1 Samuel 1:5–6

1 Samuel 1:5 · Darby

but to Hannah he used to give a double portion, for he loved Hannah; but Jehovah had shut up her womb.

Elkanah's sacrifice should have been a family celebration, but it exposed a wound: Hannah got the larger share and no child. The verse sets a husband's love beside a closed womb, and it names God as the one who closed it.

The double portion

A doubled share carried a clear message. Boaz sent Ruth home with one:

The "six measures" of barley that Ruth was carrying to Naomi equalled two ephahs. That was twice what she had gleaned herself. It was a "double portion," a sign from Boaz of special favour (Deuteronomy 21:17; 1 Samuel 1:5).

Modernised from William J HockingOriginal wording

A divided home

There are two portions because there are two wives. That arrangement is where the trouble starts:

Among the Israelites, taking a second wife was not always driven by lower motives. In many cases it came from the desire for children, which the first wife could not have. This was probably the reason for Elkanah's double marriage. But "from the beginning it was not so." Marriage was meant from the start to give a man only one companion. Marriages with more than one wife never seem to have worked well in practice. Look at the humiliating discord in Abraham's family over Hagar, and the bitter jealousy in Jacob's family between the two sisters, Rachel and Leah. Here too it breeds strife and bitterness that is shameful to see. The bitter taunts of a proud Peninnah spoil what might otherwise have been an ideal Hebrew home, and they leave her barren rival in sorrow.

Modernised from C KnappOriginal wording

Love that provoked hatred

The verse puts the husband's love beside the wife's emptiness. That love made the home harder to live in:

Hannah means "grace"; but before she matched her name, she pictures the flesh that cannot bear fruit for God. We must always begin there… Like Sarah long before, she faced the hatred and contempt of the wife according to the flesh. That wife was thriving, for Peninnah "had children" when Hannah had none. But the first wife hated her all the more, because their husband's love turned toward Hannah — the wife who was miserable and barren.

Modernised from H. L. RossierOriginal wording

The Lord's hand

The text does not blame nature or bad luck. It puts the closed womb in God's hand, and one writer sees purpose in that:

When he sacrificed, Elkanah did not forget his wives and Peninnah's children, but he favoured Hannah because he loved her. The Lord had, in His wisdom, withheld her from bearing children. … But Hannah was to learn the lesson, as we all should, that "it is not the spiritual that is first but the natural, and then the spiritual." The Lord allows mere human nature to have its way at first, to prove its own emptiness. Then He brings in something far better — just as Adam was the first man, Christ the second Man. … Even though the Lord Himself is enough to satisfy our hearts, He has planted in every believer a desire to bear fruit for Him. This is only normal and right.

Modernised from Leslie M. GrantOriginal wording

Why the door stayed shut

Hannah had a choice about where to take her pain:

Here we find that it was God who had closed her womb. I believe He did it to test her faith and to make her pray as she did. In this way she would be an example to us of prayer and perseverance, and of answer and response to God. What a wonderful story it is. So Hannah was persecuted and ridiculed, and how deeply she felt it. She could have gone to her husband and complained about the treatment, but in verse 10 she prayed to the Lord and wept bitterly.

Modernised from Frank WallaceOriginal wording

Barrenness as a picture

Her barrenness stands for more than her own grief:

The barren woman is in Scripture the picture of nature's ruined and helpless condition. There is no ability to do anything for God — no power to bring forth any fruit to Him; all is death and barrenness. Such is the real condition of every child of Adam.

Modernised from C. H. MackintoshOriginal wording

But that is not the end. The same writer names the one who can reverse it:

It is the Lord's special work to make the barren woman rejoice. He alone can say, "Sing, O barren one, who did not bear; break forth into singing and cry aloud, you who have not been in labor! For the children of the desolate one will be more than the children of her who is married, says the LORD."

Modernised from C. H. MackintoshOriginal wording

Summary

- Love — the double portion was a sign of special favour. Elkanah gave Hannah more because he loved her.

- Lack — his love could not give her a child. A home with two wives bred taunts and grief instead of peace.

- Lord — the verse names God as the one who shut her womb. He withholds in wisdom, letting what is natural prove its emptiness first.

- Lesson — barrenness pictures our own inability to bear fruit for God. Every child of Adam starts there.

- Later — the closed door drove Hannah to prayer and tears. It is God's special work to make the barren woman sing.

1 Samuel 1:6 · Darby

And her adversary provoked her much also, to make her fret, because Jehovah had shut up her womb.

Hannah lived with a rival wife who kept up the pressure, and the wound that rival aimed at was one God Himself had made. Why would the Lord close her womb, and then let that pain become a weapon against her?

