against Goliath, but that he saw the matter to be a question between God and the Philistine. This is what filled him with astonishment as he watched the men of Israel in their abject terror. He talked to them and heard it all again and again, for he needed to be sure they were serious in making such statements.
Eliab had accused him of pride and a bad heart. David answers in one sentence and then lets it go. Commentators trace that calm to grace, not to David's own strength.
The Bible TreasuryGod blessed and strengthened David for the service he gave Israel that day. Grace also kept him in a spirit that was altogether excellent. He does not resent his elder brother's accusation. He knows his own motives are honest, so he leaves his character and himself in God's hands, for God to make them clear in His own good time.
Writers also see the Lord Jesus in this restraint under a false charge from His own people.
An Outline of Sound WordsWhile He was on earth, the Lord Jesus had to meet the same spirit of opposition, but when He was reviled, He did not revile in return. How often was He misjudged and falsely accused! The very nation He had come to save did not receive Him, yet His confidence in His God and Father was unshaken while surrounded by all the evil.
The people kept giving him the same answer, so nothing seemed to change.
William KellyAnd so one man walked in quiet and simple confidence in the Lord, and that fact gradually forced itself on the host of Israel. News then came to the king about that one soul whose heart of faith the Philistine could not shake.
Commentators call the opposition he met on the way normal for anyone who takes this road.
H. L. RossierHe comes into the camp, where his brothers accuse his confidence in God and his faith of being pride and wickedness of heart. We too can always expect the same treatment in following the simple path of faith. Our relatives can no more understand our motives than the Lord's brothers could understand His.
- Reproach. David's own brother called his confidence in God pride. Commentators say to expect the same from relatives who cannot understand our motives.
- Turn. He neither argued nor quit. An energy Eliab knew nothing of carried him on, so he moved to the next man instead of defending himself.
- Repeat. The words he would not change named Israel as the armies of the living God. That made the fight a question between God and the Philistine.
- Restraint. He left the charge against his character in God's hands, for God's own time — the same spirit as the Lord Jesus, who met His own people's contempt without an angry word.
- Result. One man's quiet confidence spread through the whole army, until the report reached the king.