If they have sinned against thee, (for there is no man that sinneth not,) and thou be angry with them, and give them up to the enemy, and they have carried them away captives unto the enemy's land, far or near;
Solomon kneels at the dedication of the new temple. In the middle of asking God to hear His people, he stops to state a fact about every human being. These words shape the rest of his prayer. If sin is certain, Israel will not need a better record. It will need somewhere to turn when the record has failed.
In the ESV the verse opens with "If they sin against you." One commentator argues the real sense is "when."
Leslie M. GrantAgain, in verse 46, Solomon says, "When they sin against You," not "If," and God in anger delivers them into an enemy's hand, so that they are carried captive. Then they repent and make supplication to the Lord, and he asked that God may hear in heaven and forgive them. This section (verses 46-53) bears directly on Israel's condition today. They sinned terribly against God by rejecting His beloved Son, and so they were carried away into other lands. Solomon likely did not realise that a dispersion would last for centuries, as it has.
Because sin is certain, the outcome Solomon describes is certain too. But there is still a way back.
H. L. RossierVerses 46-53 mention the end of their history as a responsible people. Their sin brings them into captivity. Solomon is a prophet here. He sees in advance what must come upon this people under the law, for there is no man who does not sin. Yet a resource still exists. The house is there, and God cannot deny His promises. Solomon does not refer to the law, but to grace. By pure grace the God of the promises had saved His people from Egypt — could He deny this grace, even under the system of law? They are His people; will God abandon them? No. If they repent and turn toward the land, the city, and the house, God will listen to them. Daniel is an example (Daniel 6:10).
Solomon had just built a magnificent temple. Yet he aims his plea for pardon past it. One writer explains why:
The Bible TreasuryForgiveness is linked with God in His dwelling place, the heaven of heavens, and not with the house. For grace is sovereign and has its source in God dwelling in the heavens. The temple and its magnificence were well suited for the law and the covenant, but forgiveness is with God in His dwelling place... Up to this point Solomon's prayer is general. But he knows there is no one who does not sin. And he stands in the presence of the holiness and righteousness of God, who can only meet man on the ground of infinite mercy and sovereign grace. He did not know, as we do, how the cross of Christ secures that mercy — and indeed makes it overflow.
A ruler once told Jesus he had kept the commandments. One writer sets that answer beside Solomon's words.
C E StuartBy his answer the ruler claimed he had kept the commandments. That showed how completely he had forgotten the confession of the wisest of men, that "there is no one who does not sin" (1 Kings 8:46).
Solomon can only ask God to forgive. Another writer asks how God can forgive sinners and still be righteous.
J T MawsonHow can He do it, and be consistent with God's holy name and righteous rule? That question we must ask as we draw near to Him, and He answers it. Look at the multitude He calls. "There is no one who does not sin," said Solomon, as he knelt and stretched out his hands in prayer to Almighty God. How can this question be met? Above that multitude of sinners a cross raises its rugged head, and to that cross Jesus went. On it He bore our sins in His own body. There He was wounded for our transgressions.
The captivity Solomon foresaw came. Daniel still prayed toward Jerusalem, though the city and the temple lay in ruins.
C. H. MackintoshWas there any divine reason for Daniel's praying toward Jerusalem? There certainly was!... Jerusalem was God's centre. It was, it is, and ever shall be. True, it was in ruins — the temple was in ruins; but God's word was not in ruins, and here is faith's simple but solid warrant.
- Certain — Solomon treats the sin and the captivity as settled facts, not as risks. Israel's long dispersion has proved him right.
- Universal — the words allow no exception. The wisest man in Israel counted himself in, and the ruler who claimed he had kept the commandments shows how fast that is forgotten.
- Upward — because sin is certain, Solomon aims his plea for pardon past the new temple. It goes to God's dwelling place in heaven, where grace is sovereign.
- Grace — he pleads the God who saved Israel by pure grace, not the law they had broken. The cross secures the mercy he could only ask for.
