And Elijah said to the prophets of Baal, Choose one bullock for yourselves, and sacrifice it first; for ye are the many; and call on the name of your god, but put no fire.
Mount Carmel has become a courtroom, and Elijah gives the opening move to the other side. Why would one man, facing four hundred and fifty opponents, hand them first choice of the animal and first turn at the altar? And why does he insist they light no fire of their own?
Elijah's terms sound generous, and they are. He lets the men who serve Baal pick their bull and go first. One writer finds the reason for his calm in the verse's last words: "but put no fire to it."
W. W. FeredayIt was important to stress that last clause when dealing with unprincipled villains. Priestly "miracles" have a bad reputation for fraud. In the calmness of faith, Elijah could afford to let Satan's agents move first. He knew well that the god they served had no power.
At the start, every outward advantage sat on Baal's side.
The Bible TreasuryAt the start the cause of Baal appeared at its best. Baal had his choice of the sacrifice and the sympathy of the court. He also had a large priesthood, zealous for his interests — that is, for their own.
Both sides would build an altar. Both would lay out a bull. Seen from a distance, the two religions looked alike, so something had to separate them.
H. L. RossierTwo religions meet face to face: Elijah's and Baal's — for the third, Israel's, takes part in both. Publicly these two religions appear to offer the same sacrifice. How are they to be told apart? One of the bulls must be consumed by fire from heaven, and not the other. By this means people will be able to recognise the true God. By this means the people too will learn to know themselves, and so be turned to repentance.
Elijah stood alone against four hundred and fifty. He asks for a test that no head count can settle.
Hamilton SmithElijah boldly proposes to put this great question to the trial by fire. "The God who answers by fire, He is God." The appeal is to God. The decision will not rest with the lone prophet of the Lord, nor with the four hundred and fifty prophets of Baal. It will be no question of human reasoning, or of the opinion of one man against four hundred and fifty. God shall decide.
The prophets of Baal took the offer and called on their god.
W. T. P. WolstonLet us go back to Carmel and see how Elijah deals with the prophets. He gives them the first chance, and they prepare their sacrifice. What comes next? They cry, "O Baal, answer us!" But there was no voice, and no one answered. And they limped around the altar that they had made. He knew the whole thing was false, just as today everything that is not Christ is false. What you and I want is the truth. And Christ is the Truth.
Their effort was enormous.
The Bible TreasuryAll day long they tore their throats, if not the heavens, with their cries. But the sheer scale of their effort only showed how useless it all was. There was no reply. The mountain of zeal did not bring forth even a mouse.
The ban on human fire was not only a guard against cheating. One writer carries it further, to the sinner and his own efforts.
Samuel RidoutThey used up the day in useless cries and in cutting themselves, and there was no response. Ashamed and silent, they had to wait for the voice of God. Then the prophet took those special precautions to make clear that it was indeed God, and He alone, who was dealing with His people. Water is poured again and again over the sacrifice and over the altar, until it fills the ditch around it. Now no possibility of fire is left, and all of nature's heat is quenched. Then, in a few simple words, the prophet asks the Lord to show Himself. He cannot show Himself where the smouldering embers of nature's efforts are still glowing. It is good for the sinner to realise this.
- Fire decides. Two altars looked the same. Only fire from heaven could tell the true God from the false, and teach the people what they themselves were.
- Fire, not numbers. The opinion of one man against four hundred and fifty proves nothing. Elijah handed the verdict to God.
- Fire, not fraud. Elijah aimed "put no fire to it" at unprincipled men, since priestly "miracles" have a bad reputation for fraud. Faith could let them go first.
- Fire, not frenzy. A whole day of shouting produced nothing. Effort on that scale only exposed how powerless the object of it was.
- Fire, not our embers. God shows Himself once nature's own heat has died out. The sinner needs to learn this.
And they took the bullock which had been given them, and sacrificed it, and called on the name of Baal from morning until noon, saying, O Baal, answer us! But there was no voice, and none answered. And they leaped about the altar that had been made.