A Divided Home

Elkanah had two wives. One writer traces the trouble back to a marriage God never designed, and points to the same pattern in earlier families:

Among the Israelites, taking a second wife was not always based on lower motives. In many cases it came from the desire for children, which the first wife had not been given. This was likely the reason for Elkanah's double marriage. But "from the beginning it was not so" (Matt. 19:5-8). Marriage at first meant a single companion for a man, and plural marriages appear never to have worked well in practice. Look at the humiliating discord in Abraham's family over Hagar, and the bitter jealousy in Jacob's family between the two sisters, Rachel and Leah. The bitter provoking of the proud Peninnah, and the sorrow it caused her barren rival, spoil what might otherwise have been an ideal Hebrew home.

Modernised from C KnappOriginal wording

The Sting of the Taunt

To grasp why the taunt cut so deep, you have to know what childlessness meant to a woman of Israel.

We know from the book of Daniel that Jewish women longed to give birth to a son. They hoped that son would prove to be the Messiah, the One long promised to Israel. So for a Jewish woman to be barren was a great reproach to her.

Modernised from Frank WallaceOriginal wording

Peninnah picked a public moment, and she had proof ready to hand — her own children:

She looked at Hannah's tender conscience with proud contempt and scorn, and she used this public occasion to provoke her. She did it all the more boldly because she could point to her many children as proof of the Lord's blessing, while Hannah's barrenness must be a sure sign of His displeasure. This intensified not only her grief but her isolation. In the middle of a crowd of outward worshippers, and in the presence of Eli, she was alone — but alone with God.

Modernised from The Bible TreasuryOriginal wording

Whose Hand Closed the Womb

The verse traces her barrenness to the Lord Himself. That is what Peninnah used against her, and it is also where the hope lies:

Here we find that it was God who had closed her womb. I believe He did it to test her faith and to make her pray as she did. In this way she becomes an example to us of prayer and perseverance, and of answer and response to God. So Hannah was persecuted and ridiculed, and how deeply she felt it. She might have gone to her husband and complained of the treatment, but in verse 10 she prayed to the Lord and wept bitterly.

Modernised from Frank WallaceOriginal wording

The Barren Woman as a Picture

Writers see more in Hannah's condition than a personal sorrow; they read it as a portrait of what every one of us is by nature:

The barren woman is in Scripture the type of nature's ruined and helpless condition. There is no ability to do anything for God — no power to bring forth any fruit to Him; all is death and barrenness. Such is the real condition of every child of Adam. He can neither do anything for God nor for himself, as regards his eternal destiny. He is emphatically "without strength"; he is "a dry tree," "a heath in the desert."

Modernised from C. H. MackintoshOriginal wording

Her name carries the point further. Rossier observes that she has to reach the end of herself before she can live up to what she is called:

Hannah means "grace"; but before answering to her name, she represents the flesh incapable of bearing fruit for God. We must always begin there… It is easier to confess that we are guilty than to admit that we cannot do anything. Admitting that our flesh has no power humbles us deeply.

Modernised from H. L. RossierOriginal wording

Fretting or Prayer

The taunt was aimed at making her fret. One writer warns that the same tactic is still used:

The devil would seek to occupy our thoughts with the trial, to bring in distance between our souls and the LORD. He would seek to fill our minds with the harsh words and unjust acts of those who oppose us. In this way he leads us to "fret" and "grieve" and complain in bitterness of soul, like Hannah of old. Faith turns the trial into an occasion for turning to the LORD. It not only defeats the devil but gets blessing out of the trial.

Modernised from Hamilton SmithOriginal wording

Hannah took it to God instead. In the end her circumstances did not change — she did:

The contrast is striking. First we see Hannah unable to eat, weeping in bitterness of soul. Then we see Hannah go on her way and eat, with her face no longer sad. How did this difference come about? Was it a change of circumstances, or the removal of what caused the sorrow? Not at all; the circumstances had not altered; she was still the barren woman. The secret of the change is that she had poured out her soul before the Lord. The persecution of her adversary, the fretting of spirit, the bitterness of soul — she poured it all out with weeping before the Lord. Her sorrow is poured out and God's peace is poured in.

Modernised from Hamilton SmithOriginal wording

Summary

- Cause — A home built outside God's design for marriage bred the strife. Going against His Word brings its own pain.

- Weapon — Barrenness was a deep reproach for a woman of Israel. Peninnah aimed there, and used her own children as evidence that God was against Hannah.

- Hand — The verse says the Lord Himself closed her womb. One writer reads this as God's own work to test her faith and drive her to prayer.

- Picture — The barren woman stands for human nature, with no power to bear fruit for God. Hannah, whose name means grace, must first admit she is helpless.

- Result — She did not repay the taunt. She poured it out before the Lord, and though her circumstances stayed the same, her face did not.