- Usable — Daniel later prayed toward a city in ruins. The temple had fallen, but God's word had not.
and if they shall take it to heart in the land whither they were carried captive, and repent, and make supplication unto thee in the land of them that carried them captive, saying, We have sinned, and have done iniquity, we have dealt perversely;
Solomon is dedicating the temple. In the middle of the celebration he looks ahead to the worst thing that could happen to his people: defeat, exile, and life in an enemy's land. This verse is the turning point of his long prayer. It asks what a ruined people can still do, and gives the answer: a changed heart and an honest confession.
Solomon has just said that there is no one who does not sin. He then treats captivity as the end of the road for a people under law. Even so, he finds something left to appeal to.
H. L. RossierVerses 46-53 mention the end of their history as a responsible people. They are led into captivity because of their sin. Solomon is a prophet here. He anticipates what must necessarily come upon this people under the law, for there is no man who does not sin. Yet a resource still exists. The house is there, and God cannot deny His promises. Solomon does not refer to the law, but to grace. By pure grace the God of the promises had saved His people from Egypt. Could He deny this grace, even under the system of law? They are His people; shall God abandon them? No — if in repentance they turn toward the land, the city, and the house, God will listen to them.
The confession Solomon gives them piles up three admissions with no excuse attached. One writer has no doubt Israel will say these words one day, and names what has to break first.
Leslie M. GrantThere is no shadow of doubt that Israel will do this one day, though centuries have passed since they were scattered through the world. The pride of man's natural heart is so great that he keeps up his rebellion against God even while going through the forms of religion. But in the end the Great Tribulation will break down their arrogant pride, so that they make such a confession.
The repenting happens far from home — in the land of the enemy, with the temple out of reach. So the prayer points past the building to God's own dwelling place.
The Bible TreasuryThe Holy Spirit through His inspired instrument gives this repeated cry: "Then hear from heaven, Your dwelling place." It teaches the broken and humble to look up through the surrounding gloom to God's eternal dwelling place. It is a gracious hint for the last and closing days of the people's long captivity. They are in a far country with no access to the temple. Every outward mark that they are still the chosen people of God is gone. Let them only look up to the heaven of heavens, and He who sits on the throne will hear, and will forgive.
Centuries later Daniel, an exile in Babylon, prayed with his windows open toward Jerusalem. One writer explains what he was standing on.
Edward DennettThere was a reason his windows were open toward Jerusalem. Daniel was resting on the sure word of God when he prayed this way. The Lord had said to Solomon, "I have heard your prayer and your plea, which you have made before me" (1 Kings 9:3).
Commentators read this part of the prayer as still reaching forward to our own day.
Leslie M. GrantThis section (verses 46-53) bears directly on Israel's condition today. They have sinned terribly against God by rejecting His beloved Son, and so they have been carried away into other lands. Solomon likely did not realise that a dispersion would last for centuries, as it has.
The king who prays here is only a faint picture of someone greater.
H. L. RossierSolomon himself is only a weak picture of the true King, the true Servant of the Lord. Christ's intercession causes God to receive this people anew. He will restore them for the glory of Him who made the promises and for the glory of His Beloved.
Solomon's words about sin are not about Israel only. One writer takes them as a picture of the whole human race, and then points to the cross.
J. T. Mawson"There is no one who does not sin," said Solomon, as he knelt and stretched out his hands in prayer to Almighty God. Above that whole crowd of sinners stands a cross. Jesus went to that cross. On it He bore our sins in His own body; there He was wounded for our transgressions.
- Cause — Captivity comes from sin, and Solomon assumes it will happen, because no one is sinless.
- Turn — The one thing left to a ruined people is a changed heart and an honest confession with no excuse in it.
- Reach — God hears from heaven, so distance from the temple is no barrier; the far country is close enough.
- Proof — Daniel prayed on this promise in Babylon, resting not on the ruined building but on God's word about it.