On Mount Carmel the prophets of Baal get the first turn, and they use it for a whole morning. Their failure raises the questions the whole scene turns on: what makes a god real, and what makes prayer more than noise?
Elijah lets his opponents go first, and one writer notes he had a reason for insisting they light no fire themselves.
W. W. FeredayThe people knew well that Baal was the reputed god of fire, and said, "It is well spoken." Elijah then turned to the prophets of Baal and said, "Choose for yourselves one bull and prepare it first, for you are many, and call upon the name of your god, but put no fire to it" (1 Kings 18:25). It was important to stress that last clause when dealing with unprincipled villains. Priestly "miracles" have a bad name for fraud. In the calmness of faith, Elijah could afford to let Satan's agents move first. He knew very well that the god they served had no power.
The prophets shouted for a whole morning and got nothing back. A psalm says why.
W. W. FeredayWhat a day it was! From morning until noon the prophets cried, "O Baal, answer us!" — knowing that for them everything was at stake. Their god's silence threw them into a frenzy, and they leaped about the altar they had made. "The idols of the nations are silver and gold, the work of human hands. They have mouths, but do not speak; they have eyes, but do not see; they have ears, but do not hear, nor is there any breath in their mouths. Those who make them become like them, so do all who trust in them" (Ps. 135:15-18).
One writer names the reasoning behind the leaping, and finds the same habit in all false worship.
The Christian's FriendHaving taken their bull and dressed it, they called on Baal from morning to noon to step in and prove his claims. "But there was no voice, and no one answered." They thought, as in all false worship, that more energy was needed from them. So they leaped on the altar they had made.
Baal's side had every advantage that day: numbers, the court's backing, first pick of the sacrifice.
The Bible TreasuryAt the start, Baal's cause seemed to have everything in its favour. He had his choice of the sacrifice, the sympathy of the court, and a large priesthood, eager for his interests — that is, their own. All day they tore their throats, if not the heavens, with their cries, "O Baal, answer us." They waved their arms like madmen. They leaped in a frenzy on the altar and cut themselves with knives until the blood gushed out on them. But the sheer excess of what they did only showed how useless their efforts were. There was no reply. A mountain of zeal produced not even the smallest result.
The idol was lifeless, yet something real stood behind the worship of it — and the blood it cost settled nothing.
H. L. RossierBaal does not answer (vv. 25-29). See the irony in how the prophet treats this lifeless object! Through it Satan was working his terrible influence on the hearts of men. The blood of the false prophets flows (v. 28), but neither their blood nor the blood of any man can atone for Israel's sin or open heaven to this poor people!
The Lord warned His disciples about empty repetition in prayer. One writer points back to this scene as the example.
Arend RemmersIf the Lord had to charge the Jews with hypocrisy, He had to judge the nations for their empty repetitions and many words in prayer (see 1 Kings 18:26-29). Beyond that, He also warns His disciples against thoughtless prayers. He knew in advance what would develop in Christianity. Pagan religions are not the only home of empty repetition of pre-written prayers. Christian churches practise it too.
One writer defends the way Elijah dealt with the prophets, and turns it into a test for today.
W. T. P. WolstonI think Elijah was right in the way he treated them. He knew the whole thing was false, just as today everything that is not Christ is false. What you and I want is the truth. And Christ is the Truth.
- Cry — From morning until noon they called on Baal. Everything was at stake for them.
- Silence — No voice, no answer: the idol has a mouth that does not speak, and those who make idols become like them.
- Frenzy — When a false god stays silent, his worshippers supply more energy. They leaped on the altar and cut themselves, and a mountain of zeal produced not even the smallest result.
- Repetition — The Lord judged the nations for empty repetitions and many words. Repeated pre-written prayers carry the same fault in churches today.
- Contrast — Elijah gave his opponents the first turn in complete calm. He knew their god had no power, and that everything which is not Christ is false.