- Result — Forgiveness and restoration. Commentators see this as still ahead for Israel, and the cross secures it for every sinner.
and if they return unto thee with all their heart and with all their soul, in the land of their enemies who led them away captive, and pray unto thee toward their land which thou gavest unto their fathers, the city that thou hast chosen, and the house that I have built unto thy name;
Solomon is still on his knees at the dedication, picturing the day when his people will be prisoners in a foreign land, far from this new house. The verse describes what will bring them back — not a journey, but a turning of heart and a direction of prayer.
Solomon does not pray only for the good days ahead. One writer sees his prayer reaching over the whole future of the nation, its fall and its recovery together:
The Bible TreasurySolomon's prayer looks onward to it, but takes up also the time in between. He counts, as it were, on the coming glory, and pleads for mercy in view of it; he sees the scattering of rebellious Israel. His prayer is a divine forecast of their history, put in the language of supplication. Grace will restore the nation to the rule and glory of Christ.
Another commentator notes how sure Solomon is that this day will come, and reads these verses as reaching to Israel today:
Leslie M. GrantAgain, in verse 46, Solomon says, "When they sin against You," not "If." God in anger delivers them into an enemy's hand, so that they are carried captive. Then they repent and plead with the Lord, and Solomon asked that God may hear in heaven and forgive them. This section (vv. 46-53) has a direct bearing on Israel's condition today. They have sinned deeply against God in rejecting His beloved Son, and so have been carried away into other lands.
The condition Solomon names is total: heart and soul, with nothing held back. One writer points out who produces that turning:
Leslie M. GrantIt will be a work of God's grace in their hearts that moves all this. His grace causes them to return to the Lord with all their heart and soul in the land of their captivity.
They pray toward the land, the city and the house because God had chosen that place and spoken about it:
C. H. MackintoshThe great question remained: "What does Scripture say?" Did God give Daniel a reason to pray toward Jerusalem? He did! First, the Lord had said to Solomon about the temple at Jerusalem, "My eyes and my heart will be there for all time." Jerusalem was God's centre. It was, it is, and it always will be. True, it was in ruins — the temple was in ruins; but God's word was not in ruins, and here is faith's simple but solid warrant.
Years later Daniel, far from home, opened his windows toward a city in ruins. One writer explains why that was not his own idea:
C. H. MackintoshFaith always seeks and finds a warrant for its activities in the word of God. This is of the very deepest importance. Without God's warrant for praying toward Jerusalem, Daniel's conduct would have been absurd. It would have been the height of folly to rush into the lions' den just to carry out some theory of his own.
God had already answered Solomon's prayer, and Daniel rested on that answer:
Edward DennettDaniel was therefore resting on the sure word of God when he prayed this way. The Lord had said to Solomon, "I have heard your prayer and your plea, which you have made before me" (1 Kings 9:3).
Solomon prayed for a whole nation, yet one man in trouble leaned on the same words. A commentator traces Jonah's hope back to this prayer:
G C WillisWords like these gave Jonah authority from the Lord Himself to count on God's mercy to forgive his sin and rescue him.
The same writer looks past the present scattering to a repentance still ahead:
Leslie M. GrantTheir present scattering has lasted for nearly 2000 years. That shows the stubbornness of the human heart. But God will yet work in the hearts of at least a remnant of Israel, breaking them down in repentance to pray for His restoring mercy. Then He will answer according to the goodness of His heart.
- Foreseen — Solomon prays for a disaster that has not yet happened. His prayer is a forecast of the nation's history.
- Given — the whole-hearted return he asks for comes from God's grace working in them, not from hardship.
- Aimed — their repentance has a direction: the land, the city and the house God chose. That is where He said His eyes and His heart would be.
- Enough — ruins did not cancel the promise. Daniel opened his windows on a word God had already heard, and Jonah leaned on the same word.