And it came to pass at noon that Elijah mocked them and said, Cry aloud; for he is a god; for he is meditating, or gone aside, or he is on a journey; perhaps he sleeps, and will awake.
It is noon on Mount Carmel. The prophets of Baal have shouted at their altar all morning and nothing has happened. Elijah finally speaks — not to pray, but to mock. Why would a prophet of God use ridicule? And what do his excuses for Baal say about the god they were calling?
Elijah said nothing all morning. He let the prophets of Baal call on their god for hours before he opened his mouth.
Hamilton SmithThey prepare their altar, dress their bull, and call on their god. From morning until noon they cry to Baal. It was useless — there was no voice, and no one answered. Until midday Elijah is a silent witness of their futile efforts. Then at last, for the first and only time, he speaks to these false prophets. And it is only to mock them.
Elijah offers four excuses for Baal. He is deep in thought. He has stepped aside to relieve himself. He is travelling, or asleep. Each excuse gives Baal a limit. Two of the writers quoted below use an older translation, which has "he is talking, or he is pursuing" where the ESV reads "he is musing, or he is relieving himself."
Leslie M. GrantElijah gave the prophets of Baal plenty of time to call on their mystical god... When there was no answer, they jumped around the altar they had made. They acted as though their movements could influence their idol! After a few hours of useless energy, Elijah mocked them. He told them to cry louder. Perhaps Baal was preoccupied, or busy, or on a journey, or asleep and needed waking. They had no idea of a God who knows everything and is present everywhere.
The idol itself was a lifeless thing. One writer names who was working through it, and what all the blood spilled that day could never do.
H. L. RossierSee the irony in the way the prophet treats this lifeless object! Through it Satan was exercising his terrible influence over the hearts of men. The blood of the false prophets flows. But neither their blood nor any man's can atone for Israel's sin or open heaven to this poor people!
Elijah's words did not calm the scene. They drove the prophets to try harder, and to cut themselves for an answer that never came.
The Christian's FriendThey thought more energy was needed from them, as in all false worship... Elijah mocked them, for he knew that gods made by human hands were only emptiness. By his taunts and irony he provoked them to desperation, so that they cut themselves with knives and lances "until the blood gushed out upon them." It was all useless. They kept up their "prophesying" until the time of the evening sacrifice, but "there was no voice. No one answered; no one paid attention."
One writer draws a lesson from the contrast. Elijah knew what it was to pray and be heard. The priests of Baal did not.
The Christian's FriendNow let me ask whether you know what prayer is. What use is prayer if you have no sense that God has heard you? Look at the priests of Baal. Elijah said to them, "Cry aloud" — cry louder still, until he does hear. "Either he is talking, or he is pursuing, or he is on a journey, or perhaps he is asleep and must be awakened." He said it mockingly. He himself knew what it was to be heard, to be joined in his own soul to a God who always hears. So it is with us now.
Was Elijah right to mock? One writer answers yes, and points past Baal to what is false today.
W. T. P. WolstonAnd now the prophet turns a little sarcastic as he says, "Cry aloud! for he is a god; either he is talking, or he is pursuing, or he is on a journey, or perhaps he is asleep and must be awakened." I think Elijah was right in the way he treated them. He knew the whole thing was false, just as today everything that is not Christ is false. What you and I want is the truth. And Christ is the Truth.
- Silence — Elijah watched from morning to noon without a word. His only words to them were mockery.
- Smallness — Every excuse in the taunt gives Baal a limit: distracted, away, asleep. The prophets had no idea of a God who knows everything and is present everywhere.
- Emptiness — Elijah knew that gods made by human hands are only emptiness. And no amount of spilled human blood can atone for sin.
- Frenzy — The taunt drove them to knives and lances. More noise and more blood produced the same result: no voice, no answer, no one who paid attention.
- Certainty — Elijah could mock a sleeping god because he knew a God who always hears. That contrast runs through the whole scene.
And they cried aloud, and cut themselves after their manner with swords and spears, till the blood gushed out upon them.
For hours the prophets of Baal had called on their god, and no answer came. This verse shows what they did next: they shouted louder and cut open their own bodies, as if their own blood could force him to act.
The word behind "lances" is a soldier's weapon. One reference work explains what these men turned on themselves:
Morrish Bible Dictionaryromach. A spear used by warriors, with a metal point. 1 Kings 18:28. The word is often translated 'spear.' The priests of Baal, in their desperation, wounded themselves with this weapon.
The cutting did not start the contest. It came after hours of silence, and after Elijah had mocked them:
W. W. FeredayWith the crowds looking on, when noon came Elijah mocked the unhappy prophets. He suggested that they were not crying loudly enough. Perhaps their god was busy with something else and could not attend to them. Perhaps he was away from home. Or perhaps he was asleep! Stung by these taunts, the false prophets gashed themselves with swords and spears until their bodies streamed with blood! This unholy farce, carried on by men made in the image of God, was allowed to continue three hours longer.
Before the knives came the leaping. One writer names what these men had never understood about God:
Leslie M. GrantWhen there was no answer, they jumped around the altar they had made, as though to influence their idol with their physical movements! They had no conception of an all-knowing, ever-present God.
Silence did not stop them. It only made them work harder, and that pattern runs through all false worship.
The Christian's FriendThey thought that more energy was demanded on their part, as in all false worship. So they leaped upon the altar that was made. Elijah mocked them, for he knew that gods made with men's hands were only vanity. His taunts and irony drove them to desperation, so that they cut themselves with knives and lances "until the blood gushed out upon them." It was all in vain.
Their blood flowed, and it settled nothing. One writer says why that blood could do nothing for Israel:
H. L. RossierBaal does not answer (vv. 25-29). See the irony the prophet uses against this lifeless object! Through it Satan was working his terrible influence on the hearts of men. The blood of the false prophets flows (v. 28). But neither their blood nor any man's blood can atone for Israel's sin or open heaven to this poor people!
Scripture later warns believers against people it calls "the concision." One writer links that warning back to what the priests of Baal did:
William Kelly"Beware of evil workers, beware of the concision" — a play upon the word "circumcision." We know how the idolatrous priests cut themselves with knives and lances (1 Kings 18:28). This may refer to that practice. It is astonishing how far the flesh may go in its religious energy, entirely opposed to the mind of God.
The verse says they cut themselves "after their custom." This was a settled practice, not a one-off, and one writer traces the same idea into later systems of penance:
For the YoungLong ago, the priests of the heathen nations required their people to do works of penance and self-punishment. They even cut their flesh with knives, like the priests of Baal in 1 Kings 18:28. So Rome teaches that God is not satisfied without bodily tortures and endless penances. But this denies the value of the FINISHED WORK of the Lord Jesus Christ. It denies the PRECIOUS BLOOD that alone cleanses from ALL sin.
The same writer contrasts this with true self-denial:
Leslie M. GrantThese poor, deluded Baal worshippers did not notice Elijah's sarcasm. So they took his advice: they cried out more loudly to Baal, and they also cut themselves with knives and lances. In this way idolaters injure the body literally. They think this is the self-denial that will influence their false god. How different is the true self-denial of a believer! True self-denial makes no show, but involves a sober self-judgment in spiritual reality.
- Silence — Baal never answered. His prophets had no idea of a God who is all-knowing and always present.
- Frenzy — silence pushed them to shouting, then to blood. In all false worship the demand falls back on the worshipper's own effort.
- Blood — their blood flowed, yet no man's blood can cover Israel's sin or open heaven.
- Flesh — Scripture's warning against "the concision" may point back to this cutting. It shows how far religious flesh will go against the mind of God.
- Contrast — penance and self-harm deny the finished work of Christ. Real self-denial makes no show at all.