- Unfinished — the long scattering shows how hard the human heart is. The answer still waits for the day a remnant prays this prayer.
then hear thou in the heavens, the settled place of thy dwelling, their prayer and their supplication, and maintain their right;
Commentary for this verse has not been generated yet.
and forgive thy people their sin against thee, and all their transgressions whereby they have transgressed against thee, and give them to find compassion with those who carried them captive, that they may have compassion on them
Solomon is ending his prayer at the dedication of the temple, and he has just pictured the worst future for Israel: sin, defeat, and exile in an enemy's land. Verse 50 is his plea for that moment: that God would forgive it all, and then soften the hearts of the people holding Israel captive.
Solomon does not ask God to overlook one slip. He asks Him to forgive the whole record. One commentator, writing on this same prayer in 2 Chronicles, notes where Solomon sends that request — past the building he has just finished:
The Bible TreasuryForgiveness is linked with God in His dwelling-place, the heaven of heavens, and not with the house. For grace is sovereign and has its source in God dwelling in the heavens. The temple and its splendour suited the law and the covenant well. But forgiveness is with God in His dwelling-place... For suppose God judged on the principle of law, on righteousness apart from grace. Then He would — yes, He must — forsake His house and leave Israel under the awful judgment of a broken covenant.
Solomon is praying about a captivity that has not yet happened. Commentators see his words reaching far past his own day:
Leslie M. GrantThis section (vv. 46-53) bears directly on Israel's condition today. They sinned terribly against God by rejecting His beloved Son, and so they were carried away into other lands. Solomon likely did not realise that a dispersion would last for centuries, as it has.
Solomon asks God to make Israel's captors pity them. He rests the plea on who these people still belong to:
Leslie M. GrantGod will indeed then grant them compassion before their enemies. Those enemies will show compassion to the people they once persecuted. Solomon pleaded with God on one basis: the children of Israel were God's people, God's inheritance, whom He had brought out of Egypt (v. 51). Though Israel's failures were great, Solomon had confidence that God would not give them up. He had in fact set them apart from all the peoples of the earth as His inheritance, and He would not let that setting apart come to nothing (v. 53).
Commentators find the same pattern running through Israel's history:
Numerical Bible NotesBut in their distress He could not but show His pity still; and His covenant of promise was a necessary limit to their chastisement. Through all their wanderings and in their captivity He still caused mercy to be shown to them by those who were His instruments to chasten them.
Solomon is praying inside a system of law, for a people who have broken it. That leaves one resource, and behind the praying king commentators see a greater one:
H. L. RossierYet a resource still exists. The house is there, and God cannot deny His promises. Solomon does not refer to the law, but to grace. By pure grace the God of the promises had saved His people from Egypt — could He deny this grace, even under the system of law? They are His people; shall God abandon them? No — if in repentance they turn toward the land, the city, and the house, God will listen to them... And this Solomon himself is but a weak picture of the true King, the true Servant of the Lord. Christ's intercession causes God to receive this people anew.
Solomon's words did not stay in Solomon's day. Another writer traces them into Jonah's prayer:
G C WillisSurely Jonah's mind turned back to Solomon's prayer at the dedication of that temple... It was on the ground of words such as these that Jonah had authority from the Lord Himself to count on the mercy of God to forgive his sin, and deliver him.
Solomon's reason for asking reaches wider than Israel:
J. T. MawsonThere was no difference in this, no exception, for as Solomon said, there is no one who does not sin. And no man was able to deliver himself from the tempter's power, to break the yoke of sin, or wash out the stain of it.
- Cause — Solomon prays because no one is sinless. Israel's future has to rest on forgiveness.
- Source — He looks past the temple to God in heaven. Forgiveness flows from sovereign grace, not from a fine building or a broken covenant.
- Gift — God forgives the whole record: the sin, and every transgression with it.
- Reach — Mercy reaches into enemy hands. The people God used to punish Israel end up pitying them.
- Result — The scattering is not over yet. Israel's restoration rests on the intercession of the true King, of whom Solomon is only a weak picture.