And it came to pass when midday was past, that they prophesied until the [time] of the offering up of the oblation; but there was neither voice, nor any that answered, nor any attention.
On Mount Carmel Israel had to choose between the LORD and Baal, and the test was simple: the God who answers by fire is God. Verse 29 is the end of Baal's turn — a whole day of crying out and cutting, and not one sound from heaven.
Baal's prophets had the whole day to themselves, from morning until the evening sacrifice. One writer traces the hours and their growing desperation:
Hamilton SmithFrom morning until noon they cried to Baal. It was in vain. There was no voice and no one answered. Until midday Elijah watches their useless efforts in silence. Then at last he speaks to these false prophets, for the first and only time — and only to mock them. Stung by the scorn of Elijah they redouble their efforts. For three hours more, from noon until the evening sacrifice, they cry aloud and cut themselves with knives until their blood gushes out. Still it is all in vain: "there was no voice. No one answered; no one paid attention."
Nothing answered, because there was nothing there to answer:
A. J. PollockThe prophets of Baal call upon their false god. No fire leaps from a cloudless sky. They become frenzied in their call upon Baal. But Baal did not respond. He was only something the devil had imagined.
Yet a real power stood behind that empty name, working on real hearts:
H. L. RossierBaal does not answer (vv. 25-29). See with what irony the prophet treats this lifeless object! Satan was using it to exercise his terrible influence on the hearts of men. The blood of the false prophets flows (v. 28). But neither their blood nor any man's blood can atone for Israel's sin or open heaven to this poor people!
The knives had a purpose. These worshippers believed their own pain would move their god, and one writer holds that up against real self-denial:
Leslie M. GrantThey took Elijah's advice and cried out more loudly to Baal, also cutting themselves with knives and lances. So idolaters really do injure their own bodies, thinking this is the self-denial that will influence their false god. How different is the true self-denial of a believer! True self-denial makes no show, but involves a sober self-judgment in spiritual reality. The prophets of Baal continued this useless noise all afternoon until the time of the evening sacrifice (v. 29).
The verse says they "raved on" while no one answered. Men made in the image of God spent a whole afternoon doing it:
W. W. FeredayDriven on by these taunts, the false prophets cut themselves with swords and spears until blood ran down their bodies! This unholy farce on the part of men made in the image of God was allowed to continue three hours longer.
The silence did not break at a random moment. It lasted right up to the one hour in the day that already belonged to God:
W. W. FeredayAt "the time of the offering of the evening sacrifice" Elijah judged that his opportunity had come. It was 3 p.m. In Jerusalem the evening lamb was being laid on the altar of the LORD, together with its grain offering and drink offering. All of it spoke to God of Christ, whose death at Calvary took place at that hour (Ex. 29:41; Matt. 27:46). It was the hour of divine blessing: compare Ezra 9:5; Dan. 9:21. The hour had struck for Elijah's sacrifice to be offered, and for the blessing which followed.
The scene is not only about an ancient idol. It is about anything a heart leans on instead of God:
C. H. MackintoshHow solemn, and how true for all time, are those words of Jeremiah: "Cursed is the man whose heart turns away from the LORD"! It does not matter who or what we put our confidence in — a religious system, a religious ritual, or anything else. It is a departure of the heart from God. A curse follows it. When the final struggle comes, people will call on their Baal in vain: "there will be no voice, no one to answer, no one to pay attention."
- No voice — from morning to the evening hour the false prophets got nothing: no sound, no answer, no attention.
- No power — the silence had a reason. Baal did not exist; the influence behind him was Satan's, and it could not send fire.
- No atonement — their own blood streamed out for hours, but no man's blood can cover sin or open heaven.
- No cover left — Elijah stayed silent and let the farce run its full course. Their failure was complete and public before his own hour came.
- One answer — their religion ran out at the hour of the evening sacrifice. That hour pointed to Christ's death, and it was the hour of blessing.